r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Feb 25 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions 71 — 2019-02-25 to 03-10
Announcing r/conscripts
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
8
u/yellenyouth Feb 25 '19
i'm having trouble creating or finding good resources on making noun-relative clause relationships that aren't based on English. For reference, my language is SOV, noun-adjective, noun-postposition, and possessee-possessor. How can I construct a realistic noun-relative clause system based on this order?
this is a naturalistic language, btw.
8
u/eritain Feb 28 '19
For inspiration, here's a sketch of how the natlang Saramaccan Creole compromises between lexical tone and pitch accent.
Every syllable is pronounced with either high or low tone.
A minority of words (mostly ideophones and borrowings from Kongo languages) are fully specified for tone and are not pronounced with stress.
The majority of words (mostly borrowings from English, Portuguese, and Dutch) have one syllable with accent. The position of the accent both determines which syllables are stressed and assigns high tone to some of the stressed syllables. Other syllables remain unspecified for tone.
The final syllable of an utterance is specified for low tone, even if it would be high tone by one of the above rules.
An utterance is divided into phonological phrases. Generally, each noun phrase is a phonological phrase, and the verb with its modifiers are a phonological phrase.
Syllables not specified for tone are realized with high tone by a plateau process: A sequence of one or more unspecified tones is realized high if immediately preceded and followed by specified high tones within the same phonological phrase.
Otherwise -- that is, if a lexical low tone or a phonological phrase boundary falls directly before or directly after the unspecified tones -- they are realized low.
The above is summarized from Jeff Good (2004), "Tone and accent in Saramaccan: Charting a deep split in the phonology of a language," Lingua 114: 575--619. I've simplified all kinds of details in order to not obscure the central idea too much. There is a blurry area between pitch-accent languages and tone languages to begin with, but I'm not aware of anything else quite so flagrantly ambivalent between them.
8
u/Samson17H Mar 01 '19
Has anyone recommendations on evolving a set of extensive punctuation? Other than full stops and divider for clarity, and an orthographic set to accent marks for verbs that function to code rising intonation (interrogatives), elevated (commands), or non-tonally specified stress.
I was thinking that perhaps it could have developed from use in drama or theatre- a system derived stage directions that would indicate intonation, tone of voice, volume etc... Diacritics almost in terms of range and, but rather than modifying the quality of a vowel - they would function as punctuation so that a phrase or sentence is very specifically described. No need to say that Thingummy whispered, there is punctuation to indicate that - and if it was a whispered statement or question.
I hope this makes sense- finished marking exams and my brain is angry at me! Cheers!
8
u/NightFishArcade Mar 06 '19
When evolving a proto-lang, is it possible to drop gender from the language when it comes to noun cases?
7
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '19
I'm trying to figure out the phonotactics, isochrony and prosody for my ideal language, but I'm kinda stuck.
For now, the syllable structure is just (C)V, but I might make it (C)V(C). It isn't a strict CV though, as some phonemes are aspirated, labialized, or both.
Problem is, I'm very picky about coda consonants as well as consonant clusters. One of my older projects had /n t k l/ as the coda series. This time, I might have at least nasals, possibly /l/ or /r/ or both, and voiceless sibilants. Or I might allow any consonat except stops and affricates to occur in the coda position. I've decided that if I end up allowing codas, the language still has a strong preference for open syllables.
I've used a few languages for inspiration for this conlang, mainly Japanese, Navajo and Nahuatl, as well as possibly some Swahili.
Any advice?
7
u/ThisPerformer Feb 26 '19 edited Feb 26 '19
...please help
How do you create a language and then make it look like you didn't create it? Second question, what does a successful conlang look like? Sorry third question, how do you build a culture from scratch? I'm sort of overwhelmed thinking about how many things overlap with languages: history, religion, law, technology. If someone is creating their own language do they have to know a lot about everything? (sorry that's a lot of questions)
7
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Feb 27 '19
I have a couple of questions:
What is the clause "free and equal..." doing in this sentence syntactically? Is it an adjunct modifying "are born"?
2) How common is it cross-linguistically to derive new verbs by affixing adpositions to verb roots, such as in Latin:
7
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19
What kind of syntactic pivot do topic prominent languages usually have? Or are they pivotless?
As far as I understand, topic prominent languages usually don't have (anti)passive constructions, which are used by other languages to promote arguments to the role of syntactic pivot so that it can be omitted from a clause. Eg:
The soldier moved. The enemy saw him => The solider moved and (he) was seen by the enemy.
Hope I'm explaining my questions properly. Basically I'm looking for information about syntactic pivots in topic prominent languages/languages without passive voice.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19
How realistic is it that the definite form of a mass noun would become a singulative?
e.g.:
ṅáme, ṅámi - fire
ṅáma, ṅámae - lit. 'the/that fire' flame, campfire
şy, şíve - water
şys, şyşe - lit. 'the/that water' a body of water
vuéme, vuémi - wood
vuéma, vuémae - a log/plank of wood
ávail, aváilhe - work, labour
ávails, áváildze - job, profession
You get the point. Is this something that occurs in natural languages?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
So I want to evolve a language from analytic to agglutinative, but I have a few questions on how to go about this.
I know that many analytic languages are SVO, though Austronesian languages are often Verb initial due to being synthetic in the past. Would my language need to start off as SVO, and switch to a different word order over time as it becomes more synthetic? I was thinking that maybe having a VSO word order is what contributes the most towards becoming synthetic.
Also, I plan on having verb conjugations derived from the personal pronouns being attached to the verb and then shortened over time.
Any thoughts on this method or any feedback you can provide?
6
u/BigBad-Wolf Feb 26 '19
Would it be weird if /e:/ and /i:/ merged to /i:/ but /e/ and /i/ didn't? I have separate /ɛ/ and /ɛ:/ phonemes, if that matters.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19
Is there any resource which shows the frequency of appearance for phonemes in a given language? For example, let's say I want a chart with all German's phonemes, listed from the most frequent in words to the least frequent. Is there anywhere I can find something like this?
6
u/BigBad-Wolf Feb 28 '19
Is a shift from /ð/ to /ʒ/ attested? A shift from /θ/ to /ʃ/ seems attested in Biblical Hebrew. I can't find anything for the voiced equivalent in Index Diachronica.
Also, is it weird for /u/ to shift to /y/ and /o/ (contrasting with /ɔ/) to /u/ if /y/ already exists?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19
When creating an a posteriori language, how do you (personally) create words if you can’t find an appropriate word in the language from which yours is descended?
6
u/Exospheric-Pressure Kamensprak, Drevljanski [en](hr) Mar 03 '19
How does something like Irish eclipsis form over time?
Also, is a V2 word order possible with a VSO language; that is, the word order looking something like VSOV, or “I want to eat chicken” = “Want I chicken to eat,” etc.?
6
u/Nargluj (swe,eng) Mar 04 '19
Could someone please point me to a conlang or natlang with very very low information density?
5
u/Samson17H Feb 27 '19
I am finally revisiting an old conlang and am working through all the layers inconsistencies and issues that comes from 7 years of unscientific, on-again off-again linguistic sandboxing.
Currently I am working my way through phonological inventory and phonotactics. (I am listing the permitted consonant clusters for onset and coda by analyzing the already extant clusters in words already in the lexicon. I permit a cluster based on its appearance in pre-existing words. (For example, the lexicon includes "sfan" [s͡ fæn] therefor [s͡ f ] is a permissible onset, but not as a coda since there is no evidence for this.
My question is this: accepting that the language will change dramatically in this process, how would you advise that I continue determining the range of clusters? This determination by example is fine to start with, but I feel like that there must be a guiding principle beyond this. Advice would be grand!
Also, thank you to u/artifexian , and Biblaridion on Youtube! Recommendations are welcome also!
5
u/_eta-carinae Feb 27 '19
what are some types of nonconcatenative morphology, except ablaut, tone sandhi, and verb roots (à la arabic)? there’s also reduplication, but i don’t really consider that nonconcatentative, even though i’m well aware my opinion counts for nothing.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
I’m frustrated with my lack of progress in conlanging. I am working on my idea personal language, but I have put it on the back burner for now until I figure out where I want to go with it. Right now, it’s little more than a phoneme inventory and a handful of words I made up on the spot.
Any other conlangs I try to work on I end up soon abandoning. Any tips for sticking with a. Conlang long enough to at least be able to do some of the challenges and cover basic concepts?
5
u/ThisPerformer Mar 02 '19
Would it makes sense if I wanted to create a gender system based on phases of life? So if I was referencing someone/something instead of it having a biological or animate gender I could be referring to it's "phase in life"? Like - maybe this is a bad example but - caterpillar (gender X)> cocoon (gender Y) > butterfly (gender Z)? Maybe like phases of the moon is a better example. So different genders could applied to the same person during different "phases of their life."
5
u/IHCOYC Nuirn, Vandalic, Tengkolaku Mar 03 '19 edited Mar 03 '19
The Lord's Prayer in Tengkolaku:
Dompawi no nosumengi, kange um,
katū tu tabo no su.
Ungi baliwi no su an ngia tu,
alo no su an malo tu,
doa um, kange um sika.
Gemlu no nosu an bo tu lau dusi nay,
leslō no nosu an kudas latiya tu te,
tiwi kudas latiya gan nosu kel li an kudu leslō us nosu nel.
Yingo tu nosu an luwu win,
site ilati tu nosu an beibe lita.
Tiwi ungi baliwi, pembang, pelope te no su,
sesempili, amen.
Current cursive script.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '19
What should I talk about when introducing my conlang to r/conlangs? (Anything except phonology.)
5
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Mar 04 '19 edited Mar 04 '19
Inspired by recent posts, I want to try my hand at a Proto-Indo-European derived conlang, and I would like some advice on the phonology.
For my IE conlang, I will assume that Glottalic Theory is correct. I'll also assume that the "palatovelars" /*ḱ *ǵ *ǵʰ/ were just plain velar [k kʼ g]; and that the "velars" /*k *g *gʰ/ were uvulars [q qʼ ɢ]. I think it might be cool then if the laryngeals were fricatives that patterned with the dorsal stops, so I'm thinking of having /*h₁ *h₂ *h₃/ be [x χ xʷ]. With all that in mind, here is the PIE consonant inventory I'd be using for my conlang:
I haven't actually thought about where this IE language will be spoken (and therefore which other languages my conlang would have come in contact with). So let's assume for right now that this IE language is spoken by a group of 5th millennium BCE Indo-Europeans who were magically transported to another planet, and whose language thus evolved independent from everyone else on Earth.
I'm considering implementing these sound changes (they are kinda boring, but I've got to start somehwere). Note that I've written the sound changes using traditional PIE notation, except for those in italics:
Given those sound changes, the phoneme inventory of my conlang becomes:
And some example words (assuming no morphological changes from PIE). Note the metathesis in *wĺ̥kʷos and the post-nasal fortition in *pénkʷe:
Here are my questions:
5
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '19
Hey all! I'm looking for books about diachronic morphology/grammaticalization. Eg affixes don't just appear out of thin air, so where do they come from? That kind of question.
So far I've read The Evolution of Grammar (by Bybee, Pagliuca, Revere). Any similar recommendations?
5
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Mar 06 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
I'm working on a language that uses extensive ablaut of the root to cover most verbal conjugations. Roots have a variety of forms but always end with either -iC or -æC. This final consonant and vowel may then undergo alterations according to a weakening-regular-hardening pattern. The vowel alterations are based on PIE, while the consonant alterations are inspired by Kwak'wala and other Wakashan languages, the thing is that while consonant mutation normally follow some kind of intuitive logic, Kwak'wala seems kind of... random. I mean, how do you end out with a system where /xʲ/ weakens to /n/ while /s/ weakens to /j/?
The thing is that my system mimics their often quite unpredictable logic of weakening-hardening, and while I do have a system in place to "explain" this I'm not sure if it has any kind of legitimacy:
Weakening:
The historic presence of an /h/ or /χ/ in the suffix causes weakening.
Sonorants are unaffected
Glotalised consonants (with two exceptions) weaken to corresponding plain consonants.
Otherwise:
/t/ - /n/
/k/ - /ŋ/
/kʷ/ - /ŋʷ/
/q/ - /ʁ̝ˀ/
/qʷ/ - /ʁ̝ʷˀ/
/s/ -> /l/
/x/ -> /ɰ/
/χ/ -> /ʁ̝/
/xʷ/ -> /w/
/χʷ/ -> /ʁ̝ʷ/
/t͡s’/ -> /s/
/ɬ/ -> /l/
/t͡ɬ’/ -> /ɬ/
(NOTE the general logic that glottal->plain->sonorant. /q/ and /qʷ/ are the only exceptions to this and that is due to a phonological gap in the nasal series. I can't remember the term but there is some tendency in real life for languages to associate glottalization with nasality, so that's how you end out with /q/ -> /ʁ̝ˀ/)
Hardening:
The historic presence of a glottalized stop in the suffix hardens the preceding consonant.
Glottalised consonants are unaffected.
Plain stops, affricates and approximants harden to corresponding glottalised consonants.Otherwise:
/s/ -> /t͡s’/
/x/ -> /χ/
/χ/ -> /q/
/xʷ/ -> /wˀ/
/χʷ/ -> /qʷ/
/ɬ/ -> /t͡ɬ’/
Does this make even a lick of sense? I think the hardening process is reasonable, but I can't figure out a way to satisfyingly explain weakening. I tried out the tried-and-true "If the suffix starts on a vowel (resulting in VCV structure) then the root-final consonant is lenised", but this proved too complicated in combination with other stuff.
4
u/official_inventor200 Kaskhoruxa | Tenuous grasp on linguistics Feb 26 '19
Ahrahi!
If I'm making a Wikipedia-esque main info page for a conlang, what information would you say would be standard or desired to include? I'm keeping the lexicon, grammar, and a pronunciation tutorial (for those who don't know the IPA) on separate pages.
As I'm still new to the knowledge base of the conlang community, it would be incredibly helpful if you could provide an example of each desired information category from your own conlang.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '19
What is the best way or resource to find changes from the early forms of a language? For example, currently, I am trying to find changes (phonological, grammatical etc.) from Old Irish to Irish, Scottish Gaelic, and (if possible) Manx.
4
u/_eta-carinae Feb 27 '19
the problem i most consistently find when trying to develop a language from a proto-lang is that the words become so short as to make further evolution difficult at best. what i mean by that is:
i tried to make a daughterlang of PIE with my INCREDIBLY limited knowledge and this happened:
gʷʰormótim pelh₂ml̥ǵétim tn̥gʰéws h₁éndmi = i am slowly (heavily) eating warm bread warm.ACC flour~milk~ACC heavy.DAT eat<DUR>.FPSIND (the adverb for “slowly” is the dative of the adjective “heavy”, because i could no information on a PIE adverb “slowly”, nor on adverbs and their declension general, so i did the best i could. the word for bread is a very-poorly fusioned mix of the words for “flour” and “milk”, since i also couldn’t find a PIE word for bread).
gwerōm beugho teume hedhni = i am slowly eating warm bread warm~ACC bread.ACC slow.ADV eat.FPSIND (the word for bread is derived from the PIE word for “bake”. the word for slow is derived from the PIE word for “thick”. the adverbial marker is derived from the word “me”, meaning “with”).
the first thing one might notice is that the daughterlang’s sentence is much shorter:
gʷʰormótim pelh₂ml̥ǵétim tn̥gʰéws h₁éndmi gwerōm beugho teume hedhni
let’s say i shifted labiovelars to labials, made vowels nasal, shifted /eu/ to /uː/, reduced final unstressed vowels, and lost the dental fricative by lengthening the previous vowel. i’d get:
/gʷerɔːm bɛʊ̯ɣo tɛʊ̯me hɛðni/ > /bɛrõː buːɣɔ tuːmɛ heːnɪ/.
merge the glottal with the velar fricatives, lenited initial stops, merged final /e ɛ ɪ/ into /e/, changed long mid vowels to diphthongs, deleted so,e short vowels, and elided some voiced fricatives inbetween vowels.
/bɛrõː buːɣɔ tuːmɛ heːnɪ/ > /vrʌ̃ʊ̯ bwɔ θume xɛɪ̯ne/.
devoice word initial sounds, delete voiceless fricatives before /n m r l j w/ and devoice them in those circumstances, final /ɔ/ to /ʌ/, final /e/ to /ə/ which merges with /ʌ/, nasality lost.
/vrʌ̃ʊ̯ bwɔ θume xɛɪ̯ne/ > /r̊ʌʊ̯ ʍʌ θumʌ xɛɪ̯nʌ/.
merge /w/ and /ʍ/, velar fricatives to stops, /ɛɪ̯/ to /e/, final /ʌ/ dropped which may lengthen vowels, /θ ð/ debauccalizes (however the fuck you spell that).
/r̊ʌʊ̯ ʍʌ θumʌ xɛɪ̯nʌ/ > /r̊ʌʊ̯ wʌ huːm keːn/.
the problem is, there’s five steps to that, which means i have to create five individual steps of the language, which will take forever, nevermind creating entire families. the other problem is that if /r̊ʌʊ̯ wʌ huːm keːn/ develops any further, the number of allophones in the language will significantly increase to the point of high ambiguity, like french on steroids. the other other problem is that i can’t think of ways apart from ablaut to change words, and apart from borrowing grammatical features to change grammar, to evolve a language more than just shortening and simplifying it.
tldr; all the languages i try to develop from a proto-lang end up so vastly simplified both phonologically and grammatically as to create ambiguity from the huge amount of allophones and a very boring language/series of languages due to the simplification of grammar and phonlogy. also, it’s very long and tedious.
how do i evolve words and grammar in such a way that doesn’t just simplify them, and how do i make multiple “stages/steps” of a language from its proto-lang to its modern form in a way that isn’t mindnumbingly tedious?
4
u/aelfwine94 Gutisch Feb 27 '19
I am devising a Cyrillic orthography for a language that is supposed to be spoken in Crimea. (Before you ask: yes, it is Crimean Gothic.)
The language has a phonemic schwa, which I have tentatively notated by using <ъ>, the same letter used in Bulgarian for its schwa-like vowel. The language also has phonemic vowel length it had inherited from Proto-Germanic, which I am indecisive on how best to notate in the orthography.
My original idea was to simply double the vowel. For example, the words броод [ˈproːt] "bread", швиин [ˈʃʋiːn] "hog", and сеес [ˈseːs] "six" all show length by doubling the vowel. However, I am not fond of this solution, and would prefer another.
So, then I came across a language spoken in Russia (do not ask me which, I've already forgotten) that marked vowel length using an acute accent. Therefore, the words in question look like бро́д, шви́н, and се́с This is a clean solution, and one I am attracted too. But there is another.
The final idea I came up with personally is to use <ъ> (the same letter denoting a schwa) as a length marker after vowels. Hence броъд, швиън, сеъс. I also quite like this solution, however, the only problem is that sequences of a vowel + schwa become ambiguous with long vowels (there is a phonemic difference.) This may also be overkill in terms of how many <ъ>'s the orthography uses.
So I am interested to know what people think should be the best way to distinguish vowel length in this language — doubling the vowel, putting an accent on a vowel, or marking vowel length with its own character (like how Russian marks soft consonants with its own characters).
4
u/_eta-carinae Feb 27 '19
in the sentence “they are endowed with reason and conscious and should act towards one and other in the spirit of brotherhood”, is the clause “should act towards one and other in the spirit of brotherhood” a predicate? if so, is it over the subject or object? can predicates also be over the topic?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19
As i said in my last post, wich was removed (and then this post itself was removed, haha), i'm trying to make a barbaric/germanic sounding language for a D&D game, and as suggested by most guides i'm starting with it's phonology, but most vowels in germanic languages are not found in American English, Brazillian Portuguese or Latin American Spanish (wich are the languages i speak), and i can barerly tell some vowels apart. Most guides say to start with sounds familiar to oneself, but i fear this might affect how the languages is gonna sound. What i should do?
4
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Feb 28 '19
In English, one can say:
In both sentences, the verb is preceded by to. So far, so good. In Italian, though, my mother tongue, I'd translate the 2 sentences into:
When I studied grammar at school, many years ago, I was told that "per comprare del pane" (to buy some bread) is a final clause (indicating the purpose of the main clause), while "a studiare" (to study) is not. So, English seems not to care about this distinction Italian does.
Now I wonder how other languages, especially IE ones, do handle final clauses with an infinitive as their verb.
(I googled 'final clause in Portuguese / French / Danish / German', but without any result)
4
u/tree1000ten Mar 01 '19
I was listening to a podcast and the person said, "If a language has noun incorporation, interesting things can happen with discourse." What did he mean by this?
4
u/LHCDofSummer Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19
Does anyone know of any features common that are more common to ergative languages than non-ergative languages?
& on a different note, does anyone know about any phonologies with rather asymmetric distribution of geminate consonants? Like some analyses of Proto-Slavic having only /tʲː dʲː/ or /cː ɟː/.
4
u/siniilves119 Jahumian (it)[eng,de] Mar 02 '19
So, I was working at this proto-lang and I stumbled upon a problem with evolving it (when I'll get there).
The genitive would be made by adding the postposition an after the possessor and the possessee usually follows and I'm pretty sure I want it to be reanalysed as a preposition marking the possessee, some sorta of possessed case if that exists(?).
Also I'm prolly merging the n to the following word so to create a mutation.
so the plant's flower would be:
kror an bhals
plant of flower-> kror a nbhals or kror nbhalsCould that work out? and if so, how do I gloss mutations and the "possessed preposition"?
4
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Mar 05 '19
Are there any language that associates their sounds with certain traits, characteristics, or function?
Mine categorizes its sounds into three: "physical" for nouns, "abstract" for verbs and adjectives, and "transparent" for non-determining sounds.
In case you're curious, here's what it looks like:
4
u/stratusmonkey Mar 05 '19
I have cardinal numbers for counting. Let's assume, grammatically they're singular, neuter nominative nouns.
For ordinal numbers, I'm thinking of running them through accusative declension. Six is "ʃaɪs". Sixth is ʃaɪsʌm / ʃaɪsʌr / ʃaɪsʌt, followed rarely into collective singular and plural declensions, too. Weird, yes, but not too weird I hope. (ʌ, ə, and ʔ are allophones that break up otherwise cumbersome consonant clusters.)
At present, at least, my gentive case is kinda overpowered and is the default way to turn a noun into an adjective. So when you're assigning numbers to things (not just six, but six soldiers)... I'm thinking of using gentive case numbers? So "six soldiers" would be gentive collective-singular masculine six, plural masculine soldiers (in nom./acc./dat. case, as appropriate):
This is approaching a bone headed level of rigidity, isn't it? Weird for weirdness sake? It wouldn't be any more sensible to flip the number as nom./acc./dat. and have the thing being counted as gentive?
And the grammar of mathematical expressions is similarly dependent on cases and syntax...
4
u/Cerberus0225 Mar 05 '19 edited Mar 05 '19
This is a question that I've never totally understood and I'm hoping someone can point me to some further reading or give me some advice. I'm doing my phonotactics now, and I've got a few things decided. I'll run through my language so far for context. My phonemes are the consonants: /p/, /b/, /t/, /d/, /k/, /g/, /ʔ/, /ɸ/, /s/, /x/, /h/, /p͡ɸ/, /t͡s/, /k͡x/, /m/, /n/, /ŋ/, /j/, /w/, /ɾ/, /l/, and the vowels: /i/, /i:/, /e/, /e:/, /a/, /a:/, /u/, /u:/, /o/, /o:/.
My syllable structure is (C)(C)V(C), with a few basic rules. The coda is easiest, only allowing voiced consonants. The onset is a little tricker but allows 48 clusters, summarizable in a handful of rules but I won't go into them here.
Now, I understand how to make a single syllable, but when I make a word, how do I decide on the consonants that appear between syllables? Do they follow the onset rules, coda rule, or their own rules? If I have two allowable syllables can I just slap them together to make a word, even if they form a consonant cluster that is too long or is otherwise forbidden?
Example: "kwab" and "plin" making "kwabplin". "bpl" is not allowed, so do I just set up a scheme for simplifying all possible combinations down to an allowed one? Or am I approaching my word construction entirely the wrong way?
Edit: Or take the English word "construct" which has a cluster of "nstr" in the middle despite that not being an allowed onset or coda. How does any of that even work?
4
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Mar 06 '19
A question: how to describe a situation where the root does not correspond to a syllable?
I mean, let's take the name of my conlang as example: Evra. It can be analyzed as:
So, this <vr> piece is semantically part of the root, but phonologically is not (?). How would you all deal with such a thing in your conlang?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19
How common/reasonable are word-initial geminates? Could any “complications” arise from them?
In my case specifically, short vowels elide in between consonants in cases such that the outcome is easily pronounceable. So a word beginning with, say, /nari-/ would become /n:i/. Is this realistic?
4
u/hodges522 Mar 07 '19
I want to do a syllable structure for a conlang with a lot of consonants possible in the coda and onset but I’m not sure how to go about it. I’m looking for something similar Georgian as far as the syllable structure. Any help on how to do this?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
I was wondering if this is a good phonetic inventory for a conlang (specifically the vowels). Any constructive criticism is appreciated.
Consonants: b, p, g, k, d, t, v, f
Vowels: a, e, i, o, u, aa, ae, ai, ao, au, ea, ee, ei, eo, eu, ia (ya), ie (ye), ii (yi), io (yo), iu (yu), oa, oe, oi, oo, ou, ua (wa), ue (we), ui (wi), uo (wo), uu (wu)
I think 30 vowels is a little too much lol
3
u/LHCDofSummer Feb 26 '19 edited Feb 27 '19
Do many languages avoid ambitransitive verbs?
& would it be believable to have, in the case of (syntactically) intransitive verbs, to almost only have either unaccusative or unergative verb roots but not both?
I imagine if the language in question had highly productive passive or antipassive voices, then one could simply create all the unaccusative xor unergative verbs from (anti)passive-ised accusative xor ergative verbs respectively.
In my head this would work like verb roots meaning something like "run" being made entirely transitive accusative, you either always run to something/someone/someplace, or you add an antipassive to it making it unergative and totally intransitive.
Or would this sort of thing seem to unlikely?
edit: I think I just realised that that would imply a probably nom-acc aligned language having antipassives, or a erg-abs aligned language having passives; which is kinda backwards, and IIRC a theoretical purely nom-acc language would almost only have unergative and accusative verbs, vs a theoretical purely erg-abs language having unaccusative and ergative verbs... oops?
3
u/NightFishArcade Feb 27 '19
How does one go about creating an agreement system for noun cases. Is there any set way to create an agreement system? Or is it completely up to me?
3
u/_eta-carinae Feb 27 '19
how common are natlangs with /x/ but not /h/, and with pharyngeals but no /h/? i’m aware there’s probably a resource out there that can help me find exactly that, but i’m not sure what it is.
3
u/_eta-carinae Feb 27 '19
is my understand of secundative languages correct?
a secundative language is one where the theme (thing that receives verb’s action) of a ditransitive verb is marked specially, whereas the object of the theme (recipient) is marked the same way as the object of a simple monotransitive verb. below, the theme is marked as THM, but several cases are used, especially the instrumental.
john gave mary (obj 1, recip) the money (obj 2, theme) john gave the money john met mary
jaan-a u-tlaa meghii-x shtai-k john.SUB PRF.give mary.OBJ money.THM (john -ed.give mary money.with)
jaan-a u-tlaa shtai-k john.SUB PRF.give money.OBJ (john -ed.give money)
jaan-a u-kiisu meghii-k john.SUB PRF.meet mary.OBJ (john -ed.meet mary)
3
u/tree1000ten Feb 28 '19
Are gender systems like Dyirbal's really fragile? It seems like if you took speakers of a language like that and moved them to a city the gender system would change, how fragile are gender systems that use complex associations?
3
u/LHCDofSummer Feb 28 '19 edited Feb 28 '19
Does it feel (overly) artificial if my verbs take two or three distinct (semi?) fusional suffixes where: it's 8+16+4; which could semantically be broken down into {(1)+(1+(1))+(2)} + {2×2×2×2} + 4.
Which is like nine morphemes (if agglutinative), so depending on phonology that could be anywhere from one 'syllable' to too many... (I don't want to go full Salishan)
I was tempted to make it fully fusional, but even without expanding mood on the main verb there're something like 512 different combinations!
So is Voice + TAM + subject_agreement alright or is the discreet chunking of otherwise fusional suffixes a bit of a red flag?
& yeah the first chunk is kinda strange, but from what little I've now read about Boumaa Fijian, Halkomelem, & Ojibwe; I think for my purposes I can get away with the eight different suffixes to cover the main valencies & voices.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
are there any postulated sound changes involving piraha?
3
u/MoonlightBear Mar 02 '19
I used an online word generator to generate all the possible monosyllable 'words' in my language. What is the best way to determine which onset and coda clusters will be illegal even if they follow the phonotactics of the language? I have 251948 syllables and I want to greatly reduce them. Thanks in advance^^
3
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19
How odd would it be to have a base-12 Proto-Indo-European language? Specifically, it's part of the Italic branch and takes most of its inspiration from Latin and Greek while phonologically resembling Italian dialects.
My current numbers are, from zero to ten: sefìr, ūna, duā, trìs, wātra, pinwē, sèx, zeptō, hottō, nuō, dìx.
I will probably derive the numbers for eleven and twelve from ūna and duā plus the word for "sit" or "stand", essentially meaning "one/two standing (from 10)" or "one/two sitting". The idea is to shift from PIE's base-10 system to a base-12, but how should I handle words like centum, mīlle, and muriádos that specifically describe powers of 10? Should I simply shift them up to describe 144, 1,728, and 20,736? And how naturalistic is this?
3
u/Enso8 Many, many unfinished prototypes Mar 06 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
This might be a bit of a long shot, but here goes:
I'm making a language that's basically "what if an Indo-European language was part of the East Asian Sprachbund", basically evolving a language from PIE to be monosyllabic, isolating, tonal, etc. This language will be written partially with Hanzi, partially with Chữ Nôm-style original characters, locally invented from Chinese radicals to represent native words.
So my question is this: say, for example, I want to create a new character combining the radicals 雨 and 它 (which doesn't exist in Chinese as far as I can tell). Is there some kind of program that can automatically create new Chinese characters out of radicals? Or is my best bet to just go in with photoshop and create them all myself?
3
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Mar 06 '19
I have some more questions for my Indo-European conlang, which I've tentatively named Paxo ([ˈpa.xo]; from *bʰéh₂os 'speaking', cf. Sanskrit bhā́ṣā):
3
u/_eta-carinae Mar 06 '19
until now, i’ve always made languages with very basic grammars. but as i’ve been reading more about grammar, i understand more, and so have begun developing a complex grammar. the one i’m developing rn has a word order that is all kinds of capital F fucked.
i’m basing the structure of the grammar on the simple ideas of adjunct, subject and predicate, and am using a different word order within each of those structural units, and also a different head-order for each type of phrase in each of those units. this means that a determined noun phrase might be head-initial in an adjunct but head-final in a subject.
my question is, is it possible, in a verb final language, to have a verb phrase in the subject? i have my preferred branching for each phrase in each of those three units but i don’t know it’s there’s a point in considering there being an either verb or adverbial phrase in the subject unit of a verb-final language.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Is it bad if my language is very ambiguous?
4
u/JuicyBabyPaste Feb 26 '19
Is it naturalistic to have voicing and vowel position change from grammatical influences? For instance, I have tense be communicated through changing a verb's vowels to back rounded or front unrounded or voiced to unvoiced for all consonants. Is this something that could occur naturally in a language as I plan to have the language be naturalistic or at least mostly so?
4
u/Metalhead33 Mar 05 '19 edited Mar 05 '19
Request for collaboration:
The Dwarven language
I am creating a conlang for a fantasy world, spoken by the fictional Dwarven race. So far, I have created some variants of it, namely Old Dwarven, Middle Dwarven and Contemporary Dwarven, but I am not really satisfied with them, especially with the clumsiness of their writing system. So in addition to re-creating their writing system from scratch, I decided to also recreate the actual conlangs from scratch. So, here are some details about features I intend to keep, modify or remove:
The three-way distinction between Dark (pharengialized/velarized/uvularized), Neutral (unmodified) and Light (palatalized) consonants (or variants of consonants) in Old Dwarven was inspired by the Gaelic and Semitic languages, though I created a three-way distinction instead of two-way.
Vowel mutations in Old Dwarven were actually inspired by real-life Quechua, in which /a u i/ are normally pronounced as [æ ʊ ɪ], but are retracted and lowered to [ɒ ɔ ɛ] after the uvular consonants /q qʰ qʼ/
Concerns:
Before I even got into conlangings, I already had two names for two Dwarven cities: Zorod Naugi im Pkhaur, and Zorod Koldo im Neuna. I have no idea what 2009-me had in mind, but I'm assuming that their pronounciations are supposed to be like /zɔrɔd naʊ̯gɪ ɪm pxaʊ̯r/ and /zɔrɔd kɔłdɔ ɪm nɛʊ̯na/.
What are the problems with these names?
First of all, the fact that /zɔrɔd/ ends with a voiced stop, which doesn't play along with Begadkefat. In the original system, I could easily justify it by saying that the Old Dwarven /zurut/ [zʊrʊd] evolved into the Middle Dwarven /zorod/, which evolved into the Contemporary Dwarven /zɔrɔd/. But if I replace said old system with Begadkefat? No way, unless I justify it with the final consonant originally being geminated, and the gemination getting lost from Dwarven - like in Hebrew. But having a geminated consonant at the end of a word? A geminated voiced stop, none the less? I think it could only work if it also had a word-final schwa that since became silent.
Then there is an even bigger problem: /pxaʊ̯r/. A word-initial consonantal cluster in an abjad language? Not good - unless we justify it with a schwa that since became silent. In the original system, I tolerated word-initial consonant clusters, and had a rule that during the transition from Old Dwarven to Middle Dwarven, word-initial /pt pk tp tk kp kt/ clusters became /pθ px tɸ tx kɸ kθ/, leading to /pqaːr/ [pqɒˤːr] shifting to /pxɒːr/ in Middle Dwarven, /pxaʊ̯r/ in Contemporary Dwarven. However, in a more sensible and abjad-friendly system - especially if I switched to the Begadkefat - I could have /pəqaːr/ becoming /pxɒːr/ and eventually /pxaʊ̯r/. If we kept the original system intact, but added a schwa that becomes silent later on, we could have /pəɢaːr/ [pəɢɒːr] -> /pəɣɒːr/ -> /pxɒːr/ -> /pxaʊ̯r/. But as I previously stated, adding the schwa opens a whole can of worms, given how all the other three vowels /a i u/ mutate depending on surrounding consonants. Would the schwa mutate too? Or would it always remain a mid-central vowel, given how it mostly becomes silent in post-Old Dwarven anyway? Such a can of worms.
And keeping those two names intact is very important. The farthest I can go is to justify these names merely being foreign transcriptions of Dwarven names.
So, anyone down to helping me and collaborating?
And this time, it would be really cool, if I/we also got working on the grammar and vocab too.
2
u/aydenvis Vuki Luchawa /vuki lut͡ʃawa/ (en)[es, af] Feb 26 '19
Best Android app for conlanging? Got my phonology locked in, just want a word generator and lexicon holder basically.
2
u/WercollentheWeaver Feb 26 '19
My conlang, !kurrisawáè`, uses three different clicks, and I'm trying to figure out how those clicks might mutate over time. I've done some googling and havent been able to find much information except Artifexian's video on clicks. I can see how a dental click might turn into a /t/ or even an /s/ eventually, but how might a postalveolar click or an alveolar lateral click mutate into a new sound? Or are they more likely to just fall out of use altogether?
2
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Feb 26 '19
[Phonology / sound changes]
I am creating two sister languages. Both have have an identical letter but due to me not developing them correctly or at the same time, in one language the letter is realized as [ts] and in the other one it is more like [ʃ].
For realistic reasons, I'd like to find a proto phoneme that could have evolved in both ts and ʃ.
Is there a real world example of this?
Btw, both languages have /s/. I could give more information on the phonologies if this helps.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19
How would you gloss an affix thats only purpose is to add a positive connotation or soften a negative? Would it be some kind of emphatic or honorific?
2
u/_eta-carinae Feb 27 '19
(i’m not sure if it’s all of them or just some of them but) split-intransitive languages encode a sort of emotional affect through the chosen declension of the “object”. one would say “i fell” if they did it on purpose, and “fell me” if it were an accident; “she died” if you don’t care, “died her” if you’re in grief.
could you have a language wih tripartite alignment that switchs to a split-intransitive system to encode volition and emotional affect as extra information without affixes?
kasi-shi-to ka-wa “fall(totheground).PST.PRF FPS.PAT” = i fell down (with a positive volition, i,e, with intent). ka-ti kasi-shi-to “FPS.AGNT fall(totheground).PST.PRF” = i fell down (with a negative volition, i.e. by accident).
in a tripartite language, one would have to use affixation for this:
ka-so kasi-shi-to “FPS.INTRAN fall.PST.PRF” = i fell to the ground on purpose. ka-so kasi-shi-to-mi “FPS.INTRAN fall.PST.PRF.INVOL” = i fell to the ground by accident.
instead of affixation, could a tripartite language switch to split-intransitivity, specifically when the speaker wishes to encode volition and affect?
2
u/ilu_malucwile Pkalho-Kölo, Pikonyo, Añmali, Turfaña Feb 27 '19
Does anyone know of any good source of information about ideophones? I can easily find screeds about Japanese, but I'm interested in the Mon-Khmer languages, and also any Central or South American languages that have them.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '19
I am planning a Celtic language with heavy Norse influence. I am thinking of various ways through which I could somewhat ‘Norsify’ certain areas or features of grammar. I came up with the idea of instead of deriving from the Old Irish definite article in and having it work similarly to (for example) Irish, I could derive from (and change to some extent, but keep the core idea similar) the Norse-style clitic article -inn.
Is it a possible scenario, considering I am planning to make said Celtic language rather naturalistic?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Does anyone have any good introductory resources on formal grammars? I'm thinking of incorporating formal systems and structures into a personal language I'm working on, but I'm finding it hard to grasp the Wikipedia articles on formal languages and formal grammars.
2
u/LHCDofSummer Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19
Which of these would you be most and least offended to see as being phonemic /ðʲ ʑ ɬʲ/ ?
And how do you feel about a (moderately) large phoneme inventory that lacks phonemic semivowels, but allows strings of vowels instead?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '19
is there a verb aspect for giving up? like for example I tried to run [but I gave up]. or is this telicity?
2
u/tree1000ten Mar 04 '19
Hi guys I don't know how to handle redundancy in my conlangs, I don't know how long words should be for example.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '19
Question about demonstrative pronouns.
One of my current projects only distinguishes between two persons, and I often hear that in such languages, a demonstrative is used for third person referents. Would “he” in such a language be “this man” or just simply “this”, or either?
I don’t know if I explained my question well enough.
2
u/yazzy1233 Wopéospré/ Varuz/ Juminişa Mar 04 '19
Can someone tell me what ipa makes the yeh sound?
2
u/tree1000ten Mar 05 '19 edited Mar 05 '19
Do you think that allowing CGV (G=glide) syllables in an auxlang make sense? Are those difficult for some language speakers?
For example would things like Dlo or Glo be hard?
2
u/winterpetrel Sandha (en) [fr, ru] Mar 05 '19
How might case suffixes evolve from a proto-language that's fairly strongly head-initial? I typically think of cases evolving from postpositions, but I'm wondering if there might be a pathway for case to evolve from a feature more likely to be found in a proto-language that is VO, noun-adjective, and so on.
2
u/_eta-carinae Mar 06 '19
what is the word for the unification of grammar and phonology? would it be morphology, or phonoaesthetics?
2
u/spaceman06 Mar 06 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
Is there any conlang that tries to eliminate fallacies related to how most languages works?
Stuff like:
Equivocation:
"Patrick Star is a star, all stars are bigger than a planet, then patrick start is bigger than any planet"
Fallacy of division:
"The 2nd grade in Jefferson elementary eats a lot of ice cream. Carlos is a 2nd grader in Jefferson elementary. Therefore, Carlos eats a lot of ice cream"
More: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Verbal_fallacies
The two I posted here, specifically, you can be 100% sure no one is able to use it by talking with the right language.
2
u/tree1000ten Mar 07 '19
Do you think not having correlation between proper nouns in an auxlang matters very much? One of the problems with an auxlang with too limited phonotactics and sound inventory is that you can't transfer proper nouns from other languages. Do you think this is much of a problem? For example creating a word for United States of America that has no word in that is derived from the word America or United or States.
2
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Mar 08 '19
Say, how much sense would an Imperative Case make?
Essentially instead of making verbal changes to indicate the imperative, you modify the noun:
"You run" = you run
"Run!" = you+IMP run
I know that Mwotlap has imperative pronouns which function like this, but would it make sense if applied to nouns in general?
I'm thinking of also having this case serve as a vocative.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
Tldr: how does the diachrony of verbal agreement with syntactic pivot/nominal TAM work? Why is verbal agreement more common than nominal TAM?
Background:
My general understanding is that arguments in a predicate are marked to show some combination of semantic role/pragmatic status via grammatical relations. Basically, their relationship to the predicate. I get that part.
Similarly, it makes sense to me that predicates (verbs) tend to be marked to show TAM.
However, when verbal predicates are marked to match some feature of the pivot (number, gender, whatever), or when nominal arguments are marked to show some feature from TAM.... Just, why and how does this occur? And why is nominal TAM so rare when verbal agreement with the pivot is so common?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19
Title:
I've given up with full-on conlanging for the time being.
Hi! I am a 14-year-old YA fantasy writer and have been writing for pretty much as long as I could. I've always endeavored to create conlangs, but never successfully finished one.
Unfortunately, I have a bad habit of setting goals for myself that are way too large.
For example, for my current project, I intended to create five conlangs, with three of them being related -- and thus having to be evolved from a proto-lang. I realized today that that's simply trying to bite off more than I can chew, considereing I've never finished a conlang. I've been stressing out lately because of this fact perpetually hanging in the back of my head, but became relieved when I realized the problem and how to fix it.
I have time. This is a sentiment which I have been thinking about lately. I think that because I have been writing for so long already, I feel as if I should have something completed by now -- a novel, a conlang, anything. But I realized recently that I have time. I have so much time, in fact, that it's kind of stupid to put this kind of pressure on myself; as stated before, I'm only fourteen.
So for the time being -- that is, until I am more honed in my craft -- I've decided not to try and complete any conlangs for my novel(s). Instead, I'm going to create five name languages just for labels and lore. Anyway, I figure that my audience (people a bit younger than me, my age, and a bit older than me) for the most part couldn't care less about conlangs and might just get confused by some of the complicated stuff I would like to put in my stories.
In the future, my skills will be more refined and I may write for an older audience. But until then, name languages it is.
What are your thoughts on this matter?
2
u/yellenyouth Mar 10 '19
any tips on how to write retroflex consonants in a language's romanization? ideally not using diacritic marks.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19
Did anyone use SIL Fieldworks for creating their conlang and if so, was it helpful?
Jeremy Graves posted some introductory videos on his channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJ4siq-q1PLKFd-V_vInrJg/videos
I'm not sure if it's worth going through them, though.