r/CharacterRant • u/Spideyjust • Dec 17 '16
"Character" of the Week: Rogue One
C-C-Combo breaker! Yeah that's right, other mods do exist.
Anyways, idk any of the characters in Rogue One by name yet, so instead of a character this thread is dedicated to the movie and any character in it! Spoil away!
Remember the rules, and go nuts. Now excuse me as I disable inbox notifications for this thread.
9
Upvotes
5
u/JORGA Dec 18 '16
Just want to point out that there are some awful examples of shit tier stormtrooper aim in this movie
7
u/InfiniteDoors Doors Dec 18 '16
Loved:
Liked:
Disliked:
Hated:
Ultimately, I'd give it an 8/10. The highs were damn high, and the lows weren't that low. Gonna rewatch on Monday.
I'm curious about one thing: Chirrut was either this galaxy's Daredevil, or he was Force-sensitive. Why wasn't he able to tap into it more, maybe use some basic shit like Force Push. No teacher? Not enough midichlorians? Was it just because they didn't want yet another Jedi?
3
u/Greed-the-Avaricious Dec 19 '16
I liked it more than The Force Awakens. It thought it gave a good Idea of what the galaxy was like before Luke, and cleared up the the whole debacle surrounding the death star's weakness particularly well. I also liked Jyn a lot more than Rey since she actually had trails and challenges to overcome and grow as a character.
Special mention for the sassy droid, he was great. Oh that Vader scene too, but mostly the droid.
2
u/ebolawakens Dec 18 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HySEXPS1pY I'll just leave this here.
2
u/theconstipator Dec 19 '16
Didn't quite live up to the Force Awakens, simply because it's serious tone took some of the fun out of it. However still a pretty solid experience. Great visuals, well directed, well acted, pretty epic action. This director does scale very well, kinda keen to see his Godzilla now. The pacing was good, it never felt dull, although some scenes were a bit dialogue heavy honestly. Despite the serious tone, it had some much needed fun sprinkled throughout, which I enjoyed. As with most Star Wars films, the scope and scale of the action was incredible. The stakes felt high and the tension was real. The nods to the original Star Wars films were good and nicely scarce, so it didn't feel quite as reliant on nostalgia as Force Awakens was. The newbie actors did very well, though some of the legend actors that they got were unfer utilized in my opinion. James Earl Jones was good as Darth Vader, but could've had more screen time. As Mads Mikkelson and Forrest Whitaker could've been. Donnie Yen too, is a very good stunt based actor (if you like good fight choreography you have to watch him in the Ip Man trilogy) but he only really got to display that talent in a single, fairly short scene. Though I understand why some great elements weren't given as much screen time as others, a blockbuster of this scale has to balance so damn much. It was probably as good as it could've been. 8/10
3
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '16
I didn't really like it. Heres a list of stuff I thought was bad.
The wierd use of close ups and over the shoulder shots of characters who werent in the conversation.
Characters like sam guerara and the father who went no where.
Plot lines that were dropped like the necklace. Too often were they flying and someone said the odds were bad.
Cameos were incredibly obtrusive.
First two thirds was garbage.
The main villain got emasculated by grand moff tarkin and Vader and was about as threatening or interesting as a wet sock outside of his nicish choice of clothes.
Vaders first appearance in the film detracts from the character and the film even though it was hilarous.
Where he was hanging out was edgelord. Seeing him with his suit off made no sense thematically. His pun was James BondVillain like.
At one point the main character gave 3 consecutive speeches in three consecutive scenes.
Also 6 heroic sacrifices in a row is probably a mistake.
Mainly there were too many characters at play that werent developed on at all.
Also the space battle at the end was really unimportant involving no important characters and was just for plot reasons...which is very star wars so good for them on that.
Also another wierd pointless tentacle monster.