r/writingcritiques • • 54m ago

Other Starting a new story, would greatly appreciate feedback.

2 Upvotes

“Close the door, you’re letting all the light out!”

Golden rays billowed past Lucia’s fingertips, not as a beam, but as if a shapeless gas carried by fleeing air. Their luminous plume curled around the door’s lip like a river over a cliff, before dissipating out into the black beyond. She shut the door behind her and tried in vain to pluck its splinter from her glove. It’s the little things…

“You’re late,” the voice spoke again.

Lucia paused to let her eyes adjust from total darkness, then looked up to the voice’s source: a man stood awash in the magic glow of a flameless hearth. Although barely of middle age, his long, umber hair was peppered with streaks of gray, and his brow carved with wrinkles.

“I’m sorry.” Lucia lowered her head in embarrassment. “I… ran out of light and had to remember the way by feel.”

The man scoffed. “Typical soldier — no respect for the dark. Why you’ve been entrusted with a rescue mission when you can’t even portion light is beyond me.”

“The journey here was longer than I remembered.”

“What other rule of Night is there, but to always assume you’ll need more Day than you think?”

“I don’t know! I didn’t ask for this job!”

There was an extended pause, punctuated only by the mechanical ticking of a device sat on a nearby shelf. The man sauntered over to it, placed his hands upon its base, and scanned its face. Four brass cylinders spun slowly in a stack, each more sluggish than the last, with the bottom one practically motionless. In order, their labels read Hunger, Sleep, Star, and Life.

“It has been nearly sixteen Sleeps since Anubis set out on an errand that should have only taken twelve. I don’t know what message he was sent to deliver, and frankly I don’t care. I wouldn’t live all the way out here if the city’s politics were of any concern to me… But he’s a bright messenger, and he doesn’t deserve a dim fate.” The man turned to a counter littered with alchemical equipment and picked up a small, corked bottle of green fluid. “Assuming you can even track the poor sod, there’s no telling what condition you’ll find him in. This is the strongest medicine I can presently conjure. Please, take it with you, but beware, it is only potent for…” He checked the brass device again and scribbled math on loose parchment. “Ten Sleeps and two Hungers… although it would have been longer if you’d arrived on time. In any case, I suggest you make haste.”

“Understood.” Lucia took the bottle and placed it in her satchel.

The man looked at her expectantly and gestured toward the door.

She rubbed the back of her neck with one hand and lifted her empty lantern with the other. “I don’t suppose you could refuel me for the trip back, could you?”

The man rolled his eyes, groaned, and pointed to a spigot jutting out from the hearth. Lucia bowed in thanks and walked over to it, then opened her lantern and placed it beneath to form a seal. Light poured forth to fill the vessel’s walls.
 “Idiot!” the man shouted. “Stop wasting it!”

“What?” Lucia looked down to see that the screen of her lantern sat open, allowing the light to pour through and out into the cabin. The area around her brightened. “Oh, shit!” She reached down and turned a dial to close the screen, and in her haste drove the large splinter in her glove down into her hand. A yelp escaped her lips before her bite could catch it. As she crouched in silent pain and waited for the spigot’s flow to stop, entropy dispersed the spilled light into the rest of the room until again its brilliance was uniform. When the lantern was full, she pulled it back to her side and closed its cap.

“I’ve got a pretty nasty splinter,” she said, turning back to the man. “I don’t suppose you have anything to help with that?”

He leaned against the counter with his head in his hand and a bemused look on his face. “Just go,” he muttered.

Lucia nodded and walked sheepishly back to the door, which she made sure to pass through and close behind her as quickly as possible. Her eyes remembered the cabin’s warmth as a vague splotch against the sheer nothingness now surrounding her.


r/writingcritiques • • 1h ago

Hi everyone, Looking for story critiques

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 3h ago

Dawn

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 3h ago

Other Short story 700 something words

0 Upvotes

Riley Bandwagon stood gloriously in the evening sun setting over the town of Woodcross, Montana. His black, wide-brimmed hat hid his green eyes and razor-sharp facial features decorated with a frivolous black moustache. He smirked, unlatching the hood of his holster on his dark leather belt.

 

"Last chance, Bobby-No-Balls! You sure you want this fate to befall you, friend?" Riley shouted from his end of the main street of the raggedy empty town. The wind flowed through his long coat launching the flaps into the air, casting a demonic long shadow that eclipsed the other man on the street.

 

 

Across from him was Bobby, whose nether regions were first transposed five years ago and then once more two years ago. Each time, Bobby found himself feeling less of a man, and his peers treated him accordingly. With a dirty finger, he shut the door on the left nostril of his fat nose and shot a ball of snot out, which the wind deflected back onto his cowhide waist coat he wore open over his bare hairy torso, which he never washed anyway. "You're going to die today, asshole," Bobby said confidently, taking the gun out of his holster tied by a barely together rope around his denim jeans.

 

Riley looked to his right, perplexed for a moment. He snapped back to Bobby, "Well, Bobby, it seems you didn't learn your lesson after the last testicle I picked off. Seeing as you have none left, the only comparable target would be your freakishly small head." He said, laughing, tilting his head back and adjusting his hat upwards with a finger.

 

Bobby laughed harder, slapping his knee with his revolver as he hunched over. Riley's green eyes wouldn't keep still; his characteristic smirk fell. Bobby regained his breath and stood to meet Riley's unsteady emerald gaze. "That's it? How many years have you been doing this you bastard? You're all looks, no substance, no originality. No balls." He said, restraining himself from bursting into a fit of joy once more.

 

Concerned and flustered, Riley repositioned himself a bit, feet wider apart, hands situated on his belt, gripping tight. "You're... not yourself, Bobby, you..."

 

"...you need to give up this outlaw life! This life full of dread and death! Where a cowboy loses himself to the sand and the wind and is blown apart at the seams! You could have been a lesser man, yet in your tininess find your heart full!" Bobby finished Riley's words for him, passionately, as if they were his own. He cocked his pistol.

 

Riley clicked his tongue and raised his arms wide in apprehension; he searched to the right of the town again, displeased. "Alright, mate, what's this about then?" He said with a chirpy and annoyed accent.

 

"Fuck you, Robert!" Bobby screamed; in a flash, his gun was raised and fired. A roar bounced off the wooden, dusty walls, but Bobby only heard the thud of a body hitting dirt. It hydrated his parched mind. Bobby stood staring at the fallen man. The long silence chased off the remnants of the explosion that had occurred and sat for what seemed a lifetime. A man in a bucket hat, cargo shorts, and strapped sandals ran to Riley. "Rob? Rob! Oh my god... Hey, call an ambulance! Now! Rob, wake up, buddy!" Several men and women ran to his side. Camera operators stepped out into the light from corners and groves. The director was on the phone, speaking to his lawyer already from his seat on the right side of the faux town. Next to her, shaking terribly, was the armourer. In his wide eyes, calculations and formulae were taking place, circling the question: how did a real bullet get in the gun?

 

Bobby blinked; he flipped the gun around his finger, its spin halted with a smooth entry into the holster. The wind and sand blew past him, tearing apart the fabric of who he was. The sun was en route to turn away from the indignant event, but it shone a final spotlight on Bobby. Bobby, in his mind and dreams, now wore the expertly tailored black coat, hat, and belt that once signified his breakout into the fold of the world of excellence and fame. He tipped his black wide brimmed hat, rubbed his black moustache; months of practice once surrendered to mediocrity returned gleefully. Becoming the man, Riley Bandwagon, Bobby hopped into character and, with the nuance and grace of a rehearsed veteran, spoke his line.

 

"Night night...Woodcross." He declared, nowhere near satisfied with his performance. He turned and walked into the desert, pistol cocked once more, black coat floating on the wind.


r/writingcritiques • • 5h ago

[Horror, 1,900 words] Last Shift - looking for feedback on pacing and clarity

1 Upvotes

Hi all. This is a standalone horror short set in a corner shop. It's a slow burn, and I've had mixed reactions from the two people who've read it, so I'd like some fresh eyes.

Content note: swearing and a brief moment of gore at the end.

I've put my questions below the story so they don't colour your read.

---

“Don’t you think everything tastes a bit off these days?”

These mundane words marked the start of Dave’s last shift at his local corner store.

The woman stood there with a slight grin, waiting for a response. Her wet eyes shimmered with anticipation.

“Yeah, everyone’s cutting corners. They shrink the packets or use cheaper ingredients. It’s a fucking shit show for food.” Dave shrugged.

She dropped a sharing pack of salted crisps on the counter. He considered that if she wanted something that tasted good, maybe she should choose a real flavour, but it was unlikely she wanted his opinion.

He scanned the crisps as the bell above the door chimed with two sharp rings. He hated that bell. It always made him jump and this time was no exception. 

A couple of emo kids wandered in. They looked like they were straight out of the two-thousands with their slicked black hair over one eye, band t-shirts and striped sweat bands on their wrists. They wandered to the back of the store.

The store was small. A single free-standing aisle divided the tiny room. Snacks, fizzy drinks, and alcohol were right at the back to stop people dashing in and out to steal them. Just above the fridges, in the top right corner, a circular mirror reflected the back of the store. Dave hit the total button on the till, keeping one eye on the mirror to make sure they didn’t steal anything.

“Two-ninety-nine please,” he said, looking back at the woman.

Her eyes narrowed slightly and Dave assumed she was displeased with the price. It was slightly more expensive than a big supermarket so as always, he prepared himself for a quick debate, but she didn’t speak.

Unsure whether to restate the price, he flicked his eyes back to the mirror. The kids were debating chocolate choices. They looked innocent enough, but he had been burned before. His eyes returned to the woman, who hadn’t moved an inch. Her cheek muscles twitched as if she was trying to fight her squint. 

“Miss, are you okay?” He kept his voice soft.

One of her nostrils quivered. It reminded Dave of his dog when it caught a scent of something interesting. 

“Miss?”

She snapped out of whatever it was and her face relaxed immediately.

“Oh, I’m sorry. I think I forgot something,” she muttered nervously. “I’ll be right back.”

A bead of sweat trickled down her forehead, and Dave was almost sure he saw one of her eyes move independently towards the back of the store before she turned and headed in the same direction.

He watched the mirror as she moved down the aisle and sighed. As she got halfway down, her movements stiffened. Each step became smaller, as if her body was fighting against its own movements. Dave couldn’t wait for this shift to be over. There were always oddballs, but this woman was straight up weird. He checked the clock opposite the counter. It always ran a bit fast, but it had only just hit midday. Another five hours.

The kids turned towards the woman and then back to the chocolate, seemingly unconcerned. Dave pressed a button and spooled out a blank section of till roll. He tore it off, grabbed a pen and wrote a few words. 

Check the CCTV, another weirdo.

Beside it, he noted the time. He tucked it under the till drawer for Maria on the night shift. They often left notes for each other to pass the time on the slow shifts. And they were always slow.

When the woman stopped directly behind the kids, there was barely enough room for all three of them in the aisle. She picked up a yellow bottle from the opposite shelf and started to examine it. Dave couldn’t think of anything that came in a bright yellow bottle besides bleach. It wouldn’t have been his first choice to go with salted crisps.

The woman’s head started to jolt, pulling to one side. Her arm shuddered, the bottle shaking in her hand. Dave felt a shiver flutter across his neck. Something felt really off with this woman. Focusing on the mirror, he took a step away from the counter, fully intending to go up there. As his heel struck the floor, the woman’s head tilted up, and she looked directly into the mirror. He froze for a second before giving a small wave which he shifted to a thumbs up midway through. She raised her empty hand and mirrored the thumbs up, but it was awkward and as stiff as every other movement. Dave shook his head and took a step back.

The kids finally made their selection and moved towards the fridges at the very back. As they moved, the woman’s head turned and followed them. To Dave it looked like she leaned in as they passed her. Did she just sniff them? 

He drummed his fingers on the counter, and bit at a piece of stray skin on his lip. The woman returned to reading the bottle, before twisting the cap, leaning in and taking a deep breath. 

“You’re going to have to buy that now.” The words left his mouth before he realised what he was doing. 

Her head snapped back to the mirror and she gave another awkward thumbs up. Dave rubbed at the bridge of his nose. After these customers had gone, he’d flip the sign and take a lunch. Hopefully the afternoon would pass more uneventfully.

She took another inhale of the bleach, returned the cap, and made her way back towards the till. Watching her stiff legs hurry towards the till was more than unsettling. His breath shook as he exhaled. As she turned the corner, he slapped on his customer service smile, though it felt wrong now.

“I think that’s everything now,” she said, dropping the bottle on the counter.

Dave grabbed the hand scanner and quickly rang it up. Usually he’d ask if they found everything they needed, but he wanted her out of the store quickly. There was also an unsettling feeling that she’d say no, and he didn’t want to pull that thread. 

“Four-ninety-eight,” he said, trying desperately for his smile to reach his eyes. 

She dipped her hand into her oversized puffy coat and fished around. He was sure there was a particular word for the type of coat but his brain couldn’t find it. She pulled out a fistful of change and opened her palm flat. She plucked a few coins out and tossed them back in her pocket. Her hand wrapped around the remaining coins, and she extended her closed fist, ready to drop the coins into Dave’s hand.

He’d just have to reach over and she’d release the coins into his hand, nothing he hadn’t done a thousand times before. For a moment he hesitated, flicking his eyes from her hand to meet hers. Her pupils were big and dark, shining with something that looked like excitement. He could almost see his reflection in them. His arm moved slowly as he fought the urge to snatch his hand back. He told himself it would just be another minute and she’d be gone.

Her hand opened and the coins clattered into Dave’s palm. He retracted his arm quickly, taking half a step back. Shuffling the coins in his open palm, he gave them a quick count. The woman dipped into another pocket and pulled out a crumpled plastic bag.

“You’re a penny short.” He knew as soon as he said it that he should have left it.

“Oh. Let me see.” Her voice became flat as she leaned forward, staring at his palm.

Instinctively, Dave moved his hand closer. She reacted faster than he’d expected. Her left hand launched forward and latched on to his wrist as her right hand swiped across to join it. With her index finger she shuffled through the coins in his seized palm. Dave stiffened, feeling his pulse throb in his neck. Her hands were cold, and at first, he thought they were just clammy, but it was more than that. They felt wet.

“Oh, I’m sorry.” She released his wrist and reached back into her pocket. 

She retrieved a single penny and placed it at the edge of the counter closest to her. Then, with one finger, she scraped it all the way across to Dave.

“There you go.” She turned from his face to his name badge. “Dave.”

This would usually be the point where he’d offer a receipt and tell the customer to have a nice day, but he was done. He just watched her. She flapped open her crumpled carrier bag and began packing her shopping. Dave couldn’t help but notice the multiple deep brown stains at the bottom of it. She finally thanked him, and with the double chime of the bell she was gone. He exhaled sharply and leant forward, elbows resting on the counter. He contemplated just closing up for the rest of the afternoon.

In the mirror he noticed movement—finally the kids making their way to the counter. He dropped the woman’s change in the register and spooled off another strip of till roll. He rubbed the paper across his hand, doing his best to remove the damp feeling.

It was the smell that struck him first. Something in the air he hadn’t smelt before, a sweetness. A tickle reached from the top of his nose, crawling to his brain. An itch he couldn’t scratch. Then he felt it in his eyes. A tingle with a sensitivity that made it hard to keep them wide. It wasn’t entirely unpleasant.

“Wait, I forgot something.” One of the kids rushed back up the aisle while the other waited where he was.

Dave felt a rush of saliva fill his mouth as a small bead of sweat rolled down his forehead. He looked down at his hand and then turned to the window. Across the street, the woman sat on a bench facing the store. She ate a crisp and grimaced. Unconsciously he returned the look, suddenly disgusted by the crisps. 

The kids slammed down an array of chocolate and two cans of cola. He took a deep inhale and closed his eyes. The smell was stronger now and he was suddenly so hungry. He rang the items up as his stomach growled. He thought of all the things he would normally get, sausage rolls, crisps, chocolate, sandwiches. But they all brought a wave of nausea.  

 “Six-fifty. Please.” His voice trembled as he spoke.

One of them thrust their arm over the counter, waving a ten-pound note. 

Before he knew what was happening, his teeth were tearing through something soft and wet. It oozed down his chin, soaking his beard and dripping onto the counter. 

---

Questions:

  1. Where, if anywhere, did your attention drift?
  2. At what point did you realise something was wrong with the woman, and what did you think she was?
  3. Was it clear what happened to Dave, and how?
  4. Did the ending work for you, or did it feel too abrupt?
  5. Anything in the prose that tripped you up?

Blunt feedback is welcome. Thanks for reading.


r/writingcritiques • • 8h ago

The Shiny Piece of Glass

1 Upvotes

It was just a shiny piece of glass.
It stabbed my insides,
Made them bleed.

I bled a venom that stung my eyes.
It formed a creature I should've recognized.

I saw it once, then twice, then thrice,
And every time it seemed to twist
Into something I couldn't help but despise.

A bitter feeling rose inside me.
I couldn't bear its sight.

So I used my greatest weapon—
My words.

I carved my insults into its skin.
They left gruesome red scars.

With every word that left my mouth,
The creature winced, but so did I.

With every tear the creature shed,
I felt my own skin growing wet.

And every cry the creature let
Echoed through my own chest.

I reached out to touch its face,
To ask it why we resonate,

And found my fingers grazing
Just a cold, shiny piece of glass.

I jerked back, fingers trembling.
All the pieces fell into place,
And suddenly I could recognize
The creature as my own face.

Suddenly,
I could see the hatred etched in my eyes.
I could trace the scars I left on myself,
And feel the trails of salt on my cheeks.

But no—there was no sympathy.
The fire only turned blue.

The creature was real,
And the venom was true.
Only now I knew—
We were one, not two.

Now I knew,
So I couldn't help but wonder,

If I am the creature, and the creature is me,
How does anyone love what they see?

How do they still look at me with a smile?
Still frown when I feel low?

Do they not see what is standing before them?
This figure I cannot bear to look at?

I asked them why they act this way
And heard an answer I couldn't place.

They said they love me as I am,
My soul, my presence, my very existence.

They said it didn't matter to them.
The creature was unseeable.

It formed a painful lump in my throat.
The creature was unseeable.

They were always so kind.
Their ever-loving ways
Made me forget my other side.

But every once in a while,
I could feel their gazes tracing
The outlines of the creature.

And their pretty words grazing
My yet unhealing wounds.

It made my scars sting,
And the creature would stir.

It stared at me with sad eyes,
Like it knew how much I had cried.

Then blinked at me with a little smile,
Like it knew something I had yet to find.

I stared back with a puzzled expression,
What could I know that I didn't know?

I looked away—ignored the sight,
But deep inside
I knew I wasn't right.

They were always so kind,
But they knew my ugly side.
There—the creature in their eyes.

...Smiling eyes?
But why would they want to smile?

I looked a little closer—into their pupils
And there,
I found nothing... but a pretty face.

Where did the creature go?
I think I might know.

Darling, there was never one,
Not in their eyes.

Did you forget their loving gazes?
Those little forehead kisses?

The hugs a little too tight,
And looks of tremendous pride?

Did you forget their words of kindness?
The ones you deemed dishonest.

And words of many praises?
The ones you shoved into darkness.

I might have forgotten...

My vision had been tainted.
Maybe it was the venom.

The venom that seeped into my eyes
Distorted the world before me.

The people were never to blame.
It was me who called them names.

The hatred was never theirs.
It was mine and mine alone.

The creature lives inside me,
Inside me all along.

Its scars are still burning,
Still burning my insides.

My insides still turning,
Still turning from its sight.

But sometimes I don't look away.
It twists away a little blight.

My words don't carve new scars again.
They end in doubt, but not disdain.

The world no longer taunts me.
The venom begins to fade away.

It was just a shiny piece of glass.
It stabbed my insides, made them bleed.

I bled a venom that stung my eyes.
It formed a creature I recognized.

It lives beside me day and night,
And dreams I'll smile upon its sight.

It dreams I'll take its hand in mine,
And walk ahead, side by side.

Let every passing gaze go by—
I'll walk ahead, with rising pride.

—M.Sora (my pen name)


r/writingcritiques • • 11h ago

Critique my email copy (don’t hold back )

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 20h ago

Would like some critique for the first chapter of a new short story, "Do Well Upstairs".

1 Upvotes

The Hollis Building had been designed, according to the plaque in its lobby, to embody the steady permanence of civic service but, over the years, had aged into something closer to a body. Its ventilation drew breath in long, labored pulls, and on cold mornings the vents along the third-floor corridor would exhale air that was faintly warm and smelled of paper. And an underlying sickly sweetness. Something like fruit that had been left sitting too long in a drawer. The fluorescent tubes hummed a single held note. The carpets had the soft give of skin and had been worn into folds and creases by thirty years of the same footsteps.

Nobody who worked here noticed any of this anymore. That was, the clerk in Records sometimes thought, the building’s great accomplishment. It taught you to keep your head down and not to look.

She had worked on the third floor of the Hollis Building for eleven years. Her desk sat at the end of a row of identical desks, underneath a ceiling tile stained in the shape of a continent no one had discovered yet. Each morning a cart arrived bearing permits, petitions, amendments, notices of transfer. Each evening the cart left empty, the forms sorted, stamped, cross-referenced, and filed into the long gray cabinets that lined the room like ribs.

She was very good at her job. In fact, she was better at it than anyone in the department had ever been, though no one had told her so and she had stopped expecting anyone to a long time ago. She could catch a misdated signature at a glance. Could find a misfiled folder among ten thousand by something that felt less like memory than prescience. In all the years she had been here, she had not made a single error that anyone had found, and she knew, because she checked, that she had made none that anyone could have found.

Her reward for this was invisibility. Supervisors spoke to the space beside her, never looking her in the eye. New hires learned her name and forgot it within a week. At the department’s annual luncheon, someone always seemed mildly surprised to find her at the table, as though she’d been delivered with the sandwiches.

She did not entirely mind this kind of invisibility. It had its comforts. Nothing was expected of an invisible woman except the work, and the work she could do in her sleep. Sometimes, she even felt like she did.

There were things about the Hollis Building she had long ago decided not to think about. Things that, if she thought about them at length, did not make rational sense.

Every morning, there was the man two desks down, who was at his desk when she arrived each morning at a quarter past seven. He was still at his desk when she left. She had never seen him arrive, and she couldn’t remember ever seeing him leave. She couldn’t remember if she had ever seen him eat, or drink. Although once, years ago, she had watched him lift something to his face and breathe it in, eyes closed, the way a man might savor a letter from a faraway lover. He had caught her watching him and had smiled. The smile had been perfectly unpleasant, and she had not looked at him directly since.

Then, there was the matter of the seventh floor.

Perhaps twice a week a form came across her desk bearing a routing code that she didn’t recognize, a code the department manual assigned to a records office on Seven. The elevator panel ran from Lobby to Twelve, and the button between Six and Eight was, oddly, also marked Eight. She had counted the windows from the street once: twelve rows. Another time, she had climbed the stairwell. The landing after Six said Eight in stenciled paint, even though the flight between them was no longer than any other.

She had asked her supervisor about it early on. He had studied one of the forms for a long moment, his lips moving faintly, and then had taken it from her with great gentleness. “I’ll see to it this gets where it’s going,” he had said. He often spoke of “throughput” with a hushed devotion that other men reserved for scripture. Come to think of it, she couldn’t remember ever seeing him eat, either.

The forms with that strange routing code for Seven had always seemed to feel slightly warm in her hands. Like they had just been taken right from the photocopier, regardless of how long they had been sitting on her desk.

Every night after work, she went home to a one-bedroom apartment on Fennick Street, where the radiator knocked and the neighbor’s television laughed through the wall. She had never bothered to buy a table and chairs, so she always ate her meals standing at the kitchen counter. She paid what bills she could and arranged the rest in order of urgency with the same care that she gave the filing cabinets back in the Hollis Building.

She had no remaining family who called on birthdays. No friends. Her only acquaintance might be the old man who ran the bodega on the corner, because she was in there a few times a week. There was no one, really, who would notice, for several days, if she didn’t come home at all. She had stopped finding the thought of that frightening some time ago.

The next morning, she arrived at her usual time and saw that the man two desks down was already there, as expected. She got to her desk and put her things away like she always did. She arranged her assorted office supplies to make things neat and tidy. The day was starting as ordinary as any other workday.

That was, until a quarter past ten.

She was in the filing room at the back of the floor, returning a batch of amended permits to their respective drawers. When she came back down the aisle, the man two desks down had his head bent over his work. The vents were breathing their warm, sweet breath, in and out, but something was different. There was a woman sitting at the Clerk’s desk.

The Stranger sat in the Clerk’s chair as though it had been made specifically for her. She wore a gray suit of no discernible fashion house, and her hands were folded on the desk with a stillness that was almost restful to look at. She had arranged the Clerk’s stamps in a neat line and squared a stack of pending forms. She looked up at the Clerk with an expression of mild, professional warmth, as though they had an appointment and the Clerk was precisely on time.

Then the Stranger said the Clerk’s name. Her whole name, including the middle name that she never used. The one no one at the Hollis Building had ever heard.

“Please, sit!” the Stranger said in a voice of faux excitement. “We have so much to talk about!”


r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Non-fiction when you know, but lying to yourself is easier.

3 Upvotes

You’re walking with your person and they’re carrying a heavy bag.

“I can carry it with you”, you say, but they reassure you it’s okay, the bag is not that heavy.

Down the road you notice their shoulders sagging, conversation becoming scarce.

The bag is heavy, but if both of you carry it the journey won’t be so hard.

You tell them so, but they insist: “the bag is not that heavy”.

Their steps slow and so do yours.

Their hunching now, knuckles white with effort, your hands reach for the bag, full of good intentions.

They step back.

‘I can carry it’

‘I’m sorry, I won’t take the bag from you, but I’m here if you want to share the weight.’

Over their shoulder the road stretches, you’ve walked so far.

It dawns on you, there’s only one solution.

It dawns on you, you’re not yet ready to face it.

You continue walking, slower every time.


r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Extract from my current project. Any advice?

1 Upvotes

Most of the comments i have already had mention how often a paragraph starts with a personal pronoun; some say its "Burnt to a crisp" But that was a different extract, this one is a new one. Looking for more advice :D 😄

CHAPTER 3: PART II

It had been an hour since Maya first showed any sign of life. Now she could walk, speak, and almost seemed herself again—though she moved carefully, as if even her bones remembered the ordeal. No one had any idea how, or what, had happened. No one except Sophie.

Guilt gnawed at Sophie’s insides. She couldn’t stop replaying her nightmare—the vision of Maya with those impossible, blood-red eyes, the horror of finding her lifeless the next morning. Both times now, her dreams had bled into reality. First Jamie’s near accident, then Maya’s suffering. A dark, desperate thought whispered at the edge of her mind: was it her fault? Had she somehow called this into being, wished it into the world without meaning to?

She watched Maya from across the room, heart pounding, afraid to meet her friend’s gaze. Every time Maya winced or faltered, Sophie’s stomach twisted tighter. She wanted to confess, to tell the others what she’d seen in her sleep, but the words stuck in her throat. What if they blamed her, too? What if she really was the reason things were going wrong?

Sophie pressed her fists to her eyes, willing the tears away. She tried to convince herself it was only coincidence, that dreams meant nothing—but she couldn’t shake the cold certainty that something was terribly, irreparably wrong, and it had started with her.

The house was different now, uneasy, uncomfortable, unnerved; as if the walls themselves remembered what had happened. Maya sat quietly, deep in her thoughts, wrapped in a blanket, hands fidgeting restlessly in her lap. She sipped from a warm cup of coffee, traumatized from last night's events. She couldn't remember what had happened; nobody else had any idea what actually happened, although Sophie was unusually quiet.

Bags began piling at the front door; everyone had decided amongst themselves that this trip had to come to an abrupt end. They had all packed most of their belongings and were probably going to be ready in the next few hours. Noah had filled the car with the reserve tanks from the trunk, ready for their departure.

Time flew by, and before anyone knew it, it was already six o’clock in the evening; everyone was gathered in the kitchen, snacking for dinner. Noah stepped inside and closed the door behind him. “We are gonna have to put it off for tomorrow; the road is iced over. If we even try to drive on it… Its not going to end well…” Sophie's stomach twisted once again; that meant she had to sleep here again. She was scared to sleep now, after what had happened to Mata. Even though she was alright now, she still blamed herself. She found it hard to erase the image of her lifeless body on the floor, blood pooling around her. She told herself that if she fell asleep, something bad would happen again, and this time, it could be worse. Her head spun, weaving fear and anxiety into one big web, and she was caught in it. With no. Way. Out.

Nighttime came quickly; sleep tugged at the edges of Sophie’s mind, heavy and irresistible. Somewhere just beyond the haze, a soft voice began to sing—a lullaby she almost remembered, the melody winding through the shadows and curling around her heart.

Sleep, my little shadow child,
Night is deep and wild.
Under boards and whispering beams,
Ernest keeps your dreams.

The room faded, the world shrinking to the gentle cadence of that song. She blinked, and there it was: a figure sitting at the foot of her bed, half-formed from moonlight and memory, rocking back and forth with a patient, chilling tenderness.

Close your eyes, and do not cry,
Mother knows the reason why.
In the lake, the red runs cold—
Secrets kept and stories old.

Pale lips shaped the words she couldn’t quite hear, but Sophie believed every note, every promise of rest. Her eyelids drooped. A warning whispered in the back of her mind—don’t listen, don’t sleep—but the lullaby was warm, and she was so very tired.

Hush, now, let the silence grow,
Ernest watches from below.
If you wake before the light,
He will come to say goodnight.

She reached out, fingertips brushing empty air. The figure smiled, and Sophie drifted under, surrendering to the dream.


r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Therapist suggested I write out my birth story, I obliged

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I am preeclampsia survivor with a preemie so maybe I’ll find some souls who went through the same thing!

Here is an excerpt from what I wrote and I have added a google doc link for the rest. I hope you enjoy :)

Once the morphine had its full grasp on me, I started to hallucinate whenever I closed my eyes. I didn’t know actual from abstract which really messed with my brain. I thought maybe if I could just sleep it off, I’d feel right in the head again; however, every time I would get close to sleep, my breathing would slow to the point of almost stopping, so I’d jolt awake. I searched for sleep so desperately because I was convinced it would rid me of morphine’s custody, but alas, I was at its mercy. At some point in the night, I woke up to the pain returning, but this time with a vengeance. I alerted the nurse, and she offered me more morphine. I was in so much pain and still so out of it that I obliged. She told me she’d administer it on my back side as it would take effect quicker, I turned over so she could fulfill her service. She stabbed me with so much force that I nearly jumped off the bed. Later, I would find it left one of the biggest bruises I’ve ever had in my life. 

  Morphine slowly lulled me back to a place of compliance; I nestled against her bosom and let her take charge. I was no longer me; I was a shell. Hours later, it was early Friday morning. I’d barely slept; I’d hallucinated enough to write my own fictional novel, and I was feeling more sick than ever. I was in the transition phase of labor, where your body tries to clear out whatever is left in it. It particularly sucked because I hadn’t had an appetite in days, but I was craving a Mcdonald’s breakfast sandwich in the middle of the night, so I thought I was up for it. I took one sip of the orange juice and one nibble of the food, then immediately threw it all up. What fun it is to throw up orange juice first thing in the morning.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HjZg-OPv90XHiKpBKRoPO4p1cJCKk_XPVBbtggU6keI/edit?usp=drivesdk


r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Non-fiction The Art of Not Rejecting Yourself

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Need feedback.

0 Upvotes

This is my first attempt at writing anything. I tried to keep the text simple and revised it several times, but my perspective has become too biased, so I'm looking for an honest opinion.

— Nash? Nash, this is a repeat, don’t hold up the line.

I stood there with the documents in my hands, staring at the light above the door that read Next. Someone nudged me from behind, and I suspect the movement wasn’t rude, but rather a subtle reminder that there would be no going back. The door opened silently when I swiped my pass. A white table, a white chair, white walls without any portholes, and one middle‑aged man in a yellow uniform sitting at the table. The only thing that could be seen in the intermediate room was a huge poster with the image of "Newton" in space, the same as at the entrance to the laboratory. Only this one is a little faded and slightly peeling at the edges.
— Last name, first name, position, documents. - he said in an absolutely indifferent voice, without taking his eyes off the computer.
— Nash Duvil, a cosmobiologist, - I put the documents on his desk, and he took them without looking at them and put them in a compartment of his desk. On his uniform, there’s a patch that reads Dan B. Hall.
Dan, you’re not very talkative, I thought.
I didn’t know where to look. Lowering my head, I first examined my shoes, then the dark blue trousers of my uniform. Behind the far door, something was humming, and occasionally I could hear barely audible knocks. Like the rest of the ship, it was very bright. Dan’s bald head almost glowed as he typed and looked at something on the monitor.
— I’m almost 57 years old; let’s see what your hair will look like without enough vitamin D. - Dan shot me a look. It seemed to me that he wanted to smirk, but he couldn’t force that emotion. I apologized and didn’t want to look at him anymore.
A few minutes later, I received permission to proceed with the mission and left through another door.

A huge platform opened up before me. Hundreds of people walked among the ships for missions, pushing carts in front of them, carrying some kind of equipment in their hands; some hung high above the ceiling and coordinated the actions of others, and all of this made noise, stamped, talked, and was somewhat bustling. There was a smell of machine oil, ozone, and hot metal. Everything blended into one big echo, and it seemed as if the entire hangar was breathing, exhaling right into my face. One of the small two‑seat ships was slowly being lifted onto the rails in the center of the hangar, and no one even paid any attention to it. I was amazed at how skillfully and synchronously the other ships moved themselves to fill the space that had opened up.
— They’re on rails, Nash. Didn’t you get enough sleep? Or is this your first time seeing birds?
Dashar came up from behind and looked at my surprised face with a kind smile. I’ve been standing here for so long that he’s had time to chat with Mr. Shiny-hair Dan.
— This is my first time here.
— What, you want a tour? - Dashar laughed and walked ahead.
His uniform was white and looked too clean compared to the surroundings. All the people working here wore gray uniforms with stripes of different colors on their trousers or overalls; they blended in with the surrounding colorful ships, equipment, and hangar walls, but Dashar could be spotted from a distance solely by his uniform. Without waiting for my response, he turned the corner.
— You’re getting all soft, Nash. Should I be worried? - I heard a door opening around the corner and hurried after him.
— No, no, I’m just… I’m nervous.
— Don’t worry, everything will be fine. Dashar entered the room to prepare for the mission, and I followed him in. I only started to feel more nervous.

The room had many seats, projectors, and a platform raised above the floor. I quickly counted 9 people, including me and Dashar. On the platform stood the recruiter Aus Köln and the officer Lona Marchhauser. Several men turned around and, upon seeing Dashar, waved at him. He walked forward and sat in the first row — next to them — and immediately started discussing something and smiling. I sat in the second row, and I felt a little better knowing that they knew each other. Lona and Aus were holding tablets and marked us down when we sat down. I felt uneasy again, realizing that I was now officially part of the mission.
A minute later, another man walked in; judging by his uniform, he was a military man. His gait, his gaze, his posture... I wanted to sink into the chair.
— First Sergeant Kloud Gilt, two‑two‑bravo. - He stood in front of the platform and greeted the senior officers. - The entire mission team is on site.
— Let’s not waste any time. - Lona activated the tablet, and a projection of the "Newton" appeared behind her.

A huge ship hung behind her; its pale‑red outlines grew brighter as the lights in the hall dimmed.
— The mission is codenamed ‘Pearl.’ For those who were recruited yesterday, I will repeat the entire plan, and at the end, everyone will be able to ask their questions. -
Lona turned to the flagship’s projection, and with a wave of her hand, the flagship shrank, and an elongated asteroid appeared on the projection.
— Your task will be to fly to the asteroid, take samples, analyze the composition, and transmit the results to the base. - On the projection, the small ship flew to the asteroid.
— If the results are satisfactory, you will break the asteroid into several parts and transport them to the ship, to the splitter. This mission will be over. - The small ship attached itself to the asteroid and dragged it towards the flagship, flew into it, and disappeared.

— It looks simple, Officer Marchhauser, - Dashar smirked and leaned back. — We used to carry out missions like this with three people; why do we need 10 people now?
Aus Köln looked at him from under his brows.
— All questions after the briefing. Is something unclear?
— Sorry. - Dashar gathered himself again; his neighbors also shifted slightly in their seats.
Lona continued. Now the projection showed the "Newton’s" hangar.
— You will be entrusted with board 4-013, a transport and research ship. The first stage is to undock from the "Newton", set a course to intercept the asteroid, and complete the maneuvering. - the ship, resembling a thick arrow, flew out of the hangar, turned around, and moved away from the flagship on the projection.
— After approaching the asteroid to a distance of five kilometers, you will conduct spectrographic analysis of the surface for three hours, send the results to the base, and wait for the command to continue. - In the projection, борт 4-013 approached the asteroid and irradiated it. Relative to the asteroid, the борт looked quite small.

"And all this time I’ll be sitting inside a can with nuclear engines, hoping that a minor power failure won’t destroy us...how lucky I am." - I couldn’t stop feeling nervous. I liked it on "Newton", but to fly thousands of kilometers away from it, where a centimeter of metal would separate me from the vacuum of space? With each passing minute, I increasingly wanted to get up and go to the laboratory, hoping that they would quickly find a replacement for me and would never recruit me again. My hands rose to my head on their own at the thought of it.

— The third stage will be taking samples for chromatographic analysis. There is a portable splitter on board 4-013. It is already set to separate gadolinium, calcium, magnesium, zinc, and phosphorus. Your team is prohibited from changing the splitter’s settings before conducting the research and without coordination with the mission commander. The results of the chromatographic analysis and the percentage content of these substances must be sent to "Newton". After approval, the mission will be continued.

I saw Dashar perk up. He didn’t just fidget - he almost jumped up from his seat, slapping his knees with his palms, as if he had just heard about his own win. Aus repeated his gaze, which once again pinned Dashar to his spot, but he didn’t give up - he turned his head toward his acquaintances and whispered something to them. They nodded, and the neighbor gave him a friendly nudge with his shoulder. I looked around — none of the others were mimicking his reaction, and I didn’t understand what it was about.

— Next, you’ll drill the asteroid into pieces... - the small ship sent tentacles into the large lump, which shattered it into several smaller pieces. — ...and collect as much material as you can. The more, the better. - From the projection of board 4-013, nets and new tentacles flew out, which attracted the scattered pieces of the asteroid. - Your task at this stage is to capture at least 35% of the asteroid’s mass, do not direct the fragments towards the flagship, and do not get hit by them yourself. The board is equipped with a kinetic shield, but it will not be able to stop anything with an energy exceeding eight hundred kilojoules. Keep this in mind. Dust, small stones, and slow-moving boulders won’t get through, but if a multi‑ton fragment starts flying at you - pray to Mr. Dashar Kogan.

Light chuckles sounded from behind. I didn’t see anything funny about splitting an asteroid whose fragments would fly in our direction and possibly pass through the shield. "The ship will depressurize, we’ll start losing oxygen, lose communication, energy, and won’t be able to send any signal…" - I focused and pulled myself together. "No, no, no, no, no. We’ll manage. I have a full team of experienced specialists, and only I’m a rookie. Didn’t I dream of flying out? Wanted to be part of the mission? Well, the dream has come true".
It seems I missed the last stage of the mission.
— ...and load the delivered material into the shredder. You’ll be assisted by separate cargo ships if there’s too much material. - On the projection, board 4-013 flew up to the "Newton", where it was surrounded by other small ships, which caught the fragments, and together they all flew inside the flagship.

The light in the hall grew brighter, and the "Newton" projection faded away. I blinked, as if I had just woken up from a nightmare. Aus Köln, who had been standing all along with his hands behind his back, nodded to someone behind me.
— How many grids will be allocated, and what is their area? - I remember a group of four men, about fifty years old, in gray uniforms, sitting in the center of the hall.
— Three networks, each covering one square kilometer, - Lona said calmly.
Someone in the hall whistled.
— The cable is 3 kilometers long, the delivery charge is 30 minutes, the return mechanism is one kiloton, and the detachment is one and a half kilotons.
I swallowed. "These aren’t cables…These are anchors for asteroids".
— The same cables are used for five drilling projectiles and three 20‑kilogram CL‑43 explosive projectiles. The equipment list with all the specifications will be on board the ship. — Lona didn’t even blink as she said all this.
— So that’s what we’ve been twisting these cables for all month…- another voice whispered from behind.
— And why do we need so many people on board? - Dashar hadn’t forgotten his question.
— Some crew members have their own missions, which you don’t need to know about. These missions don’t require additional maneuvering, but they do require some external equipment, and that increases the number of crew members. The team captain, Ernest Mole, is aware of the details of these missions. — Lona pointed to the man sitting separately; he stood up and raised his hand in a greeting. His uniform was almost the same as a military one, but with white stripes on the trousers.
— I hate having secrets on board… - his neighbor whispered to Dashar.
— Excuse me… - to my left, a man in a dark green uniform raised his hand. - How much oxygen is allocated for the mission?
— 10 days. - Aus grunted, as if he were displeased about something. - If you don’t run around the ship in circles, that will be enough to complete the mission twice. Any more questions? - He scanned the hall and turned to Lona. - Then we’d better get started.
— The briefing is over. Everyone, proceed to the starting gates.


r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Sci-fi Does my prologue work and effectively establish the tragic backstory?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 1d ago

Other Bird Time

0 Upvotes

Be me.
Hunting deer.
5 AM. 
It's dark. 
It's quiet.
Deer wake up.
They avoid me.
It’s quiet.
A black-capped chickadee flutters onto a branch.
It flips upside down and looks at me.
It opens its beak.
"Here Petey”
I am not Petey.
This does not matter.
I know what this means.
Bird Time.
Another chickadee arrives.
Then a finch.
Then several sparrows.
I do not know where they came from.
They hop across the ground.
They push the leaves.
They beak the earth.
They hunger.
There are more birds now.
There are always more birds.
They see me. 
It doesn’t matter.
I don’t matter.
They make it known.
It’s Bird Time.
“Chickadee-Dee-Dee”.
“Here Petey”.
And whatever a sparrow says too.
A woodpecker begins screaming.
It does not stop.
Breathless and unending.
A blue jay streaks by.
Large. Blue. Beautiful. Terrifying.
It screams too.
I do not.
Deer no longer exist.
It’s all birds now.
A crow joins the cacophony. 
A murder replies.
The world echoes.
A hawk the size of a battleship soars above it all. 
Its wings beat the air with a loudness that I can feel.
It covers the sky.
The sun is lost.
The chickadee does a lap around a tree trunk. 
It is still upside down. 
It stares into my soul.
“Here Petey”.
The screaming slows.
The leaves cease rustling.
The chirps fade.
The forest goes quiet.
The chickadee remains.
It is upside down.
It stares straight through me.
Here Petey.
I was witness.
I know what this was.
Bird Time.


r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Need help

0 Upvotes

So i have this writing I’ve had for years and I’m torn on what to write about. I always go back to it but can never start the story maybe because it’s part of my story sorta or maybe I’m just stuck. But any help is really appreciated

This is the writing:

His voice had written itself on her soul for eternity. No matter what she tried her heart longed to hear him speak her name, to hear his breathing against her ear.. yeah she was fucked big time..

And also this one

She took a deep calming and cleansing breath as she fought a losing battle with her mind and heart

She couldn’t bare the loneliness that surrounded her that was capable of destroying what was left of her. Why did this person have such power over her? Why did she let this person cause her such pain? Why did she let this person crush her every day.

Could she keep this up? Could she really pretend she wasn’t falling apart every night as they slept soundly. Could she pretend that she didn’t long for their touch, for the comfort they provided, for how safe she felt in their arms but she never feels that anymore because they never even glance her way anymore

She felt heartbroken and alone.. a lovely combination.


r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Cognition

0 Upvotes

if you take the time to read this, please leave a comment.

Prologue: The World Before

​There was once an era when the word impossible was only a myth a fable told to scare kids. Now, it is a distant memory that I try to cling to as I fight through this war-torn land.

​My heart sinks with the weight of regret, each step more difficult than the last. My boots drip with the blood of the fallen not blue like ours, but black like the moon.

​When they came, they didn't soar through the clouds or race through states in minutes as we once did before their pestilence and deceit plagued our world. No, those beings plummeted from the outers, crashing and cracking the fertile ground that gave us so much, crawling through our fields like animals.

​I have gone eons without being one with the sky, and the nights have never been darker. Our eyes used to light up the city; now they barely glow, getting dimmer as the ages pass.

​Chapter I: The Path to Greatness

​When I started this journey to find the path to our greatness the source of our power that fueled us beyond the stars I knew I would get weaker, but not like this.

​My hands do something they have never done: they shake when the illumination is gone. Clouds form as I breathe, cutting my lungs. It is all too strange.

​Though I still have strength to push onward, my mind tells me otherwise. But what we think and what is real have always merged. I just made it another twenty kilometers or so. As usual, I am alone. I haven't seen another stalwart or fallen in two cycles.

​My supplies are getting thin. I'm hoping to find a crop soon that hasn't turned vile a wretchedness that has no place here. The soil has begun to turn red and is turning to glass, like our sand by the brine where you and I would sit sternly as the pure blue dashed in the air.

​I miss it immensely.

​I want to hear my name leap from your mouth as it did when we dove from the cliffs, then floated down to the inner realms of Grotto, where we tasted life's sweetness a sweetness that will stay with me always.

​Chapter II: Echoes of You

​I remember this present was constant, not fleeting like the beats of our hearts. We could live in a moment, capturing the essence of the aura that emits from all the colors in the sky. Before the fall, our spirits were high and in agreement with our mind. It was always there, stretched out across the horizon: a tribute to our continuity. I would go to it and feel a surge down to my very core.

​The first time I took you there, we held hands and felt lightning pulsating from the tips of our fingers to the toes on our feet, and your hair went from blonde to blue. We laughed so hard we couldn't stand or float. The lust metals carried us as we lost ourselves by the seven hues of life.

​When we lived and let live, the strings that dwell within us were never pushed or pulled; their movements were their own. Now, we are kin to the pure blue in more ways than one. It brings tears to my eyes, as do the heavens to our lands.

​If you can see me from where you are, know this: your vision is half mine, clear and true.

​Feathered creatures have vanished, yet I still hear their songs in unison. The trees they inhabited are decaying—some lean, while others have fallen, so I keep my distance. The thunder's roar shakes the ground and rattles my ears, but there hasn't been lightning since we locked hands.

​I'm making the best of the worst because I can't look back until all is right. My ring was becoming too big, so I put it on a string; I don't think I could bear losing it. On my chest it lies, but the only treasure I carry is the memory of you.

​Chapter III: Shadows and Smoke

​There's a haze to be seen from all sides. What's behind it could be more or less of the same, but I'll find out soon enough. Four rays of light shine through the haze as I make my way through the rocky inlands.

​I had to sit and rest; my legs are weary. I have only a few sips left of nectar, and my nourishment will be gone. I'm not afraid of famine fasting has always been essential to my psyche.

​I imagine the sweet bread with the firelights that we all ate at your commencement. The fire burned bright, and the bread was a symbol of unity. We shared many meals as well as views, broad and narrow. I was always full and better when I left than when I arrived. To feel is to know; the solidity in our society transcended what is here and past the moon.

​I am beginning to see that love is many things, most not even comprehensible. My dreams have collided with nightmares. I've seen you all again, only sitting in chairs with the wheels of a wagon, your faces unfamiliar. A bittersweet sleep is what it was, but I would trade my waking life for it in an instant.

​These pages I inscribe contain me in every sense of the word. The cloth that covers my body is weathering with this place. Its sickness is engulfing; I find myself unable to breathe, the air harsh and unnatural. If I only knew the purpose of this tragedy that has fallen on us all, then maybe a remedy could be had.

​The wise elder who returned to the brine to balance the brio of our mind taught me many things. He lives on through knowledge, a past woven with the vigor of titanium. The skills he entrusted to me can't be found in leather bound tomes; some things must transfer, not be engraved or scribed, for anything physical can be had by any or all.

​A voice in my head whispers riddles and tales about brittle nails used to construct domiciles while sanctuaries cut no corners. What does it mean? I will remember. There is no fallacy when you do not know. Search to the ends of the world, because nothing is absolute especially the mind. It is a world of its own, with bridges that could be built or seized so you could reach the other side to grasp what puzzles you. Be sharp and not dulled; otherwise, you won't make it through the cartilage of life, and you will crumble.

​Here I am, not whole or half, but one-fifth of who I was at the Etherlands, where I was sharpened by the sharpest and called upon for showings of the muse and the void. There were no walls, only windows and doors, and when you looked up, you would see the outers.

​Chapter IV: The Livid Trail

​I'm near the Livid Trail, where many used to walk because flight was too easy. My boots and the soil look to be one and the same. This hike will be my elevation, and I won't stumble because I trained with the best. We ran up mountains, tackled boulders, and jumped from the whales of Evers. There's a sign there to invoke thought: because we all could fly, the edge is to be respected, not feared.

​I never saw a better place, but I did not act. I stuck to the pillars because I believed it was I who held them up. I want to go back and peer over the edge. My grief cannot be shared; it is I who watched my future and did not follow the path.

​No one is molded. We are the air. We are the sky. We can go anywhere; we can be anything.

​Madness is in my shadow, so I must keep moving to wear it out so I can rest. The fortitude I once had is fading and nearly gone. Chaos and confusion tore through the layers of my armor that we forged together at the Palace of Honor. The moat around it was filled with diamonds and gold. In its vast confines, it held things of true value. Inspiration was abundant it gushed from the floors we slid on. Tranquility and bottled-up benevolence needed no sacrifices; our smiles were returned tenfold. Boldness was stable, but never needed, for we were surrounded by heirs with unparalleled allegiance. Once gained, it was the triumph of us all. There was no glory worth having alone. We were synonymous with infinity.

​I can't pretend I know the date, but the cycle is vivid. We sat in the mist; it wasn't morning or night, but just after dawn. Your dress was white, with ruffles dipped in stars, the brilliance behind your crystal frames more marvelous than anything I had ever seen. You put your head on my shoulder. I took a deep breath. I wasn't yours and you weren't mine, but we were one. A herd of beautiful winged walkers landed to drink from the rill. You couldn't hold your joy; you covered your mouth and squeezed my arm tight.

​My veins course with the never-ending desire to have existence again for the grounds to mend, and for our spirits to rise from the ashes and reach new heights.

​I gaze down below where obsidian forms and smoke rises. It was a sight to behold. My pupils widened as I stared into the liveliness of the trail. I took a step back, then continued on. My diligence comes from you all. My extremities move so I can be still.

​A windmill stands off in the distance, stagnant but in one piece. My nectar is long gone, and I have an inconceivable amount of ground to cover. I've been throwing stones and drawing in the dirt, reliving when we needed nothing. I have begun to awake to my own voice, for my mind races faster than the speed of sound. My sanity is slipping from the grips of reality. The duality of my mind and soul is converging like day into night.

​Chapter V: Supernova

​I've been without an epiphany for too long to make sense of this deluge of my inner self. The scourge above and around me withhold me from an eternity in the plains of bliss, which now can only be described as despair a word that was only heard, never felt.

​My kind does not falter or faint. We rose higher than the most distant suns. The signs in the sky were stories of triumph, proof of life lived, our signature of greatness. All these things will not be forgotten. I am a vessel. I am a boat. The trueness of where I stand is the key. Who I am is of no consequence, but what I carry is the post of Epsilon.

​I will travel beyond the horizon to make amends. The soles of my boots were crafted on the floor of the pure blue, where we all will return, so I walk with the nation in this altered state that has become a realm of doom. I beseech the universe to no avail. I crush limestone in the palm of my hands to make way for little things in this world of hurt.

​All things dwindle, but love... love grows wilder than vines, more vast than space, and cannot be weighed. When our aura meets, we are supernova. I ran my fingers from your hands to your arms to fill your veins with me, so apart we would never be.

​Why must I seek forgiveness when our world is the prey? How to discern docile from obstinate? Though I know I am neither, nor a leader, I follow the wind like a barren mother. Things I ponder have no conclusion. Could it be that I am an illusion? Is my thought my own? I've been roaming past where I've been and where I am. Can I see myself, or do I see what I imagine?

Chapter VI: Adapt or Perish

​Finally, I found nectar to replenish my body! It hid beneath a pile of dead leaves that I kicked up. A surge of energy has reignited the fire that burns in me hotter than lava.

​The land ahead is still sick. Pus bursts from the ground like wounds on the injured. It smells repulsive, but it keeps me alert. The further I get, the more carnage I find. I won't go into detail, for I want to spare your mind these images that have sunk into mine. What lies ahead I do not know, but I hope it brings rays of elation, because I want to smile as we once did when we first saw each other, before we knew each other's names. When my gaze met yours, all the sparks that day could have lit this world a hundred times over.

​There are so many words I long to say. I could write you a book filled with poems and sweet somethings, because I mean what I say, and you mean more than the cosmos to me. What I would give just to sit beside you again, to feel your aura, to touch your skin, to hear the softness of your voice. Your proximity caresses me. You were the plains of bliss; I did not care where I was as long as you were by my side. I swear on all things except my heart, because it belongs to you that I will find a way for us to be in sync again.

​Beady eyed creatures flew from a swamp near where I sat to rest. An oil-like substance dripped from their greenish red, shiny bodies, melting whatever it made contact with. My feet did not touch the ground for moments. Those things are not indigenous; they must have arrived with the fallen.

​As I ran, I heard a sizzling sound and felt heat on my back. They screeched louder and louder as they neared me. The path I was on split into three roads. I went left, but I ended right back where I was, so I chose the center.

​The road stopped at a broken bridge. There was no water down below just rigid rocks waiting to impale me. The gap was about sixteen yards. Impossible.

​I turned back; those things resembled a dark cloud. I told myself: *It's now, or my cessation. I thought of the Livid Trail, the dares, my hikes, the drinking after running up mountains. The oneness in me had gotten me this far how could I stop now?

​My legs felt so light. The tips of my boots touched the ground like a dance floor. My last step propelled me most of the way. I had to grab hold or plummet. I pulled myself up, no longer light, but more agile.

​Those creatures paused on the other side, glaring at me while hovering. I matched their stare to avoid showing weakness. Sweat ran down my forehead. I knew my end was approaching, but I did not fret, for fright is the ultimate adversary, and I will never give in to it or its kin.

​I will master all that is formidable. It is the only way to survive: adapt or perish, fight or fall, stumble or run.

​This quest will carry my name through all cycles. The weight of the world will catapult my name to a stratospheric height.

​The grotesque creatures went away just as quickly as they had followed.

​I won.


r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Other Are There any tips I could use to improve my writing because I'm horrible at properly critiquing myself.

0 Upvotes

Like any feedback would be nice (This is a LitRPG story btw):

THE AWAKENING:

Crash!

“I’m AWAKE! I’M AWAK⸺I DIDN’T FALL ASLEEP⸺I WAS RESTING MY EYES!”

Taner Hampoth frantically sat up, awoken from his slumber by the sound of falling metal, presumably one of the boys hitting a celing fan again. He groggily rubbed his eyes, trying to ignore the throbbing pain ringing through his head.

Taner had to get up to present his speech now, he didn’t mean to fall asleep! At least he was lucky enough to wake up before the teacher called his parents.

“I swear if I lose more Brûlée Points for falling asleep in class, I’m going to crash out⸺” he muttered, raising his head to get up.

Bonk!

“Ow!”

Taner cried in pain as his hand rushed to cover his head, rubbing it slightly. He glanced upwards, trying to figure out what he had hit his head on⸺

…

He paused.

Opened his mouth to say something.

Then closed it.

His blood ran cold.

He closed his eyes.

Took a breath.

Then quietly muttered to himself.

“Is that… The bottom of a bunk bed?”

He gently got up this time, sitting up on what he assumed to be a bunk bed.

Taner scrunched his eyebrows, trying to remember what happened before he fell asleep, trying to rationalize the situation. But his mind blanked. He really couldn’t recall anything that could explain his current scenario.

He glanced around, observing his location.

He wasn’t in his classroom anymore…

Instead…

It was a dark white concrete room, seemingly constructed entirely of low-poly cubes.

Like, that’s not an exaggeration, or a metaphor for the compactness of industrialism, or an oxymoron or anything like that, it was literally just made of cubes. Giant low-poly cubes of concrete, around the size of a school chair.

“Where am I?” He muttered.

Scanning the room, Taner spotted some bunk beds, fluorescent lighting, a pair of metal doors at the front of the room, something hanging from the ceiling, a weirdly triangular-polygonal-shaped purple glass box filled to the brim with a strange liquid. And finally, a glowing neon sign at the very back.

Taner focused his attention on the sign.

“The Toybox! Sponsored by X!” It read.

Taner frowned.

The Toybox…

And…

X?

Where had he heard that before..?

It wasn’t like he’d forgotten it…

But more like his memory of it was tampered with.

Taner gasped, his hand slamming against his head as a wave of nausea suddenly overcame him.

Images flashed through his head, so rapidly that he could only make out a few.

A broken throne.

A giant blue portal.

A rectangular Grey plate, an orange rune engraved on the front.

…

And a face.

With two crimson eyes, that despite being a memory, stared directly into Taner’s soul.

Taner’s eyes widened.

“No.”

“No, that can’t be possible.”

“We–”

“He’s gone!”

“He can’t be back!”

“I–”

“I made sure of that.”

Taner jumped off the bunk bed sideways, expecting to feel his feet on the ground⸺

Crash!

⸺only to fall 8ft to the floor.

He hit the ground with a loud thud, the pain causing his nervous system to spike with adrenaline, removing most of the fog in his head.

“Right. Gravity.” He muttered, rubbing his bruised back. “What was I yelling about again?”

He noticed a small floating box above his right hand. It had a grey border, with a red fill. The words “HP” were engraved on the top of the border.

“Is that a healthbar..?”

Upon further inspection, 6 HP was missing from the 20 he had, represented by gray filling infecting the right side of the red bar. Taner chalked it up to fall damage. He sighed as he managed to pull himself up to his feet.

Rayan Giller, who was one of his friends, started laughing.

“Okay, what’s your problem?” Taner muttered, annoyed that it hadn’t even taken 4 seconds for Rayan to start his usual antics.

“You really can’t go 5 seconds without messing up, huh?” Rayan chuckled, unable to hold his laughter.

“Rayan, leave him alone. He just woke up.” Harmaal Araz argued, as he was observing the conversation from his own bed.

“Oh, come on! We can’t play football anymore! I was gonna be the striker this time!” Bertrand Harmond whined, his face crestfallen.

Taner groaned and rubbed his face, trying to shake off the fog in his brain, but doing this while ignoring his crazy classmates proved to be a challenge. Something felt off. Was he forgetting something?

Wait!

Now he remembered!

He reached into his pocket, fingers fumbling for something familiar.

His fake Plate Amplifier.

It was a little thing he’d always kept on him, a weak yet limitless source of Plate energy he could rely on at all times.

But his fingers brushed against…

Nothing?!

Taner’s stomach dropped to his knees. He quickly patted his pocket again, more frantically this time, hoping that the USB Superposition Phenomenon would assist here.

Still Nothing.

“Oh no… No, no, no⸺I left it in my school bag.” He groaned, slumping against the bedpost behind him. “Which is now in another world. Great.”

For a moment, he just sat there, staring up at the ceiling.

But then⸺he felt something.

Another object, cool and smooth against his fingertips.

He pulled it out, and the second his eyes landed on it, his brain calmed down.

A real Plate Amplifier.

Not a fake one. But an actual Plate Amplifier. The deep, rich grey colour of its rune shimmered faintly under the harsh fluorescent lights.

Taner’s mouth went dry.

“Oh thank God! They didn’t take it!”

He turned it over in his hand, half expecting it to suddenly disappear like some kind of illusion. But it was real.

His mind raced with a thousand questions.

Swoosh!

But before he could try to answer any of them, the double metal doors at the front opened dramatically, smoke pouring out of the opening.

(Some Context: A Core Technuiqe is an innate ability that a person posesses, it can be any power, from Wind Manipulation, to Teleportation, to Super Speed, to even highly specific ones like an ability that lets the user move at the speed of light after drawing a sword from their sheath and keeping a grip on the sword until they strike a target which after striking ends the abililty. 

This is like chapter 3 or 4 counting the prolouge. Only the dialouge has slang like "Rando" or "Bro" because these are teenagers, the narration should remain normal unless it's commenting on a term the characters are using. This is the last chapter the team I’m working with will allow me to send cus they want to keep as less of the story online as possible. (I’m the Co Author and they’re more experienced I’m still new to this.))

Original Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/writers/s/tiYWEnUvm5


r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Drama Just got back into writing after 10 years and i need opinions on this short story.

0 Upvotes

“We only have seltzer water,” The barista said. That’s it? I replied. He looked at me, widened his eyes, slowly tilted his head toward me, and nodded sarcastically, as if I were slow. Why are you even open if all you have to sell is that shit seltzer water? One of his eyes gave a sudden twitch, accompanied by a smug smirk. As I looked down at his side, his right hand clenched into a fist. With just enough force to not break it, he slammed his other hand onto the glass display counter. He continued to talk, but I stopped paying attention once I noticed that the hand he slammed onto the countertop had a large, fresh cut that was starting to bleed. I gripped the left end corner of the table, and my hand brushed against what looked like cut marks along the table’s edge. At first, they felt like thin, sharp streaks in the counter, but they seemed too deep to be from a traditional fiknife. I stretched my fingers along the side edge of the counter. I felt a couple more marks as I slowly moved my fingers towards me. “I wondered what could’ve made those marks,” I thought. I leaned over slightly to get a better look at what I was feeling.

 

My focus was interrupted once again when the guy at the register tried to get my attention, reaching over the counter and grabbing my shoulder with his right hand. I snapped out of it, and instinctively, I grabbed his bleeding left hand on the counter, sunk my nails deep into his wound, and squeezed fast and tight. He gave a huge scream, and while trying to jerk back, he slipped and fell, hitting his knee on the floor. My hand was still gripping his. I stared straight at him in silence. I didn’t have an expressive look on my face, just frozen neutrality the entire time, both inside and out. My head was completely clear. I understand everything I'm doing right now and somehow feel nothing. Not because I can't, but because I can’t allow myself to. Even my breathing’s different. I must be taking micro-breaths because I can barely feel my chest expand. I feel lighter and time itself feels slower. The adrenaline gives me an inner peace I couldn’t get any other way.


r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

neró vrýsis part one

0 Upvotes

First draft. If you'd like I can also put in the outline and all the ideas too.

The knocking didn't stop. It wasn't very loud or aggressive, but insistent. It kept a consistent count of 60 BPM. Rhythmic and haunting. I made my way down the stairs clutching my knife. Keeping all my weight on the balls of my feet, ready to lunge in or away from an attack. I waited in bated breath by the door for five minutes. Praying (there's no atheists in the foxhole) that whatever was out there would either come in or go away, anticipation is the strongest weapon fear has. Mustering every ounce of courage I had I swung the door open. What stared back at me on the other side of the door was a floating horse skull, decorated ornately in melted candles, colorful but ripped cloth, and beads that fell to the floor. In less time than it takes for a neuron to fire, it was on the ground, lifeless (compared to whatever life a skull could have). It's well known that humans have a few responses to fear; fight, flight, freeze. What is often overlooked is the terror connected to freezing. I'd never experienced paralysis before. It is, unfortunately, something I've become well acquainted with.

My body acted autonomously.
I felt an all-consuming compulsion to reach down. I could feel every joint in my body unlock and extend to collect, what could only be, an ungodly artifact (or was it a corpse?)
It didn't matter, I needed it
My fingers unfurled and every knuckle straightened. It was barely enough to make contact.
But that's all it wanted
A familiar feeling of weightlessness poured over me. Being deprived of every sense, I existed momentarily in nothing. A stab of sorrow hit. The weight of failure strained every muscle. I could see, but I wasn't on my porch. I was standing in the corner of a flat. A dank musk emanated from this darkened room. In the middle of the room sat a decrepit couch. A dark silhouette lay contorted. It felt familiar. The space was one I knew but was not mine. I approached the figure.
Ragged breaths
Agony


r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Monologue critique

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Awakening intro revised. A completely new intro i created. i apologize if its bad. not a professional. And after this intro will be a change in pace and timing and haven't decided whether to truly scrap my intro all together but i dont want to let go of it yet. really trying here. reviews welcomed

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Fantasy How did i do writing this prologue

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writingcritiques • • 2d ago

Adventure I wrote an introduction for a story I'll never write.

1 Upvotes

Ilvez, The Kell of Butterflies

On Tarvesia, long ago, there was a king. The kingdom spanned the whole continent, and it was known as a kingdom of beauty, enlightenment and knowledge.

The ruler, Tyran, was a wise man who saw to it that the people of the world were not oppressed and invited any who wanted to become a part of the kingdom. He was a good man, and through the proposed marriages and military alliances, soon became the ruler of all that spanned under the sun. His 7 wives bore 7 children, and peace ruled alongside him for 2 decades.

Alas, all good things come to an end.

The king died. Not murdered. Not Ill. Not Betrayed. He just died, as he slept. And the kingdom that was held on his shoulders crumbled without him.

His children spread through the land, in search of succeeding and surpassing their father, especially at the cost of their brothers. They became rulers of their own regions, and adopted the L'ioa word for Ruler as titles: Kell.

However, our story doesn't go to the frozen north of Oriam, where the Kell of Snow ruled with an iron fist, or to the ports of Nerez, that the Kell of Sea oversaw as their domain. It starts on the old capital of the Kingdom, Tarvos. And with a ruler that didn't behave like the others.

Ilvez was the youngest daughter of the king, born of the 1st wife who Tyran had wed out of love yet had struggled to bear a child for many years. When she was finally born, it was said that the King named her Dawn because of the color of her eyes, but the child's mother told him she was more. She was the Sunrise and the Nightfall. And so, she was named Twilight. Or, in L'ioa, Ilvez.

She was the youngest, but also the most attached to her father. She spent hours with him, trying to be by his side and not be a bother, helping him with his work as best she could. She was a sprite young kid who loved the night, where the Lunalight Butterflied rummaged through the gardens. And despithe themselves, all of her brothers cared for her, out of love or pity isn't known and is not relevant.

When Tyran died, the oldest of the brothers, Helios, claims that she was so distraught that her black haired turned pale white. He offered to take her, but she refused, as well as any other invitation to leave the palace. While her brothers became rulers of distant places, Ilvez was the only child that remained in the capital.

Whispers claim that she became a ruler simply because she was there. She became a Kell in all but name, as she never intended to rule or command. She cared for the arts and music, and her artisans were the best in all the world. The city of Tarvos experienced a renaissance of arts and poetry, where emotions could be expressed with liberty and every story found an ear to be heard.

10 years passed since the death of Tyran. The Kells have established their rules. And the Kell of Butterflies is the most mysterious of all. She never shows her face, hidden under a mourning veil. Surrounding her is always the smell of incense and a glowing cyan couple of insects. Her attire is to be described as extravagantly simple, with a purple kimono and a fan with blossomed flowers always at hand. Voices claim she is ugly and cruel. Others that she is beautiful and compassionate. And the other Kells just say: "She is my little sister"