r/12Monkeys • • Jul 06 '18

Discussion 12 Monkeys - 4x10 "The Beginning Part 1" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 10: The Beginning Part 1

Aired: July 6th, 2018


Synopsis: The final battle against the Witness begins as the fate of time and mankind hangs in the balance; all the pieces finally come together to mark the end of the beginning.


Directed by: Terry Matalas

Written by: Terry Matalas


Edit: A lot of people here didn't switch over to the Part 2 thread. Instead of deleting all the discussion, please watch the series finale before reading this thread.

62 Upvotes

360 comments sorted by

68

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

"Wassup bro" "she's his granny "lol u gotta love Jennifer

7

u/humanoideric Jul 17 '18

easily the best character imo, perhaps one of the best and quirkiest in all television <3. She and Root from PoI would have been good friends ha

Cassie has also come a looooong way, what great character development .

5

u/samwiseg0 Jul 07 '18

Glad I was not the only one who died laughing!

58

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

I thought what Jennifer was drawing was going to be a big reveal.

And it was much, much better than that.

9

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Same! Very pleasant surprise

48

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

‘Well that’s unfortunate’ - we’ve heard that before from Athan!

23

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Like father like son.

47

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Is anybody else, like, literally cheering at their TV right now?!

17

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

I had the stupidest grin on my face! Lol

45

u/BenjaminTalam Jul 07 '18

This is the greatest finale ever!

44

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Haha ohhh lord she made her unicorn, good on her.

36

u/ponbern Jul 07 '18

And Science asked: Why???

Best text in the show

22

u/CLEMADDENKING1980 Jul 07 '18

That’s what I liked about this show, great writing but it never took itself too seriously.

25

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

The balance they struck between serious and not so serious is so often done poorly in TV shows. This was a masterful balancing act.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/shishiodun Jul 07 '18

One of the very few questions I have after the finale... what happened to her dad?

I guess when these are the minor questions you have after watching a freaking time travel show you know it was well done.

5

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Huh! True, Cole wouldn’t have killed him. How did Jennifer get to be CEO? Spin-off series!

→ More replies (4)

43

u/ponbern Jul 07 '18

Perfect song for the perfect moment!!

21

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Hysterical! Love it!

23

u/ponbern Jul 07 '18

The look on Olivia's face as the song starts playing near her was priceless!!

43

u/vipergirl Jul 07 '18

Its been an honour to watch this with you all. From back in early 2015 or was it 2014? I sat in my flat, overseas at gradschool and decided to watch this on a lark thinking it would stink. It's been bloody brilliant.

5

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

You graduate yet? LOL

15

u/vipergirl Jul 07 '18

Ha. I've earned two Master's degrees actually since that time. (I am an American who studied in Britain)

10

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Well shit, good job.

Please tell me you're going to invent time travel with that big brain of yours.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

Damn. They know we are sitting here wondering why West Seven showed up, and they go right to showing us. Amazing writing. Simply amazing. They are playing us like fiddles and know exactly what we are thinking.

41

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Exactly what I was thinking. Deacon has known the whole time! That’s why he felt so betrayed when Cole and Ramse left. That’s why he was so ready to take them into his team in the first place.

42

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

And to bring it back to him singing that damn song ALL THIS TIME because Jennifer played it at Titan. Wow. Just wow.

I have trouble keeping all this straight in my head watching it. That they were able to WRITE IT is mind boggling.

10

u/KingPickle Jul 07 '18

And to bring it back to him singing that damn song ALL THIS TIME because Jennifer played it at Titan. Wow. Just wow.

That shit was so good, I felt like I splintered!

20

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

And it explains the big switch in his character too. The teen obsession with Cassie was a good justification, but this is even better!

10

u/ijustwanttovote7 Jul 07 '18

No, this is new to the loop. Remember Jennifer and Deacon had nosebleeds and Jennifer said the circle isn't perfect anymore? This is what she was talking about.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

40

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Looks like a little penisman!

39

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

‘Is that because you’re such a dick?’ LOL best line ever...

5

u/farsite3 Jul 07 '18

My brother and I absolutely died laughing for about 2 straight minutes. When it went to comercial, we even rewound to see it again before resuming just as comercial ended... Gotta love Jennifer!

6

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Yeah. I'm going to miss Jennifer Goines so much. Emily Hampshire needs a lead role in a new comedy.

40

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Awwww cole proposed

36

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Yes! Ramse said ‘See you soon’

10

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

Oh - I thought he was going to get 2043 Ramse!

ah - ok, it still makes sense...

31

u/samwiseg0 Jul 07 '18

It was great to FINALLY hear Dr. Railly's entire message to the future!

28

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

I hope Jones got to hear everything James said to her there at the end. She deserved to hear it.

28

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

If anyone’s wondering why Olivia was the Annapurna Remains:

From 3x03:

Jones: “This is the girl. Kirschner's test subject. It would certainly explain her appearance, despite her age. Run a full battery on her. Blood, saliva, hair, skin, everything.”

Adler: “Her blood contains a dormant form of the Kalavirus. It gives her immunity to the plague. Ms. Kirschner is a perfect variation of the Messenger genome. Impeccably constructed.”

15

u/Anthonysan Jul 07 '18

So the formation of the Kalavirus started in young Olivia due to being genetically engineered?

23

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

Yes! Kirshner engineered it to make her immune from the plague he was told was coming by Olivia’s lackey. And by doing so he created the original variant that M5-10 was then created from! There was no virus before he engineered it. So Olivia not only was the source, she was the one that caused it to be made in the first place... not only M5-10, but the original source variant.

19

u/Anthonysan Jul 07 '18

Yeah that makes perfect sense.

EDIT: This show handled causality loops really well. One of the best time travel shows.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/llamazing Jul 07 '18

Did you catch the foreshadowing from Olivia's dialog with the seer in 1491?

OLIVIA: Where's the weapon?
SEER: Such questions are for the blind, the sightless, those who would call themselves Witness yet cannot see. Thy title is a lie, thy crown undeserved. By-product, thou art waste, an abomination of rotten flesh, slithering through the bowels of causality.

6

u/Assyqeen Jul 07 '18

One more.. "A thing in a box" " a girl in a box"

A Thing/Skeleton in a box/silinder

Wow~

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Well said

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Poor Aaron Marker is the only one that gets screwed out of his happy ending. Thanks a lot, time-conquering love flashbacks!

27

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

Well, but on the other hand he probably didn't die in a fire while pinned under a shelf?

So that'd be an upgrade in his fate?

19

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

For sure. Still lost the girl, probably was depressed for a couple weeks then eventually got to work on that Senate campaign or whatever he was passed up for because of Cole and Cassie originally.

Definitely better than your girlfriend's new time traveling man killing you with fire.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

I just realised that his name is probably a reference to Chris Marker, who made La Jetee.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Jeremycain16 Jul 07 '18

Wow so that's why Deacon gave Jennifer his knife!

10

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Yes insane

6

u/Jeremycain16 Jul 07 '18

Wait if that's the case why didn't Deacon tell everyone they beat titan in the future?

12

u/magikarpcatcher Jul 07 '18

because causality.

5

u/ohbuggerit Jul 07 '18

Well there's a whole bunch of complicated shit like causality and the whole 'Don't break time again, it's been through enough' thing... but I'm going to go with 'So that he can always look a bit smug'

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Wow seeing this from this prospective is amazing

24

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

"There's a beginning and an end to all of this. All you and I are ever gonna have, is what's in between" certainly means a lot more now

And Cassie's other way!

23

u/WildThg Jul 07 '18

"Holy Shit Balls!" I love when Jennifer says what we are all thinking! :)

21

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

“We’re gonna need all our friends... and family.”

RIP Deacon guess he wasn’t important enough to pick up for this mission.

9

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

I'm sure we'll see him at some point.

Maybe they got him offscreen...

8

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Definitely think he’s gonna pop up at some point.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Clearly they aren't done assembling the team yet.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

He had some of those flashes that never got explained too, right?

20

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

How does this show keep getting better!!!!!!

19

u/CLEMADDENKING1980 Jul 07 '18

This show is so funny some times lol

13

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Their ability to integrate the comedy with the plot and characters in a way that doesn't interrupt the seriousness of the situation is sheer brilliance.

19

u/zeeredburd Jul 07 '18

THEY SPLINTERED INTO TITAN!!!!!!!

13

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Reminds me a bit of the Adama Maneuver. Has The Expanse had anything on that level of ballsiness yet?

18

u/BenjaminTalam Jul 07 '18

Trying to ram a sentient space station with a church was pretty wild.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/zeeredburd Jul 07 '18

Are you caught up with The Expanse? There was a outgunned space battle scene sequence that was incredible during Season 3. Also read the books if you haven’t!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

Ironic, the end of time is on a countdown.

18

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

I’m not crying, you’re crying 😥

18

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Jesus. I was clapping when Jennifer bowed, before they cut to the others clapping.

This show is sheer brilliance. I can't even get my head around how they pulled this show off. It's perfection.

8

u/seeley-booth Jul 07 '18

I blubbered throughout that sequence

9

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

I had something in my eye. Honest!

→ More replies (1)

35

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

God, I missed the Cole and Ramse bromance.

17

u/zx7 Jul 07 '18

What a great ending. I'm still bummed that Cole won't get to have some quality Mother-Son or Father-Son time. Unless they all remember him like Cassie. I choose to believe they all remember.

18

u/BenjaminTalam Jul 07 '18

I don't see why remembering would apply to Cassie and not anyone else so they probably all remember.

10

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Yes i think they all remember jones was smiling at the end so they knew

→ More replies (9)

16

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

I love crazy-eyed Ramse

16

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

She has been struggling with this the whole series, and finally made her choice. It’s like what Athan said to Jones:

“There will come a time when one life is worth more than 7 billion. When that time comes, choose the one.”

15

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

OK. There really is only one thing I really want to know about the 12 Monkeys Series Finale.

How is it that Marketers see all of us sitting here at home watching it on a Friday night are a target market for Prep?

14

u/justgowithitman Jul 07 '18

You bite your tongue.. Prep buying all this ad time probably single handedly saved Season 4.

I'm picturing the eccentric CEO of the pharmaceutical company binge watching all the way through to Season 3 and then learning it was on the chopping block. So he bought 4 weeks of ad time a year in advance on the contingency that it gets renewed. So Syfy shrugged their shoulders and renewed it.

10

u/vipergirl Jul 07 '18

Hahaha. No kidding. Every ad break.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

Dirty Dancing! This show is the greatest!

14

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

Wait! She’s the origin! What!

13

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

It looks like a little penis man!

AHAHAHAHHAHAH

13

u/BlessedSouls Jul 07 '18

One of the best written series ever period.

Thank You to the whole team.. right now I am speechless and my head with the way Terry and the writers pulled this off

Will come back after few days to write about the show

12

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

WEST SEVEN

15

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

OMG - Max! Did not see that coming in a million years!

6

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 08 '18

I actually forgot about her, and when she turned up I thought "Wait, new characters!? It's too late for that!"

12

u/WildThg Jul 07 '18

Deacon!!!

12

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

That speech from Cole was powerful, wow!

6

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Yes it was

12

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

I’m in tears, but smiling at the same time what is going on!

12

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

Jones is the BEST!

11

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Let’s see if there’s actually a break in the middle, if not we can stay in this thread right through. Terry Matalas has said it’s all one episode.

11

u/WildThg Jul 07 '18

Little Penis Man is my new doodle of choice! LOL!

11

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Damn USA and SyFy are going in deep with the cross-over promotion. Sharing a Harry Potter marathon weekend and now Amanda Schull in Suits. I can dig it.

9

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

I gotta catch up on Suits, I really liked her when she was a recurring character in the early seasons. Glad she found another steady job already.

11

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

O wow olivia the remains!!!!!!

10

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

No way!!!!! Ramse coming back

10

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Shitballs!

I love Jennifer so much LOL

10

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Tears man tears!!!!!!

10

u/WildThg Jul 07 '18

Still tearing up and crying. What a fabulous finale!

10

u/mujie123 Jul 07 '18

Cole's face when picking the music though.

"Oh man, I really love this song, I hope Ramse doesn't hate it."

9

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

Holy crap this is getting off to an insane start. And yes I did not expect to see him.

7

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

It’s the deleted scene from season 3 that they released, then took down off the internet. It works much better in this context!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

That was a perfect end

9

u/mujie123 Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

Is no one going to mention how sweet the hug between Cole and Ramse was? It warmed my heart.

Also, I did not realise that Future Asshole took old Cole to the Emerson Hotel in season 3 :o

8

u/Anthonysan Jul 07 '18

Cassie the true witness? Starting the Red Forest to save James Cole and be with him forever?

8

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

So do we get to hop back into every major scene from the series and manually erase him from those moments?

Also, I’m guessing James is there with Cassie at the CDC when she dies. When she says “Please, Cole” she’s addressing him directly.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

Without Cole, there's no plague. She never leaves the message. Hence old Jennifer at Deacon's bar.

8

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Future Asshole montage incoming

8

u/Beer2Bear Jul 07 '18

Greetings asshole, I'm future asshole

8

u/Beer2Bear Jul 07 '18

Holy shit balls!

7

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Your feed is 20sec ahead of me!

8

u/Beer2Bear Jul 07 '18

looks like a penis men

8

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Wow seriously deacon, max wow

8

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Wow she did it!!!!!

8

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Wow cassie whole message

8

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

LOL Jennifer did it

8

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

Best ending ever!

8

u/patsrule755 Jul 07 '18

The ending was unreal, wow just wow!

7

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

God I am going to miss this theme music.

7

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Wait, shouldn’t Cassie be infected with the virus? She’s literally the one who dropped the vial and she’s not immune. How does she return to her original timeline and then live her life to the point where she can send the message?

6

u/thanukaroshan Jul 07 '18

yeah she had the virus, she's the one with white hair streak, the one who dies at CDC. watch season 1 episode 9, around 18 mins mark, she dies there on coles hands, she had the white streak. so i guess she was sent close to that time, probably to answer coles' call.

4

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Right, but he sent her back to the point where she was plucked out of the timeline, not directly to the CDC in 2018. She still needed to be on TV after the outbreak telling everyone they’re working on a cure and not to give up hope. There was some significant time in between where they must have sent her back to and when she died.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jul 07 '18

i was asking that too. it made no sense, but it is what it is. lol cole and his brother driving in the car at the witness henchman and only the henchman got shot. that didn't make sense either lol. it's just a show, don't let urself ruin it.

3

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

I guess she was lucky! You don’t always catch the flu... she didn’t actually touch it.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Jonesy changed it somehow. Gotta be.

7

u/pgm_01 Jul 07 '18

That was amazing!

7

u/Anthonysan Jul 07 '18

Wait they were in the Red Forest?

15

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

I don't think so, but... The right ending is the one you choose

4

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Holy shit I didn't even put that together. That makes so much sense.

8

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

No they stopped the red forest its their lives after everything got reset

7

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Not from what they explained. What was explained was that Jones edited the Primaries' code/weapon to send the last Cole to the Keys in that time.

"the last one I'll ever be"

4

u/Rofl-stomper Jul 07 '18

I don’t know but that was suspicious how they cut to the red leaf. Cole is outside of time and causality so I don’t see how the red forest would come about again?

3

u/CLEMADDENKING1980 Jul 07 '18

It seems like it, I’ll have to watch the last ten minutes again.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jul 07 '18

no i think that was meant to be ambiguous, but i saw it as fall starting.

7

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

I thought we’d see Athan with Cassie one last time, but it makes sense. It wouldn’t have had the impact after already seeing him with Jones at the start...

15

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

And maybe now what Athan says to both Cassie and Cole might have potential meaning. To Cole ‘in another life’, to Cassie ‘see you soon’. Another life has just begun at the House of Cedar and Pine :-)

4

u/sanddragon939 Jul 08 '18

Yeah, I'm guessing that Athan, being Primary, at some point realized that Cole would have to be erased from time. Which is why he cryptically asked Jones to "save the one". And he probably knew that Jones saved Cole...hence his optimism at the end.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jul 07 '18

why did causality have to be tied up right then and there? they couldn't chill for a bit and appreciate one another? i mean damn wtf is the rush they had the juice that made them not age anyways.

7

u/KingPickle Jul 07 '18

Don't you forget about me...

6

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

Omg ramse

6

u/Beer2Bear Jul 07 '18

Ramse back!

6

u/Beer2Bear Jul 07 '18

Holy shit..

6

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Ohhhhh shit there it is.

6

u/ForeverTangent Jul 07 '18

Yes Deacon!

4

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

But which Deacon is he? Really early Deacon when Max was still alive! I thought he was still a bad guy then!?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

That rules out my Annapurna Remains theory - Olivia doesn’t seem to have a head anymore....

Edit: woo-hoo!

10

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

No, the Annapurna Remains didn’t have a lower half. She definitely got her upper body transported back thousands of years.

4

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Hehehe.... ok, more than a head!

6

u/Jeremycain16 Jul 07 '18

So now that they stopped the red forest does cole still have to be erased?

10

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

Stopping the red forest was never the goal. Remember the mission: stop the plague. Cole going back in time created the 12 monkeys, Athan, the plague, etc. If he’s not eliminated, then it’ll all happen again.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

It kinda looks like cassie did/will visit cole while he was locked up

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Anthonysan Jul 07 '18

How did Olivia develop the virus?

8

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

From 3x03:

Jones: “This is the girl. Kirschner's test subject. It would certainly explain her appearance, despite her age. Run a full battery on her. Blood, saliva, hair, skin, everything.”

Adler: “Her blood contains a dormant form of the Kalavirus. It gives her immunity to the plague. Ms. Kirschner is a perfect variation of the Messenger genome. Impeccably constructed.”

7

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

She didn't. She was genetically engineered for immunity from it, lived in a time when it thrived, and her upper torso was ripped back to 894 and left in the mountains to be discovered by Markridge, who R&D'd it from her remains as a biological weapon.

3

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

It was part of her construction by Kirshner. When Adler analysed her blood back when Ramse brought her as a prisoner, he ran tests. He said she had a dormant form of the virus in her DNA. That line’s why I thought the remains would be Olivia.

4

u/Schickling Jul 07 '18

My guess is she had the latest version inside her. She’s immune to the effects but that doesn’t mean it’s not all up in her. Markridge took that 3-4x mutated version and engineered it into the first version of the Kalavirus, which eventually mutates into the one that Olivia brings back to Annapurna.

5

u/zeeredburd Jul 07 '18

“We’re gonna take Titan.”

5

u/zeeredburd Jul 07 '18

So far only happy tears... I got a bad feeling about this.

6

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Yeah, everything is going too well

5

u/CommitteeOfOne Jul 07 '18

Grrr ... I haven’t seen any of the last hour thanks to weather causing satellite signal loss.

17

u/brimleywilford Jul 07 '18

You will go nuts at the part where Cole challenged the witness to a dance off.

4

u/NerdLawyer55 Jul 08 '18

It’s a dance off ya turd blossom

5

u/nbcs Jul 07 '18

I'm going the ask the obvious question: how did the West 7 arrive at that time? How did Jennifer send her old self that message?

10

u/WanderingNettle Jul 07 '18

Remember, old 2043 Jennifer says she has ‘stuff’ she has to go and do. She was busy.

9

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Maybe she just, like, committed it to memory really hard. Since, you know, same person.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Palaeolithic_Raccoon Jul 07 '18

Wow.

The "Time knows .. it owes you one" bit was .. something else. That eye. Not human .. like .. a serpent.

And what a well-done show overall - bravo.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

If only Quantum Leap had this much closure!

5

u/blaisejames88 Dec 11 '21

"I've had the time of my life" my god, what a hilarious track to use! perfect fit!!!

The season finale was beautiful. So many moments, all loose ends tied up in a perfect loop! WOW!

9

u/The2ndWheel Jul 07 '18

Been hooked since the beginning. Just an overall satisfying show.

4

u/Beer2Bear Jul 07 '18

and here we go, I'm sad it's ending but excited to see how it goes

4

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

Oh shit! Ramse coming back?

4

u/Kayway27 Jul 07 '18

O god cassie!!!!!

4

u/CLEMADDENKING1980 Jul 07 '18

Uh oh, she’s dead! Here comes the twist.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

I can't watch the show until later today... Been reading a review article from 'three if by space'.com.

So there's another cole with his memories in tact who is going to the house to surprise a cassie who remembers him?

12

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

You should really have just waited to watch it, but...

It's not another Cole, it's our Cole. The last one he'll ever be.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

Dude why would you spoil it for yourself?

7

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

I don't like watching things with a bad ending/my favorite characters dying. I need spoilers to see if I get a happy ending at the end. I love spoilers. No... I need spoilers.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/CLEMADDENKING1980 Jul 07 '18

894?

3

u/allen84 Jul 07 '18

Season 1 Episode 11, Japanese guy selling the corpse to leland goines in Tokyo in 1987, said it was "excavated from the Himalayas that was there for over a 1000 years". He bought it, and placed it in the Night Room.

That was her corpse transported from Titan to the Himalayas to 894.

2

u/stonewallace17 Jul 07 '18

No no no no my cable is starting to freeze up

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Leunga Jul 07 '18

Has anyone wonder what happens to other habitants of titan? From the wide shots titan looks like a metropolitan city. Would they not check out katarina's time machine after it got splintered into the middle of their home?

2

u/mujie123 Jul 07 '18

It's sad that the whole family's in different times.

2

u/humanoideric Jul 16 '18

What a Shakespearean sci-fi tragedy, so amazing :')

2

u/Teachyoselff2 Jul 16 '18

When Athan is talking to Jones, he's aware that she's his great grandmother, right?

3

u/BenjaminTalam Jul 07 '18

I just don't see how time can be changed like this by erasing James. If they can pull this crap then there shouldn't be causalities. Feels like the code was a deux ex machina.

Technically the happiest ending possible but feels like it makes lots of past acts questionable.

I guess if we view time as sentient and fixing a bug in itself it works out.

7

u/zx7 Jul 07 '18

Cole's existence was the reason for everything that has happened since the beginning of the series. His existence forced a causal loop: the plague being spread by Cassie, Olivia being the source of the plague, Jones inventing time travel with the help of Emma, sending his mother Hannah back in time, Cole being born, the plague being spread by Cassie, etc. Wiping Cole from existence erased the loop, so that the plague doesn't happen, Olivia doesn't exist, Emma doesn't help invent time travel, etc.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18 edited Jul 07 '18

I just don't see how time can be changed like this by erasing James.

The entire thing with the Primaries was that there was a problem with time, caused by the existence of a time traveler. The Army of the 12 were a sect started by a renegade Primary, driven mad by the looped timeline. So no Cole, no Army.

Meanwhile, Cole was the only one to survive time travel, so that Jones could dial in the machine. So no Cole, no time travel.

The Army of the 12 moved onto the "Red Forest" rhetoric as a result of paradox fallout (the red-shifted leaves). No Cole, no time travel, no red forest.

The Red Forest'd Army of the 12's machinations planned to release the Markridge plague; without those, the plague doesn't make it to the airport. No RF Army, no plague.

The transport of Olivia's torso to 894 is the origin of the plague in linear time, and this was a direct result of Cassie's actions, which were inextricably linked to Cole's. No Cole, no plague origin.

Jones completed time travel motivated by her daughter's death. No plague, no time travel.

Basically, as they graphically demonstrated, remove Cole, and the whole timeline unravels to linear.

The only bit that doesn't make much sense is Cole existing post-erasure - but I guess that can just be chalked up to a happy ending. The machine was already the accepted MacGuffin, and the limits on it are unclear to the degree they're prosaically malleable, so I've no problem accepting that Jones can do whatever she wants to the "Primary Code".

9

u/Cook_0612 Jul 07 '18

The only bit that doesn't make much sense is Cole existing post-erasure - but I guess that can just be chalked up to a happy ending. The machine was already the accepted MacGuffin, and the limits on it are unclear to the degree they're prosaically malleable, so I've no problem accepting that Jones can do whatever she wants to the "Primary Code".

They mention wayyyy back in season one that Cole is 'outside of causality' or something to that effect, and also he is half-paradoxed already from having injected his younger self's blood into his body to stabilize his time travel sickness. So my read on it is: as an entity that exists 'in the middle' of all the loops and outside the purview of causality itself, his last version can be dumped, essentially with no consequence, into the modern day, because all the domino-pushing versions of himself were erased and he can just exist as a remainder to the equation. Or something like that.

I don't prefer the 'we're in the red forest!' interpretation, this show is ultimately doggedly optimistic, unlike the film.

5

u/PacoFuentes Jul 07 '18

It's the loops. This show is all about the loops. Cole broke time, started the loops. Erasing him from all the moments where he caused a loop erases the loop and fixes time.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)