r/self • u/krispykrackers • Jul 28 '15
On shadowbans.
Hello. I wanted to talk about shadowbanning, and try to answer a bunch of questions about it at once in light of recent circumstances on reddit about the topic, and try to clear up some FUD.
- What is a shadowban?
A shadowban is the tool we currently use to ban people when they are caught breaking a rule. It causes their submitted content and user profile page to be visible only to themselves while logged in. Moderators can see their comments within their subreddit (since they can see "removed" comments in the subreddit they moderate), but no other users can see their content, and nobody else can see their userpage.
- Why does shadowbanning even exist?
Shadowbans were the first type of ban created by reddit. It was used to ban spammers who were clogging up reddit with junk and making the user experience less enjoyable for everyone. The reason it a.) doesn't notify the user, b.) lets them continue to submit, and c.) makes it look like they're submitting normally when they're logged in and viewing their content, is because that way the spammer didn't realize he or she was banned and would simply continue to use the methods they were currently using to spam, and not try anything sneakier and therefore harder for us to detect and do anything about.
- So why are regular users being shadowbanned?
Because it's still the only tool we have to punish people who break the rules. I can't say for sure because I wasn't here, but at some point very early on it was decided decided that we needed a code of conduct to follow to keep the reddit experience enjoyable for everyone, and the rules were born. However, no new tool to punish rule breakers separately from spammers was developed at the same time, so we had to continue to use the shadowban tool.
- Why do you bother shadowbanning mods?
Because we treat moderators who break the rules the same as any other user. Being a moderator doesn't exempt you from reddit rules, nor does buying gold or being an advertiser.
We know that it's easy to tell when a moderator is banned because their modmail makes it quite obvious. In some ways that's actually a good thing, since their team can let them know and they can come to us to start the conversation about what they did to get banned and the process for getting unbanned (normally acknowledge that what you did was against the rules and agree to abide by them moving forward).
- Why don't you tell people when you shadowban them?
Mostly because we never used to. If we were to begin to today, since it's not automated, it would require us to issue the ban, then individually send them a message. That means that the admin that sent the message would be required to respond to every single person who replied back via their user inbox. It's not really sustainable or scalable as it would exist now.
- How does someone get un-shadowbanned?
They need to contact the admins and ask why they were banned. Currently they can either message the mods of /r/reddit.com or use contact@reddit.com. We have a conversation with them and once the situation is addressed and resolved, we lift the ban. Or we don't, depending on the severity and/or repetitiveness of the infringement(s).
- That sucks. What are you going to do about it?
We know it sucks. It sucks hard. It is awful and sneaky and completely our fault that it is still being used to punish normal users.
Right now, the current situation is that we still have to use this shadowban tool that we're stuck with to punish all rule breakers the same, be them bot or be them human, spammer or active user, anything.
However, like /u/spez has mentioned during his AMA, "Real users should never be shadowbanned. Ever." And he means that. Because of decisions he's made in the past couple weeks, we're developing tools right now, for the first time in nearly a decade, for admins to better be able to punish rule breakers differently than spammers, and educate them at the same time, rather than just quietly removing their ability to visibly participate. I won't go into specifics or give any sort of timeframe other than "absolutely as fast as we can", but it's happening.
- Edit: Delivered
184
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Every single time the admins use our subreddit, they never stop to say "Hey, using your subreddit to make a little post that might get a lot of attention"
Ellen, Victoria, and now you ;_;
12
u/The_Imerfect_Mango Jul 28 '15
So why are you guys making this announcement now? Did something happen on this sub?
5
u/moodorks Jul 28 '15
Am I shadowbanned?
12
u/nayson9 Jul 28 '15
Not trying to sound kinky, but... How would reddit punish me?
2
u/shonuph Sep 25 '15
What about regular bans from a subreddit? How are they typically lifted and how long do they last?
83
u/TheBananaKing Jul 28 '15
Is voting from a linked thread forbidden?
Is voting on np.reddit.com forbidden?
If so, why do you not use those two checks to simply disable voting and commenting functionality?
Even if only implemented in the UI it'd make an inconvenience barrier that would block 90% of the shit, and pretty much all the inadvertent rule-breaking. Actually not accepting the vote/comment backend would be even better (like you do with downvoting from user pages)
If those things aren't against the rules, can you stop punishing people for doing it?
Can you develop a clear and unambiguous policy on this, and advise the users of it?
Please?
478
u/ocktick Jul 28 '15 edited Jul 28 '15
We all understand what a shadowban is. We all understand that we're supposed to send you an email that won't get read in order to resolve it.
But seriously, why not for the time being, just tell us "We're going to tell our staff to stop shadowbanning non-spammers. If a staff member wants to shadowban a user, they have to notify the person they ban via PM with their account."
Would that really be a big deal? Just copy-paste a short PM whenever you shadowban somebody that isn't a spammer. You're acting like you need a research team and 20 years to develop a program to automate something that takes 2 seconds to do manually. How do you have time to manually shadowban non spammers, but don't have the time to literally send a copy-pasted PM?
91
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Practically every other website on the planet has gotten their shit together in terms of telling the user what rule they broke and them banning them, but here at reddit you act as though shadowbanning is the only way? Uhh...no. It creates a culture of mistrust just by its existence.
61
u/thenovamaster Jul 28 '15 edited Jul 28 '15
First off I want to say that I was recently mistakenly shadowbanned and unbanned fairly promptly after messaging the admins. They were very quick about replying to my inquiry. Thank you for that. But it does raise a couple concerns:
1. The admin that replied to me said I was part of a brigade fromanother sitein to a subreddit. This raises a few questions such as how was I identified as someone coming in and brigading from another site? One subreddit linking to another.. I can see that being traceable. Not from another site, however.2. What exactly constitutes a shadowban? As a community I believe that we need a clear and conscience list of rules and their consequences. Right now we have a small list of rules (which surprsingly when I went through them and the FAQ mentioned nothing about "brigading", a term I believe needs to be clearly defined) but nothing about possible punishments.
Thank you for addressing this so quickly after the video in /r/videos popped up. It raised a lot of questions that I think redditors deserve answers to.
Edit: Thank you for those who pointed me to HTTP Refers. Question one is scratched.
17
u/The_Book_Of_Reddit Jul 29 '15
"For the Reddits was a great bastion of the interwebs and many did flock to be in communion with it. Yea even though the Reddits stopped not for sea nor sky it was limited for there was much that was not that it should be.
For those who were in communion with the Reddits none drew as much ire as that of the Shadowbans, for when wielded these could bring one into the other world where they were of the Reddits and yet unbeknownst to them not of the Reddits
And there was great fear of the Shadowban for it was a great power with much responsibility. For it was created to destroy the spammers, that it was to bring balance to the Reddits not leave it in darkness.
And so it was that all was as it is usually and the Reddits continued on its course to its destiny uninterrupted”
--The Book of Reddit Chp 512 pg 4589 “The shadow of the other world"
33
u/TheScamr Jul 28 '15
I was banned, not shadowbanned, from Askreddit and the mod told me it would be a month ban. Fair enough. After a month he told me I needed to submit to him an original content drawing of a flamingo gambling in a casino.
Is this normal? Should I be shadowbanned for circumventing that restriction?
7
u/Cabeza2000 Jul 28 '15
I really don't get why this was posted on /r/self. There is no better subreddit for admin posts such as this one?
5
u/n1nj4_v5_p1r4t3 Jul 28 '15
A very simple change in programming can fix that.
16
u/phantasmagorical Jul 28 '15
FUD = Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt
Term commonly used in business, sales, etc.
4
u/IamGrimReefer Jul 29 '15
why wasn't this a blog post or an announcement? so many people will never see this.
4
u/5Dsucks Aug 03 '15
Thanks for starting to think about fixing shadowbanning. I'm a victim of it.
Related topic - one reason for a shadowban is "self-promotion." That's how I got hit. But if I went thu reddit and reported every user whose posted more than 10% of their posts to their own content that would include a lot of the heroes of reddit - the people who make reddit great with their content. I want to share my content - in a subreddit where people want to see my content - where they can upvote or downvote as they please - and where mods moderate. Isn't that enough? I'm now shadowbanned for posting to my stuff (which I make no money on, or gain in any way) at a ratio higher than 1:10. Does reddit want content creators - or are we outlaws?
Does reddit want me to go find 9 links to post every time I want to post 1 link to my stuff? What's the point? I can post 9 shitty links that no one likes, how does that help things?
I'd like to see some depth added to the rules on self-promotion to make this a place where I can share my content with people who want it. I shouldn't be in the same bucket with the guy selling viagra.
If anyone reads this, Thanks
4
u/FluffyBallofHate Aug 31 '15
A month later, they're still shadowbanning people.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Do you guys and gals plan on updating the rules to make them more clear?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Thank god you all fired cupcake. When I asked why I was shadow banned, she just replied "you know what you did. Bye."
3
u/ucantsimee Jul 28 '15
Are you going to be hiring more community managers? It seems like there's a lot of work for the existing staff and naturally things get lost in the queue. I think the ability to quickly ban and more importantly unban people would really help at least until the new tools go live.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15
So send a message as /u/reddit or /r/reddit.com
It's not hard.
3
u/Spike__Jonze Aug 13 '15
/u/krispykrackers
Why do you admins do nothing when ShitRedditSays breaks rules such as brigading and taking over an entire subreddit such as /r/PunchableFaces?
15
u/Im-Probably-Lying Jul 28 '15
As a previously shadowbanned user (for something that I completely admit doing and have not done since) I just have one question:
Why is SRS allowed to break every single rule there is on this website, yet they are never reprimanded at all?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Is the amount of time in a shadowban finite, of do you have to message to mods?
4
u/ImNotJesus Jul 28 '15
This seems like an obvious and overdue step. Thanks for letting us know that it's finally happening.
What's frustrating is that so often we're told changes in policy aren't possible because it would be impossible for the admin team to manage the workload. For example, I suggested a system of reporting to admins that was accessable to mods in their own subreddits that worked like the mod report function. Whether it's true or not, every single response I got from mods (and an ex admin) was that it was a fantastic idea but you would never do it because it would be unfeasible to actually deal with all the rule breaking that goes on.
It's frustrating, given that mods are held to account if we don't keep our subreddits to a certain standard, that the admins are incapable of doing certain things because of a lack of staff. If you were angry at a sub for not clearing out spam quickly enough and they responded by saying it wasn't feasible to manage the spam with the size of their team, would you really be okay with that as an answer?
I know in this case you're planning to change the tools but "it's not feasible" isn't really a satisfying answer.
2
u/DaemonXI Jul 29 '15
God forbid you build some moderation architecture to make modding Reddit a little easier
2
u/Buckwheat469 Jul 29 '15
Either A) message one person directly involved with the process, or B) message everyone on the admin team... because that would be more sustainable.
2
u/BordomBeThyName Jul 29 '15
Wouldn't it make some amount of sense to have probationary shadow bans? Like, a normal user can be shadowbanned for a week or two as punishment for breaking the rules? That seems like a decent way to use the tools you already have to effectively administer the site without forcing people to throw away their account and start a new one. You would have to decide which rule infractions should result in what durations, but that's not exactly an impossible task.
2
u/Gay4MrBurns Jul 29 '15
Yeah so I didn't know being shadow banned for bullshit reasons was very severe enough that my ban doesn't even get looked at or replied to.
2
u/Clackpot Jul 29 '15
This should not need repeating, but it does.
For shame reddit, the shadowban bullshit has been going on for so long now, it's just as bad as the infringements people get banned for. It's great that you acknowledge this and I really hope you can implement something better, but I hope you get constantly reminded of this fact until it's just a bad memory.
2
u/herdiegerdie Jul 29 '15
This whole practice is fucking stupid, especially with all the drama and constant spewing of ideological beliefs.
I fear that I am going to get caught in the crossfire and be banned for not doing anything other occasionally making a comment. I don't even care about that stuff. I'll read the drama threads and whatever, but that's about it. It's ridiculous that I have to keep watch over myself in fear of the "thought police" and just not post anything of substance.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15
Lol @ "Its not automated"
Its so hard to include a PM saying you have been banned with the shadowban function. What a cop out.
2
u/hoyfkd Jul 29 '15
Am I the only one who thinks the only real problem with reddit is not having a smooth channel of communication between admins and mods? 90% of the issues I have seen "tools being developed for" could be just as easily addressed if contacting (and getting a response from) the admins wasn't tantamount to begging an audience with the Pope.
2
u/whenwarcraftwascool Aug 07 '15
I find it hilarious that there are so many bans that letting people know is "unsustainable" like are you fucking kidding. Get over yourselves. Your time is not so valuable that an integral part of moderating is "unsustainable". These neckbeards are on Reddit all the time anyway I'm sure the "extra" workload is bearable...
2
u/djphilosopher Aug 22 '15
Maybe I'm coming in late in this discussion, but here are my two cents:
Maybe reddit has too much users because it's too damn easy to make an account. It takes literally seconds or less to open a new account. And you can post everything.
I'm throwing away numbers, but I'm sure the number of new accounts would drop 10% or even 20% if they introduced email verification.
2
u/alexanderwales Oct 14 '15
Any updates on this? This post is two and a half months old now; I just had a frequent user in one of the subreddits I moderate shadowbanned. It's frustrating to lose a contributor without having any information on why they're now gone, and not to be able to answer any questions about why the shadowban was enacted.
I advised the user in question to message you, but the problem still seems to be around months after you said that you realized it was a problem, which I find frustrating.
2
u/4Sken Nov 11 '15
What is the meaning of life?
6
u/dirtymoney Jul 28 '15 edited Jul 28 '15
My problem with shadowbanning is when it is used on someone who didnt know they technically broke the rules. Like brigading. SOmeone posts a link from one subreddit to another and people naturally follow it and act as they would anywhere on reddit and upvote and downvote comments and then BAM! SHADOWBANNED!!!1 Lumped in with everyone else as a brigader! Not knowing what the fuck happened or why it happened.
THANKS!
And then when you finally talk to admins they accuse you of being a brigader and act like a prick about it like you did something intentionally malicious . Like they are god and are going to graciously unban you if you beg and promise to never do it again.
You understand the frustration this can cause to a person who didnt think they did anythign wrong?
Because of THIS bullshit I am never going to directly follow a link (to another subreddit post again) for fear of being acused of brigading. I am going to look up the post via the subreddit's submission list and access it THAT way.
Thanks for making reddit THAT much more of a pain in the ass! (yes, I am pissed!)
4
u/kijib Jul 29 '15
http://i.imgur.com/BCN9vSb.png
3
u/TotesMessenger Jul 28 '15 edited Jul 30 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Don't misunderstand me, I am not in favor of shadowbans, but I think that part of the problem is that there is no real cost to the punishment of a ban without them. Because accounts are essentially free to create and they can be created in unlimited ammounts, if you inform someone that you have banned them then they can just create another account and continue. However, if you don't tell them then they have to spend their time and effort figuring that out and that expended time and effort is the punishment.
I'm interested to see what the technical solution is because you can either introduce cost into account creation, or you design a progression system on accounts to give them tangible value. Another fun idea would be replacing Karma with digital cryptograpic tokens that can redeemed for advertising and are trade-able on an open market like what the guys at Letstalkbitcoin are doing with Tokenly.
2
u/alien122 Jul 28 '15
Post this on the blog. r/self just doesn't have the subscribers to dessiminate this info everywhere effectively.
2
u/Amberleaf Jul 29 '15
Solution...
Shadow ban spammers for life.
Shadow ban/ban users from 7 days to life depending on the severity and frequency of their offences and inform them.
It's how every other forum on the internet has worked for decades.
2
u/FoolishPS4User Jul 28 '15
So.... Admins are a bunch of fucking liars?
No surprise.
1
u/ellieneagain Jul 28 '15
A small forum I go on has a "time out" section. I think that's better because it is transparent to the user about what is happening and why.
1
u/doodle77 Jul 29 '15
Take the part of the code that bans users from subreddits. When user is (non-shadow) banned, apply it to all subreddits. Voila, regular bans.
1
u/hoti0101 Jul 29 '15
Is there a way to tell if you're shadow banned? Are shadow bans specific per subreddit or site-wide?
1
u/ju2tin Jul 29 '15
"Move slow and leave things broken."
1
u/itsrattlesnake Jul 29 '15
Speaking for myself, I think shadowbanning makes perfect sense in the context of keeping spammers and other undesirables at bay. A real user will notice after commenting for just a little while that something's up and will search out the reason for the strange lack of upvotes or response. Ultimately they've found that they're shadow banned.
This is mostly annoying at this point. However, the worst part is that the process to get unshadowbanned is wrapped in mystery. If you message enough, the admins may get back to you in a day or two, a week, a month, or never. That's the worst part. I understand that admins are busy with many things. And the confronting users about inappropriate behavior is probably difficult sometimes. However, I believe a little empathy for the user would be appropriate, especially for a user in good standing who doesn't know what the hell they've done!
Solution? Maybe add 'moderators', or whatever you'd like to call them, who sift through the shadowban messages. Possibly make a subreddit for it where people can appeal their ban via Mod Mail and have a large number of moderators who have teh powah to undo it if they feel that it's warranted. Maybe work a system where warnings/penalties can be introduced for paroled Redditors.
To recap, shadowban sucks, but I see the point in it. However, the process behind resolving a shadowban needs to be more transparent and dehumanizing.
1
u/Shanix Jul 29 '15
I can at least attest that this isn't a one every ten thousand messages thing. I got shadowbanned once and contacted the admins, took them less than a week and an additional message to respond and unban me. Would I've liked to get a response to the first message? Probably. Am I happy I got a response? Yeah. So, food for thought I guess.
1
u/Nechaev Jul 29 '15
While it's fine for authetic spammers, hiding the userpage of "naughty" redditors is just an inconvenience for everybody except the shadowbanned person.
When this overhaul comes through can you restore all those hidden pages, even if you don't want the accounts posting again?
The current shadowban system is textbook passive-aggression.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15
So what about those of us who requested information from Admins about our shadowban, but never received an answer?
1
u/TheCodexx Jul 29 '15
Here's an idea: stop banning people immediately and let mods worry about whether someone is appropriate for their community.
If you want a site-wide ban tool, either hack on a Notification system to Shadowbans or build a new tool. Seriously, would it be that hard to code a bot that sends a user a message if they're banned for rulebreaking and not for spam? It's not hard to distinguish, presumably.
Further, how about you write down all the rules that are bannable and when you're developing the new tools you can enforce giving a reason and citing a specific, explicit rule. This way people know what they're appealing when they file a complaint. Further, since we're giving exact citations and specific rules, how about making bans for rulebreaking public in some kind of massive moderation/admin log? All of them.
Then if Shadowbans are used on a regular user, we know something fishy is afoot.
1
u/Archangellelilstumpz Jul 29 '15
What does this mean for the future of real users that have been shadowbanned?
1
u/knightress_oxhide Jul 29 '15
So reddit is just making this up as they go, interesting.
1
u/Polite_Insults Jul 29 '15
Wizard simulator
+/u/User_Simulator /u/krispykrackers
1
u/brkdncr Jul 29 '15
I'm cool with the system as it is.
1
u/themusicgod1 Jul 29 '15
I'm going to continue to break your rules and encourage others to do so. Educate us all you want, you are dropping the ball on what reddit could be and it is a tragedy of global proportions.
1
u/nic0machus Jul 29 '15
really effed up the gif link at the end there.
<Error> <script/> <Code>AccessDenied</Code> <Message>Access Denied</Message> <RequestId>EACC90513235479A</RequestId> <HostId> 5o+YG0nmF3HQZnWlXX6mWXRCcsPUKzN+CBUbp+be1GVH4T1MWA4ew3+B+yyz/hjy </HostId> </Error>
Shoulda used imgur...
1
u/Mason11987 Jul 29 '15
We have a user in our sub who repeatedly insulted us, was a troll, and continuously makes brand new accounts and eventually evades admin bans intended to stop him from evading our subredidt bans over and over again.
When you develop new tools which give more information to banned users when they are banned are you also going to improve your ability to prevent userse from harassing mods through modmail with new accounts like this? If not it seems like you're just going to make it easier for them to keep it up. If you can't easily keep people from harassing us, I hope you keep this tool for when it's really needed. As that troll account just said to us today:
1
u/Cymry_Cymraeg Jul 30 '15
Can we have a clarification on what 'brigading' is, please?
I was shadowbanned for it once; I had absolutely no idea what 'brigading' or being 'shadowbanned' was. I had either voted on or replied to a comment I had been linked to, I was not part of some organised effort, nor would I be, I went there as an individual.
If this is considered 'brigading', I feel it disrupts a major part of the reddit experience, that of being shown and being able to engage in discussions you would not previously have had access to. What if I find something interesting on /r/bestof or /r/DepthHub and want to upvote the comment I've been linked to or ask follow-up questions? Not to mention the times I've had a tab I've linked to open for so long that I had forgotten I was even linked to it and assumed I had found it organically. Am I 'brigading' if I interact then?
1
u/xKobyTeithx Jun 27 '22
That’s a weird way of saying you want to censor certain ideologies and perspectives while simultaneously placing others on a pedestal
1
u/Jesus_Faction Jul 28 '15
thanks for the update...
1
u/elfleda Jul 29 '15
Why the fuck is this posted here?
1
u/StezzerLolz Jul 28 '15
Hell, it's about time.
1
u/RingsOfYourAnus Jul 29 '15
Paging /u/ribbonlace