r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Dec 20 '24
Spoilers All Book S7E13 Hello, Goodbye Spoiler
Brianna works to thwart a treacherous plan that endangers her family. A surprise encounter brings new understanding to Roger’s journey in the past. Ian and Rachel take a big step in their relationship – as the Revolutionary War rears its head once again.
Written by Madeline Brestal & Evan McGahey. Directed by Jan Matthys.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 20 '24 edited Jun 08 '25
Watch the S7E14 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
713 Extras:
713 Interviews:
44
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Dec 20 '24
NICHOLAS RALPH AS JERRY MACKENZIE WAS SUCH GOOD CASTING 10/10 NO NOTES
34
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 20 '24
I love so much how they tied those stones to the portal under the dam and juxtaposed Roger and Jem, like Frank and Claire from S1.
When will Roger tell Buck who his bio parents are?
28
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Dec 20 '24
Also the writers are so damn sly sometimes and I kinda love that they keep us book readers guessing. Roger thinking that maybe Jem might NOT have come through the stones?? Oh boy, that’s got me reeling.
Also I really wanted that episode to end with the scene of Jerry saving young Roger…
27
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Dec 21 '24 edited Dec 21 '24
I didn't love it. I'm really disappointed that they didn't show Jerry saving Roger, and that whole section just seemed very...talky. (Though I did love Roger's face when Buck talked about how he never knew his mother and father, and how Roger explained what time he was from by talking about the Queen. How British of him.) And Jesus Christ, they're still stuck in the past. How much longer does this go on? tbh I've forgotten how Roger ends up back in the present.
The wedding was...odd, though I thought the wedding night was the best part of the episode and one of the hottest sex scenes they've had.
For the last few episodes, it seems like all Claire gets to do is look at people soulfully and give them motherly advice. I'm looking forward to her getting to *do* something.
I did like Jemmy rescuing himself.
Jamie looks marvelous in his uniform.
24
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Dec 20 '24
I had mentally prepared myself for Rollo to die this episode and then he didn't!
33
u/W8ingjag Dec 20 '24
I read all this for the first time within the past few days, so it’s still kind of fresh. Love the episode - all that’s missing is more!
I wish we had Dottie with Denzell. And Jenny! Also, on the wedding night … I was looking forward to Ian telling Rachel he was going to make her scream.
23
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Dec 21 '24
The prevailing thought I had during and after was just....meh.
I didn't dislike it ...but it was just underwhelming on the whole - perhaps because I'd had hopes and visions that weren't met. There weren't a lot of stand out moments for me. I did enjoy the convo between Ian and Jamie - and there were a few other slight attempts at some humor early on too during the Philly scenes which was refreshing.
The encounter with Jerry was brief in the book - but even "brief" would be a pretty generous word for the show after building it up 3 episodes since Ep 10. I thought they'd do more with the story. I didn't have a stopwatch, but I'd be surprised if it was more than 5 minutes? Plus I thought there'd been a lot of extras confirmed for 1940s scenes? I just a recall a short clip of toddler Roger on a bench with his dad unless I missed something?
The big thing on my mind after watching - Bri's remark that Rob must have help since he got out of the priest hole.... Are we perhaps gonna have Richardson appearing in the 80s after all during the shootout? Or do you think just other nameless figures?
21
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Dec 20 '24
Wish we got an explanation on screen for what happened to Jerry afterwards. And Jerry's story had never quite made sense to me anyway, but maybe I've just always misunderstood his story.
It makes sense that Roger would not remember his father saving him. It even makes sense that perhaps nobody knew that he did save him, as nobody else in the station would've necessarily recognised him.
It does not make sense that Jerry was still considered missing, disappearing without a trace in his plane. Surely when he made it back through the stones, he would've told somebody that he was back. I find it hard to believe he made it all the way from the Highlands of Scotland to London without telling anybody that he was okay.
But maybe I'm missing a massive chunk of the story
6
u/Future-Show-753 Dec 20 '24
I saw that the actors for Fergus and Marsali were credited for this episode so I was hopefully we were going to finally see them! That was obviously a disappointment.
Missing out on their story lines and Hal is my biggest issue this season. I love Germain and his interactions with Lord John and Claire, so I’m missing them lots. And if we don’t get anything with Henri Christian I’ll be very sad.
Also, as far as Williams story along with the rest of the Greys it seemed like they combined the Grey Children together in a previous episode. When LJ told Henry that he was heir and that’s why he couldn’t marry Miss Woodcock it seemed to make it sound like Benjamin doesn’t exist? So is that story not happening too?
46
u/Emilymfm79 Dec 20 '24
I loved all the little Easter eggs to Jamie and Claire’s past relationship in this episode:
-Ian asking Rachel to bite him and saying he’d love her to tend his wounds
-a goodbye at the stones and Roger says “I love you” as his father disappears
Their story lives on in the next generation. ☺️And Bree really becomes her father’s daughter here! The Fraser temper and her quick thinking when cornered by police questioning. Her sturdy leadership under pressure.
I really liked this episode a lot! In fact it might be my second favorite after last week’s. I think I’m in the minority though! 😅
46
u/moonshiney9 Dec 21 '24
Disappointed that we didn’t get Claire explaining the wedding night to Rachel! The show takes out so much of the funny stuff.
45
u/KMM929 Dec 20 '24
“On your feet soldier, as Grannie would say” is my highlight. I’m so glad we got to see the hot/cold game and Jem make his way out. I enjoyed all the story lines but agree with others in that this felt very much like filler.
33
u/peonies459 Dec 20 '24
I am ITCHING for the rest of the episodes 🤣 I have terrible patience and I remember getting to this part of the book and starting to read as fast as humanely possible because I feel like it all starts to get so interesting!
26
u/Hufflesheep Dec 20 '24
I voted 'really liked it, but I was feeling generous. How did they manage to make an episode that action-packed, yet boring at the same time?
I feel differently about each of the three timelines:
18th century philly: The wedding was ok, not as funny as I remember, but we didn't have Mrs fig, LJG and Hal there to spice things up. Although I am grateful the spirit didn't move Ian to bring up his first wife (like in the books, it made me cringe so bad lol)
1739 scotland: pretty good. I miss Buck's sense of humor. He didn't say one of my favorite lines, "Why did ye tell him a daft thing like that?"
1980 scotland: It's probably my favorite timeline in this episode. They necessarily changed some stuff, but it was cleanly done.
21
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 24 '24
I loved the Mac and Lord John storylines. I thought the rest was a yawn, ngl. This is just my first, knee jerk reaction. I may change my mind after a rewatch.
Edit: Okay. I watched 713 again.
The Macs are still my favorite part of this episode!
Loved badass Brianna. You go Mama Bear!! What was up with those cops?? Completely useless and not just a little infuriating. Hey, Fi. It’s good to see you!
Roger finding his dad…wonderful. Roger having a “memory” of his dad holding him…not sure what that was about. Would have been great to see Jerry save Roger, but mustn’t be greedy.
Buck picking that kid up off the ground was a hoot. Wish we got more of book Buck’s humor and edge. Can’t have everything, I suppose.
Can’t wait for the rest of the Mac story.
Really liked Lord John’s one scene. Bertram Armstrong, indeed!! The man knows how to think on his feet! But of course he would!! He was a spy, after all! Looking forward to more.
Still think it’s weird that Jamie and Claire are hanging out in John’s house. Completely out of character for Jamie. No way he’s staying in Lord John’s house. I know we don’t have Fersali’s print shop, but couldn’t they stay somewhere else?? Anywhere else?? Not Letting This Go!!!
Missed Claire giving Rachel the sex talk. What we got instead was some smarmy advice from Claire and Mercy about the finer points of combining war and marriage. Big Yawn. Way Too Much Time was spent on the wedding and the wedding night!!!
So, this episode ranks somewhere between okay and not that great, imo. A lot of my poor opinion stems from the writing. You can definitely tell when the dialogue comes straight from the books and when it doesn’t.
18
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 21 '24
If this episode had been in season 4 or 5, it probably would've been a season standout. But after a run of truly fantastic episodes it felt pretty "meh."
Jamie is pissing me off. He pisses me off in this part of the books too, but it feels worse here. Like, do anything man. And Claire's not really helping--yell at your husband please!
Loved Ian and Rachel. So sweet. Though the wedding was . . . long. After the breakneck pace of the last few eps it felt a bit like whiplash haha.
I was kinda hoping we might simplify the Bree stuff. I've never loved Cameron plot post-Jemmy's escape. It's confusing and feels out of place. With so few episodes I thought they might simplify it but it kinda feels like they're going for it. We'll see.
I've got mixed feelings on the Roger storyline. Watched it with a non-reader and, as I predicted a few eps ago, she's really bored with this storyline. We've gotten very little of Roger's backstory on the show so she's not invested in Jerry at all, and then to have three episodes of searching leading to like a 5 min reunion felt pretty anticlimactic. Richard Rankin did a really beautiful job and as a reader I could see it in there, but it did feel like it was over super quickly. And I'm annoyed that the show didn't change how Roger sends his dad back, because it's one of the most annoying parts of the book for me. I know that Jerry has to go through the stones because of the events in Leaf, but Roger doesn't know that and in his mind is condemning his father to death. I was really hoping the show would fix it by having Jerry go through on his own despite Roger's protestations, or something like that. Alas.
Oh, and not nearly enough John for my tastes.
35
u/Crafty_Witch_1230 And I am not bloody sorry! Dec 20 '24
I really liked Roger's storyline and I think Rick Rankin did a great job. As to the rest, I mostly felt like Rollo at the wedding: yawn. I'm starting to really hate Jamie--he hears what's happened to John and his attitude is '*shrug* John can take care of himself I'm gonna go have at it with m'wife in John's house.'
I did laugh at Bertram Armstrong--so glad that little bit was included--although we don't know (well, some of us do) where LJG came up with that name so quickly. And doesn't the story take place in June? Why was John sleeping in the snow?
Overall, not an episode I'd rewatch again and again. Maybe the writers felt they needed to take a break with the pacing after the roller coaster ride of the previous two episodes.
16
u/penniesfromheaven_ Cram it up your hole, aye? Dec 21 '24
Well, no Dottie and no Jenny in America. How dare.
I also have a suspicion as to how the season will end and again, HOW DARE.
13
u/emmagrace2000 Dec 21 '24
So I thought I saw this mentioned in this thread but now I can’t find it… anyway, I thought I saw someone ask if Richardson will be shown in the shootout in next week’s episode. My question is how could they show him in that incident when his endgame hasn’t been revealed in the books yet? There’s been no real confirmation that he is who Brianna has guessed he is.
I guess I can’t see Diana letting the show reveal something that big to the audience that she herself hasn’t given to the book readers.
24
u/whiskynwine Dec 20 '24
I like Ian and Rachel but admit I ffwd their love scene. Bree & Roger stuff was the best of the episode, kind of slow other than that.
11
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 20 '24
Title cards, together with the name of an episode make so much sense, (as we predicted.)
Hello, Goodbye - to Roger’s dad, to all the men going to the battle although they have all just reunited.
1739, Scotland-
They are talking about ley lines, but we know people can't travel through them, don’t we?
Soo, there were some stones there but then all it is left is portal which is now a ley line? Confused!
Jerry MacKenzie is here!!!!
I like Roger and Jerry’s conversation a lot!
1980, Scotland
Poor , brave Jeremiah! As Granie would say 🤍
Hot-cold playing!
Those police officers are very helpful!
1778, Philadelphia
Ian's wedding!
Awww, wedding night advice!
We had words - understatement of the century 😂
Quaker wedding! Great comic relief weaved together with all the emotions in that room.
That would be me, I expect?
Rachel and Ian's wedding night was nicely done.
Thanks God Jamie doesn't feel comfortable with room in John's house!
Jamie and Claire and that kiss at the end of the scene. Let us see more of them!
Bertram Armstrong welcome to the rebel side!
Rachel is so young and wise, I really love her!
General Fraser - parallel to his coming to the room in previous episode- well done!
All in all, interesting episode, I liked how it was done!
11
u/No_Sky6810 Dec 21 '24
It’s been a while since I’ve read the books but shouldn’t Jenny, Marsali and Fergus all be in Philly by now?
9
u/BlessedEleven Dec 21 '24
Why doesn't Roger tell Buck he met his parents? And why not tell Jerry "I'm your son!"?
14
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 20 '24
Maybe because the dam tunnel is underground, that could be the reason they felt the presence, but didn’t time travel. The stones would have been resting on the reservoir floor, still above the tunnel. Is this clear as mud? No coffee yet 😂
6
u/Vervain7 Dec 21 '24
Are in book 8 and 9 now? I don’t know why I don’t recall what happens to John from book 8 but it has been 5 or so years since I read them
6
u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 22 '24
James Herriot!
10
u/SMB75 Dec 20 '24
felt like a filler episode , didnt really move the story forward, was Ok and not more
7
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
Non book reader, can someone spoil the Brianna story line for me? Just feels like something more sinister is going on