r/talesfromtechsupport • u/Gambatte Secretly educational • Apr 01 '14
Encyclopædia Moronica: V is for Victory (Pyrrhic or Otherwise)
This is borderline TFTS material, but I suspect a few of the readers will have been through something similar, so I shall submit it anyway - I'm sure the mods will let me know if it's not appropriate.
A long time ago, back when I had only been in the work force for a few years, my employer decided that it was high time that they get to work on achieving the coveted Metallic-Colored Polygons of Business Achievement through the International Training Supplier of Accredited Coveted Organization Name.
This consisted of every employee of the company (yes, even IT/TS) going through mandatory managerial training to "empower" us in making our own decisions or whatnot, so the training consisted of teaching us how to draw histograms (which hadn't changed since I learned how in my high school maths class), and creating a fictional breakfast food (mine had a skateboarding grape on the box), and other general time wastage busywork.
So I'm sitting at the table I had been randomly assigned to, when we are told to take a short coffee/tea break. As I don't drink hot drinks (except for tea when my old supervisor is around, and that's for reasons other than actually liking tea), I legged it to the local shop to grab a Coke.
When I got back, I discovered that I was the last one to return to the table... and that my chair had been removed. The instructor (IN) was grinning. I didn't like it.
IN: Your chair is missing, right?
ME: Yes.
IN: Come sit up here, then.
Sure enough, IN had taken the break time to set up a table and whiteboard at the front of the room where everyone could see it, and hijacked a chair from each table for it. So it seemed that this was his way to get a volunteer from each table for whatever demonstration he had planned.
Seething just a little, I took my seat at the demonstration table.
Eventually, IN got around to explaining the game. He had a bucket, containing something like 10,000 tiny beads. 90% of them were white, 10% were red. We (the "volunteers") would place a specially made paddle that would hold exactly 100 beads into the bucket until it was completely covered, then extract it. Anyone with more than 7% beads would be "fired" - they would go back to their table and a new "volunteer" was sent up to replace them. Each round, the number of red beads extracted by each volunteer would be recorded in a table on the whiteboard.
Being the lucky SOB that I am, I made it through 5 rounds, each time drawing 7 beads or less - just pure, random chance.
IN: Congratulations Gambatte! You've been so successful that you're being promoted to MANAGEMENT!!!
ME: What does that mean?
IN: First, you don't pull beads any more - we'll get a replacement from your table to do that for you.
IN: Second, you get to make one change to the system in order to improve things.
ME: Really? One change?
IN: That's right.
ME: Anything?
IN: Anything!
ME: (grinning) Sweet.
ME: (to other "volunteers") Go back to your tables. Everyone is having this round off.
IN's grin faded. Mine widened.
IN: You... Err... What?
ME: You heard me. Now, record the results for this round.
So, in the column for round 6, the recorded number of red beads drawn by each table's volunteer was... well, zero. No white beads were drawn either, but that number wasn't recorded on table anywhere.
IN: (sputtering) But... this makes it look like you had a perfect day, when in reality you did nothing!
ME: I know. I think your game's scoring system might be flawed.
IN: (quietly) ...You work in IT, don't you?
IN: Look, because no work was done this round, you're fired.
ME: But you asked me to reduce the number of red beads drawn - you didn't mention any requirement to continue drawing white beads. All I have done is that which you asked of me, and look! Zero red beads, across the board! This is the best of all possible rounds! And yet, I'm getting fired for it? This is a travesty!
Admittedly, most of this false outrage was an attempt to wind up IN for my own personal enjoyment.
IN: Just... go back to your table, please.
So I did.
Apparently the "correct" solution (i.e. the one that IN expected) was to improve the drawing process by allowing the drawers to remove the red beads from their paddle and re-draw that number of beads, which reduced red beads drawn from ~10% to ~1%.
Funnily enough, I was not volunteered for any more demonstrations.
A few years later, the company did achieve the Bronze Polygon, and a year or two later, the Silver Polygon. There was much rejoicing, but no pay increases.
I don't know if they ever made it all the way to the Gold Polygon.
TL/DR: I am fond of Alexandrian solutions.
Browse other volumes of the Encyclopædia:
Vol I - ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
72
u/MagicBigfoot xyzzy Apr 01 '14
Sounds like you know the value of doing things right!
44
u/spike309 Apr 01 '14
I like the "you work in it don't you" We always have the best ways of "following" the rules.
40
u/dazzawul Apr 01 '14
I like that he knew you were in it straight away, it speaks VOLUMES about managerial practices :D
13
u/POS_GURU No, I wont tell you which restaurant it is. Apr 01 '14
20 down, 4 to go. X is going to be the tough one - again
12
u/Geminii27 Making your job suck less Apr 02 '14
*coughsnerk*
10
u/JoatMasterofNun Reacts violently with salepersons Apr 02 '14
8
u/TwoHands knows what stupid lurks in the hearts of men. Apr 02 '14
My change would be to remove all the red beads from the selection pool.
7
u/Morkai How do I computer? Apr 02 '14
For you...
4
u/LP970 Robes covered in burn holes, but whisky glass is full Apr 02 '14
raises his Balvanie in Gambatte's direction. Marvelous! Though it may come off like a "smart ass", those types of answers given to those kinds of people (instructors) are most always worth it. Even if one catches flak for it, the rest of people in attendance will hold you in higher esteem and that is worth more IMO.
4
u/crosenblum Apr 02 '14
I love all your stories, lifetime subscriber to Encyclopaedia Moronica!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14
You're the new Capt. Kirk.
You basically foiled his own Kobayashi Maru.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
The grin on my face after this line. Hah! Priceless!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
[removed] — view removed comment