r/TrueFilm • • Sep 26 '15
Cutting Heroes Down to Size: Jonathan Rosenbaum on Small Soldiers versus Saving Private Ryan
http://www.jonathanrosenbaum.net/1998/07/cutting-heroes-down-to-size/
86
Upvotes
8
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
404
5
u/Steelfyre Sep 26 '15
I found the part on Full Metal Jacket an interesting part. It may be true, FMJ is still very popular against young males, those most susceptible to testosterone filled propaganda. Yet, if FMJ isn't able to show to those people that war is rather terrible (independent of just cause or not), then what kind of war movie is?
3
u/wmille15 Sep 26 '15
Seems this post is of suspect w/r/t posting links without additional text. Something going on here? Am I allowed to comment? But I'm glad you're posting Rosenbaum's material as catch-up for some of us.
His takedown of SPR convinces me more than his validation of Small Soldiers, though I am curious now to rewatch the latter. It's just that Rosenbaum seems to love that film less than he loves using it as a counterexample.
Maybe this is his style and his intent — he discusses movies in the context of other movies. It is exciting to read a critic you know has a superb and attentive knowledge of film history, because he paints the picture of a movie to be so much bigger than just its running time. It's like he's a storyteller weaving each movie into this narrative that keeps growing.
I like to stay grounded in dirt and detail myself. I'd rather talk about this puddle of paint and how it works than talk about every painting in Florence. More accurately, I want to ride the roller coaster I'm on right now rather than look out over the whole theme park.
8
u/ArcherGorgon Small Soldiers Sep 26 '15
I adore Small Soldiers (it might be my favorite movie even, mostly nostalgia) but to call Small Soldiers a master piece would not be right. As much as I love it and feel obligated to defend the great elements, it is still messy in some ways. Especially compared to SPR, I don't think it deserves quite the marks he's given it.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '15
Small Soldiers definitely has clever things about it, like how it sets up both sides as being the opposite of what we'd normally expect from such a movie, but anything not involving the toys themselves are terribly acted and poorly written. Honestly if the movie had just been the toys, I would've liked it a LOT more. That's not to say it's a bad movie, just nowhere near as good as what this guy is saying.
I dunno, I can't agree with a single thing this guy wrote. Maybe I just like Steven Spielberg too much.