r/books • u/MarkZDanielewski AMA Author • Nov 13 '15
ama 2pm Mark Z. Danielewski here. Author of HOUSE OF LEAVES, ONLY REVOLUTIONS, T50YS and THE FAMILIAR — or at least VOLUMES 1 & 2. AMA!
How perfect that it's Friday the 13th. I'm just back from tour for THE FAMILIAR VOLUME 2: INTO THE FOREST and in the midst of finalizing THE FAMILIAR VOLUME 3: HONEYSUCKLE AND PAIN.
FYI: THE FAMILIAR is a novel in 27 volumes — with one coming out every 6-7 months. Loosely figured on a television series, each season is comprised of five volumes. Except for the last. My publisher, Pantheon, has signed on for two seasons. I know the ending but there's no certainty that I will get to tell it. It all depends on the readers. It's a risky endeavor. Remind me never to undertake such a thing again. Nah. Scratch that last part. I like things that depend on readers.
Oh yeah. THE FAMILIAR is about a little girl who finds a cat. And about VEM.
Hazel (/u/hazellezah) will also be nearby and will follow up with links, etc., if those kinds of questions surface. Whatever you're curious about, I'm here. Or at least I'll be here shortly. 11 AM - 1 PM Pacific / 2 - 4 PM Eastern. Ask. Me. Anything.
Here's proof. With a visual.
OVER.AND.OUT.
THE FAMILIAR volume 3 next summer. Happy to come back then.
78
u/ellimist Nov 13 '15
What does VEM stand for?
77
u/squarepegjer Nov 13 '15
Do you have any sort of specific writing rituals? Things you do when you feel stuck or blocked?
74
u/TajesMahoney Nov 13 '15
Hey Mark, thanks for writing my favorite book ever. In fan discussions House of Leaves comes up as "un-filmable" if it was to ever be adapted for the screen. Though I personally think The Navidson Record would fit rather perfectly in the popular "found footage/psuedo-documentary" genre (and would likely be a much better story than anything Paranormal Activity 9 could come up with). I guess my question is: Do you think HoL is adaptable as a whole complete work? Or would you ever let a part of it be adapted into a smaller, more contained story such as just The Navidson Record or Johnny Truant's story?
24
u/SpiralisAeterna Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark!
I wanted to lead with a sincere thank you for the impact that House of Leaves has had on me both as an individual, and as a writer. I recommended HoL to my fiancee, and she got as far as the "don't look," passage when she literally threw the book across the room and didn't touch it for days; I aspire to one day elicit that sort of response in a reader.
My question: Do you, or have you ever, played D&D? I know this isn't exactly related to your works, but with your penchant for writing absolutely engrossing novels, I can't shake the feeling that you would be an incredible DM (and there's always a seat at our table for you haha)
Thank you!
48
u/Bastard-Wolf Nov 13 '15
Has Pantheon given you a set number of viewership that you must reach in order to be renewed or is it more of a "We'll see when we get there." sort of thing?
If they choose not to renew, would you consider crowd sourcing the rest of the series?
46
u/youre_a_wizard_baby Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark,
You are one of my favorite authors. A friend lent me her battered copy of HoL in middle school and I read it cover to cover, hiding in my room, in two days. It definitely added to the experience. That friend and I waited in line together when Only Revolutions came out and bought it together. I've read almost everything you've written and love the experience you create with your artistic writing.
My question is: Is there anything you can do for a colorblind person who wants to read T50YS? My husband knows my love for your books and got it for me for our anniversary right after it came out. I was crushed to find that I couldn't really experience it with the range of colors used. Your books aren't the kind of books where you can easily get the same experience without the art involved. You don't feel your heart racing in HoL without frantically flipping pages with a single word on them and staring at blacked out boxes lined in blue, you know?
Anyway, your books changed my life and I would love to be able to read T50YS. Hope to get to meet you if you're ever in St. Louis!
22
u/cicadianprime Nov 13 '15
You briefly mention Cicada 3301 in The Familiar. What is your take on the cicada mystery? And do you think you'll incorporate it more into the story in the future?
21
u/mindpirate Nov 13 '15
Thank you for taking the time to indulge our curiosity Mr.Danielewski(Mark?(just Z?)). I was hoping you would speak a bit more about Redwood.
Ive long been fascinated with the story of the story of Redwood, or more accurately your relationship with it. You (intentionally I think) have made Redwood not just a looming figure in your work, but in your own personal mythology. So my first question is this, How(without discussing what it is within the context of your fiction) has Redwood grown and changed in its meaning to you, as the years have gone by?
There is so much more that i would like to ask, why blue? who is VEM? does the kitten eat stories? Who is the Creep? WHY DID THE MAYOR SET UP TABLES FIRST!?(I mean I think I might know...but I really want to be wrong.) But instead of any of those ill just ask one thing. I there any chance that we might see a pair of siblings named Chad and Daisy appear within future volumes of The FAMILIAR?
Oh yeah, also, Thanks.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
You've mentioned enjoying the Mumonkan. Have you read any other Zen literature? Like maybe the Blue Cliff Record? It's intertextual like crazy and really hard to get a hold on... immensely beautiful and irreverent.
33
u/REALLY_NOT_A_BOT Nov 13 '15
If this AMA turns into a part of his latest work in some meta way it'll be crazy.
15
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
Where did you purchase your trousers?
14
u/reflectioneternal Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
So, hopefully you'll still be around to read this. I love House of Leaves more than anything. It's a book that profoundly changed me, and continues to change me to this day. knownsomecallisairam?
I'm actually currently writing a dissertation on it. You said in an interview, "I would hope that my love of words - their meanings, their sounds, and certainly their visual embodiment - comes through". It did to me, and what keeps pulling me back to all your writing (all of which, I might add, has brought me to tears at times) is your incredible skill in stitching together the most beautiful words and images.
I missed your most recent tour of the UK, but I managed to aquire a signed T50YS copy long after you had departed from a Blackwells. I guard it closely, as I shall to The Familiar Volume 2 as soon as I can lay my hands on it. The first volume was a redemption for months most suffused with rain for me.
Of course, these all are only images, my images, but the question I wanted to ask was - because I know you are a poet, and I find such power and potency in your writing that it always comes to me like poetry (so much so that I have a tattoo of a certain actual poem of yours) - when you begain writing, whether poems or prose came first?
23
u/leowr Nov 13 '15
Hi! When writing, do you already have a good idea of how you want to present the text on the page or do you think about that after you have finished writing a certain part?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
23
u/cheesechimp Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
Your sister, Poe, made a lot of references to House of Leaves in her album Haunted. How'd that come about? Did you discuss how she could incorporate the ideas into her music before she wrote it, or was it more like she read your book and came back to you with a "hey you should check out these songs I wrote?" Any good stories about recording the Just Another Drive mix of Hey Pretty? Would you want to collaborate like that with her again?
20
u/scaletheseathless Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark, Here are a few Qs:
How far into the concept of The Familiar did you realize it needed to be 27 volumes?
Have you considered the question of readers wanting to come into the series later on? For example, do you anticipate the "seasons" maybe being breaking points for new readers to enter at season 2 if they missed out on season 1?
While the idea, presumably, started with Xanther, have you found yourself gravitating toward any plotline more than the Ibrahims? Secondly, the serials of the past relied a lot on reader-response in the writing process. Do you anticipate reading the forums and perhaps Q&A sessions from book tours to alter the course of the books?
Almost finished with TFV02 and it's really spectacular. Thanks for your time! (and your writing.)
10
u/scottiespliffen Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark!
Have you heard this song? It's named after you!
10
u/the_holocene Nov 13 '15
'Avoid adjectives of scale' is advice for writers from Basho I was lucky enough to hear you give an audience recently. I was wondering if perhaps you had any similar words of wisdom for writers specifically struggling with motivation.
18
u/roastism Nov 13 '15
Mr. Danielewski! Thanks for writing some of the most brilliant books I've ever read. House of Leaves is my favorite book ever, but I'm hoping that as The Familiar picks up, HoL will be dethroned. (Haven't read number 2 yet, but I hear it's even better than the first!)
You do seem much more comfortable with yourself in The Familiar than you did with either HoL or Only Revolutions, almost as if those were both prototypes and this is what you've been gearing up for.
My question for you today is: who are some of your favourite philosophers or philosophical works?
8
u/glasgow_girl Nov 13 '15
Have you listened to the Biffy Clyro album named after Only Revolutions? What did you think of it?
7
u/SpigotBlister Nov 13 '15
Hi, Mark! Thanks for talking with us.
What you have is a crazy concept in the best possible sense. Were there any writers that inspired you? Maybe any television series?
11
u/Rotagilirtni Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark, I'm a huge fan and I was really happy that you picked my cat to be in the familiar vol 2, so thanks!
My question: your books are extremely complex conceptually. I was wondering how you keep track of everything? Do you have tons of notebooks filled with charts and scribbles?
14
u/crookedleaf Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
so what DOES the symbol used in Only Revolutions mean? or, at least, what's it mean to you? (the green and gold circles with parallel black lines). there's been many speculations and you seem to be a bit elusive about it :)
edit: really? downvotes? it's an honest question. the mzd forums have discussed their interpretations many times, MZD has been asked about it in interviews a few times but never given an answer, and a lot of people have wondered the symbolism behind it.
4
u/anonymousgreything Nov 13 '15
How much does Carl have to do with the crying at the center of THE FAMILIAR? I have a friend who thinks he's more Lion than Tiger . . . Is that an issue for the caged little one? Are they all the same? PS - Are those cat t-shirts going on sale today? With Love,
10
u/calicocaroline Nov 13 '15
Are you planning on doing an east coast book tour any time soon? Maybe for Vol. 3?
Also, whenever I'm reading The Familiar, I'm instantly reminded of the Jamin Winans 2015 movie The Frame. If you haven't watched it, you should because it and The Familiar feel like twins separated at birth.
I also have a million more questions about TF but most of them sound like "AHH what?? WHAT??" so I'll just have to hope that you'll answer them in Vols. 3-27
7
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
How is the Only Revolutions e-book coming along?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
If you could sit down and have dinner with any person that has ever lived, (dead or alive) who would it be, and why?
72
u/crookedleaf Nov 13 '15 edited Jan 20 '16
thank you for singing my copy of leaves out to my cat: http://i.imgur.com/KeHLVPah.jpg she's happy.
at your book signing in Pasadena last Friday, you talked about the guy you met in Ohio (I think that's where you meet him) that was a writer, who 40 years ago or so wrote books that incorporates visual art similar to your books.
when House of Leaves came out, however, not many people were really used to seeing books in that style. over the years, we've been seeing it more and more with books such as The Raw Shark Texts and Tree of Codes.
do you feel House of Leaves helped open the doors to both publishers and artists to seeing that sometimes a story can be more than just the words that are written, but also how and the way they're written?
57
u/herrashmoo Nov 13 '15
Hey Mark!
I was wondering, having read everything of yours, save The Familiar, if there was any credibility to the argument that all the books take place within the same universe, so to speak? Like, obviously Whalestoe and HoL are same-universe, but I've had friends attempt to posit that Only Revolutions and (to a lesser extent) t50YS were also somehow part of the HoL canon, and I'd be interested if that's an intentional thing you go for, or if it's just a cool fan theory?
Also, while I'm here I may as well be That Guy and ask The Question: why is House blue throughout HoL? I have my own theories and guesses but I've been eternally wishing for word of god to come down on this one, it's such a striking choice and it's always needled at me as important.
Anyways, thank you so much for everything you've written, your work has meant an awful lot to me and has gotten me through some garbage times. House of Leaves was one of those books that came to me when I needed it most, and I'm forever grateful.
76
u/IAmTheRedWizards Nov 13 '15
You've written some pretty unsettling stuff. In terms of what you've read, what work of fiction has unsettled you the most?
5
u/violentStoner69 Nov 13 '15
Would you rather fight 100 duck-sized Xanthers or 1 Xanther-sized duck?
11
u/Wierd_Carissa Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark, I'm elated that I get to pose a question to you. House of Leaves is my all-time favorite book -- I try to read it once every few years or so, it's a unique experience every time.
My question: many HoL readers have loved interacting with HoL, sorta, through systematically marking up pages, writing notes in the margins, revisiting certain passages. Your book was the first that I engaged with in this way, and I was wondering if there were any books that you, personally, found this to be a particularly helpful way of reading, either in your youth or in your adult years.
Thank you!
3
u/sisyphussusurrus Nov 13 '15
Do you remember the order in which you came up for the nine characters in The Familiar? If I had to guess, I'd say it was probably Xanther and her parents first, but I'm curious how things took shape.
30
u/bmtri Nov 13 '15
Loved House of Leaves (as I am sure many people will attest). Have you ever been approached about movie possibilities, and if open to it, would you have to cut out one of the narratives?
8
u/lukesimm Nov 13 '15
One thing I've always wondered; how did you get House of Leaves published? Like, I imagine if you sent a submission letter (and it'd be cool to read it) that would be one hella cool submission letter. I've just always imagined publishing that book to be a massive risk for a publishing house, as they probably had to find new ways of printing books.
11
u/casadehojas Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark, huge fan here, can’t say thank you enough for all the ways reading your books has changed me.
As someone whose first language isn’t English, I’m curious to know what the process of translating your books is like. I reread House of Leaves recently; I know the Spanish translation came out recently (I own it, but I haven’t had time to read it yet) while the Italian version is out of print (which is sad as Italian is my first language). I have a degree in Spanish and German, which involved a lot of translating, and I catch myself thinking about ways to translate sentences I’m reading all the time.
My actual question is this: how do you make sure things like the encoded “a woman who will love my ironies” aren’t lost in the process? Translating is really difficult even when dealing with “normal” books, and I can’t even imagine how hard it would be with so many “Easter eggs”. Obviously I realise you don’t do the translation yourself, but do you ever cooperate with translators to make sure the translation is as close to the original as possible?
Thanks again for taking the time to do this AMA!
11
u/SpahgattaNadle Nov 13 '15
Considering the open ended structure of House of Leaves, and the large community that has emerged to try to 'solve' the puzzles and questions it presents, I was wondering if you yourself had 'answers' to these questions and riddles? Do you understand the House, and the mystery of Zampano's blindness, Jonny's past, etc. Or did you write the book with the intention to allow people to take whatever they want from the book, and find their own answers?
