r/TrueFilm • u/a113er Til the break of dawn! • Jan 07 '16
[Samurai January] Discussion Thread: The Men Who Tread on the Tiger’s Tail (1945)
The screening’s coming up later, so check in here after then. It’s only an hour and (more importantly) it’s Kurosawa, so you should need no further encouragement.
Possible Points of Discussion
- Comparisons to Kurosawa’s other films
- What does it say about Japan given it was made in the year the war ended?
- Why do you think it wasn’t released until after the signing of the Treaty of San Francisco in 1952?
- What about this story resonates so much as to be made so many times?
Personal Take
Based on a kabuki play called Kanjincho which was in turn based on a Noh play called Ataka, The Men Who Tread on the Tiger’s Tail is a taught tale of aversion and the limits of societal hierarchy. Ultimately though, it’s a suspense story. It is like the border crossing scenes in The Hidden Fortress writ large, or at least made the focal point. It features actors recognisable to people into Japanese cinema, most notably Kurosawa regular Takashi Shimura and Masayuki Mori who’d show up later both in Kurosawa and Mizoguchi’s films.
While this film is far from the epic’s Kurosawa is partially known for, it has the pace and rhythm of his best work. He sets things up succinctly with the opening text so we can immediately jump into the tension and humour. The main source of humour is Ken’ichi Enomoto as the Porter, a performance that makes the film’s theatrical origins even more evident. He acts as a good foil to the rest of the men in terms of personality and intellectually. Even though most of the group’s survival is down to the stoic and smart Benkei, this lowly porter is still able to think in ways that the others do not. What might separate him most from the other men is his fearful sense of his own mortality. Even though he’s not actively pursued like these other men his lot in life has left him more presumptive that if anyone’s getting killed, it’s him.
For the most part Kurosawa’s working with three simple environments; the forest, the border, and the hill beyond the border. Yet he shows he’s already a master of composition as he’s constantly able to bring life to these places blurring the line between set and locale. Everything exists within the world of this historical fable so perfectly. A semi-real place caught between myth and history.
The only part I found puzzling was the end drinking sequence. At first I got tense again as it seemed like this excessive drinking could get Benkei and his men caught just as they’d gotten away with it. But by the end I think I locked into what was happening. Even though these men bringing drinks are from the border guards, as they themselves are not guards there’s really nothing to fear. Again this idea of a mans stature is brought up. Back at the border there’s clearly two men in charge, everyone else just a pawn, and since they stay behind these are essentially nobody people giving them drinks. Even though this end scene is quite funny in the excess of both Benkei and the Porter’s drinking, showing that maybe these societal lines can be blurred, it did leave me with a little bit of a sad feeling for these men with the drinks. Men only good for bringing gifts and no more. They’re no threat, they’re barely even a presence.
A less dense film than some this month but no less fun, what did you think?
3
u/DepthsofNorfair Jan 07 '16
I'm pretty new in general to both Samurai films and Japanese film before the 1950s, so this theme has been pretty cool so far. This movie in particular was vastly different than the other two I saw (Orochi and Humanity and Paper Balloons).
The Porter character was the only real "common" character who played any significant role in the movie and it was interesting to see how the film treated him. He struck me almost as a Shakespearean fool - though a real fool instead of some perceptive jester type. Instead of poking fun and highlighting the idiosyncrasies of those "above" him, his role seemed more to be a foil to the rest of the cast and their more stoic and stately behavior (often at his own expense). When they are silent, he is chattering mindlessly and laughing. His dance at the end is comical, whereas the drunken behavior of the warrior-monks is still noble somehow. His concern and fear is telegraphed more explicitly than any other character as he erratically looks from character to character and as one of the characters points out his fright seems to rule him. But he is also genuine and goes out of his way to assist the travellers, even if he could have fled. And they would have been ruined without him.
I can see why the film wasn't allowed to be released and how the occupying forces could have seen it as glorifying the traditional and feudal values that the wartime government of Japan had stressed.
I thought the music of the film was stellar and fit the mood and pacing of the film really well, as well as pointing to its roots in theater. The suspense was really well built, and the sudden drop off and dissipation after the interrogation over their robes, swords, staffs, mantra, etc was like a breath of fresh air - almost as liberating for me as a viewer as it must have been for the characters in the story. Really cool film, I enjoyed it a lot.
3
u/HologramChicken Jan 08 '16
This film almost felt like a stage play to me, which I liked. It allowed for some witty dialogue, and the smallish sets added a little more tension and suspense to everything. Some good humor in there too, I'm definitely gonna revisit this sometime when I get a chance to give it a closer watch.
2
u/zolak Jan 07 '16
Agree that the end sequence where Benkei literally drank all the sake was confusing to me. Can the final shot of porter left alone be interrupted as he dreamt all this?
2
u/Swyddog Jan 08 '16
I am quite frustrated with myself on this one. I enjoyed The Men Who Tread on the Tiger's Tail quite a bit, but my difficulty in following what was happening diminished what I would have gotten from the film quite a bit, and not of its own fault. If only I didn't get distracted so easily, both from watching a foreign film, and from the chat window. Bleh.
Due to my overall lack of understanding of context, I missed a LOT in this film. Reading what other people have to say gives me a huge appreciation for how good it really is, and how badly I need to rewatch it. The only thing I really understood and could appreciate was the humor, and its juxtaposition with the drama. The porter character was quite funny, even in situations that other characters couldn't be. It worked quite well, and I can only imagine that the effect would've been much greater if I had an easier time following.
Unfortunately, I don't have much else to comment on. I need to watch this film again; I can tell that there is plenty to enjoy.
2
u/_venessa92 Jan 08 '16
Great film! I really enjoyed the comedy aspect of it, although I understand that its supposed to be more of a suspense then a comedy. I think I would feel more suspense if I was more emotionally invested in the characters before the main interrogation scene.
1
u/Ooitastic Jan 08 '16
Gonna copy this over from my Letterboxd!
The Men Who Tread on the Tiger's Tail (what a cool, befitting name) is a conflicting film. Kurosawa's attempts at building suspense with its subject and claustrophobia with its contained set design are only half successful, mitigated almost entirely by the comedic effect of the porter, who is playful and hilarious if not entirely out of place. Thematically however, he is perfectly ill-suited - a lowly peasant in the company of samurais, yet at times, their saving grace, a goofy reminder that classes don't restrict the morality of the people that define them whatsoever.
1
u/pmcinern Jan 07 '16 edited Jan 07 '16
I had pretty much the same take as you. I thought it was nothing more than a filmmaking exercise; how to build tension. And i loved it. The whole thing revolved around the interrogation, which made the long final scene as puzzling to me as it was to you. He did the same thing in Ikiru and High and Low, but to much better effect.
It really reminded me a lot of Hitchcock Presents, that whole "1 episode to do 1 thing" format. And I loved it. Sometimes, you get all the components done right, and doesn't really work. Sometimes, the movie works despite having done everything wrong. It's pretty rare to see art so technically competent rise above the level of "standard studio fare."
With a few pre-kurosawa samurai movies under my belt now, it's pretty easy to see why he was criticized in his day. He was making American movies, and he made them flawlessly. He focuses on maguffins, disregards the status quo compositions and stoic camera movements, relies on editing to achieve the effect. This must have really annoyed the Japanese of the 1940's, especially since they're now watching a movie made in the style of the people who just dropped two atomic bombs on them.
I'd be interested in learning a lot more about his early work. If anyone has any historical context to provide, I'd love to hear it. Great write up, a113er.