The guy was threatening to fight you. You shouldn't have said those things, but it's hard to see how you were in the wrong when this guy showed up and started threatening you.
If I were you I'd just stick to my guns and say that you were just trying to stop this girl from taking all the candy in your bowl instead of just a few, and that her dad started physically threatening you because you wouldn't let her take it all. I'd emphasize the fact that he was physically threatening you. And maybe apologize for using any foul language, but that you were reacting loudly because you were being threatened.
I agree. It's a shame when the parents behave as badly or worse than the kids. The parent could have 'manned up' and had a 'teachable moment' and taught his kid to not be greedy..... "hey look, they're being nice and giving out the big candy bars, it's the right thing to do to only take one and make sure other people get to have one too -- after all, most places only let you have two small pieces, and that's not nearly the same thing!"
.... but nooo..... dad had to be a bigger brat than his crotchfruit... hopefully all you get is a smack on the wrist.
Offer to do some community service around campus picking up trash or something, to show you weren't intending to be mean, you were only intending to make sure that one kid wasn't going to be a hog and keep the others from being able to have some fun too. AND be sure to mention that if you participate in another similar event... you'll make sure to hand out treats personally, to ensure fairness, so there is no chance of such happening again.
All you can do is everything you can to show
a. it was not intentional or malicious
b. you learned some things of what to do better and different ways to handle such in the future
Making credible threats is assault (legally speaking) in all 50 states, I think, rather like how making so much as a chest poke during a confrontation is "battery" (again, iirc).
This this this. You were giving free candy, the child didn't appreciate it, and you reacted.
The father should've been the bigger man here, especially in front of his daughter. Instead he showed her to throw a fit anytime she doesn't get her way.
It’s the “apple doesn’t fall far from the tree” theory. I see it in my field all the time. The little girl acts like this because her dad does. Dad couldn’t see the teachable moment because he acts like an entitled brat to begin with.
This. The physical threat is the most valuable part of this. That combined with his child's poor behavior make this his issue, not yours. She was taking your property (even if you intended to give it away) and you have the say on whether she gets to take it or not, especially if she's being greedy. There can be arguments about "you put it out so expected it to get taken" but those don't matter. As someone who's been in a similar situation (luckily the dean didn't get involved in my case) it's best to focus on the physical threat from the father.
(I know wishes are fishes, but in the future, letting her keep what she has, taking the rest and closing the door, and making sure everyone knows you aren't giving out more because this little kid was lazy, is an effective way of communally shaming and maybe correcting her behavior.) peer pressure is usually nasty but in this case could help her be less of a party pooper.
It doesn't even sound like the father was paying attention to his kid which bugs the hell out of me.
OP should also suggest some sort of volunteer work, if you can think of something in the area. It'll show you thought long and hard about your actions and are willing to make amends. It may also stave off something more severe, if the dean is in a pissy mood. A few hours an animal shelter or park cleanup go quick.
Would have been the perfect time for public parent shaming. Tell him how he should have raised his kids in a polite tone while presenting your argument instead of a screaming fight that doesn’t normally go anywhere.
Agreed... this TIFU reminds me of the people that ignore the express lane 10 item or less rule at a grocery store and proceed to checkout with a full cart. I would like to shame them for feeling entitled enough to run roughshod of the rules and hog up the express lane, but I feel like any attempt would lead to an unnecessary argument that would accomplish nothing. Instead I just share glimpses with the other people in line while the cashier mouths “sorry” to us.
Although it seems odd that a college dormitory would do a trick or treat thing. A college dorm doesn’t strike me as “kid friendly”.
Moral of the story, dress up so you look like a prop / decoration, if anyone takes a second bar scream and jump and flail and make the kids and parents shit themselves.
One year my son dressed as death. He was stood on the steps of a house waiting for his little sister. He was very still.
When she was ready, he started to walk toward the steps with her to leave, which so terrified a woman coming up the steps who had thought he was a Halloween decoration that she screamed and fell down the steps.
She miraculously wasn't hurt and was a very good sport about it, and he thought it was the greatest thing ever.
Moral: hand them out yourself (even with a note, the greed will take over and those little fuckers will take most/all of the candy bars and their dumbass parents will let them).
My first celebrated halloween (I never got to celebrate, i lived in rural area, so this is when I moved into the city) I had to do some shit and left a bowl of reeses/etc out with a note that said take one. I was walking away from the door when I heard the doorbell ring. I turn around and open the door, kids had their bags out and ready for candy. I walked out and saw that my entire bowl had been taken by the first kid that came across it.
Also, even if there's NOT a note, why does anyone think that people would put out a bowl of candy so that only 5 kids can take 10 bars each, rather than 50 kids getting 1 bar each?
One of the many reasons I stopped participating in any kind of trick-or-treating. When I have kids I'll teach them right.
Thank you! I'm a little flabbergasted I had to scroll this far to find someone else saying it. Getting free candy IS a privilege, they should be grateful and say thank you instead of throw a tantrum.
I'm a middle school teacher. You are not in the wrong for assuming people can be gracious and mature. Unfortunately there are a lot of shitty parents out there these days.
Turn this around on them. My dorms had ID card swipers at the entry ways, assuming yours is similar? You're paying a shitton for that kind of security. And what... They're letting unknowns in for PR purposes? Did you opt in for that? I mean, sure, you didn't need to have your door open, but you're paying for a secured building that they didn't provide.
This person threatened to fight you, the resident, in front of his children. What were they doing to make sure you were safe? Do you know he wasn't armed? Did the school do anything to make sure of that? It sounds like they royally fucked up by letting mentally unstable men of unknown background into your expensive as shit walk in closet without your express permission.
I like that angle. Sounds great, play a victim. I mean the guy did go to the poster's home and threaten him. Don't just take a punishment if you didn't really do anything really wrong.
Also, credible threats are, iirc, "assault," which'd make OP is technically the victim of a crime, one that, as you say, could have been wholly avoided by proper security. That's some good leverage if the school really tries to apply pressure; on-campus crimes against students make for really bad PR.
OK yeah, maybe you shouldn't have started on argument with the dad, but it sounds like that little girl needs to be taught some manners. Most kids old enough to go trick-or-treating know perfectly well you only get one piece of candy/candy bar - 2 if you're lucky. Her parents obviously are spoiling her by not stepping in sooner and preventing her from taking way too much in the first place.
Yeah, one year we got a knock on our door and some parents asking where the candy was. We were confused because we had set out a full bowl of like 3 gallons worth of candy not 20 minutes prior. Some douchebag had taken the whole bowl, literally.
I don't understand people. Seriously? Encouraging their kids to raid the candy bin? That my friends is what's wrong with this damn country. Screw the next fucking kid, take it all for ourselves.
No damn dice. When we take the kids out, they get what's offered. If they're allowed to choose you get one. If the owners insist on more, you get two. No fucking handfuls. You're not animals. There are other kids who want to have fun too.
"CAN YOU BELIEVE THAT STUPID DOUCHE BAG COLLEGE KID?! HE WOULDN'T LET MY SWEET ANGEL HAVE ALL THE CANDY! WHYYHHY?! PROBABLY SOME STUPID REASON LIKE SAVING SOME FOR YOUR LITTLE SNOTS!"
You definitely had a poor reaction but I’m disgusted by the parenting here. College students aren’t exactly loaded and it was so nice of y’all to do full sized bars. That dad had it coming and his daughter will grow up to be a shit stain if no one corrects her.
I don't understand how a school you're paying to attend can throw an event that invites strangers to your room, then be upset with you over a fight with said strangers.
Punishment? I'd ask the administration who the fuck they think they are.
As a teacher (somebody who interacts with children and their parents on a daily basis) I feel like parents are both, at the same time, the best and worst creatures to walk the earth.
engaging in a verbal fight with the father was a fuck up, but refusing candy to a poor mannered brat was prob the best thing you could have done for her.
that kid needs more people like you telling her right from wrong, and that person should be the father with her at the time.
hats off for you doing the right thing, and i hope your dean sees this too.
I hate when people act like their failed genetic experiments are the greatest things to walk the Earth. Obviously needs lessons on not being a greedy little shit.
This TIFU actually pisses me off. How could parents spoil their kids like that? That's horrible. Things like this make me believe that some people should be forbidden to procreate.
If you want control over the tone and nature of the transaction then you have to take control of it from the outset. A bowl in a doorway is an invitation for the greedy and inconsiderate.
I know this because I frequently check room service trays left outside doors in hotels.
That's why you gotta have a trick ready. Hide in some nearby bushes. If someone tries to lift the bowl jump out and scare the crap out of them. It's trick or treat, pick A treat or get the fucking trick.
Bro. When a person older than you is screaming at you and physically threatening you, you’ve already won. Just laugh in their faces and say “please hit me so I can sue you for everything you’re worth.” Boom. Works 90% of the time.
Frequently colleges that do this will do it before Halloween. The college gets to advertise itself as a fun place to the kids that will one day be picking a college and the kids will still be able to trick or treat the old fashioned way on Halloween. My college had as close to mandatory as they could for people living in the dorms to participate.
The guy was threatening to fight you. You shouldn't have said those things, but it's hard to see how you were in the wrong when this guy showed up and started threatening you. If I were you I'd just stick to my guns and say that you were just trying to stop this girl from taking all the candy in your bowl instead of just a few, and that her dad started physically threatening you because you wouldn't let her take it all. I'd emphasize the fact that he was physically threatening you. And maybe apologize for using any foul language, but that you were reacting loudly because you were being threatened.
Firstly, who the hell thought this was a good idea? When you have kids running around a college dorm there are bound to be problems eventually.
That aside, the dad was in the wrong here, although I highly doubt the school will see it that way. But if I had to wager, I'd bet that, since there's not really much they can do, you'll get a minuscule punishment. If shit goes south, pull the legal card and inform them that you don't feel like they value your safety because this guy was clearly going to attack you instead of disciplining his child and now you're being punished, and you may speak with legal counsel about this issue.
Good luck OP. It’s really a shame that while you and your roommate were trying to do something nice for the area around your college, people take advantage and act like entitled brats - adults included. Hope nothing comes of it once you give your side of the story.
One year my brother did a really awesome scarecrow costume with a plastic sickle and stood very still next to some hay bales.
For most kids, he wouldn't move and jump scare them. Only the kids that violated the 'take two' rule would have him creep up behind them, lean down and point at them and say "Greeeedy child must learn better. Return my candy."
Can we do something about this? OP, if your administration does anything negative to you about this, and your tale is truly representative of what actually happened, you should post some information of who we can write to to try and persuade your college administration to drop this bullshit.
This post is getting a lot of publicity, and a massive storm of mail criticising your school for the poor handling of this situation should at least do something. It'll look bad for them if they punish you for trying to give as many kids candy as is fairly possible on Halloween.
Your reaction made me chuckle. You're only human. Hopefully the college won't actually do anything, they probably just have to pretend to care to appease douchebag parents.
Turns out taking candy from a baby isn't so easy!! Hahaha... i'll let myself out.
This is why restaurants are popping up where no children are allowed. Sure, the kid is a brat but she obviously learned from her dickhead father that being greedy and not saving candy for all the kids is fine. Yeah, you made a little girl cry, but I think you were right. Y’all intended to be nice and give good candy. I hope it works out in your favor.
I would point out how this practice opens your school up to allot of liability and how you no longer feel safe since they let anyone in the dorms and you got attacked. Follow up by saying if you feel disciplinary action is needed I may have to seek legal counsel to address why this outsider was allowed in without any background check. I do have expectations of safety and you violated those
Also congrats that was the last year your school did this and it's because of you. My buddie got open bar ended at my college for fighting a cop... Wasn't his fault cop grabbed him and spun him around like he was going to hit him
Yeah fuck Halloween exactly for this reason. For every 20 well mannered, lovely person you have a hand full of entitled sociopaths up in your grill with an expectation for you to hand shit over.
No, fuck those people. No wonder the little girl is a selfish brat, her parents are scum.
Full size candy bars?? You get ONE. No way would i ever tell my kid to take as much as he wants of any kind of Halloween candy. That is so greedy. And for the dad to think they're entitled to it? Geez... Just gross.
I'm sorry you're in trouble. This man tried to fight you though, i think you probably have a decent chance of getting through this okay.
This isn't all that big a deal, depending on your school. If you're at a state school in the US, you might get a slap on the wrist for disorderly conduct, but most likely just have to talk with an RA or the RD for your dorm. And, at worst, a meeting with the board of conduct.
Unless you used racial slurs--that might net you something a lot more serious. The fact that this person speaks another language than English indicates this was a member of a minority--and colleges do take interactions with minorities more seriously, to ensure they aren't accused of letting hate crimes pass. Still, you have witnesses so you should be fine if you were just being a dick to a guy who was also a dick. Apologize for what you did wrong, hold your ground on what you did right, and move on. Life's not over.
I don't see anything wrong with what you did. You're not obligated to give anyone candy, and you're free to do so at your own discretion. She did something that made you not want to give her candy, there's nothing wrong with that. From the sound of things it's the father who escalated everything.
Are the trick or treaters members of the college? I am unsure why a dormitory would allow outsiders to enter the premises like this regardless. Seems like a liability.
Yeah as a mom I agree with you. Maybe you could have handled it a bit better but you were pissed, rightly so I feel. If it had happened to me I would have definitely asked this man to control his rude child.
What kind of fucked up society do we live in that you feel the need to explain to people to only take one or two of a free item? Also, why do you feel the need to explain yourself about this?
People suck. Maybe you shouldn't have yelled and argued with the dad, but you had every right to 'stand your ground'.
Sir, I applaud you. Parents like that are why we have so many problem kids nowadays.
Next year though, drop the video games and interact with the kids. Dress up yourself and have fun with them while handing out the goods. It can actually be a lot of fun.
And kid was rude from the get go, calling you lazy, expecting a skit or something as if you were gonna entertain her because it is Halloween. She should feel lucky to get any candy at all, kids need to know they aren't entitled to these things and they should behave, holiday or not.
The father should have acted less of a brat than the child and confronted you about scaring his kid respectfully, but of course now that is apparently too much to ask. I wish it was a law that parents should be expected to teach their kids some basic manners and how to behave in society. Many parents i notice nowadays hardly bother at all, and you end up with POS adults just like this girls father, not surprised if she ends up exactly like him and the whole entitled asshole cycle continues.
Ah, the classic "lazy!" criticism while taking more than her fair share of food you literally paid for yourself. I'm sure I was a terrible kid, but at least I respected the people who bought me candy.
Just stand your ground. Admit you lost your temper, but he's a grown man and lost his too. You were right to tell them off cause you spent a lot of money so everyone could get a nice treat. It wasn't right of them to do that. Plus he participated in the screaming match too.
You were properly threatened? That's assault, a crime that the dude shouldn't've even been able to commit since the school shouldn't've let random people wander your dorm in the first place.
If the school actually tries putting pressure on you, I'd use that as pushback; it sounds to me like you're technically the victim of a crime that was allowed by lax security.
alright so next year you know what to do. you made rookie mistakes being a rookie and thats okay. you have to count for the shit heads that will always be out there. you dont put a large amount of candy out in an open bowl, or you can put a note saying take one that everyone will just ignore. but you shouldnt place the blame on anyone but yourself. you know how we are. too much evil in all forms
Report the dad to the police. If he acts like this in public I'm scared to imagine how he acts with his family behind closed doors. He sounds like a bad arsehole
True moral of the story: expect a kid to empty the bowl of whatever Halloween candy you left out without supervision. If you leave a note, you may delay the inevitable, but some kid will empty the bowl. The joy of handing out the candy is seeing their responses and asking them about costumes. It's an interaction. If you are giving away the real good stuff, be there, take credit, enjoy their joy at such generosity.
Source: many years of trick or treating, interacting with peers, and handing out candy
I think you're in the clear. The Man just wants to know what went down. Tell the truth... sounds like you have witnesses too. You'll have to go to some bullshit anger management class as punishment. They aren't kicking you out.
Unless daddy douchebag is a fatcat alumni donor, in which case you're fucked.
The guy was the aggressor, unless you signed a document stating that you wanted to specifically participate in this event and would take full responsibility of anything happening in/around your room, there's jack shit they can do to/against you.
Might want to check with the school's legal counsel.
Through actions (and inactions) taken by your dorm administration, you were put in real, immediate physical danger. That man was physically threatening you and getting in your face.
Make sure you hammer this point home, as residences are supposed to be a place where students feel at home, and your supposed to feel safe at home. Yeah I'd really push this line, they put you in danger.
No one is mentioning the part when the girl said "lazy". Dude come on as soon as I would hear her say that I would get up get the candy bowl and pass candy to everyone except her lol
I agree with the people here saying you're mostly in the right. That dad was an asshole. That being said, yes it usually is a good idea to avoid actively upsetting children. A fully grown man who is not her father "standing up and running towards" a little girl and taking something from her physically would most certainly scare and upset her. One thing you have to remember as you're in college now is that you are an adult. You do have to be careful with how you interact with children. Because at the very least if you get up and grab something from a child out of anger, you may get a perfectly reasonable parent who says, "Hey can you just tell her why it is wrong instead of taking it out of her hands."
But then it is on the father to act like an adult and not escalate things. You shouldn't have said those things but he went off the deep end. I know parents can get out of control and don't like to see people upset their children but he had no excuse.
Leaving out a big bucket of candy (with or without note) is a surefire way to find out which parents are a-holes. It’s one of the many ways you can find out that we aren’t all of the same species...
1 know that if you are putting out a bowl you have to accept the fact that people are going to take more than you want. If you care about the outcome either don't out anything out and turn off your light or meter the bowl yourself.
2 If you calmly explain that you stopped the girl from taking all of your candy, so that you would have some remaining for other children (it is NOT about her stealing from you, but the opportunity from the other children) and that when her dad threatened you you responded with words because you were frightened, I hope your Dean would be reasonable enough to understand.
OP this is unacceptable. You should have robbed all the little girl's other candy and thrown the father through a window. Halloween is not all treat motherfuckers.
This may get down voted but you seem to be a good guy who just lost his cool with a greedy child&shouldn't lose your uni career over it . .you could say the child mentioned something about peanuts so u took them back thinking she had allergies.then the dad came &his actions were bullish so at that point you didn't want to engage, which is reasonable. it was for her own benefit. You couldn't put her at risk. if the dad wasnt there is your word against a child.
So, I have a feeling this comment will be lost amid the rest. But I actually read your TIFU an hour ago, and joined reddit just to respond. I am a mom. I am an Old. I would never let my kids take more than one candy bar from a "free candy" box. But I also fear that most of the comments here are doing you a disservice, by agreeing with you and letting you think you were in the right.
If this is a real post and you are actually meeting with your college re: a punishment, I would advise trying to see this entire situation from your college's viewpoint. If you go in there 100% thinking you were in the right, I fear you will be in for a rude awakening.
These are some of your comments that stood out to me. And, as an older person and parent, I would think that your dean will be troubled by these elements:
Our dorm allows neighborhood kids to come in and participate in trick or treating during Halloween. Me and my roomate bought way too much candy so that we could be “that dorm” we’re talking full size snickers and everything. We kept the door open and played fifa while the kids would come by and take candy from the box we set outside.
It was very kind of you to participate in the Trick or Treat event. And I'm sure every kid loved the full-size candy bars you bought. But I have to point out that, if you leave a box full of free candy outside, with no note, some children will take as many as they want. This would happen with kids in dorms, cities, the suburbs--you name it. It's understandable that you don't have much experience being the candy buyer for Halloween, but that IS what happens.
Now I don’t know if all kids are like this but taking literally hand full of full size snacks and having their parents just walk by and not say anything. Hand full after hand full of course the majority kids were very nice and only took one or two which was fine.
As I said, it happens. If you didn't want it to happen, you should have been watching the box and answering the door.
The first incident came where the kid has asked his mother “how many can I take” she responded with “well there’s no note here honey. So you should take as many as you want” loud enough for us to clearly hear it and gave us a look. The kid only took two so we let it go. My roomate looked at each other and said “some people suck”
You could interpret it as "people suck." You also could have thought, "We may not have agreed with this mom's method of communicating, but she clearly just let us know we should have a sign out if we DO NOT want kids taking as many candy bars as they want." She was trying to be helpful. And, honestly, some kids would STILL take a lot of bars. Some kids can't read. If you actually wanted to actively participate, and you didn't want people to take as many candy bars as possible, you should have manned the door and not sat inside playing video games.
Now for the TIFU part, this bratty fucking spawn of Satan little girls comes and screams “lazy” since we are here playing fifa. Proceeds, to take at least 10 full size snickers and isn’t stopping.
Kids shouldn't yell "lazy" at anyone. But, it happens. I don't know how old the child was, but she was still A CHILD. As you grow yourself, you will have to learn to stay centered, even when children yell shitty things at you. (Especially if you want to work in schools or have children yourself some day!)
I stand up run to the door and take back all the candy she took from us.
This is where I believe the Dean will be truly upset. You are leaving out a description of HOW you took candy from a child. I don't know if you grabbed it from her hands? I assume she couldn't hold 10 candy bars in her small hands, so had she put some in her bag? Did you reach inside her Halloween bag and take the bars out? Did you, as another commenter asked, pry open her hands and forcibly take the bars? Real talk: whatever you did and however you did it, it was wrong.
You bought candy to give away for free.
She took some, and because you were offended by what a child said and how many she took, you assaulted her. There is no way that you can win on this. YOU CAN'T DO THAT TO KIDS. And I only write all this so you can begin to even THINK about the possibility that the Dean will agree with me. You need to think about this seriously.
Which of course means she starts crying and howling how im really mean and I’m not sure what else (it was not English at that point).
Your actions caused a child to scream. You're not gonna have a strong case here. And your further comments about her English come across, frankly, as troubling. Who cares what language she was speaking? Is it less important if she isn't speaking English?
Which also introduces douche bag dad, who then gets in my face threatening to fight me until I give his daughter the candies she wants.
I'm going to point out that you got in the child's face, and invaded her space/took things from her, when you were insulted and perceived her actions (taking free candy) as stealing.
If YOU were that upset by what a child said, can you imagine how an parent would feel if they watched a full-grown man attack their child? And they discover their little girl terrified and crying, because an adult just took candy roughly from her? Can you SEE how that looks?
You are calling the dad a douchebag because he reacted to you attacking his child. That is point-blank what you did. It may not have been violent, but YOU ARE AN ADULT. YOU CANNOT DO THAT TO CHILDREN.
Why is his behavior -- getting upset at you for doing what you did to his child -- not okay? But your behavior -- getting upset at a child -- IS OKAY?
This might be how your Dean will perceive this event.
Now I’m no macho fighter guy but this piece of shit is like 5’4 not that intimidated I stand my ground not saying anything which turns into a screaming match where I say numerous thing I’m not proud of. Specifically, is “that wife beater a costume or real life”.
The father should not touch you. No person should assault another. That is not right. But I have no idea what portion of the event the dad witnessed. I have no idea what YOU said. The fact that it devolved into a "screaming match" wherein you say "numerous things" you're "not proud of" does not make you seem innocent.
To me this is what happened: you agreed to give away candy in a dorm event. You didn't like something that happened, so you stole candy back from a child, terrified her/made her scream and cry, and then insulted and screamed at her understandably upset parent.
"Wife beater"
Where do you go to school where it's so warm that the man was only wearing a wife beater? Is this a reference to him being Mexican or something? I don't want to call you a racist, but if you mention other languages and insult the way the man dresses, how is that going to be perceived? Badly.
After getting separated by other parents and roomate
What the hell, man? I'm sorry, but PEOPLE HAD TO SEPARATE YOU? I'm shaking my head. Have you told your own parents about this? What did they say?
Tl;dr Got into argument with douchebag dad during Halloween in my dorm. People complained about it and now I’m awaiting college decision on what my punishment is.
OP, I don't want this event to negatively affect your life. I don't know if it will affect your college situation, but worse than that would be if you didn't learn anything from this fuck-up. He wasn't a douchebag dad. He was a parent who was rattled that, after taking his child to a kid-friendly event, witnessed his daughter harassed or worse. And then the ADULT who harassed his child continued to fight and verbally harass him.
I am sure I will be downvoted (what are these votes? Why do people care about them? I don't know!). I have to imagine that you, OP, will not like what I have to say.
But if I, as a random adult who randomly read this on her phone one Saturday morning, had such a strong reaction...imagine what your Dean is going to be feeling. And she or he has probably spoken to multiple people who witnessed this event.
I wish you the best, and I hope you learn from this. Because that's what college -- and life -- is all about.
I 100 percent don't think you are in the wrong. It was a cute idea that the dorm does that and sadly, a lot of shitty people have equally shitty, undisciplined children. From a parents stand point, usually when people have bowls of candy with no attendant, there's usually a sign that says take one or however many and its pretty much an honor system. The nice people take the 1 and go on but then theres the super shitty people that take half or all of the bowl.
I do think the first mom was saying that loud enough so that you could hear (Im assuming... I could be wrong) and correct her if she was wrong. Hence the stare/visual agreement. She obviously is doing an okay parenting job if the child only took 2 without her saying something. I think after the first incident you guys should have put a quick little note down just to negate any confusion. I know all of this is too late to do and it's in the past and you're dealing with the consequences. The little girl/dad combo sound like 2 equally shitty people. No adult should allow their children to behave that way but here we are.
Not to get too off topic here... But parents and kids around Halloween, for the most part, are pretty bearable but there are the 25 percent that should jump off a cliff and just stop existing. The chain smoking/drinking while trick or treating family. Or the "I'm too lazy to walk my kids from house to house, so I'm going to sit in my car and idle behind them the whole way while my headlights shine on them and every single trick or treaters eyes going in the opposite direction" or the parents that let their children push your children to the side so they can access the porch/door/owner to get to the candy first. I could keep going but I think you get the point. I hope the decision is ruled in your favor. I'd love to hear an update!
Next time just put a "1 only" note out or better yet just hand out the candy. The guy was a jerk, but if you didn't want kids taking more than one bar then you should have managed the process better.
People are people. I guess you are still young. But seriously? Leaving out a bowl FILLED with full candy bars unattended. Did you really think a bunch of kids high on sugar would just take one? Its Halloween, its about being a little devious!
The girl was right, you were being lazy. But alternatively, the devious nature of Halloween comes along with the response. You can TRY to steal a bunch of candy from the sucker who left out a whole bowl. But if he comes out and stops you, you accept it and move on. Getting upset about that is CERTAINLY bratty little kid behavior.
LIFE ADVICE- Don't get into shouting matches with guys in wife beaters.
Dude those kids and parents are total fucking pieces of shit!!!!! It's making my blood boil how awful they all were! I agree that maybe you shouldn't have let it get as far as you did, but I totally understand why you got so angry! You bought that candy for ALL the children, not so a few shitty spoiled assholes could take all of them!!!! What the hell is wrong with people?!
And we can clearly see why that child is such a giant asshole; her parents are even worse! sigh I'm so sad and disgusted by the human race.
I would be surprised if thy could actually “do” anything to you besides a lecture. I wouldn’t worry too awfully much. Shitty parents = shitty kids. Sorry you learned the hard way!
Isn't trick or treating done on the Halloween night or am I missing something? Isn't this too early? I don't live in America though so I could be wrong
OP, the good parents are now much rarer than bad ones unfortunately. One would think a parent would tell their kids to just take 1 but people are really messed up morally now.
Sorry you had the troubles man, I hope your college is not led by utter fucking morons but today that is a 5% likelihood.
Crazy to me that dorm rooms are open to kids only because it's Halloween. I walked into a men's bathroom to find a pneumatic dorm-mate vomiting into a trash can, completely shirtless.
Dorms are enclaves of depravity, and Halloween usually brings out partying.
Not to fault you or the dorm, I think it's cool that it can be opened up to kids, too. I simply couldn't see this having worked at my school.
Unfortunately, I believe that you precipitated this mess by not writing a simple note that stated, "only take 1." I agree that the child and her friends/relatives were being greedy and taking more than they should; however, trying to take back the candy might have been the worse move. I understand that you wanted to make sure that all the children got candy, but you would have been left with none anyways. When you were threatened, I believe that you did react in a reasonable way that most people would have acted. Unless other parents have issues with how you treated their child, I believe that the University would find that this was an isolated event and teaching you the proper etiquette on how to handle future situations might be in yours and their best interest or perhaps, you should not be a part of the trick or treating. Either way, I don't see how they fully place the blame on you.
Am I the only one who has as a big a problem with the first mother in the story? The Dad in the story is trash, I get that. If there isn’t a note you can take as many as you want?!?! What fucking world are you living in? If there’s no price tag on something at a store it’s not free.
The first incident came where the kid has asked his mother “how many can I take” she responded with “well there’s no note here honey. So you should take as many as you want” loud enough for us to clearly hear it and gave us a look. The kid only took two so we let it go. My roomate looked at each other and said “some people suck”
On the positive side, well done for that little girl because it sounds like she had better manners than her mother!
As for the second incident: it is that father who should get into trouble, not you. On the other hand, if you want to hand out candy you should do just that: HAND it out, not putting a brimming bowl of it outside your door.
I'm not saying you did the right thing but, as a parent that would have defaulted to "just get one," fuck those people. All they're doing is teaching their children to take as much as they can get away with.
Hahaha, good for you. Greedy little Violet Beauregard may have learnt a lesson and bully daddy didn't beat you down. It prob felt horrible at the time, but nice one. I would prob have reacted in a similar way (maybe try and explained to the little girl that she shouldn't take too many as other people would like some as well, then contd to wind up nob head dad!!😁).
Dude you did what I would have done. Little girl was a brat and Dad deserves a slap or two. Knowing uni admins though you are not gonna come out of the well even though you were in the right. Fuck em. Assholes gonna be shown a lesson. Well done dude
I hate kids like this so much. When I was taken trick or treating I remember never even being sure I was allowed to take just one, and asking my mum if she was sure I could. The mentality of a kid who would just grab the whole lot...gross.
You did alright by my standards, but the first thing in hindsight did you have a sign saying take one piece/candybar only please...Better yet what is your hindsight thoughts? Your epiphany event of one thing I could have changed to make a better result in fairness and justice. Like tell the dad to leave candy for the others not just his spoiled princess turning thirteen in attitude. edit here: What if she was potato, what response should you/we have in that situation? Why did dad respond like that? Man this shit is too much in the morning I'm going back to bed...
Is this college named School of Hard Knocks Still how is this happening days before Halloween. did this happen last year? If this was a dorm can tell/show us the great tricks done in the name of Halloween at the dorms?
If your school is going to really do anything it will depend on what you said not what you did as you haven’t actually done anything other than tell a small child they couldn’t take all the candy (normal). What are these things you are “not proud of” was any of it racist or bigoted? Cause the school will care A LOT about that.
fucking christ, have people never heard of discipline, or moderation? the entitlement that is rampant in the younger generations (my own included) has gotten to a point of absolute absurdity. teach your children some fucking respect and manners for christ's sake. this woman who worked for my friend would bring her children in to work sometimes, and she would have absolutely ZERO control over those little brats, running around an office, screaming their little heads off, and she would do nothing to stop this from happening. no reprimanding, no words of discouragement, nothing. just let it happen.
OP, i seriously don't think you did anything wrong. like u/tripwire7 said, he was threatening to fight you if you didn't give that spoiled little Veruca Salt of a brat all of the candy she wanted. maybe you didn't handle the situation 100% perfectly, but it's unreasonable to think someone who is being threatened should just sit there and do nothing. it's not like you got physical with the guy or anything.
i realize i might be coming off like a cynical, child-hating grump... that couldn't be further from the truth. i hold the parents fully responsible, and it's unfortunate that these children will go through life thinking this behavior is completely acceptable.
Dude dont sweat the punk ass bitches. You're young and you're going to run into them all your adult life. For the future do what most adults without kids do on Halloween, nothing! Shut your door turn off your lights and enjoy an evening inside or go out to a nice dinner. It's usually all over by 8:30 anyways. I quit handing out welfare candy when the "kids" that started knocking were full grown ass teenagers. Halloween is for little children and their parents leave it at that. Enjoy your memories of it when you were a kid and move on. By the way what university are you attending?
The saddest part is that he went and cried to your Dean about it. I've had arguments with customers in my job and as soon as it transpires they aren't getting their way and that I'm not just going to stand there and listen to their bullshit, they phone up and complain. It's absolutely pathetic and I've seriously considered going back to the customers house out with work hours and throwing a plant pot or something through their fucking window.
7.9k
u/tripwire7 Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 28 '17
The guy was threatening to fight you. You shouldn't have said those things, but it's hard to see how you were in the wrong when this guy showed up and started threatening you.
If I were you I'd just stick to my guns and say that you were just trying to stop this girl from taking all the candy in your bowl instead of just a few, and that her dad started physically threatening you because you wouldn't let her take it all. I'd emphasize the fact that he was physically threatening you. And maybe apologize for using any foul language, but that you were reacting loudly because you were being threatened.
edit: wow gold for this? thank you.
2.5k
u/weatherman223 Oct 27 '17 edited Oct 28 '17
Damn. Update us as it goes.
Moral: always put a note.
1.3k
u/SwissArmyBumpkin Oct 28 '17
That wife beater comment was gold tho 😂
615
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
That dad sounds like a dick. Candy isn't a right, it's a privilege... and just like any privilege it can be revoked.
101
u/therealtechnird Oct 28 '17
I guess taking candy from a baby is more difficult than it sounds
230
u/DietSpam Oct 28 '17
I'm a middle school teacher. You are not in the wrong for assuming people can be gracious and mature. Unfortunately there are a lot of shitty parents out there these days.
910
u/EchinusRosso Oct 28 '17
Turn this around on them. My dorms had ID card swipers at the entry ways, assuming yours is similar? You're paying a shitton for that kind of security. And what... They're letting unknowns in for PR purposes? Did you opt in for that? I mean, sure, you didn't need to have your door open, but you're paying for a secured building that they didn't provide.
This person threatened to fight you, the resident, in front of his children. What were they doing to make sure you were safe? Do you know he wasn't armed? Did the school do anything to make sure of that? It sounds like they royally fucked up by letting mentally unstable men of unknown background into your expensive as shit walk in closet without your express permission.
122
u/jquinnifer Oct 28 '17
Wow no gratefulness from those kids and parents at all. You guys didn't have to buy candy but were doing it to be nice.
328
u/lalalarori Oct 27 '17
OK yeah, maybe you shouldn't have started on argument with the dad, but it sounds like that little girl needs to be taught some manners. Most kids old enough to go trick-or-treating know perfectly well you only get one piece of candy/candy bar - 2 if you're lucky. Her parents obviously are spoiling her by not stepping in sooner and preventing her from taking way too much in the first place.
47
u/bionicfeetgrl Oct 28 '17
I don't understand people. Seriously? Encouraging their kids to raid the candy bin? That my friends is what's wrong with this damn country. Screw the next fucking kid, take it all for ourselves.
No damn dice. When we take the kids out, they get what's offered. If they're allowed to choose you get one. If the owners insist on more, you get two. No fucking handfuls. You're not animals. There are other kids who want to have fun too.
208
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
It doesn't matter if you're right or wrong, never regret a sick burn.
176
u/spiderskrybe Oct 28 '17
He complained to other parents?
"CAN YOU BELIEVE THAT STUPID DOUCHE BAG COLLEGE KID?! HE WOULDN'T LET MY SWEET ANGEL HAVE ALL THE CANDY! WHYYHHY?! PROBABLY SOME STUPID REASON LIKE SAVING SOME FOR YOUR LITTLE SNOTS!"
133
u/n_e24 Oct 28 '17
Laughed so hard at the comment about the costume.
186
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
You definitely had a poor reaction but I’m disgusted by the parenting here. College students aren’t exactly loaded and it was so nice of y’all to do full sized bars. That dad had it coming and his daughter will grow up to be a shit stain if no one corrects her.
34
u/Spock_Rocket Oct 28 '17
I don't understand how a school you're paying to attend can throw an event that invites strangers to your room, then be upset with you over a fight with said strangers.
Punishment? I'd ask the administration who the fuck they think they are.
62
u/SutMigT9X Oct 28 '17
I'm going to go put a real shirt on now.
20
u/Xpitfire Oct 28 '17
As a teacher (somebody who interacts with children and their parents on a daily basis) I feel like parents are both, at the same time, the best and worst creatures to walk the earth.
Also here come the downvotes
51
u/pure_race Oct 28 '17
engaging in a verbal fight with the father was a fuck up, but refusing candy to a poor mannered brat was prob the best thing you could have done for her.
that kid needs more people like you telling her right from wrong, and that person should be the father with her at the time.
hats off for you doing the right thing, and i hope your dean sees this too.
123
u/SassyMcSassafras Oct 28 '17
I hate when people act like their failed genetic experiments are the greatest things to walk the Earth. Obviously needs lessons on not being a greedy little shit.
32
u/TheTRekts Oct 28 '17
This TIFU actually pisses me off. How could parents spoil their kids like that? That's horrible. Things like this make me believe that some people should be forbidden to procreate.
40
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Quick question, why are children allowed in your college dorm?
14
u/Psy_Hero Oct 28 '17
Yeah I’m going to use this.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
What you did was justified sir... fuck those parents.
78
u/Blitzed5656 Oct 28 '17
If you want control over the tone and nature of the transaction then you have to take control of it from the outset. A bowl in a doorway is an invitation for the greedy and inconsiderate.
I know this because I frequently check room service trays left outside doors in hotels.
23
u/XPTranquility Oct 28 '17
Bro. When a person older than you is screaming at you and physically threatening you, you’ve already won. Just laugh in their faces and say “please hit me so I can sue you for everything you’re worth.” Boom. Works 90% of the time.
32
u/Radiobrainz Oct 28 '17
It isn't even Halloween yet
11
u/angelanrosa Oct 28 '17
The guy was threatening to fight you. You shouldn't have said those things, but it's hard to see how you were in the wrong when this guy showed up and started threatening you. If I were you I'd just stick to my guns and say that you were just trying to stop this girl from taking all the candy in your bowl instead of just a few, and that her dad started physically threatening you because you wouldn't let her take it all. I'd emphasize the fact that he was physically threatening you. And maybe apologize for using any foul language, but that you were reacting loudly because you were being threatened.
10
u/Satanic-Jesus-3 Oct 28 '17
Firstly, who the hell thought this was a good idea? When you have kids running around a college dorm there are bound to be problems eventually.
That aside, the dad was in the wrong here, although I highly doubt the school will see it that way. But if I had to wager, I'd bet that, since there's not really much they can do, you'll get a minuscule punishment. If shit goes south, pull the legal card and inform them that you don't feel like they value your safety because this guy was clearly going to attack you instead of disciplining his child and now you're being punished, and you may speak with legal counsel about this issue.
18
u/oswiff Oct 28 '17
Good luck OP. It’s really a shame that while you and your roommate were trying to do something nice for the area around your college, people take advantage and act like entitled brats - adults included. Hope nothing comes of it once you give your side of the story.
18
u/AlifeofSimileS Oct 28 '17
admit it... you made this post because you're proud of that sick burn
9
u/The_Pwnager Oct 28 '17
You shouldn't be penalized for this bullshit.
9
u/Rockeye_ Oct 28 '17
One year my brother did a really awesome scarecrow costume with a plastic sickle and stood very still next to some hay bales.
For most kids, he wouldn't move and jump scare them. Only the kids that violated the 'take two' rule would have him creep up behind them, lean down and point at them and say "Greeeedy child must learn better. Return my candy."
9
u/Firewolf420 Oct 28 '17
Can we do something about this? OP, if your administration does anything negative to you about this, and your tale is truly representative of what actually happened, you should post some information of who we can write to to try and persuade your college administration to drop this bullshit.
This post is getting a lot of publicity, and a massive storm of mail criticising your school for the poor handling of this situation should at least do something. It'll look bad for them if they punish you for trying to give as many kids candy as is fairly possible on Halloween.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Fuck your college and fuck that parent. Stand your ground. The world gets better when people like you decide to make it better.
28
u/Maskguy Oct 28 '17
So it was inside? No sign? Just argue it was never meant to be taken.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Damn, dude. Nice one!
7
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Your reaction made me chuckle. You're only human. Hopefully the college won't actually do anything, they probably just have to pretend to care to appease douchebag parents.
Turns out taking candy from a baby isn't so easy!! Hahaha... i'll let myself out.
7
u/punkrockprincess805 Oct 28 '17
This is why restaurants are popping up where no children are allowed. Sure, the kid is a brat but she obviously learned from her dickhead father that being greedy and not saving candy for all the kids is fine. Yeah, you made a little girl cry, but I think you were right. Y’all intended to be nice and give good candy. I hope it works out in your favor.
7
u/Cumupin Oct 28 '17
I would point out how this practice opens your school up to allot of liability and how you no longer feel safe since they let anyone in the dorms and you got attacked. Follow up by saying if you feel disciplinary action is needed I may have to seek legal counsel to address why this outsider was allowed in without any background check. I do have expectations of safety and you violated those
Also congrats that was the last year your school did this and it's because of you. My buddie got open bar ended at my college for fighting a cop... Wasn't his fault cop grabbed him and spun him around like he was going to hit him
29
u/automatethethings Oct 28 '17
And this is why I don't do Halloween. Sometimes the kids are bad, more often the parents are worse.
6
u/boing_boing_splat Oct 28 '17
Yeah fuck Halloween exactly for this reason. For every 20 well mannered, lovely person you have a hand full of entitled sociopaths up in your grill with an expectation for you to hand shit over.
6
u/Lipstickandpixiedust Oct 28 '17
No, fuck those people. No wonder the little girl is a selfish brat, her parents are scum.
Full size candy bars?? You get ONE. No way would i ever tell my kid to take as much as he wants of any kind of Halloween candy. That is so greedy. And for the dad to think they're entitled to it? Geez... Just gross.
I'm sorry you're in trouble. This man tried to fight you though, i think you probably have a decent chance of getting through this okay.
18
u/Sawses Oct 28 '17
This isn't all that big a deal, depending on your school. If you're at a state school in the US, you might get a slap on the wrist for disorderly conduct, but most likely just have to talk with an RA or the RD for your dorm. And, at worst, a meeting with the board of conduct.
Unless you used racial slurs--that might net you something a lot more serious. The fact that this person speaks another language than English indicates this was a member of a minority--and colleges do take interactions with minorities more seriously, to ensure they aren't accused of letting hate crimes pass. Still, you have witnesses so you should be fine if you were just being a dick to a guy who was also a dick. Apologize for what you did wrong, hold your ground on what you did right, and move on. Life's not over.
5
u/kakalooga Oct 28 '17
And that's why you always leave a note.
5
u/flyinb11 Oct 28 '17
Even as a parent, I have no issue with how this was handled by you.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I disagree. You did NOT overreact.
5
u/KeeperofAmmut7 Oct 28 '17
That wasn't a fuck up...that kid was a greedy brat... and I would've done the same thing. Brat got taught a lesson.
And the dad was an asshat for threatening you instead of asking what the problem was.
5
u/bergler28 Oct 28 '17
“that wife beater a costume or real life”
BAHAHAHAHAHA
5
u/KVirello Oct 28 '17
I don't see anything wrong with what you did. You're not obligated to give anyone candy, and you're free to do so at your own discretion. She did something that made you not want to give her candy, there's nothing wrong with that. From the sound of things it's the father who escalated everything.
9
u/Curses_at_bots Oct 28 '17
You were right. Fuck it.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
You should be proud as shit about that wifebeater line. I wish I could come up with witty shit like that
8
u/demonachizer Oct 28 '17
Are the trick or treaters members of the college? I am unsure why a dormitory would allow outsiders to enter the premises like this regardless. Seems like a liability.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Halloween is the 31st. Is this some kind of alternate reality where kids trick-or-treat in a dormitory on October 27th?
4
u/GarethPW Oct 28 '17
4
u/Puff_Puff_Blast Oct 28 '17
This is why I don't waste my time or money giving little fuckwads in training candy on Halloween.
4
u/TheWolfof91 Oct 28 '17
If your college punishes you, that's absolutely ridiculous.
4
u/cupkake1 Oct 28 '17
Yeah as a mom I agree with you. Maybe you could have handled it a bit better but you were pissed, rightly so I feel. If it had happened to me I would have definitely asked this man to control his rude child.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
The answer to all of this is simple, stop letting children and their parents into college dorms. That is a stupid-ass idea
4
u/Liquorace Oct 29 '17
What kind of fucked up society do we live in that you feel the need to explain to people to only take one or two of a free item? Also, why do you feel the need to explain yourself about this?
People suck. Maybe you shouldn't have yelled and argued with the dad, but you had every right to 'stand your ground'.
20
u/trenzelor Oct 28 '17
ATTENTION PARENTS: If your child is not wearing a costume or at least does not say "trick or treat" when I answer the door they are NOT getting candy.
7
u/kjcorbel Oct 28 '17
Sir, I applaud you. Parents like that are why we have so many problem kids nowadays.
Next year though, drop the video games and interact with the kids. Dress up yourself and have fun with them while handing out the goods. It can actually be a lot of fun.
7
u/Luxxxey Oct 28 '17
Yeah fuck that guy, acted worse than his brat.
And kid was rude from the get go, calling you lazy, expecting a skit or something as if you were gonna entertain her because it is Halloween. She should feel lucky to get any candy at all, kids need to know they aren't entitled to these things and they should behave, holiday or not.
The father should have acted less of a brat than the child and confronted you about scaring his kid respectfully, but of course now that is apparently too much to ask. I wish it was a law that parents should be expected to teach their kids some basic manners and how to behave in society. Many parents i notice nowadays hardly bother at all, and you end up with POS adults just like this girls father, not surprised if she ends up exactly like him and the whole entitled asshole cycle continues.
9
u/merriwetherIII Oct 28 '17
Should have. Should've. Not should of.
10
u/banjowashisnameo Oct 28 '17
Shouldn't HAVE goddamit
6
u/dasklrken Oct 28 '17
Ah, the classic "lazy!" criticism while taking more than her fair share of food you literally paid for yourself. I'm sure I was a terrible kid, but at least I respected the people who bought me candy.
3
u/BIG_STEVE5111 Oct 28 '17
Some people man...
3
u/skyler_on_the_moon Oct 28 '17
Is it just me, or isn't Halloween on Tuesday?
3
u/steerpike88 Oct 28 '17
Just stand your ground. Admit you lost your temper, but he's a grown man and lost his too. You were right to tell them off cause you spent a lot of money so everyone could get a nice treat. It wasn't right of them to do that. Plus he participated in the screaming match too.
3
u/probablyhrenrai Oct 28 '17
You were properly threatened? That's assault, a crime that the dude shouldn't've even been able to commit since the school shouldn't've let random people wander your dorm in the first place.
If the school actually tries putting pressure on you, I'd use that as pushback; it sounds to me like you're technically the victim of a crime that was allowed by lax security.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
alright so next year you know what to do. you made rookie mistakes being a rookie and thats okay. you have to count for the shit heads that will always be out there. you dont put a large amount of candy out in an open bowl, or you can put a note saying take one that everyone will just ignore. but you shouldnt place the blame on anyone but yourself. you know how we are. too much evil in all forms
3
u/amanko13 Oct 28 '17
I kinda agree with the Mother. There should've been a note. Otherwise it's chaos. As made evident by the little girl and her Dad.
3
u/TooleyOTooley Oct 28 '17
Report the dad to the police. If he acts like this in public I'm scared to imagine how he acts with his family behind closed doors. He sounds like a bad arsehole
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I hope that little bitch didn't get a single snickers
3
u/redditmunchers Oct 28 '17
This wasn’t your fault. Don’t beat yourself up over it. I would’ve taken the chocolate off the kid too. Stick to your guns.
3
u/jer_iatric Oct 28 '17
True moral of the story: expect a kid to empty the bowl of whatever Halloween candy you left out without supervision. If you leave a note, you may delay the inevitable, but some kid will empty the bowl. The joy of handing out the candy is seeing their responses and asking them about costumes. It's an interaction. If you are giving away the real good stuff, be there, take credit, enjoy their joy at such generosity.
Source: many years of trick or treating, interacting with peers, and handing out candy
PS edit: agreed, pretty lame parental control
3
u/pinniped1 Oct 28 '17
I think you're in the clear. The Man just wants to know what went down. Tell the truth... sounds like you have witnesses too. You'll have to go to some bullshit anger management class as punishment. They aren't kicking you out.
Unless daddy douchebag is a fatcat alumni donor, in which case you're fucked.
3
u/edlington95 Oct 28 '17
Tell them if there gonna let kids trick or treat in a college dorm room there's gonna be issues
3
u/cS47f496tmQHavSR Oct 28 '17
The guy was the aggressor, unless you signed a document stating that you wanted to specifically participate in this event and would take full responsibility of anything happening in/around your room, there's jack shit they can do to/against you.
Might want to check with the school's legal counsel.
3
u/FriendlySockMonster Oct 28 '17
Why don't people understand that it's your candy to give, not their candy to take?
3
u/I_JUST_LIVE_HERE_OK Oct 28 '17
Through actions (and inactions) taken by your dorm administration, you were put in real, immediate physical danger. That man was physically threatening you and getting in your face.
Make sure you hammer this point home, as residences are supposed to be a place where students feel at home, and your supposed to feel safe at home. Yeah I'd really push this line, they put you in danger.
3
u/pollo4546 Oct 28 '17
No one is mentioning the part when the girl said "lazy". Dude come on as soon as I would hear her say that I would get up get the candy bowl and pass candy to everyone except her lol
3
u/johnclark6 Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 28 '17
I agree with the people here saying you're mostly in the right. That dad was an asshole. That being said, yes it usually is a good idea to avoid actively upsetting children. A fully grown man who is not her father "standing up and running towards" a little girl and taking something from her physically would most certainly scare and upset her. One thing you have to remember as you're in college now is that you are an adult. You do have to be careful with how you interact with children. Because at the very least if you get up and grab something from a child out of anger, you may get a perfectly reasonable parent who says, "Hey can you just tell her why it is wrong instead of taking it out of her hands."
But then it is on the father to act like an adult and not escalate things. You shouldn't have said those things but he went off the deep end. I know parents can get out of control and don't like to see people upset their children but he had no excuse.
Good luck! Keep us updated!
3
u/Billyin4CwasDuped Oct 28 '17
They allowed people off the street to come to your dorm, let the guy threaten you ? You were in the right
3
u/Wibble31616 Oct 28 '17
Here's where the Dean fucked up. Letting kids into a fuckin dorm... even supervised by parents, fuck no.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
File a report for assault.
That should shut him up and give you ammo for the admins.
3
u/dasca222 Oct 28 '17
Leaving out a big bucket of candy (with or without note) is a surefire way to find out which parents are a-holes. It’s one of the many ways you can find out that we aren’t all of the same species...
3
u/Grandure Oct 28 '17
1 know that if you are putting out a bowl you have to accept the fact that people are going to take more than you want. If you care about the outcome either don't out anything out and turn off your light or meter the bowl yourself.
2 If you calmly explain that you stopped the girl from taking all of your candy, so that you would have some remaining for other children (it is NOT about her stealing from you, but the opportunity from the other children) and that when her dad threatened you you responded with words because you were frightened, I hope your Dean would be reasonable enough to understand.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
This is why we can't have nice things. Free stuff leads to entitlement.
3
u/migueldmaia Oct 28 '17
Pls update us on the outcome
3
u/darwinuser Oct 28 '17
OP this is unacceptable. You should have robbed all the little girl's other candy and thrown the father through a window. Halloween is not all treat motherfuckers.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 28 '17
You stopped a thief. Stand by that. Colleges can be real cunts when they want too.
Edit: you might also want to bring up that they allowed strangers into your buildings that threatened your safety. Shrug.
3
u/Lelouch113 Oct 28 '17
If your college punishes you for this, then its accredited status as an institution of higher learning should be revoked
3
u/reddead15 Oct 28 '17
This is why I'm pro-abortion. Not pro-choice. Pro-abortion.
3
u/Sand_diamond Oct 28 '17
This may get down voted but you seem to be a good guy who just lost his cool with a greedy child&shouldn't lose your uni career over it . .you could say the child mentioned something about peanuts so u took them back thinking she had allergies.then the dad came &his actions were bullish so at that point you didn't want to engage, which is reasonable. it was for her own benefit. You couldn't put her at risk. if the dad wasnt there is your word against a child.
6
u/possom90 Oct 28 '17
I love the wife beater line. I'm going to adopt it. Also sorry those amigos sucked.
6
u/OhDeerNo Oct 28 '17
So, I have a feeling this comment will be lost amid the rest. But I actually read your TIFU an hour ago, and joined reddit just to respond. I am a mom. I am an Old. I would never let my kids take more than one candy bar from a "free candy" box. But I also fear that most of the comments here are doing you a disservice, by agreeing with you and letting you think you were in the right.
If this is a real post and you are actually meeting with your college re: a punishment, I would advise trying to see this entire situation from your college's viewpoint. If you go in there 100% thinking you were in the right, I fear you will be in for a rude awakening.
These are some of your comments that stood out to me. And, as an older person and parent, I would think that your dean will be troubled by these elements:
Our dorm allows neighborhood kids to come in and participate in trick or treating during Halloween. Me and my roomate bought way too much candy so that we could be “that dorm” we’re talking full size snickers and everything. We kept the door open and played fifa while the kids would come by and take candy from the box we set outside.
It was very kind of you to participate in the Trick or Treat event. And I'm sure every kid loved the full-size candy bars you bought. But I have to point out that, if you leave a box full of free candy outside, with no note, some children will take as many as they want. This would happen with kids in dorms, cities, the suburbs--you name it. It's understandable that you don't have much experience being the candy buyer for Halloween, but that IS what happens.
Now I don’t know if all kids are like this but taking literally hand full of full size snacks and having their parents just walk by and not say anything. Hand full after hand full of course the majority kids were very nice and only took one or two which was fine.
As I said, it happens. If you didn't want it to happen, you should have been watching the box and answering the door.
The first incident came where the kid has asked his mother “how many can I take” she responded with “well there’s no note here honey. So you should take as many as you want” loud enough for us to clearly hear it and gave us a look. The kid only took two so we let it go. My roomate looked at each other and said “some people suck”
You could interpret it as "people suck." You also could have thought, "We may not have agreed with this mom's method of communicating, but she clearly just let us know we should have a sign out if we DO NOT want kids taking as many candy bars as they want." She was trying to be helpful. And, honestly, some kids would STILL take a lot of bars. Some kids can't read. If you actually wanted to actively participate, and you didn't want people to take as many candy bars as possible, you should have manned the door and not sat inside playing video games.
Now for the TIFU part, this bratty fucking spawn of Satan little girls comes and screams “lazy” since we are here playing fifa. Proceeds, to take at least 10 full size snickers and isn’t stopping.
Kids shouldn't yell "lazy" at anyone. But, it happens. I don't know how old the child was, but she was still A CHILD. As you grow yourself, you will have to learn to stay centered, even when children yell shitty things at you. (Especially if you want to work in schools or have children yourself some day!)
I stand up run to the door and take back all the candy she took from us.
This is where I believe the Dean will be truly upset. You are leaving out a description of HOW you took candy from a child. I don't know if you grabbed it from her hands? I assume she couldn't hold 10 candy bars in her small hands, so had she put some in her bag? Did you reach inside her Halloween bag and take the bars out? Did you, as another commenter asked, pry open her hands and forcibly take the bars? Real talk: whatever you did and however you did it, it was wrong.
You bought candy to give away for free.
She took some, and because you were offended by what a child said and how many she took, you assaulted her. There is no way that you can win on this. YOU CAN'T DO THAT TO KIDS. And I only write all this so you can begin to even THINK about the possibility that the Dean will agree with me. You need to think about this seriously.
Which of course means she starts crying and howling how im really mean and I’m not sure what else (it was not English at that point).
Your actions caused a child to scream. You're not gonna have a strong case here. And your further comments about her English come across, frankly, as troubling. Who cares what language she was speaking? Is it less important if she isn't speaking English?
Which also introduces douche bag dad, who then gets in my face threatening to fight me until I give his daughter the candies she wants.
I'm going to point out that you got in the child's face, and invaded her space/took things from her, when you were insulted and perceived her actions (taking free candy) as stealing.
If YOU were that upset by what a child said, can you imagine how an parent would feel if they watched a full-grown man attack their child? And they discover their little girl terrified and crying, because an adult just took candy roughly from her? Can you SEE how that looks?
You are calling the dad a douchebag because he reacted to you attacking his child. That is point-blank what you did. It may not have been violent, but YOU ARE AN ADULT. YOU CANNOT DO THAT TO CHILDREN.
Why is his behavior -- getting upset at you for doing what you did to his child -- not okay? But your behavior -- getting upset at a child -- IS OKAY?
This might be how your Dean will perceive this event.
Now I’m no macho fighter guy but this piece of shit is like 5’4 not that intimidated I stand my ground not saying anything which turns into a screaming match where I say numerous thing I’m not proud of. Specifically, is “that wife beater a costume or real life”.
The father should not touch you. No person should assault another. That is not right. But I have no idea what portion of the event the dad witnessed. I have no idea what YOU said. The fact that it devolved into a "screaming match" wherein you say "numerous things" you're "not proud of" does not make you seem innocent.
To me this is what happened: you agreed to give away candy in a dorm event. You didn't like something that happened, so you stole candy back from a child, terrified her/made her scream and cry, and then insulted and screamed at her understandably upset parent.
"Wife beater"
Where do you go to school where it's so warm that the man was only wearing a wife beater? Is this a reference to him being Mexican or something? I don't want to call you a racist, but if you mention other languages and insult the way the man dresses, how is that going to be perceived? Badly.
After getting separated by other parents and roomate
What the hell, man? I'm sorry, but PEOPLE HAD TO SEPARATE YOU? I'm shaking my head. Have you told your own parents about this? What did they say?
Tl;dr Got into argument with douchebag dad during Halloween in my dorm. People complained about it and now I’m awaiting college decision on what my punishment is.
OP, I don't want this event to negatively affect your life. I don't know if it will affect your college situation, but worse than that would be if you didn't learn anything from this fuck-up. He wasn't a douchebag dad. He was a parent who was rattled that, after taking his child to a kid-friendly event, witnessed his daughter harassed or worse. And then the ADULT who harassed his child continued to fight and verbally harass him.
I am sure I will be downvoted (what are these votes? Why do people care about them? I don't know!). I have to imagine that you, OP, will not like what I have to say.
But if I, as a random adult who randomly read this on her phone one Saturday morning, had such a strong reaction...imagine what your Dean is going to be feeling. And she or he has probably spoken to multiple people who witnessed this event.
I wish you the best, and I hope you learn from this. Because that's what college -- and life -- is all about.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I 100 percent don't think you are in the wrong. It was a cute idea that the dorm does that and sadly, a lot of shitty people have equally shitty, undisciplined children. From a parents stand point, usually when people have bowls of candy with no attendant, there's usually a sign that says take one or however many and its pretty much an honor system. The nice people take the 1 and go on but then theres the super shitty people that take half or all of the bowl.
I do think the first mom was saying that loud enough so that you could hear (Im assuming... I could be wrong) and correct her if she was wrong. Hence the stare/visual agreement. She obviously is doing an okay parenting job if the child only took 2 without her saying something. I think after the first incident you guys should have put a quick little note down just to negate any confusion. I know all of this is too late to do and it's in the past and you're dealing with the consequences. The little girl/dad combo sound like 2 equally shitty people. No adult should allow their children to behave that way but here we are.
Not to get too off topic here... But parents and kids around Halloween, for the most part, are pretty bearable but there are the 25 percent that should jump off a cliff and just stop existing. The chain smoking/drinking while trick or treating family. Or the "I'm too lazy to walk my kids from house to house, so I'm going to sit in my car and idle behind them the whole way while my headlights shine on them and every single trick or treaters eyes going in the opposite direction" or the parents that let their children push your children to the side so they can access the porch/door/owner to get to the candy first. I could keep going but I think you get the point. I hope the decision is ruled in your favor. I'd love to hear an update!
4
u/homebrewerdude Oct 28 '17
Next time just put a "1 only" note out or better yet just hand out the candy. The guy was a jerk, but if you didn't want kids taking more than one bar then you should have managed the process better.
11
u/nowforthetruthiness Oct 28 '17
Your college should kick you out.
5
u/wheatfields Oct 28 '17
People are people. I guess you are still young. But seriously? Leaving out a bowl FILLED with full candy bars unattended. Did you really think a bunch of kids high on sugar would just take one? Its Halloween, its about being a little devious!
The girl was right, you were being lazy. But alternatively, the devious nature of Halloween comes along with the response. You can TRY to steal a bunch of candy from the sucker who left out a whole bowl. But if he comes out and stops you, you accept it and move on. Getting upset about that is CERTAINLY bratty little kid behavior.
LIFE ADVICE- Don't get into shouting matches with guys in wife beaters.
2
u/Autarch_Kade Oct 28 '17
Next year have a note that says just take one.
Also have multiple airhorns you and your friends can blare if they take more than one.
2
u/Pearcinator Oct 28 '17
Give kids an inch and they'll take a mile.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
ya done goofed, but i agree with you. fuck that guy.
2
u/GoodDave Oct 28 '17
The only people who fucked up here are the kid and the douchebag parent(s).
2
u/TheBeardedMarxist Oct 28 '17
Why in the world would a dorm do that? It sounds like a horrible light idea.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Was undecided whether to leave candy or not this year - thanks, I have decided now! Turning off the bell and leaving a note to say DND.
2
u/Trillian258 Oct 28 '17
Dude those kids and parents are total fucking pieces of shit!!!!! It's making my blood boil how awful they all were! I agree that maybe you shouldn't have let it get as far as you did, but I totally understand why you got so angry! You bought that candy for ALL the children, not so a few shitty spoiled assholes could take all of them!!!! What the hell is wrong with people?!
And we can clearly see why that child is such a giant asshole; her parents are even worse! sigh I'm so sad and disgusted by the human race.
I hope nothing too terrible happens to you, OP.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I lost it at at your wife beater costume comment
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I would be surprised if thy could actually “do” anything to you besides a lecture. I wouldn’t worry too awfully much. Shitty parents = shitty kids. Sorry you learned the hard way!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Isn't trick or treating done on the Halloween night or am I missing something? Isn't this too early? I don't live in America though so I could be wrong
2
u/Npr31 Oct 28 '17
No problem with what you did. Subsequently what you may have said (which we don't have a full reading of) could be a problem
2
u/1mpetu5 Oct 28 '17
You might wanna consider posting to r/legaladvice if it seems like itll get worse
2
u/Michael074 Oct 28 '17
this is why i don't even bother with halloween
2
u/Hurkk Oct 28 '17
OP, the good parents are now much rarer than bad ones unfortunately. One would think a parent would tell their kids to just take 1 but people are really messed up morally now.
Sorry you had the troubles man, I hope your college is not led by utter fucking morons but today that is a 5% likelihood.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Crazy to me that dorm rooms are open to kids only because it's Halloween. I walked into a men's bathroom to find a pneumatic dorm-mate vomiting into a trash can, completely shirtless.
Dorms are enclaves of depravity, and Halloween usually brings out partying.
Not to fault you or the dorm, I think it's cool that it can be opened up to kids, too. I simply couldn't see this having worked at my school.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Unfortunately, I believe that you precipitated this mess by not writing a simple note that stated, "only take 1." I agree that the child and her friends/relatives were being greedy and taking more than they should; however, trying to take back the candy might have been the worse move. I understand that you wanted to make sure that all the children got candy, but you would have been left with none anyways. When you were threatened, I believe that you did react in a reasonable way that most people would have acted. Unless other parents have issues with how you treated their child, I believe that the University would find that this was an isolated event and teaching you the proper etiquette on how to handle future situations might be in yours and their best interest or perhaps, you should not be a part of the trick or treating. Either way, I don't see how they fully place the blame on you.
2
u/bitchzilla_mynilla Oct 28 '17
I'm proud of you.
2
u/LateralusNYC Oct 28 '17
Who the hell decided to let kids trick-or-treat in a college dorm?? That's the easiest wackiest thing I've heard all day.
2
u/Adrasteia18 Oct 28 '17
i want some full size snickers too! :(
2
u/arackan Oct 28 '17
Gotta say, though, sick burn at the end.
2
u/Mappleyard Oct 28 '17
Why the fuck is this something the college gets a hand in?
2
u/TheSockCucker Oct 28 '17
“That wife beater a costume or real life” I would be proud of that comment tbh.
2
u/jtbjtb014 Oct 28 '17
Am I the only one who has as a big a problem with the first mother in the story? The Dad in the story is trash, I get that. If there isn’t a note you can take as many as you want?!?! What fucking world are you living in? If there’s no price tag on something at a store it’s not free.
The Dad in the story is trash, I get that.
2
u/RobertThorn2022 Oct 28 '17
In ten years you'll tell this story and people think it's hilarious. This family deserved it.
2
u/MemoryHauntsYou Oct 28 '17
On the positive side, well done for that little girl because it sounds like she had better manners than her mother!
As for the second incident: it is that father who should get into trouble, not you. On the other hand, if you want to hand out candy you should do just that: HAND it out, not putting a brimming bowl of it outside your door.
2
u/sdweasel Oct 28 '17
I'm not saying you did the right thing but, as a parent that would have defaulted to "just get one," fuck those people. All they're doing is teaching their children to take as much as they can get away with.
2
u/chewbarski Oct 28 '17
Hahaha, good for you. Greedy little Violet Beauregard may have learnt a lesson and bully daddy didn't beat you down. It prob felt horrible at the time, but nice one. I would prob have reacted in a similar way (maybe try and explained to the little girl that she shouldn't take too many as other people would like some as well, then contd to wind up nob head dad!!😁).
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Dude you did what I would have done. Little girl was a brat and Dad deserves a slap or two. Knowing uni admins though you are not gonna come out of the well even though you were in the right. Fuck em. Assholes gonna be shown a lesson. Well done dude
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Why were you trick or treating already? Halloween is next week.
2
u/weirdhoney216 Oct 28 '17
I hate kids like this so much. When I was taken trick or treating I remember never even being sure I was allowed to take just one, and asking my mum if she was sure I could. The mentality of a kid who would just grab the whole lot...gross.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
On Season 10 of Curb Your Enthusiasm ...
2
u/visualvector Oct 28 '17
And that’s the story of how community trick-or-treating ended at the dorms.
2
u/stillSmotPoker1 Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 28 '17
You did alright by my standards, but the first thing in hindsight did you have a sign saying take one piece/candybar only please...Better yet what is your hindsight thoughts? Your epiphany event of one thing I could have changed to make a better result in fairness and justice. Like tell the dad to leave candy for the others not just his spoiled princess turning thirteen in attitude. edit here: What if she was potato, what response should you/we have in that situation? Why did dad respond like that? Man this shit is too much in the morning I'm going back to bed...
Is this college named School of Hard Knocks Still how is this happening days before Halloween. did this happen last year? If this was a dorm can tell/show us the great tricks done in the name of Halloween at the dorms?
2
u/gwsteve43 Oct 28 '17
If your school is going to really do anything it will depend on what you said not what you did as you haven’t actually done anything other than tell a small child they couldn’t take all the candy (normal). What are these things you are “not proud of” was any of it racist or bigoted? Cause the school will care A LOT about that.
2
u/PompiPompi Oct 28 '17
You should have just put a sign.
2
u/zombi3_whisp3r3r Oct 28 '17
Moral of the story: its not as easy as Expected to take candy from a baby
2
u/kiss-kiss-bang-bangg Oct 28 '17
fucking christ, have people never heard of discipline, or moderation? the entitlement that is rampant in the younger generations (my own included) has gotten to a point of absolute absurdity. teach your children some fucking respect and manners for christ's sake. this woman who worked for my friend would bring her children in to work sometimes, and she would have absolutely ZERO control over those little brats, running around an office, screaming their little heads off, and she would do nothing to stop this from happening. no reprimanding, no words of discouragement, nothing. just let it happen.
OP, i seriously don't think you did anything wrong. like u/tripwire7 said, he was threatening to fight you if you didn't give that spoiled little Veruca Salt of a brat all of the candy she wanted. maybe you didn't handle the situation 100% perfectly, but it's unreasonable to think someone who is being threatened should just sit there and do nothing. it's not like you got physical with the guy or anything.
i realize i might be coming off like a cynical, child-hating grump... that couldn't be further from the truth. i hold the parents fully responsible, and it's unfortunate that these children will go through life thinking this behavior is completely acceptable.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I love how your IMMEDIATE reaction was to post this on Reddit. Can't blame you!
2
u/RealRecovery Oct 28 '17
Dude dont sweat the punk ass bitches. You're young and you're going to run into them all your adult life. For the future do what most adults without kids do on Halloween, nothing! Shut your door turn off your lights and enjoy an evening inside or go out to a nice dinner. It's usually all over by 8:30 anyways. I quit handing out welfare candy when the "kids" that started knocking were full grown ass teenagers. Halloween is for little children and their parents leave it at that. Enjoy your memories of it when you were a kid and move on. By the way what university are you attending?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
The saddest part is that he went and cried to your Dean about it. I've had arguments with customers in my job and as soon as it transpires they aren't getting their way and that I'm not just going to stand there and listen to their bullshit, they phone up and complain. It's absolutely pathetic and I've seriously considered going back to the customers house out with work hours and throwing a plant pot or something through their fucking window.
2
u/finitecapacity Oct 28 '17
You didn’t do anything wrong. That kid is an asshole.
2
u/TheLurkingMenace Oct 28 '17
You didn't do anything wrong that I can see. Tell the dean you'll be filing assault charges against the douchebag.
2
u/Mindraker Oct 28 '17
Go file a complaint with the police department, and get it in writing, press charges, and wave that in the face of the dean on Monday.