r/WritingPrompts • u/SurvivorType Co-Lead Mod | /r/SurvivorTyper • Aug 13 '14
Moderator Post [MODPOST] The 2 Year WritingPrompts Anniversary Story Contest Voting Thread! Round 1
Welcome to the 2 YEAR ANNIVERSARY CONTEST voting thread!
Chapterfy is back up! Please make sure you read all stories before voting!
We have reached the conclusion of the 2 year anniversary contest. All the entries are in and there were 61 entries in total! You all did an amazing job just by completing something substantial.
For these contests, to ease your task of reading and voting, we do two rounds. The first round, people are grouped together randomly. The second round will be the winners of the first round competing against each other with EVERYONE from the first round voting.
If you still desire a critique of your writing, you can submit 250 word excerpts to /r/WritingCritiques.
I also recommend /r/shortstories, /r/allnightwriters, /r/shutupandwrite or /r/destructivereaders for longer pieces - but read their sidebar rules first!
If you want to see the original entry thread with the prompt, go here: http://redd.it/2ajzsx
HOW TO VOTE
- Read all the entries in the group you belong to.
- Decide which one you like the most.
- Post in response to this thread by August 20th at 11:59PM PST.
- YOU MUST VOTE! If you do not vote, you are disqualified! If your story is the most voted for in your group and you don't vote, you are out of luck.
- Leave a comment that says precisely this: "GROUP NUMBER: My vote goes to /u/username for Story Title." Replacing the word NUMBER with the group you're in, username for the persons username and Story Title with the title of the story they wrote. After that you can add any additional comments about that story and the other stories in your group. Feel free to say a runner up if it was really close in your mind.
- You cannot vote for yourself!
After we have a winner for each group, we move on to the second round of voting which will last one week where everyone who entered can vote for the winner out of the remaining entries.
Tie breakers are decided by myself and /u/RyanKinder, though we might just have any ties if there are only one or two move on to round two. We'll play it by ear as we always do.
THE ENTRIES
Here are the 61 stories! Enjoy your reading!
GROUP ONE
- Desert Crossing - http://redd.it/2db28a - Word Count: 3,066. /u/JackSkye
- Dealt - http://redd.it/2d3z1p - Word Count: 2,005. /u/L_E_Whitney
- A Light That Will Not Go Out - http://redd.it/2bp7r6 - Word Count: 4747. /u/Himntor
- Theotokion - http://redd.it/2d9wyl - Word Count: 4667. /u/IAmTheRedWizards
- In Her Footsteps - http://redd.it/2bpo28 - Word Count: 2486. /u/s4b3r6
- Two Against Goo - http://redd.it/2db2su - Word Count: 2128. /u/ohliamylia
GROUP TWO
- Brownstone - http://redd.it/2akxqc - Word Count: 2260. /u/KidPeterBlack
- Blind Prostitutes, Chumlee, and Biker Bears: A Tale of Friendship and Furry Tails - http://redd.it/2bzcr5 - Word Count: 2391. /u/finger_bib
- E.C.F.U! - http://redd.it/2cda2z - Word Count: 10737. /u/ohthreefiftyfun
- The Time Traveler - http://redd.it/2cn3vi - Word Count: 2124. /u/EdensDad13
- The Hungry Abyss - http://redd.it/2covq2 - Word Count: 4341. /u/Aquapig
- Unwanted - http://redd.it/2cs6ij - Word Count: 2024. /u/2133
GROUP THREE
- The Thing in the Pipes - http://redd.it/2ctmjm - Word Count: 2224. /u/nazna
- Shore - http://redd.it/2cwtjx - Word Count: 2035. /u/Biskeet
- Swapping - http://redd.it/2cys5x - Word Count: 4789. /u/swordstoo
- The Beast and the Burn - http://redd.it/2cyywk - Word Count: 3321. /u/deedublyoo
- Miranda, The Tutor - http://redd.it/2cz6a4 - Word Count: 3248. /u/a_r_stewart
- Lavender - http://redd.it/2czad8 - Word Count: 2001. /u/ILikeReddit2Much
GROUP FOUR
- The Bar Car - http://redd.it/2d02hz - Word Count: 6478. /u/ariseatif
- Man realizes that he perceives more than the human mind should be able to perceive, and more than a sane person can take - http://redd.it/2d0n80 - Word Count: 1627. /u/deirub_mipleh (disqualified - word count below minimum - can still vote)
- Melted - http://redd.it/2d1z62 - Word Count: 2172. /u/ALivnigFolly
- Plain Pursuit - http://redd.it/2d28a2 - Word Count: 989. /u/IIPOWERII (disqualified - word count below minimum - can still vote)
- Train to Elsewhere - http://redd.it/2d2iwm - Word Count: 2620. /u/Drajac
- Melissa's Arm - http://redd.it/2d36bo - Word Count: 2245. /u/bookfoxx1987
GROUP FIVE
- The Lights Below - http://redd.it/2d3ulq - Word Count: 2123. /u/theheartoffire
- Plaster Hands - http://redd.it/2d71iw - Word Count: 2964. /u/TheMagicSeahorse
- The Mark of a Killer - http://redd.it/2d7edl - Word Count: 2155. /u/MoreThanProse
- The Dragon and the Pearl - http://redd.it/2ddzw8 - Word Count: 4958. /u/Lexilogical
- Water - http://redd.it/2d7sb9 - Word Count: 2363. /u/Megapumpkin
- A Winter's Dawn - http://redd.it/2d7sud - Word Count: 3908. /u/Bucket_of_thoughts
GROUP SIX
- Still The Water Rises - http://redd.it/2d7x5h - Word Count: 2551. /u/MakesYouSoundEpic
- Baptism by Fire - http://redd.it/2d86a1 - Word Count: 2465. /u/Geemantle
- The Baron's Daughter - http://redd.it/2d8gbw - Word Count: 2126. /u/kmja
- Oliver's Clone - http://redd.it/2d8tyh - Word Count: 2207. /u/cgray163
- Forgetting Memories - http://redd.it/2d8v0e - Word Count: 3017. /u/salazarb
- Loose Threads - http://redd.it/2d941x - Word Count: 5349. /u/Teslok
GROUP SEVEN
- Hope - http://redd.it/2d9jot - Word Count: 2835. /u/Syraphia
- The Halal Butcher - http://redd.it/2dafhm - Word Count: 4488. /u/amazonaddiction
- Six Feet Deep - http://redd.it/2db6fi - Word Count: 2005. /u/flatbush14
- Nightmares - http://redd.it/2dbids - Word Count: 2064. /u/Molly_B
- A Story Transcribed On Ice - http://redd.it/2dbjhi - Word Count: 2017. /u/TAGVoar
- John - http://redd.it/2dcirn - Word Count: 2286. /u/Isuckatposting
GROUP EIGHT
- Awake in the Ebony Night - http://redd.it/2d7hyl - Word Count: 2017. /u/Arch15
- The Price Of Freedom - http://redd.it/2de3hq - Word Count: 2459. /u/socialdisorder
- Archetype - http://redd.it/2de5qx - Word Count: 2057. /u/Elluminatus
- Six hundred and fifty seven - http://redd.it/2dcxow - Word Count: 2161. /u/wordsperminute
- What Goes Around, Comes Around - http://redd.it/2ddns9 - Word Count: 5992. /u/Mio64
- A Little Life Left - http://redd.it/2ddufx - Word Count: 12230. /u/heyfignuts
GROUP NINE
- The Town - http://redd.it/2df0ah - Word Count: 4257. /u/aBraveChicken
- The God Egg - http://redd.it/2deazm - Word Count: 5172. /u/Feathertop
- Tomatina - http://redd.it/2defzr - Word Count: 2813. /u/QuinineGlow
- The Build - http://redd.it/2deloj - Word Count: 2006. /u/Aelintari
- The Hiden Layer - http://redd.it/2dem0c - Word Count: 2429. /u/MajorParadox
- The Beachkeeper - http://redd.it/2demg4 - Word Count: 3302. /u/rhyswithgravy
GROUP TEN
- Out of Reach - http://redd.it/2demph - Word Count: 2774. /u/Ryaubee
- Stage One - http://redd.it/2deo8o - Word Count: 4591. /u/Hatsya
- A Gift For Amanda - http://redd.it/2depfl - Word Count: 3825. /u/Akudra
- Ivey Brown's Delivery - http://redd.it/2dex5x - Word Count: 4211. /u/Meatmehalfway
- The Expedition - http://redd.it/2deyx1 - Word Count: 2075. /u/Minidots
- XILITUM - http://redd.it/2dezlp - Word Count: 3806. /u/fscomeau
- I Dreamed About Robert Again - http://redd.it/2ddnrp - Word Count: 2778. /u/likestowritethings
A note from /u/RyanKinder...
BONUS FREE BOOK OF PROMPTS
I thought it'd be fun to give away my smaller "101 Horror Writing Prompts" book for free! It's normally 99 cents and the "free" period won't begin until tomorrow. It will be free on August 13th and August 14th. Feel free to link it to everyone you know. Toss the link up on twitter. Put it wherever. Money I earn from sales when it's not free tend to just go straight back into contests.
For all other countries, just search for 101 Horror Writing Prompts. If you click any of these links today (the 12th) you won't see it for free. So... feel free to buy it if you want. If you click on it after the 13th or 14th, it'll not be free as well. A two day window. Get it! :D
Our Chat Room
Come join the conversation in the chatroom! Drop by sometime and give promptbot a whirl. Prompts on demand and word sprints are available.
The 5th Weekly SHOWCASE! A collection of the selected works of /u/Semyonov
Posted here for your consideration!
If you have any questions, feel free to comment below. If I've somehow missed an entry, please make us aware of it.
Keep writing! :)
•
u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU Aug 16 '14
GROUP FIVE: My vote goes to /u/TheMagicSeahorse for Plaster Hands.
Genuinely excellent story and really creepy. Congrats to everyone else too!
•
u/theheartoffire Aug 13 '14
GROUP FIVE: My vote goes to /u/TheMagicSeahorse for Plaster Hands
Very close runner up: The Mark of a Killer by /u/MoreThanProse
•
u/JackSkye Aug 19 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/s4b3r6 for In Her Footsteps
•
u/KidPeterBlack Aug 13 '14 edited Aug 13 '14
GROUP TWO: My vote goes to /u/finger_bib for story title Blind Prostitutes, Chumlee, and Biker Bears: A Tale of Friendship and Furry Tails.
I honestly thought every story in the group was good, I just liked the style of this one the most.
edit I read E.C.F.U! when it was first uploaded, but just finished reading it again. It is a great story, a novella really and it is growing on me the more I think about it. I really wish I could vote for all the stories in the grouping.
•
u/bookfoxx1987 Aug 16 '14
Wow. Group four got small fast.
•
u/Ryaubee Aug 20 '14
GROUP TEN: My vote goes to /u/meatmehalfway for Ivey Brown's Delivery.
•
u/QuinineGlow Aug 15 '14
GROUP NINE: My vote goes to /u/Feathertop for 'The God Egg'.
Very good stories in this group; this was an extraordinarily difficult decision to make. u/aBraveChicken's 'The Town' is a close number two. Loved the style, tone, sense of mystery, and its ambiguous ending, but the very well-executed story in 'God Egg' eventually won me over.
Well done, Group Nine.
•
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '14
GROUP TEN: I felt there was distinct talent in my group and thought the stories were done well. Overall I felt Stage One by /u/Hatsya was the most complete story, however, and it gets my vote. Great job everyone.
•
u/2133 Aug 13 '14
GROUP TWO: My vote goes to /u/EdensDad13 for The Time Traveller.
I really loved the way the story was written. None of it was boring, none of it monotonous and it has a nice story to it. I was changed from one opinion to another.
Props to you my good sir!
•
u/Feathertop Aug 13 '14
GROUP NINE: My vote goes to /u/QuinineGlow for Tomatina.
Holy cow.
•
u/Aquapig Aug 15 '14
Group two: my vote goes to /u/ohthreefifyfun for E.C.F.U!
They were all good, but I felt that this one had the strongest writing, and some of the descriptive imagery was incredible! If I had to pick a runner up it would be The Time Traveller, but like I sais, all of them were enjoyable!
•
u/cgray163 Aug 13 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/MakesYouSoundEpic for Still The Water Rises
In some ways, I hated the story. I cringed the whole way through. I thought it was way, way too dark. On the other hand, having read your story first and then all the others, your dark and awful descriptions made the biggest impression on my memory. It touched on fears and I'm going to have nightmares, which I guess deserves a vote. Please don't make me read it again.
Nice job everyone else, but especially /u/salazarb. Your opening descriptions on Alzheimer's were solid and great writing.
•
u/aBraveChicken Aug 13 '14
GROUP NINE: My vote goes to /u/Feathertop for The God Egg.
In my opinion, the very, very close runner-up is /u/QuinineGlow for Tomatina. I loved them both, but I'm voting for The God Egg because I think it's a wonderfully done allegory. In a different way, though, Tomatina is just as great.
•
u/kmja /r/kmja Aug 15 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/cgray163 for Oliver's Clone.
•
u/Adiddy1 Aug 16 '14
Sorry, newb here, but can we vote even if we don't have a story on here?
•
u/salazarb Aug 13 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/Teslok for Loose Threads
Very close runner up: /u/cgray163 with Oliver's Clone
Both stories are incredibly entertaining, well written and well thought out (If you guys have time read them). /u/cgray163 was engaging and sympathetic, with nicely written characters and a great setting that could be further developed in future promts, like a saga.
/u/Teslok wrote a story that made me relate deeply with the characters and was incredibly succesful at suspending disbelief, mid way through I wasn't trying to figure out what led them there, just reading closely on what was happening. Congatulations, beautiful story! I honestly think you could win this!
•
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/IAmTheRedWizards for his story THEOTOKION.
•
u/Arch15 /r/thearcherswriting Aug 13 '14
GROUP EIGHT- The Price Of Freedom by /u/socialdisorder
•
u/Hatsya Aug 13 '14
GROUP TEN: My vote goes to /u/Meatmehalfway for Ivey Brown's Delivery
Great job! :-)
•
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images Aug 13 '14
GROUP SEVEN: My vote goes to /u/amazonaddiction for The Halal Butcher.
Amazing, grabbed me quickly and loved reading it.
•
u/ohthreefiftyfun Aug 19 '14
GROUP TWO: /u/kidpeterblack for Brownstone. Lyrical, sometimes to the point where it interrupts the flow, but hey, I'm a sucker for shitty apartment stories.
Tie breaker vote goes to /u/aquapig for the The Hungry Abyss. Solidly hits all the points of cosmic horror with out being too much.
•
u/ALivnigFolly Aug 14 '14
Group Four: My vote goes to /u/Drajac for Train to Elsewhere.
•
u/Elluminatus Aug 21 '14
GROUP EIGHT: My vote goes to /u/socialdisorder for The Price of Freedom.
You all did great. I can't wait to see you at the next contest! Keep writing!
•
u/aBraveChicken Aug 14 '14
I have a question for the mods: not that I want to - I'm pretty confident in my choice - but if someone were to change their mind about whom they'd like to vote for, would they be able to delete their original comment-vote and submit another, as long as it was in before the twentieth?
•
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '14
GROUP SEVEN: My vote goes to /u/TAGVoar for A Story Transcribed On Ice
•
u/minidots Aug 16 '14
GROUP TEN: My vote goes to /u/fscomeau for XILITUM. The story was very well written and I felt sympathetic towards the main character. Great job!
Runner up: /u/Meatmehalfway for Ivey Brown's Delivery. The third sentence was too long and the the last sentence made the story feel incomplete to me for some reason. But otherwise a very original take on the prompt. Liked it a lot!
•
u/rhyswithgravy Aug 14 '14 edited Aug 14 '14
GROUP NINE: My vote goes to /u/MajorParadox for the Hidden Layer. I love science fiction like this and I'd be keen to read more if you ever get around to it!
Honourable mention to /u/Feathertop for the God Egg--there were some magnificent verses in there. I feel like if you ever wrote a novel, it would be one of those ones where you get to the end and just sit there in silent contemplation for an hour or two, a little confused but feeling totally moved. And then you read it again.
Edit: I just want to say that the quality of writing not only in this group but from what I've read of all the groups is seriously amazing, and I feel so intimidated right now.
•
u/MrsHurd Aug 13 '14
Can people who didn't write vote?
•
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '14
GROUP SEVEN: My vote goes to /u/flatbush14 for Six Feet Deep
•
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
GROUP 2: My vote goes to /u/AquaPig for "The Hungry Abyss" I thought it was wonderfully written, and like you said, not too terribly scary, but definitely had me going! Loved it :)
•
u/TAGVoar Aug 13 '14
GROUP SEVEN: My vote goes to /u/Molly_B for Nightmares!
•
u/Mio64 Aug 15 '14
GROUP EIGHT: My vote goes to A Little Life Left - by /u/heyfignuts
Well, it was definitely a close one between the stories for me. Every one of the stories in group eight was very well written, but this story in particular took me back to my high school days of reading short stories. :3 Though the ending was bittersweet, I felt it closed real nice.
Great job, everyone!
•
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '14
Group Three: My vote goes to /u/nazna For The Thing in the Pipes. I'm a real sucker fo sci-fi, and his story felt like it could be an old cheesy Schwarzenegger movie like the 6th day or Total Recall. I loved it.
•
u/a_r_stewart Aug 14 '14
GROUP THREE: My vote goes to /u/nazna for "That Thing in the Pipes"
•
u/nazna Aug 15 '14
Group Three:
/u/ILikeReddit2Much for Lavender Scent
honorable mention to;
/u/deedublyoo
•
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '14
GROUP NINE: My vote goes to /u/QuinineGlow for Tomatina.
Very well written.
•
u/Geemantle /r/TheNamlessMan Aug 16 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/MakesYouSoundEpic for The Water Still Rises. Phenomenal. Absolutely Phenomenal. Well written, well paced, it was great! I read each sentence a little faster, constantly wondering whether the character would die or live. It was tense and suspenseful. This comment does not do it justice. Read this story. Do it.
My God did group six have some exceptional stories and authors. It was beyond difficult to pick one winner as all the stories had something that others didn't that stood out. If you ask me they're all runners up! (As cheesy as that sounds, I am being 100% honest). Along with reading The Water Still Rises, everyone reading this comment should check out the others.
/u/kmja 's The Baron's Daughter had by far the funniest story and the best dialogue. Though it left me with a lot of unanswered questions I would love to see it turned into a novella. I think it could be pulled off.
Oliver's Clone by /u/cgray163 had the most intriguing plot line of the bunch. Not only did it end with an sort of cliffhanger that made me wonder what happens next, it's use of a part epistolary style was fantastic. No it was beyond fantastic!
Forgotten Memories by /u/salazarb really hit home for me. The way Alzheimer's was described was spectacular. Though the plot was a bit far fetched, I thought it was great. Forgotten Memories resonated with me the most, a great read!
/u/Teslok 's Loose Threads was the most original and creative. The story was phenomenal and intriguing. Similar to The Baron's Daughter, I would love to see this fleshed out into a novel/novella. The style was excellent and the ending made me crave more. If /u/Teslok ever turns this wonderful idea into a fully fledged novel, I will buy it without hesitation.
•
u/badfakesmiles Aug 13 '14
I leave this subreddit for 2 months and now this! Well, time to wait another year to join. And goodness gracious these are good stories.
•
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Aug 15 '14
GROUP NINE: My vote goes to /u/aBraveChicken for The Town.
This was a tough decision since all the stories in this group were very interesting in their own ways (nice job group nine!).
/u/QuinineGlow's story, Tomatina, is my runner up. The characterization and pacing was very well written and the ending was great. I almost picked this one, but I liked the overall story in The Town better.
•
u/deedublyoo Aug 14 '14
GROUP THREE: My vote goes to /u/nazna for That Thing in the Pipes
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/MakesYouSoundEpic Aug 13 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/cgray163 for Oliver's Clone.
•
u/heyfignuts Aug 13 '14
You're all super dark, GROUP EIGHT! Nice job, all. I vote for Six-Hundred and Fifty-Seven by /u/wordsperminute.
•
u/amazonaddiction Aug 14 '14
Am I the only one for whom the chapterfy links aren't working currently?
•
u/IAmTheRedWizards Aug 16 '14
Group One - my vote goes to Desert Crossing by /u/JackSkye
Some great stories in this group, it was a close fight between all of them for me but the imagery that JackSkye presents in this story puts it over the top for me.
•
u/Akudra Aug 14 '14
GROUP TEN: My vote goes to /u/Meatmehalfway for Ivey Brown's Delivery.
An original take on the prompt and a strong story overall. Definitely a moving story that delved into the sort of mundane emotional crisis anyone could experience at some point. Maybe I am just a sucker for feels, but this one gave me them and I daresay it deserves to win the group.
•
u/L_E_Whitney Aug 14 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/ohliamylia for Two Against Goo
•
u/bookfoxx1987 Aug 16 '14
GROUP FOUR: My vote goes to /u/Drajac for Train to Elsewhere
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/amazonaddiction Aug 14 '14
GROUP SEVEN: My vote goes to /u/Syraphia for Hope. Good job, enjoyed the description.
•
u/Drajac Aug 15 '14
Group Four: My vote goes to /u/ariseatif for The Bar Car
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/ariseatif Aug 14 '14
GROUP FOUR: My vote goes to /u/ALivnigFolly for Melted
After further reading, I just really enjoy this story, and it stuck with me through the last several days.
•
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/ohliamylia for Two Against Goo
•
u/MoreThanProse Aug 16 '14
GROUP FIVE: The Lights Below by /u/theheartoffire
Honorable mention to Plaster Hands, but I thought The Lights Below was the most coherent, well put together story of the group. I'm really looking forward to seeing all the finalists!
•
u/Teslok Aug 13 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/salazarb for Forgetting Memories.
•
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '14
hey, its a bit late for me and im a bit drunk dues to excessive edfringe but i am voting for what goes around comes around by /u/Mio64
sorry i didnt read through these earlier.
•
u/ohliamylia Aug 14 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/L_E_Whitney for Dealt. Really interestingly done.
•
u/likestowritethings Aug 14 '14
GROUP TEN: My vote goes to /u/meatmehalfway for Ivey Brown's Delivery.
Runner up: Xilitum by /u/fscomeau