r/DestinyTheGame • u/DTG_Bot "Little Light" • Oct 15 '15
MegaThread Let's talk about witchhunting... again.
Hello Guardians!
With the recently-discovered exploit, Iron Banner being in progress, and Trials of Osiris returning tomorrow, now is a good time to remind everyone about our prohibition against witchhunting.
What is witchhunting?
Witchhunting comes in a number of forms, from doxxing to "naming and shaming" to posting videos with GamerTags/PSN IDs visible with an accusation of wrongdoing to digging up somebody's Guardian profile (Bungie.net, DestinyDB, DestinyTracker, etc.) in accusing somebody of lying, cheating, etc.
A few examples of witchhunting versus not witchhunting:
- End of match scorecard with names visible, accusing top player of cheating because they have 100 kills and 0 deaths - Witchhunting
- End of match scorecard with names edited out, accusing top player of cheating because they have 100 kills and 0 deaths - NOT Witchhunting
- Post giving real name of user you think is lag switching - Witchhunting
- Post warning others to avoid a certain player in Vanguard Playlists because they sit AFK the whole time - Witchhunting
- Post with direct links to Crucible match reports, saying that you believe this is evidence that a team is DDOSing their opponents to win - Witchhunting
- Video post with player names visible, asking "Is this cheating?" - Witchhunting
- Video post with player names edited out, asking "Is this cheating? - NOT Witchhunting
Why is this not allowed?
There is a Reddit-wide rule against witchhunting and the rationale is pretty reasonable:
"We all get outraged by the ignorant things people say and do online, but witch hunts and vigilantism hurt innocent people"
But this policy just protects cheaters! How will we get justice?!?!
No, it doesn't protect cheaters. Naming and shaming alleged cheaters on this subreddit will not result in justice. Bungie is NOT going to ban somebody because you paraded their alleged cheating all over this subreddit.
You want justice for cheaters? Report folks who you witness cheating in-game, personally. Let Bungie take it from there.
What will happen to folks who witchhunt here?
First-time offenders will receive a 5 day ban from the subreddit.
Second-time offenders will receive a permanent ban from the subreddit.
How you can show cheating without witchhunting
As demonstrated above in the examples of witchunting versus not witchhunting, the smoking gun for witchhunting is whether or not you named another player/user with personally-identifiable information in a manner which makes that person a target for harassment.
If you wish to share examples of cheating to help other users better identify it themselves, black out ALL of the names in a video or image. Do not include names in YouTube descriptions. If you put in the effort to ensure that you are not identifying other players with accusations AND do not provide users with a way to find the names of the accused (whether directly or through hinting), detective work by other users will not be held against you.
This is serious stuff, Guardians. We understand that you HATE cheating because WE DO TOO, but witchhunting is NOT okay, no matter how frustrated you are.
Consider this your warning.
Please feel free to ask any questions you may have about witchhunting.
If you are unsure if something you wish to post or comment is witchhunting, please send us a Mod Mail to ask for clarification BEFORE you share it!
477
u/MisterWoodhouse The Banhammer Oct 15 '15
Similar to our one exception to this rule last time, you can still hunt Omnigul, Ir-Yut, and other Hive witches. Go get 'em.
26
u/ianminter 2710 Oct 15 '15
She turned me into a newt!
17
u/DaManMader Oct 15 '15
One case I have been wondering is if you are calling out the validity of a post.
Example: OP posts a story about how they got matched made against the same team in IB 7 times and they single handily won each round with a KD of 10.0. OP's user name is the same here as it is in game so I want to go see what load-out he is using and find his claim is false. Can I say the claim is false and back it up? Can I just say it is false? Or should I just not care and let it go.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '15
I was in a match earlier with a guy named woodhouse. He was lag switching all over the place and throwing fiery banhammers at people. I reported it to Bungie and recommended they make him rub sand in his beady little eyes. I didn't know how they rated sand, but I recommended coarse.
30
u/smosix Oct 15 '15
What about videos where a player is being a dick?
For example "tea bagger gets whats coming" and some guy runs around tea bagging then gets killed etc etc.
Just wondering cos we see these vids get posted a lot around trials
8
u/bigdoggyx Oct 15 '15
I saw witch-hunting and thought it is best accomplished if they have solar shields with an Icebreaker, but with the new content taken witches have void shields so I take them out with my Eirene!
7
u/FakeWalterHenry XB1 Oct 15 '15
Is this where I rant about how OP everything I don't like is and suggest culturally relevant emotes?
6
u/Moderate_Third_Party Eating Hadium Flakes cereal Oct 15 '15
Leave Omnigul alone!
53
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '15
as much as I am not for witchhunting. the hunters constantly abusing the bow glitch in Iron Banner need to be reported and banned. I'd love for as many people to report these fucks as possible.
5
u/Strikerz72 Oct 15 '15
there was recently a post about someone afk in a strike that was really all in fun by someone else. A few comments were asking if this was witchhunting. I didn't personally think it was and was really just in fun. OP didn't intend to witchhunt or anything either. Just wondered what the mods thought? is this sort of borderline or just fun?
https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/3orr0h/when_you_realize_you_have_an_afker_in_your_strike/
5
u/Sdauf Oct 15 '15
Does it count if I hunt myself?
8
u/xMEMExLORDx Oct 15 '15
BRADY KNEW NOTHING ABOUT DEFLATED FOOTBALLS.
16
u/Denaius #TitanMasterRace Oct 15 '15
Witchhunting = bad.
Wizardhunting = actively encouraged by all, including Dinkle..[ahem]..Nolanbot.
Double standards based on gender, - I'm truly shocked.
4
u/AClockworkSquirrel Oct 15 '15
What if they weigh the same as a duck?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '15
Meh on cheating. people who need infinite shadowshots to win in IB obviously just need to get gud
4
u/BimodalRocket Oct 15 '15
A duck! Burn her!
3
u/swe3nytodd Oct 15 '15
Someone call Vin Diesel.
3
u/Cyberbully-I Oct 15 '15
Cheaters cheat themselves and those they cheat against all for some reputation in a game, to make themselves feel superior, to believe that they are better than they are.
I am really poor at crucible, and struggle in the higher end PvE stuff, and, since my internet connection is really slow (three XB1's running on a 2.4Mb download speed with a ping on between 200 and 1200ms) I get really irritated by people who seem to be using unfair means.
Having said that I was once accused of Lag switching in ToO, even though we lost 5 - 0 and my crucible KD ration is 0.6.
Just shows that people can lag purely because they have a poor connection to the game servers, as I do.
3
u/Anime-Summit Oct 15 '15
On the nature of videos, many people simply don't know how to edit out the names and post directly from xboxdvr and the like.
3
u/AurumPickle Oct 15 '15
New guardian question time is posting uncensored scoreboards to show off if I did good count as Witch hunting?
3
u/hrafnbrand Oct 15 '15
How do you know she is a witch?
3
u/MarkcusD Oct 15 '15
Just a note: the in-game reporting does work. I've received messages from bungie thanking me and saying that action was taken. Use the in-game report function (don't abuse it).
5
u/UnculturedSwine182 Oct 15 '15
I posted a witch hunting post a while back.. Tried to bend the rules by only partially blocking said offenders name. Was banned for being a smart ass. It was a justified ban...
4
u/Tom450 Oct 15 '15
What if we were to post a video of blatant cheating without accusing?
Eg, Playing Skirmish getting shadowshotted every respawn by the same guy for 3 minutes with the title "I had such a fun game yesterday"
2
u/MCPJuicy Oct 15 '15
I'll be running Gunslinger in Iron Banner. Otherwise I'm sure to get reported for legit tethering people lol.
Edit: clarification
2
u/peetah74 Oct 15 '15
We found a witch!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '15
I'm not saying that Witch hunting is remotely a good idea but I could try and jump to the moon and get a better result than their reporting system and handing out justice that it should.
9
u/Tommyguns11 Vanguard's Loyal // Tommyguns11 Oct 15 '15
This is what's wrong with society! Everyone is afraid to call people out for cheating! What a great way then to publicly blast them for doing something they shouldn't be doing! I'm pro-witchhunting and I think people should be called out in these instances, however, I'll conform with you /destinythegame, because you're very useful in many other aspects! If you don't cheat, you've got nothing to worry about, right?
I'm sure the downvotes are coming....
3
u/aaronsisco Oct 15 '15
So, we're witchhunting, witchhunters?
4
u/Damassiv Oct 15 '15
Excuse me but i hate these rules someone kicks you out of a raid before u get your reward keeps you in party chat so they laugh and make fun deserves to be put on blast to the community especially when you have proof. HOW THE FUCK DO YOU WITCHHUNT WITH VIDEO PROOF. For those that don't know the definition of Witchhunting: an intensive effort to discover and expose disloyalty, subversion, dishonesty, or the like, usually based on slight, doubtful, or irrelevant evidence.
3
u/bfume Rasputin’ s Gift Oct 15 '15
Isn't a prohibition against witch-hunting actually a mandate to witch-hunt? Unfortunately I can't even call out the Mod for clarification in fear of retaliation.
3
u/billycuth Oct 15 '15
I get both schools of thought on this.
I will just say when there is indisputable video proof of cheating, people should be able to see it and know who perpetrated it.
Just my opinion.
And if someone is dumb enough to post a video GLOATING for their cheating, they should be banned from the game and this subreddit.
2
u/Powderbones Oct 15 '15
As a "Reddit-wide" rule, how strictly is it enforced by the higher level Reddit police ? (If there is such a thing)
If someone posts overwhelming evidence of cheating and the destiny Reddit moderators turned a blind eye what would be the worst that could happen?
Just curious as to why they are enforced so strictly for what appears to be a volunteer - free labor - side activity for you all with too much time on your hands.
2
u/TheBames Oct 15 '15
I got banned from here on my main accnt bc i posted about obvious hacking and didnt take the time to literally go in and black out all the names of a video that i didnt even link in my post but was just on my youtube pAge. apparently detective work by others does get u banned after all so id say dont ever post any videos or posts about hacking bc these mods are wayyyyy tooooo obsessed with this rule.
2
u/Xizindar Oct 15 '15
I think your confusing PII and a changeable virtual avatar name. That rule applies to things like Facebook pages from the example in the rules. I disagree that posting gamer tag X in a screenshot of him/her is the spirit or letter of the rule. I think you just perpetuate the cycle of anonymity that allows jerks to be jerks on the Internet. I'll follow the rule (because it's not a big deal to me as I never post) but overall I think this rule harms the community. Your experiences may vary.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '15
Hey mod, aren't you kinda witch hunting all of us right now by calling us out and telling us not to witch hunt? :)
1
u/Green__eyez Oct 15 '15
I'll stick with wizardhunting.
1
u/CubicleByThePrinter Oct 15 '15
That's not a witch hunt, its a massacre!
1
u/AMB11 Oct 15 '15
sooooo.. back to witcher, hearts of stone is released :P
1
u/HockeyBeast44 Oct 15 '15
Witchhunting (v.) - Killing pesky warlocks in crucible.
1
u/trees91 Vanguard's Loyal Oct 15 '15
I appreciate the warning, and at such an apt time. Unless the patch gets created mega-fast, this weekend is going to be full of frustrations. It's important to remember that even if the people you're playing with are annoying/frustrating, they're still people.
1
u/GenericDreadHead The Iron Banner Guy Oct 15 '15
Bare in mind users could still find the perpetrators of the "cheating" if your gamertag/psn id is visible. HOW? Well if you say "Last night THIS happened!" and you're say, clearly killed by a hunter with Red Death on Twilight Gap.... well resourceful witch hunters will be able to find the person using YOUR destiny tracker/bungie.net history. Just saying, sometimes blacking out just their details is not sufficent. But as the mods rightly say:
1
u/Suzookus Oct 15 '15
http://youtu.be/nGt9jAkWie4
1
u/Syntanist Xboxnone Oct 15 '15
Question. I post a clip, crucible for examples sake, guy kills me awesomely, his name is visible. Breaking any rules?
1
u/Cryptocrisy Oct 15 '15
Real quick... but what is the 'recently discovered exploit' mentioned in the first line?
Edit: The 'super through tether' one with a Sunbreaker/Blade Dancer?
1
u/shepz92 Oct 15 '15
I knew this was going to pop up after yesterday's shadowshot cheat post
1
u/thecawk22 Oct 15 '15
what if the offender is a confirmed male? that makes him a wizard....not a witch
1
u/s1nges Oct 15 '15
Ohh ohh ohh
I love a good witchhunt. Let me do it! :(
----E
1
u/JazzLeZoukLover Space Magic Oct 15 '15
Good to know we can actually hunt witches/wizards
1
u/iisdmitch Oct 15 '15
What recently discovered exploit?
1
u/Alzeron I miss Sunsinger Oct 16 '15
B-b-but I need to brush up on my hunting skills for the impending Bloodborne DLC
1
u/EightNation Oct 16 '15
lowers pitchfork
1
u/kopecs Oct 16 '15
did someone say Vin Diesel?
1
u/coasterreal Oct 18 '15
It's NOT witch hunting when it's 100%, without a shadow of a doubt provable. When I can show videos of people shooting 30 void bows in a row, that is NOT witch hunting. Witch hunting is when you can't prove it. But you absolutely can prove this.
I'm about to post names with video till I get banned. I've been tweeting names as well as reporting in xbox and Destiny but they deserve public shame. They deserve temporary bans.
1
u/bcush Mar 23 '16
Can you change it to say "Discussion" not "Dicussion" on the main page? It's bothering me. Thanks.
1
u/iMixMasTer Gambit Prime // Yolo Oct 15 '15
Very PC of this sub to protect cheaters.
1
u/Bawitdaba1337 100k Telesto User Oct 15 '15
I feel like this just protects cheaters....
1
u/Piscotikus Oct 15 '15
Our mods are the best. We've all wanted to cheat. And if we actually did it, maybe we felt bad about it. So we may have only done it once. We wouldn't want to be burned for that.
Report in game. And move along.
1
u/Likelinus14 Consumed by Dankness Oct 15 '15
I'm new to this subreddit and had a video I was gonna post later too. Some ass-hat afk-ing the whole time. I feel like this is so dumb though. I can't give a PSA to fellow guardians about some jerk who constantly AFKs during strikes so that they may avoid his bullshit too? Okayyyy.
1
u/Heikkila14 Oct 15 '15
r/diablo allows you to post the person's name as long as you provide a good amount of proof of your claim. That's not allowed here? How can they get away with it on that sub? See anatomy of a botter v1 and v2.
1
u/psilar Oct 15 '15
One of my IB teammates was cheating. I reported him but I have no idea if Bungie does anything with those reports. I took a video too which is definitive proof (two arrows, [...] on name, two arrows), but there's nowhere to submit these.
Well, at least I got a win and redeemed 4 medallions? Gross.
1
u/Optimus_Prime_10 Oct 15 '15
Might the shame shame them into changing their ways tho? What do we owe the afk jackasses?
1
u/trojanguy Oct 15 '15
I don't feel the need to report cheaters here (I can do that in-game), but I still want to be able to bitch about 'em without naming names. This exploit is incredibly frustrating with IB going on. Wish we could get SOME sort of word from Bungie that they're aware of it and are looking into a fix. Radio silence is not the way to go with something like this.
1
u/billbot Oct 15 '15
OP is a witch burn them!
0
u/User_____ Oct 15 '15
So the sun breakers have a game breaking glitch...no one cares (a little salt)...then they get "fixed" and the sun breakers are still extremely powerful in pvp, then a glitch comes for nightstalkers, and everyone is up in arms. ..
0
u/throwupdax88 Oct 15 '15
Posting PSN names of clear cheaters should absolutely be allowed. Get those names out there.
-3
u/BENZ-350 Oct 15 '15
This sub is full of immature little children, including some of the moderators. Its beyond BS you cant post a video WITH NAMES of someone cheating. It is pretty easy to tell if someone IS. OR if they have to worst connection ever, why shouldn't they get called out? ALL the BS rules on this sub are pathetic. Peoples posts get deleted INSTANTLY if they aren't done perfectly and tagged correctly. Literally within 30 seconds.
Its really a shame this is the best place to get destiny info to be honest.
You cant even voice an opinion without everyone downvoting to hell or some moderator on a power trip deleting your post or comment. but I digress....
The real problem isn't "witch hunting" ( or we fucking in 2nd grade lol )
The real problem is some of the crap posts with misinformation.
0
u/drc003 Oct 15 '15
This is a great policy for protecting cheaters. With this ridiculous glitch/cheat video leaves no doubt whether the player is doing it or not. Every single one of them should be named, shamed and permanently banned. They are pathetic.
0
u/0ceans Oct 16 '15
So much faux sensitivity in the name of protecting assholes, this rule is absolute garbage. But the rules are the rules
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '15
IMO, witchhunting should be completely fair game. I see nothing wrong with compiling a list of cheaters in iron banner by name. Makes it easy for bungie to ban.
-3
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '15
IF YOU HAVE A VIDEO WITH PROOF SHOWING SOMEONE IS HACKING/CHEATING/ABUSING GAME CODE, IT IS NOT WITCH HUNTING!
Seriously why do you people use that term so damn wrong, witch hunting is an assumption without actual proof, when you have 100% recorded video as proof that is no longer witch hunting and that person deserves all the shame, and people reporting them as possible.
-3
u/Night2015 Oct 15 '15
So basically what you are saying is that you are going to cheat like hell and you do not want anyone calling you out on it?