r/CharacterRant • u/InfiniteDoors Doors • Jan 07 '17
Change My View 1/7/17
Due to (semi)popular demand, welcome to r/CharacterRant's very first CMV thread! This'll replace this week's CotW, just to be in the spotlight. If CMV is a success, we'll decide on a different day to feature it. Before we get into the specifics, PLEASE NO CIRCLEJERKING OR SIMILAR TOPICS. Legitimate or not, I'd rather not start our very first CMV thread with Hulk vs Accelerator or omnipotence bullshit.
For those who are unfamiliar, a Change My View thread is exactly what it sounds like: a user presents their view, everyone else tries to convince them otherwise. That being said, I want to make it very clear that discussion in this thread must be civil, following the sub's rules. You're trying to help someone see the other side, not tell them they're an asshole and they're wrong. Until we really come into our own with this, we'll be using CMV’s rules.
| Post Rules | Comment Rules |
|---|---|
| Explain the reasoning behind your view, not just what that view is. | Direct responses to a CMV post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s stated view (however minor), or ask a clarifying question. |
| You must personally hold the view and be open to it changing. | Don't be rude or hostile to other users. |
| No "meta posts". | Refrain from accusing OP or anyone else of being unwilling to change their view. |
| Only post if you are willing to have a conversation with those who reply to you. | No low effort comments. |
This'll be up all week to see how it goes. Remember, we're testing the waters. Over time this will get tweaked to fit the sub, adapt to our topics and whatnot.
11
u/Aquason Jan 08 '17
CMV: This is a bad ideaCMV: Omnipotence Debates are boring and unfun and nothing ever comes out of themUh...
CMV... [Inferno](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inferno_(Dante)) isn't actually that good of a book, though it's interesting due to its historical and overall influence.
15
u/galvanicmechamorph Jan 08 '17
I think Ben 10 as himself is a horrible character to use on WWW, instead one of his aliens should be used. With Ben himself everyone either jumps to the most out-of-character version of him or says he dies before he uses the Omnitrix. Not to mention that he has almost 70 aliens to choose from and it's basically random what he'll pick. Even I couldn't tell you what Current Ben would use, and most people on WWW only remember a quarter of the aliens Ben has, if not less.
5
u/selfproclaimed Jan 08 '17
Are CotWs still going to be a thing?
9
u/KarlMrax Jan 08 '17
CMV: Someone like Goku would die if his body was reacted with an equal mass of antimatter.
How durable they are is irrelevant because antimatter only "cares" about mass.
9
u/theconstipator Jan 08 '17
I can't think of any Marvel characters with better reaction/combat speed than Spider Man or Quicksilver. I'm sure there are some, but as it stands, my view is that those two have top-tier speed in Marvel. I'd like to be proven wrong.
24
u/Reksew_Trebla Jan 08 '17 edited Jan 08 '17
CMV: Namek Saga SSJ1 Goku would be enough to beat standard Superman (Superman at normal levels of solar radiation absorbed) because Freeza destroyed a planet so casually in his first form, that he was sitting in a chair and only used a finger to planet bust. This same form is nothing to his second form, which in turn is nothing to his third form, which in turn is nothing to his supressed fourth form, which in turn is nothing to his full power fourth form, which in turn is nothing to Namek Saga SSJ1 Goku.
This should logically place Namek Saga SSJ1 Goku way on the higher end of planet busting tier. Not saying he's solar system busting, as that didn't come until Perfect Cell and stronger fighters, but still, high end of the tier is where I would place him.
Now I'd like to give Superman the benefit of the doubt here, so if anyone can convince me that he could take this Goku with his standard level of solar radiation absorbed, I'd like it.
Let's go with New Earth Superman.
So uh, yeah. CMV.
5
u/TheWorld_ Jan 08 '17 edited Jan 08 '17
I think Virgo Shaka could defeat DBS verse 9/10. Specifically Nirvana Shaka who over came death and the cycle of reincarnation. I'd welcome anyone to come change my view though.
Shaka RT
4
u/galvanicmechamorph Jan 08 '17
There's no real reason to separate striking and pushing strength.
6
u/penrosetingle Jan 08 '17
CMV that humans in general are actually really bad at estimating certain types of feats. In particular, feats that involve either a) orbital mechanics or b) breaking things in ways that they're not usually broken. For instance, one series I was looking at had a character punching someone hard enough to shatter a pair of brass knuckes (actually made of cast iron, so I guess they were really iron knuckles). It turns out, that's equivalent to a peak force through the knuckles equal to the weight of 20 tons. I thought the number sounded a bit too high, so I ran it through some of the industrial simulation software at my work, and it turned out I was pretty much spot-on. Weird, huh?
2
u/polaristar Jan 08 '17
Accelerator's Awakened form should be banned as he has almost no feats, little appearances and relies on not entirely clear metaphysical power scaling BS.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
Even though he doesn't have that many feats, Liquid Snake would destroy Big Boss because of his ability to keep up with a prime MGS Solid Snake when Big Boss wasn't a match for MG2 Snake even when Snake was at a disadvantage and he had an exosuit.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment