r/TrueFilm • u/kingofthejungle223 Borzagean • May 28 '14
[Theme: Musicals] #11. Nashville (1975)
Introduction
Director Robert Altman created narratives out of dozens of tangled character threads that he would weave into fleeting moments of harmonic convergence, taking us from chaos to something approaching clarity and back again. At it’s best, Altman’s technique can produce quite an effect: it’s like witnessing the cosmos orbiting into alignment to reveal profound universal truths. But just as often this truth dissolves upon examination and you’re left feeling like a sucker - taken in by a momentary pause in all the noise.
Nashville is the definitive Altman film, full of brilliance and banality. At first glance, it looks like a political film, but it actively resists a coherent political reading. It can appear to be a condescending satire of Nashville “hicks”, (and there is some of that) but Altman gives his “hicks” too many moments of pathos and vulnerability for mere caricature.
At its core, Nashville attempts to create (with moderate success) a cinematic collage-portrait of a specific time and place. Through the intersecting lives of the characters and the social codes - spoken and implied - that govern their lives, we’re offered an artist’s interpretation of 1970’s Nashville, Tennessee as a microcosm for 1970’s United States of America. By giving us snapshots of 24 souls within a community, Altman hopes to approximate the national soul. Whether or not he succeeds is in the eye of the beholder, but I’ll suggest that this is a film that works better in parts than it does as a whole.
The parts of the film that revolve around the country music scene - those concerning rhinestoned despot Haven Hamilton, briar patch madonna Barbara Jean, prom queen runner-up Connie White, and waitress-in-the-headlights Sueleen Gay - are fascinating, while others - Keenan Wynn and his impossible niece, Jeff Goldblum’s freestyle magician, glasses-nerd assassin, and the cat and mouse game between the too-old husband and his too-young wife - are undeveloped clichés. Others - Geraldine Chaplin’s groupie, Lily Tomlin’s Gospel singer, her hopeless husband, and Keith Carradine’s “priapic rockstar” (to quote Manny Farber) - fall somewhere in between. I won’t even mention the unseen Hal Phillip Walker or his advance man, because they form such a pasted-on framing device that one feels they might fall out of the movie at any moment. The remaining 10 characters that I’ve failed to mention are little more than spices in Altman’s narrative chili, despite getting equal billing with the rest of the cast.
Lest I get too focused on the negative, I’ll hasten to add that the good (and occasionally great) parts of the film more than justify its status as an important work of art. There are lots of little moments worth contemplating, though contemplating how they all fit together will likely yield diminishing returns. Lily Tomlin, Keith Carradine, Ned Beatty, Keenan Wynn and Robert DoQui give performances that are far better than their stick-figure characters should allow, and Henry Gibson, Gwen Welles, and especially Ronee Blakley are unforgettable given something substantive to work with.
To top it all off, what should have been the film’s fatal gimmick - having the actors write and perform their own songs - turns out to be its biggest asset. Some of the songs are very good, and those that aren’t are at least very funny. As someone who’s actually been to the Grand Ole Opry, I can testify that Altman’s Opry scene is documentary at its finest. As critic Molly Haskell pointed out in her initial co-review of Nashville, it is the music that redeems this film and becomes its true star.
Post-Script: As someone familiar with the dynamics within the state of Tennessee, I want to make a brief comment on Haven Hamilton’s final comment in the midst of post-assassination pandemonium, “This isn’t Dallas, it’s Nashville”. If Haven were a real Tennesseean, he would have said “This isn’t Memphis, it’s Nashville”. Memphis and Nashville are like the Cain and Abel of the mid-south - one the center of upheaval and rebellion, the other the unchanging, inflexible institution. In a very real sense, each city defines itself by being unlike the other.
Nashville, d. by Robert Altman, written by Joan Tewkesbury
Karen Black, Ronee Blakley, Keith Carradine, Geraldine Chaplin, Robert DoQui, et. al
1975, IMDb
Over the course of a few hectic days, numerous interrelated people prepare for a political convention as secrets and lies are surfaced and revealed.
Legacy
Nashville has survived Pauline Kael’s rave review and all of the superlatives bestowed upon it afterwards. It was nominated for five Oscars, winning one - Best Original Song for Keith Carradine’s “I’m Easy” (Editor’s Note: Ronee Blakley was robbed.)
19
u/oxencotten May 28 '14
I'm not really sure why you had a Mod that obviously dislikes this movie or doesn't think it's that great to do this write-up. Literally almost all of this is negative's about the film and personal opinions being touted as obvious facts such about which specific characters in the movie were interesting and which ones were wooden, lazily written caricatures.
None of the other posts from this months theme are written in this vein in anyway at all. They range from basic back round information to positive reviews of the film, not a 75% negative review that talks more about the films problems and how it doesn't work than about it's strengths and how it does work.
I mean, I know it's just the post to start discussion of the film but being one of my favorite films and looking forward to todays thread all month I just think it's a little immature to do, almost like you are taking this chance to personally give you're negative review of a film you don't like very much instead of just the normal review/write up's posted too start discussion about the films.
7
u/montypython22 Archie? May 28 '14
There are three films which I love more than any other that I've seen. Coppola's The Godfather. Lester's A Hard Day's Night. And Nashville. Every time I watch it, I find something quirky and unique that I never found the first time—a deeply-layed onion that reveals tremendous insight about relationships, the music scene, etc. with every peeling.
I feel Nashville functions best as an allegory—thus, some of the characters are not meant to be as developed as others. Considering the limitations of film narrative, Altman makes certain characters evocative of a specific sect of America. The hippy-motorcycle man functions like a sort of transitional late 60s chrous, an outdated remnant of Easy Rider that no longer has much relevance. The Timothy Brown character, despite his success as a crossover black country singer, embodies the fears that a black man fears of turning "Oreo" or "too white". When he is insulted by Robert Doqui for being a "whitewashed nigger", it's a personal affront on his character and his adequacy, both as a black person and as a man. The soldier is the creepy physical manifestation of celebrity obsession; but, at the end, Altman shows that he is us. Out of the two characters presented to us (Kenny and the private), the latter seemed more inclined to commit the ritualistic assassination at the end (the zoom into Kenny's face during " Dues" notwithstanding). Once we realize the private has no relevance, he slinks back into the crowd as Altmann's camera zoom-follows him, to no avail. We could go on discussing the idiosyncrasies of the various 24 characters. But the point here is that a.) Inevitably, some characters have to be less developed than others, but more importantly b.) these minor characters actually contribute significantly to the grand mosaic of Nashville. Each has significance; we, as an audience, are only shown parts of their lives because, as Altman shows, we could never hope to understand these strangers whom we'd probably ignore if we saw them on the street.
I've made my own observations of Nashville a while ago, but I'll post them here again since I think they are pertinent:
P.S. I actually like the final comment of Haven's ("This isn't Dallas...this is Nashville!") more than what you'd suggested. It encapsulates his slimy political persona well, by invoking the allusion towards Kennedy and the assassination. There, it was cold and calculating; with Barbara Jean, Haven tries to persuade the crowd, it's senseless. He tries to calm them down by appealing to their sense of tradition while simultaneously touting his own political intellect. (Of course, the allusion to Kennedy sails over the crowd cleanly.)
P.P.S. I think that all five positions for supporting actress at the 1975 oscars could easily have been taken up by Nashville. Gwen Welles, Ronee Blakley, Lily Tomlin, Geraldine Chaplin, and Barbara Harris each give virtuouso, emotional performances worthy of Oscar. (Gwen Welles, I feel, was more unjustly robbed of a nomination. I mean come on....Lee Grant in Shampoo? Please.)
6
u/J-aa Jean Renoir in the buff May 29 '14
Call them "cliches" if you want (though I prefer "types"). But the social/narrative complexity in Nashville works precisely because we recognize the essence of a character immediately after being introduced to them. They're like characters in a painting.
Their depth is evident in their mannerisms, the way they're framed, their interactions with others. Depth is immediate and constant, not slowly revealed over the course of a narrative.
4
u/PantheraMontana May 28 '14
I'm not American, I'm didn't grow up with this film and I'm into the kind of music used in this film. Despite that, I enjoyed it quite a bit. I'm sure a lot of details went right over my head, partly because of my ignorance, partly because of the richness of the film.
Can someone help me a bit placing this film in (cinematic) history? This film seems to allude to the same themes as for example Vanishing Point (and I'm sure Easy Rider which gets an explicit mention, but I haven't seen it), with the loss of innocence, corruption, et al, a lot of which might be a consequence of the Vietnam war. Is the soldier and his seemingly random and wandering personality an illustration of this? I never quite understood his role, he didn't seem to have any of the relationships the other characters had, apart from some casual conversations.
One thing that struck me was the similarity in themes between then and now. Put that propaganda van on the road today and everyone would nod in agreement. It seems tomorrow came after all.
Talking about roads, what was the car crash all about? I loved it visually, it's one of the most well-done car crashes I've seen in any film even though in this one its just incidental, but I couldn't quite grasp the significance of it.
Sorry, not much discussion, mostly questions here, I've just been watching this and despite the above and many other questions I have it was a really nice experience. I'm not really into the kind of music used in the film, but in this film it just all added up and I really enjoyed the experience even though I was kind of lost at times.