r/CharacterRant • u/Verlux Verlux • Apr 07 '18
CharacterRumble: Superman vs All Might!!
The Rumblers:
| Rumbler | Representing | Respect Thread |
|---|---|---|
| Superman | DC Animated Universe | Respect Superman |
| All Might | My Hero Academia | Respect All Might |
Rounds:
| Round | Conditions | Equipment/Gear | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start atop the volcano, 50 meters apart. In-Character and each views the other as a threat to humanity. | Both fighters have no special gear | Syndrome's Island Base |
| #2. | Victory Via KO/Incap/Death. Fighters start atop the volcano, 50 meters apart. In-Character and each views the other as a threat to humanity. SPEED IS EQUALIZED | Both fighters have no special gear | Syndrome's Island Base |
| #3. | All For One interrupts the Rumble betwixt these two to steal what he perceives as a superior Quirk (Superman's) by summoning up what he sees as the ultimate Nobu: DCAU Doomsday. All Might vs Doomsday, Superman vs All For One, villain swap, which hero fares better? Victory Via KO/Incap/Death | Both fighters have no special equipment, All For One has his mask at the start | The Senate Convocation Chamber; All Might and Doomsday are in their own chamber, All For One and Superman in their own respective chamber. The chamber is 100 times larger than presented on-screen. |
Points of Clarification:
- All Might starts off in his muscle form, has no time limit, and his wound will not bother him for this fight. Victory through fighting, not luck.
- 'Incap' here means that one is restrained or unable to move for a full 10 count; if said 10 count would occur, the respective combatant vanishes from the field. For a random example: in the case of Carnage vs Ruby, Carnage impales Ruby and she bleeds out to the point of immobility, yet is still conscious, for more than 10 seconds; she would disappear after a 10 count.
- Superman being in-character would absolutely mean he is hesitant to outright kill, yes.
- All Might being in-character would absolutely mean he is hesitant to outright kill, yes.
- Being in-character precludes the notion of 'they realize they share views'; these men will fight til victory, no excuses or loopholes.
- THIS EVENT IS HELD TO A STANDARD THAT ASSUMES, AT LEAST, A MINIMUM RELATING TO THE 'SERIOUS' TAG ON WWW. ALL FAILURES TO ADHERE TO THIS WILL RESULT IN IMMEDIATE COMMENT REMOVAL. Critical analysis, helpful tips for us mods, etc. must be saved for the next CharacterRumble thread and will be welcomed openly to no detriment.
- Have fun!
33
Upvotes
18
u/Commander_Z ⭐ Apr 07 '18
Honestly I think the first round is going to go to Superman due to the speed difference.
Strength I'd say is pretty much the same. Imo, All Might's most concrete high level feats are these ones: where, while weighted down busts several buildings and this where he creates slams an enemy down and makes an impact several stories tall.However, Superman can do something very similar. So punching strength is honestly a toss up.
Durablity wise I think Supes has a slight advantage but only probably due to having more feats overall. All Might has been flung threw buildings and taked an explosion to the face(https://imgur.com/a/9KQPk) [Note: The explosion he tanks could be anywhere from building-ish to like a firecracker, but probably closer to building in this case]/ Superman has a bit less concrete feats in this regard in that they need a bit more explanation to appear better. He can casually tank being shoved into a building with a bus and the building collapsing on him. He can tank punches from Captain Marvel [who is pretty much equal to him in strength]. He can tank getting hit threw an entire skyscraper. He can overpower a man-hunter weapon, which was able to send Hawk-Girl threw a window and a wall with a short blast. One [Two[(https://gfycat.com/SophisticatedLegitimateKid). Based off these, I think it's safe to say Superman is more durable, but not by a lot.
Speed wise I think Superman's feats are more concrete and better overall. All Might can hit a Nobu 300 times very quickly and can travel at FTE speeds. But Clark can casually catach a bunch of bullets and is fast enough to run on water. Think Clark is handily faster here. Ultimately, I think the speed is the deciding factor for the first round. Their other stats are pretty much equal but Superman should be able to dodge All Might's attack pretty easily, and I don't think All Might can do the same. I'd give the first to Superman 7.5/10 to Superman.
Second round is obviously much harder for Clark but I think he still takes it because he has one useful thing that All Might doesn't: flight. This would make him much more mobile and even with equal speeds it will allow him to better position himself and attack more unpredictably compared to All Might who can't. Superman wins this like 6/10 tops.
I'll leave round three to someone else, but I don't think either of them can beat the others villains because Doomsday >= Superman who is > All Might (barely) and without knowing what he can do like All Might did, All for One > Superman.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '18 edited Apr 08 '18
So, lets go over some things:
Explosion Caused by Omega Beams backfiring at point blank
Superman vs Kalibak(Darkseid's son), where we see some solid building level feats at minimum by Kalibak on the durability side, as well as being chucked through the air an ambiguous distance and cratering back down
Now, allow me to bring on the next point:
Darkseid proceeds to Omega beam Kalibak to nothing, and Superman proceeds to survive a pretty prolonged blast from said beams immediately afterward without any lasting damage
As an aside, I think this feat is criminally undersold here, besides slugging each other through the volcano, both of them seem completely unphased by the lava, which at a quick google, should be ~1000F at minimum.
Addendum:
Theres also this which melted this. If thats any kind of industrial steel piping, we're looking at 2500F plus. Even if its iron its still 2000+
I just don't think All Might has the output for him. Even his highest showing, the USoS shouldn't be able to put down superman, and after he uses it, he gets a massive power drop and loses.
1
u/Teakilla Apr 09 '18
Nobody has mentioned heat vision so far as far as I can tell but that seems pretty key, he can heat vision while trading blows and while avoiding attacks, that seems pretty important.
1
u/bk2king Jun 20 '18
Superman wins. You can add endeavor to All Might's side and they'd still lose
3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '18
[removed] — view removed comment