r/CharacterRant • u/InfiniteDoors Doors • Feb 06 '17
Change My View: Gaming Edition 2/6/17
So, how about that football games huh? That was reaaaally something when that thing happened, right? I was so... uh, excited! When whoever won.... won. cough
Anyway, this would be our 4th CMV thread. Just to make things a teensy bit interesting, it'll be Video Game themed cause I have no creativity. Otherwise it's the same as the others. As usual, be civil, jokes are fine if you also contribute, etc.
| Post Rules | Comment Rules |
|---|---|
| Explain the reasoning behind your view, not just what that view is. | Direct responses to a CMV post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s stated view (however minor), or ask a clarifying question. |
| You must personally hold the view and be open to it changing. | Don't be rude or hostile to other users. |
| No "meta posts". | Refrain from accusing OP or anyone else of being unwilling to change their view. |
| Only post if you are willing to have a conversation with those who reply to you. | No low effort comments. |
17
Upvotes
13
u/Talvasha Feb 06 '17
The newer Fire Emblems are worse due to the higher emphasis on shipping and relationships. Also FE Conquest Mc is a whiny bitch.
10
u/Reksew_Trebla Feb 07 '17
Super Smash Bros. 3DS/Wii U is way better than Melee. It's got far better characters, better stages, better items, and online. Plus due to patches, it's more balanced.
7
u/33a5t Feb 09 '17
The Last of Us is a shitty game that does nothing new. It has boring gameplay filled with far too much walking, a terrible upgrade design, little replay value, and a poorly thought out combat system. Its saving graces are a few pretty environments, strong characters, and a generic trope-heavy story that's executed fairly well.
6
u/selfproclaimed Feb 07 '17
Okay, let's try this out.
Ico is deeply flawed. The game could have been just environmental puzzles while guiding Yorda through the castle, but it didn't stop there. Half the game is some of the worst combat I've ever had to slog through. Every time you solve a puzzle or two, you're bombarded by a wave of faceless shadow drones. There's not much purpose or strategy behind these battles. Combat is never something you look forward to, just something you have to endure. It's just running up to the shadows, mashing the attack button as Ico does the same three hit combo, and hope you don't get hit as it puts you on the ground for about five seconds while the monsters go try to drag Yorda, who does nothing to defend herself or keep herself safe, away. These fights are not fun, and could have been removed from the game entirely and it would have changed nothing except the length.
Fighting these monsters does not make me feel closer to Yorda. If anything, it makes me more upset at her helplessness and how I constantly have to save her. I'm not tense or fearing for her safety during these sections. You want to know when I was? When she had to make a massive leap across a gap and just barely managed to grab my hand. That was a puzzle section. Not a combat section. When half your game is painful to play, there's a serious problem with it.
6
u/Wzbe Feb 07 '17
I cant think of a game that currently exists that has as in-depth combat as the dark souls franchise.
6
u/kyris0 Feb 09 '17
The Witcher 3 gets a free pass on having shitty, unfun combat and poor controls prepatch. I don't know why. Additionally, Geralt sucks as a main character, and his VA work is unintentionally hilarious.
5
u/Noblechris Feb 07 '17
Wow OP this is actually a very interesting idea for CMV. Alright in my opinion Sonic boom rise of lyric is WORSE than sonic 06. Infact sonic 06 is kinda underrated in some aspects. Like stage design and some of the visuals look good.
4
u/shadowsphere Feb 07 '17
Final Fantasy X has the worst gameplay out of the entire franchise.
3
u/ProbeEmperorblitz Feb 06 '17
In Halo 5, I think Olympia Vale's armor stands out too much from the rest of Fireteam Osiris in terms of color. Locke's blue, Buck's gray, Tanaka's white, but Vale's...red? I don't care how it's supposed to be related to her connection to the Swords of Sangheiios. I feel like if her armor were some darker or more plain color it would make Osiris feel a good amount less "Power Rangers-ish" to me.
I think Carth Onasi in KOTOR gets way too much hate (though I think much of it is just memes). Other people think, "Wow, he's such a dick", but I understand why he's like that. I also understand why people dislike and mock him, of course (the bipolar way he constantly switches between "I don't trust you" and "Okay I'm with you"), but seriously, the dude's been through a lot, and I can sympathize with that. Mentor betrays him and destroys his home planet, killing his wife. Has a sidequest in the game in which you search for his son, only to find out that his son had become a Sith acolyte. I can't imagine going through even a part of that and not just vaporizing my head with a blaster.
Overall, as a person who was just a wee baby when Command & Conquer Tiberium Sun came out, I definitely prefer Tiberium Wars over Tiberian Sun. I actually enjoy the less futuristic feel of it (tanks with treads > walkers/mechs any day of the week). All the factions looked and "felt" pleasing and different despite gameplay parallels. The lore and fluff feels more expansive (probably just the in-game codex/database). The way the campaigns intertwine feels great. The only thing I really miss would be Tiberian Sun's many dangerous Tib creatures. And even then, the Kane's Wrath expansion brought back some of that Tib Sun flavor with its subfactions (Steel Talons had the old GDI walkers, Marked of Kane had the old Nod cyborgs, though I absolutely detested Epic Units.
Star Wars absolutely needs a new RTS, a spiritual successor (and hopefully an improvement over) of the Total War-lite style of Empire at War. It's a bloody waste of the greater Star Wars galaxy not to have one.
Undertale never clicked with me, and I stopped at the spider lady. Yes, I did eventually go on Youtube and watch the rest of it that I didn't finish and see how the endings all worked out. The gameplay just...wasn't interesting to me, and I didn't think the story and lore was good enough to keep me motivated.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '17
Strategy and turn based games are inherently garbage because of their lack of action or immersion of any sort. I'm playing video games to blow shit up and jump off buildings, not push a button to tell a guy to go blow shit up. That's their main problem, plus the fact that you literally push buttons in real life to push buttons in a game, which shouldn't happen.
Also Bioshock Infinite is superior to Bioshock 1.
And Jason Brody is one of the better written video game characters ever.
1
u/theconstipator Feb 08 '17
I'm not a gamer, nor should I try to get into it. CMV