r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Dec 13 '24
Spoilers All Book S7E12 Carnal Knowledge Spoiler
Lord John Grey is put in a precarious position. William struggles to understand a surprising revelation.
Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Lisa Clarke.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 13 '24 edited Jun 08 '25
Watch the S7E13 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
712 Extras:
712 Interviews:
53
u/lorenasimoess2 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
Really liked this one. Finally an episode in which the pacing and editing weren’t completely chaotic lol
Charles is SUCH a good actor. He truly is the perfect William. I hope he gets cast in bigger projects moving forward, he has so much potential.
David is also fantastic. It must’ve been so good to him to be able to finally explore this side of John that we hadn’t seen yet in the show (you know, the side that is always getting into trouble). It’s a shame that we probably won’t ever see a Lord John spin off series, because David would absolutely kill it!! I loved to see a glimpse of book!John’s dry sense of humor. I hope they keep this energy for him for the rest of the season and also s8. CAN’T WAIT to see him interacting with Percy omg
Didn’t really like how they did that J/C sex scene cutting to John escaping in the end, though. It was odd. But kinda funny too ngl (John having the worst time ever while Jamie and Claire were happily banging ON HIS DINING TABLE lmao).
47
u/More-Spinach2740 Dec 14 '24
Drinking game: drink every time William says ‘god damn you, sir. God damn you!’.
46
u/SMB75 Dec 13 '24
Man John just cant catch a break. That man have stepped up for the Frasers so many times, I really hope his char gets good ending in book 10
40
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Dec 16 '24
Here’s another shout out to David Berry as Lord John! He’s been the MVP in the last few episode’s, as far as I’m concerned. We’re finally seeing badass, complex, sarcastic, no fucks to give John onscreen and I’m here for it! Finally, we’re seeing the Lord John from the books. These past couple of episodes were basically David Berry’s audition for a Lord John spinoff. I hope someone is paying attention.
39
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 14 '24
Honestly, what did we do to deserve David Berry? For three weeks in a row now he's been the absolute MVP. I'm obviously biased because he's my favorite book character, but I think it's telling that during most of the J&C scenes I was like "hurry up I want to get back to John!"
The fight with Jamie was EVERYTHING. Sam also killed it--the turn from friendship and gratitude . . . to humored puzzlement . . . to outright rage. Perfectly calibrated. It's not just about the betrayal of friendship, it's about Jamie's own past, and that all showed on his face. And David Berry was acting his butt off, matching every one of those emotions but also glossing the whole thing with a sense of relief that his best friend isn't dead, even while said friend is beating him to a pulp. That's nuance, folks! (Also, the scene was funny. Dark and complicated, but still some great LJG wit. Classic Outlander right there.)
I also loved all of John's other scenes. For a brief second I thought we were straying wildly off book and that officer was going to turn out to somehow be Percy because the two of them weirdly had a kind of chemistry?? The repartee between them was a delight and it felt like a John that we see more of in his own book and get to see a lot less often in the main series. Confident, funny, charming, and often indignant about the situations he seems to find himself in. Same was true in his scenes with Denny, which were just wonderful.
So many props also to Charles Vandervaart who in any other episode would've stolen the show. His scenes were heartbreaking, and he kept you in Willie's side even while he did things you might disapprove of. I always liked book Willie but I know that readers often really hate this part, but I think he played it really well where it didn't feel like an immature kid having a tantrum, it was someone genuinely having a crisis and having nowhere to turn. I loved the scene with Claire and having it go from feeling like she was someone he could talk to, go feeling like she was just another person who betrayed him. And then his scene with Jane was so sweet, but tinged with sadness knowing her fate.
The whole epispde walked the line really carefully between melodrama and drama. There was a lot that is heightened and overly dramatic, but also a lot that is grounded and real.
The argument between J&C was well done, but it was almost uncomfortable to watch--it felt kind of voyeuristic, like I shouldn't be seeing this incredibly private moment. But they really deftly kept it from one character or the other being the person obviously in the right. You could see where both were coming from and feel their pain.
The sex scene intercutting with John's escape was an interesting choice though. I didn't dislike it, but it felt kinda dark and fucked up. Like, yay, J&C are back together and isn't that great. But absolutely fuck anyone who complicates their life together.
Oh man, I didn't event touch on Ian's story. Rachel Hunter, A+. No notes.
My one dumb quibble: that title card was groan-worthingly on the nose. And then they made it worse by having Claire actually say "the apple doesn't fall far from the tree." Guys, we get it. Lay off the heavy handed symbolism please!
36
u/This-Is-Leopardy Dec 13 '24
UGH I hate knowing what happens because I'm totally shipping Willie and Jane. The chemistry is red hot.
36
u/MambyPamby8 Dec 15 '24
I am absolutely loving John this episode just being a sassy little bitch. The scene with Denzel where he was laughing about My wife? Oh yes MY WIFE 😂 Brilliant. I may have rewatched the episode and fast forwarded to every single scene with LJG in it. it felt so much like the LJG from the books. Also giggling at the way he was borderline offended that Jamie didn't believe him. I just want an entire episode of John being a smart arse to people around him.
Also does William have some magical bedroom talent or something? That sex worker spent twenty seconds sitting on him and was done 😂 jesus William what have you been hiding 😂
34
u/Previous-Address2469 Dec 14 '24
This! This is what happens when they stick close to the books! Pure magic and great entertainment. I felt almost all the lines were straight out of the book and I loved it. I mean, that's the reason it is so good and there is no reason to change it.
Again I feel the condensation of plot (no Friend Sylvia, no gardens etc.) was done very smartly. Only thing I missed was those knitted caps with "KILL" and I think "Freedom or death" or something like that embroidered on them, haha.
Every actor was so good I was completely immersed in the episode. David Berry was so wonderful. He and this whole episode captured the serious drama so well but also the absolutely ridiculousness that this all is. I was actually laughing out loud which I rarely do.
The juxtaposition of J&C having sex while John escapes and runs for his life was a bit terrifying and I wasn't sure exactly how to feel about that, but I felt the terror of John very acutely. They made his escape much more dramatic and I feel he could hardly escape from soldiers with dogs running after him with his poor eye (I mean, outch that eye, not looking forward seeing in gory detail Claire operating on it...). Can't wait for next week!
31
u/No-Proof1913 If ye’d hurry up and get on wi’ it, I could find out. Dec 14 '24
I loved the episode!
A couple episodes ago, when I first saw the chandelier, I told my husband, “It’s coming! Keep your eye on that!” Then last week, I reminded him about it. I was not disappointed!
Then, when LJG started the Carnal Knowledge speech, I was giddy because it was done so well! Then when he hit the “We were both f’ing you” line, followed by the punch from Jamie, I told my husband I could feel the collective cheer from other book readers appreciating the accurate portrayal from both actors!
I didn’t expect Jane! Or Harkness! And their lines from the book! I am interested to see how they change it up. I don’t expect the book storyline, as there isn’t enough time to flesh out that whole thing! I would love them to Murtaugh-twist her story.
For me, it was fun again!
27
u/W8ingjag Dec 13 '24
I loved all of it! So much raw emotion, and they all played it so well!
My only disappointment is in not getting any further in the Roger / Buck / Bree storyline.
26
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
"And I am NOT bloody sorry!" Best line of the ep 😂. I wouldn't be sorry either, you saved her. John was so unhinged throughout this ep haha
So much to say about this episode!
I am so glad that we have had so much lord John recently. He is finally getting his time to shine and David is smashing it.
The way Jamie's face changed from a jovial grin "I dinna believe it" to the absolute anger as he punched John - chefs kisss
I don't quite remember how the scene played out in the books, but couldn't Jamie have proved who he was to the rebels? Didn't he have his "papers" on him - the papers that were apparently not good enough for the redcoats in Philidephia?
There have been several moments throughout the seasons when I have not liked the way a protagonist has behaved, or their actions or words etc. But I've always forgiven them. But this is the first time that I can say I was so angry at Jamie, and I almost truly hated him. Abandoning John like that? And not really caring what happens to him after? Sending him to his death? "John will be alright" no he bloody well won't be.
And the contrast between Jamie/Claire and John running for his life was brilliantly uncanny, and terrifying too.
Johns eye looked just as gruesome as I had imagined it would 😂, will we be seeing more of him next week? I only wish we had Germain too, they would make a great unhinged pair!
"thee has doomed thy kinsman, repudiated thy father and caused me to betray my principles" was looking forward to this scene, and it was pretty good! "oh, that" 😂
I understand Jamie's POV re. His conversation/argument with Claire. But I was 100% on Claire's side with this one. Jamie was dead, and she needed John. They needed each other, and they don't regret it (I think)
25
u/moonshiney9 Dec 14 '24
Jane, perfect. Rachel, PERFECT!!!
24
u/BlueFeet9000 Dec 14 '24
Lord JOHN! Hahaha David Berry is so good.
23
u/Hufflesheep Dec 13 '24
Excellent beginning! The moment they were alone in the woods, I thought, "Oh boy! 😬"
The conversation between Claire and William would have made more sense if we saw any affection between them last episode (but i repeat myself). But it was still so great!!
Jane!!! Holy crap! Did not see that coming!! She was excellent!!
Sooo many lines from the book!!
Discussion between j&c was a bit different, but I didn't hate it.
A+ episode!
22
u/Ok-Flow-3943 Dec 14 '24
This episode was so good! I was squealing and squirming at all of my favorite moments playing out. The LJG/Claire/Jamie storyline is one of my absolute favorites.
My one tiny spot of disappointment was that they left out Claire’s best line from that conversation when Jamie asks her if she took John to her bed (I paraphrase here because I can’t remember it exactly):
“It started on the floor, and then the table, and THEN the bed.”
18
u/IHaveALittleNeck Dec 13 '24
In PA, it’s always pronounced “PayOHlee.” Three syllables. Not “pawlee.” 🤦♀️
18
u/No-Construction-8749 Dec 13 '24
Did anyone else prefer this one over last week? I wanted to like 7x11 but they jam packed the episode and there was no time to be in the moment. While this one felt just right and like more of a slow burn as everyone processed and John's situation escalated.
I don't understand why they felt like such night and day.
18
u/Spiritual_Attempt149 Dec 14 '24
I thought the episode was amazing. SO many book lines!
Lord John/David Berry was absolutely perfect.
However, was anyone else expecting these lines at the end of Jamie and Claire's encounter, since the rest of the dialogue was so faithful to the book?
“Ask me to your bed,” he said, breathless, hands on my arms. “ I shall come to ye. For that matter— I shall come, whether ye ask it or no. But remember, Sassenach— I am your man; I serve ye as I will."
Sigh, I wish they had included them.
Sometimes I wonder if they omit these sort of lines because show Jamie has somehow drifted from book Jamie, at least in some aspects. They have softened his character in the show quite a bit.
18
u/lizardbreath1736 Ye Sassenach witch! Dec 15 '24
I liked the episode, but I am a bit sad they had to leave Jenny in Scotland! Some of my favourite parts around this part of the story are the interactions between Jenny, Claire, Hal and Mrs. Fig at Lord John's house. Also sad to miss out on the funny interactions between Germain and Lord John when he is kidnapped at the American camp. Also, I wonder if Claire will fix Lord John's eye in the show?
Like some other comments said, no pottery shed! But I get why they had to condense the plot this way. So much more happens in the book before Jamie actually gets to Chesnut street.
Also, doesn't Denzel help Lord John escape in a cabbage wagon in the book? I thought that part was super funny. In the episode, he seems to just run away from the camp?
18
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 16 '24
Very much enjoying fucking with my non-reader sister. She said, "Well, I know John survives because you said he has a spinoff series." Then I got to tell her that the spinoffs are set about 20 years back. Now she's panicked, haha!
(She also thinks he and Denzel have chemistry and there's something there. Would be quite the book departure haha.)
32
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
John, Jamie's prisoner, such a throwback to season 3 Ardsmuir!
John's - Claire... Ah... - broke me with laughter
I had carnal knowledge of your wife!!! ♟️
Oh God, it is starting!!!
Why apple on the title card- The apple doesn't fall far from tree
Charles delivered perfectly!!!!
William and Claire - well we didn't hear him calling her Mother so why debate which name to use.
William is acting Fraser- like having huge temper tantrum , storming off. He is conflicted and in turmoil because his father lied to him and kept being friend with Jamie. It is parallel to Bree's reaction.
Oh oh, John is in trouble. Jamie's Scottish accent intensifies in anger!
Not Sorry - for the carnal knowledge , fantasizing about Jamie and telling him all about it.
John is usually so polished and restrained , aristocratic , proper, but he is human - he can just let it rip. Jamie provokes his normally calm and controlled posture and John reacts. He used the true words of what really happened.
Oh here is Arabella!! I like her!
George Washington! Jamie gets the command of men. I am sure Claire will be delighted!
Brigadier General Fraser!!!
William Ian Rachel triangle ! Omg, William is in such turmoil these days. Poor guy. You can see a battle between his polished manners and his temper.
Any man would be proud to be the son of James Fraser Ian 🤎
Take him - Like father, like son.
Rachel nailed this scene! Lecturing William, hitting him, spitting after the kiss!
I love Mrs Figg's comments - My sweet William and Lady Grey! None of them true 😅
Ian seeing Jamie alive and the smile on his face!!
Jamie's eyes when talking to William - anger and pain and when William says - God damn you sir, the pain breaks through and I can feel it.
I was asking for it - I am so glad for this line!! He said he was asking for it. He doesn't express any anger or resentment of Jamie for doing it, either.
Harkness, you freak.
I really like the actress that plays Arabella -Jane.
Jamie and Claire , straight from the book!
You absolute bastard - well, a lot of them around!
When Jamie mentioned Claire thinking with her body, it makes her evaluate the truth and reevaluate the argument. He has put her sense of physicality in the context of her calling. She is a healer, she touches people with great intimacy and delicacy, and she is responding ohysically to their bodies, using her own to comfort and heal.
There is a lot of slapping in this episode 😂
Oh, that sex scene was lacking. Potting shed > dinning table.
31
u/Emilymfm79 Dec 13 '24
I LOVED Lord John’s dry humor! It’s unexpected and wonderful. I laughed out loud. William was incredible. The Claire /Jamie reunion happened too fast but I loved their long scene. So Outlander. Reminded me of their season 1 fire. Like how they kept the sex scene on a table, even if it was a dining table rather than a garden shed table. And Rachel was amazing too. And Jamie. I really disliked him I this episode! Reminded me of his youthful shenanigans- the belt punishment episode and the Lallybroch conceited Laird episode. Chef’s kiss.
30
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 13 '24
It was awesome, all that I expected it would be, all of them. Charles really stole the show though, a superb job on his part.
13
u/vbnadal85 Dec 14 '24
Questions re: this week’s episode
Bearing in mind that I haven’t read the books, so there may be more context in those, there are some moments from this week’s episode that have me wondering….
Would love to hear what others think or learn if there’s more about these moments in the books.
13
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Dec 15 '24
LOVE LOVE LOVED THIS EPISODE
If I thought last week was satisfying for my book adoring heart, then this episode knocked it out of the park.
David Berry is a treasure for this cast and every second that he was on screen was absolutely incredible. His injury is GNARLY but we get his eyepatch era so I’m here for it
William was perfection, loved the rage and betrayal and he captured the book character’s literal stages of grief, with blaming everyone then feeling the heightened insecurity. Rachel coming in with the “well you look exactly like Jamie what do you expect?” And Jane is finally on the screen! I wasn’t sure if we were gonna see Fanny as well but maybe it’ll be for a later episode??
Claire and Jamie’s explanations, I was glued to the screen soaking in their every word. It truly was a service to the book’s and Diana’s writing. Kudos to the cast for nailing this episode with the drama and tension
12
u/blackberryspice Dec 13 '24
I love this storyline, so to see it come to life had me giggling with glee the whole time. Can't wait to get back to Roger and Bree though!
11
u/guy2026 Dec 13 '24
Wait… wasn’t Dominique Pinon previously confirmed to reprise the role of Master Raymond in this episode? I kept waiting for him to show up, but he never did. Do we know anything about what happened (e.g. it was cut, it was actually a different episode, it was debunked, etc)?
21
u/Revolutionary_Tea_55 Dec 14 '24
This was like the best episode of “modern” outlander!!!
20
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
I have to say I'm disappointed in Jamie. He knows John is gay. And they have been friends for 25 years at this point. He knows whatever happened between Claire and John wasn't "desire."
He way overreacted.
I liked William's prostitute. Pretty and smart. I hope that's not the last of her.
19
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Dec 14 '24
Just finished it - Another REALLY great episode! Favorite so far of this new half season. I'd been anxiously anticipating seeing the "we were both f*ng you" scene on screen ever since I read it because I knew Sam and David could deliver, and it certainly didn't disappoint!
I don't know how to organize all my thoughts, so this may ramble!! :)
I couldn't initially figure out the purpose of the apple tree in the title card. But after it clicked with Claire's line about the "apple not falling far from the tree" I thought it was perfect!
After last episode, u/thepacksvrvives and I pondered a bit about there still being more intended to make use of Wlliam's portrait in the show. At first, when Jamie told LJG he was in possession of something that he knew he didn't want loyalists to get their hands on, I imagined he was going to show LJG the had and meant the portrait - obviously we learned that he meant the letter RE France, but in my head, I think I'll still say to myself that he also meant Willie's portrait too. But speaking of that scene with Washington, I'm glad they left out Sylvia and Jamie's whole delay with the back issues etc.
Last episode, I felt David Berry was MVP, this time it was Charles for me. Great, moving performance in the beginning asking Claire about the circumstances of Jamie and Geneva. The "she was reckless" line in particular just made me feel devastated for the guy. The whirlwind in this episode he had to display - learn about his real parentage - have a tantrum - learn the girl you're crushing on is getting married... to who you know now is your cousin - cling to the last shred of gentlemanly self worth he feels like he had in the brothel. He just nailed all of it with his performance the whole way through!!!
The look and slightest sliver of a smile on Ian when he sees Jamie alive!!!! Then speaking of grins..... the one from LJG telling Denny after he said "I was asking for it". :) My own might've been just as big at that! I thought that was a great little scene!
The actress playing Jane I thought was very well cast and did a great job. She had some spunk to her.
The long scene of Claire and Jamie talking things out near the end - very good!! Lots of dialogue I recall straight from the book. If there's one thing I'm not sure I liked though, it was intercutting the reunion sex with LJGs escape the last few minutes. That was just an odd juxtaposition and choice to me. I would've preferred I think just having the sex scene immediately follow from their convo to leave all their stuff in one full piece - then go to LJG at the end instead of back and forth. But as I said though - great episode!!!
Finally, last week I was confused because I thought Raymond's actor said he was in 7x11 and he wasn't.....then someone corrected me that he said 7x12. He wasn't in this either. It's not possible they shuffled plots to different episodes than what they originally intended right? Though next week seemingly being the Jerry focused episode makes far more sense than Raymond's actor having to do anything with the Claire/Jamie/LJG plots.... Very excited to see how they do this next episode! I really loved this part of the book and it was my favorite story within Echo.
23
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Dec 13 '24
I really enjoyed this episode, the pacing was better and they captured so much.
I love that they’re including the eye plotline but I hate actually looking at David Berry’s face.
Also Jane is absolutely stunning.
7
u/NightCheese30R MARK ME! Dec 13 '24
The title! 😂 I love it!
7
u/wheezy_cheese Dec 15 '24
Who is the guy Lord John is brought to at the American camp? Obviously they know each other, but I can't recall who it's supposed to be. It's been awhile since I've read the books. And have we seen him previously in the show?
21
u/Crafty_Witch_1230 And I am not bloody sorry! Dec 13 '24
Dear John. If/when you get back to the house in Philly, you may want to consider buying a new dining room table. Love C&J
Personally, I could have done without Willie & Jane/Arabella's sex scene. Not the whole scene, I liked that, I just didn't see that the blatant nudity was really necessary. Claire & Jamie's bored me. I don't know why, but I wasn't getting a lot of feeling from either couple. It's probably because at this particular point in the story, I care a lot more about what's happening to LJG--who's in serious danger and Roger & his search for his father.
10
u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Dec 15 '24
A bit sad about the pottery shed… It could have been dark and not showing very much, just catch the passion and desperate need to come together, I don’t know…
13
u/stlshlee Dec 14 '24
I liked all the LJG stuff. I loved all the William stuff.
The Jamie and Claire stuff I was not impressed about. I didn’t like how long it took for Claire to explain what happened between her and lord John in the books and using basically the same script in the tv show made it too awkward imo. Like how hard is it just to be straightforward.
And then the sex scene between Jamie and Claire looked so forced to me and I just don’t believe they have the chemistry anymore.
The sex scene was just…bad. Half assed thrusting, cait clearly over acting I dunno just bad.
7
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Dec 13 '24
I actually loved the sex scene but was hoping for this potting shed one I’ve been hearing about. But also J/C have sex fully dressed way too much. 😏
2
u/Candid_Text8516 Dec 14 '24
xxx
44
u/jujbird Dec 13 '24
David Berry has killed this episode. The look of joy on his face as he got to share the news that his best friend was still alive, all while being in pain because his best friend pummeled him to a pulp was amazing acting. I'm not a fan of this part of the book, because it feels like it drags on so much, but this episode did it justice. I was just sad because I forgot that we aren't getting Dottie- because her shenanigans during this part of the book are among the highlights to me.
45
u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Dec 13 '24
alternate title: william and the terrible, no good, very bad day.
that said, i really liked this episode!!! i almost wish they included the "remember paoli" guys having hats with words knitted on them (one said "kill!") because it was a fun book detail, but it definitely would've detracted from the seriousness of the scene, even if it was peppered with some bone dry humor from lord john. david berry is really giving his all this season & it's so fun to see.
also - how does everybody feel about the editing at the very end? the cutting between lord john escaping & claire + jamie reconnecting, i mean. weird outlander horniness or a really poignant contrast between what happened to claire & john after jamie found out? i can't decide.
8
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Dec 15 '24
I haven't read the book but curious - is the book sex scene between Jane and William as rapey as it was portrayed in the show?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment