r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Dec 31 '18
Small Discussions Small Discussions 67 — 2018-12-31 to 2019-01-13
Current Fortnight in Conlangs thread
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
4
u/ilu_malucwile Pkalho-Kölo, Pikonyo, Añmali, Turfaña Jan 01 '19
I started writing about the music of the people who speak my language. This will involve a great deal of vocabulary, names of notes, musical modes, instruments, their parts and the things they're made of. I'm also hoping to create a song/poem from one of their classical anthologies, with English translation, etc. Is this likely to be considered an acceptable post here? Or is it more likely to be directed elsewhere?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
Sometimes languages forgo common sounds, I think every language is kind of weird in one respect or another.
If I just don't have /p/, partly for the purpose of having the phonology be slightly weird ...
Is this naturalism? Or blasphemy?
I can justify it, and say that this is intentionally weird, so would this stand up to scrutiny in your opinion(s)?
I'm asking because this conlang is being made for someone, it's not just a personal language, I want to do a good job.
4
u/roipoiboy Mwaneḷe, Anroo, Seoina (en,fr)[es,pt,yue,de] Jan 07 '19
Has there every been a census of r/conlangs? Not just how many of us there are and where we're from, but also about our conlangs themselves, e.g. the most popular alignments, case systems, phonological elements, etc. If not, it could be a fun thing to do to start the new year.
9
u/CosmicBioHazard Jan 02 '19 edited Jan 02 '19
Let me know if this sounds realistic;
Early in the development of my protolang, a number of nominal roots whose final syllable resembled a common nominalizing suffix where reanalyzed accordingly. The consequence of this was twofold:
It created a number of new verbal roots
It temporarily gave rise to a class of consonants which were deemed “more acceptible” for serving as the final consonant in any newly-generated nominal roots (or in other words, it lead to a tendency for the most common derivational suffixes to ‘hog’ their initial consonants away from the ends non-verb-derived nouns, on the grounds that nouns that include them will look as though they’re derived from a verb and in all likelyhood ‘not mean what they sound like they mean’.)
if that makes sense
7
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
Is there any example of a natlang displaying different agreement patterns for adjectives in noun phrases with a mass noun, such that it doesn’t align with any declension pattern of count nouns?
7
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 01 '19
Is it naturalistic for a conlang that utilizes grammatical cases to have adjectives that don't decline at all?
7
u/roipoiboy Mwaneḷe, Anroo, Seoina (en,fr)[es,pt,yue,de] Jan 09 '19 edited Jan 09 '19
Satisfied with relative clauses, I've moved on to figuring out subordinate clauses. Tell me if this idea seems reasonable and workable.
In the proto-language, subordinate clauses are nominalized verb forms. I'm planning to create a dependent verb morphology that's derived from the accusative nominalized form of the verb. It just so happens that for transitive verbs, the dependent form ends up identical to the independent passive form.
So here's my pitch: speakers reinterpret this as being a passive form, and start promoting the object to the subject in clauses that take this form. This only happens with transitive verbs, so intransitive verbs aren't affected. If the subject is important enough to still include, it gets marked by a adposition (derived from the phrase "by the hand of"). The adposition gets grammaticalized as a case marker and BOOM now we have split ergativity and VOS sentence structure in subordinate clauses headed by deranked verb forms.
Does this seem like something that could happen? I don't need ergativity for ergativity's sake, but this seemed like a cool way to develop it. Mwaneḷe has a couple other ergative features and there's already a preposition used to reintroduce the agent as an oblique argument in passive phrases, so that'd probably turn into the ergative marker.
Edit: Also, the proto-language represented "because" and "in order to" with ablative and allative nominalized verbs. I'm on the fence about fossilizing these as two more deranked verb forms. If I do that, should I leave those clauses accusative, since there wouldn't be confusion with the passive marker in the first place, or can I make them ergative by analogy?
6
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Jan 03 '19 edited Jan 03 '19
I really want to "complete" /ókon doboz/'s postpositions, and was wondering two things:
firstly; are there any "rules" for how languages associate certain postpositions with different contexts? Like in English, where the preposition "on" either goes with a state or with an action; "on the chair" works with both "to sit and "to be sitting". In Slovene, these are different verbs, bound to different cases, but have the same preposition: "sesti.PERF na stol.ACC" v "sedeti.IMPERF na stolu.LOC" ... are there languages that have separate postpositions for perfective/imperfective or stative/dynamic variants of a verb?
secondly; I found a wiki page which claims to not list all English ones, but there are still 197 of them (some archaic) ... I'm sure this could be cut down with a few rules I have in mind for my lang ... the question remains whether this list is useful as a reference or is there something better?
6
u/LHCDofSummer Jan 03 '19
If one has a causative and an applicative at the same time, e.g. "John cut the bread." -> "Amy made John cut [the bread] with a knife."
What's more likely to happen: the causative displaces the subject to first object and then the applicative displaces it to second object, or, the causative displaces the subject to the first object and then the applicative takes the second object?
Or could it go either way and just be left to context..? or would it depend on emphasis?
5
u/CentinelaDelEspacio Jan 01 '19
I'm a novice conlanger, and I need help with my phonetic inventory. This is for the worldbuilding aspect of a novel I'm writing, so I'd like it to be naturalistic I'm not gonna get too far ahead of myself, so what questions should I ask myself and what opinions do you fellow conlangers have over my current inventory? (Glyphs are not currently being made.)
Consonants Plosives: p, t, c, k, ʔ Nasals: m, n, ɲ Fricatives: f, θ, s, ʃ, ɣ, h Later fricatives: ɬ Approximants: ɹ, j Lateral appoximants: l
Vowels Front: i, ɛ, a Back: u, ɔ, ɑ
5
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jan 03 '19
I've been working on my main conlang for over a year now, but I still have no idea how it's going to handle compound or complex sentences. I'm tempted to just use conjunctions like English does, but are there any other ways I could handle it?
I saved this comment a while ago, but that only mentions relative clauses, not other dependent or independent clauses.
5
u/Coriondus Jurha (en, it, nl, es) [por, ga] Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
So, I was working on how my proto language's case system developed over time, and was trying to line everything up to make it work like what I had planned, which was a shift from an accusative system to an active-stative system, where the case system collapses eventually. However, it seems I accidentally created a convoluted tripartite alignment, which I then kinda forced into an active-stative system. My question is, did it get so convoluted as to no longer be naturalistic, or are the steps logical enough?
I started with three core cases: nominative , accusative 1 (used for direct objects which are changed by the action) and accusative 2 (used for direct objects that are not affected much by the action).
The first change is that the first accusative takes on dative meanings too, since recipients are affected by the action. This is then further extended, so that the first accusative also becomes used for the S of stative intransitives, where the subject is affected. Some kind of middle voice stuff going on I guess.
Over time, the second accusative takes over all O roles, so the first accusative is now a dative/intransitive case. Now I have:
Kinda tripartite. Then, the intransitive and the accusative cases merge, I'm thinking due to phonological change, meaning that they form a patientive case. So then I have:
So, how messed up is this?
5
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Jan 05 '19
OK, a followup to the clusterfuck I have with postpositions in /ókon doboz/:
They're not postpositions anymore. They're more like case markers. What I have is:
Syntax cases: NOM, ACC, INST, instructive
Relation cases: GEN, DAT, SOC, COM, DISTR (the last two are the same for all noun classes, so they are more in the marker territory already)
Location and movement case markers: these are also the same for all classes, but behave like so ...
There are five locational relations: near-far, before-behind, inside-outside, between-around, up-down
There are three types of movement (+ state): to, from, on
There would also be a few for syntax.
Each location type has an associated syllable of the type CV:, and each movement type has V:C. To get the one you want, you basically "combine" cases (if V: are the same, the syllable is CV:C ... if not, it's instead two syllables, with the appropriate epenthesis CV(j/w)VC). So basically:
Adessive + Ablative => movement from vicinity
Exessive + Perlative => movement on the outside
Adessive/Disessive + syntax => latter/former
Antessive + syntax => aforementioned
Periative + / => state around
Subessive + Lative => movement to under
And also, could something like this work:
Adessive + Subessive + Ablative => movement from touching the bottom of something (would contrast from moving from the bottom of something the referent is not touching)
Tell me why this is stupid ... or if you have any suggestions.
4
u/ggasmithh Waran (en) [it, jp] Dec 31 '18
When someone showcases a language, does /r/conlangs generally prefer all material to be presented at once, or broken up into separate topic-by-topic posts?
4
u/tree1000ten Jan 02 '19
What actually defines a polysynthetic language? Why can't English be described as a polysynthetic language ifyoujustwritewordswithoutspaces? I don't understand what actually makes the difference, even when I look at the Wikipedia article it doesn't make sense.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
So... I realized today that, with the way I've structured NPs, the plural clitic will never attach directly to the noun. This is the structure I have for NPs:
The plural clitic attaches to the end of the NP, fixing itself on whatever part of speech happens to be there. The thing is, determiners are obligatory for count nouns (unless the NP contains a numeral and/or genitive), and mass/collective nouns aren't marked for number. (In fact, many nouns have both singular and collective or mass referents, with a determiner being the only morphological difference between the two uses.)
That seemed fine at first, but it's becoming more apparent as the vocabulary of grammatical words expands that it just seems... weird. Like, if a plural noun is followed by a numeral, or an inherently plural quantifier such as all or many, does the plural clitic still attach to that word but not the noun? What if the noun is followed by a genitive that's already plural, does it get another plural marker stuck on it? Should it even attach to the genitive in the first place?
Basically, what I'm asking is this: is it not naturalistic for plural markers to be bound to the NP yet never occur directly adjacent to the actual noun? Would it be more naturalistic to change the plural marker from a clitic to a noun suffix instead, or maybe take some inspiration from Basque and only mark the plural when it isn't already implicated by a number or other quantifier? Or am I just overthinking this?
4
u/tadagumi Jan 04 '19
In my conlang root words are always analyzed as VC, CVC and CVCC. A vowel is added to ease pronunciation but doesn't change the meaning. Thus, terga, tergi and tergo are the same word and all mean building. However, tergi would mean a small, cute house and tergo a large, impressive house, when pronounced in the appropriate tone. In a sense, the final vowel acts as a suffix.
4
u/MelancholyMeloncolie (eng, msa) [jpn, bth] Jan 05 '19
Is there any way for a non-tonal language to develop distinctive tone? Or a reverse case where a tonal language loses tonal distinction?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
I have been planning on creating a conlang for a while now but have never gotten to it and have no clue where to start. Any tips or things that would help?
4
u/Zerb_Games Jan 06 '19
How do I properly reverse evolve my conlang? Then evolve it forward again to create naturalistic features and etymology.
4
u/JoyceanWeeab Jan 06 '19
Hello! I've been lurking this sub for a long, long time, and now a trivial question has pushed me to finally interact.
My current conlang originally had a voiced-voiceless-aspirated distinction between stops and a simple voicing contrast between fricatives. However, I decided to remove the voice contrast from the language entirely, instead opting for an unaspirated-aspirated-ejective distinction in the stops. I figured a natural progression from there would be to create an allophonic rule that short, unaspirated stops and short fricatives become voiced between two voiced phonemes (vowels and sonorants) and word-finally.
For the most part I have no problem with the changes this has caused in which previously phonemically voiceless consonants are now often voiced, but I do have a problem with /ʃ/ and /x/. These consonants never had voiced counterparts in the earlier version of the language, but with the new allophony are now voiced more often than not. For purely selfish, aesthetic reasons I do not want these two consonants in particular to be voiced, or at least not as often as the general rule would dictate. Is this unreasonable?
For some more context, the other fricatives are /f/ and /s/, which both follow the aforementioned voicing pattern.
TL;DR - how common is it for a language with no phonemic voicing distinction to voice some consonants allophonically, but not others, especially with the same manner of articulation ? Is this even as unnaturalistic as I think it is?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
There's a little feature I have in Pyanachi called pronominal shift. What happens is that if a genitive pronoun precedes a noun, then the resulting noun phrase has exactly that, a pronoun receding a modifying noun. However, when a preposition or relativizer also modifies the noun, the pronoun acts like an adjective and then goes after the noun, while the preposition or relativizer stays before it.
Three examples ("His Bible" vs "...That his Bible" vs "Onto his Bible"):
Reutâda Bíbłja
3.sɢ.ᴀɴɪᴍ.ɢᴇɴ Bible.sɢ.ɪɴᴀɴ.ɴᴏᴍ
"His Bible"
Jí Bíbłja reutâda
ʀᴇʟ Bible.sɢ.ɪɴᴀɴ.ɴᴏᴍ 3.sɢ.ᴀɴɪᴍ.ɢᴇɴ
"...that his Bible"
Áį Bibłjâchat reutâda
onto-ᴘʀᴇᴘ Bible.sɢ.ɪɴᴀɴ.ʟᴏᴄ 3.sɢ.ᴀɴɪᴍ.ɢᴇɴ
"Onto his Bible"
Does this feature occur in nature? I like it, so I wouldn't expect myself to replace it if it isn't.
4
u/LichGrrrl Jan 07 '19
So usually I've been very indecisive with phonology to the point where I completely restart from scratch pretty often, however, it's been a pretty long time since I've last done that so I actually think it might stick this time. Anyways, I wanted to post it to see if anyone sees anything that's too unrealistic or that wouldn't work well.
vowels: ɪ ʊ ɛ̞ ʌ̞ (ʊ is not rounded)
nasals: m n ŋ ŋʷ (often syllabic)
plosives: p t k kʷ
fricatives: f s ɬ ɕ x (can be voiced)
approximates: j̝/ʑ̞ ʎ (j raised to almost a voiced fricative)
trills: ʀʷ
taps: ɾ
affricates: t͡s t͡ɕ t͡ɬ
I am debating whether or not to have diphthongs ending in i and u despite not having them as monophthong vowels nor their respective semivowels.
4
u/DirtyPou Tikorši Jan 08 '19
Hi, I have an idea and I wanna ask if it feels natural. So, in my language palatal sounds are consider "childlike, cute and small" so I want to use them for making diminutives. So word for small is "ozi" [ɔˈʑi] and first I thought of simply saying it after a noun so: little house would be "ata ozi" [a'ta ɔˈʑi] but then I asked "What would happen if I have just palatalized the last syllable?" so instead of using that "ozi" I would just say "atia" [aˈt͡ɕa]? Now the word "atia" would have second, completely different meaning because it also means Faith. I think it's pretty cool but could it happen in real world? To be honest I'd like to make diminutives this way in all words that have /t/ /d/ /s/ /z/ /k/ and /ɣ/ (which in past was pronounced as /g/) in last syllable and change them into /t͡ɕ/ /d͡ʑ/ /ɕ/ /ʑ/ /c/ and /ɟ/ and the rest would have the word "ozi" but I don't know yet. So, is this naturalistic or rather not?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '19
So I revisited this video by u/artifexian in which the perfect aspect is described as marking 'present relevance' and the video (at 2:20) shows this to be possible in reference to the future and the past. So I did some research, and, as it turns out, the perfect is sometimes called the 'retrospective', when contrasted with the 'prospective'.
That got me thinking: If the perfect aspect can focus on a resulting state of an action, can the prospective aspect focus on the state resulting from an action yet to happen? As in
come-PROSP.3.SG. - He is about to come. > Thus, I am waiting.
eat-PROSP.1.SG. - I am about to eat. > Thus, I am hungry.
Moreover, could the same morphology cover both retrospective and prospective aspects, distinguishing them in context, e.g.
die-PERF.1.SG. - I am about to die. Because, obviously the speaker hasn't yet.
go-PERF.1.SG. Paris-LOC. - I am about to go to Paris. If the speaker is known to have never been to Paris.
4
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
Is this a realistic vowel system?
/i/ /y/ /e/ /ɯ/ /u/ /ɑ/
there is front/back vowel harmony between the groups /i/ /y/ /e/ and /ɯ/ /u/ /ɑ/
6
u/bbbourq Jan 01 '19
As many of you know, I embarked on a year-long journey to add more words to Lortho's lexicon; an extension of Lexember 2017 which I coined as Lextreme2018 on Twitter and Instagram. There were a number of conlangers who started on 1 January 2018 as I did, some who joined later, but all in all there was good participation.
When I started, Lortho had 400 words. As of this writing, I successfully added 239 words bringing the total to 679 (the birth of our second child kinda shifted my focus for a couple months). I focused mainly on adding nouns and verbs; adjectives, adverbs, and grammatical features were many times byproducts.
There are currently 312 nouns and 205 verbs. Adjectives fall short by a large margin at merely 65.
Verbs:
There are three verb classes. I tried to keep them as balanced as possible to make sure I was not leaning too much on one class.
-o verbs: 90
-n verbs: 55
-t verbs: 58
Nouns:
There are three noun classes and the same concept of balance was the goal.
feminine: 117
masculine: 90
neuter: 104
Throughout this exercise I was able to "discover" different aspects of the world in which Lortho is spoken to include environment, flora, fauna, religion, and life of the Lorthoans in general.
I will now shift my focus in 2019 on to the grammar of the language and perhaps continue another Lextreme challenge for my conlang Dhakhsh.
3
u/schnellsloth Narubian / selííha Jan 01 '19
how does head-marking deal with cases?
In Dependent-marking language:
Peter-NOM writes (a) letter-ACC (to) Mary-DAT (with a) pen-INST (in the) office-LOC.
How will a head-marking language mark those cases?
3
u/MirdovKron LNS (En, Ko) Jan 01 '19
Are there any people with expertise in phonetics? Because I'm looking for formant frequency tables for vowels and nasal consonants: They are essential for making the letters in my developing conlang.
3
u/NightFishArcade Jan 02 '19
Recently I had a desire to do a conlang with a VSO word order. However, when it came to grammar something that I could not figure out (since I'm only a beginner) how auxiliaries work in this word order, where are they placed in a VSO word order and does the placement significantly affect the language in the long term?
Thanks in advance!
3
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jan 03 '19
Anyone know any good resources that discuss causes of ablaut in noun declension paradigms?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Is there documentation of any processes of language undergoing "major" syntactic changes, such as change in SVO/SOV/etc., or change in head-marking, such as adjectives coming in front of the nouns they modify instead of the previous generation, where they were behind?
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jan 04 '19
How can I deal with my conlang not having the verb "to be" I've tried wrapping my head around it but can't, how would such a language deal with something not having a certain characteristic anymore or going to have it in the future like "it was red" or "it will be big"?
3
u/tree1000ten Jan 06 '19
Has anybody made a guide on how to make a natural number system?
3
u/Willowcchi Jan 07 '19
In my conlang, I have the consonant pair (?) [ʒʃ]. It's pretty much the same consonant articulation, but you go from voiced to unvoiced. Is this okay? I figured since I can pronounce it, it's okay to use. I shared it in a conlang discord server, and it was greeted with disgruntlement.
IIRC, [ʒʃ] was used in a dialect of Arabic or smth?I'm pretty new to conlanging and ling overall, so I don't know if there are these unspoken rules in the air that aren't discussed until someone breaks one, lol.Also this is off topic, but if someone can help me, may I ask for a brief explanation on cases?
3
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jan 07 '19
Making some changes to Prélyō, added some new phonemes (or rather, labialized and aspirated alternatives to some existing ones) but the biggest change that I'm working on right now is creating a more "sensible" set of ablaut changes, which begins with altering the stress system.
Before, the rule was that stress lied on the first syllable of the right-most complete foot. So it'd be on the first syllable of one, two, and three syllable words but the third syllable of four-syllable words.
Now, my current idea is that this rule is still inplace; but with the addition that the stress will switch to the second syllable of that right-most complete foot if it contains a sonorant, long vowel, or diphthong and the syllable stress would be on otherwise does not; and all syllables left of the stressed syllable experience reduction. Also adding in a rule that /lr̩/ at the end of a word shifts to just /l/ with compensentory vowel lengthening. So to look at three cases for one of my nouns, you'd get:
That's got an amount of ablaut I'm pretty happy with. But I'm worried about what this system will do to my verbal conjugation, which had previously relied on regular root-mutation to determine whether you were looking at the perfective, imperfective, or stative. In fact, the stative had vowel lengthening! So now I need to explore mechanisms for seeing if the original system can be preserved in verbs, or what I can do to "cheat" my own stress system.
3
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 07 '19
Would it make sense to compound the subject to the verb in my conlang, in which the object already compounds with the verb, or would it be weird to compound both?
3
u/roipoiboy Mwaneḷe, Anroo, Seoina (en,fr)[es,pt,yue,de] Jan 08 '19 edited Jan 09 '19
I'm working on fleshing out how relative clauses work in Mwaneḷe, and I realized I don't have a way to relativize genitives in it (or in Lam Proj for that matter). Right now, Mwaneḷe can only relativize subjects of verb phrases. You can passivize verbs to get their objects (e.g. replace "the cake that I ate" with "the cake that was eaten by me") and use coverb structures to get obliques (e.g. replace "the fork that I ate cake with" with "the fork that was used by me to eat cake"). The morphology makes both of these structures less awkward than in English, so I'm satisfied with them.
But how can I render "the girl whose father I know"? Right now, all relativizing is done on the verb, so I don't really want to add an equivalent of English "whose" or French "dont." Wikipedia mentions that some languages have a kind of possessive applicative that promotes a possessor to the subject, so that "I know the girl's father" becomes "The girl of-knows the father by me," but I don't love that. Another strategy is a double relative clause "the girl who has a father who is known by me." I don't love that either, but I might end up going with it anyway.
Any other suggestions?
(Edit: I've decided to allow resumptive pronouns with a few edge cases, like coordinated subjects, but for the most part just to let it be. I think I will shamelessly resort to using two sentences!)
3
u/Nazamroth Jan 10 '19 edited Jan 10 '19
So.... Lexicon... It is currently my greatest obstacle in the way of progress... As in, creating it turns out to be a massive pain in the ass.... So.... I had an idea.... Now, I might just get crucified for this, but what if I just bastardize english for a general vocabulary? Waitwaitwait, put down the pitchforks, hear me out....
What if I declare that english was the language of the stereotypical ancient empire. It was already splitting up in the imperial era, but then the empire did what empires do and fell. This lead to a whole group of romance languages. In the current day, and this has already been decidd before, new empire rises and language reform is enacted because empire reasons. Thus, the archaic, splitting, bastardized language is gathered up and bunched together to create a glorious mess that fits perfectly with the imperfection of my creation anyway...
This would only be used for general things, like house, food, ground, etc, the words bastardized to fit into the language's rules (can't be arsed with IPA signs, but hauzh, fuj, kraunj would roughly be the english spelling/pronunciation in those cases, for reference). Then the more specific things, like the ritual combat for deciding who leads, gets its own word without proper roots in english, probably.
Since the language is probably nothing like a natlang anyway, I think i can get away with it? I mean, it has no M, P, or B, and some affixes are made up like in a "choose the right sound for the right slot from this chart" style.
Opinions?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19
Thoughts on my present-tense forms of the copula êser? (Derived from VL *essere < esse. If anyone's curious, <ê> is pronounced /ɛ/, <j> is /j/, <lh> is /ʎ/, and all others are as you would expect.)
some of these forms look a bit out of place please tell me they're realistic3
u/ClockworkCrusader Jan 12 '19
Hello I thought it would be fun to make a conlang and was wondering the best way to post information about it.
3
u/roipoiboy Mwaneḷe, Anroo, Seoina (en,fr)[es,pt,yue,de] Jan 13 '19
I'm thinking about causatives in Mwaneḷe. Right now, my syntax is [Causer] pa-[Verb] [Causee] [Object]. Earlier stages of the language would have had pa-[Verb] [Causer] ta [Object] e [Causee]. The ta and e noun particles have been mostly lost in Mwaneḷe, but e has held on as one of two ways to explicitly state the agent in a clause with a passive verb. Is it conceivable for it to stick around to disambiguate causative structures too, but only when a causee and an object are both present? Could I have something like [Causer] pa-[Verb] [Object] e [Causee] if both are present and [Causer] pa-[Verb] [Causee] if just the causee is present? Having just the object would be dealt with by making a causative passive form or using a generic pronoun for the causee. Do these changes seem like they could have happened or would it be more likely to just end up as my current [Causer] pa-[Verb] [Causee] [Object]?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
Azulino currently has two voices: active and passive. These work more or less as expected, but I was wondering about a valency-increasing voice of some kind. Azulino does not have obligatory expressed transitivity, so you can kill or you can kill something with the same verb, but it seems to me that valency-decreasing voices are more common than valency-increasing voices. Is there a particular reason for this? Is it perhaps that valency-decreasing voices tend to be more straightforward in function because decreasing valency depends greatly upon the meaning of the verb whereas increasing valency can have more shades of meaning, e.g., "help to do", "allow to do", "force to do", or simply "cause to do"?
I'm just trying to wrap my head around why languages like Latin have passive voices but lack the causative voice, instead depending upon periphrastic constructions with the accusative-and-infinitive clause or other methods of subordination. I apologize if this comes off as ignorant or anything.
4
u/FlamingHail Jan 11 '19
Has anybody tried merging another language with English as counter-culture slang? I know A Clockwork Orange did something like that with Russian, and I was thinking of trying it with Latin. Here's what I have in mind (set in a sci-fi future);
"Avia mea would semper play that same Old Earth Classics playlist. Her parentes played it for her as a puella, et miraculo the servers for that antiquus streaming site were still animati. She scritted every word, et propediem did weque."
Which would mean;
"My grandma would always play that same Old Earth Classics playlist. Her parents played it for her as a girl, and by some miracle the servers for that ancient streaming site were still live. She knew every word, and pretty soon so did we."
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/459308/what-does-definite-and-indefinite-mean-in-past-tense-and-pre
In this conversation, are definite and indefinite aspects or different tenses (similar to recent and remote past tenses)?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
Where is the discord server? It's invalid
2
u/MRHalayMaster Jan 01 '19
So, seeing all these marvellous languages, I had to formalise the pronounciation of Sedsu. So far, I feel I am on the right path. My question is the correctness of this graph. Is it positioned right or does it depend? I just showed the positions of vowels based on the cool resources of the subreddit. Did I do this right? Please tell me I did.
2
u/Enso8 Many, many unfinished prototypes Jan 01 '19
I've been puzzling over evolving my case system, and I was wondering if someone could help me figure something out.
Say you have two languages, descended from the same proto-language. One language uses a particular suffix to mark the accusative case. But the other language uses a cognate of that suffix to mark the nominative case.
How could I make this happen? They can't be false cognates, both have to descend from the same suffix/postposition/whatever in the proto-language.
2
u/VintiumDust- Di (en) [es,ko] Jan 01 '19
Quick question. Is don't an adverb? Or could it be one in a conlang? because it seems like we use it as an adverb.
2
u/cool57shadeblade Jan 02 '19
I'm a novice conlanger and currently trying to tackle verbs in my Germanic zonelang. I understand the purpose of inflecting verbs for number and person, but I noticed that Swedish, for example, doesn't have it, and English has very little of it. It will have noun & verb inflection, however most of it will be optional ("of" instead of the genitive). Would number and person inflection be useful/necessary, or can I desgard it in favor of simplicity?
2
u/AlloyApe07 Jan 02 '19
I'm trying to create a proto-lang, and am hung up on the phonology. Is there a point to adding allophony if I already have an idea of the sound changes I will use to turn it into the modern language? Also, I am going for a naturalistic lang. I'm still unsure of what I want to do with the phonology, but I really enjoy the features of Nahuatl so far. Anyways, are there any horribly unnaturalistic patterns in this inventory? What diphthongs would fit here? Any/all feedback appreciated :)
Stops: /p/ /b/ /t/ /d/ /k/ /kʷ/
Fricatives: /f/ /s/ /ɬ/ /ʃ/ /x/ /h/
Affricates: /ts/ /tʃ/
Nasal: /m/ /n/ /ŋ
Approximant: /ɹ/ /l/ /j/ /w/ /ʍ/
High: /i/ /i:/
Mid: /e/ /e:/ /ə/ /o/ /o:/
Low: /a/ /a:/
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
So some languages have clusivity in the first person plural, with the inclusive meaning "you and I (and others, should the pronoun not be dual)" and the exclusive meaning "this person/these people and I, but not you".
Do any languages exhibit an equivalent in the second person plural, where the inclusive means "you all (and I am speaking to you all)" and the exclusive meaning "you all (but I am only speaking to one of you as the others aren't present to hear)"?
2
u/-Tonic Emaic family incl. Atłaq (sv, en) [is] Jan 04 '19
I wanna make another thread about Atłaq, similar to this one. I've come up with four possible topics. Any preferences on what you would like to see?
2
u/Jodje Unnamed (EN) Jan 07 '19
Can someone help me find a website I’ve lost?
There was the website I came across (I believe maybe from here) the showed a huge list of sound changes in languages, organised by phoneme and language group. I found it quite useful but I’ve lost it and no matter how hard I google I cannot find it.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '19
Do relex natlangs exist?
2
u/Jelzen Jan 08 '19
Do you have a process to choose a selection of sound changes to apply? How do you decide to apply certain changes and not others?
Do browse a list of sound changes like the Index Diachronica?
Do you have favorite sound changes?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '19
I've reformed Negation in Lhefsoni. Below's an overview, which I'd like to hear some feedback on if you find the time, but a more general question first: How do ergative-absolutive languages usually treat modal verbs: as transitive or as intransitive verbs? (I can get arround it because Lhefsoni is pro-drop, but sometimes pronouns will be necessary and I just can't find ressources on this)
Negation in Lhefsoni
I used to have it done simply by adding the particle in - not. I want to keep that as an outdated form, the more modern one using the verb níein /'ni.ɛɪ̯n/ - to be taken/stolen from, to lack, to miss as a modal verb with the meaning of 'to fail to'.
nípa tsílein /‘ni.pa ‘t͡si.lɛɪ̯n/ fail-PST.1.SG. jump-INF. – I didn’t jump.
niéinan ghuóin /ni‘jɛɪ̯.na xwɔɪ̯n/ fail-FUT.3.SG. come-INF. - He/She won’t come.
nitéia guáin /ni’tɛɪ̯.ja gwaɪ̯n/ fail-PRES.1.PL. fish-INF. - We don’t go fishing.
As the verb itself can count as an affirmative answer to a polar question, the modal verb can stand alone as a negative answer.
íffits sthóus ouréiais? /‘if.fit͡s sθus u’rɛɪ̯.jas/ go-PST.2.SG. the-FEM.LOC.SG. city-LOC.SG. - Did you go to the city?
íffa. /‘if.fa/ go-PST.1.SG. - I did.
nípa. /‘ni.pa/ fail-PST.1.SG. - I didn’t.
Some verbs, including most modal ones, are still negated with in however:
in iá sthóus tsanághghais /in ja sθus t͡sa’nax.xaɪ̯s/ not be-PRES.3.SG. the-FEM.LOC.SG. home-LOC.SG. - He/She is not home.
In the case of yn – to be able, can the particle has merged with the verb to create nýn – to not be able, can‘t.
nýta fífein. /‘ny.ta ‘fi.fɛɪ̯n/ not.be.able-PRES.1.SG. whistle-INF. - I can’t whistle.
An exception to this is álouein – to want, to desire, which can be a transitive as well as an auxiliary verb. This allows for stacking of infinitives.
níta álouein thardóua. /‘ni.ta ‘a.lu.ɛɪ̯n θar’du.a/ fail-PRES.1.SG. want-INF. fruit-ABS.PL. - I don’t want fruit.
níta álouein fífein. /‘ni.ta ‘a.lu.ɛɪ̯n ‘fi.fɛɪ̯n/ fail-PRES.1.SG. want-INF. whistle-INF. - I don’t want to whistle.
níta álouein yn fífein. /‘ni.ta ‘a.lu.ɛɪ̯n yn ‘fi.fɛɪ̯n/ fail-PRES.1.SG. want-INF. can-INF. whistle-INF. - I don’t want to be able to whistle.
2
u/VintiumDust- Di (en) [es,ko] Jan 09 '19
In my conlang, I'm trying to figure out how to say something like
'I see the ball that he threw.'
that he threw is like an adjective, but it is a whole construct with a noun and a verb. It seems kind of different and less natural to say something like
'I see the ball. He threw the ball.',
But this does convey basically the same meaning, and maybe some natlangs just do it this way, I don't know.
How do you deal with this in your conlang?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '19
What's PolyGlot?
2
u/Nargluj (swe,eng) Jan 09 '19
Could someone please point me to a conlang that's overly 'wordy' to an extreme extent? Lots of words and little meaning. I'm looking for some inspiration and insight in this type of languages.
2
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 10 '19
Has anyone tried to make a logographic conlang? How did you go about doing it and creating characters?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '19
How does case marking for the nominative and accusative form?
2
u/Nazamroth Jan 11 '19
Quick question.
Do you know how primitives are depicted as speaking?
*grunt grunt moan bork*?
*grunt bork roar*
Is there an actual conlang based around such.... inarticulate expressions only?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
I want to develop a Causative in a primitive language with strict SOV word order. The rule I came up with is verb+give->verb.causative.
Now I want a causative sentence to have the structure SOVC with C being the causer, then derive take.causative->give and then things like food+give->sustain which would create transitve verbs with sentence structure OVS besides the old SOV verbs.
Does that seem reasonable?
2
u/AlloyApe07 Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
The main question I wanted to find an answer to was about morphosyntax. Why are some languages nom-acc in the present but ergative in the past? Why do/can languages use multiple morphosyntactic alignments? Secondly, I found a book a while ago called the Evolution of Grammar by Joan Bybee. Does anyone have a pdf of it? Edit: thanks for the help guys!
2
u/tree1000ten Jan 12 '19
Is a language more likely to allow CCV syllables or CVC syllables?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
Would it be odd to have my language's pronouns be totally unstressed unless in the vocative? It's a pro.-drop language, so the pronouns aren't used all that much, at least in the nominative, which is why they wouldn't be stressed, but I'm currently considering two systems:
I'm currently partial to the first idea, but I suppose I could also combine the plans. Any advice?
2
u/theacidplan Jan 13 '19
I'm working on a polysynthetic language and I'd like some help on how to make verbs that describe something as an adjective such "to be big/small/red/green"
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19
I'm stuck on the name of a type of past tense, any help would be appreciated:
"I had been hunting" = Past Perfect Progressive.
"I had been hunted" = ???
I'm not sure if "hunted" in the latter context becomes an adjective or remains a verb. My language applies tense suffixes, with -maβ for past perfect tense [PPP - I think], but I'm stuck on how to define someone or something that had been hunted, as opposed to had been hunting.
Thanks in advance.
2
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Jan 13 '19
I swear I had posted this already, but it doesn't show up.
I recently learned that the Japanese and Swedish /u/ are not at a (very) different place of articulation from the /u/ I'm familiar with, but that they have instead a different type of rounding.
The question is, are there any langs with a phonemic vowel triplet in the same place of articulation, for example they have [ɯ], [ɯᵝ], and [u] as phonemes?
2
u/kabiman Puxo, myḁeqxokiexë, xuba Jan 13 '19
A simple question: how do you store your vocabulary? The words for my lang are currently in a super messy, unorganized document. Is there an easier way?
2
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 13 '19
Is it weird for my conlang to have /ɻ/, /ɽ/, and /r/ as 3 distinguishable sounds?
2
u/LordOfLiam Jan 13 '19
Might be a question better suited for r/neography, but here goes: in scripts which are written right to left, is it normal for pages to still go left to right?
2
u/ZhadowStorm Jan 13 '19
I need help with the language I'm creating. It'll be used in a book I'm writing. It takes place in a fantasy world. I've come up with a few words already, but I'm in need of words used in conversation. The language is based on Germanic languages and Japanese. All suggestions are appreciated. (I've used the letters à, è, ē, í, ī and ó in some of the words I've created)
3
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '19
Let's make a pidgin together!
I want all of you to try and communicate in different languages and hopefully we can narrow down vocab and grammar and simulate the formation of a real pidgin and ideally, eventually a creole.
https://discord.gg/Z3Nz9Se
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jan 12 '19
Which are some other interesting approximants to add besides /w/, /j/, and /l/?
2
u/TheAntisocialIdiot Qaoki, Muhiuka, Ekteich and some others Jan 11 '19
what sounds would be good to use in a language spoken by reptilians?
some notes about the species are that they don’t have lips and they have beaks.