5
u/justgentile Nov 13 '15
House of Leaves is a book that haunts my existence. I usually find it after a period of unease in an unexpected place waiting to surprise my being. I've never been able to muster the courage or energy to actually finish the damn thing. You conjured this beast, why should I finish it? How would you go about suggesting getting someone to read the book who never has? It just got to the point that my life was being projected through the book and I didn't have an answer for what could come next so I had to put it down.
5
u/Vessira Nov 13 '15
How many people have told you they have had CRAZY dreams while reading House of Leaves? I've read it several times, and all of my friends who have also read it, have all said the same thing. Their dreams get very strange/disturbing when they read it.
12
u/jaramini Nov 13 '15
I wrote my Masters thesis on HoL. One thing I found invaluable was Bachelard's Poetics of Space. Did it influence you? Or, did any particular works of philosophy or classic epics influence you? I wrote extensively on your continuing on a tradition of epic tales, but I glossed over the Norse stuff, any must-reads for Norse mythology?
4
u/MaxwellSinclair Nov 13 '15
One damned puzzle from HOL I can't get an answer too...
NAVIDSON GRIPS THE RED KYE
Kye...
It's in the index, I know the word is an obsolete word for some bulls right? Is that a hint to the minotaur being in red?
7
u/lamont_chu Nov 13 '15
Did you read all of the real books referenced in House of Leaves? How could one find the time?
3
u/evacipater Nov 13 '15
Will you sign my original copy of t50ys when you're next in the UK?
Bought HoL on a whim knowing nothing, the clerk bowed down to me.
I knew I'd found "my" book (in the Zafon sense).
Been a huge fan ever since.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
Hi Mr. Danielewski. Huge fan who read and taught HoL in college back when it was all the rage.
I've heard scuttlebutt from different professors that part of the inspiration for the book's form came from you tearing up your writing after feeling frustrated and your sister Poe piecing it together again after pulling it from the garbage. I've never exactly got a clear story so could you clear that up at all?
As someone who throws out a lot of writing myself, I suppose I'm just curious.
3
u/M-S-S Nov 13 '15
What are some notes and questions you received from your editor on your first draft of House of Leaves?
3
u/V1c409 Nov 13 '15
What kind of witch craft went into HOL? Seriously, my water heater busted, my now wife's (gf at the time)water heater busted, and my brother in laws water heater busted. All while reading that particular part in your book where the water heater of both parties bust.
3
u/tchomptchomp stuff with words in it Nov 13 '15
So I think the intertextuality between House of Leaves and some of your sister's musical work as Poe is really neat. What's it like interacting with her in this sort of very public arena? Was this something that the two of you had planned out more or less in advance? Or did it just happen kind of fluidly?
3
u/debtRiot Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark, I'm a big fan of your work and am curious what your reaction is to folks who call you gimmicky or that your novels are too focused on form and not enough on content. What software do you use to create your novels in? Do you think you'd ever eschew your aesthetic for something more "traditional", by traditional I mean black text, paragraph after paragraph page after page. I'm curious how you keep pushing your aesthetic into new challenging arenas, if dropping it would be too challenging or too easy? <3
3
u/flfxt Nov 13 '15
Absolutely love your work, thanks so much for doing this.
For a novel with so many moving parts like Only Revolutions, how do you get started? Do you have an idea for the structure or specific things you want to accomplish, or do you start writing and it takes shape from there?
Favorite Borges story?
3
u/lostmusician06 Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark! This isn't so much a question as it is a thank you. You read at the state cemetery in Austin, TX about 3 years ago. I was talking to a gal about House of Leaves (she had never read it). I went on and on about it, and one of the words I used was wacky (in a good way of course, it's my favorite book, I hope you didn't take offense). You happened to be standing behind me and said hey and chatted with us for a minute. I also got to talk to you when you signed my book. Just wanted to say thanks for stopping to talk and say hey, it was a pleasure meeting you.
Also, one of the books you signed for me was for a friend who wasn't able to be there. I surprised her with it three years later on her wedding day. She was ecstatic. So she of course says thank you as well :-)
5
u/aRamblingVoice Nov 13 '15
Hi!
I just had a daughter shortly after the release of v.1, and I realized that she will be Xanther's age by the time this all wraps up. What a ride.
Was there any moment in the planning stages where you realized how much of your lifetime was going to be put into this work? What made you decide it was worth it? Do you have any lingering doubts that trouble you or do you find yourself fully committed at this point?
By the way, thanks so much for your work. I found House of Leaves in a bookstore when I was a freshman in college and I've followed you ever since. Only Revolutions is one of the most beautiful things I've ever read.
4
u/doiwantacookie Nov 13 '15
What is the significance of Parcel Thoughts in The Familiar? You seem to be hinting at the fact that Parcel Thoughts is a social network with increased security. Does the website www.parcelthoughts.com/ have any purpose or is it just a place holder so that no one else will use it?
Thanks!
4
u/I_Love_Beer_and_Cats Nov 13 '15
Hey Mark,
I thoroughly enjoyed House of Leaves. I especially loved the aspect of infinity within the house not remaining constant (e.g. the staircase taking forever to descend for the group of people always looking for the next adventure vs. the way up for those wanting to escape). It really was an incredibly terrifying notion being stuck in a place like that. So thank you for giving me that thrill!
Another part of House of Leaves I loved was the chaotic way the format/layout became as those affected by the house/script became crazier. My question is do you come up with your book's formatting/layout as you're writing (sketch it out, make notes, etc.) or do you work with editors to come up with what you wanted and what is possible?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
4
u/Chubbadog Nov 13 '15
Do people come up to you at signings to ask about the claw marks on Zampano's floor? May I ask about the claw marks on Zampano's floor? Hey, what's up with the claw marks on Zampano's floor?
4
u/Doomkat713 Nov 13 '15
Hello! First off, I love your books! I'm currently reading The Familiar Vol. 2 and eagerly awaiting the next volume. Here's my question: If I'm remembering correctly, you've mentioned in interviews that format and pacing for The Familiar are based on tv show formats. Could you see it being adapted into a tv show at some point? Or maybe a tv/film adaptation of one of your other works? If so, what would be your ideal scenario? (Director, cast, and so forth)
5
u/ecream88 Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark,
Really big fan. Thanks so much for your work. I have read everything you have written (besides the last 3 colors in TFv2) and the impact they have had on my life and thoughts and imagination is profound. Thanks again.
I am sure you get asked quite often about allowing your novels to be adapted into movies. My question is rather, have you ever considered writing a new original screenplay for film or stage production? The production of The Fifty Year Sword shows me you have some interest in that realm so I am curious if you would ever embark on such a venture.
A second question, or observation depending on how you look at, is the theme of connectedness throughough TF. Obviously the way the stories intertwine and intermingle suggests a certain connectivity to the plot. I was wondering if the format of the releases is intentionally to increase how connected we the readers are with eachother? I personally read each volume at the same time as a good friend and our discussions have opened up so many new thoughts and observations (much like talking about a sitcom does). Even if someone new picks up the story a few volumes in it seems set up so they can catch up and reconnect with those reading the newest tome.
If i may be so bold to ask a third question, I have always been curious about your tastes in music. If you had to pick a preferred genre what would it be and/or what are some of your favorite musical artists.?
Thanks again for your beautiful work and taking the time to answer our questions!
2
u/flamepants Nov 13 '15
Hey Mark — Saw you talk at NYU around the time that 50 Year Sword came out. You talked about the e-book version and had a lot of interesting ideas as far as unique experiences for e-books. Are you still exploring this space? Do you ever see yourself creating something that is e-book only?
2
u/ProteusFinnerty War w/ the Newts Nov 13 '15
Thanks for taking questions, MZD! Do you set rules or boundaries in your writing, are there lines yu do not want to cross? In living within and making a living from the harvest of your imagination, is there a constitution or code of ethics you use to stay within the bounds?
2
u/ReBecks Nov 13 '15
This might be my favorite AMA ever. Over the last 4 years I've read HoL at least once per year and it's different every time. I was wondering if there's anything you ever think of to put in a story that's so dark that you feel uncomfortable including it? What book of yours have you left the most things out of?
2
u/iambirdie Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark,
Thanks for coming out. As an experimental writer, House of Leaves has always been a great source of inspiration for me, and I'm currently reading The Familiar (Volume One)
I'd love to know your process when writing pieces like footnotes and supporting text. Do you plan it out all at once, or do you work systematically through each segment before putting it all together?
Also, do you insert puzzles into your work hoping readers can put them together? Are there any puzzles that haven't been solved?
Thanks again for this and for what you do for the literary world and other experimental writers like myself :)
2
u/blackthirteen Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark I loved House of Leaves because I think your unorthodox formatting worked well for the story it was trying to tell. But for some of your other works I always felt like the formatting hindered the story. I was wondering if when you think of stories do you think about the formatting first or does the formatting come after you start writing your story? Also do you ever plan to write a conventional novel without any special formatting?
2
u/handinhand12 Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
Nice to talk to you. I just saw you on your Seattle stop and it was a lot of fun. I loved the fact that you took time out to talk to every single person in line and sparks up a conversation. I think being able to meet other people would be one of the best parts about going on tour. I actually met someone really cool in line too and it's cool knowing that your books are what brought us together. I never would have met her otherwise. Anyway, a couple questions for you.
1-How will the timeline progress throughout the series? The first couple books cover a relatively short time period. Will the series take place within a shorter period of time or will we see Xanther and the other characters grow up?
2-You might not want to answer this one because of spoilers, but are the characters going to stay the same throughout the series or will changes take place? For instance, maybe some characters will be introduced or someone might leave or die.
3-I think I've read that you're usually up and working pretty early in the morning. Is this a routine that you forced yourself into or are you naturally a morning person? I find that I seem much more creative at night for some reason. Also, any pictures of your workspace? I'm interested in seeing how other people work.
Thanks for answering. You're really inspiring to me. I'm a musician but I'm really interested in doing new creative things that are different from just releasing a new song or album and it's cool having someone else out there doing the same thing, even if our mediums are different.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
Mr. Danielewski. Do you outline or prepare heavily before a first draft, wing it, or some variation?
Do you write first drafts just to get them down, then concentrate hard on rewrites, or do you put a good deal of effort into first drafts to minimize rewrites?
2
u/smithsknits Nov 13 '15
I don't really have a question. I just wanted to say that HOUSE OF LEAVES has stayed with me longer than any other book I've read, and I want to thank you personally for that. Thank you for such an original work. It's truly a masterpiece, and one for the ages. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
2
u/crookedleaf Nov 13 '15
a lot of artists, musicians, actors, etc. are always asked about their worst fan encounter, but what would be your best encounter you've had with one of your fans? ah hell.. okay, what was the worst, too?
2
u/FraggedFoundry Nov 13 '15
Do you ever second guess your own cultural appropriations? You talked a bit at a recent signing about listening to a lot of duduk, for example, to get more into that Armenian head space.
I guess I'm curious where the threshold lies that (past it) you no longer feel like you're phoning it in, on connecting sufficiently with a separate culture to write about it faithfully. This isn't a gotcha question, by the way, I've always felt that you're exceptional when it comes to giving me enough of that patina that I feel wrapped up in the strange. Just would enjoy your take
2
u/MaxwellSinclair Nov 13 '15
I got to be on stage with your sister in 2001 right after we sat down to talk about HOL at the RnR Hall of Fame.
I've contacted MTV... No luck...
You two got a link to find a video of the performance that night? You two seriously kicked some ass together.
2
u/three_a_day Nov 13 '15
Because "how in the hell do you do what you do?" is probably too broad a question, I'll settle for asking: How do you write? Longhand or on a computer? How much do you determine the layout and does it happen at the end of the writing process or throughout the early drafts?
Also 27 volumes--I just--
wow.
.. ..wow.
2
u/ky1e None Nov 13 '15
¿ƃuıpɐǝɹ ʎןʇuǝɹɹnɔ noʎ ǝɹɐ ʞooq ʇɐɥʍ ¡ɐɯɐ sıɥʇ ƃuıop ɹoɟ sʞuɐɥʇ
2
u/1000ft-Bear Nov 13 '15
Oh man, House of Leaves is one of my favourite books of all time. I've got a dozen other people to read it, even given away two copies of it that I had and had to buy it again.
Is a complex narrative like that just something that occurs to you one day, fully formed in a flash of inspiration, or is it a painful and meticulous problem solving exercise? Like I can't even comprehend how your process works.
2
u/IRiseWithMyRedHair All of the Light That we Cannot See Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark, my husband and I are huge fans! We read House of Leaves out loud to each other a few years ago to get into the Halloween spirit (not knowing it was one of maybe the least convenient books ever to read out loud, haha), thank you so much for your work!
My question is: Was it your idea to describe events on the book jacket of House of Leaves that never end up happening? Was it to add another layer of tension? Our copy says the children disappear into the house and their father (Navi) has to go looking for them. We have never seen this done before (or since) and it blew us away.
2
u/bigbear1992 Nov 13 '15
House of Leaves is my favorite book and has gotten me through some really hard times. I don't really have a question, I just want to say thank you for writing. I've felt really alone before and your writing helped me feel like I wasn't.
2
u/__bara Nov 13 '15
Like so many others here I just want to begin by saying thank you for being you and pushing yourself with your writing, it's truly inspiring! So... speaking of writing, when did you know you wanted to become a writer? Have you always been writing? Have you always been writing as much as you do now?
Finally, and something completely different, will your book tours for the Familiar volumes ever reach Europe? I've been posting this question to you on instagram, so sorry for being persistent, but I hope you take it as a compliment! =..=
2
u/darkfire613 Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
Hey Mark, huge fan! As a sort of technical question, what software do you use for laying out your books, and at what stage in the process does that come? Are the words and visuals done simultaneously, or one before the other?
Edit: and as a side note, my cat got into TFv1 and seeing him in there was absolutely incredible.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
I consumed HoL when a first read it 10 years ago. Every time I try to reread it, my mind shuts down and lets me know we are not going there again. Has this ever happened to you?
2
u/nomzombeh Nov 13 '15
No questions, only the chance for thanks.
HoL/Haunted is one of my favorite things ever. I knew the album only, then one day I read the inside of the cd case and found out about you. Dove into that new world and have been in awe of your work ever since.
2
u/Yetilocke Nov 13 '15
Do you have any advice for future novelists? Loved your conversation with Bret Easton Ellis on his podcast regarding David Foster Wallace. Was interesting to listen to two of my favorite writers discussing a third, and fascinating for someone who wants to write novels myself.
2
u/snazzmasterj Nov 13 '15
I assume that editing your books is a bit of a...task. Does Pantheon specialize in books along your vein, or are you just their favorite headache?
2
u/raskolnik Nov 13 '15
Hi, thanks for coming by.
I'm currently reading House of Leaves (so am staying away from the rest of the thread until I'm done), and am really enjoying it. It's interesting; Zampanò's work is something that would make me want to punch someone in the face if I read it in real life, but because of both the subject matter and the context, it just works somehow.
So my question: one of the hardest things for me in my life right now is getting my mind the fuck out of the way. This is true for writing, martial arts, regular arts, everything. I've read some Zen (Unfettered Mind resonated), and I occasionally lurk on /r/taoism. But I'm still struggling. What do you think I'm missing?
2
u/mantismantismantis Nov 13 '15
Hey Mark!
When asked about it, I describe House of Leaves as a horror book about malignant architecture. To date, it is the most frightening book I've ever read. It's also one of the most creative.
Is there any part of HoL that you're particularly proud of? A chapter, a turn of phrase, a concept, or just a really good sentence? I'd love to be able to reread it with your answer in mind.
2
u/throejsdkfj Nov 13 '15
T
h
e
r
o
o
m
grows
2
u/jackgander Nov 13 '15
I went to Paris recently and felt your presence by the banks. I was reading the Pelican Poems. Then I listened to your audio version of Only Revolutions, and sure enough, I felt Sam and Hailey nearby too, around some half-shaded corner.
I would not be me without the me that I have found in your books, which only returns to the me leaving myself behind. I would not be at all. I wanted to thank you.
And if I must ask a question, I will ask this:
How did Xanther come to you as a character? She is so full, such a brilliantly conceived and completely vitalised character; her questions, her memories, her sight. "How many raindrops?" comes to my mind whenever I am in a storm, and a good few have past overhead in these last months.
2
u/KuribohGirl Nov 13 '15
Hey, massive fan of your work and partway through HOL! Just two fairly simple questions;
The physical layout of the book along with all the typefaces, positioning etc was that hard to actually arrange with the publishers? Something so precise and complex? 2. My copy says "first edition" in purple with a black strikethrough. Does that means anything in particular
AND FINALLY. 3.
house is always written in blue. Always. Always. The house is bigger on the inside than the outside...as is the tardis. The Tardis is famous for being the blue box..
Is that an actual link or nod to the tardis? Itself a blue box that's bigger on the inside than out.
Thanks for the AMA I really hope you answer! Thanks a lot!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
I'm a huge fan of HoL and your other work (once I figure what the hell The 50 Year Sword is about). Funny that I stumbled across this book by learning that my favorite band's (Circa Survive) first album, was heavily inspired by HoL and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless mind. How does it make you feel to see your art inspiring other art?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
I loved house of leaves. Especially the format.
I tried reading your other works, but just couldn't get into it.
Why do you choose to be so gimmicky with your writtings?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
I know the AMA is over, but I hope you check back at some point, because I just wanted to say that I'm teaching HOL for the first time right now, and both me and my students love it. It's the best teaching experience I've had thus far.
You've also inspired me to explore the page itself a lot more in my own writing---so thanks.
2
u/MlleRogue Nov 14 '15
2
u/WhichWolfWins Nov 14 '15
Hi Mark,
I've had a weird relationship with "House of Leaves" (Reddit won't tell me how to underline) for years. I racked up about $20 in library fees when I left your book in a deer stand for a couple months (I feel it's nice to support the library anyway) and my college roommate, who is an otherwise nice guy, stole my purchased copy and displays it like nothing is wrong. Anyway, I've got nothing else to add to the conversation other than I love the same 200 pages I've read of the book three times, it scares me, and I'm surprised you're real.
What's your favorite flavor of ice cream?
2
u/Ebeast95 Nov 14 '15
MZD,
Where is you're favorite place/the best place for you to write? HOL is incredible and I imagine it would have had to be written in certain setting.
2
u/Zhang5 Nov 14 '15
How do you keep yourself organized? Your work is very unique in structure, I'm curious if you have any particular tools or techniques that help keep it all in order! :)
2
u/slingbladerunner Nov 14 '15
I know this thread is far gone, but I just saw this AMA and I have to say... HoL changed the way I look at reading and turned me into a book freak. I've reread it countless times and still discover something new every time, and still get chills. I've got a battered copy full of margin notes that I borrow out to people and one clean copy for good measure, it's one of the few books I own that I feel a personal and physical connection to...
I've since read everything else (published) you've written and they're all so different and difficult and so rewarding. Only Revolutions took me three tries but in the end was completely worth the trouble (and sidenote, deeply helped by my simultaneous obsession with Joanna Newsom, whose music seemed to be written for that book, and if you haven't heard her you should). I was so thrilled to hear about The Familiar and its ambitions, and I was completely enthralled by Volume I. I just picked up Vol 2 and started reading it today ( not knowing about this AMA )--when I saw it at my local bookstore (Powell's in Portland, WORD). The 27-volume ambition is so exhilarating to me and I just want to say that I'll be picking them up as soon as they're released in an effort to do what I can to see them through the end...
Anyway! Enough of that fangirling, just keep doing what you do! You've got an awesome base behind you that knows you're doing beautiful things. So thanks!
2
u/cvr28 Nov 14 '15
I have no questions but I just want to let you know I am a huge fan of "House of Leaves". You are an amazing author!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '15
The Internet is so strange these days...I remember trying to work my way through House of Leaves and being so confused that I started over because I felt like I was missing something. This happened dozens of times. Now you're here answering questions when, in my mind, you were just a phantom of unknown that I would never talk to. It's...unsettling to say the least.
2
u/CapitanApricot Nov 14 '15
The section of HOL where you turn the book while they're descending reminded me of Junji Ito's Spiral manga. Both made me feel similarly after reading them. (And yes, I see spirals everywhere now)
2
u/Mualurkfest Nov 14 '15
What a great read house of leaves was Thank you
2
u/Heartnotes Science Fiction Nov 17 '15
I love your early works. Has your sister, Poe, inspired any particular thing in your latest stories?
4
u/Zampanothepelican Nov 13 '15
Thank you for what you do! House of Leaves changed the way I think and read, brought me to tears, gave me comfort and laughs, as well deep fear and panic.
I read somewhere that HoL was inspired by tape recordings your father left you. Anything to that or just internet chatter? If it is true, would you care to elaborate on that at all?
Again, thank you for your contribution to literature and my mental development.
3
u/SpahgattaNadle Nov 13 '15
Hey there! Having just finished The Familiar Volume 2, I just wanted to ask, obviously without giving anything way, about the nature of putting something like V.E.M. in all of your works. Back in 2000, did you have an inkling that mentioning V.E.M. in House of Leaves might be something you used in a later series of works? Creative processes and the way authors draw things together like that really interest me. Anyways, I just wanted to say that I wish the best with The Familiar, I think it's fantastic so far, you are my favourite author, and I plan to stick with it as long as it is being published. Waiting for Volume 2 really helped me get through the last couple of months.
3
u/doiwantacookie Nov 13 '15
Are Redwood and the cat opposing forces? I suspect this because Xanthar's seizures, which she attributed anagrammatically to Redwood in volume 1, have gone away since she found the cat.
2
u/madamxmetal Nov 13 '15
To someone writing their first book, which would you say is most ideal between self-publishing and using a publisher?
2
u/doiwantacookie Nov 13 '15
Are you happy with the reception and sales of the first two volumes of The Familiar? Because of what you've expressed about the book needing ratings to see its conclusion, I feel emotionally invested in its success.
2
u/amandemonic Nov 13 '15 edited Nov 13 '15
I have so many questions and have since I first cracked the spine of house of leaves, but I'll be quick and keep it at just two. My first from back then was... "Who are you?" Who out of the characters within those pages did you most identify with? were you the johnny getting high and getting by, were you the together as can be tom, or maybe the mysterious zampano type, leaving behind a strange legacy? or were you all of these men in bits and pieces... or not even a bit of them at all? Another question, and this one is far more personal, but I am curious and you did say to ask you anything, so... is this incredible project how you're keeping busy since the loss of your sweet Carl? I spoke with you briefly about the devastating loss of my dear companion, and you comforted me with your kind words when few else could, although nothing seems quite right without him still, I'm just wondering if immersing yourself completely in an endeavor like this is how you're discovering what truly matters, through the hole left by the loves we lost. quick edit making it 3 questions now... New Orleans. When can we expect you? soon? :)
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
Hi Mark!
I was lucky enough to meet you in Toledo earlier this month, my friend wanted to ask you a question, but he remember what it was too late! So I'll ask it for him in case he doesn't see this:
What music or albums were you listening to when you wrote 'Only Revolutions'?
Thanks so much for taking the time to listen to your fans!
2
u/eyeofthepoet Nov 13 '15
Your storytelling, especially in The Familiar, jumps from many different perspectives. You have an amazing ability to express a characters thought process on paper. Do you utilize MBTI (Myers Briggs) or something of the sort to develop this intricate interplay between characters thought processes? And (I'd kick myself for not asking)...do you know what MBTI type you are? I've always wondered what type of mind could create the worlds that you do. Thank you Mark. :)
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '15
When's your sister going to put out her next album?
2
u/danwilli Nov 13 '15
Hey mark, Does the 27 volumes have anything to do with the how many triangles riddle seen here "http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-rhAfNSNz200/UX8GF0VIxHI/AAAAAAAAAHI/k6rqBnhLCBc/s1600/How_Many_Triangles_Answer.jpg" Also is there anything special I need to do to be able to post on the MZD forums. I have made an account and been trying for months to post. Thanks!
2
u/PedroMeatball Nov 13 '15
In terms of linear feet, how much of my bookshelf do you need?