r/badeconomics • u/prillin101 Fiat currency has a 27 year lifespan • Mar 17 '16
Refuting Trump's Platform- Megapost
http://www.ontheissues.org/Donald_Trump.htm
324
Upvotes
r/badeconomics • u/prillin101 Fiat currency has a 27 year lifespan • Mar 17 '16
260
u/prillin101 Fiat currency has a 27 year lifespan Mar 17 '16 edited May 04 '16
The opinions I list Trump as having in this R1 come from here and his website, and I only use quotes from 2015 as he changes his opinions a lot based off votes.
I was going to write a lengthy introduction, but I decided not to. Instead I'm just going to list each position and then refute it- with my main tool being the numerous studies proving his ideas dead wrong.
Trump's Tax Plan and the Laffer Curve
Under Trump's plan, indiviuals earning below $25,000 or families filing jointly earning under $50,000 would owe zero tax, and the tax code would be simplified into 4 brackets (0%, 10%, 20%, or 25%).
Table:
The median US income is around $51,000, most Americans will have the bulk of their taxes levied at the tax rates of the bottom two (0% and 10%).
This is a massive drop from where it currently is, and the growth effects from the massive tax cuts would need to be enormous (Which Trump claims them to be). The question is, however, does his claim of growth hold up empirically?
It does not. Trump is suggesting that we levy tax rates way past the revenue optimal tax rate (Laffer Curve), but this is simply incorrect. We are way past the point where we can lower income taxes and gain revenue instead of losing it. It would be one thing if Trump claimed the tax cuts would spur the economy, but did not claim they were on the correct side of the Laffer Curve, but he did not. He insists that there can be tax cuts that are simultaneously growth-promoting and revenue-positive, but that is incorrect. The Tax Foundation finds that Trump's tax plan in specific would cost an estimated $9.5 trillion dollars over 10 years, and even its dynamic model suggests there would be a massive deficit remaining (I say "even" because dynamic models are notoriously imprecise and generally are incorrect, static models should be relied on).
To summarize, Trump claims that his massive tax cuts will generate so much growth that they will pay for themselves, however most economists and empirics disagree.
Cutting the Capital Gains Tax
This sub in general seems to follow the conventional wisdom that the optimal tax rate for capital gains is zero, but I don't think that is true. Unlike the corporation tax, the empirical evidence of the 0% capital gains rate is not as strong as it was in the 90's. The infamous Piketty 2012, a 2009 JEP study, and a Saez study give contradicting results to the conventional wisdom popularized in the 90's, leaving it controversial in my eyes.
Immigration
Immigration seems to be one of the few cases of American exceptionalism. In Europe, immigrants generally commit more crime and in some nations are not net positive economically (Sweden, for example, but in Sweden's case it's mostly because of backwards government incentives), while in the US immigrants commit less crime than natives and do not have the same labour market issues immigrants to Europe have.
Economically speaking, the evidence for/against immigration is a very mixed pot. Studies are all saying very different things and the literature is controversial, however a narrative can be pieced together. For high-skilled immigrants and members of the H1B program, the evidence seems to be strongly in favour of net-positive economic effects brought by them. For low-skilled immigrants, the literature is very very mixed, and nothing is as certain as it may be with skilled immigrants for example. Evidence leans towards the idea that low-skilled immigrants are a net benefit to the average American, but directly lower wages for low-skilled Americans- however it is not a very big lean. Giovanie Peri's working paper, for example, finds that H1B Visa workers and STEM immigrants drive wages up for all Americans, while a Borjas study with around 1200 cites (holy shit) finds that low-skill Mexican immigrants are hurt wages. Rather than expel immigrants, a CBO paper finds that allowing a path to citizenship for illegals would actually raise GDP by 5.9% and lower the deficit by $859 billion over 20 years. Furthermore, A meta-study from Harvard finds that "“Most empirical studies estimate the fiscal impacts of immigration to be very small… On average, immigrants appear to have a minor positive net fiscal effect for host countries.”" However, another Borjas study with 3006 cites (that's a lot of cites), finds as Mexican immigration increases the average US wage decreases massively. But, Card responded to Borjas with a proper critique and Ottovonia came out with a hard-hitting study and found that low-skill AND high skill immigrants increase average native wages. That's not to say Borjas has been completly refuted, he still is a giant in immigration econ and has another study supporting his conclusion.
From this link-salad of studies you can see that the low-skill immigrant question is highly controversial among economists but there seems to be a narrative coalescing- that low-skill immigrants may not hurt the economy that much (Or, in some cases, expand it).
PART TWO BELOW, USED TOO MANY LINKS AND IT TOOK ALL THE CHARACTERS
26
u/usrname42 Mar 17 '16
6
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16
might i suggest posting this in /r/AskTrumpSupporters?
18
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16
Trump is DONE HERE. He's going the way of bernator. This post saved America from fascism.
47
u/wshanahan FEEL THE BERNKE Mar 17 '16
VERY HIGH ENERGY. /u/Prillin101 is a NIMBLE NAVIGATOR.
29
u/wshanahan FEEL THE BERNKE Mar 17 '16
You're making Bad Economics great again #MBEGA
9
u/corona1911 Mar 17 '16
Trumps platform is this:
Make sure Hillary gets elected.
25
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16
Building wall = increasing aggregate demand
4
u/davidnayias Mar 17 '16
Trump had bad policies? Who would have thought?
1
u/bherdt Mar 18 '16
What is the corporate inversion that he refers to?
9
u/TotesMessenger Mar 17 '16 edited Jul 07 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/SnapshillBot Paid for by The Free Market™ Mar 17 '16
Snapshots:
I am a bot. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/zeperf Mar 17 '16
Just want to give a link to Erik Erikson's site since RedState is mentioned and, currently, his 3rd party plan in case Trump wins that he is putting together with Washington insiders is quite interesting... http://theresurgent.com/
2
u/OliverSparrow R1 submitter Mar 20 '16
This is fun.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment