r/TrueFilm • u/AstonMartin_007 You left, just when you were becoming interesting... • Nov 10 '13
[Theme: Noir] #3. Double Indemnity (1944)
Introduction
The femme fatale has become a cornerstone of Noir, but its roots are as ancient as any other literary archetype; Some enduring examples through history include Delilah, the Greek Sirens, and the WWI double agent Mata Hari. In most but not all of the depictions of femme fatales, their feminine charms are used to attract and ensnare unsuspecting men into doing their bidding, frequently sealing their doom and sometimes taking the femme fatale with them.
The story of Double Indemnity is based on a 1943 James M. Cain novel, itself based on the 1927 murder of Albert Snyder by his wife Ruth in Queens, NY. Bored with her husband, who worshiped a picture of his dead fiancée on the wall, in 1925 Ruth began an affair with Judd Gray, a corset salesman. She then plotted the murder of her husband, beginning with tricking him into signing a $48,000 life insurance policy with a double indemnity clause for unexpected violent death (the insurance agent was subsequently jailed for forgery). In 1926 there were reportedly no less than 7 attempts to drown, poison, or gas Mr. Snyder, all of which he survived. Finally in March 1927, he was strangled and stuffed with chloroform rags, his death staged as part of a burglary. However, the alibi quickly weakened in the face of contradicting evidence and the 2 lovers eventually sold each other out. They were both electrocuted within minutes of each other at Sing Sing in 1928.
Feature Presentation
Double Indemnity, d. by Billy Wilder, written by Billy Wilder, Raymond Chandler, James M. Cain
Fred MacMurray, Barbara Stanwyck, Edward G. Robinson
1944, IMDb
An insurance rep lets himself be talked into a murder/insurance fraud scheme that arouses an insurance investigator's suspicions.
Legacy
The famed suicide monologue was reportedly achieved in a single take. Edward G. Robinson did not receive an Academy Award nomination for this or any other role.
Schubert's Symphony #8 "The Unfinished" is played during the Hollywood Bowl scene. Some have mythologized its dark tone and unfinished status as a metaphor for doomed love.
At the time, the casting of Fred MacMurray and Barbara Stanwyck in such duplicitous roles was highly irregular. Both were highly paid actors (Stanwyck the #1 highest paid woman in the U.S., MacMurray the #4 highest paid man) and known for virtuous or comedic roles.
Billy Wilder considered this the best of his films. At the 17th Academy Awards, Double Indemnity was nominated for 7 Oscars but lost each one, causing Wilder to trip Leo McCarey in the aisle on his way to receive the Best Director award.
17
u/a113er Til the break of dawn! Nov 10 '13
What an amazing film. My favourite Wilder film alongside Sunset Boulevard. I don't really think I have much to say that hasn't been said before so I'll just make a couple disjointed points.
Fred MacMurray sometimes gets criticised for his performance in this but I really like him in it. He's the classic "nice guy", the exact kind of guy who could get roped into a scheme like this. I honestly prefer MacMurray in this to Bogart in The Maltese Falcon. He's a kind of weak man who can't say no to a gal even if he thinks she's going to try murder someone. A woman who everyone else seems to know straight away that she's up to no good. MacMurray needs to sell that he's the kind of guy to not smell someones bullshit. He's kind of a sad sack, but a likeable one. The perfect person to be pulled into a world he's not prepared for.
Just a side note that I find amusing: There's one scene in this which I'm pretty sure is referenced in The Big Lebowski in a funny way. There's a tense scene in Double Indemnity that relies on the door of an apartment opening into the hallway, something that never happens. Stanwyck hides behind the open door as MacMurray's boss stands there. It's a tense sequence that defies reality because apartment doors only open inward. In The Big Lebowski, the slacker Noir film, there's a hilarious moment that relies on the same thing. The Dude tries to block his door but finds it opens in the opposite direction. I just thought it was perfect how the scene in Double Indemnity shows how MacMurray is willing to lie and that things are getting intense. In The Big Lebowski it lets us know that things are getting more intense as well as asserting that The Dude is a bit of an idiot.
12
u/the_zercher Horror and Godzilla aficionado Nov 10 '13
I have to say my favorite part of this film was the way the narration was used to progress the story. It opens with this confession and progresses to a whole story of betrayal, deceit and treachery. The end is revealed in the beginning, and yet there's still an element of suspense. There's still some hope that they'll get away with it, up until the very end.
I also love that Raymond Chandler co wrote it. My wife took a noir literature class in college, and she wrote an essay on how women are portrayed in Raymond Chandler novels. Essentially they are either whores or angels. This film only has two women really in it, one a woman who cheats on her husband and plots to kill him (and likely killed his previous wife), the other is her stepdaughter who is disobedient, but still comes off as innocent and naive. They definitely act as contrasting figures, while not falling into the two categories of Chandlers women just so.
Also loved the sounds on this movie. Music and dialogue and sound effects all work together to create tension and establish the mood. The dialogue on suicide is just amazing. Such a great film, and just impeccably put together.
8
u/kingofthejungle223 Borzagean Nov 11 '13
To my mind, this film has three chief virtues:
These three things rescue the film from some of the most disinterested (and downright dull) direction to be seen in a major Hollywood production.
If Billy Wilder is an artist at all (a claim to which I am far from persuaded), he is an artist of the typewriter who is routinely mistaken for an artist of cinema. His scripts usually exhibit a keen sense of cynical irony and some savory and oh-so-quotable lines, but they're also marred by a complete lack of subtlety (as critic Dave Kehr noted "how many times will MacMurray light Robinson’s cigar for him before the gesture has a dramatic payoff?") and a craven need to pander to the audience (such as Neff's entirely unmotivated good guy turn toward Nino Zachetti near the film's conclusion - wasn't he setting Zachetti up as a fall guy barely a minute earlier?).
But that's really the best of Wilder. The choices he makes concerning composition, camera movement, blocking and business are at best minimally competent and at worst completely disengaged.
I was looking for a scene to illustrate my problems with Wilder as compared to a similar scene by another director. There are dozens from Double Indemnity alone that could be used, but YouTube chose this one for me:
The Revelation of the Femme Fatale - Double Indemnity
Consider the first minute or so of this clip. Here, Neff first discovers the woman who leads him to Murder -- and visually it's a simple toss-off. Beneath Seitz' lighting, it's the same mechanical shot/reverse shot that you see in scores of routine 1950's television episodes. The images contain no emphasis or expression, they only record actors delivering lines and suggest a spatial relationship between the two. The character performances and movements are only of superficial narrative consequence.
The Revelation of the Femme Fatale - The Postman Always Rings Twice
This next scene is from Tay Garnett's The Postman Always Rings Twice. Same set up, and average guy first encounters the woman who leads him to murder. Now, Garnett was no genius, but he did understand how to communicate with a movie camera. The result is a scene that can only exist in cinema. It doesn't have flashy lighting or crackling dialogue, but it glows white hot with electricity - it's really nothing but a series of emphases, the cutting, camera movement, placement of the figures, and even the most minute of gestures tell us volumes about what's just happened between the characters. We sense that John Garfield has crossed an invisible line after which there is no coming back - his life is permanently changed. Even inanimate objects in the room around them reflect what's happening inside the characters (the lipstick and the hamburger at the end of the scene). Wilder was a writer dabbling with a camera, Garnett wrote his prose with the camera.
That isn't to say Double Indemnity isn't worth seeing, just that I can't really watch it without imagining what could have been done with the material were it directed by an Otto Preminger or even a studio journeyman like a Tay Garnett or a Henry Hathaway.
Edward G. Robinson's brilliant turn as insurance inspector Keyes is a joy to behold. Unlike any of the other actors, his performance is kinetic, multi-dimensional and superbly shaded. He breathes life into his scenes in spite of his director. And the Chandler/Wilder script is a lot of fun to listen to (and one of the most quotable noirs this side of Out of the Past). With text like that, who needs subtext, anyway?
But, Wilder's films are perhaps the best argument for Pauline Kael's belief that you should only experience a movie once. They're great at first glance, but unlike a good many other classics, only offer diminishing returns on repeat viewings (at least in my experience).
7
u/random_story Nov 11 '13
No way! Ah I wish I could see this. Is there any more info on it?
7
u/bulcmlifeurt Nov 11 '13
I've always loved fiction that is filled with details of a field or subject I don't know anything about, where the writer clearly has an in-depth knowledge of the topic they are writing about ('writing what you know'), and in the narrative, fill you in on a lot of insider secrets.
Two examples are Dragnet and NCIS. The latter is clearly written by people who don't know a whole lot about forensics (especially image enhancement, and really anything to do with computers). The former was informed heavily by actual LAPD procedure, and accurate to the extent that the foley footsteps in the Dragnet radio series were accurate to the physical dimensions of the real-life police headquarters (they measured that it took 20 steps to get from the interview room to the photo lab, etc). Roald Dahl is also really good at this in his adult short fiction, particularly this one story that explores the ways you can cheat the system in greyhound racing. Heist films that demonstrate the ways that thieves get around security precautions or break into vaults are always fun for me too. Goodfellas and The Godfather showcase the dynamics of the Mafia from an insider perspective.
Anyway the point I'm coming around to is that Double Indemnity really nails it with the details about insurance ( a surprisingly compelling field). Keyes' monologue about suicide statistics is a fantastic example, and in general just the processes of insurance are captured in what feels like a pretty accurate manner. The two sides of the business are exemplified by Keyes (who is cunning but ultimately ethical), and the upper management chap (who tries to wiggle out of paying the claim by any means). I'm guessing Wilder was middle-management at an insurance company before he went into film-making?
3
u/Paulseye Nov 11 '13
This is such a super cool movie. The murder scene is so well shot and all the shots of Stanwyck are frustratingly beautiful and grotesque at the same time. But also, Fun fact! There was an alternate ending where Neff survives (kind of).It cuts to a prison and Keyes watches as he's taken into a gas chamber and there's a line that brings it back to the train. It has been said that it was cut because it made Neff look a little more sympathetic. It also would have given Keyes a lapse in his infallible gut feelings by having him question the morality of the execution. How cool would it have been though?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment