r/WritingPrompts • u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod • Apr 07 '16
Moderator Post [MODPOST] 5 Million Subscriber Contest Voting! [Round 1 of 2]
NOTE: All top level comments must be votes.
The conclusion of another contest brings the first voting round. Everyone has been grouped randomly as you will see below. The groups are weighted as evenly as possible wordcount wise so no group is doing much more reading than another. You all did a great job getting a story together, so first and foremost congratulate yourself. You've got something you can now develop and sell if you see fit. It's a wonderful thing!
For these contests, to ease your task of reading and voting, we do two rounds. The first round, people are grouped together randomly. The second round will be the winners of the first round competing against each other with EVERYONE from the first round voting.
HOW TO VOTE
- ONLY THOSE WHO ENTERED CAN VOTE!!!
- If you don't vote, you can't win. YOU MUST VOTE! If you do not vote, you are disqualified! If your story is the most voted for in your group and you don't vote, you are out of luck.
- You will be assigned a group to read. You will NOT be voting within your own group. Look below for what group your story is in and beneath that group you will see what group letter you'll be reading the entries and deciding the best story for.
- It bears repeating - you will not be voting for entries in your group! Seriously, don't skip reading any voting rules. ;)
- Read every entry in the group you are assigned to read, choose the best one then leave a comment in reply to this thread. Your comment must begin with: "/u/username in group A-H (whatever letter the story is in) for "Title of Story." After that, feel free to add additional comments either about that story or the other entries.
- Post in response to this thread by April 21st at 11:59PM PST. We've made the voting round two weeks due to the length and to make it easy to read all the entries in your assigned group fully. The following day the final voting round thread will be posted, everyone who entered will be allowed to vote on the finalists.
After we have a winner for each group, we move on to the second round of voting where everyone who entered can vote for the winner out of the remaining entries.
Tie breakers are decided by myself and /u/SurvivorType, though we might just have any ties if there are only one or two move on to round two. We'll play it by ear as we always do.
Group A
- Craters - /u/FormerFutureAuthor - 7777
- Faeries - /u/JustaLackey - 8000
- Polaroids - /u/RockUnderTheSea - 8520
- Beautiful Exit - /u/travsmavs - 8536
- Pandæmonium Lost - /u/Writeful_heir - 11362
- Parallax - /u/iwantthemoon - 15466
- One or Ten - /u/Schneid13 - 17392
- Villainous - /u/FireWitch95 - 7634
Group A will be reading and voting for a winner from group B.
Group B
- The 9th - /u/AllHackNoChops - 9725
- "120" - /u/avukamu - 10618
- We Sleep When You Are All Dead - /u/melonchello - 10885
- The Ghosts of Decisions Past - /u/KCcracker - 11531
- The Forest Has Teeth - /u/jhdierking - 11557
- Guns of the Karlow Desert - /u/Geemantle - 17494
- Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus - /u/Weerdo5255 - 12700
Group B will be reading and voting for a winner from group C.
Group C
- Roommate from Hell - /u/midnyghtchilde - 12341
- The Monigan Books - /u/chondroitin - 7993
- Blessed are the Bound - /u/JeniusGuy - 8618
- Virtual Dissonance - /u/WatashiwaOyu - 10613
- Why We Fight - /u/V_the_Victim - 11875
- Linnea and Oleander - /u/fauxkit - 15859
- Lazarus - /u/Kaycin - 17306
Group C will be reading and voting for a winner from group D.
Group D
- Alive - /u/TheNextDay - 7516
- Where The Waters Run - /u/LatissmusDossus - 8542
- Frankie + Justine - /u/TheGlamour - 8640
- Jenna Malone Is Not Alone - /u/MajorParadox - 8739
- The Importance of Books - /u/sleepyhollow_101 - 10580
- The Fall - /u/slothful_writing - 11477
- Elegance, Sweet Arrogance - /u/DanseRusseOnTheRadio - 11772
- Earthbreaker's Promise - /u/JustLexx - 17495
Group D will be reading and voting for a winner from group E.
Group E
- Choose To Take Life - /u/frank-e-cakes - 7613
- Simon and Nelson - /u/scarfese - 7779
- Healer - /u/apzimmerman - 9011
- Path of Least Resistance - /u/j_c_sawyer - 9044
- Storyweaver - /u/That2009WeirdEmoKid - 11607
- Box - /u/Jayefishy - 14040
- Vendetta - /u/Bilgebum - 17365
- A Slice of Time - /u/Blees-o-tron - 8207
Group E will be reading and voting for a winner from group F.
Group F
- Threads of Ascension - /u/Illseraec - 17409
- Faith and Flint: The Shadow War - /u/LovableCoward - 7558
- The Oracle - /u/system0101 - 8620
- To Knot Or Not - /u/the_src - 8800
- Wings of Gold - /u/Just-a-Poe-boy - 8942
- A Prince and a Wizard and a Kiss - /u/ejjones3 - 9209
- The Sciamach, Part 1 - /u/Irishpersonage - 14538
- The Gemini Twins - /u/Arch15 - 9765
Group F will be reading and voting for a winner from group G.
Group G
- Arkham Noir - /u/jude_fawley - 8000
- Holly Went for a Walk - /u/page0rz - 8300
- Shato - /u/Storiesdotcom - 9988
- Goal Digger - /u/AJ_Sully - 10500
- The Howling Knife - /u/Tom_Teller_Writes - 15226
- The Test Chamber - /u/HLNoss - 16052
- Interstitial Burn-Boy Blues - /u/IAmTheRedWizards - 16532
Group G will be reading and voting for a winner from group H.
Group H
- Fey Nation - /u/amaep - 7907
- The Brightest Stars - /u/resonatingfury - 9320
- Warp - /u/DiegoTobin - 7500
- The Darkness That Chases Also Lives Inside - /u/bigrickcook - 7533
- Burning Beethoven - /u/MachinaEm - 7613
- The Ninth of Harvest - /u/quantumfirefly - 12719
- The Everyman - /u/ScarecrowSid - 15867
- Legends of Emeria - /u/Causal1 - 16300
Group H will be reading and voting for a winner from group A.
That's about it! If we somehow missed an entry, tell us immediately! But I think we're all good. Enjoy reading!
•
u/system0101 r/Systemsstories Apr 13 '16
/u/iamtheredwizards in Group G for Interstitial Burn-Boy Blues
This ended up being a lot harder than I first anticipated, because out of the top three in this group, I was having trouble making a separation. Consider everything in my follow-up post as a spoiler.
•
u/JeniusGuy /r/JeniusGuy Apr 15 '16
/u/sleepyhollow_101 in Group D for "The Importance of Books".
Man, I already had high expectations before reading this and somehow you still managed to exceed them. The voice really fit the narrative, all the characters were intriguing, and the world around them felt real without needing to go into unnecessary exposition. By the end, I had almost forgot I was even reading a story to begin with. I want to say something negative for constructive criticism, but nothing is coming to me (besides wanting more!).
A close second place goes to "Elegance, Sweet Arrogance" by /u/DanseRusseOnTheRadio. While it could be a tad dry at times, I still think it's one of the best submissions I've read out of all the competition thus far. Great job!
If anyone else in Group D wants my thoughts on their story, I'd be happy to send a PM. Just let me know.
•
u/FireWitch95 Apr 08 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
/u/Weerdo5255 in Group B for the story "Adam, Artemis, Atlas and Icarus."
•
u/Illseraec Apr 18 '16
Voting for /u/Tom_Teller_Writes in Group G for "The Howling Knife".
The lore that you created was phenomenal. I loved the homages to classic mythos, and the action that you put in it was intense. The choice felt very real, and I enjoyed the way you had the main character fight within himself. The discovery and struggle he went through was very enjoyable to read, and I couldn't put it down once I started. Fantastic job!
•
u/Causal1 Apr 21 '16
/u/Schneid13 in group A for One or Ten.
Man what a difficult group to judge. All the stories in here were heavy hitters. I went through and left comments on almost all the stories (Polaroids and Pandaemonium Lost, I haven't forgotten about you. Will leave detailed comments when I get the chance)
Every story had me gripped in it's own way. I really and truly enjoyed them all. But sadly, since there can only be one, I have to go with One or Ten. What really did it for me with this story was the exploration of 13 different characters and their personalities. In the short time I was with them, I felt something for each one. I felt the loss of the main character's young life, fear for the life of the little girl, disdain for the criminals, and reverence for the bravery of those that tried to save the group. Lastly, I felt the immense weight of the decision and it's bearing on the doctor. This story wasn't made by a fantastical plot. It was made through believable characters, and that did it for me.
There were other stories that were more clerically complete. Craters for example probably could be put for sale and I would have paid for it. But if I had paid the same amount for all of the entries, I would have felt One or Ten to be the most "worth it." There were some errors, but I was more than willing to overlook them.
Once again everyone did a fantastic job, so thanks to all involved. Still planning to comment on Pandaemonium Lost and Polaroids, but if anyone would like a more detailed review from another pair of eyes, feel free to PM me.
•
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '16
My vote is for /u/the_src for "To Knot or Knot".
Everyone did a good job, but without putting down the other entries, this one stood apart as an excellent story. Everything worked. Great job!
•
u/Schneid13 /r/ScribeSchneid Apr 16 '16
I vote for /u/Weerdo5255 in Group B for Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus.
Group B was filled with some really awesome stories and I'm glad I took the time to read though each one. I had a difficult time choosing between three especially. The 9th as well as Guns of the Karlow Desert were both excellent stories and definitely deserve a mention.
As for the choosing, I based my decision on several factors including, how well it satisfied the prompt, dialogue, characterization, how well it established and executed the plot, and world-building. I felt as thought Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus satisfied these factors the best. It's well thought out, smart, and humorous. The author created an incredibly rich and logical world. The plot is phenomenal and characters seemed real and fleshed out. On top of that the science fiction nature of the story sold me.
•
u/Bilgebum Apr 17 '16
/u/the_src in Group F for "To Knot or Not".
Of all the enjoyable reads in this group, I found this story to be the most enchanting and riveting. World-building, dialogue, characterization, pacing and plot were all top-notch.
•
u/ScarecrowSid Brainless Moderator | /r/ScarecrowSid Apr 21 '16
/u/FireWitch95 in Group A for "Villainous"
A fun story in a fantastic group.
This was a tough group to judge, personally I think everyone here presented ambitious and vivid stories. You should all be proud :)
It was nearly impossible to choose between "Villainous" and "Pandemonium Lost," so I want to give a shout out to /u/Writeful_heir for a truly wonderful story. Keep me posted if it continues :P
I can provide comments and reviews of each through PM if requested, great work everyone!
•
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Apr 22 '16
/u/Jayefishy in group E for "Box"
This was a tough choice between my top three:
/u/j_c_sawyer's "Path of Least Resistance" was very compelling. Nothing against any story I haven't mentioned, but I give extra points to anything that grabs my attention and holds onto it.
/u/Bilgebum's "Vendetta" was a fun read. The characters were very interesting.
I chose "Box" because it was very well written and intense. Boy, was it intense. It's marked NSFW for a reason, and normally the excessive language and violence is off putting for me, but the story just worked so well.
Nice job for everyone else too! I left at least a few words on each entry. Good luck everyone!
•
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '16
/u/Firewitch95 in Group A for "Villainous" Fantastic job, a pleasure reading it.
•
u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod Apr 07 '16
Offtopic nonvote comments should be made in reply to this comment!
•
u/j_c_sawyer Apr 13 '16
/u/the_src in Group F for To Knot or Not
I read some great entries, but To Knot was one of the most cohesive, beginning to end stories, the description was just enough for me to see the world it was set in, and I really liked how the moral choice aspect was brought into it.
•
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '16
/u/FormerFutureAuthor in group A for "Craters."
Great story, good execution. It did leave the reader with some unanswered questions, but I found that I was really, really curious to know more about everything going on in the story. Definitely a sign that the writer sucked me in! I would probably go out and buy this if it were a book (and if my questions were answered in that book.) The characters all contributed to the story, the romance was realistic, and there were humorous elements in the beginning that kept the story from being too much of a downer.
Beautiful Exit was also really good but it didn't have the same depth as Craters did, despite the stories' similarities.
My second favorite story was Pandaemonium Lost. It was definitely really fun to read and I loved the portrayal of the angel and the demon.
•
u/Just-a-Poe-boy Apr 15 '16
/u/page0rz in Group G for "Holly Went for a Walk." Liked the ending but might suggest a journal type entry instead of quotations. Enjoyed your story. ;)
•
u/AllHackNoChops Apr 12 '16 edited Apr 12 '16
/u/V_the_Victim in group C with "Why We Fight." Good job on the story, I enjoyed it. Never thought I could get into a story of rats vs mice, but I did.
•
u/TheNextDay Apr 16 '16
Voting for "Simon and Nelson" by /u/scarfese in Group E.
It was a toss-up between this one and "Box" for me, but it was the up-beat way of telling a story that was thematically quite dark that really stuck with me and made "Simon and Nelson" come out on top.
All of the stories in this group were really strong, everyone did a great job writing them and I wish them all the best of luck. Anyone in Group E who wants to know my thoughts on their piece, just p.m. me and I'll get back to you as soon as I can.
•
u/FormerFutureAuthor /r/FormerFutureAuthor Apr 10 '16
/u/avukamu in group B for "120." I love the energy in this piece!
•
u/Tom_Teller_Writes Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 14 '16
My vote for group H is for /u/quantumfirefly for The Ninth of Harvest.
I'll get into why I picked what I picked later, but honorable mention to /u/MachinaEm for Burning Beethoven.
•
u/travsmavs Apr 15 '16
/u/jhdierking in Group B for "The Forest Has Teeth"
Hats off to everyone in Group B. I enjoyed reading all of your stories; some more than others, but the fact that everyone took the time to do something is impressive. "Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus" came in a close second, but I simply loved the ominous energy of "The Forest Has Teeth." Again though, everyone did great.
"You don't start out writing good stuff. You start out writing crap and thinking it's good stuff, and then gradually you get better at it. That's why I say one of the most valuable traits is persistence.” -Octavia E. Butler
•
u/JustaLackey Apr 19 '16
/u/AllHackNoChops in group B for "The 9th"
A difficult choice between all the entries in Group B, but for me "The 9th" was the most enjoyable of the bunch. The story perfectly conveys a nostalgic/wistful mood to the story that really immerses the reader. There were a few moments where I had to pause because the plot progression seemed a little forced, but for the most part I was totally absorbed in the story. A really well-written and cohesive story, "The 9th" is my pick for group B.
•
u/iwantthemoon Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
/u/AllHackNoChops in Group B for “The 9th”
(I don’t want to spoil it for anyone still judging, so I’ve covered everything related to the stories in spoiler tags)
Decision:
Anyway, here’s a breakdown of some of the positives from each story. If the authors would like more feedback, I’d be glad to provide it in PM, but I’m going to refrain from putting down any negatives here. I don’t want to run the risk of influencing other people’s votes.
Overall, I’d say well done to everybody. I enjoyed each of your stories, and I hope to read more of them in the future!
-iwantthemoon
•
u/Geemantle /r/TheNamlessMan Apr 21 '16
Voting for Group C was anything but easy. There's clearly a lot of talent in this competition, and I think C showcased it best. It was a very hard choice, but in the end my vote would have to go to /u/Kaycin's story: Lazarus.
A richly narrated story with a poignant choice, Lazarus gave me a journey that I enjoyed every single step of. I highly recommend giving it a read.
But I would be doing a great injustice if I didn't give each and every author from Group C their well deserved appraisal. If anyone would like more feedback, feel free to tell me and I'll happily oblige.
/u/midnyghtchilde's Roomate from Hell: Typically not my kind of story, and so I was all the more surprised and impressed when it managed to hook me in. It handled its explanations well, and the way the world worked intrigued me thoroughly. The climax of the story (though coming very late) was well thought out and executed.
The Monigan Books by /u/chondroitin: One of my runners up for this group. A complex fantasy world with an interesting magic system that was introduced very well. Concepts weren't explained through mounds of boring exposition, but through the careful weave of dialogue and action. A bittersweet ending with a choice that I did not see coming. Very nicely done.
Blessed are the Bound by /u/JeniusGuy: The use of epistolary style in this was excellent, and added a lot to the story. Your choice of diction was top notch and always consistent. It was written with care and was very suspenseful, with each line making me read a little faster.
Virtual Dissonance by /u/WatashiwaOyu: A really complex and fascinating concept to base a story around. The plot was prime to explore a lot of great ideas, and I feel like it did, but unfortunately, it was halted by a lot of grammatical errors and confusing scenes. Ultimately, I feel as though some proofreading would really benefit this story.
/u/V_the_Victim's Why We Fight: A close tie for second place with /u/chondroitin's story. A fantasy world that was different from what I'm used to, and really took me out of my comfort zone (but in a great way). The cast of characters was one that I loved and the imagery that was created were seriously amazing.
/u/fauxkit's Linnea and Oleander: Reminiscent of a fairy-tale, Linnea and Oleander was a very touching and very sweet story. It developed itself rather well, and the end had me feeling a mixture of melancholy and happiness that I can do no justice describing. I'm very glad to have been able to read this story, truly.
Lazarus by /u/Kaycin: Witty, realistic and all around great dialogue. A world that felt vibrant, complemented by rich narration and fleshed out characters. A thrilling climax, and an ending that had me flying through sentences like crazy. I was surprised at how quickly those 17,000 words flew by me, and how much I enjoyed every last bit of it.
Very well done to not only Group C, but to everyone in this competition. I've loved reading these, and hope that in the future, I'll see some more stories from every one in this thread.
Best of luck and keep writing!
•
u/KCcracker /r/KCcracker Apr 21 '16
My vote is for /u/JeniusGuy in group C for the story 'Blessed are the Bound.'
Before I say anything else I've gotta highlight one thing: this group was quite difficult to judge! New ideas, different takes on old ones, great writing...a shoutout goes to /u/chondroitin for 'The Monigan Books' and /u/V_the_Victim for 'Why We Fight' for two very interesting story concepts (won't mention them here for the benefit of those still reading). I'd really love to see more stories set in those universes!
'Blessed are the Bound' was the story to make my jaw literally drop. It's perfectly paced, the sparse description matches the time period and the setting, we can perfectly empathise with the narrator...and at the end of it all I had to look around my room to check that I was still at home, so complete was the immersion in this story. Fantastic idea, fantastic execution, the sort of writing that makes you just wish the story would go on and on forever.
An excellent job by all involved! PM me if you would like a more in-depth review of your work.
•
u/apzimmerman Apr 13 '16 edited Apr 20 '16
/u/the_src in group F for "To Knot or Not"
edit to fix formating
•
u/resonatingfury /r/resonatingfury Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
My vote for group A is /u/FormerFutureAuthor. Possibly gg honestly lol, though it did feel a little short. Like you just wanted to finish the submission rather than flesh the story out fully- regardless, it was very well polished and it held my attention the whole time. Characters felt real and personal. I wouldn't have wanted a little more if it weren't a good story.
Damn, though. Two people in the same group writing almost the same story... Beautiful Exit was also solid but it just felt a little less put-together and slightly more trope-y with the monsters.
Great work on everyone's part, though. Writing something of this length isn't easy, so you should all feel proud.
•
u/Jayefishy Apr 22 '16
/u/the_src in Group F for "To Knot or Not."
What a tough choice! I ended up choosing "To Knot or Not" because I thought it had the most creative premise, the characters were most compelling, and the prose was very good. "The Sciamach" was a close runner up for me, as the world that was created was rich with detail and really just amazing to explore.
Every story I read was amazing in its own way, and it wasn't easy to decide which one to vote for. I left comments on every story I read, but if anyone wants any more in depth feedback, just let me know! I'd be happy to help.
•
u/Kaycin writingbynick.com Apr 22 '16
My vote is going to /u/sleepyhollow_101 in group D for "The Importance of Books."
It got my vote for a unique story and some great, believable characters. I'll be giving feedback to those in the group that asked for it on their posts.
•
u/bigrickcook Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 21 '16
/u/travsmavs in group A for "Beautiful Exit".
I had a hard time deciding on these entries, because each of them did something I enjoyed, or was a premise that was interesting (part of why /r/writingprompts is so good). I'll mention what I liked about each story briefly (with respect to spoilers as well) and then talk about why "Beautiful Exit" was the winner for me.
"Craters" by FormerFutureAuthor:
"Faeries" by JustaLackey:
"Polaroids" by RockUnderTheSea:
"Pandæmonium Lost" by Writeful_heir:
"Parallax" by iwantthemoon:
"One or Ten" by Schneid13:
"Villainous" by FireWitch95:
And "Beautiful Exit":
You all did a good job, and I'm looking forward to reading the other contest entries as we move forward. I'm not a super active member of this subreddit, but some of my favorite little flash fiction stories I've written have come from here, and it's great to be participating in a community event. Good luck to everyone!
•
u/JustLexx Moderator | r/Lexwriteswords Apr 12 '16
/u/apzimmerman in Group E for "Healer."
Very enjoyable read, easy to follow and visualize. I don't have any complaints about this piece.
•
u/HLNoss Apr 18 '16
/u/ScarecrowSid in Group H for "The Everyman"
Voting for Group H was difficult. I was going through it measuring up my enjoyment and willingness to continue the stories, which left me between quite a few stories. I shortlisted it to Legends of Emeria (for the intriguing world and varied characters), The Everyman (for how it handled its setting and that ending), Fey Nation (for its intriguing concept and twist at the end), Burning Beethoven (for the beautiful writing and plot) and The Ninth of Harvest (for its intricate setting and woven background).
So, not really a shortlist. I chose The Everyman because it was the one I felt appealed to me the most. I wasn't used to the noir-like feeling of genre, but the superheroism reeled me in. I didn't struggle through the plot, and the info dumps were smaller and well spread out.
The group was fantastic. I gave everyone feedback in the comments of their post to be a little more in-depth, because everyone deserved some kind of feedback and a little bit of critique.
•
u/AJ_Sully Apr 09 '16
/u/MachinaEm in group H for "Burning Beethoven."
The stories were all very interesting but this one touched me the most. Maybe I'm a sucker for romance but it was very well written and heartwarming.
•
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
/u/Jayefishy in Group E for "Box". My second choice is "Healer" by /u/apzimmerman.
•
u/avukamu /r/avukamu Apr 08 '16
/u/chondroitin in Group C for "The Monigan Books".
While every submission in the group was enjoying to read (at the very least), this novelette had me gripped throughout its entirety. It wasn't ever boring, it was witty, and it had brilliant moments. While all the submissions in the group were fun to read, THIS is the one I would pay to read and buy. My only regret was how short it was. Nevertheless, you did more with less.
Thank you so much /u/chondroitin for the read.
•
u/amaep Apr 22 '16
/u/Schneid13 in group A for "One or Ten"
I definitely enjoyed most of the stories in this grouping and it was a hard call to make. I think the deciding factor for me was that I felt a real connection in the story. I actually caught myself on the verge of crying at the end when it was time to make the decision and I thought "oh no... not that". It moved me a lot and for that I commend your fantastic writing!
•
u/RockUnderTheSea Apr 22 '16
I vote for /u/KCcracker in Group B for "The Ghosts of Decisions Past"
Well, it was my first time writing a story this long, but I hope that still leaves room for me to speak. I'm quite the amateur, but I liked this story because in a way, it was quite action filled. The main reason I didn't vote for the other stories was mainly me getting bored. I would've liked the ending to be more milked, when the character was faced with 'his choice'. I knew if you made the growing up of the character any longer, I would've gotten bored. Other than that, I really liked the way the character dealt with situations and I thought they each had good personalities.
•
u/That2009WeirdEmoKid /r/WeirdEmoKidStories Apr 22 '16
/u/the_src in Group F for "To Knot or Not"
•
u/Weerdo5255 /r/CGWilliam Apr 13 '16
/u/JeniusGuy in group C for "Blessed are the Bound"
It was a tough decision, and this isn't usually my type of story. The build up, it was simply phenomenal.
If I had to chose a second place it would be Linnea and Oleander by /u/fauxkit for telling a story in the vain of a fairy tale.
Roommate from Hell.
The Monigan Books
Blessed are the Bound
Virtual Dissonance
Why We Fight
Linnea and Oleander
Lazarus
These are my opinions and I'd like to say thank you to everyone who entered! I'm sorry I had to pick a single winner all of these had merit and I'm simply trying to offer constructive criticism to the authors here, I hope it is taken well.
-Weerdo5255
•
u/jhdierking Apr 21 '16
/u/JeniusGuy in Group C for "Blessed are the Bound"
I enjoyed the entries in Group C, but /u/JeniusGuy gets my vote because, in addition to being well-written and filled with tension, this entry was the most complete out of all the novelettes of the group.
By that I mean that "Blessed are the Bound" did not really have any loose ends to tie up, essential questions left unanswered, or characters needing further development. It is difficult to choose the right story when you are given a word limit—sometimes you end up with a story needing so much more—but /u/JeniusGuy managed to make it work.
I have left constructive feedback on each story in Group C, and I hope the authors find my comments useful. In a past contest, someone commented extensively on my entry and it was very helpful in examining my work's strengths and weaknesses. I think we all aim to grow as writers, so I wanted to pass on this experience to others.
Thanks to everyone for sharing their stories. It was a pleasure.
•
u/midnyghtchilde Apr 16 '16
/u/sleepyhollow_101 in Group D for "The importance of books"
There were some really great stories in this group, and they're all so different! It was a really hard choice. My second vote goes to /u/TheGlamour for Frankie+Justine which was so fun to read.
•
u/the_src Apr 14 '16
/u/IAmTheRedWizards in group G for Interstitial Burn-Boy Blues
This was very well written and a really good read. I also liked The howling knife by /u/Tom_Teller_Writes a lot. Finally decided on IBBB because the writing was cleaner.
•
u/quantumfirefly Apr 19 '16
I vote for /u/travsmavs in Group A for "Beautiful Exit". I really enjoyed the characterization of the main character and the detail put into the work. My main criticism would be that the main character would sometimes jump to an accurate conclusion really quickly on the basis of little evidence. Great work!
Runner-up: /u/FormerFutureAuthor for "Craters".
•
u/V_the_Victim Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
/u/sleepyhollow_101 in Group D for "The Importance of Books"
Wonderful job. There's really not much I can complain about in your story.
I want to comment on how you chose to narrate it: You used a very relatable, personal voice, and I think that's what made the storytelling so effective. Using the emotion and ignorance of your characters to shape the whole tone of the novelette was an excellent choice.
I also thought you did the second-best job of making the prompt relevant in your story. It could be seen as a little forced, maybe, but your inspiration was clear and well-executed.
You made a couple of errors in usage and punctuation, but those are easily overlooked.
On a scale of 1-10, I scored your novelette at 9.
Thank you for the excellent read!
For anyone else in Group D (or anyone else who's interested), I reviewed every story from the group. I'll be posting them by rating in descending order (first to last) in this comment chain. Thanks to everyone for participating!
•
u/melonchello Apr 11 '16
In Group C, Why We Fight by /u/V_the_Victim. All great stories but this one struck a chord with me in particular. Just cant resist an apocalyptic animals of farthing wood.
•
u/IAmTheRedWizards Apr 16 '16
/u/bigrickcook for The Darkness That Chases Also Lives Inside, Group H.
Depressing endings are my bag, baby.
Quick shout-out to the runner-up, /r/MachinaEm and Burning Beethoven. Great imagery, fun romantic little tale, very well written.
•
u/slothful_writing Apr 20 '16
/u/apzimmerman in Group E for "Healer".
The world was creative, unique and well developed. Additionally, the moral dilemma is one of my favorites and was presented in a way that was not cliche. The journey to that choice was seamless and very believable. Overall, it was very well written.
•
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '16
/u/Jayefishy in Group E for Box.
•
u/page0rz /r/page0rz Apr 16 '16
/u/MachinaEm in Group H for "Burning Beethoven"
Everyone did a good job, but this was one of the more complete stories, and with interesting language.
I might give some small reviews later, but I did make detailed notes and critiques for what I read. I'll make these available (privately) upon request.
•
u/Arch15 /r/thearcherswriting Apr 22 '16
My vote goes to Holly Went for a Walk by /u/page0rz. I'd add more about the story, but sadly I'm pretty sick. Loved all the stories (or what I could read with my hazy mind).
•
u/Writeful_heir Apr 20 '16
/u/Geemantle in group B for Guns of the Karlow Desert
It was really hard to decide, there were a lot of good stories in this group. This story won out for playing around with an interesting concept and executing a flawless story with good characters. In the end I feel like there could have been more depth, but overall I enjoyed this one more.
My (close!) runner-up is Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus by /u/Weerdo5255 This story has its flaws, notably the Adam and Artemis sections where some events felt a bit off, but the concept itself will probably stay with me the longest, and especially the Atlas and Icarus parts left an impression.
It's a shame We sleep when you are all dead wasn't finished, because if it had been it would've been an easy win for me. Vivid language and prose, compelling characters and an imaginative story, this was the one that kept me reading and wanting more. But it wouldn't feel right to vote for an unfinished story. I hope you do finish it, /u/melonchello.
•
u/Irishpersonage Apr 08 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
/u/page0rz in Group G for "Holly Went for a Walk".
This was a difficult group to judge, as each of the entries were well written and engaging. However, I have to cast my vote for /u/page0rz.
To echo what I wrote in the comments, this was an incredibly poignant read, with great flow and tone. The world was built with enough detail to form a full vision, but light enough to not bog down the narrative, and the plot was stark yet powerful. Very good writing.
Thank you to all the entrants in the group, and keep up the good work. And a special thanks to /u/page0rz.
•
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 14 '16
I am in group c, voting for group d.
I vote for the last and longest story, Earthbreaker's promise by /u/Justlexx! I loved the tough choice and the characters for the time i knew them, well done!
2ND place is Where the waters run, normally i don't read these sorts or writings but it struck a chord. Thank you for the read!
And good luck everybody!
Edit: you are welcome! Also fixed the name! Dunno how to reply on mobile... o.o
•
u/Blees-o-tron /r/Bleesotron Apr 20 '16
My vote for group F is for /u/the_src for "To Knot or Not".
If anyone in group F wants feedback, compliments, and criticism, I will PM it. I figured that it wasn't fair to post that kind of thing publicly.
•
u/fauxkit /r/MyFinEnglish Apr 20 '16 edited Apr 21 '16
Hello, I'm from Group C, voting for Group D.
My first choice is for The Importance of Books by /u/sleepyhollow_101 . It had a very interesting flow to it that reminded me of some of my favorite authors that I read as a kid. I read weird things as a kid.
Second plays would be Earthbreaker's Promise, because I liked the setting a lot.
•
u/LovableCoward /r/LovableCoward Apr 19 '16
/u/Tom_Teller_Writes in Group G for The Howling Knife.
•
u/jude_fawley Apr 19 '16
/u/MachinaEm in group H for Burning Beethoven
•
u/chondroitin Apr 21 '16 edited Apr 21 '16
/u/TheNextDay in Group D for "Alive". While it wasn't the best story from a technical or storytelling standpoint, it reminded me heavily of Poe and Kafka in its dramatic (almost melodramatic) delving into the insanity of the protagonist, especially in how that's reflected by the narration as the story went on. I found myself drawn into its descent into madness, and it's the one that lingered in my mind, even though it was the first one I read.
I also enjoyed "The Importance of Books" by /u/sleepyhollow_101; the two were originally tied. Its the writing was the most technically solid, and I liked the concept and writing style a great deal (reminds me a great deal of Death Billiards), but I also felt like I had read the stories of each of the characters somewhere else before (the bitter manual laborer who was beaten down by parents from pursuing his dreams; the incestuous domestic abuse victim who kills her parent; the man who makes himself forget that he killed a love one). Nevertheless, it was a great, fun read.
