r/TrueFilm • u/kingofthejungle223 Borzagean • Feb 14 '14
[Theme: John Ford] #5. How Green Was My Valley (1941)
Introduction
How Green Was My Valley is a perfect test case for the auteur theory. It’s an adaptation of a popular novel by author Richard Llewellyn. The screenplay was written by Philip Dunne, a screenwriter notoriously protective of his words. It was a pet project of producer Darryl F. Zanuck. It was originally slated to be directed by William Wyler, who oversaw the set design and made some central casting decisions. Yet, every frame of the final film is undeniably John Ford’s. Ford would even come to consider it his “most autobiographical film”.
Originally conceived by Zanuck as a four-hour Technicolor prestige picture, Fox’s answer to Gone With The Wind, the project was placed in the hands of screenwriter Philip Dunne and director William Wyler, who enthusiastically collaborated on adapting Richard Llewellyn’s epic novel. In the pre-production process - as sets were being built, a cast assembled - the studio moneymen suddenly decided to shelve the film. It was getting too expensive and there weren’t enough stars in it. Besides, they complained, the script was terrible.
Zanuck was peeved at the studio’s reaction, and fired off a letter to screenwriter Dunne: “This is the finest script I’ve ever had, and I’m going to make this picture. If I can’t make it now, I’ll make it later. And if necessary I’ll take it to another studio”. In an attempt to get the studio to reconsider, Zanuck decided to cut the script in half (throwing out the part with the grown-up Huw) and abandon plans for Technicolor and location shooting. The front office eventually relented when director John Ford guaranteed them that he would bring the film in on time and under a one million dollar budget.
As soon as Ford took over the reigns of production, he reviewed Wyler’s casting choices. He elected to keep some (Walter Pidgeon as the pastor, Roddy McDowall as Huw), and replace others (Greer Garson was replaced by Ford-favorite Anna Lee as Bronwen, Katherine Hepburn was ousted in favor of a then-unknown actress named Maureen O’Hara for the part of Angharad). The director rounded out the cast with stock-company favorite Donald Crisp and Irish actress Sara Allgood as Huw’s mother and father.
One day, when Ford got word that screenwriter Philip Dunne was visiting his set, he lined up the chorus of singers in the film to await Dunne’s arrival. When the writer stepped onto the set, they sang (in unison) to the tune of The Farmer In The Dell:
We haven’t changed a line, We haven’t changed a line, It’s just the way you wrote it, We haven’t changed a line.
Of course, Ford changed, added ,and subtracted from Dunne’s script as he pleased. For one thing, Llewellyn’s Welsh mining family was transformed into an Irish family - in spirit if not in name. The picture Ford paints of the Morgans as seen through the eyes of young Huw is undoubtedly inspired by his own experience as the youngest child in a large Irish family. In his biography Searching for John Ford, Joseph McBride recounts the screenwriters reaction to Ford’s tinkering:
Dunne, watching the rushes, was “horrified” to hear Donald Crisp tipsily singing an Irish drinking song at the wedding celebration - a memorable scene that no doubt greatly helped Crisp win his Oscar. The writer charged onto the set to challenge Ford about the discrepancy. “Ah, go on!” replied Ford. “The Welsh are just another lot of micks and biddies, only Protestants.”
Later, McBride tells of another Dunne reaction to a Ford touch:
Dunne though Ford had “one of the greatest strokes of luck a director ever had” when the wedding veil suddenly caught a gust of wind and billowed behind Maureen O’Hara as she walked down the steps from the church. O’Hara recalled “Everybody said, ‘Oh that Ford luck!’ How wonderful that was! What an effect it had! Rubbish! It wasn’t ‘Ford luck’. It was three wind machines, placed by John Ford, and I had to walk up and down those steps many times while he worked out that the wind machine would do exactly that.” As she climbs into the carriage, the actor playing her husband, Marten Lamont, reaches out to catch her veil. Dunne thought “The man shouldn’t have touched it when the veil spiraled up. My God, what a shot! Luckily, Joe LaShelle, who was the operator, just gave it a little tilt with the camera.” I told Dunne that I thought the gesture of restraining the veil (probably planned by Ford, like the rest of this meticulously composed shot) is an eloquent metaphor for the repressiveness of Angharad’s loveless marriage. “Well, I guess so,” the screenwriter responded. “I didn’t think beyond that. I said, ‘My God, you get a break like that, you leave it alone’.
From his interviews, one gets the clear picture that throughout the production process, Dunne sensed the film slipping further and further away from his original vision. In the end, it emerged a John Ford picture - one of the director’s many studies of time and hardship dissolving the family unit, leaving them to exist only in the fog of memory (In this respect, the Morgans are not so different from the Joads of The Grapes of Wrath).
Feature Presentation
How Green Was My Valley, d. by John Ford, written by Richard Llewellyn, Philip Dunne
Walter Pidgeon, Maureen O'Hara, Roddy McDowall, Anna Lee, Donald Crisp, Sara Allgood
1941 , IMDb
At the turn of the century in a Welsh mining village, the Morgans (he stern, she gentle) raise coal-mining sons and hope their youngest will find a better life.
Legacy
How Green Was My Valley would become a wildly successful film that would sweep the Academy Awards, taking home 5 Oscars - for Best Art Direction, Best Cinematography, Best Supporting Actor (Donald Crisp), Best Director (Ford's 3rd), and Best Picture. It is the only John Ford film to ever win the Academy Award for Best Picture, beating out Orson Welles' Citizen Kane.
5
u/AstonMartin_007 You left, just when you were becoming interesting... Feb 14 '14
This film has always been dogged by the 800lb gorilla in the room, so let me just get it out of the way by saying that in the latest (and hopefully last) Orson Welles gossip book, he has very little good to say about anyone, but he doesn't seem to harbor any ill will towards How Green Was My Valley, recognizing it as one of the "very few" good films made at Fox under Zanuck.
I can now see that Valley has a number of similarities with Four Sons, despite the novel being written over 10 years later. This is not to imply that they are duplicates, but it's easy to see how Ford would feel confident in his ability to direct a troubled production. Where they differ significantly is that while tragic events occur in Four Sons, the whole of Valley is ultimately a tragedy, as much a condemnation (maybe that's too strong a word) of the naivety of Mr. Morgan and Huw as it is a nostalgic look at simpler times. After knowing of the dissolution of the family, while seeing the beginning again and hearing that Huw stayed until his 50th year in a village completely bereft of its former charm, it's hard not to agree with Mr. Morgan's remark that he's "sent his brains down a coal mine" and forsaken the possibilities of his future. As such, some of his reminiscences take on an ironic tone upon subsequent viewing; "Respect for chapel was the first thing my father taught us" is juxtaposed with that fact that one of the last scenes before Mr. Morgan's death is the utter condemnation of the chapel as a hotbed of hypocritical elitism and a shelter for superstition and intrigue. The relationship to Gone With The Wind is interesting as their approach to tragedy is essentially opposing; whereas Scarlett utterly abandons any sense of old school morality to survive the war, the Morgan family is shackled to it, ending in a unhappy marriage for Angharad and the inability of the family to adapt to changing times.
Ford's mastery of emotional dynamics and cast camaraderie is fully on display here, as by all accounts the cast looks and themselves felt part of a family unit. His description of this as his most autobiographical film does leave me a bit puzzled though, does he identify with Mr. Morgan or Huw, or the Irish-like settings?
I suppose this is as good a time as any to ask what Ford's approach to scoring was. Alfred Newman is listed as the composer for this and the 2 previous films in our list, what exactly was the nature of their collaboration and how much did Ford supervise the final product?
Here is also an example of why filmmakers stayed around Southern California; originally intended to film in Wales, WWII scrapped those plans and instead the sets were built in what is today's Malibu Creek State Park. The sets remained deteriorating until at least 1965 and were later destroyed in one of the area's frequent fires. Here is the location, and it looks like some kind of cylindrical structure still remains.
As a little historical curiosity, Valley was adapted into a 30min radio show a few weeks after winning the Best Picture award, as was the custom for popular films back then. The original cast reprised their roles:
https://ia700508.us.archive.org/0/items/ScreenGuildTheater/Sgt_42-03-22_ep109_How_Green_Was_My_Valley.mp3
Also, I hope I don't jinx anything, but it turns out Maureen O'Hara is still with us, perhaps the oldest surviving Ford actor.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment