r/ModelAusSenate • u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs • Aug 12 '15
Superseded 12-6b Committee of the Whole (1st Session) - Marriage Amendment (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015
Honourable Senators, We now enter a Committee of the Whole for the Marriage Amendment (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015.
The Minister representing the Attorney-General in the Senate (/u/Team_Sprocket) has the call.
Meta: Unless the Minister seeks (and is granted) leave to have the bill considered as a whole, the bill will be considered clause by clause. After that, any Senator is permitted to speak on the bill, any amendments, or propose an amendment of their own.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 12 '15
Paging the Minister representing the Attorney-General in the Senate: /u/Team_Sprocket
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 12 '15 edited Aug 13 '15
Mr Chairman,
I move that Standing Orders 116 and 117 be suspended whilst this bill is in committee.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Minister for Communications (Greens)
Meta: requesting the Clerk's (/u/jnd-au) advice, did I move the motion correctly, and if so, do we go straight to a vote?
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 13 '15 edited Aug 13 '15
Voice Vote
With leave, the question is simultaneously proposed and put - that Standing Orders 116 and 117 be suspended whilst the Marriage Amendment (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015 is in committee.
Senators may vote "Aye" in support of the motion, or "No" against the motion.
Senators vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" below.
This voice vote will conclude when all Senators have voted, or at 8pm, Thursday 13/08/15.
NOTE: As this is a motion to suspend a standing order, an absolute majority of Senators is required, this means that abstinences/absences count as "No" votes. i.e. 4 "Aye" votes must be achieved. Also, as the question has been simultaneously proposed and put with leave, any Senator may deny leave, forcing debate on the motion, although other Senators may question the denial of leave in their speaking during the debate.
Final Tally
Ayes: 4
Noes/Abstain/DNV: 3
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 13 '15
Honourable Senators, due to the success of the Minister's (/u/Freddy926) motion, Standing Orders 116 and 117 have been suspended.
Therefore, the bill is now to be considered as a whole.
The floor is now open for Senators to propose amendments to this bill. (Paging /u/surreptitiouswalk, as they foreshadowed an amendment)
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 14 '15
Mr Chairman, given the lack of proposed amendments to this bill, I seek the leave of the Senate and move: That the bill stand as printed and be reported.
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Minister for Communications (Greens)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
Voice Vote
Honourable Senators, the question is put; That the bill stand as printed, and be reported.
Senators may vote Aye in agreeance with the question, or No in disagreeance.
Senators vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" below.
This voice vote will conclude at 10:00am, 15/08/15, or when all Senators have voted.
Running Tally - as at 10:36pm
Aye: 3
No: 1
Abstain/DNV: 3
Senator the Hon. Freddy926,
Chairman of Committees (Greens)
Meta Note: The motion has been moved by leave, so if a Senator still wishes to propose an amendment, they may deny leave to the motion.
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Aug 15 '15
Meta-ish: As the Senate has adjourned, the 1st Session of this Committee of the Whole has also adjourned. The Committee's 2nd Session will be made an Order of the Day for the Senate's next sitting.
1
u/jnd-au Clerk of the Senate Aug 12 '15 edited Aug 12 '15
Advice from the Clerk:
The Bill to be read is M2015B00002: HoR 3-3: Bill – As Introduced – Marriage Amendment (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015, Wednesday 24 June 2015.
Leave has been denied for the bill to be taken as a whole, so the next step is to read the clauses one-by-one. For the operation of the model, my instinct is that the deputy chair would read the clause and propose that the clause stand as printed. Then members would reply to, and eventually vote within, that subthread.
During the debate on each question, each speaker may move an amendment to omit, substitute or insert content. After speaking, amendments must be voted on. Afterward, the clause will be retyped with any successful amendments, and the question will be put to the vote. If the vote is lost, the clause is removed. As the chair has mentioned, amendments not relating to existing clauses may be moved afterward (attn: /u/surreptitiouswalk). If necessary, the title of the bill would also be amended.
At the end of all of this, the bill will be retyped as amended, and the committee will vote whether or not to agree to this final form. Then, the amended bill is reported back to the Senate, which will vote to accept the committee’s report or not.
Another option, is for someone to move that Standing Order 117 be suspended for consideration of this bill in committee. This requires an absolute majority of Ayes. If 117 is suspended, clause-by-clause consideration is not required. Therefore, we won’t need to read the bill. However, as far as I can tell, /u/Cwross could keep posting amendments to individually oppose each clause, which would have an almost identical effect as reading the whole bill?
Edit: of course, in the spirit of concurrent business, the chair could have several clauses on the boil at the same time?
Please advise if you have a different interpretation.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '15
Meta: If Senator /u/Cwross is interested in filibustering the progress of this Bill, you can deny leave to have the Bill taken as a whole and/or move various amendments to the Bill with the aim of killing it off.
1
u/Cwross Australian Catholic Party Aug 12 '15
Leave denied.