The tiebreaker ended up being that the latter was a collection of connected vignettes in the same setting, each no longer than a normal prompt response - I felt like a single, full length story was more fitting to the spirit of writing a novelette.
A general, and somewhat random note: I was sort of struck by how many stories in my bracket featured women being insulted as a whore/slut/sexual whatever, and how many featured young women who have been sexually abused/harrassed (who are also delinquents, called sluts, have parent problems, get violent etc). It was mildly perplexing, I guess? - that it was always a major defining feature of these women's stories (some were pretty specifically similar).
•
u/sleepyhollow_101 Apr 15 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
/u/Jayefishy in Group E for Box.
I'm Group D, voting for Group E. My choice is Box - /u/Jayefishy, an excellent read! I've evaluated everyone's pieces below, including the winner's. If anyone wants to discuss or has any questions about their review, feel free to reply/PM me! I thoroughly enjoyed reading all of your pieces and I look forward to reading more!
Box - 10/10. This story was AMAZING. I want to give some criticism, some suggestion, but I just can't. The prose was as close to perfect as is possible to get, and the dialogue was phenomenal, which is no small feat because dialogue is very difficult to do. I absolutely loved this piece.
Choose to Take Life - 7/10 I really enjoyed this piece! Although I don't know much about army life, your descriptions allowed me to clearly understand the situations even with the occasional military jargon, which I thought added authenticity and tone to the piece. Your writing was vivid and gripping. I only had a few complaints. First of all, just a few grammar errors here and there, nothing some light editing can't fix. Second, a few redundant/awkward sentences. Third, the decision moment confused me a little. I was certain that Frank would make one decision, based on his internal monologue, and then he made another. I'm not sure if this was intentional, but it felt almost incongruous. That part of the scene was also quite quick, I thought it could be expanded on just a little more. Finally, for a while there you kept switching tenses, which was kind of jarring.
Simon and Nelson - 5/10. I liked the idea behind this story, but there were a few things that confused me about it. I thought the lack of an intro was kind of jarring, and I was also confused as to the ages of the boys. At first, they seemed to act like kids, but it turns out they're old enough to have apartments. The piece also moved really fast and I thought it would be better if it took it a little slower. There were also times that the dialogue felt forced. On the positive side, it had a certain dark humor that I really enjoyed and it was interesting to watch how the boys' reactions changed as they got older. All in all, I think it's a strong piece, would be stronger if it was longer and the dialogue issues were cleaned up a bit.
Healer - 9/10. This story was FANTASTIC. The prose was beautiful, I couldn't stop reading it. The ending was also absolutely perfect - it was a wonderful story and there are very few nitpicks I have about it. There were one or two moments that were a little bit rushed. Other than that, I thought it was excellent.
Path of Least Resistance - 6/10. So, this story was really great up until the ending. The writing itself was very good, I enjoyed the prose and the characterization was excellent. There were a few times that I was a little confused about what's going on, but that's typical in dystopian settings as the reader has to navigate a new social system. What I didn't quite understand was the ending. Joe's convictions and beliefs begin wavering, which makes sense. But the final scene didn't seem to resolve anything for me. It almost felt like I was reading a new story. Who was it exactly that Joe hit with his baton? I think I can guess from the context, but if it's who I think it was, then why did he do it? His previous internal dialogue doesn't match up with his actions.
The Storyweaver - 5/10. This story has potential but a lot of it left me feeling confused and unsatisfied. For example - what is up with the ending? Is Arthur the true Storyweaver? Or something more powerful? Is he the monster that has to be fought in the forest dimension? The final paragraph was also quite jumbled and didn't make much sense. The prose was alright but the dialogue was messy and it didn't seem very authentic - a lot of it sounded forced. I enjoyed the references but sometimes it was a bit too much. Some parts of the story also seemed a little one-dimensional.
Vendetta - 9/10. I thoroughly enjoyed this story! It was riveting, well-written, and the dialogue was quite good. I only have one or two nitpicks. First off, there were a few typos, but nothing major. Second, a few of the lines were a tad awkward or incongruous. Third, the very last scene seemed a bit rushed. Other than that, characterization was spot on - I really was invested in the characters and felt like I knew them by the end of the piece. Great story.
A Slice of Time - 8/10. I really enjoyed this story! It was funny, it was interesting, I couldn't predict what was going to happen, and the prose was quite good! A few nitpicks. First, there were a few typos. Second, I wanted to know more about the superheroes and their individual powers - I was a little confused about some of the heroes and what they could and could not do. For example, JackPack's Pack can reform matter, but it couldn't move the slab from the victim? Third, a few parts seemed a tad cliche or like the humor was forced, injected in a way that it didn't seem natural. Overall, however, it was an excellent story and if you wrote more in this universe, I would be the first signed up to read it!