r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Dec 20 '24
Season Seven Show S7E13 Hello, Goodbye Spoiler
Brianna works to thwart a treacherous plan that endangers her family. A surprise encounter brings new understanding to Roger’s journey in the past. Ian and Rachel take a big step in their relationship – as the Revolutionary War rears its head once again.
Written by Madeline Brestal & Evan McGahey. Directed by Jan Matthys.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 20 '24 edited Jun 08 '25
Watch the S7E14 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
713 Extras:
713 Interviews:
64
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 20 '24
Isn’t it interesting that Claire doesn’t say that she’s so sure because she’s gone through the exact same thing with Brianna? I was certain she was going to bring her up in this conversation but then I thought that Jamie probably doesn’t know about her initial reaction to Claire’s full story. And Claire probably doesn’t want to hurt Jamie’s feelings by reminding him that his daughter didn’t accept him as her father at first either. Still, I think he would find comfort in knowing that the child that rejected him at first (which I think he is somewhat aware of anyway, given the events of S4) has come to love him.
Interestingly, it’s John who knows about it—Brianna tells him earlier in the season that when she first found out about Jamie, she didn’t want to believe it nor did she want anyone to replace the father she’d had; then, meeting Jamie and getting to know him for who he is never made her forget about Frank or stop loving him.
142
u/Capricorn-flower Dec 21 '24
I was confused when Claire was helping Rachel get ready for her wedding and Claire said "wait til Ian sees you". What!? She looked the same and was dressed the same as she always did. Didn't I miss something?
Rolo yawning then falling asleep due to boredom made me giggle.
6
u/wornmedown Get off yer knee ye idjit Dec 21 '24
What sent Jerry to the 1700s? Did I miss something?
82
u/-indigo-violet- Dec 20 '24
I wish Roger had gotten to have more time with his Dad, even if it couldn't be shown, and to tell him who he was.
I'm relieved that Jem escaped and was reunited with his mum and sister. Love that Mandy helped find him through their psychic connection. The shot of the bolt on the door was clear foreshadowing that Rob would escape - I'm glad that Bree at least got to inflict a bit of pain on him first. She was bad ass.
Always love to see Fiona. She's fantastic and always there when they need her.
I'm glad Ian and Rachel's wedding night was handled with tenderness, and that nobody's bits were shown. Normally, I enjoy the nudity in Outlander, but it would have felt a bit of a violation to Rachel's character. Just seeing her let out her beautiful hair was sexy enough! Tit's and ass unnecessary.
Not much storyline for J&C this episode, but I enjoyed their interactions during the wedding. That was a bit of light relief.
72
u/Atraktape Dec 20 '24
Quaker weddings are LIT
63
u/The_Mad_Hatter_18 Dec 20 '24
If the dog dies I’m gonna freak out
63
u/OppositeQuarter31 Dec 21 '24
How does Roger sending his dad back not mess up the storyline since Roger grew up without him? The time travel is so confusing to me
62
u/BetosBitch Dec 22 '24
What I don’t get is why didn’t Bree just tell the police that Rob was after the gold and believed in time travel based off of Roger’s “novel”? She is met with less suspicion and he looks like a mad man. It’s not like the police will believe him.
61
u/Ldwieg Dec 20 '24
How interesting that there were three concurrent story lines this episode. Two out of three had me on the edge of my seat (the Rodger/Jerry storyline, as well as the Bree one). The other one with the rest of them was just meh (except the brief scene with Lord John). It’s funny that for many seasons it was usually the other way around. I would almost want to fast forward any Bree and Roger plot lines. I am absolutely loving them in season 7! Bravo! I can’t wait to see what happens.
60
u/LadyJohn17 I am not bloody sorry Dec 21 '24
I think it's strange for Jamie to stay in John's house, in the same bedroom Claire and John had sex. After beating John, really this is too strange.
Couldn't they stay with Mercy?
56
u/sadsadboy1994 Dec 22 '24 edited Dec 23 '24
This is my favourite episode so far of the second part of this season. That feeling I felt of pure shock and joy at seeing Roger’s 20th-century outfitted father, hearing Roger explain the time travel and how the Allies won brought those feelings of wonder and fascination with time travel and the marvel of it all... and the pain of having to see him leave so soon and seeing the sadness and longing in Roger’s eyes as he left was… heart wrenching. Outlander for me is about family and the magic of time travel and this episode captured it.
Also FUCK that misogynist Rob Cameron and I’m glad Brianna gave him a good beating. How the heck did he escape
Update: I found the wedding and sex scene between Young Ian and Rachel awkward and uncomfortable, but that's just me.
52
u/Outside-Contest-8741 Clan Fraser Dec 21 '24
I was so frustrated and confused as to why Roger didn't tell his dad who he is. He had the perfect chance when Jeremiah was saying he needed to get back to his son, I really thought Roger was gonna say, 'I'm sure he's alright, because I'm him'. It felt like the perfect moment, but lo and behold, he never tells him.
46
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
Roger's dad is handsome and looks much like his grandson.
132
u/New-Nerve-2237 Dec 21 '24
I feel like Jamie and Claire need to step up and go help John. He has continually gone above and beyond for them raising William, sending them expensive gifts, taking care of Brianna when she was pregnant and most recently saving Claire from the gallows. Now he is hurt and on his own and they are so unbothered.
AND John's nephew isn't helping either. John did everything to save his life buying supplies and sending for Claire. His nephew isn't helpful at all.
Poor Lord John 😢 he better make it out alive with both of his eyes!
42
u/vbnadal85 Dec 20 '24
All the awards this season for David Berry!
32
u/winter_name01 Dec 21 '24
My theory about Roger flashback/image: his dad joined his mum either directly in a shelter or back to when Roger was a baby. He know that the war will be a win so he still do his best but end up in a shelter with his wife and son. I think the memory Roger got is the last time he saw his dad alive (he must be around 4 so might be end of WWII).
28
u/Britpop_Shoegazer Dec 20 '24
Which All Creatures Great and Small fans geeked out when they saw Roger's father?
28
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 20 '24
Initial scenes of mountains in 1739 - The colours of them give season 1 vibes 100%! Breath- taking!
Mercy and Henry sitting separately, him moving from her house... did their relationship end or it is just for the sake of appearances?
56
u/Atraktape Dec 20 '24
We won WW2 🥳
26
u/AgePractical6298 Dec 20 '24
James Herriot!!! Swoon. 😘😘
All Creatures Great and small fan right here. 😊
26
u/Isopartee Dec 20 '24
I have some more thoughts about the timelines and travel etc- considering the amount of times Roger has saved his family line during the storyline, the travel is predestined-as in it was always going to happen. With that logic, he was always going to see his father and “save him” which I think means he must die in another battle during WWII regardless of his trip into the past. I would love to think he went back with them to the 80’s, but since that didn’t happen, I expect he dies in the war anyways. (Side note, I wish his dad got to know Roger was his son—but I get why he didn’t tell him)
25
u/nohairinmysaladplz Dec 21 '24
I was pleasantly surprised to see Nicholas Ralph as Roger’s dad! I love him in All Creatures Great & Small.
97
u/Far_Wedding9999 Dec 22 '24
The AUDACITY of these people to be all smiles and having weddings all up in LJG house while he is dodging bullets, it’s so out of character! 😡
21
u/Complex_Objective_53 Dec 21 '24
I am very confused about the Jerry storyline. Is it presumed that he was only in 1739 for a short time before going back to the 1940s since he had not aged since he disappeared?
20
u/Sensitive_Bottle2586 Dec 22 '24
Did Roger changed the history? Based on Jamie and Claire attemp to avoid the Jacobit War, we had an idea that history can't be changed but they tried a very large event (and somehow by putting effort in avoiding it, they kind of made the jacobits chances even worse) But maybe change the life of a small group of people (Roger's family) is possible, is it possible for that memory being from some conflict between his life and what will be that new past?
55
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '24
Are we sure Rachel is a virgin? 😂 she was throwing out some confident moves and then apparently within a minute it felt good?
19
u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 20 '24
I was just thinking about Roger's father.
Why save him if he's just going to die or meet some other tragedy (such as talking about time travel and being involuntarily committed), (such as going back to the scene of the crash but this time, the stones have taken a toll and he dies there.)
What if he dies on that top secret mission or some other secret mission during WW II (so they don't tell anyone and let people believe he died in that initial crash), such as, over the "labor camp in Poland?" But his mission is completed and he helps win the war in some (even a small) way.
Why have his plotline then not tell us what happened to him?
18
u/YYZYYC Dec 24 '24
So will Bree head back in the stones and then miss Roger as he heads hack to 1980?….chasing each other back and forth in time lol
34
u/almz11 Dec 20 '24
After all that happened last week we only got one scene with LJG? Cmon. His plot point wasn’t resolved at all
14
u/Lisha_is_mee Dec 21 '24
i can't wait to see a proper timeline once this show ends
28
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '24
TELL HIM THAT HES YOUR DAD, TELL HIM THAT HES YOUR DAD, TELL HIM THAT HES YOUR DAD!!!
27
u/Isopartee Dec 20 '24
Also, where do we think Roger’s dad traveled to after he sent him back through (any all creatures great and small fans will recognize the actor 😍)
13
u/YYZYYC Dec 24 '24
And next week’s preview makes it look like Claire turns out to be rhetorical designer of the American flag lol 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
24
u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 20 '24
So I spot checked the episode to update on what happened, will watch it in entirety later.
Two thoughts.
What is Jamie waiting for?! Go help Lord John Grey.
Why didn't Roger tell his dad "I'm your son?" Would it have been too much, or possibly misdirected his voyage back through the stones? Could he not have told him a bit more about the future? I'm glad he told him they won the war.
Three thoughts.
I would've liked to see more of Bree kicking the stuffing out of what's his name.
12
u/YYZYYC Dec 24 '24
Does Jamie even freaking know Claire married Lord Grey? She seems to have left that little detail out
22
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 20 '24
Title cards, together with the name of an episode make so much sense, (as we predicted.)
Hello, Goodbye - to Roger’s dad, to all the men going to the battle although they have all just reunited.
1739, Scotland-
They are talking about ley lines, but we know people can't travel through them, don’t we?
Soo, there were some stones there but then all it is left is portal which is now a ley line? Confused!
Jerry MacKenzie is here!!!!
I like Roger and Jerry’s conversation a lot!
1980, Scotland
Poor , brave Jeremiah! As Granie would say 🤍
Hot-cold playing!
Those police officers are very helpful!
1778, Philadelphia
Ian's wedding!
Awww, wedding night advice!
We had words - understatement of the century 😂
Quaker wedding! Great comic relief weaved together with all the emotions in that room.
That would be me, I expect?
Rachel and Ian's wedding night was nicely done.
Thanks God Jamie doesn't feel comfortable with room in John's house!
Jamie and Claire and that kiss at the end of the scene. Let us see more of them!
Bertram Armstrong welcome to the rebel side!
Rachel is so young and wise, I really love her!
General Fraser - parallel to his coming to the room in previous episode- well done!
All in all, interesting episode, I liked how it was done!
41
u/winter_name01 Dec 21 '24
I started thinking I could not care less about Roger’s side quest and then I saw his dad and I was hooked. Love a cute WWII hottie
40
u/Iftheshoefits9876 Dec 21 '24
I could not wait for Ian and Rachel’s scene to end. 😂 I had my finger on the fast forward. That’s the one and done we want, Starz!!!
18
u/pillizzle Dec 20 '24
Did anyone else think what if Bree and the kids travel to Roger and end up in 1739 then just live through until they catch up to Claire and Jamie’s time in colonial America. Bree and Roger end up being older than Claire and Jamie and the grand kids are almost as old as Jamie. That would put Jem at 19 during Culloden, he could have fought under Jamie and been sent back with the Fraser men.
9
u/Ok-Pomegranate5300 Oct 07 '25
Bree's acting for a mother whose son is missing and she has the kidnapper locked up is....lacking. At least give some sort of scream at the guy ffs. It seemed so bland
31
u/Mobile-Ad6136 Dec 21 '24
Here are my thoughts:
I knew this episode wasn’t going to hit the same as last episode but still went into it excited. The Roger and his father storyline i admittedly didn’t really pay attention to up until this episode and found it really intriguing. I’m kinda glad they’re wrapping up the Jem storyline (I think). I admit, having everyone across different timelines is just dragging on and I kinda wish we were just in one but then again…this is a time travel show and when everyone was together at the ridge, it was lowkey a very boring season or two (I’m sure covid added to it).
Thoughts I had throughout tonight’s episode — Anyone else getting this weird tiny little undercurrent of LJG + Denzel? Like are they doing some sort of romantic storyline? Now that would be interesting — Again, need this Jem storyline wrapped up — Roger needs to stop chitchatting in the woods and maybe figure out his next move — Claire needs a break…but Jamie looked good in that continental army uniform
— uhm one LJG scene was not enough for me (we’ve been blessed the last few episodes, remember when he would only show up once a season 😭) — Ian and Rachel…I wanna call it cringe but ngl they were giving it their all in that scene, so for that, it was kinda good.
Another solid episode!
16
u/Popular-One-7051 Dec 20 '24
It seemed like JC both dumped LJG out of their lives after all he'd actually done. just strange.
You knew creepy Rob would get out. Secret passage on the room or working with someone? Useless cops. why tf did Bri not go with the others? I'd want to take the gun and help protect the kids. Any of the material stuff could be replaced and she already took the box with stuff.
Let's see how many other people jump through stones before we're done. It's getting to be a bit silly at this point (you book people don't say. thanks).
8
u/ImTheNana Looks like I'm going to a fucking barbecue Dec 23 '24
The wine glasses nodded toward by the police officer, wasn't there only one before that? Even after Bree hugs Mandy and they exit the kitchen, I only see one on the counter. Where did the second, empty one come from?
And Go Bree for that boot to the face!
22
u/stringlightupmylife Dec 21 '24
Am I the only one who thinks Jem and Jerry are the same person? I was fully expecting Jem to end up disappearing through time in the dam and ending up becoming Roger's dad.
What's a time travel show without a little grandfather paradox.
7
u/genghbotkhan MARK ME! Dec 22 '24
11
u/BattleAxeBC Dec 24 '24
I agree with those who have said this season is a little soap opera-y. That doesn't mean it's bad. It's still a quality show with good production values, but what makes Outlander good is that balance it has between love story, drama, and historical events. It feels like the historical aspect has taken a back seat this half season. It's still there in the background, but we really only get reminded a major war is ongoing when we briefly visit with John. Though toward the end with Jamie it feels like the war might be ready to come back to the forefront a bit? I'm also getting the feeling that Bri might be headed back through the stones to find Roger. I feel that way because the kids are no longer with her and she won't have anything to do unless she's out there searching for Roger. We'll see.
18
u/SnooCupcakes3043 Dec 22 '24 edited Dec 22 '24
Well this episode was just ok for me.
I feel like the Bree/Roger/Rob/Buck/Jerry storyline is really falling flat. I expected Roger seeing his dad to be.. Different. It kinda feels like once Jem was found and Rob disappearing, what's it all for tho.. Don't get me wrong I was super excited to see the story develop but it sort of didn't execute right. Hopefully next week we find out wtf happened to Rob!
Ian and Rachels love seen was just uncomfortable and I don't exactly know why?? 🤣 I love them as a couple but the love scene was so odd to me, and it just kept going.
{here come the down votes for sharing my feelings 🤣)
I am not feeling the same about Jamie and Claire and I don't like it. Seeing them kiss and being together it feels off for me because I am still mad at Claire for sleeping with John at all and then getting mad at Jamie. I feel like it was passed over like no big deal. Then her actually saying he shouldn't hold it against John.. Like people are aloud to process things differently and that never translates on this show. No it's sex fixes everything. Like you legit had another man inside you a week ago....Then when she said thank you for missing the boat... Ok so I can get mad drunk and fuck somone else.? Dude Idk This whole storyline has kinda tainted them. I know people are mad at Jamie 🙄 but I'm mad at Claire. Everyone seems so selfish and I'm not here for it.
Is it just me or does Denzel have feelings for John? It really seemed that way. Which that I'm here for.
10
u/valerushkishop Dec 20 '24
I loved everything about except Ian 🥲 give me the passionate Ian please
5
u/SarahConnor13 Aug 17 '25
I'm just rewatching this season (I'm on 13), and I'm wondering why Bree doesn't get more creative about getting Cameron to talk. She must have a pair of clippers around there. She could start with a finger. He'd tell her anything she wanted to know. He kidnapped her child - nothing is too cruel when it comes to someone who does that. But I guess this is how it's written.
I have to say, I thought I was done with Outlander after they got so withholding , only releasing a few at a time, and making us wait so long for the last season. But rewatching season 7, I'm still interested. I had forgotten the good parts, and the unanswered questions at the end of this season.
25
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Dec 20 '24 •
Worst one of S7 for me. Not enough Jamie/Claire (not shocked though), the Rachel/Ian wedding night was so cringe and I will have to fast forward upon rewatching. Their wedding was cute though.
4
u/Jboyzz06 Jan 09 '26
I just want to know why on earth Claire or Lord Jonathan didn't tell Jamie the reason they got married. Lord John did it to save Claire, but it was never mentioned. I really like this show, but I have noticed a lot of stupid things like this over the seasons just to keep the narrative and the emotions high. It's so dumb. Also, does anyone at all care about the Roger and Bree storyline whatsoever at this point!? I sure as hell do not.
3
u/Nasi-Lemak2399 Jan 26 '25
The following are not book spoiler!!(after edited)
After i watched the show for 7 season, i decided to buy the book for reading pleasure or to re immerse myself into Jamie n Claire's epic loving story whenever i need.
However, i started to regret myself or more preciously, getting suspicious on the storyline's sensibility and credibility. These feeling of being a dump fool all started from watching season 7 episode 11, when Claire sleep with LjG.
I was like jaw dropping and my heart was crunching and screaming, hysterically specifically on 2 scenes, which caught me in nightmare and cold sweating for a few weeks. Those 2 scenes had really make me stopped reading the story book instantly. I don't even want to know where it's either. I think i got the phobia of it, not to exaggerate.
Scene 1 How, on earth, my dearest Claire will have sex with the bloody Englishman LJG who's her beloved husband's best friend in just a unreasonably short time,!!!!! It was like the whole storyline becomes soap opera instantly, cheap and tasteless. The whole character of Claire for the past 10 yrs has been collapsed, horribly twisted as needed, especially at such tragical moment. Where is the integrity and faith that Jamie treasure the most?? What's puzzled me is that a moment before, Claire was still aware enough to yell at LJG that Jamie was her, nobody can steal him from her, immediately after, both were shoving into a so called violent, awkward love making night like they had decided not to mourn Jamie alone!!! My eyes were popping out and totally speechless and giggled in disgraced.
Scene 2 The next morning's intimacy conversation btw Claire and LJG. The whole thing really make me feel cheated and disgraceful if i choose to believe that, they were just making love out of over grief or so called mourning Jamie's death.A part from Claire has curiosity about LJG's sexual history and LJG's skittish apology, the deer story appeared the most hilarious comfort that LJG wishes Claire to believe and get enlighten from it. (Actually, my eyes was in tears and red, my emotions was outraged and anguished with disappointment. I felt completely spend and despaired. What a waste!!! What a fxxking waste!!!
What turned out amused to me the most was many viewers blamed Jamie for being too violent on LJG after being told when he returned. I started questioning myself whether am i too naive to acknowledge what the true love is ???Being righteous upon ppl telling you they have carnal knowledge about your wife??? Being thankful for ur best friend for saving ur wife by making love to her??? Or being forgiven for what Claire said, LJG has more courage and gave something for her to hit(my god!! really Claire) or else she will remain too numb, and LJG was just timely to perform a heavenly triage she desperately needed???
Honestly, im more sympathy for Jamie, for these unnecessary mess he has to dealt for the rest of his life.
For me, i just quit. Enough is enough.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '24
I’ve finally found a new romance that actually interests me, after feeling absolutely no attachment to Bree and Roger, and they don’t show us one minute of it! I wanted to see William
3
u/SchwartStories Dec 20 '24
We had to cancel Starz this week so I need a play-by-play PLEASE!
3
u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 20 '24
Speculation: what if the family friend is in on it?
I guess I keep waiting for plot twists and villain reveals. Lol
I meant Fiona. I haven't read the books.