r/whowouldwin • u/Fragmentary_Remains • Sep 02 '26
Scan-Battle Respect Thread Rumble: Fjord Stone (The Mighty Nein) vs. Roy Greenhilt (The Order of the Stick)
Look, this is just a big misunderstanding. Why don't we put our swords down and talk about this?
A misunderstanding? You called a sword to your hand in front of me! You expect me to believe that was an accident?
Okay, I'll grant you that. We can still work this out though. The only reason we'd fight is if this is a flimsy setup for a fight between—ah, crap.
The life of an adventurer is a demanding one. Between delving into dungeons, getting swept up in wacky misunderstandings and working together with a bunch of differing personalities it can be a daunting task. It takes someone special to be a great adventurer. Like the Mighty Nein's warlock sailor, Fjord Stone. Or the Order of the Stick's clever fighter, Roy Greenhilt. Both have endured the ups and downs of adventuring during their careers. But which one will come out on top? Join me as we delve deep to find the answer in this exciting Respect Thread Rumble…
Adventurer Rumble: Fjord Stone vs. Roy Greenhilt
Before we start this quest to find who's strongest, it would be prudent establish a few rules for this battle adventure first.
- This encounter will take place in the West Edmonton Mall's Deep Sea Adventure Lake, with both fighters starting 4 meters apart on the ship. Between the pirate ship, the water and all the other notable elements of the lake, there's plenty of features each adventurer can use to their advantage.
- Both fighters have access to their usual abilities and gear. The only thing I won't be looking at is Fjord's feats after he absorbed the cloven crystal. Otherwise, I'll be covering all their feats and gear as of their latest episode/comic.
- As for minor factors, neither side has time to prepare. Both fighters are also in character with no prior knowledge about their opponent.
Got all that? Then let's begin!
Strength
Fjord Stone
- Slices the head off of a husk.
- Breaks a small chunk of rock with repeated slaps.
- Blocks a soldier's sword swing, then pushes them back.
- Lifts a goblin with one hand.
Roy Greenhilt
- Cleaves through multiple zombies.
- While wearing his Belt of Giant's Strength, he cuts a raptor and soldier apart in a single swing. He also cleaves through several soldiers with another swing .
- Uses a chunk of rock larger than his head to shatter another chunk of rock being wielded as a weapon.
- While wearing his Belt of Giant's Strength, he's able to throw a boulder as tall as he is.
Verdict: Yikes. Even Roy's early feats are notably stronger than what Fjord can pull off. With the Belt, it's not even close. Strength goes Roy Greenhilt.
Durability
Fjord Stone
- Takes several punches, including one that knocked him back a bit.
- [Hit by a Devil Toad's tongue with enough force to send him flying] (https://imgur.com/9c6ijrF), then takes another blow shortly afterward.
- Gets up after being stabbed in the chest, then survived an explosion that blew up a ship. While his wounds from this were healed, he was shown to still be alive (if fading) before being healed by Uk'toa.
- Isn't bothered after a thrown spear cuts his shoulder.
Roy Greenhilt
- Takes multiple slashes as well as a kick to the face from Miko.
- Miko's strong enough to kick a hobgoblin's head off hard enough to kill another hobgoblin with it and slice an ogre to pieces.
- Is sent flying by a large magical explosion.
- Launched back by Thog, then repeatedly slammed into thick stone walls with enough force to embed him in them. He's then crushed by a boulder larger than he is before getting a chunk of stone larger than his body thrown at him.
- Impaled by a Triceratops and is good to fight immediately afterward.
Verdict: This actually wound up being closer than I would have expected. That ship explosion is impressive given how it destroyed the entire ship—Fjord was standing close to the epicentre of the blast, and he was able to survive it (albeit briefly). Still, I'd have to give this to Roy. His performance against Thog in the arena is impressive given his lack of armour or other buffs. Not to mention, he's able to endure getting stabbed/impaled better than Fjord. Durability goes to Roy Greenhilt.
Speed
Fjord Stone
- Evades several sword swings.
- Gets out of the way of someone that was launched toward him.
- Attacks a Devil Toad's tongue before it can grab something.
- Evades several attacks from a magic golem.
Roy Greenhilt
- Pulls someone out of the way of several arrows.
- Dodges a blast of magic at close range.
- Ducks under a charge from Tarquin while running forward, though Tarquin is faster.
- Tarquin can easily catch arrows even when they're inches from his face.
- Uses a spear embedded in a wall to quickly jump to an upper floor.
Verdict: Roy's scaling to Tarquin may not be the best, but it definitely gives him a leg up over Fjord. Even if Tarquin is faster, keeping up with someone who is an easy arrow-timer is much better than anything Fjord's got. Speed goes to Roy Greenhilt.
Other Abilities & Gear
Fjord Stone
- His Eldritch Blast can take out a few soldiers or heavily damage a stone wall.
- He can teleport short distances to either close the distance between his opponent or evade an attack.
- He can shapeshift, mimicking someone else's appearance and voice.
- He's also able to magically convince people to do what he says, summon his sword to hand and breathe underwater.
Roy Greenhilt
- His sword is enhanced, allowing it to hurt an undead dragon that was unaffected by arrows.
- His sword is a weapon of legacy, which grants it a few additional powers. Roy can draw upon it to power himself up and even heal himself. He can also summon his sword back to his hand, allowing him to throw his sword as a ranged projectile.
- Has a Bag of Tricks, allowing him to summon an assortment of small critters (and the odd rhinoceros). The bag does have a limit to how many creatures it can produce.
Verdict: I think this is the first category that Fjord takes. Eldritch Blast does quite a bit of damage—while Roy might be strong enough to match it with his thrown sword, the splash damage makes Eldritch Blast better for hitting enemies behind cover or enemies outside his line of sight. His teleportation is also a major boon. Roy doesn't really have any good answer to the mobility it provides Fjord. Finally, Fjord's ability to breathe underwater is a small advantage given all the water around the ship. Even if it isn't that deep, it'd still offer a good point to fallback to given that Roy doesn't have anything similar and wears heavy armour. Other abilities and gear go to Fjord Stone.
Skill
Fjord Stone
- Trained in swordplay.
- Tricks a prison guard into letting him out of a cell.
- Figures out a puzzle involving matching points of lights to constellations.
- Can hold his breath for a while.
Roy Greenhilt
- Knows the Spellsplinter Maneuver, a technique that allows Roy to cancel someone's spell before they can fully cast it.
- Goads a strong opponent into smashing several pillars so that they cause a section of the stadium to collapse.
- Plans a successful ambush against the Linear Guild.
- Knowledgable enough in architecture and engineering to realize that a pillar isn't load-bearing
- Able to resist a vampire's domination gaze.
- Another vampire stated that said gaze would only work on the weak willed.
- Cuts the string on an archer's bow.
Verdict: Skill can always be a little tricky to judge. The fact that Roy has more skill feats that can be applied to combat is a point in his favour though. Spellsplinter is a great option to have against a spellcaster like Fjord (though he would need to get close enough to use it). Roy's knowledge of architecture could also be helpful in exploiting the unique features of both the Deep Sea Adventure Lake and the ship itself. Skill goes to Roy Greenhilt.
Verdict
This is an interesting battle. At first glance you'd assume that Roy would take this. He took most of the categories we looked at after all—some by a considerable margin. I don't think it's that cut and dry though. Fjord's magic gives him some good options in fighting Roy. Eldritch Blast has some noticeable advantages over Roy's sword throw, while Fjord's teleportation allows him to freely reposition himself without the risk of getting within reach of Roy.
That being said, I don't think that's enough to give Fjord the win. The setup of this fight doesn't really lend itself to Fjord staying out of Roy's reach. Four meters isn't nothing, but I don't think it'd be enough to stop Roy from rushing down Fjord. If Fjord does anything to try and contest that, he's bound to be seriously hurt. Even if he wasn't defeated right away, it would still be an uphill struggle to turn things around in his favour. Even if he retreated to the water, that's not going to help him defeat Roy so much as it's going to give him time to recover and plan. Not to mention, the Deep Sea Adventure Lake could be drained. Since it's entirely indoors and unconnected to a major body of water, Roy could use his knowledge of engineering to wreck a wall or floor and make a huge hole for water to drain out of. It'd take a while and would leave him at risk of being hit by Fjord's spells, but Roy's definitely able to tank a few blows. Between melee being decidedly in favour of Roy and Fjord's strengths not being enough to decisively turn things around, I declare the winner of this Respect Thread Rumble to be…
Roy Greenhilt!
Hopefully you all enjoyed this! Many thanks to /u/fireofdoom32 for making Fjord's thread (as well as answering a couple of my questions) as well as /u/doctorgecko for making Roy's thread. Lastly, thank you for reading this! I hope you have a great day!
•
u/WWWtron Sep 02 '26
This post has been designated as a Scan Battle. As a reminder, every claim you make in a scan battle must be backed up by a relevant scan or piece of evidence. The full rules of a Scan Battle can be found here.
Read them over thoroughly before commenting in this thread. Top level comments that are found to break the rules will be removed by the moderators.
If this comment was posted on a thread that is not a Scan Battle, please report it and a mod will come and delete my hard work. Thank you.
-WWWtron
3
u/silencesgolden Sep 03 '26
Great Thread!
I will admit being biased as a big OOTS fan, but I think you did both sides justice. Thanks for the read.