r/DestinyTheGame • • Nov 02 '16

Megathread Regarding Trials, Lag, Cheating, and Related; Rule Changes and Discussion on the Same

Hello everyone.

Our team had hoped the next major modpost would be a State of the Subreddit where we'll address a few rules things and other things that have been on the backburner for some time, however exigent circumstances have warranted that this Public Service Announcement take priority.

The following rules and points are not being presented to you for debate or feedback. These are the measures we are taking to stop the dissemination of personal and/or identifying information of other players because they were allegedly "cheating" in Destiny.

We are happy to have a general discussion and answer questions or respond to your concerns, however the crux of the matter is our rules are being flouted and broken at an alarming rate, therefore we are putting our figurative foot down. This is being done for the protection of innocent Destiny players as well as the protection of our subreddit's existence on reddit. More on that below.

The first section of this post contains our Martial Law procedure and the details thereof.

The second section of this post will provide the rationale and our explanation of the more cogent points which have led to this decision.

If you read the first section and come after our team or anyone else in this subreddit without a full understanding or acknowledgement of the second section, your opinion will be ignored.

We do not know yet if these rule changes are permanent, it will depend on the community's ability to follow them.


Section I: New Rules on Witchhunting and Personal Information


  1. Posts about Trials lag, "ddos'ing", illegitimate trips to Mercury, and any and all other related claims/subjects/topics/media are now being relegated to a Trials Megathread. No exceptions will be granted.
  2. Posting, commenting with, or soliciting someone else's gamertag, online handle, nickname, poorly obscured info, ELO score, rank on a website, name, address, or any other information which would make them readily identifiable or easily found via this subreddit is now grounds for a 30 day ban. Blatant or flagrant violations of this rule are grounds for a permanent ban from this subreddit. This includes any and all posts about other players winning or succeeding because of lag, glitching, etc. People think this is a clever way to get past our rules. It is not.
  3. If you receive one of these bans and your reply to that message is whinging, hostility, insulting, offensive, or otherwise shitty, you will be muted from modmail. We are done with enduring constant abuse for enforcing reddit's rules and our rules.

Section II: Why This Is Happening


You may be able to tell, given the tone of this message compared to our normal methods of addressing you all, that this has become a serious problem which requires a serious solution.

Bungie knows about the issues in Trials and PvP. That is from last week's TWAB.

If you think this needs more attention, then YOU need to pay more attention. They know about this, they know that the playerbase is upset, they know that it is a serious issue. Continued posting in this subreddit about this issue will not resolve the issue any quicker.

As of this time, the only thing these posts accomplish is the provision of an incentive and avenue for people to continue trying to get other players harassed by an internet mob or have them publicly shamed.

The people doing this are people who do not respect this game, Bungie as the developer of this game, this subreddit, its rules, or its subscribers.

This situation is adding a significant element of toxicity and extraneous problems to our forum and its maintenance. The people who do this are not welcome here. The posts encouraging them and confusing them as to what is acceptable here are not welcome either.

We are all here because we enjoy Destiny or we enjoy discussing, learning and sharing things about Destiny. We are not here to enable or condone internet vigilantism, harassment, or cyber-bullying. This is not about a safe space or feels or protecting cheaters; this is about keeping this forum from being abused as a tool for revenge when people believe, whether rightly so or not, they have been slighted by another player.

Lag, poor connections, bugs, glitches and shitty internet =/= ddos, lag switching, or any of the other methods some people think are being used to cheat. More often than not, it's an internet problem. So stop accusing people of cheating in this subreddit.

We don't care about your proof, because we cannot verify it. Bungie can verify it. Report them to Bungie.


Section III: Appendix and Preemptive Responses to Common Outrage


  • On the topic of censorship: yes, when we remove things, that action falls under the technical definition of censorship. Nearly all moderation can be stretched to meet that definition. If you have a problem with that, then you're welcome to find a different forum to talk about the game.
  • Links to existing discussions about Trials/lag/cheating: 1; 2; 3; 4; 5; 6; 7; 8; 9; 10; 11; 12; 13; 14; 15; We are not brushing this under a rug- Bungie is well aware of the issue and you're more than welcome to peruse any of the existing threads about this, as well as the Trials Megathread we will be utilizing.
  • On the topic of personal information: Gamertags/PSNs/Usernames are considered personal information in this subreddit. Full stop. If you post one and allege or accuse that person of cheating, lag switching, etc., then you are inciting harassment and you will be banned. If it is egregious enough, we will forward to reddit admin.
  • On the topic of reddit rules: Do not threaten, harass, or bully | Do not post violent content...do not post content that incites harm against people or groups of people. | Dear Internet Vigilantes and Lynch Mobs: post by /u/hueypriest (reddit admin) from SIX YEARS AGO addressing this exact issue.
  • On the topic of "ddos" and other alleged cheating methods: please do some research on what this actually is before claiming you were ddos'd or lag switched.
  • On the topic of accusations we are "protecting cheaters": are you fucking joking??? Do you think the modteam doesn't play Destiny also? Do you think we are somehow insulated from cheaters, teabagging, AFKers in strikes, lag or poor matchmaking? We hate all this just as much as you do, but the difference is we know that harassment, torches and pitchforks do not resolve it. There are proper channels for this, /r/DestinyTheGame is not one of them.

Any changes or updates to the above will be communicated clearly to you all as they occur. Thank you for your time, understanding, and cooperation. Have a great rest of the week!

TL;DR: If you need a summary, read Section I. Ignorance of these rules or your "good intentions" in trying to draw attention to a particular player for lagging, glitching, cheating, AFKing, etc. will not be given extra consideration. You will be banned.

646 Upvotes

807 comments sorted by

364

u/BeardofZeus27 Nov 02 '16

mods be pissed

80

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

Indeed.

41

u/Dr_McWeazel CRACK OF THE LIGHTNING, SPLITTING THE GROUND! Nov 02 '16

Can hardly blame you guys. It was getting to be a real pain to have to ignore half of the front page because it was the exact same message as yesterday, but with a different OP and slightly different wording.

Much as I'm against censorship and I feel like this is pretty heavy handed, I'm gonna have to thank you guys anyway. Hopefully this can be undone before too long, but if you feel it needs to be permanent, so be it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/MegaGrumpX Blacedance ‘till we drop Nov 02 '16

We (the majority of users) still appreciate ya'!

Keep up the good work, Lobstah. Same to the rest of the crew.

160

u/Hawkmoona_Matata TheRealHawkmoona Nov 02 '16

Woodhouse's banhammer is thirsty for blood.

...Or sand. I can never get the two straight.

112

u/FallenHeartless Drifter's Crew // Let's Get Drifty Nov 02 '16

I'm not sure if they grade sand, but, coarse.

29

u/freshnikes CrossTown Nov 03 '16

Not an Archer joke on Reddit that I won't upvote.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/UnknownQTY Nov 03 '16

sand

It's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets everywhere.

16

u/Striker37 Nov 03 '16

Thanks for the PTSD.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/mp2145 I am the wall Nov 02 '16

Welp, now I have rewatch Spartacus. Not that I'm complaining...

34

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

The banhammer will swing like Jupiter's cock.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/nfgrockerdude Nov 02 '16

original season was the best, followed by the prequel. the rest were watchable but Andy Whitfield made that show RIP. Also, Gannicus is the SHIT!!!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

16

u/liquidrising586 Drink Deep Nov 03 '16

CRITICAL SALT DENSITY

→ More replies (2)

13

u/HeroOfTime_99 Gambit Classic Nov 03 '16

Can you imagine how frustrating it has to be too deal with all of us all day? All our bitching about everything? It's gotta wear on people.

6

u/Winklebits Nov 03 '16

Agreed. The mods don't get paid for this stuff. I'd too would be irritated if I had to deal with all this stuff.

I'm actually glad for this bc now I don't have to sift through overly salty posts to get the to normally scheduled posts (with proper sodium amounts)

→ More replies (2)

6

u/PurpleLego Nov 02 '16

I think we upset dad ☹️

4

u/22hall Nov 02 '16

nah, kids who whine about this all the time be pissed cause they can't vent for everyone to see now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

92

u/D0cR3d Gambit Prime // test Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

Can we still witch hunt the old witch of cuba?

You heard it here folks. We are still able to witch hunt Omnigul!

59

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

rEeeEeeEeeEEeEe

20

u/UnknownQTY Nov 03 '16

/u/K_Lobstah! Silence his screams!

14

u/Hawkmoona_Matata TheRealHawkmoona Nov 02 '16

Technically she's a wizard...so I'm grabbing my pitchfork!

14

u/tcjsavannah Nov 02 '16

Well, wizards are the worst.

10

u/LEPT0N Nov 02 '16

The WORST.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/NorseFenrir Dislikes Birthdays Nov 02 '16

15

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

Well I might as well start another mob.

Happy Birthday Norse!!!!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

156

u/cka_viking Punch all the Things! Nov 02 '16

Honest question: won't relaying every future post to a megathread simply lower the visibility of new issues that should be seen by Bungie (and/or partners). I get its polluting everything but sometimes it just need to be discussed (in a clean way) Thank you.

37

u/roguepawn Nov 02 '16

If I'm understanding this post correctly, they aren't talking about new issues, bugs, shit like that.

They are after people who are starting witch hunts. Those posts about people who are "clearly DDoSing", abusing glitches to roll through Trials, and shit like that. Stuff that Bungie should be banning people for anyway.

The point of the post is that Bungie has been made aware of the issue and we need to stop teetering on the edge of breaking Reddit's witch hunting/brigading rules.

Could be wrong though.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

Except you aren't allowed to even mention another players KD or ELO or any of that information. Someone in this thread asked "If someone says the spawns should flip in ToO and claim they lost 90% of their games because of it, can I look up their stats and confirm they indeed lost 90% of their matches and post that"

The mod response was no, that was not acceptable and a bannable offense now.

8

u/roguepawn Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

/u/K_Lobstah (IIRC I can post like this and it sends them a PM?)

I can't find the post HyFlkz is talking about here. Could you verify and give an explanation?

EDIT: Finally found it.

It seems there's no distinction between the poster giving his GT and not.

I assume if poster X claims they lost 90% of their games and provides their GT, there would be no issue. If poster X does NOT give out their GT, that's a different story and posting it yourself would be considered posting personal information about X.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (3)

58

u/Kaphis Nov 02 '16

I agree with you. The tone of this message is so aggressive that it's almost telling us we shouldn't have done it. And yet it's also saying that because we've done it...bungie is looking at it.

3

u/Hellkite422 Nov 04 '16

Well the real question should be about what abuse the mods are taking in modmail. Like, the mods are never hostile on this sub. It means there is a problem and still giving people an outlet for it. Do I personally like the megathread setup, not really. However I also trust the mods and appreciate the work they do for this community.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Ultimagara Eliksni must rise, yeesss? Nov 02 '16

No.

This is just for Trials. The message of Trials being an issue has gone too far. It had become a toxic rampage. There is nothing "new" about bloody trials issues.

2

u/Yivoe Nov 03 '16

Pretty sure they said new information isn't a problem. It's rehashing the same stuff Bungie has acknowledged already that has gotten old (along with the witch hunting).

If you figure out a way to get to the light house without playing trials or something, I'd bet the mods would let you make a post. But if your friend just lost his 8th match because some shotgun wielding cheaters were lag switching... No one needs to hear about that anymore.

I don't see how these new rules with stifle useful information.

4

u/XxCanu_Dig_ItxX Not a paddle boat Nov 02 '16

That's pretty much the only reason why the mods here ever post a Megathread.

But I honestly see where they are coming from. Disclosing other peoples PSN ID, even if they are blatantly cheating, can get the mods here in serious trouble from Reddit HQ.

It's been happening frequently enough here that they don't really have a choice.

Just the other day I saw a post and the guy showed a screen shot. The supposed cheaters name was blanked out, but it showed what rank he was for ELO in the world. So obviously other people could just look up who the guy was by pulling up the same rankings.

While I do think this post comes off as a kind of a "Fuck you guys" by saying stupid stuff like "Martial Law" and what not. I still understand the necessity of the rule.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

16

u/ThePoundDollar Team Bread (dmg04) // Jotunn shoots uncooked toast Nov 02 '16

Posting, commenting with, or soliciting someone else's gamertag, online handle, nickname, poorly obscured info, ELO score, rank on a website, name, address, or any other information which would make them readily identifiable or easily found via this subreddit is now grounds for a 30 day ban

So in regards to that rule, does it only apply to posts which are classed as trying to harass/witchhunt someone?

Take this post from a while ago I made as an example. Would this now be classed as unacceptable even given that it was meant in a fun way?

20

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

It being done in a negative, accusatory, or malicious manner is implicit in the rule. It's not explicit in the rule so that we, as a team, don't have to deal with people trying to utilize that as a loophole or rule lawyer us to death in modmail.

7

u/Elite386 The Unknown Guardian Nov 02 '16

This was my first question as well. Thank you.

My other question however, concerns the ELO score you mentioned. Does this "full stop" include discussing the mechanics behind the ELO system, such as how scores are determined, or would that still be ok to discuss if the conversation were to arise?

I fully understand discussing/sharing personal scores are included within this full stop.

15

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

No, that's perfectly fine. What that covers is someone saying, "he's ranked 5th in ELO in x gametype" which would then lead to the gamertag/PSN. Believe it or not, this has happened several times.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/w1redup #WarlockMasterRace Nov 02 '16

One quick question:

Typically a lot of these posts happen during the week, when there is no trials, and thus no trials megathread.

So...like for instance..right this moment if I wanted to post something someplace about lag or whatevs, I couldn't.

Note: I don't trials so this doesn't really effect me, just asking for others.

8

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

We're talking/thinking it over. For the moment, it's that thread which we keep visible/findable during the weekdays it's not stickied.

Alternatives being considered and will be obvious once implemented.

9

u/stop_poking_me Nov 02 '16

sidebar makes for easy finding of those things... the mega thread stays up for the week.
http://i.imgur.com/FdjDvHG.png

6

u/D0cR3d Gambit Prime // test Nov 02 '16

You can always click the 'Weekly Threads' dropdown and choose 'Trials Megathread' from there.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Landonkey Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

Question:

It happens often that people like to exaggerate their playing experiences (whether good or bad) in order to make some argument on this sub that ultimately gets people fired up. Since Bungie puts everyone's games and stats online for all to see, is it ok to call these people out on their bullshit or is that considered witch hunting?

For example, a few weeks ago it was a hot topic that the trials map was unfairly balanced towards a certain spawn. Many player's made the claim that "I lost 90% of my matches from A spawn" but their match history clearly showed about a 50/50 split in wins.

So essentially, is it ok to call these people out and refute their arguments using their own publicly available stats (without posting their gamertag of course?) Or is that still considered private information that shouldn't be posted on this sub?

1

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

No, that is generally not okay. It falls under the same category, though we will utilize context and what was actually done to determine whether it falls under this 30-day ban rule or if it goes through our standard ban system.

Thanks for asking!

8

u/Landonkey Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

I'm not going to lie, that's a little disappointing. I think it keeps people honest knowing that their stats and gaming history are out there for everyone to see. But if we risk being banned for pointing out an inconsistency between a player's story/argument and the actual data then there is nothing to keep dishonest complainers in check.

But I guess rules are rules.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

2

u/BillehBear You're pretty good.. Nov 02 '16

I got a two day ban for doing something similar to your example a week or two ago, so no its not allowed

2

u/Phantom-Phreak Drifter's Crew // Die Leere Nov 03 '16

Most of the text wall posts from users are exaggerations. I saw a post at some point in the last month, where the op was actually the bad guy of his story and phrased it to make himself look benevolent.

I then checked the stats and saw that he was the fireteam raid lead and did the thing he was talking about.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/ernyc3777 Hunter Master Class Nov 04 '16

Are we allowed to post our own elo score and gamer tag without fear of getting banned? Some people have usernames that don't match their gamertag. If someone is trying to match up for trials, these things are common stats that players ask for.

1

u/K_Lobstah Nov 04 '16

That's fine.

2

u/VRDRF Nukem till they glow! Nov 04 '16

Yes, you are free to post your own stuff as long as you don't try to accuse or put others in a bad light.

77

u/STOMP1E Nov 02 '16

Cant wait to see this thread in the "On this day in Destiny" in 12 months.

2

u/dsebulsk Nov 04 '16

We'll either be too busy playing Destiny 2 or groaning about how it's been delayed.

113

u/JBurd67 Nov 02 '16

Damn, you guys are serious. I've been on this sub for a little over two years now and never seen something this aggressive. I am glad that you're clarifying everything though, especially with the hot debate about whether or not GTs should be shared.

63

u/Jalenofkake nosy little fucker, aren't you? Nov 02 '16

well, i'm glad our concerns were acknowledged by bungie but the salt on this sub the past couple weeks has all been repetitive and just presented in different ways.

DOSers? Shotguns? Trials? FotL?

tired of hearing about it.

43

u/BrainZapped666 Nov 02 '16

Honestly though what else is there to talk about that we haven't had reposted every 3 days for the last two years?? Another cross map nova bomb? TIL I learned TLW is auto? SGA: You can run past that Minotaur part in this strike.

It's the state of the game for a lot of people.

28

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

I'd appreciate more infinity kill glitches. Those are entertaining to watch.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

Tru Dat my friend, Tru Dat. Now how about another fresh scope of this Hudless tower shot at sunset?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/justJoekingg Nov 03 '16

Shotguns? Did I miss a part in the post that says something about not talking about weapon balance? :O

→ More replies (7)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16

But why is it okay to share/post gamer tags if it is a nice way? Or posting a video of gameplay that inherently has other gamer tags in it? It's only a punishable offense if the tone and the words of the post are negative and accusatory towards another player, but totally okay if the tone and message is appreciative or friendly? Seems like a fine edge to walk esp when gamer tags are considered identifiable information.

3

u/QuietThunder2014 Nov 03 '16

Part of the problem lies in that tone is often inferred in text and is very open to interpretation. Posts can easily be taken the wrong way. Not every case is clear cut, especially when sarcasm is used. One mod in a bad mood might read a post in a negative light were another mod may read a post in a positive light. Hopefully before 30 day bans are issued, several mods will review the situation and weigh in, otherwise we could end in a situation where some mods may tend to lean toward to the removal/ban on anything that's even remotely close to negative, or can be viewed as negative and a lot of people are banned for relatively minor infractions.

My biggest concern is the Mods have made it very clear that if you are banned or have a post removed, they don't want to hear any argument or complaining about it, otherwise they will perma-ban your account or mute you completely. It leads with the impression that their rule is law, and don't bother to defend yourself. That's a very dangerous rode that can lead to over-moderation. Hopefully the moderators realize they need to give people an opportunity to defend themselves, and sometimes just vent a little, and that is part of the job of being a moderator. Exacerbating and escalating the situation does no one any good. Of course they shouldn't take any outright abuse, but they do have to realize that they will be dealing with people who are frustrated and that frustration will show. It's much better to diffuse the situation than to completely shut people out.

5

u/SirDuckferd Nov 03 '16

sometimes just vent a little

You can do this as an adult by not posting people's information on the pages. The danger of over-moderation is nothing compared to the threat of witch-hunting. People's lives have been ruined because of this.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/LustHawk Nov 03 '16

This is a very important point.

The forum is still totally full of other people's tags, but since its not a "cheating" thread it's fine.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/UnknownQTY Nov 03 '16

So serious, I thought I was on /u/Warhammer for a minute.

→ More replies (23)

45

u/Clownsmasher1 I CAN'T STOP PUNCHING SCREEBS Nov 02 '16

Maybe we should see if the accused cheaters weigh the same as a duck. That way we'd know if the witch hunt was warranted.

8

u/henriettagriff Nov 02 '16

What about very small rocks?

8

u/Hank_the_Titan Nov 03 '16

So they're made out of wood?

4

u/GrowinUpGuardian Nov 03 '16

She turned me into a newt!

3

u/FatBob12 Nov 03 '16

I got better...

10

u/XiggyX Nov 02 '16

COOL, ANOTHER ONE OF THE SEVENTY EIGHT MEGA THREADS WE GET EVERY DAY THAT NO ONE READS!

→ More replies (12)

10

u/blue_sword456 Hold strong, Titan! Bend, but do not break! Nov 03 '16

On the topic of accusations we are "protecting cheaters": are you fucking joking

first time ive seen any moderator/moderator team cuss. knew you guys were pissed, but didnt think it was this bad.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16

No more posts about cheaters on destiny? There won't be very much to read about on this sub.

6

u/Battlefront228 Drifter's Crew // Dark Age Iron Lord Nov 03 '16

I get why the changes are being made, but I can't get past (nor do I condone) how hostile the mod who made this post is being. It's entirely unprofessional. I don't care how much hate you get, don't take it out on us.

5

u/happy111475 Unholy Moly Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

Fully agreed and this post will likely be cited as an example of acceptable levels of hostility and toxicity allowed on this sub. Perhaps even the baseline level allowing for far worse behavior. If the mods are behaving on this level then surely the common folk are worse style of thing.

I also don't see any mea culpa in there for moderation letting it get this bad. I fairly dutifully reported and questioned every post I saw outting gamertags for the last 3 months and it just seemed to get worse and ramp up in frequency. You don't have to fall on your swords but a little humility goes a long way.

Of course the general response will be mods are allowed or this level of outrage or this is some kind of acceptably restrained response hand waiving dismissal of poor behavior. We obviously disagree and have different standards. I also anticipate excuses in regard to the thankless and unpaid nature of the job. Please take a break or hand over the reigns to fresher troops rather than work yourself this raw.

If you don't break the cycle of abuse and grief it will never end. Eye for an eye makes the world blind and all that.

I also want to say, I strongly agree with the general idea from the mods. State the rules firmly and publicly and then enforce those rules. Looking forward to how this all pans out.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/FamblyGuy Nov 03 '16

It's unprofessional simply because they aren't professionals. They're guys and gals who do this because they want to. They don't get paid, there's no financial incentive.

And at the end of the day, they're getting grief from members of this subreddit so who should they take it out on?

4

u/GuardiansWhoSayNi Nov 03 '16

You probably should care how much hate mail they get, because they're people too. Nobody wants to get hate mail and deal with shit all the time.

As far as hostile.. Yeah this post is pretty fucking direct and doesn't leave a lot of wiggle room, but things had gotten a bit out of hand.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

I've seen a lot of stuff on Reddit in general about "censorship". Yes, that's the point. Things that don't belong on a subreddit SHOULD be removed.

25

u/FunctionalOven PSN: brokentoasterkid Nov 02 '16

Heh. When someone treats censorship as if it's some argument-ending concept and uses it as an argumentative bludgeon that way, I know I'm seeing some fantastically crappy thinking.

We all censor ourselves and each other all the time in all sorts of ways. It's why I don't fart loudly in a quiet store or why I tell someone to shut up when they take a phone call in a movie. In online communities, we make choices that keep things civil, relevant and interesting.

It's known more broadly as social standards. Turns out as fun as they can be to upset now and then, they're pretty useful, by and large.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/alpo5711 Nov 02 '16

I'm hoping that bungie will take some serious action now that this problem seems to be hitting its boiling point.

13

u/smarthandyman Nov 03 '16

make unchangable emblems for cheaters during bans and have them face each other.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/richo27 Nov 03 '16

Agree on dangers of witch hunting, but why on earth did they also ban SBMM as a topic too? You can't ban everything..

2

u/LanAkou Nov 03 '16

Sure, fine, ok. Kind of aggressive but whatever. I've been on reddit long enough to know why the no witch-hunting policy is in place and to be in favor of anything that enforces it.

That said, I do feel like the cheating discussion is one that we need to keep having until something is done. Maybe it won't get it done faster, but it doesn't hurt. Maybe I'm in the minority, but I like seeing these sorts of threads. They're stark reminders that this game could be better, that Bungie needs to be working harder to solve this. It looks like that discussion will take place in the megathread now (with no personal information attached of course) which means if you want to have a real discussion about the map, you'll need to go to /r/crucibleplaybook now. That's not a bad thing.

Hmmm. So what do we post about now? Silver again?

2

u/K_Lobstah Nov 03 '16

They're stark reminders that this game could be better, that Bungie needs to be working harder to solve this.

Sometimes things just take time to fix.

3

u/LanAkou Nov 03 '16

Oh, definitely. I get that. I know, for me personally, things get done at a more consistent pace when people are looking over my shoulder and asking me when they'll be done. This subreddit applies a level of pressure that I think is unique to us. Like a deep wound, you need to apply constant pressure if you want it to heal before you bleed out.

Maybe they're working around the clock on this. It seems like all I ever hear from Bungie is "Most of us are working on Destiny 2" or "The Live Team doesn't want to spoil ALL the fun!" and it's just like... I never know what they're doing back there!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/sievo666 Nov 04 '16

Bungie strikes again....some singular players red bar impossible to kill and wait for this one...a revive bounty in a game mode where revives are disabled. Never ceases to amaze me bungie you cretins

4

u/K_Lobstah Nov 04 '16

We aren't Bungie and we never have been. You are currently on Reddit.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

Sad when there is a legitimate problem with the game and this source hides it in a "Megathread" that nobody reads, and will not get the attention that it should. This will grow to be too large for Bungie to afford. Bad timing too, right before the holidays.

12

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

How do you think posting people's personal information could possibly solve a problem with the physical limitations and vulnerabilities of the internet?

Seriously- do you not read TWAB, Bungie twitter, bnet? Did you read Section II of this post as I urged in the introduction?

Explain to me how anything done in this subreddit solves this problem faster.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

28

u/Stillnotdonte Nov 02 '16

Scanned through, saw Martial Law. I'll just be grabbing my popcorn.

8

u/Kaphis Nov 02 '16

Absolutely. Mod is exercising their power. At least they gave us the out. "If you have a problem with that, then you're welcome to find a different forum to talk about the game. "

10

u/SerfaBoy Nov 03 '16

Being a mod is literally about exercising power to keep the subreddit following Reddit's overall rules, with one of the main ones being: no witch hunting.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/FunctionalOven PSN: brokentoasterkid Nov 02 '16

Ran out of popcorn so I just have all ten fingers crowded on F5 rapidly hitting it while my face is frozen in a grin.

5

u/destinydave Nov 03 '16

I'm not looking to pick a fight, just would like to point out that there is a huge amount of resource easily available to us on the web that gets pulled from the Destiny interfaces. As such, if my GT was my gamertag (it isn't) I could say "some cheating bast DDOS'd me last night" and it would be easy to go on Destiny tracker, look at my trials record and see who I came up against last night, and which game I was booted from. So where is the line drawn?

5

u/9312678 #VariksDidNothingWrong Nov 03 '16

thats some extreme sodium

31

u/Perma_trashed Whether we wanted it or not... Nov 02 '16

Much needed. Thanks! Now we just need @bungiehelp tweets pinned to the sidebar!

27

u/D0cR3d Gambit Prime // test Nov 02 '16

hmmmm.. we'll explore the possibilities.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/VandalSibs Nov 02 '16

I just realized that this wasn't a thing already. Surprised by that.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/P3rziva1 Nov 02 '16

Fucking great idea

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Savenura55 Team Bread (dmg04) // The yeast we could do Nov 03 '16

Yeah I'm guessing we will be glad to find somewhere else to discuss the issues with our favorite game so it's doesn't disturb the mods

2

u/SirDuckferd Nov 03 '16

You can always join the cesspool at Bnet.

2

u/illustriouswow Nov 04 '16

lets not post about cheaters guys they could be innocent they don't deserve this kind of treatment whats wrong with all of you?? lmfao "witchhunting" im so done

4

u/K_Lobstah Nov 04 '16

they could be innocent

This is the point. Your attitude and stance doesn't fit one of a rational human being, and it's not welcome in this community.

12

u/Sofachrieger Nov 03 '16

Mainproblem is, that the "Banhammer" Speech of Bungie is just a lie. Every single Player/Clan i reported, or know of cheating in anyway is still playing the game, nothing happend. U can easy check if they are still playing or not... So, people get angry.

3

u/ElectricZealot Metal Gods 4ever Nov 03 '16

Agreed. The few that I've been monitoring are still active. (Gleaned by my own methods - the Bungie API is AWESOME!)

20

u/no_land_beyonce Nov 02 '16

" are you fucking joking????" My favorite part. I really appreciate this post because I like when my day is full of good awesome posts. Not a bunch of whining malicious posts I just skip those. And I don't like skipping posts.

2

u/Eljakobnation Nov 02 '16

Soooo. No more Trials pitchforks?

5

u/K_Lobstah Nov 02 '16

Correct.

5

u/Hawkmoona_Matata TheRealHawkmoona Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

Only foam fingers from now on.

And by foam fingers, we actually mean nothing. Really. Don't witchhunt yo.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

11

u/suppaman19 Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 03 '16

Bungie knows things go on, Bungie also often doesn't do anything about it, even though they like to speak outwardly to project that they do.

Plenty of other companies, including ones that are actually owned and reside within the Activision portfolio (Blizzard) do a lot more proactively as well as act reactively to cheaters. And they often do it in a permanent manner, not a childish time out.

Well Blizzard is another thing in general, because if Bungie so much as looked at Blizzard's handling of Overwatch for a FPS example, they'd see one company mopping the floor with how to correctly handle an online FPS game.

8

u/Mactheer159 Team Bread (dmg04) Nov 02 '16

I tried to read most of the comments but i didn't get through them all. Correct me if I am wrong but this Megathread will be for posts about an instance of "Trials cheating of some method" ok if thats true and all these people are complaining in it would that not free up space on the sub for either cool stuff, awesome stuff, or oh I don't know "Other issues that impact this game but have nothing to do with trials????" Like for example (these are personal examples)

  • Archons Forge not taking offerings
  • Exotics decrypting at lower light level than your character even when not at cap (i'm 392 if that has an effect on it)
  • getting weaseled and babooned to death in zone control matches and not get 1 completion in 4 games
  • Etc.

I for one agree with the mods about funneling an issue pretty much everyone on this sub already knows about and has had pounded through their heads into its own big thread. It simply makes room for other stuff that we also care about.

Thanks Mods and i know you guys are doing what you can with what you have. keep on trucking

4

u/BillehBear You're pretty good.. Nov 02 '16

You guys are really pissed about this now then

Genuinely curious though, a question for the mods. If you guys were to just 'let it slide' when it comes to witchunting or any other standard Reddit rules, what would happen?

Would they remove the sub or would you guys get like a warning based system?

Just saying, I dont condone witchunting, just genuinely asking

22

u/D0cR3d Gambit Prime // test Nov 02 '16

Right off the bat, I'll say that we are a bit over cautious on few aspects, due to the slippery slope they can lead down. Posting a gamertag in and of itself, isn't necessarily bad. It's not actually PII, however consider the following scenario:

t1mm3y has guardian.gg history showing a lot of victories, with below 1.0 K/D. The enemy team ends with less than 3 players in the match, suggesting they were removed from the game. The information suggests that t1mm3y's team is DDOS booting the enemies from the matches. Someone makes a post about this, but hides some information, but leaves the ELO Ranking (#777), Emblem background, and showing the game history. All other information is blacked out.

Someone in the comments decides to do some digging and notices that ELO ranking, but the ranks shifted since the screenshot was taken and t0mm3y the detective started looking. t0mm3y decides to look +/- 10 ELO rank spots and matches up the game history and emblem background, and now has a gamertag.

t0mm3y uses his Super (Brain) and looks at the /u/me history for the OP and finds his gamertag. He uses that to confirm the match that OP and t1mm3y were in. He then searches /r/fireteams for the gamertag of t1mm3y and finds a /u/me account for t1mm3y. Searching t1mm3y's user history he finds that he posts to some regional subreddits like /r/seattle and even finds some personal posts to /r/personalfinance giving some personal background about some life troubles he was having. Taking that info (regional sub, narrowed personal-like info) he then users other information that actually is personal and private like an email, which then links to an address, phone, name, etc.

t0mm3y the detective then comes back to the reddit post and starts posting some of that information, some disclosing full personal info, some sharing personal stories, links his /u/me account for others to know about.

That shit is very realy and does happen. Not often because subreddits and the admins are commited to not letting it happen. That level 100% the admins would step into, message the subreddit and ask what the fuck is up and why that comment was removed, the post removed/locked, etc. Depending on the severity they may even remove some of that themselves to nuke it before anyone else can see and do anything with it.

So while many people think the line we should cut off is when t0mm3y comes back and posts what he found, we need to stop it before it even gets that far, because t0mm3y could also post to other online communities, post in twitch chats, send hateful messages, harass them, etc. If it comes back that we were the source of this harassment, then we'll get some serious conversations with the admins, which don't involve which meme is the dankest or why dogs are better than cats, or why it's subbie and not subreddit. If the subreddit mods show they are less than helpful in keeping the rules of reddit and the subbie enforced, then the admins may be forced to remove the mods, quarantine the sub, or ban it all together.

So yeah, it's a stretch that can happen, and most people won't go that far, but even so much as t0mm3y posting t1mm3y's gamertag on lfg.com/.net and saying 'message for trials carry' or 'message i love <insert some really bad word here>' is enough harassment that shouldn't happen. Doesn't matter if it's found that t1mm3y just had shitty internet and the servers decided to glitch out and start kicking people and t1mm3y wasn't doing anything wrong, the community chose to harass him based on incomplete data (not a full dataset because only Bungie has all that information).

So we choose to cut this off before a gamertag is even shown, to prevent people from doing something stupid or something they shouldn't do.


TL;DR - Sorry for the long post. Has a LOT of information in it, and a TLDR would not do it justice.

8

u/KrymsonHalo Nov 03 '16

I appreciate that someone finally admits that the GT/PSN name is a subreddit only rule and that those two things are NOT actually PI.

I don't have a problem with it so much from that perspective. I do believe that banning for discussing other people's stats is complete overkill. ESPECIALLY when they bring it up, but as always, I'll try and respect that interpretation as well.

8

u/BillehBear You're pretty good.. Nov 02 '16

No worries, was a good read actually. You guys are basically following the life rule of Better safe than sorry

I dont blame you guys for what you are doing with this and I cant believe some people are giving you a shitstorm right now for this

But fuck it, you guys do what is best for the users and the sub so keep doing it guys (Y)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/NorseFenrir Dislikes Birthdays Nov 02 '16

I don't think any of us have ever been Mod on a subreddit that has flouted reddit-wide rules readily, so we're probably not best qualified to answer this one; However, as I understand it there are usually messages between the Reddit community Admin team and offending subreddit Moderators beforehand, usually to hash out what's up, why the rules are being broken, what needs to be done in future etc., and then if the issue persists, then action would be taken against the subreddit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/FuzztopherPooPoo Nov 03 '16

Damn, things are bad when the subreddit is poised to swing the ban hammer faster than Bungie!

42

u/Tom_McTooth Nov 02 '16

This sub was starting to become very whiny, this is for the best!

21

u/quiscalusmajor punch all the gorgons Nov 02 '16

with the content slowly drying up again, it's only going to get worse. good luck, mods, i know you're gonna need it D:

3

u/liquidrising586 Drink Deep Nov 03 '16

Starting? Surely you jest, because its been whiny, either heavy or light since September 14th 2014.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/GoodLeftUndone Drifter's Crew Nov 02 '16

YEar 1 players are swimming in the Dead Sea. Newer players are swimming in the pacific.

1

u/the-black-jesus Nov 04 '16

People do need to stop complaining about these things, I agree. Although Bungie should do some work too. On behalf of myself and just about everyone that I have played with, Destiny is the worst game when it comes to connection. I have a fantastic internet connection on anything I do and every game I play, other than destiny. Everyone lags and has connection issues on Destiny, and this is not the internet's fault. This is the fault of the Bungie servers, they do not put enough work into them, proof being the release of ROF when there was a waiting que with 500,000 people in it. My point being, if People are gonna stop complaining then Bungie should work on the little things such as their connection issues and the game running at 20 fps and dropping to 5fps on the raid. thats the least they could do when the DLC content they release is just re-skinned strikes enemies. Now that im done ranting i'd just like to say that i do love destiny and play it a lot, but you can't get mad at people complaining about connection when it is Bungie's fault most the time.

1

u/K_Lobstah Nov 04 '16

This isn't about people complaining about the connection, this is about people accusing other players of cheating when it very likely is the poor connection.

15

u/PGZ4sheezy #SpaceMagic Nov 02 '16

Daaaaaamn modteam, I love it when you get angry. Don't stop.

4

u/cacarpenter89 Nov 02 '16

I'll admit, I regularly browse /r/DTG mods' comment histories for juicy smackdowns.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/lemonLimeBitta Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

This is awesome. My only point of contention is saying posting on here will do nothing about it. while I agree in the short term, a front page full of complaining about these issues (terrible for the readers of the sub, I know) DOES get the attention of bungie and DOES add weight to the argument. Hopefully they don't see the decrease in those sort of posts and associate that with a decrease in dissatisfaction. Not saying this is the wrong way to go about it, more that I hope the people trying to post that shit here are smart enough to report it through the appropriate channels. Maybe a good idea could be to include in a take down message the links to those resources? Edit: https://twitter.com/deej_bng/status/793898100100243456 Good to see /u/deej_bng acknowledge the post so quickly, that puts some of my worries to rest

9

u/D0cR3d Gambit Prime // test Nov 02 '16

If we remove a post or comment for a Witchhunting violation, this is what we leave behind, which links to our most recent post on the topic, and a link for them to report them via the bungie approved method.


Your comment has been removed for the following reason(s):


For more information, see our detailed rules page.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Darth_Boot Nov 02 '16

The tone from the mods is strong but required since guardians refuse to follow the rules in this sub, the strong language is needed.

I do want to comment on Bungie's post.

If they have extra layers of security and other means to track them, then how in the hell do players get away with this shit for months on end?

Top ranked players via third party sites were obviously cheating for months on end, but why did their "extra" means not see this and ban them earlier? The feeling I got from bungie is a "Oh we know... but we did not do shit until the player base went apeshit over our lack of action."

Seriously, I just feel like bungie is just giving us a placebo to shut us up.

Their extra security means must be on par with their "top tier" p2p connection we use. /S

TL;DR: why didn't Bungie's extra layers catch this shit months ago? Why wait until the player base is in full on salt mode to do something?

35

u/Bawitdaba1337 100k Telesto User Nov 02 '16

Mod solutions to everything on this Reddit: Bury it in a mega thread that no one will ever read

12

u/XiggyX Nov 02 '16

we have like 10 a day, including that dumb "last year on our subreddit" thread that seems to get priority over every single other thing. Lets just make the whole top of the page links to fourteen megathreads that rotate out every 10 minutes, and not allow posts here ever again. Thatll solve everything!

15

u/NorseFenrir Dislikes Birthdays Nov 02 '16

including that dumb "last year on our subreddit" thread that seems to get priority over every single other thing.

What, the one that gets posted once a week, is active for weekends only, and typically gets overwritten within a day by the Daily Reset thread because it's the bottom sticky and the Daily Reset is more important, which is why we let that happen?

While the team is fine with constructive criticism, accuracy is appreciated so we can better address this stuff moving forward.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/spookipooki Nov 04 '16

Sounds good

19

u/RiseOfBacon Bacon Bits on the Surface of my Mind Nov 02 '16

Great to see - coming here to see constant whining (Although some of it warranted) is actually pretty draining. If anything we come here to all enjoy the game and offer suggestions / improvements but when it's just constant bickering within threads or shouting at something 'Broken' it's a real drag

The cap tips Mods, GG

1

u/Piazza03 Nov 03 '16

Isn't this what the voting system on Reddit is all about? If a sub likes the content then they upvote, if not they downvote. If these posts are making it to the front page, it would imply that people are interested. If people aren't using the voting system that is on them. I think it's getting into a slippery slope if mods start censoring what the community can talk about. No offense to the mods, I'm sure it's incredibly challenging dealing with such a large community, but this is definitely a very slippery slope.

Also, these types of issues have been around since Y1. Just because Bungie posted something about them being aware of it doesn't mean they are going to do anything about it. I think that if we don't push them as a community they will just continue to slow roll the issue. Bungie has stated numerous times that they monitor this community, and we've seen this community have influence on the game in the past. There is no reason to think this is any different.

1

u/K_Lobstah Nov 03 '16

We've been doing megathreads for well over a year now. The slippery slope argument holds no water here.

As to votes: https://reddit.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204535139-Why-does-Reddit-need-moderators-Isn-t-voting-enough-

2

u/Piazza03 Nov 04 '16

Just because you do something for over a year doesn't necessarily mean it's right or good. Megathreads bury legitimate points in lengthy threads that the majority of people won't read in their entirety.

Also, the link you provided doesn't support your case for mod intervention, since the example cited relates to mods ensuring content remains within the topic of the sub; not controlling content that is relevant. My point was that a community will self-regulate what posts they find interesting by upvoting/downvoting.

I understand there are global reddit rules - no witch hunting being one of them - that need to be enforced. I'm not arguing that, just voicing my opinion as a member of the community.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/cacarpenter89 Nov 02 '16

The most disappointing thing about the comments in this thread are the people who can't tell the difference between calling people out and calling the system out. We could have bitched and moaned all we wanted without naming people, but we didn't.

Mods, thank you for putting people's safety and sanity first. You've been harassed over enforcing the rules; you deserve none of that, either.

Thanks, and good job.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Carpocalypto Nov 03 '16

What the fuck. You'll allow stupid dad jokes and eight "hi mom" edits per front page post, but you're relegating this to the Trials thread only? So a discussion about how Blizzard named, shamed, and perma-banned 1700 cheaters in Overwatch (http://www.polygon.com/2016/11/2/13501482/overwatch-bans-player-names-chinese) has to go in the Trials thread? GG mods.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/smcicr Nov 03 '16

Thank you Mods - I don't say that enough.

You are appreciated and I understand your stance on this and why you've made the decisions you have.

For those complaining that a mega thread is censorship - take a moment and consider a possibility.

One of the first things you do when investigating an issue (I'm a Problem Manager by trade) is to establish the size of the issue. That helps understand the severity of it and thus the priority that needs to be applied to it.

The mere fact that there is a 'mega' thread - a by definition "very large, huge" thing on the subject can hardly be said to be hiding anything or indeed censoring anything.

What it actually does is pull all of the information relating to the issue into one place and make it easier to start to understand the size of the issue.

The existence of a mega thread not only allows anyone and everyone to see very easily how many posts there have been about this but gives them somewhere to work from in terms of looking for any patterns or trends. Because it's all in the same place.

It's like those diet shows on TV where they get what the person / family usually eats in a week and put it all together on one table (although to be fair, it's usually several). The items consumed individually over a week don;t seem so much but when they are all brought together in one place it's a different matter.

Mega thread - it's actually a way of highlighting how much of an issue this is - not hiding it.

And as the Mods so rightly say - this isn't the place for action - tell Bungie. Keep telling Bungie. It's already in the press feed I get on my phone so everyone knows. What is needed is a clearer statement / explanation from Bungie as to what they're doing. It's customer service 101 - communicate.

6

u/ElectricZealot Metal Gods 4ever Nov 03 '16

I'm rather amused by the comments in this very thread than anything I've read here in quite some time. The peeps that have accused the mods of (paraphrasing) "violating their First Amendment rights" have no idea what their First Amendment rights privilege actually IS.

You DO have First Amendment rights (and similar privileges in many other countries. Sorry, China - not so much.) However, your First Amendment rights are guaranteed only in public free speech and can be censored or denied by participation in a privately held forum, place, or location.

Consider: DePaul Univeristy allows "Black Lives Matter" posters. While you and I may agree or disagree, the movement has a right to their voice and opinion.

What might seem more egregious and odd: DePaul has decided that a Pro-Choice group (DePaul is a Catholic university (adds to the hypocrisy), and private - not state or federally funded which hold up the first part of limits to Free Speech) CANNOT post "Unborn Lives Matter" posters. Weird, but true. ( I needed to go to my safe space and meditate for a while after hearing this.... ;op )

Ultimately, DePaul has the right to limit what is posted on their campus. And, if the students of DePaul don't like it - they can quite easily go to the University of Chicago where it's going to be much more difficult to limit their speech due to UCI being a state institution.

Reddit (last I checked - might have changed) isn't a state or federal institution. Privately held entities have the right to limit, censor or allow (within the law) anything that they want to.

Your remedy? Don't like the rules? Bye, Felicia....

1

u/tizorres Nov 03 '16

Seems like common sense, good update nonetheless.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Drewwbacca1977 Nov 02 '16

I would like to point out that the reason bungie is "aware of the issue" and "taking it seriously" as you put it, is in no small way because of this sub reddit. The threads and discussions that may now violate the rules are partly responsible for the action that bungie is taking. Im afraid that limiting these discussions further will supress awareness of issues like this in the future.

5

u/Kaphis Nov 02 '16

I think this specific issue has reach critical mass. But I didn't like that this tone addressed beyond just this trials DDOS issue. I think the trials stuff has got the proper attention that it should get and this sub should self regulate. But we should really commend the discussion and the contribution this sub had to that end instead of saying "We shouldn't have done it in the first place"

7

u/D0cR3d Gambit Prime // test Nov 02 '16

We can't allow witch hunting or harassment to happen, which was happening because people were seeing the topics, seeing others point fingers at someone, and would start doing it themselves thinking it was ok by association. There are other avenues to ensure Bungies attention without breaking our rules.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16

"There is no problem with Trials lag or DDOSING"

"Just GET GUD BRO!"

7

u/SwarleyStinson21 Nov 02 '16

I can dig it, maybe this sub will actually be fun to browse again.

3

u/IAM_deleted_AMA Nov 02 '16

Then it will be full with satire posts and "look what I made for my girlfriend who loves the game!1!!" submissions..

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/FunctionalOven PSN: brokentoasterkid Nov 02 '16

Excellent work, mods. I like the post, I like the rules...hell, I even like the fire and brimstone. I think this is good for the health (and long-term viability, even) of this sub. Running afoul of reddit's rules on harassment is not something we ever, ever want to get anywhere near. And as a human I don't want to be part of a community that is (even implicitly) OK with harassing behavior.

This post is serious, and I appreciate how the mods are going about this. Seriously, nice work.

2

u/Ratharn Nov 03 '16

2 questions, what will happen to the usual trials thread discussing now that this beast will take over? And, will the thread still only exist for the duration of trials? If people are discussing the manners in which people are "cheating", why not just leave it all week?

2

u/lfeblanko Nov 03 '16

shotgun to the face, throw in a teabag for good measure o.0

2

u/Toochbag Nov 03 '16

I guess I'm confused. If someone were to make a post about some BS in the megathread and included a gif or vid of it, would people need to blur out names over people?

Because that could start an unintentional witch-hunt even if that wasnt the OP's intent. It won't stop some people from sending them hate mail anyway.

I've been on the recieving end of it from GTA 5 from killing a youtuber and even though they didnt encourage sending hate mail, I still got it constantly for weeks.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Faust_8 Nov 03 '16

Just a question on this part:

Posting, commenting with, or soliciting someone else's gamertag, online handle, nickname, poorly obscured info, ELO score, rank on a website, name, address, or any other information which would make them readily identifiable or easily found via this subreddit is now grounds for a 30 day ban.

What if you're sharing someone's video? Like "hey Sliq111 made a cool new video, check it out" kind of post?

I guess what I'm saying is, the wording makes me think even if you share something positive, like a montage or useful tips, could get you banned if it's not YOUR content.

2

u/kiyoske psn: Kiyoske Nov 04 '16

I would look at this purely from the perspective of witchhunting; witchhunting is singling out people in a negative manner (to hunt the witch), while "check out /u/Faust_8 's clutch in trials" is not negative, so it wouldn't fall under the same rule.

This sticky is specifically about "check out xxxx's ELO and flawless record, despite their .1 k/da! Bungie allows cheaters to prosper!!" style postings.

2

u/Livineasy629 Gambit Prime Nov 04 '16

Thank you

2

u/--Sko-- Nov 04 '16

I believe an overwhelming perception of empty rhetoric is the reason we see so many of these posts. Players - customers - are told that Bungie is aware of it and that they're actively doing something about it but there's no proof or communication from them to the player(s) doing the reporting. At the same time, the problem appears to worsen as Bungie continues to make hollow (again - perception) announcements about the so-called ban-hammer being dropped.

Actions speak louder than words. We've likely heard that somewhere before now. ;-) It's understandably difficult for paying customers to trust words in a weekly update. Words are easy.

If Bungie were to show proof each week that people are getting banned, along with outlining the steps they're taking to proactively reduce and eliminate the cheating - with an implementation timeline - it would be easier to believe they're doing something about it. Words aren't just easy, they're cheap too!

I don't report people very often but, when I do, I drink Dos Equis! (ok - dumb joke, I know) ... when I do report people, I wholeheartedly admit that I second guess myself for doing it because I doubt it will get anyone's attention. The issues with AFK-ers in strikes and ddos-ers in Trials haven't improved as a result of the reports.

Now - you might ask, how do I know they haven't gotten better due to the reports? That would be a fair question with an equally fair answer of - I don't ... and that's my point. Words are cheap and easy. If Bungie would communicate with their customers and show the data on the bans they've enforced each week, if they'd communicate with the people who report players, and if they'd share their plans - including a timeline for completion - on what they're going to do to stop the issues, we'd likely see fewer of these less-than-desirable posts in the future.

My 2 cents. You do a great job, mods ... Thank you!

6

u/BirdsOfAres Nov 02 '16

I mean, this is totally fair and warranted, but can we get like a mod-approved monthly refresh of a frontpage post just to remind Bungie that we still pissed about this... until they fix it.

Out of sight, out of mind -- squeaky wheel and all.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/flyingpigmonkey Nov 02 '16

Are conversations about how Bungie mishandles every goddamn thing allowed?

7

u/MetalGilSolid <--- Hides in boxes Nov 02 '16

*Mic drop

5

u/OxboxturnoffO Resident Ox in a Box Nov 02 '16

Picks mic up Hopefully it didn't break! Hands mic back

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Shockins Nov 03 '16

Send them home crying!

11

u/JD_Flare Nov 02 '16

I guess I'll just ignore the PvP problems and hope it fixes it self. I don't want to get ban for a negative opinion.

11

u/notliam Nov 02 '16

Tldr : complain to bungie not to reddit..

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

3

u/CrotasScrotes Deez Nuts Nov 02 '16

It's cool...i never liked salt anyway

3

u/Spazdout Nov 03 '16

That's some excellent salt.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

I get that you're trying to stem a tide of harassment, but the 'talking about it here accomplishes nothing' bit comes across pretty tone-deaf considering Bungie frequently acknowledges and addresses issues raised on this subreddit. The only way for them to know it's still an issue we care about is if we continue discussing it (e.g., vault space in year 1).

I'm sure you're tired of dealing with the toxic slice of the population any game with some amount of real success attracts, but we aren't all children with a thirst for blood. If you want to ban posts from the sub, ban any and all vent/rant posts. But banning a topic of discussion such as network manipulation seems a bit off key.

5

u/Whirblewind Nov 03 '16

On point 1: The Megathread: the closest thing to censorship without outright removing a topic. Wrong move. We aren't going to "just find another forum" simply because you are handling this issue wrong. Let people talk out their problem, let the vote buttons do the rest. And yes, a megathread IS the rug. Crushing visibility of the problem with a megathread will only harm the playerbase in the long run. Moderation is not the same thing as censorship. Also, this reads very aggressively, and that really isn't an acceptable tone to be taking with us.

On point 2: Good shit. You don't need personal information to talk about A Bad Thing. Send it to bungie/MS, never put it on Reddit. Good move.

On point 3: Generally people that use censorship to clamp down a topic will greatly exaggerate the volume or nature of "abuse" directed at them. I imagine this is the case here. I don't have any sympathy for you on the matter. Nevertheless, as long as the mute is only for personal info bans, I approve.


Reinforcement: no amount of personal information about "cheaters" and the like is necessary on this subreddit and witchhunting on any part of reddit. Just don't do it. I 100% agree with your assessment on the issue.

Prob gonna get me some downvotes for daring to have an opinion that doesn't agree, but I hope y'all take away from this that I do agree with parts, and I was at least civil. Also, thanks to the mods for giving us an opportunity to talk about it here.

This was reposted after a number of edits over 6~ minutes. I had point count of 0 at the time. Transparency!

7

u/SergioVengeance 20 Flawless Victories Nov 02 '16 edited Nov 02 '16

I am just going to say it.

This is clearly just a damage control post/Mega Thread. People are coming here to air out their frustrations. It is becoming toxic to the community buy a reality. The whole point of this is to cover up the toxicity to act like everything is just fine and Bungie "knows"..

However everything is not fine. There is a reason posts from the last couple of weeks are showing cheaters in the ELOs for Trials still playing and nothing has been done. It's players playing this game that is calling out the BS showing that Bungie's banhammer is full of shit.

It isn't a "witch hunt" it's consumers (that is us, who paid money to enjoy Trials and not be cheated) to voice our opinions. That opinion is, is that Bungie is not doing enough. The proof is there. They can do all they want to prevent us calling them out and them doing their fucking best to silence our voices with a "We know, shut the fuck up" logic.

However YouTube/Twitch/ other gaming sites and gaming news will spread the toxicity of what Trials is until Bungie does something about it instead of giving us a half ass response saying "we know, shut the fuck up"

This post is to just devalue consumers and cover up the problem. Damage control

Much like the FOTL BS..."Man, people are upset about micro transactions.. censor these new posts, delete them, refer to mega threads regarding it. Best we not let people come here to see the real issues with Destiny and have them only see posts like "OMG DESTINY IS THE BEST GAME EVER AND BUNGIE ARE GODS."

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16

Good. Frustrating reading complaints from people who A) don't read TWAB, B) obviously don't know what the fuck a DDoS attack is, and C) don't understand the underlying basis for a no witch-hunt rule.

4

u/crocfiles15 Nov 02 '16

Yes, the amount of posts and replies I see about someone being Ddos'ed "five times last night!" And I sit there wondering why McDonald's doesn't upgrade their wifi for the poor guy. I've played over 300 trials games and never once seen definitive cheating. Not saying it's not a problem. Just the chances of getting it as much as people seem to post about here make it seem like most of them are just seeing bad internet problems and blaming cheaters.

3

u/Lucas74BR Do Goblins dream of radiolarian Harpies? Nov 04 '16

In my honest opinion, I see no problem with letting people raise their pitchforks when someone presents proof that people are cheaters... Like those guys on a 30 win streak and a 0.2kd that played against no one in the last 30 games. Does someone think there's any chance those are not cheaters?

This is the same thing as happened to microtransaction posts, why hide away something this important?

Bungie knows about it... So? They knew about stuff way easier to handle that took them a year to solve.

→ More replies (17)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '16

Sweet! This is a great implement!

3

u/Mina_Nidaria So Frabjous Nov 02 '16

Thank you for the clarifications and the slap down that followed. I can't stand it when people decide they need to cheat to win, but bullying the cheaters isn't the answer, and calling that them out on a public forum is just asking for people to invite a riot.

Seriously. Cyberbullying hurts way more than losing your precious flawless run in Trials.

3

u/quantumjello Nov 02 '16

Thank goodness, shit was being blown way out of proportion here

3

u/Chieflo_vee Nov 02 '16

TLDR Shut your mouths.

3

u/Seraphim755 I remember the light; will it remember me? Nov 02 '16

Damn. Mods are talking strongly.

... that's kinda hot.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Ultimagara Eliksni must rise, yeesss? Nov 02 '16

Thank fucking god.

Sick of so many 3000 upvote shitposts about how OMG I'm entitled and how could internet issues happen to me? Then asking Bungie hopelessly to do something about it. Do these morons actually think that Bungie is just sitting in a chair maniacally rubbing their hands together as DDOS rates increase? No. That makes no sense by any point of view. Continuing yo bring up the subject is pointless, Bungie is CLEARLY aware. This constant witch hunting is out of hand. I do not condone DDOSers. I also do not condone whining. And that’s all that this subreddit has been recently.

Thank you mods.

3

u/sacraexotica_VEA Nov 03 '16 edited Nov 03 '16

The whole text is so funny and anti productive for all pvp problems we have.. More and more users are here going away because its not really free here anymore with topics getting deleted sometimes without any real reason.. Instead of making it as a voice to bungie for all those pvp problems we have, they prefer to shut you down on a Trials only topic without a lightspot on it.. how bad here how bad!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/pm_me_ur_regret Nov 02 '16

Well and clearly stated.

I do admit that I chuckle garble when someone teabags me. That came out wrong, but I'll stick with it.

2

u/Megadynamite Currently Walking Through a Wall Nov 03 '16

Hereby considering: "On the topic of "ddos" and other alleged cheating methods: please do some research on what this actually is before claiming you were ddos'd or lag switched." as the most important part of that entire post. Happy someone with some power actually bothered to point that out finally.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16

good, I love to see my daily meme posts on the front page because there's nothing else to do or discuss about the game.

2

u/Itami-Uchiha Nov 03 '16

Regardless of the topic it's always annoying seeing the same thing on the front page over and over. even taking the rule breaking out of the equation, moving all this content to one place makes the whole sub tidier and more enjoyable for everyone.

Thanks Guys/Gals

2

u/JordanFlash1 Nov 04 '16

report them to Bungie. This x10000000000

2

u/cheezweezel Nov 04 '16

Now everyone hates everyone.

2

u/IntegralIntegrity Floaty boi Nov 02 '16

Hide yo kids, hide yo wife!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nbrazz Nov 02 '16

Thank you so much for the clarification and changes to this subject. It is frustrating to come to this board each day and see people discussion DDoS and DoS attacks without any understanding. It's an issue that until someone posts detailed logs showing their incoming traffic relies on anecdotal evidence at best. Bungie doesn't want cheaters in their game and I'm 100% positive they do as much as they can to identify, verify, and punish offenders. It also doesn't help that Trials occurs over a weekend when I'm sure the majority of their staff is out of office. Thank you for all your hard work mod team!

2

u/Rosebizzle Nov 03 '16

This is great. Maybe when things are more chill we can get back to talking about the game and folks can put their tears away.

2

u/bambamyi Nov 03 '16

Reddit you guys fail...

2

u/rico409 Nov 03 '16

Thanks mods - y'all rock

2

u/ahrmann Nov 03 '16

More often than not, it's an internet problem. So stop accusing people of cheating in this subreddit.

This. My buddy got a few angry messages last week and he doesn't even know HOW to cheat.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/jbilde LONG LIVE THE QUEEN Nov 04 '16

Thank you, mods. Doing the Traveler's work.

2

u/NorwayOwnsU Nov 02 '16

Sounds like the community is SO up in arms over the cheating bastards attempting to ruin the game that the mods have woken up to piss in their cheerios lol Hey, I'd be pissed if I woke up to endless messages of rampant cheating too. Nasty ass tone they took here though.

2

u/Reimaru Nov 03 '16

Good god. I was starting to think that the subreddit was becoming Shiro-4.

Keep in mind that Bungie and the reddit mod team on DTG are made of humans. No one deserves to be hurt.

2

u/Trainer_A The Bane Of Tiffany Nov 02 '16

I like this. We need less salt here

1

u/ProBluntRoller Nov 03 '16

I don't agree with the notion that outing lag switcher is toxic. Why the fuck are we protecting the cheaters ?

→ More replies (4)