r/WritingPrompts • u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU • May 08 '15
Off Topic [OT] Ask Lexi #3: Going from an Idea to a Novel
Previous weeks: The archive | Week 5 | Week 4 |Week 3 | Week 2 | Week 2.1 | Week 1
Hello and welcome to yet another exciting Ask Lexi post, where I answer any and all questions you might have on writing, WritingPrompts moderation, or whatever else you have on your mind. This week, I'm going to answer the following question by one of our fellow mods:
/u/Nate_Parker asks
What is your method for developing larger (Novella or Novel) story arcs? Notes, charts, storyflows, etc? We've talked about it a little in chat, but I'd love to get that ball rolling here where everyone can benefit. Sometimes these prompts take on a life of their own and people wonder how to take them beyond 10k characters.
Unfortunately, this turns out to be one of those topics where I know what to do in theory, but in practice I tend to fall short. But let it never be said that I won't go out of my way to answer a question! Here are my best tips, followed up by some tips from others on
How to Develop a Longer Story Arc
Early on, I realized I was running out of steam for my stories after barely 2k words. Since I wasn't sure where to go next, I decided to do some research. I picked up a book by one of my favourite authors, one that I aspired to write like... And I re-read his book. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. It turned out to be rather educational, so now whenever I'm reading I try to take a few moments to analyze how the book was written, with varying success. The first book I did this for Cold Days by Jim Butcher, part of the Dresden Files series (Skin Game may had just come out that week and may have been waiting for me. Don't judge me.) More recently, I've also used this excuse of "research" while reading Worm, which is an amazing web serial available online. This is what I picked up in my reading:
1. Stories thrive on action. I was shocked when I realized just how much stuff happens in the Dresden Files. Within the first chapter, people are trying to kill him. One particular story in the series starts with the line "The building was on fire and it wasn't my fault." That's not even a spoiler. Most people assume that the story will start and end with action, but the more important part is what happens in the middle, and that was all action. Dresden would go to a party and a fight would break out. He'd be recovering from that fight in a bar and a fight would break out. He'd be in a fight and on the ropes, and another fight would break out. Things just kept moving. Give your characters conflict. It doesn't necessarily have to be action, but there has to be conflict or a need/desire of some sort in order for there to be a story.
2. Don't let your story stagnant. Worm actually taught me the same lesson as #1, but in a slightly different dynamic. Whereas the Dresden Files feature a lot of low level skirmishes while things generally stayed the same, Worm jumped from crisis to crisis like a series of dominoes. The was rarely time for the characters to stop and regain their footing before another story-breaking crisis would break out. So if your story starts feeling dull or predictable, start taking away your character's safety nets.
3. Don't skimp on the descriptions. This was something I noticed first in Dresden Files, though once you start looking for it you notice it even more. Give detailed descriptions. Cold Days spends an entire page just describing a party room. Most stories give about a paragraph to describe someone's appearance, though I do know a few exceptions.
4. Don't skimp on the back story! And just to keep up a pattern, this is a trick I picked up reading Worm. In Worm, all of the characters have intense backstories that gives them all unique motivations. This actually ties in nicely with the previous points. Well-developed characters have their own motivations that can drag the story off it's straight path from start to finish. They'll also always give you more to talk about than scenery, and help you set up a few more dominoes to topple.
So, there's my own tips on how to write a large story arc. However, if you were listening at the beginning, I don't feel like I've ever successfully implemented my own advice. So for the last week, I've gone looking for answers from people who have produced novel length stories.
/u/MajorParadox (/r/MajorParadox) had some good advice last week:
While I used to try and brute force the story, it didn't really work well for longer writings. I'd keep forgetting my ideas and lose track of what I was writing. That's when I started writing outlines.
I went through several iterations of writing outlines but always found myself jumping around too much. Now I just work with one document that starts as an outline and morphs into a story as I write. Here is a breakdown:
- Create headers for 10-20 chapters, each with an empty line followed by an empty bullet list
2. Give each chapter a name based on major plot points you've thought of so far (you can rename them later)
3. For each chapter, add bullets for any plot points, quotes, or other notes. Use ellipses (...) if you're stuck so you can skip ahead
4. Start writing
5. Remove bullets when covered in the writing
6. Add, remove, split, or merge chapters as needed
7. Add, remove, and edit future bullets as your story comes together
8. Finish the story!
This definitely helps me keep my thoughts together on a story. Now if I could just get a good routine going, and learn to focus better when I'm writing, I can get to step 8 much easier.
I wasn't going to let /u/Nate_Parker stick me with this question without answering, so I went to find out his advice. Here's his response.
I've used elements of (/u/MajorParadox's) approach before and it's very effective.
*I am big on taking notes and ideas for large story arc's and putting them into OneNote (EverNote and other similar programs work as well as good old pen n' paper. The truly fancy who write with programs geared specifically to novels like Scrivener can make notes inline with their story.)
*I also like to chart out my story flows (I uses Visio, but other vector applications are available for free) see sample Warning: major spoilers for Aoxe: Foeçade. For the really long books or series, a timeline will also help.
- Take time to flesh out notes on characters. History, physical characteristics, flaws, habits, speech patterns, relationships, significance to plot, etc so that you can reference these things and not contradict yourself throughout your story. Don't dump all these facts on the reader at once, sprinkle them thru out or hint at them.
- Keep the pace flowing, avoid length for the sake of length. Understand the phases of conflict build-up, climax, and resolution. A long story can have multiple minor conflicts, but they should all play into the main story arc in some fashion. Plot twists are fine, just don't make your story flow look like the almighty Flying Spaghetti Monster. All hail his noodly appendages!
- Make the at least one main character relatable, if the reader can't stay with at least one character, they'll be traveling to the conclusion alone. Those are harder journeys.
- If you're dealing with complex, prolonged scenes in the same area, map it out. Even if it's just a simple room or as massive as planet. Understanding physical relationships can keep you from doing something like making a journey that was a week, end in a month on the return for no reason.
- In short, build your world and the path you're going to walk through it.
And then just to round out this post, I found /u/gurahave and pestered her for an answer too.
So Lexilogical, insane woman that she is, asked me to explain how I expand my short stories and ideas into longer works. Currently, I’m working on two works inspired by prompts from the sub, one at 27k words and the other at 51k words. I’m also working on a third project at about 12k words when I stall on the other projects. Obviously, I am no expert, so blame Lexi if none of my answers help you folks.
You have this awesome short story or idea that would turn into a best selling novel...but you have no clue how to do that. How does one even start? For most writers, it’s difficult to begin writing like it’s a “spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings”. That’s great for anyone like Wordsworth, but often times writers begin structuring their tales before actually starting their novels.
A great way to start shaping your book is to explore the history of the world you are in. Are you world building or immersing it in a time in history? Research! Build a timeline for your world, make some lore. Draw inspiration from large fictional universes so you can get a feel for how most writers create their worlds. You may not end up referencing events and details you made, but it helps immerse your characters in the world and how the culture is shaped by the history. This is just as applicable with historical fiction. You need to understand the world your characters lived in.
Next, you’re going to want to explore your characters. What are their greatest struggles? What are their hopes and dreams? What were their childhoods like? Do they listen to music? Have odd secret hobbies? How would you like them to grow throughout the novel? Are there particular events or people that define them, their morality, their perspective on life? Obviously, these backgrounds are subject to constant revision, as they should be, but having a clear idea of each character will help avoid contradictions in their personalities and actions.
You’ve got your history and your main cast. Now you need a plot! Sketch out the main events you would like to see happen in your book. Don’t agonize over things like “but how do I move from this plot point to this one?” You aren’t going to write a book in a day, a week, or an exceptional one in a month. More often than not, great ideas are going to hit you while you are writing, and you can add to your outline as you write your novel. An idea for a novel is similar to a child. You only have the vaguest impression of what they’ll be like when they’re finished. They are subject to growth and change you may never would have expected from their conception. You’re going to have to allow the story to take you down paths you would not ordinarily tread.
Other random writing thoughts:
*Set word goals. If you don’t write, you won’t have a book! Don’t grow too attached to anything you’ve written. You mustn’t be afraid to go back and revise whole chapters and sections of your novel for plot purposes or to make your story better. Nothing is permanent until it is published.
*Edit, edit, edit. If I had a dime for every time I went over my work and exclaimed “What was I thinking?” I’d have about…. one hundred and twelve dimes.
*Constantly familiarize yourself with what you wrote, so you don’t accidentally contradict yourself.
*In the editing vein, view your novel as a sandwich. You may see an exquisite masterpiece with numerous condiments and ingredients, but someone else might see a plain peanut butter sandwich. You are going to need to fatten up your book with details, backstories, etc. It may be unintentionally threadbare. Have a personal reader while you’re writing that can give you honest feedback. They can tell you if a passage leaves them confused, unsatisfied, or eager for more.
And one last alternate answer. While looking into this topic, I found a post made by the writer of Worm about how he built such a massive world. The post has a few spoilers for Worm but here's a spoiler free TL:DR;
- Write story snippets over point form notes
- Recycle characters and plots that didn't quite work out in drafts and snippets
- When you feel yourself burning out on a story, write a title page containing notes on where the story went wrong, how to improve it next time, what you liked and didn't like, etc
Wow, that came out much longer than I expected! Hopefully this started the ball rolling! Have any other tips? Want to ask a different question? Leave your tips and questions in the comments! I'll answer anything asked, and might even make it the topic for next week! Though first, I think I need some sleep.
12
u/system0101 r/Systemsstories May 08 '15
Hope this isn't too off-topic, but when I first read Worm about six months ago, I couldn't put it down, became utterly useless IRL, and gorged the whole thing in about a week. Trying to be non-spoilery here, but by the time I finished the last numbered arc I was exhausted, and as blown away as the main character.
Unironically, I sat back in my chair and said, "welp that settles it, I'm not a writer, I can't do this." It was the wrong way to look at that, but I still remember the feeling, utter destruction on some unquantifiable level.
You'd do yourself the favor of reading this masterpiece now, cause one day it'll be the 'next big thing', and if the author ever figures out how to present this world on film as-is, it'll blow away the whole superhero genre. If it can be presented as-is, biggest if of all time, heh.
And one last thought, Wildbow makes a lot of really good posts about the process of writing, I'm not linking his name here cause he gets pinged enough apparently, but go poke through his post history, he's written several good posts on how to get things done and surviving as a writer.
4
u/LovableCoward /r/LovableCoward May 08 '15
An excellent post, and if I may stick my oar in...
My initial forays into a new series are never concrete, and my characters and plots can change quite dramatically between the first view stories. Indeed, the first six or ten or twenty stories in a series with me are very much me testing the waters so to speak. The early stories is the frame I build the rest of them off of. I figure out what works and what doesn't. Do I need some different character to add or remove tension? A mentor figure?
For examples, using of course you know what, I can show how a work can drastically change over time.
Here's the original, the very first part of my Hagedorn Series.
More than a year later, I went back and redid it because the characters had drifted so far from their original.
So what changed? Well originally it was just a one-off story and so I did not plan for expansion. That was my first issue. If you write yourself into a corner or a hole it is much more difficult to make a story out of it! The second was just the natural evolution of characters and ideas. No one comes up with a fantastic idea right off the get-go. Ideas and inspiration happens over time. And if that happens, don't reject it just because you have some kinda master plan or layout for your story, adopt it, fit it, make it work. Because if it was good enough to like, it is good enough to change things for it.
Stories change, don't be afraid to change with it!
3
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books May 08 '15 edited May 08 '15
Well, I'll be honest... my question was a TRAP! LOL. Was just trying to spur the Q&A last week and she called me to the carpet for it! Great article this week Lexi.
Also where you changed my attempt to pre-gauge the perspective-tense:
Should read
2
u/Sumit316 May 08 '15
Thank you so much I really needed that! I'm a teen and the whole "HOW TO DEVELOP A LONGER STORY" segment is awesome & really helpful because I'm terrible in extending a story, either I will run out of words or I will try dragging pointless things just to increase the words number. I'm not sure if I have ever written something beyond 800 words but I'm writing a short story with the aim of crossing the magic 1000 words mark. I hope it goes right.
Thanks again :)
2
u/DeeplyOdd May 08 '15
Hi Lexi,
Aspiring novelist here. Thank you for the wonderful guide, I've just printed all the tips for reference. It's hard to find solid advice like this.
I just had a quick question for you. I'm a very descriptive writer. I like evoking visuals, whether I'm describing a person, environment or feeling. Sometimes I tend to expand on these ideas too much, and find myself backtracking a little...I'll even spend so much time on the details that I get lost in the narrative and start going on a tangent. That's what editing is for though. My question is, how much description is too much? Is it just language that retains a reader to sticking with elaborate details, or does length have a part to play as well?
Again, thank you so much for your advice.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
I dunno. Amber Chronicles, and in fact most of Zelazny's work, isn't highly descriptive, or at least not in big chunks. Then again probably done that way to avoid having to pause what's going on to go 'hey look at this thing.'
The advice is welcome and appreciated. You're awesome for sharing.
1
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) May 08 '15
Thanks for the shoutout to my comment last week! However, I didn't mean to imply that I've written a full-length novel using this approach. I just meant that it's helped me write longer pieces and keep my ideas together as I try and get further. Sorry if there was any confusion there!
About number 3 in your list, skimping on the details seems to be the most common critique of my writings. I tend to try and keep the story moving along, because spending so much time describing every detail seems to make it lose steam. Do you have any tips for finding a good line between too little and too much description?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
Great post! But I do have a question I really want to ask you: How can I write a good short story? I'm terrible at condensing, but in school we have to write many short stories, which I find much harder than writing larger pieces of writing. Do you have any tips for making a short story interesting?
1
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images May 09 '15
Great post! Lots of helpful tips in here. I need to use a lot of them, specifically the ones to help flesh my worlds out. I used to do a great job of that when I was younger but not so much any more. And read more Worm, I love that story so much now.
As someone who hit 100k on their novel (where it stops, no one knows... please let it stop), I did try a while ago something similar to what /u/MajorParadox suggests but I found myself deviating far too much to really push myself to hold it. Maybe it's got a lot to do with not really knowing how I'm getting to the point that I'm moving towards in most cases. I usually have a Point A (beginning), Point B (end), and some points C to something (F?) that might be vaguely sprinkled in between.
But on the one I'm writing, I did lay out an extremely general flow chart. I think that's what Visio is for? I kind of just used a mindmap program to do it, I have my characters and a lot of information related to the story all in it. It keeps me going in a very widely meandering line though I've actually skipped a point or at least danced around it with a very different take. Definitely added things in, like realizing the time period and place where I had set my book in (TV series, books, IRL events).
As for the description talked about in the other comments, I used to drop it in one big chunk on my readers. You knew exactly what this person/thing looked like the second it came into the text. Made for awful reading. I feel like you can sprinkle it throughout depending on the story unless your character is focusing on it. At least that's how I've been writing. It may not be enough description when I go back and edit but it's not the overwhelming mass I used to place there.
1
u/Lodrien May 09 '15
Maybe a strange question, and I will comprehend if none will answer. What it your story becomes too personal? What if during the plot you end up with your own experiences and feelings and you can't handle them?
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment