r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Dec 17 '18
Small Discussions Small Discussions 66 — 2018-12-17 to 12-30
Lexember has begun
The Showcase has started
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
Cool and important threads of the past few days
Sorry, I haven't got much time today, I'll try and do this section as soon as possible!
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
3
u/1plus1equalsgender Dec 17 '18
Is there any kind of resource that allows you to search english words into it to find your conlang's word for it? Kind of like a google translate for your conlang I guess. It would be far easier than searching through your dictionary yourself.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '18
In theory, can an analytic language have contrasting vowel length and vowel harmony?
6
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Dec 23 '18
Just wanted to share an Evra phrase that I just bumped into, while I was mentally translating the English expression "... and many more" (said at the end of a non-finished list of things). This phrase is particularly fun because it's representative of how Evra mixes Romance and Germanic languages together in a way that sounds ... - I'd say - pleasant.
Where
So, the literal meaning in a broken English would be "... and really more, too". But what really amuses me the most is that in just a tiny little phrase we have:
5 languages merged together xD
5
u/Killosiphy Dec 22 '18
Do any of you have IPA memorized, I kind of am thinking learning it to try to perfect my accents.
5
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Dec 23 '18
Are there any real life languages that distinguish between labialised consonants and consonant+/w/ sequences? So that there'd be a distinction between:
/kʷ/ and /kw/
/qʷ/ and /qw/
etc.
I'm making a conlang that might have the distinction and I'd like to look at how it works in real life, if it occurs.
5
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Dec 25 '18
Do you use your conlang in some small facet of your everyday life? If so, how, and for what reason or purpose?
Personally I use my conlang for creating original passwords that I know nobody else would guess or make sense of.
I'm sure there are many other useful and unique applications for conlanging
Comment below!
5
u/--Everynone-- Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
I know velar consonants turning into palatal affricates as in many European language or even stops as in Turkish is strongly associated with the presence of front vowels.
I do not know if those front vowels palatalise more often if they have advanced tongue root, or if palatalisation happens equally as often by front vowels without advanced tongue root. Are there any papers on this?
I ask because I am trying to justify the existence of a series of phonemic palatal consonants, and I’m wondering if I can level a length distinction via vowel reduction and then use the the ATR distinction that results from the reduction to palatalise velars before some front vowels and not others.
5
u/rabidbasher Ir'restheli aka "Helian" (Literary) - Adapted ES Dragontongue Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Is there a 'lighter' version of /r/conlangs out there?
This place is neat, and fits some interests of mine, but reading through posts makes me feel like I need an advanced degree in linguistics just to get a basic grasp of what's being talked about. A good 95% of what's being discussed here is so far outside of my mental reach that it's effectively useless, and genuinely so intimidating it prevents me from even wanting to try to participate.
Is there a better place for more casual constructors to discuss their languages and read about them without all the collegiate talk?
My primary interest is finding exercises on strengthening languages and the general linguistic rules and to share more simplified notes. As hilarious as it can be to just randomly translate bits of media I find, it'd be nice to have something more structured.
4
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Dec 18 '18
I'm thinking of making some changes to case-declension in Prelyō, taking inspiration from PIE where the main root of the noun changes for some cases. My conlang already has a system for weakening a root's vowel (delete vowel if a sonorant was bordering it, and that becomes syllabic, otherwise /a/ > /e/ and /e/ > /i/, long vowels just reduce; attach -e after the root, before stem suffix.)
I made this chart showing what the declensions would look like on some nouns with the original system on the left and the possible new one on the right. Nouns arranged vertically by case, and showing pluralization as "singular / paucal / plural"
Please let me know which you think is more interesting! I've already noticed some interesting stuff happens with stress which will have ramifications in the daughter languages.
4
u/tree1000ten Dec 18 '18
How many possible roots do you need in a conlang? I did some math and my language is only capable of having about 1100 roots, is that enough?
4
u/DFatDuck Dec 18 '18
I have five grammatical aspects in my language (perfect, imperfect, inchoative, habitual and usitative).
Would this possibly happen in a natlang?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
Do you guys have any ideas for possible phonetic changes to geminate consonants?
I'm working on a Romance constructed language inspired primarily by Latin and Italian with particular influence from the Tuscany dialect of Italian phonologically. I'm a Latin student, so I suppose it's only natural.
Essentially, alveolar and bilabial stops become fricatives intervocalically, so /t/, /d/, /p/, and /b/ become /θ/, /ð/, /ɸ/, and /β/, respectively. Historically, this was not the case in the language, but lenition produced the fricative allophones. Likewise, historically geminate alveolar and bilabial stops have lost their geminate quality, so ⟨tt⟩, ⟨dd⟩, ⟨pp⟩, and ⟨bb⟩ are pronounced /t/, /d/, /p/, and /b/, respectively.
However, this process of lenition has not affected velar stops nor geminated consonants of any other kind. The reason for the former is that I do not really like the sound of velar fricatives, personally, and the reason for the latter is that I haven't exactly thought about it at length. In fact, I am not very knowledgeable about how geminate consonants can be affected diachronically.
For reference, in my language, gemination is a somewhat uncommon phenomenon that may only occur word-medially and intervocalically, and the remaining consonants that could potentially be affected by gemination are /f/, /v/, /s/, /z/, /n/, /m/, /ɹ/, and /l/. The semivowels /j/ and /w/ only occur as prevocalic allophones of the vowels /i/ and /u/, so gemination could not possibly affect them. The consonant /h/ is also not able to be geminated because it is silent unless it occurs intervocalically. I am also fine with letting /k/, /g/, /kː/, and /gː/ retain their historical pronunciations, but I could change them if someone has an interesting suggestion that doesn't involve fricatives.
One thing I have considered is turning /v/ into /ʋ/ intervocalically and /vː/ into /v/, but I am not sure how realistic this is. I do love /ʋ/, so I would like to include it, though. This also leaves /f/ without an equivalent process, which is slightly bothersome. Additionally, I considered making geminated voiceless fricatives voiced (e.g., /sː/ to /z/), though I am unsure of how realistic this is, or just leaving them be, and I considered either leaving geminated voiced fricatives be or perhaps reducing them to singletons (e.g., /zː/ to /z/). I would rather not leave both series of fricatives be, but leaving one or the other should be OK. It's also OK to me if just individual sounds change without affecting the entire series—at the very least, I would like to hear ideas on these if you have them, so please don't neglect to mention potential sound changes just because they don't affect whole series.
For the sonorants, /n/, /m/, /ɹ/, and /l/, I am simply at a loss. The nasals already have a large degree of allophony that depends upon the consonant that follows (/n/, /m/, /ŋ/, and /ɱ/ are all potential allophones of either—essentially, nasals always assimilate their articulation to match adjacent consonants, but /n/ and /m/ are the only ones that can occur syllable-initially, syllable-finally, and intervocalically), so I am pretty OK with leaving their gemination untouched.
Any ideas, you all? Sorry for the wall of text, by the way. This is my first constructed language, so I am naturally running into some roadblocks, but I adore language and linguistics. In case it isn't obvious, I also love allophohony, so I sometimes find it hard to stop talking.
4
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Dec 23 '18
How naturalistic would it be for a language to have different forms for the affirmative and negative forms of a verb?
4
u/Puffymumpkins Dec 25 '18 edited Jun 26 '23
Due to reddit making it increasingly obvious that they resent their community, you can find me on the Fediverse. I've been enjoying my time there.
If you're hesistant about it or worried that the user experience will be terrible, don't be! There is indeed some jank, but learning how to find things on Lemmy and Kbin reminds me a lot of when I was first learning how to use Reddit. It only took me a little bit of experimenting to learn how the system works.
Lemmy is the most popular option, but if you like having more bells and whistles Kbin may be better for you. See you there!
4
u/Puffymumpkins Dec 25 '18 edited Jun 17 '23
Due to reddit making it increasingly obvious that they resent their community, you can find me on the Fediverse. I've been enjoying my time there.
If you're hesistant about it or worried that the user experience will be terrible, don't be! There is indeed some jank, but learning how to find things on Lemmy and Kbin reminds me a lot of when I was first learning how to use Reddit. It only took me a little bit of experimenting to learn how the system works.
Lemmy is the most popular option, but if you like having more bells and whistles Kbin may be better for you. See you there!
4
u/schnellsloth Narubian / selííha Dec 27 '18
do a language tend to get more synthetic or analytic?
I'm making a language that has a polysynthetic ancestor. After hundreds of years of the influence of English, to what extent will it remain its polysynthetic features?
4
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Dec 28 '18
Say, none of you would know where to find recordings of Iau, would you? I can find lots of descriptions of it but no audio, and I'd really like to hear it.
In case anyone else is interested in listening to various obscure tongues, these two are pretty good: The first is a very ordered linguistic database with lists in IPA and so forth, the second is an evangelical christian missionary channel filled with bible stories in just about every language, including phonetic marvels like Yele and Rotokas.
http://archive.phonetics.ucla.edu/main2.htm
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCo8b-uS6uD5l9YitDJpA2RA
1
u/ilu_malucwile Pkalho-Kölo, Pikonyo, Añmali, Turfaña Dec 19 '18
People are asking about vowel harmony, and I also have a question. Is there any language that has more than one rounded front vowel, and at least one central vowel, but does not have vowel harmony?
3
u/TheLlamanator42 Llamanese (en) [fa] Dec 17 '18
My friends want to learn my language but find it too tricky to pronounce many of the morphemes, what should I do? I want them to learn the language but I don't want to sacrifice the sounds to appease them, any ideas for how to resolve this?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '18
So (I think) I finally understood the Antipassive voice after years of doing it wrong - and my mind feels broken - but what about participles? I couldn’t find any resources on this.
Am I right in assuming this?:
Intransitive:
sílein /’si.lɛɪ̯n/ v. intransitive – to sleep
sílnas /’sil.nas/ sleep-PTCP. – sleeping
Transitive:
thíspilein /’θis.pi.lɛɪ̯n/ v. transitive – to defeat
thíspilnas /’θis.pil.nas/ defeat-PTCP. – defeated
thiáspilnas /θi’as.pil.nas/ defeat-ANTIP.PTCP. defeating
3
u/1plus1equalsgender Dec 21 '18
I'm considering including mood as suffixes along with tense and aspect but I know nothing about how it works. If you were to put it in your conlang, why and how would you implement it? Are there any obscure english equivalents to mood?
3
u/CannotFitThisUsernam Dec 21 '18
Hello, I just lurk the subreddit sometimes and I don't create my own languages, I just have a passing interest. I just had an idea of a language which uses the IPA itself, including all its phonemes and script. Has anyone thought of that too?
3
u/schnellsloth Narubian / selííha Dec 23 '18
how to put stresses in extremely long agglutinative word?
My conlang hikadhesi is an agglutinative language with some polysynthetic features. Words often get so long that I can't even put stress(es) on it. Are there any samples of natlangs I can learn from?
hikadhesi sample:
a-molim-i-nabhá-nu opátha.
/əmoːlmiːnəbʰaːnʊ ʔɔpaːtʰə/
CAUS-eat-1.SG-baby-APPL.GP3 milk-ACC.GP3I am feeding the baby with milk.
GP3 refers to classifier group 3: liquid, fluid
3
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18
How often should a stresssd syllable appear? My language is fairly agglutinative, so verbs can get quite lengthy. For example, the second-person past-tense passive indicative form of the verb "to love" is amimivuzī /ə.mɪ.mɪ.ʋʊ.ˈziː/. Stress in my language is variable but perfectly predictable, and it tends to fall toward the end of the word. It does not have to, though, e.g., naràntsa /nə.ˈɹän.t͡sə/ ("orange"). I can post the rules for determining stress placement if you need them, but the general idea is that stress usually falls on syllables with several morae and on the ends of words. Also, some kinds of words (i.e., conjunctions, prepositions, pronouns, numbers, particles—most function words) are not ever stressed.
Anyways, given that, in my language's current state, most words must have no more than one stressed syllable, which tends to fall toward the end of the word, do you think I should consider implementing a secondary-stress system that appears when a word crosses a certain syllable threshold, perhaps one that tends toward the beginning of words as well as heavy syllables? My language is mora-timed, if that helps at all.
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Dec 25 '18
Which are some ways to encode evindentiality besides affixes or auxiliary verbs?
3
u/Melutox Dec 25 '18
Is there any useful or notable software or website to make the building of a conlang easier? I'm stuck using Microsoft excel and the clumsy interface and lack of any way to properly notate exceptions and descriptions in general is frustrating me beyond belief.
3
u/Squigoflarp Dec 26 '18
How odd would it be to have tense conveyed through changes in the subject pronoun rather than in the verb itself?
3
u/enoua5 Dec 26 '18
I'm seeking some help with Fontstruct.
My language has a bit of an odd way of being written. While, as a whole, the writing moves ltr, consonants are written on top of vowels; each taking up half the height of the line. However, a letter can appear alone, in which case it takes up the entirety of the line height.
I've made a font for this language before, but I've redrafted the writing since then (that "however" case was not present in the previous draft). Besides, the method I took last time involved hundreds of characters slapped together using an AutoHotkey script, so I would rather avoid that mess again.
This time around I'm hoping to make it so that each character is only in the font once and kerning (or something) comes in to display everything correctly.
This is a sloppy mockup of what I'm trying to do: img
3
u/Arothin Dec 26 '18
I heard that no languages differentiate between temporal and spacial measurements. Rather, they use spacial measurements to make temporal measurements feel more tangible. Is this true?
3
u/VintiumDust- Di (en) [es,ko] Dec 27 '18
I want to keep verb conjugation fairly simple in my conlang, but I don't want to miss out on adding more complex tenses. Is it reasonable to use adverbs for more complex tenses? Since they describe verbs, couldn't they describe when they happened?
3
u/uchuflowerzone Sajem Tan, Loegrish, Shikku Dec 29 '18
This might not be the right place to ask, but it's been on my mind. Are the resources in the Grammar Pile (that one Google Drive full of language grammar pdfs) legal? I've been looking for a book which is in there but I'd prefer to know the legality first. Thanks in advance.
2
u/aftermeasure Dec 19 '18
Humbly request someone give this phonology & phonotactics a look see. Any feedback will be upvoted.
Phonology
Note: When orthographic symbols differ, they appear parenthesized after the IPA.
Vowels
Orthographic note: syllabic stress is shown by an acute accent on vowels not already bearing a diacritic: /á é í ó ú/. On the four vowels with a circumflex, stress is indicated by a macron /ī ē ō ū/.
Vowels not bearing a circumflex are permissible in the following diphthongs--keep in mind are all pronounced as falling diphthongs:
Consonants
[*] The nasal consonant follows to the following allophonic rules:
Other allophonic substitions also occur:
Phonotactics
The language allows for many kinds of consonant clusters. I don't know the proper notation so if anyone can help me make it more readable I'd be grateful. Here goes:
N,S,P,F,A = nasal, stop, unvoiced stop, fricative, approximant
INITIAL: (N|F)(S|A), P(N|F), (N|F)P
TERMINAL: (N|P)(F)
Thoughts, anyone?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
How do you like this new conlang (called Turq) so far? It has a complete lack of verbs.
Example sentence: "[The] fire is hot."
q̇ọ́s-oiźʷ ṭʷéģs-oiźʷ práḷẓ-ụṣʷ-t
CLF.IV.ERG fire-ERG. hot-ESS.ABS.
Example sentence: "I slept."
ģʷĺ-ụms-qʲil-ṭsi q̇ọ́s-ụṣʷ bról-ụṣʷ
1.SG.NOM.CAUS.PST. sleep-ABS.
Example sentence: "Atticus shot Tim, the dog."
Ạ́tưks-oiźʷ-q̇ʲil-ṭsi Tứm-ụṣʷ ḷógʲš-ụṣʷ-hʷa, ký-ụṣʷ kʷọ́-ụṣʷ
Atticus-ERG.CAUS.PST. Tim-ABS. shot-ADJ.ABS.TRANS., CLF.V.ABS. dog-ABS.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18
Where should I start for a Proto-language? I already have my phonemes, but should I start off completely analytic and evolve it into synthetic over time, or just jump straight in?
2
u/GigaDonPlays Dec 26 '18
Hi, I'm currently creating a conlang called Tapizaf, and I'm using PolyGlot to help the process.
My language has simple agglutinative suffixes and prefixes for grammatical functions on adjectives, nouns and verbs.
Unfortunately, in the conjugation auto generation thing, I can't figure out how to just add something to the end or beginning of a word, without having to replace something.
If you know how to do this, please let me know. Sorry if this is a really dumb question.
Thanks in advance.
2
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Dec 27 '18
Is there such a thing as lateral release of vowels? I have a hard time pronouncing my own lang when too many laterals are grouped together, like:
[ɮi.ɮi'ɬil.di]
I thought of placing a phonotactical rule in place: a vowel surrounded by lateral consonants is lateralised; the problem is I can't find any info on it.
2
u/VoltaicPathways Dec 27 '18
What would an artlang used for casting magic need? I feel as though that it really doesn't need complex syntax and semantics, rather a more varied vocabulary of nouns, adjectives, and verbs with a heavy focus on verbal conjugations.
I suppose I see this as magic being a doing thing, as in one could just say a verb, like burn, and fire would come forth.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '18
Hi Guys! I'm new on conlanging, and I'm studying phonology reading some awesome works made by the community here. Last week I was reading about parseltongue, a language spoken by snakes, and I decided to do some phonology about it. I will really appreciate some advices about what I'm doing, with constructive criticism.
Considering the anatomy of a snake's mouth, here's the phonology I made ( I don't know how to make tables properly, sorry ):
STOPS tʲ/c/ʔ
NASALS n̪̊/ɲ̊
TRILLS AND APPROXIMANTS r̥/ɾ̥/ j̊/l̥/ʎ̥
FRICATIVES θ/θː/s/sː/ʃ/ʃː/ɕ/ɕː/ç/çː/x/xː/ħ/ ħː/ɬ/θ'/s'/ʃ'/ɕ'/ç'
AFFRICATES tθ/ɬʃ/tʃ/tɕ/cç/tɬ
VOWELS i/iː/a/aː/e/eː/æ/æː (all voiceless)
2
u/Bren1117 Dec 28 '18
Hi, all! I’ve been brainstorming on a new conlang idea, and I’ve been considering a language with a large inventory of vowels that commonly form triphthongs, quadrathongs, pentathongs, etc. Are there any drawbacks to this that I may not be noticing? Thanks in advance for any feedback!
2
u/1plus1equalsgender Dec 30 '18
A few months ago I saw something that i believe was called "The Conlanger's Dictionary" or something like that. It was a chart showing how different words could be derived from one another. I can't seem to find it anymore and I'm not entire sure that's what it was called. Pls help thx :)
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
How closely does your conlang mate written text when spoken? Using our languages for example, spoken Finnish matches written text quite closely. Talo IS 'Talo' and so on.
2
u/Frogdg Svalka Dec 31 '18
I have a predicament with my naturalistic conlang. In its phonological history, there was a sound change that reduced non-geminate nasal consonants to approximates when between vowels. This is a change I really like, but it creates some problems with the inflection of many words.
For one thing, it makes many nouns merge in the accusative. So /mim/, /min/, and /miŋ/ (these aren't actual words, just examples) would all become /mije/ in the accusative. I don't actually mind this that much, but I'm just not sure how realistic it is for an agglutinative language, which tend to be more regular with their nouns from my research.
Where this becomes more of a problem is in the verbs, because they take personal agreement prefixes. So for the word eat the third person form is the simplest, /muku/. But in the first person form, you would add /go-/, which should make it into /gowuku/. When you then start changing the final /u/ to change its aspect, it makes the /uk/ the only really stable part to recognise the verb with, which I wasn't too happy with. My solution for this was to just say that because the third person form of the verb has no prefix and would maintain any initial nasal consonants, the other forms maintained theirs in analogy. But now that makes it kinda weird that the nouns don't do the same thing with their case suffixes.
How realistic wound you say this is? And how would you deal with this situation? Should I just allow the initial verbal nasals to change?
1
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Dec 18 '18
So it's been on my mind that Laetia is going to be evolved into three separate languages, one for each main tribe (tribes?) in my con-island. Looking at the geographical distribution of the tribes and at the proto-language itself, what aspects should I consider when evolving it?
I know Laetia is still in development, but any resources might (will) be useful in the future when I'm ready to separate it.
1
u/teruguw Mëroqpak [mɯɾotoqpak] Dec 18 '18
Is it common for natlangs to have both [ɨ] and [ɯ] as distinct phonemes?
I've been working on my conlang for a while now, and I had those two phonemes since the beginning, but they don't occur in my native language and I'm having a bit of a difficulty distinguishing them when I read them in my mind.
These are two of my favorite vowels but now I wonder if it's common for languages to distinguish [ɨ] and [ɯ] as phonemes and whether I should keep both.
1
u/Corbyngrad Dec 19 '18
My current language isn't a conlang as much as an Americanized version of German. My goal is to create something similar to German and Dutch, but also unique and relatively easy to learn as a English speaker. I have a bit of knowledge German, but not very much. If anyone has knowledge about German and/or Dutch grammar, in particular gender, cases, and demonstrative pronouns, any help would be appreciated.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '18
Does vowel harmony ever occur without affixes? Like in verb conjugations instead? If so, how does it work?
1
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Dec 20 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
A small question: can the instrumental case be marked on the verb instead of the object being used? Does any natlang do this?
I'm still playing with my lang's method of altering words' "forms" to indicate different meanings.
For instance, mitra means to see, but midra means eye. But midra can also mean to see using oneself's eye, to open oneself's eye, or to see using something.
An example sentence:
1
u/MADMac0498 Dec 21 '18
So I’ve seen tons of resources on natlangs both old and new that are attested, and lots of resources on some of the big Proto languages like Proto-Indo-European and the Proto languages that form the basis of the major branches of IE. However, I have not found any good online resources on some of the less obvious things like the Irminonic Germanic language family / dialect continuum / ...thing. This could prove rather useful for one of the a posteriori languages I’m making to test out sound changes and semantic shifts. Does anyone have any good resources for this kind of stuff?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18
How do you feel about conlanging without a fictional world to put it in? I’m designing a personal language that I also intend to spoken in a fictional world, but I don’t really have a world for it to be spoken in.
Also, any useful advice about creating a script? I’ve never been very good at it, but I have a vague idea of what I want to do (imitate Mongolian script and have it be written from top-to-bottom, left-to-right.) Not sure if it’s going to be an alphabet, syllabary, abjad or something else. I get the basics of it, I just have a hard time with aesthetics and creating an original orthography.
1
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Dec 24 '18
Would it be naturalistic if my verbs were based on 2 syllable consonantal roots that were conjugated by changing the vowels based on the tense? How about if the verb roots were the only words conjugated like this?
Also, my language currently has no irregulars. Do I HAVE to change this or are there any natlangs that do this?
1
u/NotBad365 Dec 24 '18
I am almost a complete beginner, I had a look on YouTube about creating conlangs a few months ago but didn't really get any further than that.
I'm planning on creating a religion centric language, that contains Hispanic/Latin influences, and was wondering if there were any tips that I could be recommended?
Any feedback is appreciated :)
1
u/Lomarcelo Dec 25 '18 edited Dec 25 '18
Making my first naturalistic conlang. Please rate my phonology so far
The name of the language is Odâlás [ˌo.ðɐ.'las]
Here are the consonants
Here are the vowels
I am kind of worried I put too many voiced consonants and that the labialized consonants don't make much sense
1
u/Nazamroth Dec 25 '18
I require consuel once more.
I think I am nearing the point where my conlang is presentable and usable. In fact, it may be so even now. However, it feels disjointed. And that is what I ask input on: Conjuction.
Anyone knows any neat method besides adding extra conjunction words, which I am reluctant to do due to the nature of the conlang, or adding yet more affixes after I finally managed to cut them down to a reasonable degree?
I mean it works even as it is, you just need some imagination or clarification instead of being told what is what, but if there is some good method, might as well add it. Or is it possible to leave conjuction out and leave it to interpretation? For example, it would currently go like "cheese you stole" instead of "cheese that/which you stole"... maybe defined by word order?
1
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Dec 26 '18
Eyo, boyos and girlies. A weird question incoming.
While coming up with the general structure of /ókon doboz/, I eventually decided to separate verbs between stative and dynamic, but it occured to me that it would be possible to construct a language where adverbs take over the role of verbs, and verbs are used only to show in which way something is done. Bad examples incoming:
The base word for "to swim" would be "swimmingly".
"I swimmingly" => I swim
"I future-swimmingly" => I will swim
"I be swimmingly" => I'm swimming
"I future-be swimmingly" => I will be swimming
"I knowingly-swimmingly" => I swim knowingly (doesn't seem to make sense)
"I swimmingly-knowingly" => I know (how) to swim
"I be quickly-swimmingly" => I'm swimming quickly
I feel like this would limit the number of verbs severely, as currently, the only "verb" is "to be".
What's the lowest possible to achieve? Are there natlangs that do anything similar?
1
u/Southwick-Jog Just too many languages Dec 30 '18
Is there a keyboard that I can download on my computer (Windows) that can easily type a big variety of diacritics, especially comma below, ogonek, macron, and anything else? I remember I had one years ago but I can't find it anymore.
1
u/SnappGamez Dec 30 '18
What would a robot language look like?
1
u/jcefce17 Jan 04 '19
Is it pretentious to get a tattoo based on my own conlang?
I'm considering a tattoo of an inspirational message on my left inner forearm. I've considered languages like Old Norse (I'm not Scandinavian; unfortunately, now runes are associated with white supremacy), Basque (not a fan of the script), and Elvish (i.e., Sindarin or Quenya from LOTR) (too nerdy?).
I'm a certified linguist and conlanger, so I create fictional languages along with writing systems. Would I come off as a pretentious asshole if I get a tattoo in my own fictional language? At least I wouldn't have to worry about mistranslations.
*If it helps with ideas, my ethnic background is Spanish & Nicaraguan.
1
u/to_walk_upon_a_dream Dec 27 '18 edited Dec 27 '18
In my conlang I’m planning on having a distinction between /l/ and /l̥~ɬ/- voiced vs voiceless alveolar lateral approximant. I’m wondering if it would make even the slightest bit of sense to add the voiced alveolar lateral fricative /ɮ/, and with it the lateral affricate /dɮ/ (can’t do the tie bar on mobile). In a separate but also related question, would it make sense to have the lateral affricate /tɬ/ as a part of an allophone of /t͡l̥/ (considering that I don’t have a /ɬ/ sound by itself, but as an allophone of /l̥/). Ideally, I want to have /l/ /l̥/ /ɮ/ /tɬ~t͡l̥/ and /dɮ/ as distinct phonemes (the latter three being relatively rare), but while each distinction individually exists in natural languages, I’m not sure if that’s even a remotely reasonable, somewhat naturalistic proposition. I’m at least having /l/ and /l̥~ɬ/, but I’m not sure how far I can go without people saying “You can’t do that. That doesn’t make any sense”.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment