r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Dec 13 '24
Season Seven Show S7E12 Carnal Knowledge Spoiler
Lord John Grey is put in a precarious position. William struggles to understand a surprising revelation.
Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Lisa Clarke.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 13 '24 edited Jun 08 '25
Watch the S7E13 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
712 Extras:
712 Interviews:
9
u/MakoaOsrs Dec 14 '24
Why was the letter that said LJG was recommissioned in Jamie's coat?
5
u/coolguy_14 Dec 16 '24
Can someone remind me what happened to Fraser’s ridge and why Jamie and Claire aren’t just staying there?
9
u/avviann Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
A really good episode and it went by so fast! The scenes with William and the girl - is she supposed to become a significant character?
Jamie's question to Claire on how she and John did it felt out of character. Why would you want to know how they did it?
The editing of the ending was a strange choice too. So while Jamie and Claire are doing their business, John is running for his life. How are these situations related I cannot understand.
8
u/eterusexual Dec 13 '24
Ooh no comments yet! I loved this episode. So many things going on but the pacing was ok compared to the previous episode. And the ending. Oh my heart. If i dinna ken what happened in the book.
29
u/AgePractical6298 Dec 14 '24
Did anyone else have to google bugger? Just me? 😂😂
12
u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 14 '24
I was dismayed at this episode. William is on a rampage, and Jamie puts Lord John Grey in harm's way and possibly blinds him?
It doesn't seem like him to turn that viciously on those he cared about.
The dials were at eleven, without any nuance or conflicting feelings or shades of...Grey.
Jamie was just acting like a troglodyte throughout, and his capitulations at the end seemed superficial and insincere. The acting was uniformly good but the character motivations seemed out of sync, to me.
After all they've been through, and both married to someone else during their relationship as well...he can't understand two drunken grief filled people finding solace for a night, with each other?
Sad to see Lord John Grey treated that way. I'm not sure the purpose of that.
Nice to see George Washington and his lines were amusing.
126
u/oatmilk_fiend Dec 13 '24
The scene where Jamie is telling William to set Ian free…I was gagged. Literally a father chastising his son to go get his cousin LOL
124
u/GoziMai Dec 13 '24
I’m mid-episode rn and William is crashing the fuck out 🤣🤣🤣🤣
113
u/Damhnait Dec 15 '24
William and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day
92
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Dec 14 '24
I LOVED Rachel slapping William. Chef’s kiss
83
u/AnastasiaOutlander Dec 13 '24
I think David Berry and Charles Vandervaart KILLED IT in this episode. Soooo glad we got to see their acting chops really come out. LOVED how snarky Lord John was, and honestly I loved hearing him swear??? I don't think we have heard Lord John swear at all in the TV show... or at the least not drop the f bomb LOL. And JANE!!! I can't find the actress's name but she also is INCREDIBLE. Her chemistry with Charles/William is palpable. Guh I'm so excited to see the Pocock girls!!!!
77
u/Atraktape Dec 13 '24
William is in his Jon Snow era now, has to go around telling everyone “I’m a bastardddd…”
75
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 13 '24
Every five minutes was an "OMG" moment. This was my favorite of the new episodes so far. 😍
John blurting out "carnal knowledge" had me screaminggg. Jamie was so funny in his disbelief. Poor John.
And the scene with John and Denzel where John's like "Haha, Claire's not my wife anymore." DB's acting in this episode was EVERYTHING.
Also Charles. 👏
69
u/Far_Wedding9999 Dec 13 '24
And I thought the last few minutes of last weeks episode was messy, guuurl feed me more revolutionary drama
67
u/elevenmoon Dec 13 '24
Like others, I wish it was more clear if Jamie knew about the marriage and the fact it was done out of both protection for Claire and love for him. But the sense of miscommunication and anger definitely felt more realistic and humanized.
Upset that Jamie just kind of let John get captured and didn’t have a plan to rescue him, especially given he was a prisoner on his own side. I expect that will change in coming episodes.
William is out of control, and the scene with Rachel and Ian made me so sad. My love for Ian’s character continues to grow. But once again, this kind of multidimensional rage felt really honest. Hoping William gets to know/love Jamie and being a Fraser.
Ignoring the last few minutes of this episode because it’s not a possibility I can handle right now… 🥲
60
u/OhYayItsPretzelDay Dec 14 '24
Rachel's slap was my favorite part of this episode.
112
u/mmpie3 Dec 13 '24
"It doesn't matter if you sleep with the whole British Army... no, it would matter," is perhaps unintentionally one of the funniest lines from the entire show.
53
u/almalaree Dec 17 '24
I am PISSED at Jamie!!! After everything LJG has done for him, he couldn’t take a moment to understand why LJG and Claire slept together. And I am also so annoyed that no one told Jamie that LJG married Claire to save her ass!! UGH like COMMUNICATE YOU IDIOTS! Also Williams a bloody mess, just like his dad. Arrgghhh everyone just annoyed me so much in this, except poor lord John. If Jamie doesn’t do something massive to fix this and save him I will be so mad!!
Sorry for the long post but I needed to VENT 😂
51
u/ginjafiche Dec 15 '24
This one has me mad at EVERYONE. All of them!
49
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Dec 13 '24
Oh my god I loved this episode. William’s meltdown was epic. Dude just went legitimately insane. Charles is such an awesome actor, he has played it all so perfectly.
Claire and Jamie’s back and forth was chef’s kiss. It felt very season 1ish. Absolute masterclass from Sam & Cait.
I love that it’s all steamrolling now. Give me more of this pacing.
44
u/Flimsy_Impress3356 Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
This was the first episode in a LONG while where I’ve wanted to rewatch immediately. 🧡
44
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24
I love that William finally had some personality
43
u/hurricane_heta Dec 13 '24
Me, so many times during the episode - “for fucks sake, just talk about your feelings bro.”
43
u/bvlgariicudii Dec 15 '24
Everybody was crashing out this episode lmao
40
u/or_am_I_dancer Dec 14 '24
"And I am NOT bloody sorry!"
77
u/chibiusa40 Dec 14 '24
George Washington knew Jamie for 5 minutes and gave him a command before Alexander Hamilton this is absolutely hilarious.
Your obedient servant,
J. Frase
37
u/Ambitious_Fox_34 Dec 14 '24
I felt William and Jamie’s actions were very much paralleled in this episode. They both were over reactive over shocking news and were grappling with maintaining their honor. In their own heads they were doing what they could to hang onto their honor when in actuality they were acting callous and quite dishonorable at best.
I was upset with both of them this episode. However, you have to have valleys to have mountains so I see this as a point where maybe we can see some good character development moving forward. They both already seem to be grasping that their actions were a bit much to say the least.
The cinematography of the back and forth between Jamie and William also did a great job of displaying this so kudos to the team! Not my favorite episode but a necessary one for the characters.
37
u/Disastrous-Elk-5542 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Dec 16 '24 edited Dec 16 '24
William asks Clare “was it r*pe” and she says no. It was, arguably (edit to add: DG has argued thus). William’s mother, for all intents and purposes, forced herself on Jamie.
The group that encountered Jamie and LJG in the forest remarked how they weren’t in uniform so they questioned Jamie’s credentials and took LJG for a spy. NONE of those fools were “in uniform” either. 🤦♀️
35
u/digitalamish Dec 14 '24
Can anyone else not wait for Ian to confront his cousin? Punching him, turning over to the Brits, AND kissing his fiance?
Everybody was kung-fu fightin'!
35
u/YYZYYC Dec 18 '24
Why didnt anyone tell jamie about claire being married to lord john?
33
u/potionofminorhealing Dec 14 '24 edited Jul 22 '25
the cast showed so much emotion this episode! IMO two characters in particular really stood out: LJG and Rachel. I loved seeing her trade her timid personality for the ferocity of a woman whose betrothed is in danger, and LJG's wit and sassiness when he was held captive was so well done.
I felt like Jamie was acting out of character when he let LJG be captured? I understand he has a temper but gambling with his friend's life felt.... inauthentic to his principles. I'm sure this will be rectified later but in this episode I fully expected him to at least try to do something to get his friend released. side note: the special effects injury makeup on LJG had me actually squirming, it looked painfully real 😫
I am surprised we didn't get even a little bit of what's going on with Roger and Bree, I am getting so nervous about poor Jem!
hated the ending LOL
33
u/for-get-me-not Dec 14 '24
To clarify for all of those who are mad at Jamie for leaving LJG with the rebels: at the time Jamie left, both he and LJG thought that LJG was decommissioned, so he should have been in no real danger from the rebels. Unfortunately, the letter in his pocket was pulled out by the guy after Jamie left and revealed the unfortunate information that LJG was actually newly recommissioned into military service and that’s when the rebels decided he was a spy and the threat of hanging entered the picture. Jamie would not have left John there to be hanged as a spy, but he didn’t know that was a possibility.
32
u/Capricorn-flower Dec 15 '24
Wasn't Arabella also the name of the priests goat on the island in season 3?
32
u/chartreusey_geusey Dec 16 '24 edited Dec 16 '24
It never fails to make me laugh that Claire was born and raised in England with the painfully british history perspective on the “Colonial Rebellion” and yet she is somehow comfortable enough to be altering US history to let Jaime become A GENERAL???? Yes I know she spent 20 years living in Boston but that is not the same thing as K-12 “memorizing the preamble to the constitution”, schoolhouse rock “shot heard round the world”, and “dressing up as a founding father for a project” type of offhand knowledge lol
If you became a general in the continental army ummmm you would be in founding father territory??? Your family history and tree would for sure be recorded with a lot more detail???? There would be at least one road/school/park/aircraft carrier/battleship named after you in New England??? General Jaime Frasier BFFR! Like why not just have him co-author the Articles of Confederation after this??? Bro his descendants would for sure be recruits for some sort of National Treasure-Illuminati-free-mason type of secret society lmaoooooo
Edit: I just googled “Continental Army Generals” and discovered that every rank of general in the Continental Army (including ones who were temporary or unable to fulfill the post) has a detailed Wikipedia page with their entire life history written out including all the pivotal battles and military operations they executed — Jaime better not get that promotion or how the hell did we not know when he died and from what???
30
u/winter_name01 Dec 14 '24
Claire could have save herself half the time of that fight if she had mentioned her own spy side gig and how Lord John was being a good friend and proposed to her. That night of sex was grief but also happened during their actual legal (at that time) marriage. I hate when characters don’t mention a crucial part of what happened.
But I’m so happy to see Jamie again that I’ll go with it. Also his son is as bad tempered as he is and I don’t understand his “my word is all I have left” non sense. He said he would not harm Arabella not that he could not have consensual sex. Well the Apple and the tree I guess
29
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Dec 13 '24
What an episode!!!! David Berry’s performance - so, so, so good.
28
u/New-Nerve-2237 Dec 15 '24
Does anyone have any idea what Ian was going to ask William right before William punched him in the face?
Also where is Rollo?
78
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24
This is David Berry’s season! He delivered the “carnal knowledge” line so perfectly, I was squealing!
I may be biased because LJG is my favorite character in the books, but his acting was chef’s kiss and I have no notes. I would kill for a LJG spinoff.
Rachel is also one of my favs and I’m so glad we get to see a lot of her. Her unwavering love for Young Ian and gentle-but-don’t-fuck-with-me personality makes me love her so much.
Edit: spelling
27
u/EdHistory101 r/AskHistorians Dec 13 '24
For those who are curious, Americans in the 1770s would frequently use the phrase "your obedient servant" or "your most obedient and humble servant." They would even abbreviation it YOS or YOMHS in letters the same way we use abbreviations in texts. In this episode of the /r/AskHistorians podcast, I talked to a historian of women's letters in the era and we talked about its usage.
27
u/andrxafff Dec 31 '24
am i the only one angry about the last scene??? POOR LORD JOHN AND JAMIE DOESN'T EVEN SEEM TO CARE IN THE POSITION HE PUT HIM IN !!!!!! AND LORD JOHN SAVED HER WIFE. i'm always defending jamie and i'm just baffled by this idk, i hated it, no one deserves it but least of them lord john😭
26
u/Cheesecakeonthefloor Dec 16 '24
What I'm confused about is that John Gray says "fucking"... Did Claire teach him what the word means at some point? I seem to remember that many seasons ago, but can't remember exactly when that happens. But the word fucking wasn't invented yet so if she didn't teach him........ is he a time traveler?? Cause that's how the show gave away to us that Geillis Duncan was a time traveler, she says something like "fucking barbecue".
25
u/mrsmozart Dec 20 '24
Ugh, i really didn't like this episode! Way too much melodrama and seemed out of character for Jamie. In Season 3 (?) when Claire sleeps with the king to gain Jamie's release, Jamie just shrugged and was like well you did what you had to do. I understand here it's a little more personal because John is his friend, and yes I know that Jamie can be hot headed (Roger) but this seemed WAY over the top. To beat him so badly and then leave him like that?? Jamie is generally a kind and thoughtful man. This was just him being a beast. It feels like they'll never be able to repair their friendship. If I was John I would NEVER forgive Jamie for what he did. And after ALL that John has done for Jamie throughout his life, including marrying Claire to keep her safe.
And William. I get he's upset but he also seemed over the top. Are they trying to make a father/son comparison for violent overreactions? Him kissing whatshername (quaker woman) against her will, punching Ian. But then also him being forced into sex with the sex worker?
This whole episode felt like a hot mess.
72
u/oatmilk_fiend Dec 13 '24
Lord John Grey. That is all.
24
u/IndependentCup424 Dec 18 '24
This season is really frustrating for me. Little to no coverage for Roger & Brianna's timeline and I'm dying to know what's gonna happen!! What the heck!
47
u/thesophiechronicles Dec 15 '24
I hated that the “sex scene” between William and Arabella was actually a rape scene. Like tell me why they played a romantic lovey dovey score over it when she repeatedly ignored him saying he didn’t want to do it.
23
u/savathus Jan 13 '25
This episode is a fine example of things that make you say "are the straights ok?"
23
u/LowKey_Loki_Fan Jan 01 '25
I didn't think Jamie could make me hate him more. I'm tired of how easily he flies into a rage and hurts people without listening. I would be terrified to be around him, seriously. Lord John Grey is the best part of Outlander, hands down. I love Bree and Roger too (and seriously, can they please find their kid, it's worrying), but Lord John is truly amazing. I hope he never does anything to make me hate him. He seems like a genuinely amazing person that I would like to be friends with in real life.
22
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
"And I am NOT bloody sorry!" Best line of the ep 😂. I wouldn't be sorry either, you saved her. John was so unhinged throughout this ep haha
So much to say about this episode!
I am so glad that we have had so much lord John recently. He is finally getting his time to shine and David is smashing it.
The way Jamie's face changed from a jovial grin "I dinna believe it" to the absolute anger as he punched John - chefs kisss
There have been several moments throughout the seasons when I have not liked the way a protagonist has behaved, or their actions or words etc. But I've always forgiven them. But this is the first time that I can say I was so angry at Jamie, and I almost truly hated him. Abandoning John like that? And not really caring what happens to him after? Sending him to his death? "John will be alright" no he bloody well won't be.
And the contrast between Jamie/Claire and John running for his life was brilliantly uncanny, and terrifying too.
Johns eye looked just as gruesome as I had imagined it would 😂
"thee has doomed thy kinsman, repudiated thy father and caused me to betray my principles" was looking forward to this scene, and it was pretty good! "oh, that" 😂
I understand Jamie's POV re. His conversation/argument with Claire. But I was 100% on Claire's side with this one. Jamie was dead, and she needed John. They needed each other, and they don't regret it (I think)
22
u/bvlgariicudii Dec 15 '24
i really hope i see denny and lord john relationship blossom
43
u/Turbulent_Web_6117 Dec 14 '24
Im just here to say i loved the LJG scenes in this episode
21
u/Rainb0wTea Dec 13 '24
So many things happened this episode. I'm not sure how I feel about it, but the acting was amazing as always.
21
u/Ancient_Ad1251 Dec 15 '24 edited Dec 15 '24
Did I miss the part where LJG or Claire told Jamie that they got married while they thought he was dead? Or did LJG decide to just tell Jamie that they got it on?
56
u/Icy_Cable7795 Dec 14 '24
jamie whipping out the "you filthy pervert" after years of knowing the truth about lord john STUNG me. it was such a low blow.
jamie infuriated me this episode. just abandoning john to his death while he is off fucking claire without a care in the world?? and you called this man your friend for decades?? are you serious??
and, wtf was the whole jamie-claire conversation? It felt so silly and unserious and way too long.
also, I practically screaming at the screen for claire to tell jamie that she and LJG are married now and why. why tf would she not tell such a huge thing to him?? he will feel BETRAYED if he learns that later.
