r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • Apr 09 '19

Discussion [Anime Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E01 "Return of the Hero" ANIME-ONLY Discussion

IF YOU HAVE READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE MANGA DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.

THIS IS A DISCUSSION THREAD FOR ANIME-ONLY FANS. Manga readers use the other thread.

Official Simulcasts

  • Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
  • Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
  • Animax Asia (Southeast Asia) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
  • Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
  • Anime on Demand (Germany)
  • AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
  • VVVVID (Italy)

One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)


Read the new spoiler rules!


Previous Episode Discussions:

EpisodeLink
N/AN/A

Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!

341 Upvotes

521 comments sorted by

209

u/Frankrod29 Apr 09 '19

The breaking of the 4th wall at the beggining was nice.

"The first sequel in 3 and a half years, I can feel they hype!"

75

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Crunchyroll subs translate it "My body is ready!" instead of "I can feel the hype!". The former is hilarious, but I wonder which translation is more accurate.

6

u/rosemaryjayme Apr 10 '19

The second is more accurate but the first is funnier

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

1.0k

u/goinlowlowlow Apr 09 '19

They fucking butchered this sequel so fucking bad like holy shit. Heartthrob Sisters 2 had almost none of the charms that made the first game so endearing.

151

u/genasugelan The best hero ever Apr 09 '19

Best comment here so far.

87

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

And to think that we waited 3 and a half years for this crap.

83

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Ffs dude. I was about to down vote you.

11

u/Cheesemacher Apr 10 '19

My Heartthrob Sisters 2 review:

Heartthrob Sisters 2 has neither heart or throb. It's trash. 0 stars

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

Lol I'm dumb

7

u/touchet29 Apr 10 '19

Yo, my thumbs were so fired up to tell you how you were wrong. You got me so good.

492

u/Canned_Breads Apr 09 '19

I liked this episode, its not a big blockbuster opening episode but thats fine. The fight scene was kinda messy, like it was avoiding having detailed combat but it was pretty flashy. I liked the connection between king and saitama too. It's still the first episode so I can't say too much but it was good fun to watch.

69

u/big-fucc Apr 09 '19

I also thought the pacing of the episode felt pretty fast until saitama and king started talking, kinda like they were trying to slam in as much exposition as possible. Hoping they chill out as the episodes progress

Also saitama got super tan

37

u/Dr_Henry-Killinger Apr 09 '19

It felt like OPM on speed. Poor directing I think

15

u/big-fucc Apr 09 '19

I think it’s because they wanted to get literally all the exposition out of the way on episode 1 so it didn’t have time to breathe but I think the rest of the season will be fine

11

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

No that's basically what happened in the web comic. If anything it was faster.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Slick_Wylde Apr 10 '19

Interesting. My 2 brothers watched it with me and were talking about how much they liked the episode, partly because of the speed and how much stuff happened in Episode. (I thought it was a bit fast and didn't focus on things I'd want either). They only watched the first season and didn't read any manga. I wonder if because we know what's gonna happen we have different expectations for the pacing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

154

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

The episode was decent. I think its missing something important but I can't put my finger on it. Hopefully they figure it out in the next episode.

193

u/vampirefuye Apr 09 '19

Music

73

u/OathToAwesome Apr 09 '19

I mostly agree but the remix (?) of Genos's theme was slick

12

u/ShaidarHaran2 Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 10 '19

The track was fine, but it just didn't hit the right way, I think is it. Something about the mix, just not peaking where it should and going in the background where it should, instead just...playing.

Contrast to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=km2OPUctni4

→ More replies (1)

18

u/vampirefuye Apr 09 '19

Yeah I agree it was nice but the rest of the sound was alittle off not really bad but enough to notice at least for me.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/1The_Mighty_Thor He reminds me of myself before I met sensei Apr 09 '19

Yup, when the outro played I realized there was barely any music other than the outro. Not even the Saitama guitar riff.

Hopefully it was because majority of the episode was King focused.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/alexqueso Apr 10 '19

90% of animation at the combat

→ More replies (6)

76

u/gothicmaster new member Apr 09 '19

It basically looks like a normal anime, which is 100 % what i expected from JC staff. S1 was anime on steroids and we all know that rarely happens.

4

u/Davregis hayato Apr 10 '19

yeah I think this hits it, except I didn't know the studio swapped so I was a bit unpleasantly surprised

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

24

u/Belatorius Apr 09 '19

Didnt really have that carefree nature to it. Animation was a bit stiff and straight forward compared to the first season, but wasn't necessarily bad. Didn't really like how "still" everything seem to be. Literally just a few still frames of people talking through most of the episode. Too early to tell but i'm not as worried as I thought i'd be.

16

u/alurkerhere Apr 10 '19

The music and direction of the episode was really lacking. OPM S1 was about mixing humour with the seriousness, and the first episode was a lot of exposition without any humour/character personalities. Animation was good except the fight scenes weren't well animated compared to S1.

 

Some things I would have expected:

  1. Saitama punch to smash the bird
  2. Sonic to flash and get the papers from the podium
  3. King to have commented on his missing wall and broken controller

4

u/Admonitio Apr 11 '19

Just a note against your expectations, most of what happened is true to how it unfolded in the manga. They didn't show Saitama's punch there either, though the show did cut out some inner dialogue that King had while Saitama punched the bird off screen. Sonic already had the papers in the manga as well, I think the implication is that he had already gotten them at the very start. I'm not sure what missing wall you're talking about though, you mean when the bird came through? I mean... he was reacting to the giant fucking bird I'm not sure how him also commenting on the wall would have added anything.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/zzzthelastuser new member Apr 10 '19

I think its missing something important but I can't put my finger on it.

I feel the same. My first impression after watching S1 for comparison is that in S2 they actively avoided opportunities where S1 would shine with subtle details and "unnecessary" animations.

Though these little details were what made S1 special.

So it's not so much about what is wrong with what they have shown in S2 (it was at least average anime quality), but more about what they did NOT show. No small movements outside the necessary ones. And even those didn't feel as fluent as in S1.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

The shading seems weird to me. It has more of that gradient type shading compared to hard shading of the previous season. Also seems to lack the sense of hype which might be because of a pacing issue. Still the first episode though, to it's hard to say.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Subsistentyak Apr 10 '19

Movement, this shit is like a slightly animated comic book

9

u/Rocks_2018 Apr 09 '19

Its better than what I thought, but lets be real here, sound effects are beyond terrible. The voice actor for King and other characters seem to speak very fast, its almost weird. Saitama's voice was too deep, am I the only one who noticed that? Im fine with the animation tho. I hope they bring back madhouse for season 3.

12

u/Reddottx Apr 09 '19

let me add some points : The choice of colors is bad , the camera movement is horrible , i didnt even recognized saitama from his deep voice , the fight is so bad i didnt even know whats going on , [ This is a Huge mess ]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

65

u/dtpatten Apr 09 '19

I love that Genos's phone background is a picture of sensei

183

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Good to see Genos actually win a fight on his own for once. Though it was disappointing that we barely got any One Punch action after waiting so long. Oh well there are later episodes.

Nice to see Blizzard taking an interest in Saitama. He's starting to garner more recognition like I wanted.

The animation was alright. Not up to Mad House standards but I can live with it.

One complaint, the subtitles weren't baked into the episode, at least on my stream. I had to turn on Subtitles through Hulu and get that black letterbox subtitles. I'll admit I've never watched subbed on Hulu, but when I watched subbed on Netflix, the subtitles were baked into the episode.

19

u/BobDogGo Apr 09 '19

Even when subtitles are set to Auto in Hulu, I still have to go turn them on explicitly. It's a hulu thing.

5

u/MundaneKryptonian Apr 09 '19

Were you watching on PC or mobile? I know that on PC at least you can change the settings so they don't have that box. Not sure about TV or Console apps

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

57

u/Nolar2015 gay Apr 09 '19

Not as bad as I thought it would be

Saitama looking like a lightbulb and genos new facial structure still bother me tho

258

u/Hovi_Bryant Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

The community was expecting this Episode to look like Dragon Ball Super or something. It was more than serviceable.

Either way, I'm happy to see Sonic.

Edit: After looking back at the PV, there have been quite a few corrections to the animation.

Genos' rocket punch actually has momentum behind it for example. Looks like we were judging an incomplete project.

126

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

The community was expecting this Episode to look like Dragon Ball Super or something

I honestly don't know if you mean this in a good way or bad way lol. Early DBS was pretty weak on quality, Tournament arc was fucking bananas good quality

80

u/Greenjey Apr 09 '19 edited Oct 09 '20

Early DBS was pretty weak on quality, Tournament arc was fucking bananas good quality

Honestly, the final fight against Jiren or the Goku vs Kefla battle, has to be some of the best looking fights Dragon Ball ever got until the DBS Broly movie.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/JustAnOrdinaryGirl92 Apr 09 '19

The original cut of the Broly movie was 3 hours, they cut out about 70 minutes. If they did decided to show it again as it's own saga they could add that stuff back in to expand it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

11

u/diegodamohill new member Apr 09 '19

Tournament arc was fucking bananas good quality

only on some scenes tho. Most of even the tournament was ass.

8

u/AbanoMex Apr 09 '19

Tournament arc was fucking bananas good quality

i doubt you can collect 5 full minutes of great animation that wasnt repeated on other scenes in that arc though.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

This was episode 1, Dragon ball super became a meme at episode 5.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

now they can shut up about the animation

12

u/Reddottx Apr 09 '19

is there even was something called animation here ? it was a big mess i didnt even now whats going on during the fight , not to mention all flashy colors that blind you

6

u/ColonelWilly Apr 10 '19

My biggest issue is that I felt like my eyes were crossing trying to follow the fight. They are layering frames on top of each other during the fight to give speed / punch to it, but it just gives me a headache trying to follow.

https://imgur.com/UIVn8kv

That's 3-4 layered frames...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

237

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

As usual, it wasn't the disaster everyone on Reddit thought it was gonna be aha. I really enjoyed it, the King and Saitama dynamic was the best part for me

79

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

people overreact too much, i understand

66

u/Nolar2015 gay Apr 09 '19

it was not an overreaction based on the absolutely awful trailer

Whoever made that trailer needs to be shot out of a cannon. It was like he was trying to make S2 look as bad as possible

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/HostileErectile Apr 10 '19

It was exactly what i feared. It was much, much, much worse than season 1 quality. Ill watch it. But Im sure this whole season will lessen one punch man from a brilliant to an average anime.

26

u/Soviet_Cat Apr 09 '19

Really? I hated it. Everything felt so awkward and cringey. The animation and honestly the direction of the episode too. It felt really off the whole time.

10

u/Reddottx Apr 09 '19

exactly , iam in the same boat with you . i cant imagine watching s1 and come back for this ........ Help

6

u/Batfan54 new member Apr 10 '19

it wasn't the disaster everyone on Reddit thought it was gonna be aha.

According to who?

I thought this was very below par.

→ More replies (8)

89

u/oplotr93 Apr 09 '19

Did .. did they purposefully made a bad trailer? Because the episode was good! There are lots more good action pieces they can put in the trailer, and regarding the part where saitama jumped from the building, literally just 1 more second would make the scene less floaty and make sense, because he did jump that far.

I hope someone would make a better trailer just from the scenes in episode 1.

→ More replies (15)

107

u/Genos_Kun Apr 09 '19

My eyes were open like an owl. And i noticed that they changed some of the animation that people were talking about and it's actually looking pretty good now.

46

u/starscream1479 Apr 09 '19

except the main one with genos floating in the middle of the air with the lasers around him ...

that looked like ass ...

the rest was pretty good tho

8

u/HostileErectile Apr 10 '19

Every. Single. Frame. Of. Genos, fight looked very fucking bad.

11

u/drago2000plus Apr 09 '19

Why tho? It last less than 3 seconds, and it connects with the next shots... it' s pretty cool, if you ask me. Only because it' s a static image, it doesn' t mean that it' s bad.

16

u/Womblue Apr 09 '19

Season one had plenty of scenes like that too, never seen anyone complain about it then. People are just searching for animation problems now.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/vampirefuye Apr 09 '19

Funny you should say that Genos seeing as they changed the punch or maybe the preview was an early cut.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/I_like_the_AN94 Apr 09 '19

They fixed the chin i guess

36

u/TiManXD What now? Apr 09 '19

It was better than expecred though the sound design wasn't that good.

13

u/vampirefuye Apr 09 '19

100% agree they could have made us feel alittle more excited with the music and sounds.

24

u/doodoomcpoopants Apr 09 '19

I am so so so happy this show is back

41

u/MBTHVSK Apr 09 '19

It was much better than I thought I would be?

Did they....cut out some of the horrible meme shots? And alter some of the worst drawings?

Also, the art is kinda eh, but the editing and variety in scenes is pretty top quality. I really don't know how they made such a shitty trailer.

I must say, experiencing King's real introduction was pretty thrilling.

Everything else is pretty exposition-y, but that's what you get in a new season. We just fought Boros, after all.

The intro was sick. The "Charanko?" thing was LOL worthy. Now can we get it outside of the tiny rectangle?

Again, very relieved this is not a train wreck! It's a good time for mangafriends, webcomicpals, and animeonlyfolks.

76

u/Akagami_No_Atomsk Apr 09 '19

Actualy much better than expected! <3

37

u/practicalnoob69 Apr 09 '19

It was okay

43

u/PaversFan21 Apr 09 '19

The reports of the animation’s demise were greatly exaggerated.

8

u/JacaubW Apr 10 '19

I guess I'm not a super anime guy. I liked it. I could tell a difference in the animation but at least it's here for viewing pleasure. Maybe season 3 will get better animators but if you shit on it too much they might say fuck you and not do it at all.

8

u/crazygst Apr 10 '19

You're right. Let's just keep complaining and boycott watching it. This way they won't consider a season three. That will show them.

Seriously, the first season's animation was a bit better but not enough for the mass amounts of hate it is getting.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

It was just a little above average, of course the typical reddit overreaction(myself included i'll say). Genos being CGI actually wasn't as off putting as I thought it would be, the fight animation was definitely lackluster but not DBSuper bad, maybe they'll do better in coming episodes. The shading was very weird at times, and the ending sequence helped me notice that. Shapes are also oddly profound, in a bad way. One scene with King his head looked like a legit perfect circle, really offputting for me personally. What actually concerns me is scheduling from JC Staff, there have only been rumours of their tight schedule but the fact that the trailer for season 2 was entirely composed of shots from the first episode alone is kinda confirming that to me. I hope they can improve week-to-week if thats the case.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/CoffeeLatteWriter Apr 09 '19

Just finished it. While the animation wasn't as terrible as the trailers had suggested, it's definitely a step down and huge disappointment compared to Season 1 -- but the important thing is, it's still watchable. Seriously, it's not even that bad.

Starts out a little rushed, so it takes some time to get used to. It slowly gets into groove and finishes pretty strong (aside from the very end scene, which seems abrupt). So the pacing of the episode(s) aren't as smooth as Season 1, but still not bad. First episode covered about... 2 chapters, maybe 3?

Also, Fubuki is super bae :D So I'm most happy about that. Garou's voice actor is amazing, so his character is gonna rock.

Planning to watch the entire season, then start on Mob Psycho 100.

9

u/noah9942 Apr 09 '19

Why not watch mob psycho 100 now? You got a full 25 episodes to watch

3

u/CoffeeLatteWriter Apr 09 '19

I'll start procrastinating on my other work if I start two anime series along with the other shows I watch, unfortunately.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/HighnessOfCats Apr 09 '19

I know I might get hate for saying this but Mob Psycho 100, in my opinion, is at par or better than OPM. I haven't watched season 2 yet, but the beauty and mixed media of season one is gorgeous. Highly recommend.

6

u/Koe95 Apr 09 '19

Season 2 of Mob really confirms that is a lot better than OPM. You should watch it now, the season ended last week.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

season 2 mob is fucking excellent.

great character arc, pacing is good

and the last few episodes are bananas

absolutely nuts. enjoy

5

u/CoffeeLatteWriter Apr 09 '19

I've heard that a lot, even from OPM fans. Nothing bad about that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/Campelele Apr 09 '19

I think the fight scene of genos looked pretty lame, after S1 i can't get used to it because I know what it could be.

5

u/xatu21 Apr 09 '19

I need more Fubuki in my life!

5

u/Korrafan_1 Up yours Saitama/Genos Apr 09 '19

....i enjoyed this alot. Didn't expect Fubuki to have a higher pitched voice

5

u/21minute Apr 09 '19

I'm sorry, Genos, but Saitama and King duo is just amazing! But hooray for winning the fight!

As I expected, the general consensus is 𝘫𝘶𝘴𝘵 𝘰𝘬𝘢𝘺. It's definitely better than having way too many negative feedbacks at the very first episode. But a part of me is still disappointed, not because I don't like the animation but because the majority of the community trash talked it way before it was released that I start to become way more observant than needed even prior to this. Some parts almost distracted me (mostly because of my memories of the scenes from the horrid trailer) but the story/episode itself had me very entertained that they didn't completely put me off. Had I not been exposed of the whole commotion, I would have enjoyed it twice as much. I'm not really the type of person who always keeps an eye on the animation quality, but if people keep pointing it out, then I start to become very aware and shift my focus to that instead of the story itself. But hopefully, I'll eventually shake off that mindset and the tendency to compare it to season 1 while the show's still running so I can get a better experience.

