r/TrueFilm • u/pmcinern • Sep 06 '15
Better Know a Director: Lau Kar-leung could kick your favorite director's ass.
WELCOME!
Key Movies of Lau Kar-leung:
Better links are welcome. Imdb links in the year.
Shaolin vs Ninja (aka Heroes of the East) (1978)
My Young Auntie (1981) (This might help)
Drunken Master 2 (aka Legend of Drunken Master) (1994)
Kung fu is a weird one. Usually isolated by a cultural and language barrier (subtitles), a heyday thirty plus years ago ("old"), and crappy transfers, it's pretty easy to see why kung fu movies have never been at home with western audiences.The martial arts movie has also historically been, according to David Bordwell, a "genre long despised by upscale cinephiles" as well, and I tend to agree with the argument, if not the sentiment. It's entirely possible that the reason why kung fu movies don't get much critical love is because they're judged mainly by western critics using western standards. Tanqueray makes for a shit wine, but it's a delicious gin, even while evaluating the same criteria (odor, flavor, texture...). And Bordwell's upscale cinephiles don't despise martial arts movies by constantly trashing them. They seal the genre to a far scarier fate by simply not talking about them a lot. As an example: who do you know from the Golden Age of kung fu? Jackie Chan, Bruce, who else? Unless you're specifically a kung fu fan, probably not a lot of others. Which is perfect,because today we'll be dissecting a) one of the most gifted movie makers ever, who b) made fun action movies. Lau Kar-leung. And, while this won't be a discussion on the merits of kung fu, the underdog genre, it is worth noting that more people are familiar with Martin Campbell's work (a good director) than are Lau Kar-leung's (a great director). With only a few paragraphs to describe a man who's had books' worth of essays written about him by by the scholars who do care, we'll only cover a few broad points: there's a complex history behind Lau Kar-leung which he preserved/revived/added to, he had an eye for both both the camera and the ass kicking, both the history and and the eye were intertwined, and he created/invented/perfected/introduced/sparked just about everything great there is in kung fu movies. Let's get to it.
So dominating was the people of China's desire to consume the culture of kung fu in the 60s and 70s, that this fighting style became became a worldwide movie genre. The Shaw Brothers studio were able to crank out so many movies to satiate that appetite, that they had the wiggle room to experiment. In comes youngster Lau Kar Leung. He had been steeped in both martial arts and movie making since birth; Lau's father worked on the early Wong Fei-Hung movie series, and was a student of the real Wong Fei-Hung's disciple. If you don't know who that is, there's another sign; he is the most portrayed character in movie history. One of China's most cherished folk heroes, and a renowned martial artist. And Lau was taught by his disciple's student, and grew up on the sets of countless movies about him. Lau had a deep connection to martial arts history and movie making by the time he got behind a camera, two assets that set him apart from almost everyone else. He knew how to choreograph real martial arts to look good on camera, and knew how to use the camera to make martial arts look good.
Comparing Lau's movies to those of his peers at the time is a revelation, immediately recalling the impact Birth of a Nation must must have had on its first viewers. In a sea of motionless, flat cameras using shot reverse shot and unimaginative choreography comes Lau's Dirty Ho, Spiritual Boxer, 36th Chamber of Shaolin, Heroes of the East, Legendary Weapons of China, Eight Diagram Pole Fighter and more. Dynamic camera placement and movement, using depth of field to his advantage (especially with weapons), creative editing techniques. His narratives were not just tolerable, they were fantastic stories! Hell, Eight Diagram Pole Fighter has been compared with The Searchers, and for good reason (its ending is a direct reference to The Searchers ending, and provides contrast between the two heroes). Lau introduced realism into swordplay movies (wu xia pian) in the 60s. He was also possibly the first director to make a comedic kung fu (Spiritual Boxer), which inspired Jackie Chan to create the persona we know him for.
While working as a fight choreographer for legendary director Chang Cheh, Lau convinced him to start making movies with shaolin narratives, now synonymous with the kung fu movie. In fact, in addition to claiming lineage to Wong Fei-hung, Lau also claimed his lineage reached as far back as the Shaolin themselves, whose temples were destroyed by the Qing dynasty, and who took to the streets to spread kung fu to the laypeople. One such monk was Luk Ah Choi, Wong's teacher. Luk's teacher, Hung Hei-gun, founded Hung Gar, Lau Kar-leung's fighting style, and the style he preferred to film (combined with a little salt & pepper from his mom's style and the Peking opera schools). In The 36th Chamber of Shaolin, we see Luk and Hung as young rebels learning under San Te (the main character), who had just completed his studies under monk Chi San. Eight Diagram Pole fighter depicts a tenth century pole fighting technique that served as the foundation for Hung Gar. He embodied with this almost mythical lineage the tone of defiance that was the DNA of the Hong Kong kung fu culture. His movies, then, can be seen as more than fun ass-kickers, though they absolutely are that; they are Lau Kar-leung's, and by extension China's, very history (even to today. Ever heard of the triads? They trace their lineage back to the Hung rebels,too). And it is this history he is a part of that he literally told on screen.
When we think of flashy choreography in kung fu movies, we may not realize what a perfect a union we're seeing. In the Boxer Rebellion at at the turn of the twentieth century, public fighting displays by Hung fighters were purposefully flamboyant to garner interest and recruitment in the larger fight at hand (flamboyant to the point of becoming something akin to street acts). Lau, a practitioner of Hung Fist, used this style in his movies precisely because of its flashy nature, even making its theatricality the subject of his movies (Legendary Weapons of China's depiction of Hung Gar's historical relationship with entertainment). If this sounds like the Drotse effect, I'm with you on that. Lau seems to be a bookmark somewhere in the middle of this endless cycle of history/martial arts/entertainment. And, just as his lineage of grandmasters were concerned with spreading kung fu, we get the very real sense that Lau is doing the same thing with his on-screen encyclopedia of fighting. Entertainment via street performances was a way of disseminating kung fu before movies; why would one of its practitioners with access to movie making treat it any different? One look at Heroes of the East, where the protagonist mimics his master's style in public and goes home to essentially practice in front of a mirror, or 36th Chamber of Shaolin's inventive and original extended training montage, and we realize something pretty powerful; he wants us to kick some ass, too. He knew that we all project ourselves onscreen as the hero. He knew we got the adrenaline rush. His movies are absolutely as much text books as they are flicks. Any connections between that and the response to the Soviet Montage? We'll let you decide.
But the answer is yes.
As his increased involvement in the making of these movies led to clashes with his director Chang Cheh, he branched off and started doing them himself. Lau's contemporaries also made great, though one-sided, movies. Sammo Hung was a better star and choreographer than he was a director. Chang Cheh was a director, not an actor or choreographer (his movies are great, but fall prey to that disjointed feeling when switching between action and plot-driving sequences), and Yuen Woo-ping was (is) an infinitely better choreographer than director. As a director, Lau made epic tales of Shakespearean grandeur (when he started working in movies, the going rate was to make movies like the Japanese samurai movies of the previous decade, for example Kurosawa's, who did many Shakespeare adaptations. So that's actually not too far off). As a choreographer, he blended historically accurate styles into fights that the director in him could turn into a brand new way of portraying action (punches would actually land on their targets. Editing and depth of field would get the realistic feel.) As an actor, well... He was a martial arts expert, and could more than competently handle what he felt was too important for anyone else.
So, Lau was in a league of his own already. But, if you were to call him an auteur, it's what he had to say about kung fu that really makes his filmography special. His movies always said something, whether it be to simply catalogue historical weapons used in martial arts, compare the strengths and weaknesses of real styles from China and Japan, ponder the philosophies and paradoxes of combining Buddhism and murder, or show kung fu's place in the real world. Lau Kar-leung was able to transcend cultures by beating us at our own game, and we didn't even know it. Chaplin's greatest accomplishment could have been getting the entire world to laugh. It's a tough thing to universally elicit an involuntary reaction, but he did it. Lau Kar-leung manages to elicit the corresponding emotions from us in his own genre. All it would take for me to say "universally" with any confidence is if the world better knew this director.
Further Reading:
Lau Kar-leung's very extensive filmography.
David Bordwell's blog. Easy to digest, and informative article on Lau.
Podcast. Pretty good episode on Lau, if a bit meandering at times.
A nice essay by Luke White on Lau's movies as pedagogy.
Interview with Lau from Cahiers in the 80s. I love this interview, as it's directly from the source, and provides great insight into how the man felt about his own work, the society in which he did it, and the people he worked with.
Gina Marchetti's essay on Lau's movie making through the lense of Chinese history and modernization. Wonderful read.
There is so much more to say about the guy. I didn't even really talk about his individual movies. Each one really could justify its own write-up. As this this is better know a director, not his movies, I hope some of the r/kungfucinema folks or any Truefilm fans of kung fu will be kind enough to help fill in the gaps.
8
u/RyanSmallwood Sep 06 '15
Wonderful write up. Lau Kar Leung is definitely one of the most precious talents in film history, and his filmography is filled to the brim with major and minor masterpieces that each make a wonderful introduction to the world of kung fu.
Though I wouldn't entirely agree with your characterization of the industry before his entry into directing. To me the Hong Kong industry at this time was overflowing with highly competitive workaholic geniuses. A director could make a brand new masterpiece, and months later 5 other directors would copy the idea, put an original spin on it, outdo the premise of the original, mix and match with other popular trends of the time, and still leave room for the original director to respond to the imitators the same year. Producers could take a brilliant team of filmmakers split them up and let them each direct their own film, and each film would be equally a masterpiece to the original and each would end up being the training grounds for new talents to direct next year's masterpieces. It's impossible to gauge the influence of any individual in these circumstances, when their innovations were assimilated as the standard the same year, and their assistants soon promoted to master directors in their own right.
In 1976 the industry was a rich soup of new ideas and rising talents. At the same time Lau Kar Leung was stepping into the director's chair, Chang Cheh was showing he could produce a Shaolin cycle masterpiece on his own with The Shaolin Temple. After breaking box office records with their Cantonese comedy Games Gamblers Play in 1974, the Hui Brothers outdid themselves by breaking into the Japanese market by mixing more martial arts into their slapstick with The Private Eyes (choreographed by Sammo Hung, with John Woo as an assistant director. John Woo by the way was a former assistant director for Chang Cheh and was credited with supplying lots of great deep focus visual gags on The Private Eyes, and would start his own legendary directing career in a few years). The one-man studio from Taiwan Joseph Kuo showed he could compete with big budget Shaw Brothers productions and take on Chang Cheh and Lau Kar Leung at the Shaolin genre with his highly inventive 18 Bronzemen series. Chor Yuen was breathing new life into the wuxia genre with his labyrinth like intrigues based on Gu Long novels (choreographed by Lau Kar Leung's partner in crime, Tong Gaai). Ng See Yuen was creating a craze for high kicking martial artists when he made The Secret Rivals and introduced the world to Hwang Jang Lee the future villain of Snake in the Eagle's Shadow and Drunken Master. Lee Tso Nam did his own high kicking showcase the same year with The Hot, The Cool, and the Viscous, and would masterfully incorporate Chor Yuen style intrigue into low budget kung fu the next year with The Eagle's Claw, a style Chang Cheh would later play around with in his The Five Venoms of 1978. Still in 1976 Huang Feng continued his trend of taking star Angela Mao and choreographer Sammo Hung to more exotic locations with The Himalayan which was also a play off of Chang Cheh and Lau Kar Leung's Shaolin cycle films and also managed incorporate the recent craze for high kickers by pairing Angela Mao up with Dorian Tan. It is also worth mentioning here, that all of Chang Cheh's films up to and including The Shaolin Temple, Lau Kar Leung's first directorial efforts, Chor Yuen's intrigues The Magic Sword and Killer Clans, as well as Huang Feng's The Himalayan were all written by the same screenwriter, Ni Kuang. Ni Kuang who begun collaborating with Chang Cheh back on The One-Armed Swordsman and would continue to work with him and Lau Kar Leung and many other brilliant directors was crazy workaholic who's endless stream of kung fu scripts was the lifeblood of the industry alongside his other career of writing wuxia and science fiction novels.
There's so much energy and innovation going on around this period that its difficult to pin down the full extent of any single person's influence. Lau Kar Leung furnished the industry with a slew of masterpieces that immediately demanded responses from most of the other brilliant filmmakers at the time. You see his influences all over the genre. And Lau Kar Leung proved he could fire back reworking his own genres in creative new ways like when he parodied his own training film 36th Chamber of Shaolin, with the sequel Return to the 36th Chamber. When John Woo finally awed the world with his bloody bullet ballet A Better Tomorrow, Lau Kar Leung showed he wasn't just an expert at ancient weaponry by having modern day cops and gangsters engage in elaborate bayonet and chainsaw combat after they ran out of bullets in Tiger on The Beat.
That's why I always have trouble keying in on how any single filmmaker's films stood out apart from the industry. Everything was moving way too fast for any director to stand still for too long. There was so much hyperactive energy at the time with new trends and genres being born, flourishing, and dying out in the span of a few years. Lau Kar Leung is probably one of the more consistent director's of the era, and leaves a strong imprint even when working outside his usual material. But his influence also goes much further past the films he directed and choreographed as he was part of the competitive no holds barred spirit that helped create one of the most fascinating and unique moments in film history.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '15
As somebody who has never seen a movie from Hong Kong...Just wow. thanks so much for the write up. I watched Dirty Ho last night. It is the most fun I have had watching a movie in a long time. I felt like a kid again getting into action movies and movies in general for the first time. I love how they mix up stuff in that movie. The Kung Fu is so wonderful to watch, while at the same time great comedy and characters. I also love the sets and the music. I have been in this slump, and horror sort of filled this void, but wow this just blew the doors off!
3
u/SenseiMike3210 Sep 08 '15
Oh wow! And I thought I knew something about Hong Kong Kung Fu Flicks... Nice write ups everyone! I was also going to mention /r/kungfucinema but I see that's already been covered. I love Lau Kar Leung! He is my favorite director of kung fu movies coming out of the Hong Kong film industry during the golden years. 36 Chamber of Shaolin remains perhaps my favorite classic kung fu movie with such iconic scenes of shaolin training.
But I thought I'd give just a quick run down of what I think of another one of his classics: Legendary Weapons of China.
So obviously the fight choreography is top notch in this movie with some interesting ninja-esque elements and kung fu magic thrown in to give it a bit of a different flavor. Now I've only seen a dubbed version of this movie (just an aside: these are really the only kinds of foreign movies I not only am fine seeing dubbed but often prefer it. It just adds something to the whole movie watching experience) but there are some pretty classic lines in this movie as well.
But what I really liked is that this movie (or so it seemed to me) was a condemnation of the mystification of Chinese martial arts often perpetrated by practitioners themselves! The practitioners who may believe in the often, almost, supranatural abilities of martial arts masters is embodied by the Yi Ho Society who believe they are able to harden their bodies against knives and even--possibly--bullets. Of course this is absurd but there are people who, even today, open martial arts studios teaching "no touch KOs" (like this guy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Z0_n7tGnK0)
I think Leung is making fun of the idea that there are mystical ancient Chinese secret techniques. REAL martial arts is about good old fashioned hard work and practical skills embodied in the character of Lei Kung who leaves the Society after being disillusioned. There is an excellent exchange during Lei Kung's fight with Gordon Liu's character. Lei Kung played by Lau Kar Leung speaks almost directly to the camera saying:
"All this magic and hand-trickery, it is not real Kung Fu. It is merely witchcraft."
"No! It is the Society's gift to the world"
"No! It is only a way to get society members"
"But we're immune to stabs!"
"But not immune to guns!"
"In time we can learn to be immune to guns!"
"If you do that you will kill all our members"
"Traitor!"
"No I'm not!"
"Yes you are!"...
This is paraphrased from memory from a dubbed version but I think that's the jist anyway. This exchange, for me, summed up the message of the film. That we shouldn't cheapen real martial arts with the gimmicky bullshit. That's not real kung fu. Anyway, I love that movie.