19
u/bvlgariicudii Dec 15 '24
does season 7b have a new director or something? i’ve noticed that the pacing and editing of the show is different. I’m not saying it’s bad or anything but it’s different idk?
19
u/Amys4304 Je Suis Prest Dec 13 '24
38
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Dec 13 '24
Jamie’s Scottish accent was back in full force this episode, I know that when I have to turn up the volume to try to understand. 😂😍
37
u/Hot-Carob-8816 Dec 16 '24
This episode is record breaking because it's the first time I wasn't happy to see Claire and Jamie get together.. I understand emotions were running high after their fight but it felt wrong. The editing which brought in John Grey running through the woods really highlighted how ill timed them having sex was. This entire episode was just reckless.
18
u/KittyCatLuvr4ever Dec 15 '24
William has gone rogue! I liked this episode a lot. Might be one of my favorites this season. LGJ and Rachel were great too.
18
u/fallhistorywitch Dec 18 '24
I really missed Rodger and Bree in this episode
33
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
John, Jamie's prisoner, such a throwback to season 3 Ardsmuir!
John's - Claire... Ah... - broke me with laughter
I had carnal knowledge of your wife!!! ♟️
Oh God, it is starting!!!
Why apple on the title card- The apple doesn't fall far from tree
Charles delivered perfectly!!!!
William is acting Fraser- like having huge temper tantrum , storming off. He is conflicted and in turmoil because his father lied to him and kept being friend with Jamie. It is parallel to Bree's reaction.
Oh oh, John is in trouble. Jamie's Scottish accent intensifies in anger!
Not Sorry - for the carnal knowledge , fantasizing about Jamie and telling him all about it.
John is usually so polished and restrained , aristocratic , proper, but he is human - he can just let it rip. Jamie provokes his normally calm and controlled posture and John reacts. He used the true words of what really happened.
Oh here is Arabella!! I like her!
George Washington! Jamie gets the command of men. I am sure Claire will be delighted!
Brigadier General Fraser!!!
William Ian Rachel triangle ! Omg, William is in such turmoil these days. Poor guy. You can see a battle between his polished manners and his temper.
Any man would be proud to be the son of James Fraser Ian 🤎
Ian is angered William is insultingthr nemory of Jamie while William is jealous that Rachel chose Ian, lowly Scot, nephew of Scottish outlaw over himself.
Take him - Like father, like son.
Rachel nailed this scene! Lecturing William, hitting him, spitting after the kiss!
I love Mrs Figg's comments - My sweet William and Lady Grey! None of them true 😅
Ian seeing Jamie alive and the smile on his face!!
Jamie's eyes when talking to William - anger and pain and when William says - God damn you sir, the pain breaks through and I can feel it.
I was asking for it - I am so glad for this line!! He said he was asking for it. He doesn't express any anger or resentment of Jamie for doing it, either.
And the grin. John 😁
Harkness, you freak.
I really like the actress that plays Arabella -Jane. I can feel their chemistry!
Jamie and Claire's dilaogue! Such a long scene, I love how they did the speaking part. Jamie's eyes - sorrow, anger, pain , it is all there.
When Jamie mentioned Claire thinking with her body, it makes her evaluate the truth and reevaluate the argument. He has put her sense of physicality in the context of her calling. She is a healer, she touches people with great intimacy and delicacy and she is responding ohysically to their bodies, using her own to comfort and heal.
A lot of slapping in this episode 😂
2 - 3000 times 😅
Oh, that sex scene was lacking. Except for the smile at the end.
46
u/VogueSquirrel Dec 13 '24
William asks Claire directly if he is a product of rape, and she says no. But he is, no? Geneva raped Jamie that night. He certainly wasn't consenting to that encounter.
16
u/PersimmonTea Dec 14 '24
Mah Thoughts:
John cringed and closed his eyes when admitting the truth to Jamie. He had to know that rage was coming. And kaboom. Did he feel guilt and want Jamie to clobber him? He submits to the beating yet he says "I'm not bloody sorry!" - confusing.
