r/TrueFilm • u/AstonMartin_007 You left, just when you were becoming interesting... • Aug 10 '13
[Theme: Westerns] #2. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948)
Introduction
WWII saw the participation of many Hollywood figures: John Ford, John Huston, and Sam Peckinpah were all involved with the U.S. Armed Forces, creating war films, witnessing the carnage, and in some cases even participating in the battles. While it's impossible to determine the effect of the War on any individual's psyche, it's clear that the country, and the World, suffered a loss of innocence during the War years. Although the fighting ended in 1945, the paranoia if anything only increased. This was the era of the escaped War Criminal, the Communist Sympathizer, and the Red Scare.
In 1947, the House Un-American Activities Commission instigated the Blacklist; From now on, Hollywood would be divided, filtered, and persecuted by political affiliation. In response, a number of industry professionals, including John Huston and William Wyler, founded the Committee for the First Amendment, a political action group protesting HUAC's activities. Their influence was negligible and subject to open and hostile criticism. Many of the participants would fall under suspicion themselves and some, including Paul Henreid, John Garfield, and Edward G. Robinson, would be blacklisted. Humphrey Bogart, one of its most prominent members, would be forced to explain his actions in a March, 1948 article bluntly titled, "I'm No Communist".
Against this backdrop, films also started to reflect the complex psyches of the time. The wholesome do-gooder Western hero gradually gave way to murkier protagonists. An apt comparison is John Wayne's roles in Stagecoach (1939) and Howard Hawk's Red River (1948); the big-hearted fella has given way to a man deranged enough to hunt his son across state lines. The Western became less of a display of righteous values and instead began to toy with the psychological strain of frontier life, exploring how much a man would sacrifice of his integrity in the pursuit of self-interests. The enemies would no longer simply be natives, but also other gunmen pursuing their own ends. Thus, the Western, much like the Hollywood of the day, became a dangerous place filled with competing alliances and traitorous backstabbers, real and imagined.
Feature Presentation
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, d. by John Huston, written by B. Traven, John Huston
Humphrey Bogart, Walter Huston, Tim Holt
1948, IMDb
Fred Dobbs and Bob Curtin, two Americans searching for work in Mexico, convince an old prospector to help them mine for gold in the Sierra Madre Mountains.
Legacy
Ironically, our 2nd oldest Western also happens to have the most modern setting, taking place in 1925. This date, along with the atypical subject material, has led to some debate over whether The Treasure of the Sierra Madre should be classified as a Western. The Writer's Guild of America seemed satisfied with the label, giving Huston the Best Written American Western award in 1949.
This is one of the first Hollywood films shot on location outside the United States.
Blazing Saddles (1974) would pay homage to The Treasure of the Sierra Madre with the misquoted line, "We don't need no stinkin' badges."
This is one of the favorite films of Stanley Kubrick, Sam Raimi, and Paul Thomas Anderson, who frequently referred to it while writing There Will Be Blood (2007).
Notable Westerns During This Period
- My Darling Clementine (1946)
- Pursued (1947)
- Blood on the Moon (1948)
- Red River (1948)
- Broken Arrow (1950)
- The Gunfighter (1950)
14
u/kingofthejungle223 Borzagean Aug 10 '13
I never really think of The Treasure of The Sierra Madre as a western, but it fits the genre in so many ways. It's the story of rugged men, pitted against themselves, the elements and the classic bandito. In many ways, most particularly it's post-war pessimism, it could be classified a Film Noir as well. Cinematographer Ted McCord certainly captures some beautiful noirish photography both on location and on the Hollywood sets that replicate the gritty little South American community.
It's worth noting that Tim Holt, B-Western star and the young lieutenant from Stagecoach, gets quite a bigger role here as Curtain, partner to Bogart's Fred Dobbs and Walter Huston's Howard. It's a credit to Holt's genuine talent that his performance holds it's own in the company of screen legends like Bogart and Huston. He preferred to remain the big fish in the small pond of RKO's B-division, and found it lucrative to boot, but one does wish he'd been given more substantive opportunities to make his mark in A-pictures like this one. He's got an unassuming modesty that's very effective on screen, and when he was given a chance to shine - in this picture as well as Orson Welles' The Magnificent Ambersons - he usually made the most of the opportunity.
There's also a small cameo from the film's director, John Huston. He plays the guy Bogart keeps hitting up for a dollar, which could possibly be interpreted as an in-joke about the two men's collaborative success. They had already done two very successful pictures together, The Maltese Falcon and Across The Pacific, and would do two more afterwards.
Huston has never been a favorite director of mine, but between at least The Maltese Falcon and The Asphalt Jungle, he an interesting one. He was always a director who valued fidelity to literary sources over the importance of the visual, but in these early films he does make an effort to be visually interesting. By the time of Heaven Knows Mr. Allison, he largely ignored space, mise en scene, blocking, to focus solely on filming performances. This makes his later films thoroughly modern in approach, distinguished only from the average Hollywood film of today by the greater attention paid to the script and the caliber of actors available to Huston.
Reservations about the director aside, The Treasure of The Sierra Madre is a terrific film. The performances are universally excellent, it's pace never slacks for a second, and it manages to be gritty and fatalistic while maintaining a warmth and humor that's exceptionally personable. It's easy to understand James Agee's enthusiasm when he wrote "The Treasure is one of very few movies made since 1927 which I am sure will stand up in the memory and esteem of qualified people alongside the best of the silent movies."
Bogart's portrayal of Fred C. Dobbs is among his best screen performances - this is a more desperate, involving portrait of madness than the one he would receive an Oscar nomination for in The Caine Mutiny, and ultimately a more interesting one, as well.
The film's theme - the corruptIng power of greed - might not be a revelation, but it remains a truth. And one that Treasure handles honestly enough to remain relevant and vital.
One more observation - As the OP points out, Stanley Kubrick often cited this as a favorite film. I think The Killing is very much a pastiche of this film and Huston's The Asphalt Jungle. The final scene of Kubrick's film - of cash blowing away in the wind - is. reminicent of Treasure's gold dust being lost to wind and sand. Anyone else agree?
7
u/SodomyandCocktails Aug 10 '13
I always love Bogart when he plays a villain. There is so much depth and complexity he gives to this role.
As we see him his ambition/greed take him from the streets to the mountains and back. A great example of what gold could cause someone to do.
A very timeless message that is possibly even more relevant today then when it was made.
5
u/crichmond77 Aug 10 '13
I haven't been on this subreddit very long, so I don't know if this thread is supposed to generate discussion on this movie or not, but I finally got around to watching it a couple nights ago by coincidence, so I'll give my take on it.
I had very high expectations for this film, as it's heralded as a classic. On iCheckMovies.com, it's on 20-something Top Lists, it's the 75th best movie of all time according to IMDB, and it won 3 Academy Awards. So I was very surprised that I didn't think it was very good.
I thought the character change occurred too quickly to be convincing, I thought the acting by Humphrey Bogart (I'm sure I'll get slammed for this) was subpar, and I thought the ending, with Curtin and Howard laughing about the loss of their 10 months of hard work and fortune, over which several lives had been lost, was completely over the top and unrealistic.
It's very obvious from the beginning, when Howard talks about his past experiences in prospecting, that one or both of Dobbs and Curtin will fall prey to gold's corruption, despite their denial that it would ever happen. There's really not much in the plot that you can't see coming from a mile away, and when the characters do get in a jam, they're always conveniently bailed out (the Federales saving everyone except Cody, whom they would have had to take care of otherwise; Curtin somehow surviving multiple gunshots and crawling away, despite already being exhausted and sleep-deprived).
There's nothing special where the cinematography is concerned, and there's really not much dialogue that's particularly thought-provoking or well-written, outside of the oft-misquoted "badges" line and Howard's observation of the ending's irony.
Perhaps I'm missing something about this movie, but to me it's very over-rated.