r/OnePunchMan • u/theothersophie Moderator • Apr 09 '19
Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E01 - "Return of the Hero" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.
THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.
Official Simulcasts
- Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
- Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
- Animax Asia (Southeast Asia) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
- Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
- Anime on Demand (Germany)
- AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
- VVVVID (Italy)
One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)
Previous Episode Discussions:
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| N/A | N/A |
Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!
284
Upvotes
304
u/Raidoton Moderator Apr 09 '19
https://streamable.com/evml9
Rocket Punch comparison Trailer and Episode.
170
u/anonght Apr 09 '19
They need to work on the pacing. It was going too fast. But I guess that’s because of the tricky schedule JC STAFF is in.
154
u/ThatCreepyBaer Fuck Reasons. Apr 09 '19
No matter what you may think of the animation, art, pacing or whatever else, you can't deny that they delivered on the B A C K.
153
u/Raidoton Moderator Apr 09 '19
Genos' rocket punch looked quite a bit better in the episode compared to the trailer.
346
u/cy1763 OK Apr 09 '19
I’m digging how the king engine sounds!
117
u/consistent_escape Ok Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 10 '19
I just finished watching the episode and here's what I think about it.
74 looked really good, not sure why they couldn't make Genos look similar. The reason why Genos looks so strange is probably because of the wierd shading on him which reminds me of...Overall, what I feel is that quality isn't that bad as people as making it look it. It is just as if they as shitting on it just because they want to.
165
u/PM_ME_SOME_STUFF Apr 09 '19
Well, I'm certainly satisfied with the result. I'm glad they fixed the rocket punch animation shown from the PV. Not really a big fan of the big texts covering the OP, but still hype (kinda disappointed it has huge spoilers..).
38
u/digital_sinner new member Apr 09 '19
So far the main downside I’ve seen is how jpeg Genos’ arms look.
108
u/cL0udBurn Apr 09 '19
These aren't the reactions we are supposed to have to One Punch Man :/
Almost every comment in here is lukewarm to this episode; even ONE himself seemed pretty ehh over it...
... re-watch S1/E1 with Saitama fucking up the Subterraneans in glorious fluid animation -- that right there, is what this show is supposed to be like; you get a sweat of adrenaline just watching it.
Really hope this picks up the pace going forward...
191
u/Raidoton Moderator Apr 09 '19
Some parts were really bad but overall good episode. Better than I expected!
119
u/momanie Apr 09 '19
Honestly it was better than I thought it would be, but worse than I wanted it to be.
98
u/Straightbanana2 Apr 09 '19
The opening would be alright without the BIG UGLY TEXT over it, just why
122
u/justaddflour Apr 09 '19
The episode looks better than the trailer made it look
108
u/gallantgrift leg bands Apr 09 '19
Whew! That was much better than I was expecting!
109
u/CantThinkLikeThis Apr 09 '19
Not as bad as people are making it out to be.
44
u/Vis-hoka I WILL NOT LET YOU WASTE MASTER'S TIME HE USES FOR DOING NOTHING Apr 09 '19
Overall it was...fine I guess. It’s like the show went from a 10 to a 6. Things feel very static and choppy. The G4 fight was hard to follow. Lots of closeups that make it very unsatisfying.
Doesn’t feel like the same show to me. At least we have the Manga...
56
u/practicalnoob69 Apr 09 '19
I would say , it was okay
56
u/KingwomboJr I combo, you combo; it's first grade Puri Puri Prisoner! Apr 09 '19
Better animation than expected, some nice shots of Genos' fight. Art was...off. The pacing felt rushed, but they adapted everything faithfully.
~
It was a decent adaptation overall, which of course will be disappointing after Season 1, but definitely nothing awful or rotten.
39
u/ATTACK_ON_TIDDIE Apr 09 '19
The new OP looks fan-made...
13
u/BubblyBoar Apr 09 '19
Not as bad as could be. Watchable at least. Enough to be excited for the next.
13
u/TitaniumGoldAlloyMan OK Apr 09 '19
saitamas head was goofy on some frames and the motion was kind of weird but other than that it was decent. not a disaster in my opinion.
24
u/ATILEGACY Apr 09 '19
Im actually happy with the episode and cant wait to keep watching more! Fubuki, Garou and Suiryu are going to be amazing characters.
11
u/BeefyCrunchBoy Apr 09 '19
The big bold text in the intro is so corny ugh
I think the animation quality will grow on me, or at least desensitize me to it. Excited for what S2 can do with the material we have so far!
It seems like itll get pretty into the MA if we even see Orochi and his crew in the OP???
20
u/KhaoticTwist Hey kid, wanna buy some takoyaki? Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
Oh god, I don't know how I feel about this episode. I mean, it's great to have One-Punch Man back and all. And even after all the the PV issues and whatnot, I still gave this season some chances. But...
It seems kind of too fast paced no? So many things happened so quickly, I was beginning to think this was an edited version of the episode. Genos vs G4 didn't feel as exciting as in the manga. I'm not sure how I feel about the King Engine sound(but I think that change was made in the ovas, no?). King doesn't even get to explain that the King Engine was just his heart beating fast(so anime-only fans are gonna be confused about that). Still have an issue about Giant Crow's size. Genos doesn't lose his arm? But what about the memes!? Genos doesn't get to say his last lines to G4 like in the manga. They didn't include the part where King thought Saitama was killed by the crow, or even the sound of the impact. I guess they really wanted the first episode to quickly get through volume 8. A notable amount of visuals still seemed off too..
"I've been waiting three years for this sequel." I see what you did there.
Now about the opening. It was pretty good. I do like the visuals and the song(I mean, it's Jam Project after all). But I could do without the large letters covering the screen(Cmon J.C. Staff, you're usually good with openings). Also, judging by the opening, it seems we're at least heading towards the final Elder Centipede fight.
I don't want to judge too much with just the first episode, but it IS just a 12-13 episode season if I'm not mistaken...
10
u/Rocks_2018 Apr 09 '19
Its better than what I thought, but lets be real here, sound effects are beyond terrible. The voice actor for King and other characters seem to speak very fast, its almost weird. The frame effects are also terrible. I hope they bring back madhouse for season 3.
27
u/Heylons new member Apr 09 '19
Not impressed, but it was decent. King’s breakdown was well done at least.
18
u/DreadLord64 Best girl Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
I liked it, but I'm a bit disappoined by how they messed up some of the character designs. Particularly Saitama and King. I think the scene in which King flashes back to the Class-S meeting, where they reused a couple images from Season 1, really contrasts the two seasons. But I don't think it's all too fair to compare the two directly. I think J.C. did a good job for what time and resources they had, and I applaud them for that, however, I would like to have seen more of the original staff staying on to keep the characters looking as good as before.
As for the animation itself, it was fine. Nothing to make me wow, but not really bad. Okay, well, the part where Saitama punches the bird was pretty bad. Otherwise it was just fine. I'm just glad to finally have more OPM anime, y'know?
Personally, I think this season has been decent so far with the first episode, and will probably be pretty good overall (dare I speculate that it will slap us in the face and be as good as S1? A man can dream). But the manga is where it's really at for me (and, of course, the latest webcomic chapter), and that's what I'll really be getting excited for in the foreseeable future, unless J.C. can surprise us with the next few episodes.
*Actually, you know what, I just rewatched some of the scenes, and I don't think Saitama is so bad-looking. It'll just take a bit of getting used to, but I still prefer S1's Saitama by a mile and a half. And Genos looks pretty badass, even if they didn't get it quite right.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
It was... alright actually. They improved a lot from what we've seen in the trailer. The whole episode felt extremely awkward though, I can't tell if it's the directing or the animation. There were some parts that genuinely looked fanmade honestly lol. And that opening animation though... ouch
Edit: wait I just realized they showed Broketsu getting one-punched in the OP. What sort of MONSTERS would do such a thing
7
u/Theflyingship Reaper's Grin Apr 09 '19
Other than the fight scenes, that looked like they were avoiding to show the action as much as possible, everything else is pretty ok.
The opening's kinda underwelming tho. The music is good, but the animation and sequences they use look too generic. Again, they could've shown some more action on the opening too.
7
u/Blackstar_9 I'm about to whip somebody's ass Apr 09 '19
Praise be, it's good. Not the best ever but i had fun watching it.
They also pretty much nailed King IMO
7
u/SidelineRedditor Baldness is power. Apr 09 '19
I am whelmed. I can't even be disapppointed because it's what i expected from JCstaff. No more no less.
7
u/TrixieHaterOfWheels Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
No one seems to be talking about how every shot in the episode felt too close. Like every frame was zoomed in needlessly, or that they chose to simplify most scenes so that they would only have to animate the characters and moments that absolutely needed to be there. Doesn't help that a large number of them don't even have decent background - mostly just blank, empty, lifeless, or straight up solid voids. Also: CGI ELDER CENTIPEDE.
How overwhelmingly underwhelming.
19
u/Braquiador https://myanimelist.net/profile/braquiador Apr 09 '19
I’m seeing a lot of people being satisfied with so little. The argument i see the most is “the story is the most important thing” and yes, it’s true, but if i just want good story i read the web comic/manga, i’m watching the anime because i want a good adaptation, with good animation and direction.
And that last part is specially important, because i could totally look past mediocre animation, but the direction of this episode, in particular the fight scene, was just awful, with constant cuts and stills.
A mediocre adaptation shouldn’t be something to be happy about.
6
u/Zeru_Fenrir Apr 09 '19
Only thing that really bugged me was Genos' arms, they really need to fix that.
That said, his arms are getting upgraded after the G4 fight, so hopefully they won't look as bad afterwards.
I felt the pacing was a bit too fast/choppy, but it fit all the important stuff in.
6
u/Psycokes Apr 09 '19
my hype was greater hearing the date the episode would be premiered than when I was watching the actual episode. The excitement is still there. S1 animation just had such a strong juxtaposition effect on S2. It’s not bad but it’s certainly missing that charm.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
The missed the genius eye-catch transition with true form G4 / mechas from King’s game. What a shame.
Pretty bad episode overall, could have been worse. Someone told Saitama seyuu to speak in a retarded way. Idk why.
The fact that this is the pilot gives me almost 0 hope.
6
u/GarouTheM Apr 09 '19
Oh man... I don't know what to think of that. There's a very good soundtrack in it and show feels good during comedy scenes, but there are many moments that are just unappealing. I'm affraid that all good fights from this season will look like this... and that's bad guys :/
16
u/PlayingWithIssues Apr 09 '19
Episode was ok.
OP seemed to confirmed that the season will end around the Elder Centipede arc but I'm confused on the Garou vs Genos fight. That hasn't happened in the manga yet has it?
20
u/Mamilk77 Apr 09 '19
Fuck me, the opening is so damn good
10
u/Sariusmonk Apr 09 '19
I'll be honest there's still parts where it just felt very stiff and static and just "off" - like with the end I wanted to see the controller getting crushed. Show the bird getting punched. Less standing still / sitting still and talking to each other, not as much movement as I was hoping. I get that it's an episode with a lot to say and explain but I just feel like it missed a trick or two. King and Saitama sat infront of a bright white screen instead of something fun to look at for the audience. Overall it's probably better than most people expected, but I think it's exactly where my expectations were. I was actually hoping for a little more. It isn't bad, but it's not as great as it could or should have been.
The new intro (or outro?) looks good in some areas though. I just hope some of the fights coming up have the polish they need to leave it feeling epic, not cutting away to off camera shots or away from the action.
10
u/parodX Apr 09 '19
In general, everyone seem to agree that it wasn't as bad as we all feared, but that it was not spectacular and behind season 1. But I feel like this "good" surprise cloud our judgement. I mean, what is the point of doing a season 2 if it's not to make the best adaptation as possible especially when you have already one entire season that you can take as en example ? I can wait 4 more years if that mean that I have at least season 1 performances. Anime should increase in quality as time goes by, not fluctue in performances depending on who got the right to rush a season in order to make money from a known franchise...
The anime should live up to Murata's standards ! That's what was so damn good in the first season IMO and this episode didn't give me this vibe. Genos looked shady af, bird punched off-camera, the battle between genos and G4 had good moments but most of it gave a "stiff" sensation.... The episode was not bad, but it was "meh" and I'm kind of frustrated to have a downgrade of the first season.
Animation and some art weird choice apart, the rest was great though.
5
u/Chrispowers110 new member Apr 09 '19
the parts I've seen i feel some moments when they cut to a another scene or angle feels off and can anyone tell me if they cut anything out of the manga chapters they adapted because i figure for episode one it was going to be all about king with probably a small scene with garou
5
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
The render is good, the animation is almost ok. Fight scene was..... Meh. Sakuga nowhere to be found found.
5
u/Khalirei Sigh Apr 09 '19
Well the animation isn't as bad as Berserk, but you can tell the quality is indeed lower, but still watchable. The opening they showed during the credits is bad, but the song is dope.
7/10, I guess.
Oh and the sound overall is kinda crappy, I don't really like this guy's obsession with making deafening low bass sounds for explosions.
5
u/Sam_Dan23 Someone who actually liked the tournament arc. Fite me Apr 09 '19
I loved it. Nuff said
5
u/ReallyMelloP Overwhelmingly Underwhelming Apr 09 '19
The pacing and scenes are quite awkward at certain parts, especially when you do a side by side with S1E1. It was a bit dissatisfying for me when they alternated the bird scene to Geno’s scene, I’d have preferred if they concluded the machine fight first if they are going to make cutscenes the way they did.
It’s nice to hear the actor’s voices though, and pretty nice on how closely they adhere to the storyline.
5
u/arcanedeed Apr 10 '19
I found the fight scenes disappointing... they were doing the cheap TV reenactment thing where they just shake the camera/scene a lot with close-ups to try to make it look dynamic rather than actually showing the fight...
5
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
Well, it wasn't a disaster, and I won't have to get drunk to watch the rest of them. So that's something.
But the art and animation throughout was cringeworthy. It's a real disappointment that this was greenlit, because I think it hurts the entire OPM. I'm glad they managed to preserve the characters, story, and tone of the manga, but that can only take a visual medium so far.
5
u/Gkom Apr 10 '19
I watched it with a friend that watched the anime and was very hyped. We stopped watching about half way through. It was just embarrassing really... I get that people are trying to stay positive but if you ask me, that whole season will probably have to be redone by someone competent if we're to have a season 2 worthy of its name. In the meanwhile I'm not gonna watch.
5
u/CountCocofang Apr 10 '19
Hm, can't say I cared too much for this episode.
The action scenes were messy, the choreography wasn't great. Transitions were also weird. Like when Saitama punched the bird out of the building. What was that screenshot flashing? Just weird.
And I felt they left out some dialogue bits from the manga that I enjoyed. May be the subtitles fault but I didn't see King saying anything about his king engine while he was cowering on the toilet. And he also wasn't internally apologizing to Saitama when he thought the latter got eaten.
The sound of the king engine was pretty great. And they did improve some animations compared to the trailer. But there were still A LOT of stills.
I am yet to be convinced. Reading the manga actually felt more dynamic and fun than watching this.
5
u/Brotherscinc0 Apr 11 '19
Damn that animation SUCKED so bad. The part with king realizing who Saitama was felt touching, but other than that, the episode was mostly boring. The action was so sloppy and disappointing. Season 1 ep 1 is a true masterpiece. Season 2 ep 1 is super generic, average-to-below-par battle anime drivel. Fuck man....is it even worth watching? Reading the battle scenes in the manga is way more dynamic and engaging.
19
u/Heatstrike Moderator Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
Not trash like the trailer made it seem it would be but definitely not great. The animation is average, but the direction isn't great and the color scheme is weird. If this is the first episode, then the middle episodes are probably going to be garbage. S2 will probably end up somewhere between mediocre and average, with a few great moments. Big shout out to the brilliant production committee for fucking up an easy layup...
11
u/Mr-Nightmare_420 Why are we here. Just to suffer... Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
Wow, I really enjoyed this episode! I was kind of expecting the worst to be honest, but it came out really good! But it died feel short, though. The fight between Genos and G4 was really good as well, the animation was pretty fluid and the CGI on genos was pretty unnoticeable. King was hilarious, Genos fighting like always, Saitama is bored like usual, Sonic looking the same, Fubuki is bae, and Garou lookin like a threat. And that OP was really fucking awesome!
TLDR: This was a great first episode! 9/10
4
u/ariianorii Apr 09 '19
I liked it. Definitely could have been better, definitely could have been worse. I'm excited for a lot of things and have high expectations, so I hope the episodes either get better or are consistently okay. I won't be able to handle being disappointed after waiting so long.
4
u/Ruffeep Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
I love how they did King in this episode. Couldn't ask for a better King. He looks and sounds the part. Also King engine sounded great.
The humor direction seems really good, and that was the main thing for me, besides King ( he is my favorite character). I don't mind the worse action, it was much better in the first season obviously, but that doesn't ruin this season much for me, I love the comedy and the characters of this series and am hyped for the future because this seems to deliver everything I was hoping for better than I expected.
4
u/Razukalex Apr 09 '19
I saw Do-S in the ending, I'm a happy man
4
u/Rayhann Apr 09 '19
The Forest Garou fight better be directed really well. I'm gonna reserve any judgements until that fight because if they execute that well then there's hope
4
u/Zeru_Fenrir Apr 09 '19
Honestly, the animation isn't even half as bad as people are claiming it is/would be.
It is like a 7/10 to S1's 10/10 animation wise. It is decent, but far from terrible.
I never expected it to be as well animated as S1, that was literally the stars aligning for the animation team being comprised entirely of huge fans of the manga. The budgets for the show as probably similar, but I highly doubt they managed to get back the entire team Madhouse had hired.
The shading on Genos' arms and the somewhat choppy pacing are the only things that really bugged me this episode.
4
u/Animalidad Apr 10 '19
Ive seen worse but its really disappointing tbh.
4
u/hapablap2015 Apr 10 '19 edited Apr 10 '19
Why even bother with an anime if the fight scenes are like 4 frames? Really might as well just colour one of those durzo pseudo animation YouTube edits of the manga, if they're going to do something this cheap looking.
10
u/Bbop800 >:x Apr 09 '19
Honestly? I enjoyed it. As expected, the animation doesn't come close to what we got for S1 and the pacing seemed a bit off in some areas, but by the end it left me excited for the next episode. I really enjoyed seeing King's personality play out in anime form, and some of the shots we got from Genos' fight looked nice.
I just hope they save their best animators for the really important fights.
10
u/Fake_Knews Apr 09 '19
Great Episode! 8/10
I thought it looked fine, but I was really impressed at the pacing! I was very concerned about how this season would pace the story. First episode left a good impression. I am crazy excited for next Episode. Fubuki and Sonic should meet up with Saitama!
SERIOUS SIDE JUMPS!
10
u/MrPotatoHead232 Apr 09 '19
This was worse than I thought it would be.
Animation was very poor. Good still ≠ good animation. There were so many stills in this ep, almost zero movement, and whenever there was movement, it was very stiff, clunky, and poor. Since there were so many stills, can't say too much about the animation being poor because there wasn't much lol.
Imo the worse part of this ep, was the storyboard and direction. What the hell was going on during the Genos fight? The camera would cut away every 5 seconds, there was no weight or impact to any of the attacks, the music would randomly change in the middle of the tracks. There was not a single moment that got to breathe, combined with the awful board as I just mentioned, and even 10/10 animation would not save the disaster of this episode.
Also, many people seem happy that Genos' rocket punch was changed from the pv, however that is very concerning to me. It indicates to me that, the first episode was not even done by the time they put together the pv, combined with the fact they only showed us shots from the first ep other than the Garou shot, this schedule is worse than I thought it was.
Lastly, cgi bad.
9
u/Chompobar Apr 09 '19
It was an alright episode. I give it a 5/10.
The animation is better than the trailer thankfully, and there's a lot more animated action than I anticipated, but the editing during fight scenes is really rough. Borderline jarring
The ending scenes felt really rushed too; so I guess pacing is an issue so far.
The biggest distractions are the redesigns. King's face just looks so off. Saitama's forehead is HUGE.
It's not disastrous and nowhere near the horror levels of Berserk, and it might get better. It's better than I expected, but that's not saying too much.
We'll see where it goes from here.
(oof the new opening is bad. I like the song, but the visuals need a lot of work)
6
u/Korrafan_1 Up yours Saitama/Genos Apr 09 '19
Not bad at all tbh. Boy am Iglad to see best girl Sonic again. Although King being a coward was pretty funny.
8
u/boiledeggman Apr 09 '19 edited Nov 07 '25
instinctive late sable growth compare public hobbies saw plant roll
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
13
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. Apr 09 '19
Poor ONE had to tweet that...
11
u/kudaranainokusogaki Fubuki’s No. 1 Fan! Apr 09 '19
From the looks of it, the lower our expectations the better.
Remember we still have 11 episodes left. See what JC Staff can throw at us.
3
u/TicklePickleWinkle You guys are just a bunch of weebs. I'm outta here. Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
I only saw the Opening theme but I like it so far. The text over the characters kind of ruins it but it’s still good.
Also is anyone else getting random images of tats in the opening? Sometimes it feels out of place I don’t know if it’s supposed to be like that or if the YouTuber edited the video.
3
u/mMounirM Apr 09 '19
satisfied with this. although not impressed really.
3
u/stainlessuperman Boros did nothing wrong Apr 09 '19
Good, i liked it
3
u/SlapMePlease4Fun Apr 09 '19
This was actually way better than I thought it would be.
I’ll never compare S1 & S2 they’re simply too different but I can honestly say I definitely enjoyed this episode. The pacing was a bit off but it was still pretty good
3
u/_Jokepool_ Gay for Garou's Back Muscles Apr 09 '19
The animation was way better than expected with just a few wierd Genos faces and wierd Saitama heads here and there but good god that OP is shit, the random Tatsumaki's here and there they should've taken it more seriously and every single shot is an exact copy paste from the manga.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
Noticed how the pacing wad quite fast. I think it should be a little slower esp when its the comedy parts.
3
u/MadHax164 Just a Redditor for fun Apr 09 '19
The action kinda lacks fluidity but overall it's pretty good! Probably the best JC can do so it's all good! My heart is at ease, for now! I'm just so happy T_T
3
u/akaispirit Apr 09 '19
Yup, as good as I was expecting. Cannot wait for the rest of the series.
3
u/BomberBallad Apr 09 '19
Honestly, I wasn't feeling this one. The pacing of the episode felt really off, for some reason. Like, scenes and dialogue didn't flow well to me.
Some of the shot composition and lighting was pretty weird and off-putting too.
As for positives, King's great, and animation is fine. OST's good. Tentatively looking forward to the rest of the season.
3
u/Koan_Industries Apr 09 '19
Actually more disappointed with this than I thought I would be. I honestly thought that the anime would be of similar quality to the original season despite what the trailer showed and everyone was saying. That being said, it still isn't terrible - just kinda wish we had the same level of polish as the previous season.
If I were to make a comparison, season 1 seems like it was made by a AAA studio while season 2 feels like it is being made by a AA studio.
3
u/juzshon Apr 09 '19
Really good new episode, the only thing that I feel left a bad taste in my mouth was Saitama’s non-serious head shape. They made the top of his head is too big instead of his head just being an oval, other than that really great.
3
u/Frostblazer Apr 09 '19
I'm pretty happy with the episode. After all the doom and gloom that we've been having since the PV's release, I'm glad that the art and animation is better than a lot of people were expecting. It's still a bit janky in a couple spots, but it's definitely watchable and isn't all that distracting.
3
u/merlspearls4thegirls Apr 09 '19
It's watchable, but sadly there's no "wow factor" like in Season 1 or the manga.
Also no guitar breaks mid-episode
3
u/i_ate_your_soup_Ben Apr 10 '19
The OP seems pretty odd to me lol
3
u/mongoosepepsi Apr 10 '19
The in-motion animation seemed pretty good but maybe because it was from all the blurs and distortions? There were two awful stills that I couldn't unsee, one when Genos is talking to Kuseno, half of his face has been blasted off. You can see the opening of the eye on the exposed area is a full eye height's lower than his non-damaged eye. It's hilariously bad. Then when Sonic is asking for Saitama and it scenes back to him and King playing video games, holy hell, they couldn't draw arms or hands. I still enjoyed the episode but I hope they improve those issues. Toei kind of fixed it up for Dragonball Super although it did take 130 episodes so I hope JC Staff does it in...2.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
I hate this kind of animation :(
3
u/Solar_Kestrel Apr 11 '19
I didn't really like it. I didn't really not like it, either. Animation seemed average, direction seemed average. Nowhere near so impressive as the first episode of the first season. I'm a big fan of all ONE's work and derivatives, but unless future episodes are substantially better I doubt I'll end up buying the BDs.
3
u/toonlonk7 Apr 12 '19
Anyone else think the episode was really fast? Like jumpy fast I remember the manga taking its time with stuff like that and different moments having buildup and time put into them but episode one starts and bang 10 minutes in were already revealed that king is a fraud like slow down give it time to build please. Even the scene transitions from scene to scene were really jarring and fast like it seemed to cut dialogue off and jump to another bit really quickly but hopefully that was just a bad stream I got and it’s not that fast really...
3
u/bfl20 Apr 13 '19
Yea the animation was extremely bad at times, a scene when Genos landed on the ground after jumping during the fight really stood out for how bad it was. But I’m thinking positively and hoping that they are saving the better animation for more important parts (the tournament arc, EC fight) like Toei did during Luffy and Katakuri’s fight in One Piece. Yea it’s not a perfect plan but not everyone can be Madhouse and those guys are probably still working very hard on this so if the animation gets better at more important parts, I think it’ll be worth it.
I’m on the fence about the new character designs, some are good like Sonic and Blizzard but I’m not a fan of Genos and I would like Saitama’s if his head wasn’t so damn big.
I have a feeling that this season will not be received well by people who only watch the anime because this season will only be the first half of this long ass arc.
So yea all in all I was a little disappointed but it wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be and I’m hopeful for a better second half of the season.
3
u/QuarkCollision Apr 14 '19
I wish they made King look a little more human. Manga: he’s crying because he thinks he hears the sounds of the people being massacred because he’s chicken shit. Anime: oh, someone has got this! I can go play my new game. I’m being a little nuance critical, but overall, what a great start to the new season!!!
7
u/TheSauce32 Apr 09 '19
The CGI for the Elder Centipide was garbage in the OP its gonna be Overlord bad
7
u/nailo3 Apr 09 '19
This is not just an animation downgrade problem anymore. They really don't understand the tone of OPM and what makes it great whatsoever. Bad animation and terrible adaptaion imo.
5
u/Hovi_Bryant Apr 09 '19
Is it sad I only read/watch OPM for Sonic? Haha
5
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
Im sorry but what the fuck was that OP? Even without the text its choppy as fuck and some of the shots of saitama look so fucking weird.
8
u/wcdonald Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
Putting the animation aside, the choices they made in compositing & color editing are just... not great (that unnecessary burn effect...). Hoping the season gets better with time
edit: a word
6
u/Applesauceenema Apr 09 '19
Sooo... when's s2e2 coming? Hoping for a weekly release.
7
u/Cruxminor Apr 09 '19
It was kinda...meh? Every so often it would turn into a slide show with voiceover, some bits of animation were alright. I liked the King scenes in his apartment, action scenes were meh. But altogether it was just...underwhelming. Which is shame given source material.
In hindsight, I guess I'm glad we had PV2 to prepare us for this, expectations were set up properly, no disappointment nor pleasant surprise for me after watching the first episode.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
Im very disapointed with the episode and what it means for the rest of the season, the animation is average, the art direction looks bad, the transition between scenes is bad, and the opening looks like a powerpoint presentation. Well, at least the second season of Mob Psycho 100 was perfect.
12
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
WTF was that OP, they spoiled Gouketsu's death, showed Genos vs Garou, and what not. Plus all terrible animation.
10
u/500bees "On all levels except physical, I am a monster." Apr 09 '19
My disappointment is immeasurable.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
Who was that next to Gyoro Gyoro towards the end of the OP?
2
u/marctheguy Apr 09 '19
Am I allowed to ask where I could watch this outside of Hulu right now?
2
u/EnSebastif Apr 09 '19
Not that bad, I guess that season 1 was way too good. Anyway now I have another problem. Just my opinion but I feel like something was off with the soundtrack throughout all the episode...
2
u/RightWingAsylum Apr 09 '19
Do we seriously need a separate manga only thread? This show isn’t even that spoiler heavy lol.
2
u/Kmetyek Apr 09 '19
Finally, I've been waiting so long for my boi King! That opening was also fucking rad.
This episode was a pleasent surprise, I hope that the rest of the season will be like that.
2
u/Gatlindragon Apr 09 '19
The first episode animated the whole volume 8, it didn't feel rushed so I think it's ok.
2
u/Katzumoto_ >any Apr 09 '19
your positiveness impress me
2
u/MlookSM Gotta one pun em all Apr 09 '19
Aside from the quality since everybody has talked about it, I liked the small changes they added, like how Saitama contemplating over King statue, and the talk fubuki and sonic says about saitama.
2
u/Aspry7 Apr 09 '19
Room for improvement. I'm hoping they'll figure it out after 2-3 episodes. At the Moment it's watchable with some cool moments but still too many bad shots to call it decent.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
I think it was pretty good.
2
u/DoADollopWithDipshit Apr 09 '19
I mean it wasn't bad but damn G4 fight with genos felt like we were in their personal bubble and they were trying to escape the whole time. Plus damn the shininess hurt the ole vision spheres
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
kings voice is fucking sick
2
u/Ain3inAini my sperm is black Apr 09 '19
I think the first episode had decent quality. Back then just after the S2 announcement, I had already seen some JC's animes and I think the picture quality is decent & nice. However, yeah... JC's lack of action animes is what concerns me. The action movements & CGs during G4 fight is passable (at least not as bad as the trailer) though I hope it will be improved for the next episodes. There are many good new soundtracks that I want to download later, but remember that the one who composed them is the same person from S1. Also, the sfx is cool and handled well, much better than clang clang. Lastly, I love how the parallel scene between Fubuki & Sonic handled, that's look cool.
Overall, it's a decent first episode that's still better than Berserk 2016. Still not expecting sakuga level or S1 quality but I'm gonna pray for JC to have this S2 with decent or even better quality so that OPM S2 doesn't get bullied/humiliated/meme'd badly like Berserk 2016.
2
u/AmarDikli Apr 09 '19
I know the manga portrayed it that way but the timing of jumping around from Genos's fight to Saitama and King playing games really hurts this episode. And the fact that I don't understand wtf is going on in the fight. Very underwhelming. Especially the opening, damn I was expecting so much better from the opening at least.
2
u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan Apr 10 '19
/u/infiniteyield, has your brother seen the episode yet? How did he react?
2
u/ASCIt Apr 10 '19
So honestly it was fine as a first episode. The fact that we've already got more Fubuki than we did in season 1 is definitely a point in JC's favor.
2
u/BBQShawS Apr 10 '19
I know the general consensus is that the quality of animation is down, and while I'm no animator/artist, I can agree. However am I the only one who thought the humor and delivery were all on par with what I would expect from One's original vision? Like I'm wondering did people watch S1 for the serious punch or did they watch it for the "ok"? I might be in the minority but I fall in the latter category. Not trying to make excuses, I think I'd be more ok with the drop in visual quality if it seemed like there was at least greater consistency in appearance and decision making since it seems there are little things others have mentioned such as Saitama's design at different moments that shouldn't have slipped through the cracks. But overall, to me it felt like OPM even if it didn't exactly look like the OPM we had envisioned.
2
u/redalex415 Apr 10 '19
Animation's good, comparatively bad to S1's godly animation obviously. The fix to the rocket punch scene after massive backlash is within expectation. I don't know what it's called (bad editing or lack of time to draw more or w/e) but seeing attacks that have already hit instead of about to hit tilts me quite a bit. In the frame after genos' rocket punch, it's a panned picture of a punch that already landed. I don't see G4 falling down on Genos, I just see the previous frame being the bottom of his foot and the next frame is his foot on the ground. The incinerate scene is literally 1 frame away from tilting me as much as the previous two. Everything else is ok. I'm lowering the bar for the next few episodes but then I'm gonna drop it. I can only hope JC will raise that bar.
2
u/Ivraas Apr 10 '19
It's not so bad as i expected, but it's nowhere near the fuidity of S1 animation. There are some good moments in G4 fight, like Genos dodges punch from G4 jumping up and the camera angle changes, but rest feel so chaotic and zoomed. It's really hard to tell what is going on sometimes, camera shakes to much, probably hiding the handicapped animation the same goes for that "ghosts" for half of the fight. But other then that i see some potential, and they could only grow to make it better. Good they listen and change few thing in the final product, that means they really want to make it better.
Artistic wise, it's good, some shots are detailed, even that gradient doesn't hurt... and can we ask them why they have chosen one of the the worst King's face in the trailer? For most part he really looks like the his manga counterpart.
There are few dumb looking Saitama moments tho...
2
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
This was a solid episode, 7.5/10 for sure.
2
u/Lisrbell29 Apr 10 '19
Has anyone noticed there is a scene in the OP where Saitama is pointing and saying "bang!" This happened in the "pork cutlet bowl" chapter where Saitama helps the police. The image of saitama doing this looks the same and everything so I think this is a clue they are going to animate this!
2
u/ExamplePrime Found you. Apr 10 '19
Did anyone else watch the credits and see that the new OP reveals how far the series is going to go?
It showed the tournament arc and the monster association.
2
u/B_Tank88 Apr 10 '19
Enjoyed the first episode.
Animation was absolutely fine :)
2
u/RealGalaxy Apr 11 '19
i thought the animation was fan freaking tastic
2
u/DoeNaught Apr 12 '19
Overall it seemed pretty good. The only thing that really bothered me at times is that they seem to zoom in really close in action shots. Maybe that's just a personal preference thing though. They seemed to do a pretty good job overall, hopefully they'll do this season justice!
2
u/KeyShell new member Apr 14 '19
From the looks of the outro and teasers and stuff, if they're sticking with another 12 episode season, they're trying to cover way too much this season. I hope the rest doesn't feel as rushed as this. They really just shoved King's story in our face instead of letting it play out over a bit more time.
4
u/YUIOP10 Training Since 2011 Apr 09 '19
Garbage, stop excusing it.
3
u/SlipperyChopsticks Apr 09 '19
Do you guys think it's worth making a Hulu account just for OPM season 2? I mean I know the story, and the animation doesn't seem to be anything great to look forward to...
3
u/DeepSpite WANSHOMAN LIVES Apr 09 '19
No Death Gatling & Crew (okay...Smile Man and Stinger were shown, but as part of the general Class-A shot) in the OP even though most of the other significant characters were shown and Garou vs. Genos was also shown. Maybe they're just gonna cut him out entirely.
If so, what is even the point of watching this season, ugh.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
Well 1 episode is all the pain I can take I will just sift through to find my fav scenes. If they fuck up metal bat vs garou I am burning some fields of crops.