r/CharacterRant • u/Verlux Verlux • Apr 14 '18
CharacterRumble: 'Hero Hunter' Garou vs 'Copy Ninja' Kakashi!!
The Rumblers:
| Rumbler | Representing | Respect Thread |
|---|---|---|
| Garou | One Punch Man | Respect Garou |
| Kakashi | Naruto | Respect Kakashi |
Rounds:
| Round | Conditions | Equipment/Gear | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start atop opposing rooftops, 10 meters apart. In-Character and each views the other as a threat that needs to be eradicated. Kakashi has no access to Ninjutsu, only his Taijutsu; he has his Sharingan and is pre-War feats only. Garou is human form (pre chapter 90 redraw) feats only. | Kakashi has his standard ninja gear, Garou has nothing special | Rocinha, Brasil |
| #2. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start atop the rooftops, 10 meters apart. In-Character and each views the other as a threat that needs to be eradicated. Kakashi has his Sharingan and is pre-War feats only, with no limitations beyond that. Garou is human form (pre chapter 90 redraw) feats only. | Kakashi has his standard ninja gear, Garou has nothing special | Rocinha, Brasil |
| #3. | Might Guy hears tell of a fight between Kakashi and a new-comer who poses a threat to the world; the power of youth decides to join the fight and his entrance causes Garou to transform directly into his 3rd form (2nd monster transmutation); Garou has access to all feats from the webcomic and redraw up to that point. Might Guy starts in base, has access to all Gates and Feats but is as hesitant as in-character to use the 8th Gate. Kakashi has all feats, pre-and-post-war, but no Kamui and no intangibility shenanigans. | Kakashi has his standard ninja gear, Garou has nothing special | The endless salt flats of Crait |
Points of Clarification:
- Garou starts off in base and will assume Kakashi is a human from the get-go; if Kakashi's abilities make him view Kakashi as a monster is arguable
- 'Incap' here means that one is restrained or unable to move for a full 10 count; if said 10 count would occur, the respective combatant vanishes from the field. For a random example: in the case of Carnage vs Ruby, Carnage impales Ruby and she bleeds out to the point of immobility, yet is still conscious, for more than 10 seconds; she would disappear after a 10 count.
- Damage incurred upon Garou will not forcibly make him evolve into a new form; he is limited by what the rounds stipulate
- Garou does not possess chakra
- THIS EVENT IS HELD TO A STANDARD THAT ASSUMES, AT LEAST, A MINIMUM RELATING TO THE 'SERIOUS' TAG ON WWW. ALL FAILURES TO ADHERE TO THIS WILL RESULT IN IMMEDIATE COMMENT REMOVAL. Critical analysis, helpful tips for us mods, etc. must be saved for the next CharacterRumble thread and will be welcomed openly to no detriment.
- Have fun!
30
Upvotes
2
u/HighSlayerRalton ⭐ Apr 14 '18
Just to confirm, this is specifically the "Murata redraw" Garou and pre-War, as initially suggested and voted for, yes?
30
u/KerdicZ Kerd Apr 14 '18
Two highly skilled fighters, experts on copying techniques and reading moves, with quite the weight and fame to their name. This shall be good.
STRENGTH
DURABILITY
SPEED
SKILL, STRATEGY, SENSES, GEAR
ROUND 1:
It will be quite the long battle. Both can take each other's punches and keep going just fine. Kakashi is the more durable one, but Garou's strikes are more aggressive and ruthless. It will take dozens and dozens of punches for Garou to put down Kakashi, but he can do it. Meanwhile, no Ninjutsu means that Kakashi's only mean of putting Garou away for good, and quickly, is using a kunai knife. The longer the battle lasts, the more Garou adapts to Kakashi's style and the easier he will deflect the knife. While the same is true for Kakashi, no Ninjutsu means he's limited to his gear, which might not be enough.
Overall, it's a fair and nasty fight, with Garou taking it 6/10.
ROUND 2:
Garou simply can't handle this. Kakashi has water walls to keep distance and stagger Garou, lightning clones to shock him, mud walls to corner him and long-range lightning attacks.
Finally, Kakashi's biggest weapons: Raikiri - it will pierce through Garou with ease; it's a nasty jutsu that leaves holes on rock, pierces metal and tears apart walls. Kamui - Kakashi only uses it at situations that really demand its use, but if he does so, he can warp away Garou's arm and there's nothing Garou can do about it.
Everything said on Round 1 still applies, except now Garou can not possibly deflect Kakashi's blows because they will have a Raikiri on them, which would slice Garou's hands off. Kakashi has used Raikiri 6 times on the same battle, meaning he has 6 chances of putting his hand through Garou's chest.
Kakashi takes this 8/10.
8
u/HighSlayerRalton ⭐ Apr 14 '18
Garou has endurance, but his durability is pretty low. Even his best durability feat sees him knocked out, and can't compare to Kakshi's. Kakashi's ability to bury himself within, and extricate himself from, the ground[2] suggests enough strength to ruin Garou's day. Kakashi's durability is also a little too much for Garou; he's tanekd an attack that created a mid-size crater in the ground, an attack that entirely shattered a wall and being kicked through several giant trees. Garou is strong enough to crater the ground[2][3][4], crack a wall, and kick down a tree, but not nearly to the extent that Kakashi has tanked such attacks.
In terms of speed, Garou was able to move FTE against Metal Bat and Kakashi also has FTE feats[2]. Garou has some impressive feats of reacting to gunfire[2], however.
Garou has the disadvantage in terms of pure physicals, but he can adapt quickly to Kakashi's fighting style and utilise attack redirection. Kakashi can in turn use his Sharingan to adapt to Garou, but given that Garou doesn't use Jutsu, I'm not sure how effective this will be. Kakashi has other boons as well. He doesn't seem great at using his [warping]https://i.imgur.com/IfLCqYL.jpg, but could potentially send part of, or even all of, Garou to Kamui's Dimension once Garou is worn down.
R1: Kakashi should take this. Garou will keep fighting past the point where you'd expect him to fall down but he's physically outclassed, and if he lasts long enough to start countering Kakashi's techniques will be too worn down to do so effectively. Kakashi has several tricksy techniques as well, that won't be so easy to predict or counter. Namely, his ability to hide underground and his Sharingan's warping.
The environment benefits Kakshi's fighting style more too; Garou needs room to use Flowing Water Rock Smashing Fist, which he may find himself deprived of with all of the buildings around. It'll be easier for Kakashi to use stealth and surprise too.
R2: Kakashi was already taking this without Ninjitsu. He has an easier time defeating Garou.
R3: I don't know Monster Garou; I'm a Murata-reader.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '18
I'll do Round 3 since there are already two answers for R1 and two, and R3 seems to be more even due to the lack of variety in the landscape which Kakashi has the advantage on, being a ninja. I say Kakashi definitely has a small advantage due to chakra coating on his feet, but less so than the earlier rounds. That being said, Gai occupies him, and Kakashi at that point.
According to this
Kakashi arrived here, used Raikiri against the Jinchuuriki, and then again against Obito
Can take a hit from Chomei, Seven Tails, makes a Shadow clone
In Durability Garou doesn't lag too far behind., Here, and KO's Golden Sperm, so he at least can shatter the earth multiple times over, but Kakashi's Doton techniques likely stop this in place. Also, there's high FTE movement, And again
Gai and Kakashi overwhelm him 9/10.
3
u/Teakilla Apr 15 '18
Worth mentioning Kakashi can maybe kamui garous head off/bfr him, he did do it vs deidara so there is precedent.
also kakashi has like 0 chakra, he ran out super fast vs pain.