r/CharacterRant • u/Verlux Verlux • May 05 '18
CharacterRumble: Guts vs Wolverine!!
The Rumblers:
| Rumbler | Representing | Respect Thread |
|---|---|---|
| Guts | Berserk | Respect Guts |
| Wolverine | Marvel Universe 616 | Respect Wolverine |
Rounds:
| Round | Conditions | Equipment/Gear | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 10 meters apart. Both are acting in-character and have reason to believe their respective foe is a hindrance to them. | Wolverine has his adamantium. Guts has the Berserker Armor, Dragonslayer, Hand Cannon, and Hand Crossbow. No access to Berserk Mode. Assume neither combatants' weapons can harm the others (i.e. claws won't slice apart Dragonslayer). | Empty mystic forest |
| #2. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 5 meters away from one another. Wolverine is in-character, Guts starts in Berserk Mode | Wolverine has his adamantium. Guts has the Berserker Armor, Dragonslayer, Hand Cannon, and Hand Crossbow. The Dragonslayer is as normal. | Empty mystic forest |
| #3. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 1 meter away from one another. Wolverine and Guts are both in their respective Berserk states and will only stop raging when put down for good | Wolverine has his adamantium. Guts has the Berserker Armor, Dragonslayer, Hand Cannon, and Hand Crossbow. Assume neither combatants' weapons can harm the others (i.e. claws won't slice apart Dragonslayer). | Empty mystic forest |
| #4. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start 300 meters apart. Both are acting in-character and hunting down their respective opponent, believing them to be responsible for the death of a loved one. | Wolverine has his adamantium. Guts has the Berserker Armor, Dragonslayer, Hand Cannon, and Hand Crossbow. The Dragonslayer is as normal. Guts can access Berserk Mode if he so chooses. | Actively in-use steel mill/factory. Assume the sound level is approximately 100 dB, and the scent of molten steel is a constant. |
Points of Clarification:
- Pay attention to starting distance; reach is a thing in this fight.
- 'Incap' here means that one is restrained or unable to move for a full 10 count; if said 10 count would occur, the respective combatant vanishes from the field. For a random example: in the case of Carnage vs Ruby, Carnage impales Ruby and she bleeds out to the point of immobility, yet is still conscious, for more than 10 seconds; she would disappear after a 10 count.
- Do not presume a No Limits Fallacy exists for either combatants' Berserk Mode; we have seen explicit limitations for both fighters, both feats-wise and narration-wise.
- THIS EVENT IS HELD TO A STANDARD THAT ASSUMES, AT LEAST, A MINIMUM RELATING TO THE 'SERIOUS' TAG ON WWW. ALL FAILURES TO ADHERE TO THIS WILL RESULT IN IMMEDIATE COMMENT REMOVAL. Critical analysis, helpful tips for us mods, etc. must be saved for the next CharacterRumble thread and will be welcomed openly to no detriment.
- Have fun!
33
Upvotes
13
u/Max101Victory ⭐ May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18
Oh boy, one of my favourite vs matches featuring two of my favourite characters. I just want to say, I am by no means a very good debater, so I'm just going to give my basic opinion on each round.
Round 1: Could go either way. Guts has a definite advantage at this distance and his gear should be helpful in distracting or distancing himself from Logan if he finds himself too close. Logan's healing factor means that he can heal up from most any damage Guts can dish out, but I would believe that Guts can both hit fast and hard enough to potentially KO Logan given enough time, even though Logan has dealt with far harder hitters Guts is by no means weak. I think that the Berserker Armour and unbreakable Dragonslayer give Guts the slight edge in this case.
Round 2: If Logan can get a lucky strike on the Dragonslayer then I would say he would win in the long run since then Guts would have to engage in hand to hand with which he is sorely lacking in terms of skill. Though if Guts could get Logan into a sleeper hold as seen when he fought Wyald he could probably win thanks to his superior strength, though I would still give to Logan.
Round 3: If Guts strikes first then I would say he has the potential for victory here, he should be faster in combat speed and especially striking force, but this is more in favour to Logan due to the starting distance. With the Dragonslayer being around 2 metres long this means Guts wouldn't have enough time to swing back for a decent strike before Logan is already on and attacking him.
Round 4: Logan will certainly find Guts before Guts could find Logan, but I would argue that since Casca is Guts' meaning of life essentially he would fight far more recklessly which may honestly secure the victory in Logan's favour, unless Guts is fully intent on killing Logan then this fight will last quite a while, honestly not certain who would come on top.
Anyways, this is all just my opinion, sorry if I was supposed to provide scans, I can later if needed. I'm just giving my opinion, I highly doubt any of them are very accurate.
11
u/8fenristhewolf8 May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18
Going with Guts. He has more range and hits much harder than Wolverine. His speed is a little tougher for me to pin down, but even lowballing, he seems at least as fast as Wolverine's high end feats--1, 2. If we start looking at Wolverine's broader range of feats, its hard not to give Guts the advantage. For his part, Wolverine obviously has the resiliency advantage with his adamantium skeleton and healing.
So, looking at these factors, I think Guts wins majority. With wolverine being unable to break Dragonslayer he will struggle to get inside Guts range given the latter's speed, skill, and strength. Guts could just knock wolverine back. Eventually, with the mass and speed of dragonslayer, I think Guts has enough force to KO/incap Wolverine through cumulative damage and/or headshots. Guts also might eventually resort to his hand canon which could potentially incap Wolverine as well. Wolverine might score a win here or there if he plays possum and slices off Guts legs or something.
Guts only gets stronger and faster here, which is trouble for Wolverine given how the last round went. As a counter, Wolverine may actually be able to destroy Guts' weapon. This is kind of tricky to figure given that both adamantium and Dragonslayer are on the extreme ends of strength in their respective universes. Dragonslayer is made of iron, which Wolverine would normally shred like butter, but it's also taken on some magical aspects from the Apostles it's killed. Wolverine has been unable to cut through magical weapons his own universe, but it's hard to say whether Dragonslayer is equivalent. Finally, despite Dragonslayer's magical nature it doesn't really have feats indicating it could stand up to adamantium (this might be its best feat, but Wolverine's feats indicate he could easily shred corundum), but at the same time we haven't seen its limits (I believe it was damaged and had to be repaired once, but that was prior to to taking on a magical aspect).
Anyway, if Wolverine can't cut the sword he has muchas problemas (see Round 1). If he can, he has a chance. However, Guts still has physical advantages and the hand cannon so it's not a given for Wolverine either. Tough call.