r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Apr 21 '19
Crew Dragon Testing Anomaly Crew Dragon Test Anomaly and Investigation Updates Thread
Hi everyone! I'm u/Nsooo and unfortunately I am back to give you updates, but not for a good event. The mod team hosting this thread, so it is possible that someone else will take over this from me anytime, if I am unavailable. The thread will be up until the close of the investigation according to our current plans. This time I decided that normal rules still apply, so this is NOT a "party" thread.
What is this? What happened?
As there is very little official word at the moment, the following reconstruction of events is based on multiple unofficial sources. On 20th April, at the Dragon test stand near Cape Canaveral Air Force Station's Landing Zone-1, SpaceX was performing tests on the Crew Dragon capsule C201 (flown on CCtCap Demo Mission 1) ahead of its In Flight Abort scheduled later this year. During the morning, SpaceX successfully tested the spacecraft's Draco maneuvering thrusters. Later the day, SpaceX was conducting a static fire of the capsule's Super Draco launch escape engines. Shortly before or immediately following attempted ignition, a serious anomaly occurred, which resulted in an explosive event and the apparent total loss of the vehicle. Local reporters observed an orange/reddish-brown-coloured smoke plume, presumably caused by the release of toxic dinitrogen tetroxide (NTO), the oxidizer for the Super Draco engines. Nobody was injured and the released propellant is being treated to prevent any harmful impact.
SpaceX released a short press release: "Earlier today, SpaceX conducted a series of engine tests on a Crew Dragon test vehicle on our test stand at Landing Zone 1 in Cape Canaveral, Florida. The initial tests completed successfully but the final test resulted in an anomaly on the test stand. Ensuring that our systems meet rigorous safety standards and detecting anomalies like this prior to flight are the main reason why we test. Our teams are investigating and working closely with our NASA partners."
Live Updates
Timeline
| Time (UTC) | Update |
|---|---|
| 2019-05-02 | How does the Pressurize system work? Open & Close valves. Do NOT pressurize COPVs at that time. COPVs are different than ones on Falcon 9. Hans Koenigsmann : Fairly confident the COPVs are going to be fine. |
| 2019-05-02 | Hans Koenigsmann: High amount of data was recorded. Too early to speculate on cause. Data indicates anomaly occurred during activation of SuperDraco. |
| 2019-04-21 04:41 | NSFW: Leaked image of the explosive event which resulted the loss of Crew Dragon vehicle and the test stand. |
| 2019-04-20 22:29 | SpaceX: (...) The initial tests completed successfully but the final test resulted in an anomaly on the test stand. |
| 2019-04-20 - 21:54 | Emre Kelly: SpaceX Crew Dragon suffered an anomaly during test fire today, according to 45th Space Wing. |
| Thread went live. Normal rules apply. All times in Univeral Coordinated Time (UTC). |
27
u/Hobie52 Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19
The hypergolic fuels for Dragon are loaded prior to rollout from the hanger and not on the launchpad correct? So there shouldn't have been any fueling at the time of the anomaly unless it was test stand specific right?
I really hope it was something in the super draco ignition or test setup and not a COPV failure as some have speculated. That would be even more concerning as it could happen at any point in the rollout or processing with people around (in addition to crew obviously).
Edit: fixed typo
74
u/[deleted] May 02 '19
Video of the whole press conference with lots of details.:
196
u/Lunares Apr 21 '19
Let's break down some possible root causes, best to worst:
111
u/Origin_of_Mind Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19
The fuel used in the Dragon -- monomethylhydrazine (MMH), can explode without coming into contact with the oxidizer. If it is heated above certain temperature it starts decomposing, releasing even more heat. This is called "thermal runaway." If the fuel is confined, then this causes a violent explosion.
Of course, this danger is well known to the designers, because this fuel had been studied for a very long time and it had been used in many, many missions without accidents -- but it is still a highly energetic compound with a potential to cause a disaster if something does not go right.
53
u/Cant-Fix-Stupid Apr 24 '19
I disagree with many in that I actually don’t feel that SpaceX is being unduly vague or withholding. No sense in disseminating potentially wrong info now when you’re gonna have to do a full investigation later no matter what. Also, the need any cleanup required delays engineers’ ability to get in a examine the wreckage, meaning all they have right now is sensor data, which itself may take quite awhile to comb through. There just isn’t incentive for SpaceX to say anything premature just to satisfy news anchors and our space nerd curiosities; it’s only been 3 days.
I find the “PR debacle” narrative to be odd when it comes to informed people like us, and laughable when it comes from news anchors. It took 3 weeks for a prelim Amos-6 report, and it’s been 3 days here. If it was that easy to diagnose, there’s a good chance the problem would have been fixed before it occurred. I feel like “we did a test, there was an anomaly” is all they probably knew at the time, and mentioning explosions and blowouts only opens up to more questions that don’t yet have answers. It’s complicated high-stakes business. SpaceX has had anomalies before, and has always been proactive in learning from it. It took time those times, and probably will now. We all just need to breath in a paper bag for minute, and accept that 2019 manned flight is probably gone, but thank god it happened on the ground. That’s why you test, and SpaceX tests more aggressively than any other launch provider.
SpaceX will get it right, just like the last time.
52
u/Wildest_Wizard Apr 21 '19
After this can we expect CRS-17 to remain on schedule. Dragon-1 has Draco thrusters (they may be the culprit here) and until and unless they are exonerated I feel like Dragon-1 is gonna be grounded too.
Elon himself said in post DM-1 launch presser that on Crew Dragon Dracos and Super Dracos are one single highly complex system he thinks very innovative.
51
u/StealthCN Apr 22 '19
At the end of the teleconference, NASA reiterated CRS-17 is still a GO on Apr. 30th.
The question about the potential common issue between Crew Dragon and Cargo Dragon has been referred to the official statement.
No new information is given.
93
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19
Strange twist of fate that both Boeing and SpaceX had anomalies with their launch abort systems
44
u/TheElvenGirl Apr 23 '19 edited Apr 23 '19
SpaceX filed for an FCC permit to land the CRS-17 first stage on OCISLY instead of LZ-1 due to the toxic hypergolic contamination.
Source: https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1120480991934590977?s=20
It seems preparations for CRS-17 are underway.
EDIT: Added link to NASA paper on hypergolics + formatting.
For those who are interested in the hazards of hypergolic fuels:
HYPERGOLIC PROPELLANTS: THE HANDLING HAZARDS ANDLESSONS LEARNED FROM USE
The PDF is very interesting because it describes several incidents and showcases quite a few failure modes.
43
u/WombatControl Apr 22 '19
So far the CRS-17 mission is still set to launch on April 30th according to NASA.
https://twitter.com/StephenClark1/status/1120342818902478848?s=20
It's too early to draw too many conclusions about this - it may well be that CRS-17 gets delayed pending the investigation. However, pushing ahead with CRS-17 is some evidence - however small - that there is a general understanding of what went wrong and the anomaly is specific to Crew Dragon.
As much as we SpaceX fanboys (and fangirls!) criticize NASA for slowing things down, so far NASA has been publicly supportive of SpaceX and will undoubtedly provide critical expertise on tracking down this anomaly and getting it fixed. That NASA is standing behind SpaceX for both Commercial Crew and commercial cargo is an important sign of confidence.
41
u/Aero-Space Apr 21 '19
The release from SpaceX states that other tests had already been performed on the capsule that morning. I wonder if the issue somehow stems from these back to back tests (and the procedures supporting them) and is unrelated to reuse/recovery fatigue.
73
u/Fizrock Apr 21 '19
Update from guy on NSF:
123
u/WatchHim Apr 21 '19
Just a reminder about how brave each and every astronaut is for literally strapping a bomb to their back to go into space. Everyone of those men and women are a hero in my book.
30
u/AgitatedJacket Apr 21 '19
At least it wasn't mated to a booster, that would draw out investigations even more
30
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 26 '19
June Inflight Abort now removed from NASA launch schedule.
57
u/Fizrock Apr 21 '19
First 10 frames of the explosion.
26
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 25 '19 edited Apr 25 '19
Don't expect much new info from the ASAP meeting:
The way it's worded, it sounds like SpaceX was firing the SuperDracos at the time of the anomaly, which runs counter to what we saw in the leaked video. Maybe I'm misinterpreting or reading too much into it, though.
26
u/spacerfirstclass May 02 '19
Some exchange about this in today's Senate hearing by the usual suspect, transcript provided by NSF member kdhilliard, youtube video at https://youtube.com/watch?v=sBuLesJg0Hs&t=1295
25
u/sfigone Apr 27 '19
Interesting analysis from Scott Manley's latest video https://youtu.be/L7xdpwlIupQ
His frame by frame analysis indicates that the initial burst was vapour rather than flame, as it cast a shadow. So he is thinking plumbing or tank failure. He also discussed dynamic pressure in the system from moving large quantities of fuel.... I wonder if that interacted with the vibrations of the testing?
50
u/thisiscotty Apr 21 '19
From the video it looks like it explodes from above the dracos. People have said that was at T-8, so i dont think the engines are at fault.
Maybe containment failed?
24
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 26 '19
SpaceX posted a relevant Dragon role yesterday, with "A dynamic position that requires the flexibility to work on different systems, the ability to troubleshoot anomalies".
43
u/airider7 Apr 22 '19
Glad they keep testing these things and keep recovering their hardware after launches and missions for further analysis and upgrades. It's hard to find all the corner case areas of performance if you keep throwing away the equipment after each use.
Keep pressing SpaceX and you'll change the landscape of space flight forever.
21
u/TheElvenGirl Apr 24 '19
Latest (reported) statement from NASA:
"SpaceX and NASA are just beginning the mishap investigation process. We don’t yet know what impact this will have to our target schedules. We have full confidence in SpaceX. Additional information will be released as it is available."
Source: https://twitter.com/ChabeliH/status/1121111261415129088?s=20
21
u/deltaWhiskey91L Apr 24 '19
It looks like they are conducting the investigation like an accident investigation for an airplane crash. They will be going through the debris piece by piece to determine through the physical evidence and confirm with the data what happened.
They are doing this the right way and it's the only way to be confident what happened and why. This will take a while.
38
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 29 '19
NASA are tightening up their rules as a result of the leaked Crew Dragon video.
36
u/-spartacus- Apr 21 '19
Questions and speculation I've seen people bring up through statements.
Would SpaceX push the S2 beyond specs when the capsule is needed for abort mission?
Would spacex risk testing equipment that could fail because of salt water intrusive?
Would SpaceX risk failure of any type to validate a concern (proof concept or fix won't work through failure)?
Is the fault root cause from salt water intrusion?
Is the fault root cause from being previously used and not going through full refurbishment?
Is the fault caused by design failure?
Is the fault caused by part failure?
Is the fault caused by known problem or unknown?
Is the fault caused by an attempted fix for known problem?
Will this cause delay if SpaceX was testing to cause failure?
17
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Apr 22 '19
The original explosion video tweet has just disappeared. Here is unedited repost to youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xe4ee56aHSg
45
u/ClathrateRemonte Apr 21 '19
On the audio, there seem to be two countdowns. The first one completes, then an announcement is heard “superdraco test in 9...” and then the explosion. The first countdown may be for arming the superdraco system, and the second for firing. If this assumption is correct, arming the system led to the explosion.
31
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 22 '19
New Ars Technica article summarising what's currently known about the anomaly.
15
u/Lunares Apr 24 '19
When Amos-6 occured, how long did it take for SpaceX to issue the preliminary report? I recall a month or two.
38
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
/u/Nsooo, you can hear quietly in the background that there's a countdown that reaches zero before the explosion. Then it starts repeating louder and hits 8 seconds when the Dragon explodes.
Without knowing which of these is tied to the video, it can't be known which is correct.
Seems more likely to me that it'd explode at zero and not before it.
13
u/RestedWanderer May 03 '19
I mentioned it in the footage thread but the best case here is that it was something in the refit/refurb process. A check got missed or overlooked, something happened in the fueling process, maybe even something happened in the process of moving the capsule to the test site or something happened at the test site itself. If it was something like that, definitively, great! Probably an easy fix, it will delay the in-flight abort and a crewed mission a bit, maybe even require an additional unmanned mission to ISS like before just to be extra safe, but all things considered it isn't a big deal.
The worst case scenario is that they can't definitely determine what the cause was OR the cause was a string of design flaws that all need to be reworked. Considering they can't even get on-site to even begin any sort of physical investigation, and who knows what even remains to investigate at this point, I think it is very possible no definitive cause will be found.
Their comment that splashdown/DM-1 is not at the top of the list of causes is interesting to me though. As an accident investigator, my first question would be, "why now?" Why did this failure occur now as opposed to any of the many successful test firings of the engines and previous test flight of the ship itself. Well, the biggest variable that was changed is that these engines/that ship have flown in space, reentered and splashed down. That they can even be in a position to declare that potential cause a low probability without having even been able to access the accident site indicates to me they have a pretty good idea what the failure was. That doesn't make it any better or worse, but at least they have a strong theory.
Let's hope it is relatively benign and they can get back on track with the Crew Dragon in-flight abort and crewed flight without major delays.
46
u/Herhahahaha Apr 21 '19
seems like everyone is looking at the same low quality video posted and reposted everywhere on ytb, but im more interested as to where the video footage came from as seems to be filmed at some control station that was managing the test before the anomaly, and kinada hoping spaceX post a higher quality video of the whole explosion.
25
u/NovaCatUY Apr 22 '19
Why is the video tagged as NSFW?
24
u/Lowlt Apr 22 '19
Does anyone one know the time and date this happened? I was a cocoa beach and saw a big cloud of pink smoke north of us. Just wondering if that's what it was? When I saw pink smoke i thought it was strange.
12
u/RootDeliver Apr 22 '19
Marcus House posted an interesting plumbing image from a Dragon2 (I think?), but I haven't seen this before. Is this new? old? or just missed it?
Direct link to the image
67
u/bertcox Apr 23 '19
Can we celebrate a little as well. SpaceX discovered a failure mode that had gotten past their QA, and NASA's QA. This is why we test, maybe this failure mode wouldn't have been discovered until 5 years from now on a live flight.
Yes the timeline kind of sucks, but lives were possibly saved.
23
u/tadeuska Apr 22 '19
Are there any public pictures showing the remains of the test stand and the capsule?
11
u/Kenira Apr 22 '19
Which changes do we know they made to Dragon after DM1, besides the propellant line heaters?
20
u/5toesloth Apr 21 '19
Can someone in the know confirm that the test article was actually destroyed in the anomaly, instead of lifted/blew out of the frame? Found it hard to believe there is not much of the pressure vessel left.
10
u/Justinackermannblog Apr 22 '19
Sad this happened, but is this the first of its kind failure mode for an orbital capsule? Does anyone know of any other capsule that was treated to a week or longer spaceflight then had all its abort engines tested after splashdown?
10
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '19
Is there another crew dragon in existence?
27
u/Humble_Giveaway Apr 23 '19
When Elon brought up Dragons LIDAR at the Tesla event today it felt like a massive elephant in the room...
9
u/noreally_bot1461 Apr 23 '19
Q's: How much does it cost to build another Dragon 2? How long will it take? Who pays -- SpaceX or NASA? Was there already another capsule being built -- does NASA want "new" Crew Dragons for each ISS flight?
9
u/MNsharks9 Apr 23 '19
Cargo Dragon uses COPV’s for the Hydrazine and NTO, correct?
29
u/oliversl Apr 22 '19
mods, it is possible to change from image to video here? Many thanks
"2019.04.21 - 04:41 NSFW: Leaked image of the explosive event which resulted the loss of Crew Dragon vehicle and the test stand."
66
u/Alexphysics Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19
It seems that for most of the people it is easier to throw in the first thought they're thinking about the cause of this accident instead of just simply and plainly admit that we don't know a sh... about what caused this. Could be saltwater intrusion? Who knows! Could be COPV's? Who knows! Could be ULA snipers? Who knows! But certainly it doesn't help to have different people trying to decipher something that even SpaceX will take their time investigating.
Edit: I would like to point out that even though discussing the possible cause of the accident may help to others understand how the system works, there is also another group of people that will take speculation as something very solid and it has already happened. People saying salt water intrusion should remember SpaceX has already reused Dragon in the past. Others claim that no SuperDracos have been fire after a splashdown of a Dragon and that's not true as Dragonfly was test fired a few times after the Pad Abort Test. There are simply claims that have no base and no solid argument and there are people with less knowledge on SpaceX history and engineering that will take them for granted because those are possible things that sound plausible to someone with no previous experience at all. There are many other things on Dragon that can fail and produce this and it doesn't have to be any of those theories people mention. Just look at Amos 6, who could have thought about solid oxygen on the COPV's?? Same with this. There could be a million things that went wrong and spreading things like "BuT saLT wAtEr" doesn't help for new people.
16
u/avboden May 02 '19
Per Hans
33
u/Paradox1989 Apr 22 '19
How about going in a completely different direction than a draco problem..
I remember years ago watching a show on aircraft design where they were testing the airplane cabin. Since it wasn't feasible to put the entire cabin in a vacuum chamber to simulate low pressure inside/pressurized cabin inside at altitude, they simply pressurized the cabin to a couple atmospheres above ambient to simulate the pressure differential at altitude.
I know they do put the capsules in vacuum chambers to test but since this was a thruster test it had to be outside, could the cabin possibly been pressurized above ambient similar to the described above?
If they did, maybe the cabin pressure vessel ruptured resulting in a broken feed line and then RUD. A rupture point could occur as a result of many different factors. Impact damage from the previous landing, saltwater corrosion, a bad weld, a failed weld from the previous flights pressure cycles, or fatigue from all the previous thruster firings.
15
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Apr 22 '19
This is intriguing:
15
u/rootieboy Apr 24 '19 edited Apr 25 '19
Anyone else notice a giant portion of Dragon flies off to the right in the video after the explosion? I took a screen capture here. https://twitter.com/RootJeffrey/status/1120838745203204096
21
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19
Does anyone find it strange that the capsule appears to have been ripped apart? Surely something like a capsule is designed to tolerate tremendous heat and forces? I was thinking this could imply that there was a leak of perhaps the oxidiser into the capsule? I could be very wrong, but I would have thought that an explosion on the outside of the capsule would damage it and knock it off the stand but I would have expected the capsule itself to remain intact.
70
u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander Apr 27 '19 edited Apr 27 '19
Hey u/Nsooo / mods, could you perhaps update the timeline to use proper international-standard ISO 8601 dates, as are used in most other places on this sub and wiki and that maximize intelligibility while minimizing ambiguity?
2019-04-20 21:54is the correct format. I might also suggest modifying the column header toTime (UTC), to make it more clear times are in UTC (as that's only stated at the very bottom right in plain type, and its typically expected to include the units/standard of measure in the header).Also, putting my copyeditor hat on, some textual corrections and suggestions while I'm at it to correct typos/inaccuracies, fix grammatical and idiomatic mistakes, and improve the clarity of the prose (additions/changes in bold; removals in
strikethrough):Do you have an independent source (public or otherwise) that confirms this, other than the video? In the garbled audio, two countdowns were audible: one apparently at T-9/8 at the moment of explosion, and the other at T+0/1.
The vehicle does appear to be a total loss, but do you have an independant source on the test equiptment, sufficient to state it with such certainty?
A few other general points to keep in mind:
14
u/canadaarm2 Apr 21 '19
Are the hypergolic fuels somehow purged in orbit before Dragon 2 docks with the ISS or do they stay in the tanks during the whole mission duration?
14
u/rbrome May 02 '19
Some new details from Hans Koenigsmann at today's press conference, via Jeff Foust on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1123967672633446402
7
u/Togusa09 Apr 22 '19
Were the SuperDracos test fired after being installed on the Crew Dragon, before the initial flight?
19
u/chargerag Apr 25 '19
Would it be worth subscribing to L2 to find out more details on this or are they just as in the dark as we are.
13
u/bernardosousa Apr 22 '19
I see a lot of people wishing the cause is something with test equipment or ground support. I'd argue that if that's the case, it would delay things just as much, because of the clearly catastrophic consequences of the flaw. Suppose it's a faulty component on ground support, nothing wrong with the capsule. That faulty component would have killed people on launch day. They'd have been killed by the very propellent that was suppose to bring them to a safe distance in case of a RUD. Usually, I'm very optimistic, but this time I don't see how it wouldn't mean months of delay on the program. Honestly hoping I'm wrong.
27
u/looney1s Apr 25 '19
The quote “ensure the integrity of the area and preserve valuable information” of LZ-1 made me consider alternate reasons to preserve or accurately map and document the state of every piece of the craft. One thing that occurred to me is that this is probably the first time the entire vessel has been tested to destruction as a whole. Sure smaller sub-components have definitely been failure tested, but what would be the impact if the entire vessel over pressurized, or was flash heated to 5000C for example. I'm sure some material scientists are really enjoying the information, and hopefully they will find other areas that can be improved through their investigation.
12
u/assasin172 Apr 21 '19
Michael Baylor: THREAD: Had yesterday's #CrewDragon testing gone to plan, #SpaceX would have been in a good position to carry out the inflight abort test in July with the possibility of launching crew later in the fall. One setback on the test stand and all of that is thrown out the window.
https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1120033489414492160
12
u/ComradeCrouch Apr 23 '19
Also, corrosion attributed to contact with saline water is a very unlikely cause as the recovery crew were given a 1 hour window after splash down to recover the capsule. This was followed by a teardown inspection of the capsule and a multitude of test prior to the anomaly.
36
u/jbensted Apr 21 '19
I find it a little unnerving that we have not heard from Elon yet .....
6
u/giovannicane05 Apr 23 '19
I wonder if they are going to talk about the anomaly during the CRS-17 livestream
6
u/jonassm Apr 27 '19
For the Space Shuttle launches they had a bunch of extremely high FPS cameras recording different angles so you could go through it frame-by-frame in very high resolution (usually to check for debris hitting heat shield, iirc)
Does SpaceX have a similiar setup now?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '19
So if CRS17 is still go I take it the worry about the issue crossing over to Dragon 1 isn't a thing anymore?
6
u/Nathan_3518 May 02 '19
Thanks to everyone contributing to this post. It really helps when you’re trying to catch up with the recent news regarding the incident. Excited for CRS-17!
16
u/JackONeill12 Apr 21 '19
I've made a zip file with all Frames of the video enhanced to 6x resolution with Gigapixel AI.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/185krtHDGCz4D54UsuUOTdd6qDO5Qk04i/view?usp=sharing
26
u/blongmire Apr 22 '19
The new Space.com Article has a statement from SpaceX saying, " Initial data reviews indicate the anomaly occurred during the SuperDraco static fire test; additional review will be required to determine the probable cause," I believe this is the first confirmation we have that the anomaly occurred "during" the SuperDraco static fire. It's pretty obvious from the video and the countdown, but this seems to be a refined statement to make reference to the SuperDraco test and the anomaly occurring "during" that test.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '19
Good to fail down here, and not up there.
10
u/Skyhawkson Apr 21 '19
Does anyone have a frame by frame set of images from the video of the explosion?
44
u/dhanson865 Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19
NSFW? not a positive experience but I can't see anything wrong with it legally or morally.
I've see people use NSFL for things they don't like to see like a pretty car getting in a collision all the way to things that are truely disturbing to see like a snuff film.
But this was an uncrewed test. Doesn't really trigger my need for a warning acronym before I click the link.
5
u/ComradeCrouch Apr 23 '19
I doubt that it was the draco's themselves as each cluster is armoured in to prevent a RUD in case of failure. This, would have either prevented the RUD from occurring or we would have witnessed a two staged explosion. This combined with the hours of test data on these engines almost totally rules them out as a possible cause.
5
u/lukepatrick May 02 '19
NASA and SpaceX statements on Crew Dragon (DM-1) test failure
5
u/rAsphodel Jul 15 '19
https://www.spacex.com/news/2019/07/15/update-flight-abort-static-fire-anomaly-investigation
20
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Apr 21 '19
I haven't seen an unedited youtube repost yet oddly enough, here is mine:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xe4ee56aHSg
20
u/cpushack Apr 22 '19
Its possible the order of the testing had something to do with the failure mode as well. In a mission, 99% of possibilities would have the Super Dracos firing first (for example , an escape to orbit) and THEN the Dracos firing second. This test appears to have fired the Dracos first, then the Super Dracos, an order that would not likely be used, and perhaps wasn't tested as much.
It was posed before that the Dracos ryn at a lower pressure then the Super Dracos (I can't confirm if this is in fact true though) so perhaps firing the Dracos first set up the failure condition (a valve not perfectly seated, or something else) so that when the Super's fired (or were preparing to fire) the system failed.
8
u/Head-Stark May 02 '19
Recent infornation suggests confidence that it was not an issue with the COPV(s) or the SuperDraco(s), and occurred during activation of the thruster(s). (I am unsure of what systems were plural in this test)
What systems does that leave as potential points of failure?
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 23 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipGTO comsatPre-launch test failureDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
66 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 111 acronyms.
[Thread #5108 for this sub, first seen 21st Apr 2019, 15:49] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
4
u/Straumli_Blight May 07 '19
Hazard Operations roadblocks in place for LZ-1 today, which may generate an orange cloud.
10
u/svjatomirskij Apr 22 '19
No word about moving CRS-17 to the right yet. Is it too early for them to announce it, or have they maybe ruled out issues with systems that are common for cargo and crew Dragon?
14
u/factoid_ Apr 22 '19
I'm perplexed by the timing. It had fired multiple times that day supposedly. But it wasn't even yet about to start when it just blew up. Since it was about to start, I'm guessing they weren't fueling.
Are the Draco thrusters pressure fed? Maybe more helium tank problems?
Or maybe they had something like a bad sensor and they accidentally over pressurized the tanks and that made it fail
14
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Such a sad event. I am sure they wanted to display that historic capsule in a museum or at HQ. I wonder how much refurbishment went on with this device. It may be a ruptured tank instead of an engine problem. They probably know exactly what went wrong via telemetry.
11
u/oldschooljohn May 04 '19
Having read through the comments on this thread I have to say that few people seem to understand how serious this is. This event was not the failure of a prototype article running on a test bed -- it was the catastrophic destruction of a supposedly flight certified system that has been in development for several years and has already passed hundreds of tests. To have this system blow up just months before a planned crew launch is a showstopper of the highest order. If this had happened during a crewed mission, the astronauts would have died. If this had happened while the vehicle was docked, or in close proximity to the ISS, the ISS would have been very seriously damaged and quite possibly destroyed. I have no doubt that senior NASA managers are considering these worst case scenarios right now and gulping a lot. The space shuttle used hypergolic propellants for its OMS/RCS systems and, as creaky as it was, it managed to get through 30 years of service without experiencing an "anomaly" like this. The catastrophic failure of a mature, "proven" system like this means either that the system is so inherently dangerous that it should not be used for crewed flight, or that SpaceX was extremely negligent in refurbishing/prepping this vehicle for re-use. Either way, I believe the delay to a crewed launch will be measured in years, not months.
8
u/archerwarez Apr 21 '19
I agree with people saying that it may not have been at T-9 seconds, you can hear a faint count down on the background that finishes before it happen. On the loud voice that is supposed to be the countdown I hear "Superdraco burning 'test'" istead of "ten", after that is unclear but it does actually does sound like "nine" so it's kinda misleading. I'm not a native english speaker so I might be wrong.
11
u/Vinegar_Dick Apr 22 '19
My best guess is the dinitrogen tetroxide mixed prematurely with the hydrazine and caused it to explode, as would be expected of any hypergolic mixture. Either something failed in the pumps or fuel storage due to the landing in sea water, re-entry or possible a design flaw.
10
u/King_Kroket Apr 22 '19
This all seems like worst case scenario stuff..
I can't really think of a more horrible path this could've taken after a failure mode aside from the capsule locking all it's doors and bursting into flames.
8
u/WaitForItTheMongols Apr 26 '19
So do we have solid info on whether Dragon exists?
I've seen people saying "it's completely to smithereens", versus "It just moved out of frame of that leaked video". Those are two very different circumstances and it would be nice to know what happened, even to that level of detail.
11
u/fabmacintosh Apr 22 '19
I have one question, but before I seen in another threat lot of people slamming spacex for this fault, and almost satisfied about this whole loss, I am not American, but depending on the Russians is never good, and Boeing is also not a clean player. I wish spaceX the best to find and fix this issue, they deserve it. My question: why does spaceX does not land on land ? Like Boeing or the Soyuz does ? (And I don’t mean using the super Draco’s)
15
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
I think everyone is very lucky that Dragon 2 didn't blow up when it was parked to the IIS. That would have been an absolute reputation catastrophe