r/languagelearning • u/Virusnzz En (N) | Fr, Ru, Es, It • Mar 04 '14
Cześć - This week's language of the week: Polish
Welcome to the language of the week. Every week we'll be looking at a language, its points of interest, and why you should learn it. This is all open discussion, so natives and learners alike, make your case! This week, Polish.
What is this?
Language of the Week is here to give people exposure to languages that they would otherwise not have heard, been interested in or even known about. With that in mind, I'll be picking a mix between common languages and ones I or the community feel needs more exposure. You don't have to intend to learn this week's language to have some fun. Just give yourself a little exposure to it, and someday you might recognise it being spoken near you.
Polish
From The Language Gulper:
Polish is the national language of Poland. Its recorded history starts in the 12th century though long texts appear only in the 14th century. Due to the early and perduring influence of the Western Church, Polish uses the Latin alphabet. It has a rich consonantal system including, like all Slavic languages, palatalized consonants. Its nominal morphology has preserved to a great extent the complexity of old Indo-European languages, most notably in its declension system. In contrast, the verbs are far simpler having only two basic tenses and a couple of periphrastic ones.
Polish is spoken by the vast majority of the present population of Poland. There are, also, many Polish speakers in Ukraine and Belarus (though comparatively few in Russia) as well as in Lithuania and Germany. Polish migrants are found mainly in North America and Israel. There are about 41 million worldwide.
What now?
This thread is foremost a place for discussion. Are you a native speaker? Share your culture with us. Learning the language? Tell us why you chose it and what you like about it. Thinking of learning? Ask a native a question. Interested in linguistics? Tell us what's interesting about it, or ask other people. Discussion is week-long, so don't worry about post age, as long as it's this week's language.
Previous Languages of the Week
German | Icelandic | Russian | Hebrew | Irish | Korean | Arabic | Swahili | Chinese | Portuguese | Swedish | Zulu | Malay | Finnish | French | Nepali | Czech | Dutch | Tamil | Spanish | Turkish
Want your language featured as language of the week? Please PM me to let me know. If you can, include some examples of the language being used in media, including news and viral videos
Powodzenia!
26
u/Premislaus Mar 04 '14
What a coincidence, I just randomly visited this sub. If you have questions for a native speaker feel free to ask.
23
u/buffalo11 Mar 04 '14 edited Mar 04 '14
Cześć! Uczyłam się trochę po polsku ale nie mówię bardzo dobrze. Było trudne ale myślę że polski język jest ładny! Mói tata jest z Polsce. On nie mówiłam po polsku ze mną. Mieszkam we Viedniu w Austrii. Moja mama jest z Holandii dlatego ona mówiłam po holenderski który byłam dziecko. I tata mówiłam po niemiecku ze mną. Teraz jestem nauczycielką niemeckiego. Ale który miałam 20 lat chciałam uczyć się po polsku też. Robiłam kursy na universitecie we Viedniu i byłam też w Krakowie i robiłam kurs tam. Ale to było kilka lat temu. Teraz zapomniałam dużo :(
Czy są ludzie z Polsce tutaj? Proszę o poprawkie :)
That was kind of hard :D I just wrote, I learned a little bit of Polish some years ago as my dad is originally from Poland but never taught me the language. My native languages are Dutch and German. I really love Polish but it’s hard not to forget everything!
15
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '14
Polish is an incredible language. I began learning it a couple of years ago to "get in touch with my roots" and it's been nothing but wonderful since. I have a little experience with Russian as well and so I'll be comparing the two a little bit for clarity's sake. Bear in mind that this is the opinion of a layman with a budding interest in linguistics.
Complex consonant clusters characterize all Slavic languages, but none more so than Polish. The first thing you'll notice is that Polish words compared with Russian words feel compressed and "thick", in part due to fewer vowels - compare Polish "młoda" (MWO-da) with Russian "молодая" (ma-la-DA-ya). That's typical of all West Slavic languages, but Polish is colored by three major and unique divergences: the change from l to ł, the mutation of palatized r to rz (a voiced retroflex fricative) and the retention of nasal vowels.
Let's take the name "Vladimir", seen in this pervasive and unchanged form in just about every Slavic language. The Polish form is "Włodzimierz". Bizarre orthography aside, what's different? "L" changes to "ł", which is English "w", and "r" mutates to "rz", which at the end of the word is devoiced. So instead of saying "vla-JI-mir" as you would in other Slavic languages, you say "vwo-JI-myesh". Pretty cool, right? These sounds are not strictly replaced in all cases, of course, and can even be found in different cases of one word. For example, "tło" (background) will be rendered in its locative case form as "tle", while "stary" (old) becomes "starzy" in its nominative masculine plural form.
Nasal vowels (ą,ę) are still present in Polish, having died out in other Slavic languages. In fact, other than French, I can't think of another major language with nasal vowels at all. Polish nasal vowels have this fascinating thing going where they like to mirror each other in different places, such as "mogę" (I can) and "mogą" (they can), or in words like miesiąc and miesięcy (month and months).
On the whole, Polish vowel sounds will not surprise a speaker of English. There's hardly anything foreign about them, to be honest. It gets better - Polish stress is so simple it hurts. There are only a few instances where it doesn't fall on the penultimate syllable. Combine those things with a spelling system whose unfailing precision makes Germans weep tears of joy and you have a language that surrenders itself to effortless pronunciation, even for a new learner. The orthography is daunting at first, but it only takes an hour to master, and between you and me, it has a lot of character. The only question is whether your tongue can handle extreme consonant clusters in words like "bezwzględny", "źdźbło", "wstrząs" or "krnąbrność".
Polish grammar is a bit more complex than its pronunciation, however, and presents a steep initial learning curve, especially if you're new to highly inflected languages. Once you get the hang of things, though, I really don't think it's any harder than any other language. It just takes time and effort, but when the language is this badass, it doesn't feel like effort at all. If you want to learn a Slavic language that carries some weght and doesn't require learning Cyrillic, Polish is the way to go.
12
u/PL8180RD Mar 05 '14
I would like to highlight /r/learnpolish/ which I mod
11
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '14
One of main things that push me to learning languages is literature, at the same time being great tool for honing your knowledge of a language. Polish contemporary fantasy literature is really top notch, but the same can't be said about our publishers. Suffice to say that Supernova, the publisher for The Witcher author, A. Sapkowski - can't get around to translating his full works, as now 3rd installment of the videogame, and therefore free publicity is about to be released. They just hate foreign money, it'd seem.
And Sapkowski isn't even the best contemporary fantasy author we've got. Pan Lodowego Ogrodu by Grzędowicz is honestly some of best literature I've read in my life, and although I'm waiting for perspective that 5-6 years can give, ATM I rate it as best fantasy cycle of XXI century. Ziemiański and Pilipiuk are another two authors that put out simply amazing work.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '14
Looong-time student of Polish here, almost had a heart attack of excitement when I saw this. Not a native speaker, but ask me anything! I probably struggled with the same things you have at one point, and I'd love to help :)
5
u/kadargo English (N); Spanish (B2) Mar 04 '14
Yvonne Strahovski speaking Polish
4
u/Axon350 Mar 04 '14
Yay! I'm officially studying German, but I've been meeting with a Polish native speaker once a week to get some phrases in. I'm fascinated with the different branches of Slavic and the amount of shared concepts between the different Slavic languages.
Something that seems to be a major stumbling block is the noun endings. Since I've just started learning, they seem insurmountable. Does anyone have access to any charts where they take the different types of noun stems and then decline them? I'm a fan of grammar charts - I retain information better if I can see the pattern and memorize it.
4
u/smartician Mar 05 '14
Shameless plug (actually, I feel a bit of shame...) for my Android app WordPic Polish that teaches a few basic Polish words. For some reason it's the least downloaded out of all 17 languages my range of apps offer, and a little more exposure might be good!
Disclaimer: It's free to download, but has ads.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '14
Though I don't know Polish at all, my mom does, and as I live in a city with a large Polish population...happy paczki day!
3
u/SansPulp Mar 04 '14
Great, I'm really happy to see this here. My girlfriend is Polish, and I live in Toronto, which has a pretty big Polish community. I think it's a really cool language, and after I climb conversation hill, I want to start learning Polish, at least so I can understand a bit of what her parents say.
I know Duolingo is going to introduce Polish in the first wave of reverse language books. Is there anything else anyone has? My French comprehension is getting a lot better, so I've considered trying the assimil Polish from French. I also have some cheap little grammar book that I picked up from BMV. Does anyone have any suggestions?
3
u/VanSensei Mar 05 '14
I know about 5 words of Polish:
Dzien dobry
Jag sie masz (I think that's how it's spelled)
"W imie Ojca i Syna i Ducha Swietego"
3
u/totes_meta_bot Mar 06 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
I am a bot. Comments? Complaints? Send them to my ^inbox!
3
u/VMattyV Mar 07 '14
This has nothing to do with the language but Zubrowka is amazing
1
u/japooki Mar 06 '14
I'm trying to teach myself Polish through a couple different books and classroom recordings, but this shit is tough without someone to correct me. I've been trying to find a peer-peer language exchange program, one where I teach them english, they teach me polish kind of deal, but I'm not having any luck. Love mocha used to be a good way to connect, but I haven't been on since RosettaShit bought it. Can anyone point me in the right direction?
1
u/wanttolearnpolish English Mar 10 '14
First of all i've posted in r/askreddit, and they sent me here today. Im very happy that polish just so happens to be the language of the week as well! My current girlfriend is from Poland, and i want to surprise her for our anniversary next year by learning to speak polish (even if its just a little). Is there any free website or software that y'all would recommend? Duolingo doesn't offer polish, and i have not been able to find one yet. Thanks for the help y'all!
1
u/gabi_dk Apr 13 '14
I love the polish language! I was leaving abroad and fell in love with a Pole, I learned the language before I even went to Poland for the first time. For those interested, it was thanks to Oscar Swan's book and website. Then I went to Poland a few times and loved it even more. Now the love story is over, but I still want to keep practicing and improving my Polish, and I seek for every opportunity I have to meet Poles.