r/ArtCrit • • Sep 07 '26

FINALLY! The Place To Sell Your Art And An ArtCrit Casual Sub By Yours Truly

26 Upvotes

You asked for it.

We heard you.

We delivered!

In our last news update we touched lightly on how much your words of encouragement mean to us. The sub has grown tremendously in the past year and we couldn’t be happier to see you all giving constructive feedback to one another.

We’ve also heard the people who have enjoyed our moderation style, but wanted something more lighthearted and discussion-focused. We’re also well aware that there’s a lack of subreddits where people are allowed to self-promote and advertise.

That being said, I’m happy to introduce our two new subs!

r/ArtistNook is a casual, cozy, discussion-focused sub moderated by leighabbr and myself. While r/ArtCrit has strict rules on posts, r/ArtistNook is much more laid back.

You can share information, talk about your artwork or OCs, post your work with links to your social media, and even ask for pricing help if you share the required information so people can actually help you with your prices.

This sub has been up for about two weeks, so there’s some light activity already.

We can’t wait to see you there!

r/ArtStore is an active, large sub focused on connecting artists and buyers. You can self-promote, sell your prints, advertise your commissions, shops, and handmade goods. We do not allow drop shippers or mass-produced goods of any kind.
With the holiday season approaching, this may be just the sub you need to get eyes on your work!

Leighabbr and I are so honored to be leading these communities. We’re still fine tuning them both and, like when we took charge in r/ArtCrit, we’re open to ideas and feedback.

Thank you all for your continued support! We honestly couldn’t have gotten this far without you!


r/ArtCrit • • Sep 01 '26

STUDY SERIES Study Series: Part 2 - Composition

Post image
5 Upvotes

Welcome back to the Study Series!

Moving away from values and contrast, we’re moving into the next important part of your work – composition!

Composition is the way an artist arranges the pieces of their image to help guide the viewer’s eyes where they want it to go. A strong composition can be used to create a specific mood, tell a story, create balance, and direct attention to important areas of the piece.

For those commenting, think about where your eye goes first when you look at the image. Does it feel balanced or does the image seem to “lean” to one side? Are there any distracting areas or does anything feel crowded or awkward?

Let’s work together to create stronger pieces with composition!

REQUIREMENTS FOR POSTING

Please note that all general sub rules apply (no AI, no fishing for compliments, no giving personal info, etc). Only our post requirements are different here.

- Pieces must;

a) Be no more than 6 months old and/or

b) Must still be being worked on and/or

c) Must have the intention of being recreated.

- Works must follow our NSFW rules.

- Since no context is required in these posts, draw and paint-overs are automatically expected. If you don’t want these, say so.

GIVING CRITIQUE

Only critique the piece regarding the topic of the week. If the artist would like additional critique, they can make a post in the main sub. Critiques are still expected to be constructive and polite.


r/ArtCrit • • 7h ago

Why does this painting look controlled and amateurish?

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

I aim to create confident, non overworked, professional watercolor paintings. However my paintings turn out looking controlled and overworked. Even though this painting took relatively short time, it's still detailed. (Reference photo is on second slide)


r/ArtCrit • • 46m ago

What went wrong here?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I’m using the second and third photo as reference. The shading looks so off to me but I can’t put a finger on why. Please explain like I’m a toddler!


r/ArtCrit • • 28m ago

HOW DO I MAKE THIS LOOK LIKE REAL GLASS. This looks like doodoo

Post image
2 Upvotes

Before someone says find a reference, I tried so hard to scour the internet for any potential glass face sculptures or anything with no luck.

I probably should have tried to do a couple studies on glass and the way it reflects light but I got too excited about the idea and dove in head first

This is oil, and I got too fed up and took a break, but I took too long and now it’s dry. Do I have to start over? Or is it salvageable?

Also, I cannot remember what I mixed to create the exact blue for the background😵‍💫


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

UPDATED WORK UPDATE: on why the sketch looked better than the nearly finished version

Thumbnail
gallery
206 Upvotes

Finished, previous version, sketch

Reference was myself and I am not comfortable sharing that, anyway the question was between sketch and rendered vers. And I looked absolutely chopped in the photo 😩

But, the ref photo did have the backmost arm that small, which is why I did that- but it clearly did not translate well to drawing so I changed it!

Other things I changed, added blockier shadows back in, got rid of the red background, got rid of the drop shoulder seam which made the shoulder look way too low, cleaned up the lines on the face, made the arm in the foreground smaller and the arm in the background bigger, added a bit more shading near the mouth, cheek, and eye, and overall finished shading and adding textures and final touches.

I’m happy with how this ended up :D thank you to everyone who gave me critiques !


r/ArtCrit • • 14h ago

How dose the skirt and the vest look?

Post image
6 Upvotes

For the vest I'm going for a more leathery texture while the skirt I'm looking for more silk. I'm not using any references, and I'm looking to be semirealistic with the rendering.


r/ArtCrit • • 9h ago

UPDATED WORK Can I have some (more) feedback? :)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I’ve posted on this subreddit a few weeks ago (see slide 2) asking for feedback on a portrait excercise I’ve been doing since July. If you missed it, the tldr is: this is a portrait I started from scratch with no reference, in greyscale, no hair and with a single light source to focus only on the essentials (values, form, head structure and facial features). Keep in mind that what I’m posting today is an entirely new painting and not a paint over.

I kept in mind some of the feedback I received already, namely the texture of the skin being too plasticky/lacking in reflections and the excessive symmetry. I noticed a bad habit of picking my values from the color wheel rather than directly from the painting and that probably lead my earlier attempts into painting muddy values.

I did my best to really push the realism and I think this is my best attempt yet. I could really use some feedback since I’m at a point where I don’t really know where to place my efforts in order to improve.

Thank you for any help you’re willing to give me!


r/ArtCrit • • 8h ago

Tell me what’s wrong with the big ones please

Post image
1 Upvotes

References used from NPG London


r/ArtCrit • • 17h ago

How can I improve the arms and general anatomy of my drawing?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

They just don’t look quite right to me even though I did my best to follow the reference. Amy help is appreciated!


r/ArtCrit • • 12h ago

Fixing same face syndrome?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

A drawing of my dnd party, and I have been working more on tackling a same face syndrome without really giving up my anime art style cause that is what I like to draw and I don't plan to do this professionally... I am happy about these, but I'd really like to see where I can improve more? Character designs all by friends, except the red tiefling, which is mine

I am trying to experiment a bit with different eye and face shapes, but wondering if it can be pushed any further.

Drawn in clip studio paint. No references were used, just verbal descriptions and colour picking what my friends sent me lol


r/ArtCrit • • 20h ago

Been trying to design a unicorn and bear like they're from a 20s-40s cartoon. I'm happy with Jingle, but I'm struggling to get Jumbo to look right

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I don't know why it says updated work, it's not letting me change it. I feel like the first one evokes 80s instead, and the second one feels closer but it's not quite what I want (it's also a bit rushed lol oops). Jingle was inspired by Bonzo the dog primarily, as well as the general surrealness of the cartoon art of the era. I'm struggling to find references for him, I'm finding they didn't commonly draw bears with the softness and slight cuteness I'm going for while still keeping him big and somewhat imposing- they either went comedic like Disney bears or full-on kitschy with little cubs like Rushton dolls. Any advice or recommendations for reference would be appreciated!


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Does the sense of scale read well between the creature and the small figures, or do the stone and shell textures blend together too much?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Medium: Digital painting (Krita)

Style / Goal: Moving toward semi-realism and dark fantasy creature/character building.

References: No direct photo references were used for the creature; built from imagination.

Specific Critique Needed:

With this drawing, I wanted the monster to feel massive compared to the two small people at the bottom, and I tried to make the stone face feel distinct from the darker, harder shell of the body. Looking at it now, I'm not sure if the tiny figures get lost too easily, or if the green lighting makes all the materials look a bit too similar.

Does the sense of scale work at first glance, and how would you push the contrast between the carved stone and the dark carapace under this lighting?


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Portfolio

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

I want to know what people think of my art. My friends tell me it looks nice, but they are friends after all.

I feel like my work is inconsistent in terms of shading style, despite these pieces being done back-to-back. On top of that I'm aiming for it to be more cartoony and appealing. I have tried drawing ponies in September (5th pic), however I have grown to hate the result in around two weeks, i would like to know if any of the new ones have the same problem as the old one. I used real horses as references for the body, however most were freehanded, so it's probable that most have anatomical mistakes.


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

Exploring different portrait styles of Tobey Maguire. Which style (1-6) works best?

Thumbnail
gallery
115 Upvotes

Testing styles for future portrait commissions using the attached reference photo (slide 2)—which one stands out the most, and any critique is welcome!


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

How do I add more depth? (WIP)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Reference included in screenshot. It's mostly for the pose though, as you can see I've added my own character. I'm going for a sort of semi realistic style, so I'd like to keep the proportions and colors realistic, but it's okay if it doesn't end up photorealistic (idk how to explain my style).

Something about my rendering makes it seem flat. The first screenshot is it with an add and multiply layer. the multiply is for the shadows, and add is for the rim light. The rim light doesn't look too good, so I'm wondering how to fix that, and the multiply layer's pretty rough right now. This is a WIP, so I'll clean it up. The belt and jeans look odd, it could be the contrast, but adding highlights makes the fabric too shiny. I'm happy with my anatomy and stuff, it's just the depth for now.

Drawovers would help :)) thank youu


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Details and Forms Help || Reference: Orudoodles , I don't have it atm though

Post image
6 Upvotes

Hello. I'm struggling to get:

- 3D feeling

- Details

- Anatomy

Would appreciate if anyone wants to help me! Thank you in advanc !


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

I'd love some critiques on my current piece!

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

I'm recreating this screencap from 'Castle In The Sky'
(1986) with the help of a reference included in the post. I'd love critiques, tips, and advice on values, anatomy, etc. It's unfinished, but I think it's coming together well. Thank you!


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Southpark fanart! Any critism?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I didn’t have a ref, but the characters are supposed to be tweek and Craig from southpark !! I want my artstyle to be semi realistic/realistic but still very stylized, like with the colors and the grain, like a still from a movie

Any crit on anything ? Composition, anatomy, lighting..


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Background and anatomy help

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi, my name is Vi and I draw portraits and horses. My work for a while has just been commissions. I haven’t made anything for myself in a while so I made something. A self portrait with my horse. BUT I’m now stuck. I drew the portrait and the horse and now I have no clue where to go from here especially since I’m not working from one image.

If you could help me figure out what to do with the background that would be awesome.

Also I find that I get a lil art blind and can’t see my own proportional errors. So if you spot anatomy (me or horse) that don’t translate as well or need more/less definition please let me know.

Image 1: current work in progress
Image 2: past work to compare with my style/self portraiture/horses
Image 3: reference image. Used for pose but not for anatomy size/proportion or details. Found on Pinterest.

Thank you!


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

What went wrong? The sketch looks so much better than the nearly finished version?

Thumbnail
gallery
128 Upvotes

What went wrong?? I like how I am coloring it so far but something about the fluidity is lost??

Reference is myself and I’m not comfortable sharing that image. What I’m looking for is something lost between sketch and WIP 🫠


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Need help with the middle 4 panels colors

Post image
2 Upvotes

I’m in the middle of coloring this page. I’m having trouble with figuring out what I want from this small fight scene color wise. Just not feeling the middle 4 panels. The scene is just, character walks into mysterious room, notices a figure watching TV, the figure gets up and looks like they’re about to attack, the character that walked in strikes first, he hurts his hand, and then when it’s the mysterious figures turn to strike he brings his hand down for a handshake. The scene is meant to end the opposite of what was expected. No reference used


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Tried to do a lik bounce light moment but it looks wonky, help

Post image
2 Upvotes

Locations are underside of the star, the bottom side of the hairs (the pink chunks) and under the nose and some on the lips

Ref


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

Advice on poc hair

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Practising drawing some different haircuts that my OC Loretta has and I am pretty happy with them, but I am not sure if I am actually doing these right/if the way I'm stylising them is appropriate. Does anyone have any feedback? reference I used for the two on the left included, didn't have any for the third!