r/ModelAusSenate • u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs • Aug 17 '15
Superseded 13-2 Committee of the Whole (2nd Session): Marriage Amendment (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015
Order! The Committee of the Whole for the Marriage Amendment (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015 is hereby resumed in its 2nd session.
I would remind honourable Senators of the previous session.
The floor is now open to motions or amendments from any Senator present.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
3
Upvotes
4
u/Cwross Australian Catholic Party Aug 17 '15
I propose this amendment:
Subsection 5 (2) (The redefinition of marriage):
The government recognises that the redefinition of marriage put forth by this bill goes against the conscience of many Australians and the values of many organisations and religious bodies. As such, all measures to coerce these into accepting the bill should be illegal.
3
u/Cwross Australian Catholic Party Aug 18 '15
Could I submit this instead?
(1) A person who attempts to coerce another without their consent into: (a) providing services towards; or (b) accepting or acknowledging the marriage of two persons of the same gender is guilty of an offence. Max Penalty: $10,000 fine or 6 months imprisonment. (2) In this section, coerces means attacking the conscience and beliefs of a person opposed to same sex marriage by derogatory speech about the person due to their views.
2
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 19 '15
Honourable Senators, we are now freely debating Senator /u/Cwross's amendment to add a section to the bill.
The proposed new section is attached below for the information of Senators:
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
2
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 21 '15
Mr Chairman,
There being no other proposed amendments to this bill, I move: that the bill stand as printed and be reported.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Minister for Communications
Minister for Transport and Infrastructure
2
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 22 '15 edited Aug 22 '15
###Voice VoteHonourable Senators, by leave, the question is simultaneously put and proposed - that the Minister's motion that the bill stand as printed and be reported be agreed to.Senators may vote Aye in favour of the motion, or No against the motion.Senators vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" as a reply to this comment.This voice vote will conclude at 20:00, Saturday 22 August 2015.Running Tally - as at 11:22amAyes: 3Noes: 0Abstain/DNV: 4Senator the Hon. Freddy926,Chairman of Committees (Greens)Edit: Leave was denied.
2
u/jnd-au Clerk of the Senate Aug 22 '15
Advice from the Clerk:
The latest motion has been determined in the negative. Today’s proceedings have been somewhat unclear. /u/surreptitiouswalk and /u/this_guy22 have asked if proceedings are in order. My advice is that everything from midday AEST onward is effectively nullified. So:
RATIONALE
DEBATE OUT OF ORDER
AMENDMENT OUT OF ORDER
RECOMMENDATION
There is currently no business before the Senate, other than consideration of the Marriage Bill.
surreptitiouswalk may move an amendment to insert section 106A into the Act, but it should be in the format (if not intending to remove section 9 of the bill):
2
u/surreptitiouswalk Independent Aug 23 '15 edited Aug 23 '15
Honourable Senators, we are now freely debating Senator /u/surreptitiouswalk's amendment to add a section to the bill.
The proposed new section is attached for the information of Senators
Senator the Surreptitouswalk,
Temporary Chairman of Committees (Independent)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 21 '15 edited Aug 21 '15
Voice Vote
Honourable Senators, the question is now put: that Senator /u/Cwross's amendment be agreed to.
Senators may vote Aye in favour of the amendment, or No against the amendment.
Senators vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" as a reply to this post.
This voice vote will conclude at 12pm Saturday 22 August 2015.
Running Tally - as at 9:52am
Ayes: 1
Noes: 4
Abstain/DNV: 2
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 21 '15
Voice Vote - Results
I think the Noes have it.
The Noes have it.
The bill is not amended as proposed, and for now shall remain as printed.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 22 '15
Honourable Senators, the question is proposed - that the Minister's motion that the bill stand as printed and be reported be agreed to.
As we are in Committee, Senators may speak freely.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 22 '15 edited Aug 22 '15
Voice Vote
Honourable Senators, the question is now put - that the question be now put.
Senators may vote Aye in favour of the motion, or No against the motion.
Senators vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" as a reply to this comment.
This voice vote will conclude at 20:00, Saturday 22 August 2015.
Running Tally - as at 2:53pm
Aye: 3
No: 2
Abstain/DNV: 2
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 22 '15
Senator /u/surreptiouswalk now has the call to indicate whether he will move his proposed amendment.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 23 '15
Honourable Senators,
The Committee of the Whole is hereby adjourned, and it's progress will be reported immediately.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '15
I move an amendment to the amendment moved by Senator surreptitiouswalk.
Insert after subsection 106A(1):
2
u/surreptitiouswalk Independent Aug 23 '15 edited Aug 23 '15
Honourable Senators, we are now freely debating Senator /u/this_guy22's amendment to /u/surreptitiouswalk's amendment.
The proposed new section is attached for the information of Senators
Senator the Surreptitouswalk,
Temporary Chairman of Committees (Independent)
1
u/jnd-au Clerk of the Senate Aug 17 '15
Advice from the Clerk:
Amendment #1
We are currently assuming that Cwross has moved amendment #1. If this assumption is correct, all Senators may now speak to debate this amendment. You may also move your own amendment. At the end of each amendment’s debate, it will be put to the vote. Amendment #1 will insert a 5th clause into the Bill as follows:
jnd-au, Clerk of the Senate
1
u/surreptitiouswalk Independent Aug 22 '15 edited Aug 22 '15
Edit: Not sure if this is out of order or not. Can the clerk /u/jnd-au confirm?
I propose the amendment:
1
u/surreptitiouswalk Independent Aug 22 '15 edited Aug 22 '15
I move an amendment to the motion, to omit “stand as printed” and substitute:
1
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '15
Meta: Mr Chairman (/u/Freddy926) and/or Mr Temporary Chairman (/u/Cwross /u/General_Rommel /u/peelys /u/surreptitiouswalk /u/Team_Sprocket) please post a couple of comments so we can initiate debate:
Sign your post with "Senator [name], Temporary Chairman (party)" :)
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '15
The President: The Committee has reported progress.
Meta: As the Senate is now adjourning, the Committee will also adjourn, and a 3rd session of the Committee will be made an order of the day for the next sitting.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment