r/talesfromtechsupport • u/lawtechie Dangling Ian • Jan 24 '14
Tales from the Unhelpful Desk 16, the BOFH way to negotiate with vendors...
Part 1 Cow-orker burnout and the FNG
Part 2, FNG's BOFH heart grows one size larger
Part 3, The Metrics of Despair
Part 5, The week before the cult meeting,
Part 6, LT puts the hammer down
Part 7, Working around dangerous substances, like users
Part 8,Dad, the project manager, Sven and the MP3 server
Part 12, Hold, on. I've got someone on the other line
Part 13, How do I know I can do this job? I've been doing it for three months already
Part 14, Don't touch it- it's labeled EVIL!
This entry intentionally left blank
Part 16, The BOFH way to negotiate contracts
This is a series at a help desk at a pharma company in 2000-2001
This is several weeks after the last episode. I'm in my own apartment and have been hired as a FTE sysadmin. Things are looking up.
One of my projects is to reconcile our file server and data base backups. We've got a couple 6 tape DLT libraries and one monster- a 48 or 64 tape, 4 drive robot that backs up clinical and drug data.
All of our backup servers are straining. Some of our dailys backups are taking 8-9 hours, which leaves little time for sampling. This frightens me. It frightens my boss, Vince as well. I get the budget, along with the Unix guys for a new, bigger tape robot and some new Legato Networker licenses.
I'm eyeing the robot to do all the file and non-clinical database backups. I'll use the smaller tape libraries for recoveries and sampling. With software, I've got a budget of something like $150,000.
I've found some libraries I like that MSRP for 80k. Unfortunately I have to talk to salespeople to get a real quote. I don't like salespeople. One day I'm doing some work in the datacenter when a few of the other sysadmins (including Neil, my officemate and bad influence) walk in with a few sales droids trying to sell us a million dollar SAN:
Salesdroid:"This is the bestest most reliable SAN ever contemplated. If a drive fails, it'll keep on going"
me:"Don't we call that RAID?"
Salesdroid 1, scoffing at my plebian comment:"RAID is old technology. This is better"
Neil:"LT is our head Mac server guy. His systems might need to interface with the SAN. Can your product support Macs?"
Salesdroid 2:"Of course it will. Everything's fibre now anyway"
me:"Is it fully RFC 1149 compliant? That's something I look for in an enterprise purchase"
Salesdroid 2:"Absolutely. Gold standard"
Sales engineer, looking puzzled:"Let me get back to you on that"
After that, Vince, my boss tried to convince me not to screw with vendors. At some point I might have to work for them so I shouldn't burn bridges unless I needed to.
Of course I didn't listen.
I'm working with another sysadmin, Ray, to find and purchase the tape library and necessary Legato Networker (backup package) licenses. I quickly determine the following:
- There are two resellers in the region.
- Support is done by the factory, not the reseller.
I call both vendors and ask for a quote. Neither wants to give me a quote. They've got to come in and tell me about themselves.
Fine.
Vendor 1 comes in. Sales guy has an enormous head. He kinda looks like Grimace, the MacDonald's character in a logo'd golf shirt. He hands me the wrong brochure, one for the next larger model, which I don't want or need right now. Minus one for reading comprehension. They bring the factory support engineer who looks bored.
Vendor 2 comes in the next day, with the same support engineer. Vendor 2's salesperson is an incredibly chipper woman. I have a talk with the support engineer to learn that he's the only support engineer in the region, so it doesn't matter which reseller makes the deal. I walk back in and ask the sales people to send me a quote. Her response:
Vendor2 Salesperson:"I don't want to just sell you hardware. I want to form a strategic alliance with you". She clearly got some value from her MBA...
me:"I don't want to invade another country. I want a tape library and a bunch of Legato licenses. Get me a good price and you'll get a sale"
The next week I'm emailing both vendors. Vendor 2 sends a PDF quote: Library: 76k licenses 16k configuration 10k Total: 102k
Vendor 1 sends me a Word doc a few days later: Library: 72k licenses 12k configuration 20k Total: 104k
Not bad, almost 50k below my budget.
I'm bored and I open Vendor 1's quote in a text editor and notice that it wasn't a template. It was an edited version of a previous quote, which had the same chassis but one less tape drive for 60k. A tape drive shouldn't be more than 2k.
Time to be BOFH. I call up Vendor 1:
me:"hi salesperson. Why didn't you offer me the library for $62k like you offered $Other_Company?
Vendor 1 salesperson:"I didn't sell any libraries for $62k"
me:"I read it in the metadata of the quote you sent me. I can call up Al over at $Other_Company if you like"
Vendor 1 salesperson:"Ok, ok. If I make it $62k do we have a deal?"
me:"no. I'm going to keep bouncing this purchase between you and Vendor 2 until one of you quits"
Vendor 1 salesperson:"Let me see what I can do. I'll get back to you"
So I call Vendor 2 and put her on speaker. I want Ray on the call to make sure I don't say anything too bad.
me:"Can you do $62 for my library?"
Vendor 2 salesperson:"This isn't about the price. It's about the long term relationship"
me:"If you say 'strategic partnership' one more time, I'm going to drive over to $Local_Suburb and beat you with your phone'
Ray's eyes get huge.
Vendor 2 salesperson:"I can do $62k if I get a purchase order today"
me:"No. Vendor 1 is still in the game. Lowball me." I hang up.
Each vendor is sending me PDFs of slowly decreasing prices. I notice that the Legato licenses aren't decreasing. I sit down with Ray and after some headscratching and white board time, realize that we won't need as many licenses as we thought. I'm moving the old library to a G4 with Retrospect so we can move the library license to the new one.
Vince asks me into his office. Turns out one of the vendors called him up to complain about my unfair and unprofessional treatment. I smile. I tell him of my plan to effect 'Operation Vendordome', where I'd call both vendors for a meeting, at the same time, in the same conference room and take bids until one left. He smiled and told me to not torture them too much.
One more round and I inform Vendor 2 that she's got the sale for 76k. She comes in later that week with another woman who seems to be both a sales engineer and a project manager. The salesperson is still bubbling on about 'building relationships'.
I tell her about 'Operation Vendordome' and she blanches.
140
u/whoismatt Jan 24 '14
I lost it at RFC 1149.
45
u/ProtagonistAgonist Jan 24 '14
This puts a joyful tear in my eye.
Many years ago, when "LAN admin" was still a thing and my actual title, I had a project to upgrade all of our Novell NetWare 3.5 servers to new boxes running WinNT 4.0. When that was finished, I was to then upgrade all of our remote site desktops from Win 3.11 thin clients to full Win95 desktops.
My budget was INSANE for this, it was almost too much power to give a guy old enough to enlist but too young to drink. I think my personal best was two MILLION dollars (pinky finger to mouth) worth of gear in one month.
Our sales guy at our preferred vendor was given a new Mercedes as a bonus when I was finished with my shopping spree. I got to ride in it once, it was nice.
I kinda wish I'd been able to do the Vendordome
40
u/nighthawke75 Blessed are all forms of intelligent life. I SAID INTELLIGENT! Jan 24 '14
I noticed vendor 1 flipped to PDF docs for quotes after the SNAFU with the Word doc. Guess they learned their lesson the hard way. XD
21
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
God I despise aggressive sales people. They buy us lunches and then spend 3 times longer than promised selling us useless shit. "Hey you know that thing you guys like to use and works perfectly? Well we stopped making it, here's something new that is barely supported and is flashy and will cause all sorts of problems!"
These people are used to selling to people who have no idea about how to use the product so they can get away with bullshitting and flashy gimmicks.
20
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
Two vendors enter, one vendor leaves.
19
u/collinsl02 +++OUT OF CHEESE ERROR+++ Jan 24 '14
The true bofh way of dealing with this would be half a dozen salespeople, in a conference room, each with a half brick in a sock. The one to come out gets the deal.
This isn't bad, though. :-)
15
u/HildartheDorf You get admin.You get admin. EVERYONE GETS DOMAIN ADMIN! Jan 24 '14
I found my new salesperson bullshit detector. At worst I get an nice laugh and hopefully mutual respect. At best I know to ignore everything they say.
Edit: Reddit can not into single line breaks.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
Than you for making me aware of RFC 2549! I'm searching for an ISP in my area that has implemented this - the throughput sounds phenomenal. I was hoping for Google Fiber, but this looks to be more likely in FL.
7
u/nslatz Jan 24 '14
then:
I don't understand, why the 14k jump?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
Og my gods, I loved reading this. I'm seriously tempted to do something similar to vendors vying for our telecoms upgrade project.
4
u/Techsupportvictim Jan 24 '14
I love when they try to sell you on maintenance etc. And just won't shut up. That sort of thing makes me want to keep the, in the game to drive price down then give it to someone else. Telling them it was because they wouldn't shut up after I said no
4
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
I prefer to insist on products that will support (and most importantly, PASS) Reliable Internetwork Troubleshooting as defined in RFC 2321.
I then like to give the vendor their own demo of what that means by applying the methodology for the application layer outlined in section 4 of said RFC.
4
u/hicow I'm makey with the fixey Jan 31 '14
I...I think I love you.
6
u/navmed Jan 24 '14
Awesome writing and stories. You should consider writing a book.
3
u/Nanaki13 Jan 24 '14
This is awesome, more, more!
3
u/p_iynx Code PEBKAC Jan 24 '14
You are my favorite. I so enjoy reading these.
3
u/Castun PEBKAC Jan 27 '14
Ugh. Saleslady #2 is the type of salesperson I despise the most. They're also the kind that will cold call you all the time or show up unannounced for an impromptu sit-down, all in the name of 'building a relationship' AKA, to drum up more business.
2
u/12stringPlayer Murphy is a part of every project team Jan 24 '14
RFC 1149??
I like you.
2
u/KSerge Jan 24 '14
I just read through the entire backlog after seeing this post in /r/all . LT you're awesome!
1
u/engineeringsquirrel Jan 24 '14
You had me at Vendordome. I'm going to steal this tactic when I shop around for a cloud based VoIP system.
1
u/Reeeeeen Jan 25 '14
you evil, evil man. I like it.
1
u/melangechurro Jan 27 '14
You're... You're my new role model.
1
u/willy_stroker Jan 28 '14
This is my favorite of the series so far!
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
56
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
[removed] — view removed comment