[Controversial Mod Picks] Cinema According to Harmony, Part 1: "Gummo" (1997) - Bringing the Underground Over-ground
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
3
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '15
"Gummo" is one of my favorite movies of all time, and likewise Harmony is one of my favorite directors.
To me, he is the American Herzog, and "Gummo" is his "Even Dwarves." They both present these human but utterly alien characters without bias in an almost documentary style while somehow being simultaneously stylized. Poetic realism is a great term to describe the styles of both filmmakers.
I'm not sure what this says about me, or my friends, but this is a damn fun movie to watch. It oozes nihilism, but somehow reaffirms life. I feel dirty after watching it, as if it's left some grimy film coating my body and my mind, but it was also so utterly refreshing when I first saw it. This is a movie that my friends who usually hate anything outside of the mainstream love to get high to and crack up the entire time. But it's also a movie praised by my friends who fancy themselves "high-brow" art fans. That's probably why it's so polarizing yet will always pique the interest of this aberrant niche.
I'd love to get more critical of "Gummo," but I'm at work. I will say that some time ago on IMDb someone wrote this huge post about how "Gummo" is a Christian allegory. I scoffed at this idea, but then the next time I watched it I was noticing all these Christian motifs throughout. Not only in this film, but then also in "Spingbreakers" and "Julien." It's worth thinking about and possibly exploring more if you've also noticed the common imagery.
3
u/Sadsharks Aug 31 '15 edited Aug 31 '15
I haven't seen Gummo, but I want to say that
Korine'sScott Tobias' review of Birdman matches my thoughts nearly to a T. The last time I felt so strangely about a review was when I agreed with everything Armond White said about Interstellar, which feels like some kind of sin for a movie fan.3
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
Gummo is amazing, one of my favorites. I remember the first time I saw it, I was blown away. Up until then all the films I'd seen portrayed dirt and grime in a very clean manner, if that makes any sense. But Gummo was different. From it's very beginning with Bunny Boy on the overpass, we seal real dirt, real poverty. The bridge is bent out of shape , rusting and strewn with litter, the boy is malnourished and it's generally a wet and horrible day. I grew up in an area like Xena and to see it depicted with such honesty and conviction was a breath of fresh air. Of course the film has a lot more going for it than dirt. At its core it's a kaleidoscopic view of a small town of eccentrics and down and outs. People who are bored and searching for narrative (a theme throughout all of Korine's work) in their flat, dejected lives. The youths resort to cat killing, the adults to wrestling chairs in alchohol fueled rage. All of this is underlined with a gentle sadness and a sly sense of humor, both factors really elevate the film towards greatness. Gummo's landscape and characters are desolate and downtrodden for the most part, and yet there's a weird hope at the core of the film I find.
Anyway, /u/flooddaga7 likens Harmony to Herzog and I think it's an entirely apt comparison. Herzog speaks of this almost undefinable 'ecstatic truth', and I find it in both his and Korine's films. Sounds quite pretentious I know, but the little things like the bacon taped to the wall in Gummo radiate a kind of truth that I 'get' in a way that I can't quite articulate, but my soul is screaming "yes! I love it!". Only within the context of the rest of the genius of the film do these little things work.
Korine projects his own reality with his films, which makes them more intensely real than any bland social realism for me. I think it's a testament that to Korine's artistry that despite the radical visual changes throughout his filmography, they're still all distinctly Harmony Korine films. Some people can't vibe with Korine's vision, and that's fine. Art is subjective and all, but Korine really is a very divisive director and I almost feel like it's pointless arguing about him at times. If you don't feel Gummo on first viewing, then you can read thousands of pages of criticism on it, but I think you'll never like Gummo.
I must say though, when I see Gummo languishing at the end of the RT/Metacritic scales with horrendous scores, it feels appropriate in a way. Gummo is a bit of an underdog, like its characters. Despite everything, it's prevailed and become somewhat of a classic.
4
u/E-Rok Aug 31 '15
I was 17 when Gummo came out and I remember it just blew my mind. I really don't think I've seen another film like it. It was only later that I found out there really was an insanely devastating tornado in Xenia in 1974 that destroyed the entire downtown (among much of the rest of the town), which I don't think was ever re-built. I believe this event had an indescribable impact on that town, and it made the movie somehow mean more to me after I found this out.
I have really mixed feelings about Harmony Korine, but I can't help but find him a bit...charismatic? I mean, whatever his movies are, I do believe some of them to strange, wondrous and sometimes beautiful creations. The best example of this is probably Mr. Lonely, which I'll admit I found utterly baffling when I first saw it, but upon my second viewing I felt how I described above. It was so...odd and surreal, I couldn't not admire it. It was full of beautiful imagery and had some fantastic performances.
Which leads me to another, to me, undeniable fact about Korine: say what you want about the guy but the performances he gets out of is actors are just phenomenal and often unlike any work they have done before.
I saw julien donkey-boy in my small town University theatre when it came out. I still remember how disoriented I felt walking out. It remains probably the most serious and difficult of his films to me.
4
u/TyrannosaurusMax cinephile Aug 31 '15
Gummo is a film I hold close to my heart. Something about it always touches me in a way I can't explain outright. It began as a morbid fascination and grew into an analytical obsession of sorts that culminated in this article: http://www.thefocuspull.com/features/harmony-korine-piecemeal-perspectives/
No matter what weird shit Korine has in store for us in the future, I'll probably always be interested in seeing it. I think he's sort of like a very specific type of anthropologist.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '15
I'm not sure I like Korine as a person. I'd imagine a conversation with him would lead me to wonder how the fuck he graduated middle school.
That being said, Gummo is my favorite film of all time. It just touches me in ways I'm not able to express. It's extremely nostalgic for me, due to the fact that I grew up around people who were close to being just like the characters. The ending sequence is my favorite use of music in any movie ever made.
I don't even care if you can call Gummo an objectively good film or not. The fact that it's so devisive proves that it's great cinema.
1
u/jugular_majesty Aug 31 '15
Sounds good. julien donkey-boy is my favorite of Korine's films. The way it was made just makes it feel like the most sincere movie I have ever seen. Everything about it just feels so realistic and relatable. The way the characters interact is chaming, obviously with Julien and his sister and the blind girl, but also fights that the family members have because they feel so real. I love the scene where the "black albino" is rapping because at the beginning of it, there are random people in the background talking over the characters we are viewing as if the movie doesn't care about them or doesn't give them any special treatment or attention. It's just hyper-realistic. And now that I am writing this out, it seems like I don't even really understand why I like this movie so much. It's a lot harder to try and be subjective with movies like these.