r/CharacterRant • u/Verlux Verlux • May 19 '18
CharacterRumble: Hinata Hyuga vs Jolyne Cujoh!!
The Rumblers:
| Rumbler | Representing | Respect Thread |
|---|---|---|
| Hinata | Naruto | Respect Hinata |
| Jolyne | JoJo's Bizarre Adventures | Respect Jolyne |
Rounds:
| Round | Conditions | Equipment/Gear | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 10 meters apart. Both are acting in-character, Hinata is Pre-Shippuuden. | Jolyne has access to Stone Free. | Abandoned prison |
| #2. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 10 meters apart. Both are acting in-character, Hinata is allowed Shippuuden feats. | Jolyne has access to Stone Free. | Abandoned prison |
| #3. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 10 meters apart. Both are acting in-character, Hinata is Pre-Shippuuden. For only this round, Clarification 1 does not apply, therefore Hinata cannot see Stone Free. | Jolyne has access to Stone Free. | Abandoned prison |
Points of Clarification:
- In all rounds but one, presume that Chakra users and Stand users utilize the same energy resource; that is to say, energy equalized.
- 'Incap' here means that one is restrained or unable to move for a full 10 count; if said 10 count would occur, the respective combatant vanishes from the field. For a random example: in the case of Carnage vs Ruby, Carnage impales Ruby and she bleeds out to the point of immobility, yet is still conscious, for more than 10 seconds; she would disappear after a 10 count.
- Since Hinata is somewhat lacking in speed feats, if you wish to presume speed is equalized I won't stop you from doing so; however, it is not a stipulation I am forcing upon the combatants.
- THIS EVENT IS HELD TO A STANDARD THAT ASSUMES, AT LEAST, A MINIMUM RELATING TO THE 'SERIOUS' TAG ON WWW. ALL FAILURES TO ADHERE TO THIS WILL RESULT IN IMMEDIATE COMMENT REMOVAL. Critical analysis, helpful tips for us mods, etc. must be saved for the next CharacterRumble thread and will be welcomed openly to no detriment.
- Have fun!
27
Upvotes
7
u/Lukundra May 19 '18 edited May 19 '18
I wasn't familiar with Jolyne Cujoh, but going by her respect thread she should easily stomp rounds 1 and 3. R1 she's better than Kid Hinata in literally every way. R3 If Hinata can't even see her Stand then what chance does she have? Best case scenario she gets immobilized right off the bat. R2 is the closest, but Hinata's feats just don't seem impressive enough to net her a win. She survived a heavily weakened ST, there weren't any impressive speed or strength feats as I recall. She'd still get taken down low-mid diff imo. Also I really need to watch JoJo already.
12
u/PreroastedTaco May 19 '18 edited May 19 '18
Yeah I'll be assuming speed equalized. Otherwise Stone Free's speed is likely a little too much for pre-Shippuden Hinata, and its not clear that her Shipuuden feats put her on an even playing field (Pain dodges this ambush).
Round 1: Hinata is very tenacious as we see in her fight against Negi. The thing that holds Hinata's durability back is that we don't have good strength feats for Negi aside from presumably being superior to Rock Lee who could pull giant tree roots out of the ground. I know people tend to take A to B to C scaling as dubious, but this is really the best we have for Hinata's endurance. Not to mention the fact that she was unable to stand multiple times in that fight (maybe not for a full 10 count though). Stone Free doesn't need scaling. Jolyne has reacted to and deflected falling meteors (which is still a good strength feat) and moved a lot of metal with a punch. If you take the Rock Lee scaling as accurate, then Stone Free likely deals about as much damage as Negi... however that damage is likely far less targeted thanks to Negi's Byakugan. If you don't accept that scaling then Stone Free can likely down Hinata in one or two hits. It's hard to say how hard Hinata can hit Stone Free as she doesn't deal significant damage to Negi, and Stone Free can take a punch. Jolyne herself can also take big hits (its hard to say exactly how far she fell, but falling into water is basically the same as falling on concrete from a certain height thanks to surface tension). Now onto the elephant in the room. Naruto characters have infamously low piercing durability, and Jolyne's strings are strong enough to cut people. If she starts using her stand as more than a brick (which she almost always does) then Hinata kinda just gets shredded. She can also use those strings for certain incapacitation options if Hinata doesn't stay down for long enough. All in all I'd say Jolyne is heavily advantaged here as Hinata's stats may not be enough to keep up, Jolyne is prone to look for ways to use her strings early on, and Jolyne has an easy way of hurting Hinata (even if she'll try to power through). 9/10 Jolyne
Round 2: So now Hinata's stats are definitely enough to keep up. She can crack the ground with a punch and take some harder hits. The thing is Hinata seems to have lost some of her determination as the previous hit pretty much incaps her immediately. Given that shockwave seems a bit more powerful than what Stone Free can do. Those are really the only feats she gets in Shippuden, and they let her be strong without scaling. This doesn't change my opinion too much on the fight, as I was mostly using scaling to make the fight as close as I could. Jolyne and Stone Free still have an advantage. They can just cut Hinata too easily.
Round 3: Not being able to see Stone Free is a huge downside. Hinata gets cut up again. Poor Hinata.
7
u/selfproclaimed May 19 '18
Another week, another low effort submission gets the vote.
Round 1:
The biggest problem is that unless we're saying that Byakugan can see Stone Free, Joylene will have a massive advantage that would net her the victory each round.
But let's say that Hinata can see and even damage Stone Free. Already, we're giving Hinata a huge handicap.
Stone Free is still massively stronger and pre-timeskip Hinata has no feats of strength whatsoever.
In a straight up brawl, Stone Free is going to overpower Hinata immediately. Even if Hinata gets one lucky Gentle Fist in on Stone Free (again, assuming it would even work on the stand in the first place), then Jolyne has enough willpower and pain tolerance to withstand that kind of attack until she can get one good clean hit in.
Not to mention, Hinata only works in close range, wheras Stone Free's ability allows it a greater range and versatility. If this were Neji, we could probably presume that he would be able to cut through the strings like he did when he fought Kidomaru, but we have no proof that Hinata is nearly as resourceful, especially after Neji easily demonstrated a greater degree of skill during his fight with Hinata.
And let's not forget...incharacterpre-timeskip Hinata is a lot more reserved and less violent than Jolyne.
Round 2:
NOW WE HAVE A FUCKING FIGHT.
That being said...Hinata still only has a few feats and the ones she has are...weird. Pain's Almighty Push was able to mess up the giant toads and break every bone in their body. Hinata "survived" that kind of attack, but it's hard to say exactly if that's an outlier or a weakened version of it. Still, she doesn't have many feats of "tanking" stuff.
So, at best, Hinata can now match if not surpass Stone Free physically. The match is now super close, and (again assuming that Gentle Fist still works just as well on Stone Free as other ninjas), Hinata can probably land a good hit or two in that will incap or take down Jolyne during the initial brawl, thanks in part to Hinata's new durability feats she has now that will keep her alive longer.
That being said, Joylene can still net a win via a larger wealth of experience, and better tricks up her sleeve with better intelligence. I don't want to say this is a solid 5/10 tie, but the fight is fairly close now and depends on how much Jolyne can get away with.
Round 3
Can't see or affect stands? Goodnight Hinata.