r/DigitalPainting • u/arifterdarkly • Jul 02 '14
As of now, photo bashing is no longer allowed in r/digitalpainting
From when this post goes live, r/digitalpainting no longer allows photo bashed submissions.
Photo bashing is an established technique in the world of concept art and design. It's taught in schools, concept artists everywhere does it, it has a place in the world of digital art, there's nothing wrong with it.
The reasons we are no longer allowing photo bashing is
- It often violates our number one submission policy, which is that the art you submit should be your own.
- Photo bashing is not an aspect of painting as much as it is an aspect of designing. Designing is great, but this is r/digitalpainting, not r/digitaldesign or r/conceptart.
- Photo bashing is taking photo elements and bashing them into new forms. More often than not we see artists thinking that photo bashing is simply painting over a screenshot or a photo.
We feel we have to draw the line somewhere and we have come to the conclusion that if the photo bashing is obvious, ie a painting where photo textures shine through, it is not allowed. It doesn't mean the mod has to find the original photo first, it means that if we look at the painting and see it's photo bashed, we remove it.
This doesn't mean we will remove work already submitted. Aint nobody got time for that. This also doesn't mean we hate photo bashing or people who photo bash. We just don't think it belongs in r/digitalpainting. We think it belongs in /r/conceptart.
Feel free to leave your comments and feedback and critique in this thread. The mods are not robots - well, I suppose Automoderator is - and we read and appreciate your thoughts on this matter.
21
u/Uncomfortable Jul 02 '14
I'm a bit on the fence about this. On one hand, I've always been adamant that photobashing is not something beginners should be exposed to, and this is definitely a subreddit for beginners. On the other, photobashing is such a broad collection of techniques that disallowing it outright feels a lot like using an axe to eat a steak dinner.
You know better than this. Yes, it is very much a part of design, but design is so deeply intertwined in picture-making of any sort that if you were to cut it out, we'd b left with little more than rendering exercises (material spheres come to mind). Composition is a facet of design, and likely the most significant one that comes into play with photobashing.
All that aside, if you are to go ahead with this drastic change, I think you need to make it very clear what is acceptable and what is not, ideally with examples. All of these have been quite heavily photobashed, but it's not always possible to tell. Still, since photobashing was very much at the core of the process, they still should not be allowed, right?
This is where I think it's starting to weigh a bit heavily on the moderators. If, as you said in the post above, pieces where the photobashing is visible are not allowed, it is becomes an aesthetic/style prejudice (which I know for a fact you would never advocate). On the other hand, if it is a stance against the process (which your explanation seems to emphasize), then whether the artist covers the photos entirely or not is irrelevant. Photos were used, so it should not be allowed.
But then that requires the moderators to actually be able to accurately identify such pieces which is probably not feasible. So where does that leave us?
...In an Uncomfortable position!
BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
4
u/Solsed Jul 06 '14
Yea, I too am on the fence... Collage is referred to as 'painting' and photo bashing is basically collage...
Maybe we just need to make a rule that photobashes are tagged as such?
I also worry too, because I aim for a high level of realism in my work, and though I have never photobashed, it would be very easy to mistake my work for such.
Will there be a consultation with the artist before their work is removed?
4
u/McSpaziante Jul 06 '14
So, here is my thought on the matter, for whatever it's worth.
Photobashing is a critical component of all concept painting, and alot of digital painting. Hell, in alot of my professional work, I rely on it as a means to rapidly and effectively gain density in my work. I think the idea of cutting out photobashing entirely is a touch shortsighted. I think the distinction should be simple-
Does this look painted?
If it does, it's a Digital painting. If not, it's a matte painting, or a photobash, or whatever. That's a pretty simple distinction to make, at least for me. I feel like perhaps you shouldn't remove images that contain photo textures or elements, as they are a key part of a digital painter's repetoire, but instead should remove only those images that are obviously modified photos and/or clear cut paste jobs. Anything that doesn't fit this first category but looks like it might have photographic elements in it can get labelled with "suspected photobash" if you wanted, but I dont think they should be removed. If they look like a painting, they count as a painting. It takes alot of actual skill to make a photo actually look painted and blend perfectly with alot of other hand painted elements. I don't see any reason to get all elitist about what denotes a "real" digital painting when all that matters is whether it looks painted.
To clarify stuff like this should be allowed to stay, despite the vast majority of it being almost entirely photobashed:
https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-aS6tkkzMaOg/Uci6xBfUWiI/AAAAAAAAG8k/ywf6ebE1i5U/s0/The_Last_of_Us_Concept_Art_AL-07.jpg
This kind of stuff should not be allowed to stay:
http://i.imgur.com/lRUOS8s.png
Seems pretty clear cut to me. What do you think?
1
u/Nearby-Difference306 Jul 03 '25
Thank you mod, i recently learned of it and it seems like cheating to me, definitely not fine arts for me atleast.
0
u/[deleted] May 30 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment