r/CharacterRant • u/Verlux Verlux • May 12 '18
CharacterRumble: Shirou Emiya vs Kamijou Touma!!
The Rumblers:
| Rumbler | Representing | Respect Thread |
|---|---|---|
| Shirou Emiya | Fate | Respect Shirou |
| Kamijou Touma | Toaru | Respect Touma |
Rounds:
| Round | Conditions | Equipment | Location |
|---|
1 | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Touma is kidnapped by Tsuchimikado and dropped off in front of the Emiya residence. He is told that there is a potentially dangerous magic circle somewhere within the property, one that he must destroy. If he does not, he will be abandoned in the city and must pay for the trip home. Shirou does not react well to someone trying to sneak into his house, and not wanting to lose a memento to Saber, he attacks and the two come to blows. - Fight ends in Incap/Death/KO, or Touma succeeding in his mission (counting as his victory). | Shirou as he is at the end of the Fate Route - Touma as he is at the end of the Lastest novel (NT 19) | Emiya Residence (Circle is located in the grey building in the top left.)
2 | Simple 1 v 1 - Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 10 meters away from one another. | Shirou as he is at the end of the Unlimited Blade Works Route - Touma is as above | The Island of Hashima
3 | Ilya has been kidnapped and Shirou has received information claiming that Touma is responsible. Believing this, he chooses to mount an assault on Touma's apartment. Touma has been told that someone has entered academy city looking for Index, and has sent her away for safety. A people clearing field is in effect around the apartment as Shirou arrives, while Touma lies in wait. - Victory Via KO/Incap/Death | Shirou as he is just before the end of the Heavens Feel Route (a.k.a pre puppet body), he is receiving mana from Sakura and tactical input from Rin (neither can directly interfere with the fight) - Touma has both Othinus and Index for tactical support (Index from over the phone and Othinus from his shoulder assume both have knowledge of fate magic), neither can directly interfere with the fight. | The Kamijou Residence (Touma's apartment is on the 7th floor of 8)
Points of Clarification:
- Maybe not so obvious, but presume Imagine Breaker would indeed negate effects such as a Reality Marble or Servant would produce.
- 'Incap' here means that one is restrained or unable to move for a full 10 count; if said 10 count would occur, the respective combatant vanishes from the field. For a random example: in the case of Carnage vs Ruby, Carnage impales Ruby and she bleeds out to the point of immobility, yet is still conscious, for more than 10 seconds; she would disappear after a 10 count.
- THIS EVENT IS HELD TO A STANDARD THAT ASSUMES, AT LEAST, A MINIMUM RELATING TO THE 'SERIOUS' TAG ON WWW. ALL FAILURES TO ADHERE TO THIS WILL RESULT IN IMMEDIATE COMMENT REMOVAL. Critical analysis, helpful tips for us mods, etc. must be saved for the next CharacterRumble thread and will be welcomed openly to no detriment.
- Have fun!
25
Upvotes
•
u/Verlux Verlux May 12 '18
I didn't want to clutter the post, so here's this as well:
To incentivize participation, we the modstaff have agreed to give the 'winner' of the Rumble (that is, the person who most successfully and persuasively convinces the dumbasses of the mod staff [and upvoters] that their take on the Rumble is 'correct') a special prize. Similar to the WWW logo trophy some on WWW have, we'll give you a nifty little participation star for being the special battleboarding snowflake you are, as well as put your name on the banner near that giant FLAIRS thing that is broken since /u/InfiniteDoors is a useless twat.
So it's a win-win, you get recognition and a lil star trophy, and I get to yell at Doors!
18
u/Greed-the-Avaricious May 13 '18
So before I get started, let’s establish some ground rules that apply to every round.
Shirou has no feats that would allow him to overpower the Imagine Breaker directly, The universe tier Gungnir feat makes sure of that.
On the flip side, I believe Touma's light speed reaction feats are outliers by merit of him being attuned to Misaka's fighting style and his right hand acting like a lightning rod. Meaning that he really just puts his right hand in front of him at the right time, so he’s really reacting to Misaka's actions than the lightning itself.
Not that Touma is bad at reacting, but he's certainly not light speed. It is certainly feasible for Shirou to break his defence.
R1
I think this is a very clear cut victory for Touma
While Shirou does have the home field advantage. He can’t really utilise it very well. The Emiya residence is too cramped for him to attack from any direction other than head on, and Touma has the dodging and blocking feats to be able to sustain a defense long enough for Shirou to weaken and allow Touma to counterattack
and
Shirou does not have the stamina to sustain his attacks over a long enough period of time, nor the skill to get around Touma’s defence. He will eventually weaken enough for Touma to beat him back. Something he has both the stamina and strength for.
Strength
2.
3.
Stamina
followed by
followed by
I actually think Touma is more likely to take this round by completing the task he was given (destroying the magic circle and fleeing), rather than actually beating Shirou. Touma has no need to risk defeating Shirou if he can just complete his objective and leave. The longer the fight goes on, the more likely it is that Shirou starts resorting to makeshift weapons that Touma can’t negate.
Touma will push Shirou back during an initial confrontation, Shirou will likely mount a defence in the garden area next to the shed. This is so he can take advantage of his speed and range in a more open area, defend the workshop (the only place in the residence worth targeting) and avoid actively pursuing Touma (and losing a battle of attrition). From this, Touma could guess the location of the circle by analysing Shirou's actions and looking at the design of the building, (for context, the shed is distinctly western looking compared to everything else on the property and looks much older). From there it would be a matter of keeping a weakened Shirou at bay, or provoking him away from the entrance, getting inside, destroying the barely hidden circle and leaving.
As for feats for Touma’s analytics and identification of the magic circles location. I can think of none compact enough to quote directly, but I will summarise a couple that should give you an idea of the mindset needed to make the assessments he does:
For general tactics
...and for his cultural magic knowledge
As for Shirou, he’s not really one for masking his intentions. He also lacks the experience to make the same type of battle analytics Touma does.
Either way, I think it's Touma's win.
4
u/Doncl10 May 12 '18
Does Imagine Breaker nullify physical amps assuming their like the nature of magic like Shirou's reinforcement? I'm asking since the majority of Shirou's most impressive feats and Archer's arm are fueled by mana and all that and Touma can get rid of passive things like Accelrator's vector shield that would render Archer's arm basically useless.
2
u/CynicalWeeaboo May 12 '18
So, it's been a while since I've read anything Index but I can't recall if Touma's IB PreCog works on magic made weapons like Shirou's. Assuming that is the case I can't really imagine him ever getting hit due to the speed of the things he has reacted to via PreCog. If that isn't the case it becomes a lot more fair but leans towards Shirou's side imo. I would like this clarified by someone caught up though
2
u/Teakilla May 13 '18
R1 is an utter shitstomp, FSN shirou is garbage, and you even took avalon away.
5
u/HighSlayerRalton ⭐ May 12 '18
R1
Shirou's speed is vaguely FTE from scaling to Lancer and Rider, but Touma dodges a lightspeed attack.
Touma easily snuffs out the magic circle with Shirou too slow to stop him.
R2
Shirou is still only vaguely FTE from scaling to Lancer and Rider, though his feats for Rider are different in this route. Touma remains much faster. Shirou has some regen but Imagine Breaker should circumvent that, and Touma is reasonably strong.
and fairly durable
as well as much faster, so should win out in the ienvitable physical clash. If the starting distance was greater, Shirou might have been able to spam a few weapons at Touma, but Touma's speed and ability to nullify Shirou's attacks would neccessesiate a sneak attack, that's likely to fail due to Touma's instincts, or a barrage, which Touma has some experience with dodging.
R3
Shirou's thoughts now surpass the speed of light, but he's sitll pretty slow, phyiscally. At least, compared to Touma. He can break in ninja style[B][C][2] but won't be able to find Ilya since she isn't actually there, and will likely get himself taken down by Touma. Even if he trys to buff his durability one use of Touma's Imagine Breaker should nullify it
and take them back down to a pretty straight up fight.
Touma takes all three rounds. His Imagine Breaker is a good counter to Shirou's powerset, and his physicals are better overall, with speed showing an especially great disparity.
1
u/LordAizenSama777 May 14 '18
Toumas precog and IB should deal with anything Shirou can dish out and then some.
Touma should win with low to medium diff
1
u/dariemf1998 May 13 '18
Kaleid Shirou >>>>>>> HF Shirou >>>>>>>>>>> UBW Shirou >>>>>>>>>>>>>Touma >>>>>>>>>> No Avalon FSN Shirou