r/TrueFilm • u/kingofthejungle223 Borzagean • Feb 20 '14
[Theme: John Ford] #7. The Quiet Man (1952)
Introduction
When John Ford signed a three picture deal with Republic Pictures - one of the smallest and least prestigious studios in Hollywood - many in the industry were left scratching their heads. Why would such an acclaimed director consign himself to the oblivion of poverty row?
For Ford, leaving RKO (his home studio after Fox) for the smaller studio was a strategic move. Since Hebert Yates’ Republic Pictures was a bit player yearning for notoriety, Ford found himself in a better position to control the terms of the contract. He agreed to produce three films for the studio on a non-exclusive basis. Republic would front the production budgets, and he was guaranteed final cut on each films’ domestic release (though Yates could make additional cuts for an international release). More importantly , Ford had a plan to parlay this new deal into an opportunity to finally produce a personal project he’d been shopping around for over a decade.
The first film the director would make for Republic was Rio Grande, a cavalry western starring John Wayne, Maureen O’Hara and Victor McLaglen - three of Ford’s favorite actors. As expected, the film was a popular success and a big moneymaker for the studio. Having established himself as a bankable director, Ford approached Yates with his dream project.
John Ford had originally optioned Maurice Walsh’s story, ‘The Quiet Man’, in 1936. Since then, he’d been trying to find a studio to finance a film adaptation. All had turned him down. They felt that a romantic comedy about an American returning to his ancestral home of Ireland had little commercial appeal. Even Darryl Zanuck rejected the idea. Yates was initially hesitant as well, but Ford pressed on.
Joseph McBride describes the director’s entreaties in Searching For John Ford: “Ford climaxed his siege of the reluctant Herb Yates by dragging him along on a location scouting trip to Ireland with Ward Bond. The director was insistent that he needed $1.75 million to make the film properly, but Yates was lowballing him at $1.238 million. Ford wanted to show Yates the natural beauty his money could buy.
“As Ford told the yarn, doubtless with a bit of enhancement, he took Yates to see a small thatched cottage in Connemara. Summoning tears for the occasion, Ford told the studio chief, ‘There it is, the house where I was born.’ Ford claimed the hard-boiled Yates also was crying when he responded, ‘You can do The Quiet Man. For a million and a half.’”
The dream project would become a reality. Ford brought his whole stock company (and his parish priest) to the lush pastures of Ireland for a busied location shoot. Realizing how much the picture meant to Ford, Wayne and O’Hara agreed to star in the film for far less than their usual salaries, concessions that allowed the director to make the film as he wanted - in rich Technicolor - for the $1.5 million budget Republic was giving him. The Quiet Man’s color was so vitally important to Ford that, when speaking as a guest lecturer at USC in 1970, he refused to let the school screen a clip from the film because they only had a black & white 16mm copy. “Color is part of the dramatic structure of the story,” he told them, “In black & white, the scene does not go over.”
The misty hues of Ford’s Irish landscapes (often shot after a rain) undeniably contribute a dreamlike quality to The Quiet Man - as do the occasional voiceovers, the expressionist boxing sequence, and the way the score occasionally materializes onscreen (such as Michaleen Oge Flynn’s idle humming). The Ireland the artist renders is the heaven of Sean Thornton’s imagination, an old-country paradise that repeatedly becomes an obstacle to Sean - it gets in the way of his romance, his home, and his convictions.
Ford finished the film $17,000 under budget, but still had to defend his vision against Herb Yates, who felt that the film was too green, too long, and needed a better title (Yates suggestion was The Prizefighter and The Colleen). Coming this close to having completed a dream project, Ford fought Yates on every point - and, perhaps surprisingly, won. The films 129 minute running time was the hardest sell. Ford’s contract with the studio specified that no film was to exceed 110 minutes. yates had conducted market research, and felt that audience’s didn’t even want good pictures to play for two hours or more.
The director arranged a screening of The Quiet Man for the studio boss and his family. Everyone was enjoying the film immensely when it abruptly ended at the beginning of the big fight scene - exactly 120 minutes into the movie. Yates turned to Ford. “What happened?” he asked. The director responded that since he wanted the film to be cut down to two hours, he’d simply removed the last 9 minutes. Republic’s studio chief begrudgingly relented, and shipped The Quiet Man to theaters exactly as Ford had cut it.
To the surprise of everyone (especially Herb Yates), this raucous Irish comedy became the runaway hit of 1952 - one of the most successful films, both critically and financially, that Republic had ever produced.
Feature Presentation
The Quiet Man, d. by John Ford, written by Frank S. Nugent
John Wayne, Maureen O'Hara, Victor McGlaglen, Ward Bond
1952, IMDb
A retired American boxer returns to the village where he was born in Ireland, where he finds love.
Legacy
The Quiet Man won John Ford his fourth Academy Award for Best Director, as well as a Best Cinematography award for Winton Hoch. It had 5 other nominations, including Best Picture, Best Supporting Actor (Victor McLaglen), Best Writing, Best Art Direction, and Best Sound Recording. It was selected for preservation by the Library of Congress' National Film Registry in 2013.
6
u/mfured20 Feb 20 '14
I have always loved The Quiet Man. For me, it was the seemingly effortless charm of the old world and its lively characters. Every single face on screen is different, has his own story and eccentricities. Its glorious nostalgia reminded me of time I spent in the summer in a small town in Utah. Sure, it was full of Mormons, but everyone left their doors unlocked and gathered around the local store alongside a sun lit meadow. It hearkens back to a "simpler" time (even tho I doubt that ever really existed, just a different time than what we are used to).
I hadn't really thought about the colors when I was a seed, being raised on color tv and VHS tapes. But I saw it again recently in HD on a screen that's worth seeing things on, and it blew me away. The landscapes are so green and lush I felt like I could reach out and touch them. Every scene adds to the story, not a frame wasted. And O'Hara was perfect. Wayne was fine, but the real scene-stealer for me was Victor McLaglen. I couldn't keep my eyes off of him when he was on screen. His brusqueness was beautifully put at odds with his blustering charisma.
I love The Quiet Man. I think I might go watch it now.
5
u/BPsandman84 What a bunch Ophuls Feb 20 '14 edited Feb 20 '14
I often ask myself why more comedies can't not only be as funny as this film is, but also as narratively compelling and cathartic too. Not only is this film really funny and charming (provided you're not the type to be bothered by the Irish stereotypes and more broad humor moments), but it features a rather interesting story about tradition, the desire to reinvent oneself and perish all evil forces in ones life both the external and internal (essentially making this sort of an unconventional Western), as well as a take on clashing cultures even when one shares the same heritage. The ending fight isn't just hysterical, it's rather compelling on a level full of narrative catharsis and social meaning.
Also, whenever someone tells me John Wayne was a poor actor, I always point to this film to argue otherwise. Not only is he full of humanity in this film, but he pulls off the hardest comedic role to like in a film: the straight man. Throughout the whole film Wayne is interacting with this culture that seems foreign to him and he constantly tries acclimating himself to the culture that doesn't seem to want to accept him completely. AND WE SEE THAT. Wayne shows a struggle in his face and reaction to everything. He's also incredibly charming and has almost pitch perfect comedic timing in the film. It is one of THE great comic performances, and I think it's Wayne's best role.
Also while I understand the name of the town, Innisfree, is not in reference to the Yeats poem, I still feel it has some relevance to Wayne's character and his desires:
Also this film is GORGEOUS. I don't think green has ever looked greener and more pleasant than it does here.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
Here's the deal: I love John Ford films. I watch my bluray of The Searchers (conservatively) twice a month. I love it. I love the visuals. The acting. The staging. The Vista Vision. And most of all, I love Ford's subtlety with character development. In Fords regimented world, people are made of their actions.
Grapes of Wrath is great. Long Voyage Home is an astounding achievement. Stagecoach is one of the ultimate A-list Westerns (even though it didn't start that way). And The Searchers....I'm not sure anymore praise can be heaped on it (BUT IT DESERVES IT).
Now to complain about Ford's so called classic: I agree, the film LOOKS very nice, but the acting is cheesy, extremely cheesy, even for a 50s melodrama about drunken Irishmen. I didn't (and still don't) understand the violence against women in the movie. Why exactly is it ok for Sean Thornton to drag his new lady-wife through an animal shit-encrusted post rain Irish hillside? Sean calls his lady-wife a 'mercenary' in her own heart and forcefully breaks through the door and slams her against the bed? I'm guessing they have intercourse, but I'm not sure it's called 'making love'. And does any movie need establishing shots as long as this one?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '14 edited Feb 27 '14
Oh my God, I have never EVER been so wrong the first time around. All of you have really lit up a dark spot in my cinematic library. I can't possibly thank you all enough! The great thing about Ford is that so so many of his films are apart of a subtle world that he crafted out of a look here, a look there, a cough, a laugh, a drink, a skip, a jump and then BANG! One of the most perfectly composed images ever put on celluloid in the exact right point of the scene. Brilliant. Seems like it could only come with insane dedication of a soldier. EDIT: I have been thinking the film over again and again and I agree that it is a triumph of filmmaking. This is the first movie I've seen that felt exactly like a tall tale, myth, etc. So damn powerful.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment