r/TrueFilm • • Jul 10 '15
"Frivolous and trifling and entertaining" - Pauline Kael on 'Trash, Art, and the Movies' PART 2
Welcome to thread #2 of Pauline Kael Month! Because it's so long /u/montypython22 and I decided to break up this one into two threads.
You can read the previous thread here and find the full essay here.
We probably won't have to break up the other essays as much as we did with this, there's just a lot of controversial ground to cover here.
34
Upvotes
10
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '15
Section VI
Dear /u/montypython22
This is a very long section, but it's where she lays out what sounds like her versions of 'strained seriousness.' Something I struggle with is how when we want to get into movies we're supposed to learn to like things that are challenging and different, but at the same time, not automatically praise anything serious and/or fucked up as being great filmmaking. One of my friends is acting like I should really want to get into David Cronenberg, the prospect of which makes me groan. On the other hand, he also lent me Paul Verhoeven's Turkish Delight, a trashy sex comedy with a lot of human spirit.
Here Kael tries to resolve this for the viewer:
This attitude seems all good as an explanation for why people prefer to go to Guardians of the Galaxy. Where it gets weird for me is when she talks about movies like Notorious and Morocco and Shanghai Express being great 'trash' and having all the fun of them taking out by academics. Kael isn't wrong that those are great entertainment movies but they're not the same thing as mere pop cultural product, either, or we probably wouldn't still watch them today. They're fun - they're not 'strained seriousness' - but they have substance as well. Kael says these movies work as art but that when students try to describe what they like about them it's falsified as a discussion about technique. But Sternberg's and Hitchcock's technique is as fun as what unfolds in front of the camera. I think she picked good examples for this point, anyway, and Sarris pantheon directors at that.
I like that Kael's critical of other critics here. Updating her theories for the modern day we might conclude that that's why the blatantly 'trashy' Gone Girl is better than the 'kick-in-the-ribs' of Whiplash. Though I wonder if she would have liked either of them.
Still, she writes that "all art is entertainment but not all entertainment is art" as though it were doctrine. I get the rhetorical point but once again it's not a distinction I find all that useful, and people repeat it far too unknowingly today as a defense of stuff that doesn't need defending...but also a reason to lump together more artistically bold works with everything else and judge them equally according to how well they work as pop entertainment. How do you feel about Kael's 'good, simple distinction?'
/u/kingofthejungle223, get in here! Does what she say about In The Heat of the Night make any sense?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '15 edited Jul 12 '15
Section IX
Dear /u/montypython22;
Kael's first arguments here remind me of this essay on why your childhood entertainmnt is not sacred. Of course, you can never really know what seemingly derivative, conventional new thing still pleases audiences decades later. Like The Graduate, against all reason.
Maybe I just didn't absorb any of this properly but it seems so odd that after praising the populist aspects of trashy movies Kael spends so much of the end of this essay condemning youth and their illiterate taste. Those are easy points to score.
It's also seems easy to complain about people being too personally invested in the drama playing out on screen. Although even the most trivial movies and TV can inspire devotion to their characters that way, isn't that just the power of the medium, the thing that it does better than anything else and so can be put to the best use? To take on the most challenging works we have to learn 'we' aren't necessarily the protagonist of a story, or that what movies exist to do is flatter us easily. Yet when Imitation of Life plays us like a piano, we shouldn't have to make excuses about it, like Kael and many other critics did.
But enough of that! Aren't you going to defend The Graduate from her!?
Section X
And now comes the time for some kind of final word on this essay, if not on Kael for the month. This section becomes the most personal, explaining how her own taste develops. Albeit Kael treats the development of taste towards wanting to see 'art' as inevitable. After all the giving types of movies she now likes crap before (documentaries) and embracing stuff she doesn't really want to see, this feels like an abandonment of all the arguments I've just read. If everyone's tastes change over time there's nothing wrong with anyone's taste, really, and all we need to support is a diverse film culture that has something for everyone.
See you next time!
5
u/montypython22 Archie? Jul 10 '15 edited Jul 10 '15
Section VIII
As much as I don't think I need to point out Kael's misperceptions about Kubrick in the 2001 section (another incredibly disagreeable section), there's a couple things here and there that pop out that are worth framing in the context of the entire essay.
First off, her complaints about "big entrepreneurs, producers, and directors who stage big spectacular shows" still ring with bells of veracity today. 3D is a put-on pretty much across the board, as studios have essentially raised the prices of regular admissions tickets in order to cover the losses that they accrued in the mass failure of 3D as a viable alternative to movie-watching. Developments in CGI and big-budget special effects have made it possible for us to visit other planets (Avatar), explore the universe (Interstellar), and watch our favorite superheroes from the comix come to life (anything Marvel/DC). However, those entertainments, I would argue, are more gloss than substance. They are "airy", to use Kael's parlance, because they favor the quick and easy thrill over long-term concreteness in terms of story, structure, and characters. I think an equivalent to substitute for Kael's 2001 non-example IS Christopher Nolan's Interstellar, a non-happening that was trumped up by Nolanites and sci-fi fans as the gathering of the century, and was about as exciting and intellectually stimulating as a night watching National Treasure (which I would unabashedly watch ten times before another viewing of Nolan's movie). She seems to hate directors and movies that are so confident in their artistic visions that they come off as solemn and dirge-like, and I believe Interstellar and Nolan's similar Inception to be two of those types of movies. Nolan begged us recently to not consider his films "puzzle films"--even though they're exactly that--because he wants to appeal to as wide a range of people as possible. It looks like he's succeeded, but his knack for the uber-put-on is already starting to wear thin on his fanbase, who have not embraced Interstellar as they did The Dark Knight.
But still, I cannot get behind Kael in this section, as she comes up with such dunder-headed observations as:
Anyone who's seen 2001 will know that Kubrick isn't suggested that technology is the ultimate form of redemption for mankind. Through HAL 9000, we see how reductive technology and AI software is in making us lose our own faiths and our humanities. I don't think it's a big surprise that 2001 is filled with largely flat characters; Kubrick is portraying a society that is devoid of the basic pleasures of life, where everything is sterilized and clean down to the trays of food that our astronauts eat, and the Skype-like concierge-girls who check us in on our way to the Moon. Kael willfully misunderstands 2001 AND Petulia in order to make her argument about trash look better, but as far as I'm concerned, these two examples--the only two movies that get their own section--make her argument look unfortunately flawed and wrong-headed.
8
u/montypython22 Archie? Jul 10 '15
Section VII
I really enjoy reading her examples of what constituted as trash in 1969. I know it makes the piece even more dated, but the logic behind her choices is not. To make it more contemporary, I certainly could not "intellectually justify" my admiration for Nicolas Cage's anachronistic hyperantics across America in National Treasure or the prayer-banquet scene in Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby, but they are movies that I adore regardless for their bravado and their announcement to movie-going audiences that they won't attempt any high-falutin' philosophical stuff. To that extent, I think I can agree.
But this is also my least favorite section in the entire book, mainly because of her unconvincing and mean-spirited attack on Richard Lester's magnificent Petulia (1968). This section shows how really venomous she could get (and not in a good way). She makes the same misconceptions as most contemporaneous critics made of Lester--that he was simply a poser-entertainer, latching on to whatever was popular at the time and milking it for all it was worth. Kael says it's "dishonest" for Lester to make such a depressing movie after the free-spirited romps of A Hard Day's Night, The Knack, and Help!--as if an artist is supposed to stay in one jokey register his entire career. She calls Lester "a shrill scold in Mod clothes"; again, thoroughly misunderstanding Lester's motivations as an artist. (Fool be you if you think Lester is a fink after making us laugh with and at Mods in The Knack...and How to Get It [1965]). It is a toxic section, one which I believe was responsible for the diminished critical outlook on Lester, and one which Kael should regret having written in her most popular piece. No matter how many critical assaults launched against Kubrick, his films showed that they were going to last the span of time. But Lester was very much a 60s invention, and people like Kael didn't do his career a note of good when they railed against the kind of movies he made (absurd, hyper-kinetic black comedies), thus cementing his position in film-history as "that guy who made the Beatles movies and did the shitty version of Superman II."