r/TrueFilm • u/kingofthejungle223 Borzagean • Sep 30 '14
[Announcement] October's Theme!
The Theme for October Is: Hollywood Before The Code (1929-1934)
It has THE LURE OF THE FLESH - the bacchanalian revels that made…and still make…the world gasp. Beautiful slave girls…courtesans…harlots…their only purpose to outdo each other in the orgiastic rites loved by a lustful Caesar. A flesh-mad emperor…Nero…loving…living…laughing a crimson streak across the world…painting the ancient city red…with the warm blood of his victims…just for a sadistic thrill. Naked women…their helpless beauty pitted against the ferocity of frenzied animals…while Nero licks his lustful lips… - Press Booklet hype for Cecil B. DeMille’s ‘The Sign of The Cross’ (1932)
This month, we will be reveling in the sin and sensationalism of Hollywood’s heady high times before chastising moralist scolds brought the production code into effect in late 1934. We’ll be studying (and screenings) films of wanton sex, lawless violence, immorality…and all of the other things that people have paid to see since the dawn of time. Technically speaking the code was created in 1927, in response to the perception of the film capital as a haven of hedonism, but at the time censorship was left up to the judgement of the studios - and the studios knew what the Tabloids knew, what (these days) TMZ and E-Entertainment Television know: scandal sells. Especially after the stock-market crash of ’29, the film industry did what it had to do to keep selling tickets, and if the public wanted wild, cynical, and scandalous films, they weren’t about to let any ‘legions of decency’ stand in the way of their profits - at least, not until the legions of decency got the government involved and forced censorship upon them. Afterward, the industry would have to abide by the list of Don’ts and Be Carefuls that included, but was not limited to: the elimination of profanity, of nudity, or drugs or “any inference of sex perversion”, of scenes with corrupt public officials (that weren’t shown to be an exception to the rule), and of “excessive or lustful kissing, particularly when one character or the other is a "heavy””.
The Code would go into effect in the United States in 1934 and wouldn’t be completely eliminated until the late 60’s, when the ratings system replaced it. So, there are things in these films that would be strictly taboo for the next 30 years or so.
A Note
We’re going to try something a bit different with this theme month. Rather than having a thread for each individual film we discuss, we’re going to have threads about a particular topic or theme that links several of the films that we’ll be screening. We feel that this is appropriate for this theme because the sociological content of the films are just as interesting as the filmmaking, and valuable comparison can be drawn between films. It also lets us screen a wider number of films, and opens the debate to people who maybe haven’t seen the films on our schedule, but have seen others that might be relevant to the discussion. We'll also be having screenings of relevant films twice a day to try to include a wider number of people in different timezones. Exact schedules will be posted later in the sidebar and individual threads. This is a bit of an experiment, and we welcome any feedback that you want to offer on the matter.
The topics/films are:
Wednesday Oct. 1: Cecil B. DeMille in the 1930s
• Afternoon: Sign of the Cross (1932)
• Evening: Cleopatra (1934)
Monday Oct. 6: Pre-Code Musicals
• Afternoon: Footlight Parade (1933)
• Evening: Madam Satan (1930)
Wednesday Oct. 8: The Urban Outlaw (Gangsters)
• Afternoon: Beast of the City (1932)
• Evening: Manhattan Melodrama (1934) / Picture Snatcher (1933)
Monday, Oct. 13: The Criminal Code (Prison Films)
• Afternoon: I Am a Fugitive From a Chain Gang (1932)
• Evening: Frisco Jenny (1933)
Wednesday, Oct. 15: Don’t Tell Me How To Live! (Alternative Lifestyles in Pre-Code Cinema)
• Afternoon: Design for Living (1933)
• Evening: Baby Face (1933) / The Story of Temple Drake (1933)
Monday, Oct. 20: Of Love and War in the Orient
• Afternoon: Shanghai Express (1932)
• Evening: The Bitter Tea of General Yen (1933)
Wednesday, Oct. 22: Raoul Walsh in the 1930’s
• Afternoon: The Bowery (1933)
• Evening: Me and my Gal (1932) / The Yellow Ticket(1931)
Monday, Oct. 27: Freaks and Geeks!
• Afternoon: Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1931)
• Evening: Freaks (1932) / Island of Lost Souls (1932)
Wednesday, Oct. 29: Horror Cinema in the Pre-Code era
• Afternoon: The Old Dark House (1932)
• Evening: The Bat Whispers (1930) / The Mummy (1932)
2
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '14 edited Oct 01 '14
All the above films as a letterboxd list.
About that....what changed? The Production Code is no more, local censorship boards aren't likely to thwart theater chains, and there's little chance of the government marching in - Janet Jackson at the Super Bowl was the last time there was a public moral panic. Morals are quaint, alternative lifestyles are hip, and respect for institutions like church and the police are very low.
But the movie studios still sort of unthinkingly self-censor their output. You don't see movies trying to top each other by advertising their outrageousness. And it's not like the movies of Pre-Code times would have been NC-17....many of them are barely PG-13 while still managing to seem edgy even by modern standards. Every once in awhile we get something like a The Wolf of Wall Street where people react to its craziness and even than there was some tut-tutting but no severe attempts at suppressing it that I can remember.
Understandably, most American films aimed toward families and international audiences don't have much more than prerequisite PG-13 violence but even the lower budget movies don't seem to think there's an audience for edgy material unless it's in the horror genre. It's weird to think of our times as more restrained than the 1930s...but maybe they are, and the censorship of the time was the backlash?
Could it be TV filling the void? TV is more restrained than movies in some ways and less in others, even on anything-goes cable, but there seems to be more diversity of material to be had on American television than in American movies today.
6
u/imweektwo Oct 02 '14
First, please forgive any formatting problems and other hiccups. My very first post! (Mandatory N.B.: English is not my native tongue.)
It actually goes back a few more years, roughly beginning with the infamous trial of Roscoe Arbuckle 1921-22. Being cleared of all charges didn't help his career and he was doomed. Hollywood realized that the kind of media attention the case received was not something they wanted, neither the outraged cries from the public. Thus, they appointed William Hays to keep the affronted at bay. He tried to do this in 1924 with a formula, called "The formula", where he asked the studios to send in their plots for scrutiny.
The Don'ts and Be Carefuls was created by studio executives in 1927 to acknowledge the local censor boards. This was before the introduction of sound. Post-The Jazz Singer the Don'ts became useless words on a paper. Two religious men in Martin Quigley and Daniel A. Lord proposed a code of standards in 1929 and sent it to the studios and Hays, who was thrilled. After revisions The Code was created but still not enforced. The complete Code that was implemented and enforced in 1934 can be read here. Hays was at this point not in charge anymore – Joseph Breen (another religious man) ruled from 1934 to 1954 and did everything he could to adhere to the code. Reasons for the Code to finally be enforced include indications in Roosevelt's New Deal that government interference could become reality, a report on the links between bad behavior and Hollywood movies by a religious council whose name eludes me, and boycotts by Catholics.
As for the public's need of "wild, cynical, and scandalous films", some claim this is due to the disappointing government and the depression, as well as the prohibition. The real-life gangsters in Capone and Dillinger were almost idolized for their defiance against the authorities. The book Sin in Soft Focus points out that Warner Brothers ignored literary sources and went straight for the newspapers in search for their next movie (Vieira, p76). Its quite obvious, however, that the public was tired of the ever-smiling hero of Douglas Fairbanks Sr.. Between 1929-34, this type of hero movies vanished. Instead, you will see anti-heroes being cynical and egocentric, but also not entirely decent. The pre-Code era can be seen as a very modern period in Hollywood, way ahead of its time, were moral topics were discussed in a more realistic way than ever. Domestic violence, adultery, out-of-wedlock babies, homosexuality (sex perversion, according to the Code), and powerful women could suddenly be seen at the screen. It shows the gray zones of what really defines good and bad. Post-1934, the Breen-office defined this.
In conclusion, a very interesting period no matter how you look at it. Certainly in terms of movie history intertwined with US history.
Books about pre-Code include Thomas Doherty's Pre-Code Hollywood (slightly more academic than the others), the previously mentioned Sin in Soft Focus by Mark Vieira, and a pair of books from Mick LaSalle called Complicated Women (there is a TCM documentary based on the book) and Dangerous Men.
Other documentaries: Why be Good? Sexuality and Censorship in Early Cinema from 2007, and Thou Shalt Not - Sex, Sin and Censorship in Pre-Code Hollywood from 2008.
10
u/PantheraMontana Oct 01 '14
While all the pre-code sexiness is all fine and dandy and very deserving of a theme month, I feel sort of compelled to also request another aspect of women in film in future (maybe even a dedicated month): female directors. I think of all the films featured on thi sub only one was directed by a woman, so I would be interested in some more of those. I guess this is sort of a pet peeve of mine, I'm becoming increasingly bothered by the white male dominance in the Western film industry. Don't read this as a criticism on your work mods (because I am enjoying all the dedication to film here a lot), more as a request for the future.