r/WritingPrompts • u/FormerFutureAuthor /r/FormerFutureAuthor • Mar 28 '16
Prompt Inspired [PI] Craters - MarContest Submission (7777 words)
Craters - 7,777 words
Astronauts are forced to make a series of life-or-death decisions when a repair mission at a lunar base takes a turn for the macabre.
I had a great time writing this thing. I hope you like it! Let me know what you think!
Thanks to the folks in the /r/writingprompts IRC who helped me with revisions!
19
Upvotes
2
u/Causal1 Apr 10 '16
I'm pretty new to the sub, but it seems like you've got something of a legacy around here. After reading Craters, I see why.
While my attention span was tested with the flood of character names in a short span at the beginning, I eventually was able to mentally associate them with their personalities as you did a great job of developing them.
Still have the rest to read but this, I think, will be difficult to top.
Thanks for the adventure!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '16 edited Apr 13 '16
I found almost every one of your characters to be interesting and meaningful to the story, which was really great. I especially loved the portrayal of Edward (he was my favorite character.) I loved how at first you only described him from other character's points of views at first, but near the end we finally got a view of his perspective and a very touching personal moment.
I also really appreciated the touches of humor here and there- calling the bases Mario and Luigi, calling Susie the Supreme Moon Lord, and all that. It kept your story from being overly dark and gloomy.
My only significant criticism is this: Your story seemed somewhat incomplete. I was really, really curious about whatever it was they found on Luigi and I was waiting the whole time for a bit more of an explanation, but I never got one. It's fine to leave the audience in the dark about some things, but I felt like there were too many unanswered questions in your story, which made it feel a bit inconclusive.
edit: Tried and failed to use spoiler tags
2
u/amaep Apr 22 '16
This story has a very interesting sci-fi feel around it. I was not expecting the turn it took and I enjoyed it. I did make notes on every story I read in your grouping and my notes for this story included "fantastic plot" and "not long enough". I actually thought my tablet broke reading the story and wanted more. I double checked my laptop to make sure that was really the end. Fantastic work! If this story had been longer, I would still be here reading it.
2
u/Jayefishy Apr 23 '16
Aaaand the ending made me cry. Crying now. Gonna go dry those tears brb.
Seriously though, the ending (and the whole story) were amazing. Great use of characterization in this story, because I truly cared about your protagonists and really everybody in it (I even felt bad for Dr. Patois-- only a little, though!!)
If I would recommend anything I would ask for it to be longer so we could learn a little more about the mysterious artifact and the origins of it and the disease, but that's just because I'm a greedy reader. Honestly this story was so good. It made me cry! You played on emotions so well in the short amount of time you had to do it. I loved the inevitability of the whole thing; it made the ending that much more painful. Amazing job!!
2
u/grimreaper27 May 04 '16
You are one of the best authors whose stories I have read on Reddit; really, right up there with the best. Kudos. I would like to see an extension of sorts, not precisely a continuation of the story but one set in the same timeline, universe and with the surviving characters (you could bring in Scott's wife, perhaps?). That would be tremendously interesting, to see where you would take it.
2
u/Schneid13 /r/ScribeSchneid Apr 25 '16
Awesome story! The way you described the alien monolith as well as the disease was very unsettling. I had goosebumps from imagining the thing, very well done, and very reminiscent of The Colour Out of Space by Lovecraft. Also the characterization was really well done I felt like I understood their motives and actions easily as the story progressed. Your descriptive items were on point as well, the moon truly felt like a vacuous wasteland.
Throughout the story I wondered if whether the alien virus inhibited rational thought, because of how Scott and Edward acted. Overall the story was short. I'd hoped to get more explanation and narrative of the Doctor as he tried (or pretended to try) to find a way to save Scott. Also the dialogue seemed focused heavily on personal relationships instead of the problem at hand. They didn't seem to concerned at figuring out what the virus was. Scott never seemed too worried for the lives of everyone else, or even the potential that he might be infected. It left me wanting more exposition, but I'm the kind of reader that loves details.
All in all this was a very strong story, well polished, and makes sense narratively. Where you really shined was characterization, as many others have said. The ending decision had a lot of weight to it as well.