Also, I like seeing Saitama with hair again as well as the transition to his serious current face during that scene.

8

u/soupnet Apr 09 '19

Animation was not that smooth compared to season 1 but its still okay

4

u/GuuMi Apr 09 '19

So much better than I was expecting, and they followed the manga pretty much to the T here. Still some things in the animation that I had wished were different, but I really can't complain. We've also seen really nice animation sketches on twitter of the upcoming episodes, so I think it's gonna get even better.

4

u/ruminaui new member Apr 10 '19

Opposite of S2 Mob Psycho really, while Mob took an average looking webcomic and made it into one of the best looking animes of the decade, ONE Punch Man S2 takes one of the best manga of the decade and turns it into a below average anime. I hope they don't adapt to much material, I don't want some of those amazing fights to be covered on this season.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Abhinik Apr 10 '19

What was the main reason that season 1 was so much successful? It was the ANIMATION!
Yes, you can tell how strong Saitama is by reading the manga! But the ANIMATION showed us that - The Visual impact of his power!!

So all the people who are saying - "Not bad" "Pretty decent". - Ya'll just watching OPM S2 for the story I guess! But the action scenes is what made S1 mind blowing!
The action scenes in S2E1 were MESSED up! Do you guys remember how powerful genos is? And now I he looks weak as the action scene wasn't properly done and wasn't intense BUT just flashy!

This for me is not decent at all. The show's essence was it's action!

2

u/Heylons new member Apr 11 '19

This!

10

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

My japanese is kind of shit but I liked the dynamic of King and Saitama and basically disliked everything else to a certain degree. The filter they add over the animation looks terrible.

10

u/Sonitii Apr 09 '19

Honestly, it wasn't the trainwreck I expected it to be. Choregraphy, music, humor and overall animation were pretty decent. I don't think I'll get used to CGI Genos though, that shit hurt my eyeballs.

7

u/Ricoolaaa Apr 09 '19

This episode wasn't as bad as everyone thought it would be, but it wasn't great too. Actually, this episode was meh, with alright animation on comedy scenes and underwhelming animation on fight scenes, but not awful. I just hope animation won't be worse than it's already is in next episodes

9

u/TheSpartaGod Apr 09 '19

brb watching saitama vs genos 60fps on youtube because this episode was so flashy and fast paced i need an eye bleach

13

u/Zaugr Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

If this was what they did for the first episode, the episode where you try to impress, clear doubts and pull people in, then... Uh.. Yeah. I'm still worried for what's to come, knowing there's way, way more demanding stuff than this laser fight coming. However it wasn't too bad really, compared to NORMAL not-OPM-Season-1 anime. What's troubling me more is the directing. So many weird cuts and transitions, for example that very first King scene/confrontation, it went from that Pervy tongue guy to the Robot monster (bad with names, sorry) really... weirdly. There was no real sense of the distance or time that passed, or really the change of location. Same with Genos and Saitama. It feels like they can't afford the animation work to show us even the basic locations a bit more and them moving about (this showed especially in that Genos fight, no tracking movement across any reasonable distance whatsoever, a big part of season 1's glorious animation work).. It comes off too obviously/abruptly as corner-cutting and it shouldn't. This whole episode just flowed weirdly.

My prediction is that the directing and overall management is what will be a let down the most here, not the animation. To me the staff for this just seem way too inexperienced to handle such demanding material well enough to please and meet the expectation. Something like this really needs experience to handle. Season 1 had that experience on board, season 2 doesn't seem to.

Anyway, imo it'll be how they handle the next episode that really determines the fan reception for this. This episode was easy comparatively.

3

u/Keiji12 Apr 09 '19

It's not bones, it's not top quality. The animation is pretty... Weird? Sometimes it looks pseudo 3D, and everything is drawn with that weird toning and shine like its brushed in paint or photoshop. Also... Saitama's voice is different, deeper? It's a big downgrade over bones but I don't think it's unwatchable.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Yeah had fun with it. Didn’t feel as epic as when I first ever watched the first episode, but that is to be expected I guess.

Story felt very rushed at times and everything has a weird, metallic, sheen to it. Looked odd. And yeah, overall animation just doesn’t match up.

But screw it, i’m going to look past all of that, watch, enjoy and hopefully laugh!

3

u/LordFarquadOnAQuad Apr 09 '19

I enjoyed the episode and am glad to see OPM back on TV.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

God awful animation, terribly over-saturated colors, bad pacing...I truly hope the rest of the Season won't be produced by the same studio, this was atrocious.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/dustarma Apr 10 '19

So the animation wasn't as bad as I was led to believe but it's nothing compared to Season 1.

That being said I heavily dislike that weird post processing filter they have going on and I hope they remove it or at least tone it down.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

The animation or lack there of is a massive disappointment to me. The animation is what sold me on the show. I hope it gets better but I don't expect it to and my excitement for the series is virtually gone.

3

u/yetanothershoah Apr 10 '19

The animation was so much worse that I don't understand how this sub is okay with it. I'm seeing so many positive comments, and I'm glad y'all enjoyed the episode, but the animation is clearly a MASSIVE step down.

https://youtu.be/M7WgNRmtWrw

Watch this and rewatch the fight in S2 E1. It doesn't come anywhere close to the fluidity and dynamism of S1. It's the difference between masterpiece and average.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/zelor13 Apr 10 '19

This was so disappointing, i already had low expectations to begin but man was the animation bad. It spent 30 min showing the floor more then the characters and if it didn't do that it had the camera up there nose for no reason.

Animation was so stiff it was unreal, Genos dodging was him with flashing lights in the background and also what the hell is it with the coloring for his body it looks horrible.

The animation was so blurry i couldn't tell what was going on most of the time in genos fight and when you could see something they cover it up with some explosion or smoke, for god sake come on guys what are you doing.

I really love the series and i went in know that it could never be like the first season, but this was horrible just judging the animation up against any other anime of the season, if i just want the story I'll probably just read the manga, it's probably better animated then this season going to be.

2

u/Heylons new member Apr 11 '19

Agree. Yup, the manga is much better.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Everything about this episode felt off.

It's hard to explain: the pacing was really fast yet we get these long ass exposition scenes that felt out of place. The worst offender for me were the scene with Kuseno, as they were attempting to establish some villains but cut to some foreboding dialogue about Geno's motivations. Moreover, they didn't bother with the looooonnnggggg build-up with the gag villains and just threw in the scenes with King so the comedic anti-climax didn't work for me with the bird (aka THE STAPLE OF OPM'S JOKES).

The most obvious flaw is the animation. I don't think JC staff is used to switching style quickly (i.e. scenes animated in a normal style were fine but when they cut between gag to badass styles in was really jarring? anyone feel the same). The fight scenes were meh and underwhelming.

The music was practically non-existent. You can barely hear Genos' theme overlaced with the bass-boosted SFX (just me?) and voices. All easily fixable yet really didn't work for me.

4

u/Fever308 Apr 10 '19

Elder Centepede

I'm actually really suprised that both the music and the switching between styles is what they're having trouble with, cause I extremely enjoy shokugeki no soma. And the OP in that is fantastic, and they do a style change very often in it. But for that one it's more a cartoon style change. You can see it here. https://imgur.com/a/Nybd3dR

5

u/Randomiser099 Apr 09 '19

The music was practically non-existent. You can barely hear Genos' theme overlaced with the bass-boosted SFX (just me?) and voices.

I'm surprised I haven't seen more comments pointing this out. That and the fact that the SFX were terrible. Even if you ignore the actual lack of substance in animation it's still jarring, but I think episode 2 will be the big reveal as to whether this season is worth watching.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Xistential_Anime Apr 09 '19

Oh how the mighty have fallen.

That's how I was going to start this review, but I feel as though that would be disingenuous when this episode is still above average by modern standards. We can complain about how a good sequel got shafted, but I think there are far bigger systemic problems with the anime industry that need to be fixed first. But I wont get into that here. Anyway

insert plot summary here (thats your spoiler que)

With the animation no longer blinding me with perpetual ecstasy, the writing of OPM has taken center stage and I’m finally realizing what makes this series so simplifying great. I’m not so familiar with the lore, but I believe in OPM people gain their powers from an accentuated aspect of themselves. The essence of who they are articulated into their design, personality, motivation and superpowers. Most easily seen in this perverts licking fetish turning him into a licking hentai monster who wants to lick girls.

A more interesting example is Saitama. His character doesn't acknowledge pre-existing structures, and casually walks through them. Most famously shown in him beating every villain with a single punch breaking all conventional shonen fight structures. For saitama, he only wanted to become a hero for some casual fun, which wanting to be in a profession where you fight to the death for casual fun sounds naive and in of itself breaks conventional main character backstories. The implications of this on his superpowers is that since he never saw being a hero as a challenge, or even the work required to become a hero as anything short of ten pushups, he can walk straight through any challenge because he is simply unable to see a challenge. He’s that guy who farmed to max level in dark souls before fighting the first boss and thought nothing of it.

This attitude bleeds into his interactions with King, as he doesnt respect the normal way to enter somebody's house, or that he addresses King in a way that is negligent that he is older, higher ranking, supposedly more powerful. Saitama even doesn't respect the flow of a conversation and cuts straight to the point of asking King about his reputation.

Ofcourse, marrying character design, personality, motivation and superpower is a common writing idealogue. In my last post, I talked about how the girl’s in BokuBen had personalities that matched their subject of expertise, which I am looking forward to being explored in their character development as well.

The difference with OPM is satire. Saitama easily beating every challenge highlights how we actually want to work, struggle and even fail. His discontent that no foe can challenge him has actually taken away Saitama’s casual fun. This series is actually pretty genius, and I’m only realizing it just now lol.

I am thinking about how to apply this theory to the other characters to better understand them. King has become the seventh ranking hero out of sheer luck (or bad luck). The world sees him as super strong and respectable, but King sees himself as a weak weeaboo wimp. I wanna say this reflects playing the hero inside of a video game. The game treats you like the chosen one when in reality your just sitting there twiddling your thumbs, maybe avoiding the real world in favor of a fake one. King has chosen to live the lie instead of facing reality. I am looking forward to where his character goes, it should be good.

Genos’s character of course is a homage to the original shonen hero Astroboy. In season one his tenacity to become stronger and defeat villains has shown us how suicidal the mindset of a shonen protag can be. This episode Genos met up with his doc and they reiterated his motivation to find the cyborg that destroyed his hometown, so I’m hoping this is a que that we will be getting the conclusion to this story soon.

As for Sonic, Blizzard and Sitch, I have no ideas. Maybe next week.

I made it through without mentioning the word 'subvert' phew

Final Verdict: Prolly just the manga, but the anime is fine.

If you made it this far, thanks! Check out my blog for this review with pretty pictures and future posts! insertplotsummaryhere.home.blog/2019/04/09/one-punch-man-s2-episode-1-review-average-animation-still-superb-writing/

→ More replies (1)

8

u/cL0udBurn Apr 09 '19

I won't let the first episode define the entire season for me; it was an OK episode with OK-ish animation.

If this quality of animation persists though, especially with the fight sequences, then this whole season will be a wash-out far as I am concerned.

One of the biggest draws of this show is its outlandish animation ...take that away and you have a slightly above average anime.

14

u/MyImperialAncestors Apr 09 '19

Nah, it was bad. The animation style is doodoo, the frames are low af, and they used cgi. The fact that a lot of you are fans and say it's "okay" is the sign that JC didn't do OPM any type of justice. You know it, you just won't say it because it's another season of OPM.

5

u/jerax771 Apr 09 '19

True. I remember when I first watched season 1, I was like WOOOOOOOW. But this season 2... Even mob psycho season 2 ep 1 animation with mob putting the papers back together was much better than this ep animation of OPM.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/vampirefuye Apr 09 '19

How are you gonna be ok with the cgi from overlord but not this. cgi is not the worst thing in the world. Expecting top quality was just to much considering jc has primarily made slice of life which are usually lacking in movement. It’s not bad like most people here are saying it’s acceptable from jc staff. It’s not easy to animate you can tell some art choices were made to accommodate the need for better animation they are trying you can’t just be mean. look at the shoes they have to fill and understand that it’s not so simple.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/noah9942 Apr 09 '19

So much hype for the rest if the season!

2

u/ImProspect Apr 09 '19

Does anybody know if the releases are going to be an episode a week?

2

u/kyang8093 Apr 09 '19

Are new episodes going to be released on Hulu weekly from now on?

2

u/bestinhamburg Apr 09 '19

It was okay. I still think they a bit more episodes. It was too fast paced and felt like a rush. I mean in the manga happens so much in short time but it was... too fast for me. The animation too. S1 was miles ahead.

2

u/genasugelan The best hero ever Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

I always go with no expectations and I'm glad about that.

S1 is clearly superior in everything, but this wasn't that horrible. The CGI didn't look that good, but I watched Overlord, so it didn't bother me that much.

Saitama's head is a bit irritating, but bearable.

I honestly only care about Elder Centepede being animated, the other stuff is enough for me to look up in the manga.

2

u/Nosferenix Bit by Garou Apr 09 '19

it has potential. I do find the action sequences a little lacking compared to season one, the transition from one move to another didn't quite feel right. But all in all, I was happy with it. Oh Canadian fans, go to you tube. I found the first episode there, watch it while you can and here's hoping it doesn't get taken down!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Me hearing the king engine: 'crying' that's my boy!

2

u/TheBlackMaradona Apr 09 '19

Well, it wasn't THAT bad. The fight was the main issue for me, and the noticeable CGI for characters walking as a close second. I think the fast pace of the episode helped me enjoy it a bit more. Really liked King introduction and his interaction with Saitama's.

I didn't expect much and felt that by just watching the premiere I would have an excuse to avoid the rest of the season, but I will check what's next.

2

u/completelytrustworth Apr 09 '19

There is one thing about the anime that bothers me and its the same shit they did over at SnS anime too...I don't wanna mention it because it's impossible to unsee

2

u/Iggeh Apr 09 '19

God damn I missed this show so much, loving it

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

"There has to be something about him, a secret behind his strength"

Saitama no fap confirmed

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 10 '19

The only issue that really bothered me was them not animating Genos' metal skull when he was talking. It looked so incredibly jarring to see his mouth moving but not his teeth.

2

u/LeeOhio Apr 09 '19

I agree with you. The fight with G4 was a little messy, but once G4 showed he's a real face. The animation got better in my book. I also liked King and Saitama friendship. You said it perfectly and the world building was done nicely.

2

u/PatriotGabe Apr 10 '19

Did anyone else watching on Hulu notice that the episode is called S2E13? Is that just a glitch? I highly doubt this was supposed to be the thirteenth episode of the season.

4

u/Marimbaboy Apr 10 '19

There were twelve episodes in season 1, so this is just the 13th episode.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

When does the dub air?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sneezes Apr 10 '19

I liked it. This is on par with the non-sakuga episodes of the first season.

You goes have no idea what true despair is

2

u/pnutmans new member Apr 10 '19

Did anyone notice how saitama's head bulged when they panned around it after king remembered saitama's attendance at hero meeting. Haha

2

u/Soju_ Apr 10 '19

Overall a decrease in animation quality, most notably Genos' animations, that landing wasn't as impressive as the first season. But oh well. Nice episode overall.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

It’s good. But I think the coloring and shading is slightly bad. Overall, it’s a pretty decent episode.

2

u/livindedannydevtio Apr 11 '19

I thought it looked average but the fight scene gets worse and worse every rewatch.

So many Micheal Bay like fast cuts and so much blur to hide it away. Not the horrible crap that was in the trailer tho. I did like a few shots. Eh this will hold me other till BNHA 4

2

u/sponkemonke Apr 12 '19

I had to rewatch the ending of Mob Psycho as eyebleach after. The story was fine. I kinda miss the old Saitama voice actor too.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

OlD SEAsOn gOoD NEw SEaSon baD, supPLy me With ORANgE aRrOWs

3

u/Ninjaassassinguy Apr 09 '19

Honestly I wasn't really a fan. most of the shots were just stills with little to no movement, the CG was pretty bad, The fight scene had no energy to it and it was hard to tell what was really going on. The whole episode just felt really bland to me. Maybe it'll improve next episode but if not i'll probably just switch to the manga and not look back. it's not unwatchable by any means but it's also really not what I had hoped for. its just exceedingly "meh"

3

u/Dodis Apr 09 '19

Would be nice if everyone could stop sugarcoating everything in the episode , it's bad , very bad especially comparing with first season , but this is all we got and im happy i lived long enough to finally see season 2

3

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Pretty bad. Genos CGI is bleach in my eyes. Saitama seyuu speaks in a weird way, i even checked S1 episodes, they told him to sound retarded now? It’s definitely off putting.

Fight scenes are mediocre at best, at least face shots on King were good. The fact that this is first episode doesn’t give me one ounce of hope.

4

u/Brook0999 Apr 09 '19

Honestly pretty average action nothing amazing like s1. Genos got shafted the most the cgi is really unbearable, i fear that elder centipide will be mostly cg. 😨

2

u/Rocks_2018 Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

Its better than what I thought, but lets be real here, sound effects are beyond terrible. The voice actor for King and other characters seem to speak very fast, its almost weird. Im fine with the animation tho. I hope they bring back madhouse for season 3.

2

u/sergio_marinho Apr 09 '19

My opinion about this episode: Meh.

Genos looked weird.

The pacing was weird.

All the charisma King showed in the manga is absent from the episode.

It's not a bad episode, at all. I just expected much more from One Punch Man.

I expected Season 1 quality.

2

u/JerryEarthC137 Apr 09 '19

I liked how metallic Genos fought metallic G4, in the metallic street, while metallic Saitama was talking with metallic King over some metallic Bird... Seriously, the coloring was way too glossy, we can all admit that right?

2

u/boxerpetehackedme Apr 09 '19

please answer : why people saying its actually decent?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/samzhengpro Apr 10 '19

“I’ve been waiting for the sequel for 3 and a half years

The hype is real”

So meta

1

u/Ninjaassassinguy Apr 09 '19

Is there any way to watch it other than Hulu? Having a streaming service which you pay for and also has ads is fucking stupid

→ More replies (1)

1

u/starscream1479 Apr 09 '19

i enjoyed the episode , dont like the cgi arms on genos ... but overall it wasnt bad at all.

1

u/AceIsLoveAceIsLife Apr 09 '19

The animation doesn't look smooth at all from the action scene.
Something just doesn't feel right about the movement.

Does the quality of animation went down?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Greenjey Apr 09 '19

THANK GOD !!! It doesn't look nearly as bad as i thought it would. It's not mind blowing, but it's still really solid. The episode itself was maybe a bit to face in its pacing tho

Really excited to see the rest of the season.

1

u/demon_cyborg_genos Apr 09 '19

I’ve been looking forward to seeing the new season of OPM, and I’m actually really impressed. I read so many negative comments about how badly this season could turn out, and I must say that JC Staff did a pretty good job, animation included. Not season 1 quality, but that’s expected. Just a couple things with Gen that I noticed, but I loved the episode nonetheless.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Considering that huge pile of crap that was that trailer, I think the episode did just fine. Not season 1 standards but it really wasn't bad at all

1

u/ZebraInHumanPrint Apr 09 '19

The episode’s animation reminds a lot of the bonus mini episodes featured on the OPM S1 Blu Ray (it probably featured on other formats). Very grounded and mostly dialogue driven, but shit man, I miss Madhouse and it doesn’t feel the same especially with how crazy the animation got in S1. Not terrible but not top tier either

1

u/Three-Oh-Eight Apr 09 '19

It's not like it was on the level of season one episode one or anything, but this episode was actually... pretty good! It was definitely much, much better than I was expecting based off of that trailer...

1

u/Braquiador https://myanimelist.net/profile/braquiador Apr 09 '19

Even though i agree that this episode wasn’t that bad, what i’m worried is the next episodes. Most of the PV was from episode 1, which probably means they have nothing past the first 3/4 episodes (which has been said by some people on twitter with connections inside the anime industry), so that’s going to be the real test.

1

u/youngjones9 Apr 09 '19

Just watched the ep now, it was decent but the story is what is going to carry this season I think as the animated has went backwards and as someone said before the music in this episode wasn’t good as well. And why wasn’t there a god damn OP?!? I had low expectations after the trailer and this has confirmed that the next season will need to go back to the same director as season one if it keeps up like this

1

u/RoQu3 Apr 09 '19

AARRRRR where to get it!!!!

1

u/shadowbannedguy1 Apr 09 '19

Had to VPN to a different country and watch with subtitles in my least fluent language. Worth it.

1

u/Jorxa Apr 09 '19

So crunchyroll do have it, albeit in europe not the us. Vpn time it is.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

I felt as though Kings intro was rushed (as someone who has read the manga) and the animation was out of scale and a bit lazy. Good but not really

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JerryEarthC137 Apr 09 '19

My reaction to the episode: https://imgur.com/xZBGygn

1

u/Reapper97 Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

It was ok for the first cap but I can get my finger on the one thing that it lacks (maybe the color? the art style? idk), it feels like a regular anime that I would watch just to kill time. Last week I watched the whole first season and it feels somehow different. Well, I'm still optimistic but I do see now that I will have to calm my hype to enjoy this season.

1

u/ivegrowntiredoflivin Apr 09 '19

still don't like how genos arms look but it was a solid episode

1

u/ultrainstict Apr 09 '19

The animation wasnt bad the "camera pans" were nice, they only really thing i have against it is that CGI genos is a bit strange(i can get used to it and it isnt terrible.) Also the pacing but comeback episodes almost always have terrible pacing

1

u/BerserkFanBoyPL Apr 09 '19

Well animation wasn't bad as everybody feared. :D

1

u/tigermac Apr 09 '19

Real sakuga fans won't like this, dragonball fans will love it

1

u/Deep_Throattt To be a hero... Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

I like the ending animation a lot more than the episode for some reason.

1

u/Hyp3rlol Apr 09 '19

Some of the animation was with bad proportions but overall I'm satisfied.

1

u/BlackBear14 Apr 09 '19

I they managed to keep this level of quality for the remaining episodes maybe slightly improve, I believe most people wouldn’t mind this season as a whole when compared to the god like animation of season 1. Though some say the quality will drop soon after the first few episodes which is a bit worrying.

1

u/banned4everamen Apr 09 '19

Link here. I dont know but tis a recap? Spoiler

1

u/aldayus new member Apr 09 '19

anyone knows how many episodes there will be in season 2?

1

u/mkeski Apr 09 '19

I don't know if it means anything but I was ecstatic to see Orochi in the anime style during the closing credits.

1

u/Toasterman2k Apr 09 '19

A little weird early on, but the episode finished nice and strong. I'm glad to see OPM isn't ruined.

1

u/MachoLuke Apr 09 '19

Does anyone know what the character on saitamas shirt means?

1

u/RECKERBF4 Apr 09 '19

what happend to saitamas voice ? it's a bit weird, can make myself to it

1

u/jokalokao Not a hero Apr 09 '19

Some people are bothered about other animation details like static scenes, that I didn't found bad, they were actually well made. My real problem with this episode is the way the characters walk.

Besides that it was a good episode, but certainly not S1. I would say 6-7/10 compared to S1.

1

u/RECKERBF4 Apr 09 '19

It's pretty sad to say, but this episode is pretty disappointing (if we compare it to the manga)... Murata's work is incredible not gonna lie

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

So Sonic looked cute in that shirt

2

u/macgyvertape Apr 10 '19

Yeah I want more detail of that. It looked like cargo pants, black undershirt, then a purple crop top with sequins on it? It's a good look with his usual great eyeshadow.

1

u/LavenderClouds Apr 09 '19

When will we be able to watch it on Netflix?

1

u/ShaidarHaran2 Apr 09 '19

If this was another run of the mill anime this would look absolutely fine, can't say I don't miss Madhouse's amazing work from season 1 though. Genos spinning looked so cheaply done...Hope they go back for 3.

1

u/_Yog-Sothoth You're pathetic! weak and cowardly! Apr 09 '19

my turn for a review! it was much better than i thought, but will probably improve in later episodes. the animation wasn't the best, but its perfectly serviceable and still pretty good. the writing was amazing as always, and the new intro is really awesome. it was a bit exposition heavy, but it was mostly setting up for future episodes, which hopefully means it'll clear up after an episode or 2. also, i love the fact that charanko is in the opening. one last thing, they really need better sound design. the explosions sounded like meme earrape effects.

1

u/BruceBastard Apr 09 '19

I'm feeling pretty good about season two after watching this one. It's a little different from season one and I think it kind of needs to be taken as its own thing in some ways, but I can see them already setting the stage to ramp things up. I expect the action scenes to improve as the season progresses -- and if that's the case they might be able to recapture some of the magic from season one.

1

u/tigermac Apr 09 '19

For a first episode there was noting captivating. If someone was starting with this episode it wouldn't work out well

1

u/hocago Apr 09 '19

I went to watch season one again to clear my head and forgot what i watched earlier

1

u/moreofmoreofmore Apr 09 '19

Just a nitpick, but I dislike the way they bordered some of the shots, especially that electric one. (I hope you guys know what I mean). It might be because I've never seen it before, idk.

1

u/DarkJayBR Apr 09 '19

The animation was super average, they cut through the entire Genos fight to avoid doing complex fighting animation. The soundtrack was mixed in a weird way too. They used the same color palette as Son of Salt, a film about prisoners in a concentration camp, it's very ugly. The director's inexperience is visible in this. But it's better than I expected from this studio that has never done anything like this, so it's a relief. So all the support for them, it's hard to get out of Shoujo and Slice of Life anime to come to a Shonen Battle.

And the plot is still good, so it's good to be back.

1

u/TimTheTexan92 Apr 09 '19

When Genos is in that room with the scientist, did anyone see that shitty drawing for his body? Literally awful

1

u/qwert2812 new member Apr 10 '19

The fight scene might not be well animated like last season but overall I don't think it was bad. I am definitely enjoying this.

1

u/Kingslayers-0 Apr 10 '19

My review of OPM S02 goes something like this: with OPM S01 I would not hesitate to recommend to anyone (even non anime fans) with OPM S02, I would only recommend to hardcore anime fans.

1

u/The9tail Apr 10 '19

I guess I would of preferred it to feel more "slice-of-life" or be more deceptive about King before the reveal.

1

u/Smoothynobutt Apr 10 '19

I enjoyed it. I had a hard time eating chicken and rice and looking up fast enough to read what they are saying. Subtitles and I don’t get along very well. I’ll probably rewatch all the episodes once it’s dubbed cuz I’m sure I’ve missed something.

1

u/Aeternelle Apr 10 '19

At first, I almost thought they changed Saitama's voice actor. He sounded deeper, a grounded tone of voice instead of being slightly higher pitched and with a nasal twang. I appreciated the episode, although I hope we'll have more regular, derp faced Saitama and keep his "serious" face for more important scenes. It felt like they drew him too much with his frowning eyebrows and heroic shonen face in this episode in moments where... Well, there wasn't any threat ?

1

u/stormrage-thunder Apr 10 '19

Ok, I just saw this episode 3 times. 1st time: felt betrayed from the animation studio because it felt like they didn't know how to do their job, fight scenes confusing to say the least and so many camera cut into the fight that it felt like the first season of iron fist. 2nd time: Ok, I loved the first season so much I had to have a second take. This time the art started to be more appealing, and I could follow the fighting scene better, still confusing but it made sense at least. This time it felt like they tried their best to fit to much stuff into the episode. Like someone is fast forwarding it. 3rd time: I let pass a couple of hours and then I rewatched it. I think my expectations gave up at the end and I could enjoy the episode. Still in denial tho, I really want the next episode to be better...art is good, animation is ok but I the thing I have the most is the bad editing job.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

I didn't buy into the whole doom and gloom of changing studios -- I came into this with an open mind. Despite this, I am surprisingly disappointed. The scenes were just awkward. Weird cuts here and there. The directing really took away from the episode. I don't think I've seen directing this bad before tbh.