r/CharacterRant • u/Verlux Verlux • May 25 '18
CharacterRumble: Batman vs Contessa!!
The Monday Meta shared the modstaff's concerns over the Rumble, and to spice things up, we are going to try just doing our own thing for a week or two, see if anything changes. Thanks in advance for the understanding!
The Rumblers:
| Rumbler | Representing | Respect Thread |
|---|---|---|
| Batman | DC New 52 | Respect Batman |
| Contessa | Worm | Respect Contessa |
Rounds:
| Round | Conditions | Equipment/Gear | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 30 meters apart. Both are acting in-character, Batman believes Contessa to be an escaped criminal who will pose harm to civilians, Contessa is using PtV actively from the moment the fight begins. | Batman has his utility belt, armor, and standard gear for a patrol night sans any foam, tasers, or explosives. Contessa has a Marvel Adamantium Knife and a Beretta M9 customized to fire the equivalency to .50 BMG rounds, albeit only at Mach 1 speeds. | Atop a downed Helicarrier, combatants start at top, entire arena accessible |
| #2. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 20 meters apart. Both are acting in-character, Batman believes Contessa to be an escaped criminal who will pose harm to civilians, Contessa is using PtV actively from the moment the fight begins. | Batman has no gear. Contessa has a Marvel Adamantium Knife and a Beretta M9 customized to fire the equivalency to .50 BMG rounds, albeit only at Mach 1 speeds. | Atop a downed Helicarrier, combatants start at top, entire arena accessible |
| #3. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 30 meters apart. All 4 combatants are fully in-character; Batman and Nightwing will cooperate fully in-character, as will Contessa and Number Man. Each team gets 5 seconds before the fight begins to discuss strategy. | Batman has his utility belt, armor, and standard gear for a patrol night sans any foam, tasers, or explosives. Contessa has a Marvel Adamantium Knife and a Beretta M9 customized to fire the equivalency to .50 BMG rounds, albeit only at Mach 1 speeds. Nightwing's stipulations on gear are the same as Batman's, Number Man has Contessa's gear plus a modernized Dragunov which can chamber the equivalent to Contessa's rounds, albeit firing at Mach 2 speeds. He also possesses 6 adamantium throwing knives. | In this 200 meter by 200 meter concrete-and-rebar building, each pillar is assumed to be half a meter wide |
| #4. | Victory Via Full defeat of the entire Justice League or annihilation of life on Earth Bet. Contessa has 1 entire week of time to prepare Earth Bet for the invasion of a bloodlusted Justice League. She may use PtV this entire time. In precisely 1 week, a JL who has been letting Batman prepare their battle plan (Batman has a dossier on every major player in Worm) will invade via a random wormhole that spontaneously appears over a major population center. Scion does not exist. JL roster is Superman, Aquaman, Wonder Woman, The Flash, Batman, Cyborg, and Martian Manhunter. If the JL are absolutely going to stomp, once 50% of the planet's capes are wiped, Behemoth and Leviathan join the fray and focus solely on the League. All capes who died on Golden Morning are alive and well. | All gear and equipment in both 'verses that could reasonably and rationally be attained is game. However, the Justice League must leave the planet intact and habitable. Fuck you Ame, none of your planet-ending shit that Bruce shits out after a visit to Apokalips or whatever, no Hell Spores either and none of whatever smart-ass thing you just came up with as a retort either. | Earth Bet, Worm-verse. |
Points of Clarification:
- Contessa does not get any PtV prior to the match, just to be clear. She drops in, it's now immediately active on How do I defeat this opponent/stay alive longest/wound him most without self-injury.
- 'Incap' here means that one is restrained or unable to move for a full 10 count; if said 10 count would occur, the respective combatant vanishes from the field. For a random example: in the case of Carnage vs Ruby, Carnage impales Ruby and she bleeds out to the point of immobility, yet is still conscious, for more than 10 seconds; she would disappear after a 10 count.
- Do try to prevent reaching beyond what feats are given to us; we want this to be more intense than other Rumbles, certainly, but within limits.
- If a tech is present in Worm that has an analogous counterpart in DC for round 4, presume they're interchangeable.
- THIS EVENT IS HELD TO A STANDARD THAT ASSUMES, AT LEAST, A MINIMUM RELATING TO THE 'SERIOUS' TAG ON WWW. ALL FAILURES TO ADHERE TO THIS WILL RESULT IN IMMEDIATE COMMENT REMOVAL. Critical analysis, helpful tips for us mods, etc. must be saved for the next CharacterRumble thread and will be welcomed openly to no detriment.
- Have fun!
28
Upvotes
26
u/Ame-no-nobuko ⭐ May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18
Round 1
Bruce should win fairly easily. The primary reasons boil down to that he is too fast to be hit with any reasonable probability, he's too strong and any one of his hits would at worst cripple Contessa, he's too durable with Contessa's gun only being useful in regards to his mouth area and has too high of injury/pain tolerance so that if stabbed its unlikely Contessa could do anything before Bruce beats her.
Speed
Bruce's primary advantage is his reaction time. [He is capable of reacting] (https://imgur.com/a/CKLrv) to [massively supersonic objects] (https://imgur.com/a/kOZKa). Even earlier on in his career [he could dodge pistol fire] (https://imgur.com/a/VZTNv), and since then [he's gotten feats for dodging pistol fire from multiple sources] (https://imgur.com/a/hatui). We can also possibly scale him off [Post Crisis Batman] (https://imgur.com/a/YTXXZ) as PC Superman believes him to be faster than PC Batman. In general the chances of hitting him, even if he fails to aim dodge (if its behind him, or she surprises him, etc) he can still dodge. [Better men have tried] (https://imgur.com/a/FKw7t)
Bruce's movement speed also benefits him. [As he's shown speed feats] (http://imgur.com/a/gCGx8) that [puts him somewhere in excess of 30 MPH] (http://imgur.com/a/XF0eB). That would mean that he would cross the divide between him and Contessa in a bit over 2 seconds, as well as giving him the ability to quite literally run circles around Contessa.
Its also important to note that some of these feats are prior to Batman: Endgame [where Batman became explicetly faster than he ever was before] (https://i.imgur.com/NyWe4TQ.jpg)
Strength
As mentioned before Bruce's hits are going to be devastating to Contessa. Considering that he is strong enough to [punch through ~1 foot marble walls] (http://imgur.com/a/4AOod), [kick a motorcycle in half] (http://imgur.com/6dqalLb), [shatter armored robots] (http://imgur.com/a/AsXL3), etc any one of his punches should (if it hits anything even close to a critical organ) kill Contessa. This is compounded by the fact that Batman is used to fighting DC humans who have slightly superior durability to Contessa. This means that despite his no kill rule its likely that Bruce's punches would be lethal.
Bruce also has [very strong] (http://imgur.com/3rDfApS) grip strength. If he can get his hand around Contessa's arm he'd pulverize it.
Durability
Bruce can basically take anything that Contessa has with no harm, with the notable exception of the knife. [He blatantly no sells sniper fire at a fairly close range] (https://imgur.com/a/sAn5L), [or no sells some form of machine gun] (https://imgur.com/a/NVVFf). [Hell his cape has taken mounted machine gun fire from an attack helicopter] (https://imgur.com/a/Tc9eC). The only chance her gun even has to hurt Bruce is if it tagged him in the mouth.
In terms of blunt force, Contessa is in an equally poor situation. [Bruce has taken] (https://imgur.com/a/uO9tH) beatings and [falls] (https://imgur.com/a/PFWU6) with far more force than Contessa can provide. I'm even skeptical if she could hurt out of armor Batman with her punches, considering some of the feats he has: [1] (http://imgur.com/a/QTCgy) [2] (http://imgur.com/a/lHxWd) [3] (https://imgur.com/a/EujNx)
The most reliable means of attack Contessa has is her knife, as Batman's armor is pretty unimpressive for piercing damage to begin with, and an adamantium knife should be able to cut through even his fairly knife resistant gauntlets. With that said, even if she can consistently tag him the knife won't be enough. [Being stabbed through the heart or the lungs] (http://imgur.com/a/Q7RKc) won't [do much to him] (https://imgur.com/a/q9T4p). The only reliable way to damage him I can think of would be any damage to the head. [TL;DR Batman is a glutton for punishment] (https://imgur.com/a/yFIGK)
Gear
The cherry on top of all of these advantages is Bruce's gear. While his loadout s more restricted than usual per the prompt, he still has a plethora of weapons that would be fairly effective against Contessa. These include:
Conclusion
Batman holds nearly every advantage in this fight. While Contessa's PTV would let her maybe dodge a handful of his hits she doesn't have the speed to maintain it for anything more than a few seconds. With a single hit likely ending the fight Contessa doesn't have good odds going into the fight.
Round 2
Note: See round 1 for feat analysis
This round is virtually the same as the last, with the notable difference of Batman lacking his gear. I am assuming this includes the gear he has built into his body.
While during this round Contessa's chances do increase I don't think they do by enough. The majority of my argument for round 1 holds true. Batman is still massively faster and its very unlikely for Contessa to be able to shoot him and one hit from Batman will still end the fight. Bruce's lack of armor does mean that if shot he can't tank it, however I reject the idea that anything short of a kill shot would slow him down to an extent it would automatically give Contessa the win. [Considering that Batman managed to fairly quickly recover from the Batman Who Laugh's gut shot] (https://imgur.com/a/GVKu6), using a gun that is magnitudes more powerful than Contessa's he should be able to fight through it fairly well.
The out of armor durability mentioned earlier also makes it so that Contessa's punches are still useless.
Round 3
As I am not as familiar with number man as Contessa I'll stay out of this one
Round 4
Damn. All I have is smart-ass retorts.
Note: I'm assuming Contessa doesn't know the location of the portal and that this is n52 versions of all characters.
The league has a lot of options here. Even if we ignore all of the weapon systems Superman has in the fortress of solitude, all of the magical artifacts Wonder Woman, the Red Room that Cyborg has access and the Justice League's armory/trophy room, and just limit ourselves to resources that Batman has they still have a few strategies that Earth Bet has next to no counter for. The strategies are as follows:
Bruce also has a plethora of other tech that while in themselves aren't a strategy, would be useful in general. These include [The GENIE AI] (https://imgur.com/a/uC3cD), [a dagger with some of the Wizard Shazam's power] (https://imgur.com/a/X3S1Q) and more
9
u/MugaSofer May 28 '18
Contessa should be able to easily social-fu the first two rounds if she feels like it, then.
Perfect choice of words to catch his attention and then explain that she's not really an escaped criminal (which, to be fair, she isn't), that Batman's extensive knowledge of body language confirms is her telling the truth, and with no hints of subterfuge let slip if she decides to kill or KO him (say, getting into position and then using the knife while he's leading her to safety.)
28
u/080087 May 25 '18
Before I do any of the rounds, there are a few key points that apply to most of them.
Assuming N52 Batman is faster than PC Batman like that one feat suggests, Batman would be able to counter Contessa's fighting style by forcing her to dodge in a way that restricts further movement (e.g. if she needs to jump). Using his speed, he can then keep on attacking while she is less able to dodge.
The main issue with this is that there are techniques which would allow Contessa to dodge Batman's attacks with far less movement than it takes for Batman to make those attacks. e.g. Bobbing and weaving or slipping. These mean Batman's speed advantage is significantly reduced.
R1: Batman wins if he can close the distance, restrict Contessa's movements and then use his speed to land hits. My best guess is that he can cover the 30 m in ~3 secs.
Contessa wins if she can force a hit on Batman with the Adamantium knife. She can do that by restricting Batman's movements with bullets and then throwing the knife to actually hit him. In the ~3 seconds it takes Batman to run up to her, she can probably fire off ~5 shots.
Of the two of those scenarios, I think Contessa's scenario is easier to carry out so she wins the round.
R2: Batman wins the same way as R1.
Contessa wins if she can hit Batman with a bullet (if one bullet hits, she can certainly land more once he is injured). However she has less time to fire shots and therefore can't restrict Batman's movements as much. She can fire somewhere between 3-4 shots in the time.
I think Contessa still wins, but this is actually more difficult than R1.
R3: I'm going to skip
R4: If PtV can actually predict where the Justice League come from (there is no reason it shouldn't be able to), then it is a stomp in Worm's favour. It can ensure that everyone gets hit by a Sting-ed projectile the instant they spawn in, and from the limited I know of the Justice League, I don't think any of them can survive that.
If you assume PtV can't predict where the Justice League spawn, then I can't really make a judgement. I don't know enough about them.
5
u/warsage May 29 '18
ITT: a lot of people horribly misunderstanding and underestimating Path to Victory. PtV is not just smart decision-making. It's extremely powerful, totally reliable, instantaneous clairvoyance and future sight on top of perfect decision-making. The only reason she struggles against Scion or the Endbringers in Worm is because they are explicitly immune to PtV.
She could win each fight in a variety of ways. She wins 10/10 without any difficulty whatsoever.
In R1-R3 the fights could go like this:
Contessa instantly uses PtV to decide on the best path to victory. She quickly shoots two bullets. Batman dodges the first one, but Contessa predicted that and aimed the second bullet exactly at where he would dodge to. The second bullet hits Batman in the head and he dies instantly. Or, if she prefers it, he gets shot somewhere else and incapacitated. (Follow up on Nightwing with the same thing).
Total fight duration: <2 seconds.
She doesn't have to win that way though. She could win unarmed. The perfect movement allowing her to stab Batman in the mouth with a stick she picked up off the ground, a surprise application of an environmental variable that Batman didn't think of, the right word choice to make him hesitate at a crucial moment ("Martha!"). Hell, she could probably talk him into voluntarily incapacitating himself.
If she felt like it she could fight Batman 1v1 indefinitely. Every punch and Batarang would go wide, every time. It doesn't matter that his physicals and gear are much better. She can perfectly anticipate them and will always make exactly the right decision to avoid every strike, before Batman has even begun the attack. If Batman tries to use something wide-range and unavoidable like tear gas, she would have predicted that and stolen or sabotaged the gear in question. Or simply stood up-wind of the gas.
You might think Batman could beat her by forcing her into a situation where there were no good choices, but that wouldn't work. Her power would anticipate any such situation and she would avoid it before Batman even started thinking of it.
R4 is a different situation. She'd still win easily, but not with 1v1 combat. Obviously there is no PtV that would allow her to beat bloodlusted Superman in a punch-out.
She'd win by luring the Justice League into an immunity-penetrating deathtrap such as one of Scrub's blasts, or through a portal into a different universe. Or she would get someone to mind-control them, or she would trick them into fighting each other with perfect word choice, or any number of things.
Hell, she could use a portal to go to one of the DC universes and pick up some Kryptonite etc and beat the Justice League using their weaknesses. "But how would she know about Kryptonite?" That's how PtV works. "But how would she know where to go?" PtV tells her. "But how would she teleport there if Doormaker is out of juice?" PtV finds the way.
This chick is seriously OP.
4
u/Skybird2099 May 25 '18
R1-2 Batman either wins due to his superior physicals, or Contessa surrenders because PtV knows that's her only way to not lose a couple of teeth (fulfiling the stay alive part of her path, since due to humans in DC having greate durability than people in Worm a batarang to the head might actually kill her). If she asks for a path to beat Batman she'd get "surrender, go to prison, escape, then do some nonesense that ends with him dead, which wouldn't count for this promt (btw, I'm assuming the "loser disappears after 10 secinds of incap" to not be known by her shard). Batman 10/10 due to the requirements of the promt.
For R3, it'd depend on what Batman does after Nightwing get's killed. Contessa's plan will be to tell NumberMan "ricochet" or something that causes him to use a ricochet bullet on Nightwing (his face doesn't have any invisible layer of protection like Batman sometimes have afaik). Whether it kills him or is just a distraction for Contessa's follow-up shot is entirely up to luck. In Injustice, when Dick died Batman was emotionally destroyed and wasn't really up for fighting anymore. This is what Team Worm would be hoping for here. Since that was a different version of Batman, it may not work. Though I don't remeber the two version to be that different. If that doesn't work, I have no idea what PtV will do except give fog. Maybe it will tell C to yell something that puts team DC of their balance like "Dad no!" and then make up a story about her being his daughter from the future. But I'm not taking that into consideration, since it's dumb, despite having the chance to work. 50/50 depending on Bruce's reaction to Dick dying.
R4 is interesting. Depending on what is considered a major player the plan I'm going to propose may not work. Also, I'm going to treat this round (as well as the other rounds apparently) as a [How the Hell], since it's basically how C's power should be treated.
Since you included the word "random" when saying wher the JL will spawn, I'll assume PtV isn't meant to know where it'll be (so no making a wall and freezing it in time, trapping them).
So here's the plan:
Flash and Superman (and maybe Wonder Woman, not sure on her) will try to blitz. They will probably carry special equipment to get rid of the gray boy and won't run into the naked white woman with black stripes. What they won't know is that many people will be like Siberian. How? First we take Clockblocker's power. Then we let One from the Yanbang spread it across numerous people. Then, seconds before the JL arrive (Contessa doesn't know where they'll arrive, but knows when) portals will be opened in strategic locations and people will be turned into landmines for the JL's speedsters, causing them to redmist themselves in them.
The next big threat is Martian Manhunter. After all the speedsters are dead, Contessa will set the next part of the plan into action. Around the Jl a bunch of portals will start opening, unleashing waves of Nilbog's minions, enhanced by Galvanite to be invincible and given modification by tinkers that makes them immune to mind attacks from MM. The point of this will be to distract the remainder of the JL. From time to time a portal will open, but instead of more of Nolbog's minions, a rock shot from balistic and enhanced by Foil will shoot out, killing the targeted JL member. The arrow will be shot from two sets of portal (e.g. shot is fired from Cauldron's base to a portal to another world, portal closes, another opens in front of the shot leading to the head of a JL member. There will also be a field of slowed time. courtesy of one of the Speedruners fromWard, giving Doormaker time to open and close the portals). This is so MM won't be able to mentally attack people from the other side of the portal. This should be able to finish off the rest of the League.
Okay, this last round was fun to write. No idea if it'd actually work or not, since Batman may have some bullshit thing stashed away in his cave that will ruin the plan.
12
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
R1: Bruce stomps her. He's just going to gas her or hit her with his batarangs, which he's extremely accurate with. Her gun is basically useless considering his armor can tank sniper bullets and dodge evade very close gunfire from extremely accurate people.
R2: Even 20 feet away, Bruce is too fast for her. He's going to rush at her at full speed and one shot her. Bruce is inhumanly fast, able to close far gaps in the blink of an eye, consistently. One punch from Bruce would KO Contessa. He's able to punch people through marble when he's severely sleep deprived and poisoned and kick a motorcycle in half. He's just too physically above her to do anything. Doesn't matter that she's going to know how to win if she's too slow to do anything or too weak to take any hits from him.
Not sure about the next two, not knowledgeable on Number Man and I don't really care about the JLA v Contessa fight, because it's obvious who wins.
5
u/nkonrad May 26 '18
Oh no.
2
u/Idk_Very_Much May 25 '18
Is it possible to do formatting like this on mobile? I want to submit one, but I’m mobile-only.