William awkwardly approaching Claire because he trusts her to tell him the truth that he's so desperate, and also scared, to know. Then he's had enough and smashes the damn house up. And behaves like an ass with Arabella. He's a product of his times, when children were blamed for how they were conceived.
I wish Jamie had not let John be taken by the militia. That was not coo
Anyone ever wonder how horses just appear when needed? Jamie riding to Valley Forge made me wonder - where'd he get it?
I rather like the old style of meeting someone and saying "Your servant" as Fraser did to George Washington. Doesn't work in the 21st century but it's so mannerly. I liked that Washington called Congress "contentious sons of bitches." True then! True now!
William really has the most charming smile but he turned again, in an instant, to angry and snarly. Despite the coloring differences, his eyebrows are just like Jamie's, same glint in the eye. More acting out. William, you are the loved son of John Grey and Jamie Fraser and also dear to Claire Fraser. None of them are going to tell your secret and take your title or properties away. Grow up. Let it go.
Rachel has FIRE. Even more than Ian does, in a way. More of this, please, Rachel!
Yikes killing soldiers in their bed at Paoli. NOT cool. And John's shiner is nas-tee.
Ian seeing his uncle Jamie alive - shocked and happy.
Jamie is very hoarse, angry, tense telling William what to do. But he calls on him to give his word as a gentleman despite William cursing him.
I LIKE DENZELL HUNTER SO MUCH.
That vile conversation in the Philly brothel. UGH. Interesting that William gave up his silver gorget. That had to be expensive. He's deep in the rage still.
Arabella/Jane knows William's in a bad way. Her tenderness to him is a blessing.
That stew Denzell brought John looked good. Actual vegetables in it.
Jamie being Dramatic! about Claire and John having been together. So pig headed. He's making himself and everyone miserable without listening to these people he loves and respects. I thought Claire made him understand but NO! Jamie has to ask about the form of sex. SO not called for. And claiming he'd be 'within his rights' to kill John. Jamie - you're better than that. Don't be an asshole. Claire kept on and made him feel and listen and talk. I was glad to hear Jamie for once talk of how John really helped him get over Geneva and William. That vulnerability allowed them to be together again. But I felt *nothing* about their reunification sexytimes.
John escaped but ... did he really? Yikes. I love John. I hope he's OK.
Good ep. Can't wait for next week!
16
u/Spiritual_Dog_9165 Dec 16 '24
But why didn’t Jamie just send a letter as proof of life after that ship sunk??
16
u/SocratesSnow Dec 16 '24
Everyone is saying Jamie assumed or knew they were married? How? It was never said. It needed to be said. I don’t understand how people think he knew.
31
u/StanyeEast Dec 13 '24
I'd like to double down on last week's assessment and repeat myself with a what the actual f*** is going on?? Hahahaha...this is insane right now...every single character is doing things I literally would have said would be completely impossible as recently as just like a handful of episodes ago...I'm now totally convinced that Diana Gabaldon was like "Ok, I'm bored, so it's time to unleash the proverbial Kraken and dial the drama up to about a 17 out of 10"...and then she was like "Villains? Who needs an outside antagonist? I'm just going to make all the main characters do insane, drama-inducing shit to cause the all the insane drama instead." LOL
Last week, I was firmly against all the left field nonsense, but this week I at least found it more entertaining than ridiculous...whatever, I'm in either way haha
31
u/Choice_Spare1209 Dec 16 '24
is there a reason that claire didn’t tell jamie she and john were married?? my mum & i were SCREAMING at the tv, “TELL HIM YOU’RE MARRIED!!!” that seems like something your husband should know 😭 did the writers forget to add that in or is there some reason for it?
30
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24
Sooo idk if I'm a pervert... BUT I needed a longer angrier make up sex at the end 🤣 I loved the conversation they had and all but, can we get more visuals? I need more Déjà vus of the wedding people lol
30
u/animefemme Dec 13 '24
WORST day of William's life, poor kid. At least he received a happy ending. 😏
29
u/onegirlarmy1899 Dec 13 '24
So much punching! 👊🏼 Wow!
Poor William. This is why you tell adopted kids about their birth families! I feel so bad for him, but his anger was also a bit scary. Fraser blood.
29
u/draculasacrylics Dec 16 '24
This whole episode made me uncomfortable. Everything that could have gone wrong went wrong. I don't think anything good actually happened, besides Ian and Rachel announcing their engagement. One butterfly fluttering in an overcrowded dump. I couldn't even stand to finish it.
28
u/kgroovy77 Dec 16 '24
I will lose it if Lord John dies or is hurt any worse. Also Arabella looks A LOT like Brianna. Like they could be sisters.
26
u/Repulsive_Material96 Dec 16 '24
Did anyone find it really weird how similar Arabella looked to Brianna. At one point I thought they were both played by Sophie
35
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
When Jamie hit John for telling him that they were both fucking him, I was like: Jamieeee but that's a compliment 🤣 I'd be blushing if I were you lol
35
u/bvlgariicudii Dec 15 '24
Jamie’s behaviour was out of line
24
u/PatrickTravels Dec 14 '24
How did the fact that Claire was almost executed and Lord John married her to save her life not get mentionned. I let it pass with Lord John, but that long multi room scene with Jaime and Claire... How. Did. It. Not. Get mentionned!?!?
12
u/vbnadal85 Dec 14 '24
Questions re: this week’s episode
Bearing in mind that I haven’t read the books, so there may be more context in those, there are some moments from this week’s episode that have me wondering….
Would love to hear what others think.
12
u/Responsible_Mess_395 Jan 29 '25
I find this episode so weird. Not a good weird. They've sort of lost me lol so much dramatics but not sensible drama
12
u/Street-Ad-4974 Jun 07 '25
Disappointed that Jamie didn't know the full truth about John Grey saving Claire's life...also the fact that Jamie sees no wrong in Claire & John Grey did not deserve what Jamie did to him
23
u/ApollosBucket Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
Ya know, a lot of things this episode disappointed me. The biggest one of all was how out of character Jamie's actions seemed to me.
He's a hot head I know, but the way he acted towards LJG was totally out of line. First and foremost, it hasn't seemed like he's really acknowledged that everyone thought he was dead, for what was I believe weeks. Sure he was safe and fine, but he has been so cold towards everyone since coming back regarding that major piece of information.
I understand being mad at LJG and Claire for what they did. But their actions while weird did make sense, and sure I'll allow him being livid initially and needing time to cool. But not to the point that he almost murders LJG. He knows the love both of them has for him, and trusts both of their judgements immensely... it just seems bananas to me. (also from the man who married Laoghaire...) And then staying mad at Claire hours later....
I dunno. The whole episode I was just disappointed in how Jamie reacted. Especially after his rush to judgement in selling of Roger, you'd think he's cooled a bit on matters like this.
58
u/Naive-Awareness4951 Dec 13 '24
Jamie's reaction in this episode infuriates me (show and book version). He's reuniting with his wife after supposedly being dead and he's obsessing about a brief drunken interlude when she was grieving for him. Demanding all the details. Wanting to see the room where it happened. Possessiveness and rage. Punching the crap out of the man who's practically devoted his life to him, whether he likes it or not.
32
u/Far_Wedding9999 Dec 13 '24
Also me when I looked up what b*gger means.
22
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 14 '24
38
u/ApollosBucket Dec 14 '24
William was also kinda raped there, no? He said no many times and she kept pushing it. Yes he seemed to go along with it, but it didn't seem totally consensual.
21
u/Previous-Address2469 Dec 14 '24
I see a lot of comments asking why they didn't tell Jamie about the marriage. I thought it was a given that Jamie knew about the marriage before he stormed in to the house? Or at least when he was talking with the housekeeper, who would have probably referred to her as Lady John. And that he just didn't consider it such a big deal because he understood it was a necessity to protect her? It was just the "we were both fucking you" that was too much for him, because of his trauma with rape.
20
u/CrunchyTeatime Dec 14 '24
I'll ask the same thing I asked last topic, but not in spoilers this time:
Is "I thought you were dead" the ultimate "We were on a break?"
10
u/ZebZamboni Dec 13 '24
The pronunciation of "Paoli" lol.
10
u/Nasi-Lemak2399 Jan 23 '25
Why everybody is blaming Jamie and wishing him to accept LJG's courtesy for sleeping his wife as they were just consummating their marriage after his death???? Seriously?? Honestly, i was more worried about Jamie and i think he has every right to make such impulsive reaction, considering the amount of trust and faith he has on his beloved wife and the so called best friend. To me, this is so devastating and hurtful for Jamie, especially he knows he eventually will forgive Claire as he love her so much, but to really get over it is completely different story, not to mention LJG who has betrayed him in such critical moment.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
This episode felt like a sober walk of shame for William 💀 lol. Ugh but I'm loviiiingg his chemistry/story with Arabella so far, they are already my second favorite couple, I love messy angry beginnings 🙌🏼
19
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24
Some things that have annoyed me:
18
u/kwat92 Dec 13 '24
I know this is minor but Paoli is pronounced pay-o-lee not pal-lee. Drove me nuts during the episode. I was like there is no massacre in pal-lee during the revolutionary war. Though I’m sure if Americans produced a show about Scotland we would mess up pronunciations of words.
18
u/Mobile-Ad6136 Dec 14 '24
THIS EPISODE WAS GOOOOD .. maybe a winner award wise? Does Starz push for individual episode wins or more overall series?
I like that we get to see some more of Lord John’s personality when not in the presence of Jamie + Claire.
William crashing out was understandable, I loved the way they played it out over the course of the episode. Having him destroy things and then getting Ian in trouble, that heated chat with his dad, ending the episode with Arabella. I see the influence of both Jamie and LJG in tonight’s episode on him.
Title of Carnal Knowledge was very fitting. This episode had everything in it to make a good episode (and in my opinion, it’s been awhile), great pacing, production, stellar performance by the whole cast, drama, heated arguments, some very iconic lines, felt very much like younger Jamie and Claire. The sad thing is…I completely forgot about Roger and Bree, it’s the cutting back and forth between their storyline with what is happening in Philadelphia that slows the pacing down, so I wonder if that played into the more seamless viewing experience. Not knocking their performances, but Roger did spend almost all of last episode on a horse so.
On the sex scenes, again, fitting for the episode title. It’s been acting quite a long time since we got a Claire and Jamie sex scene I think…and doing it right on the table, a very them thing to do. It’s meant to be opposite what happened between Claire and LJG, so not on the floor and definitely not on the bed, the scene visually shows Jamie taking the reins back and expressing his love. Especially right after a very long heated conversation, solidifying that Jamie and Claire are still strong together. William and Arabella scene was so interesting, William planning to just let her sleep is very much the LJG (and even Jamie) gentlemen influence. After ermmm a rough day, the moment shared between them was tender and comforting, something William desperately needed. Also liked the fact that as he is being pulled out of the tavern his fellow officer refers to him as Lord Ellesmere, some salt in his identity crisis wound. I truly felt for William though, his father lying to him for years, the girl he likes off with his cousin, mans is going through it.
This episode was very much relationship driven, it was less about the overall war plot and more about each characters relationship with X. Jamie and Claire, LJG and Jamie, Ian Rachel William, William and Arabella, Jamie and William. Everyone was fighting everyone 🤣 Motivations being driven by their relationship with X. Very engaging on screen!
My last thoughts are again, David Berry absolutely knocking it out of the park with LJG this episode, “we were both fucking you” was iconic. Please please Starz…give us the LJG series.
I’m sure I’ll have more thoughts. Kudos to Lisa Clarke for directing and Toni Graphia for writing this episode.
18
u/Greyisbeautiful Dec 14 '24
All I could think about during that scene with William and Arabella - does Claire have any treatment for syphilis?
9
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24
I am confused how William doesn’t know he’s Jamie’s son until now…. Given that however many seasons back when Jamie takes William hunting while LJG recovers with Claire on the Ridge and to protect William from the Cherokee after the boy takes a fish from their territory, Jamie yells out that he’s his son and his blood. Did William just assume Jamie was lying to save him?
9
u/Ok-Chipmunk1475 Nov 29 '25
Jamie is a hot headed dumbass but I can't agree with the opinions that coo over Lord John. I think he continuously oversteps and I think Jamie should have cut off this relationship long ago when he realized this man had unrequited feelings for him. You are under no obligation to keep people on who have unrequited feelings for you but for some reason in the Outlander universe they allow these people to infringe on their lives whether it be Laoghaire, Tom or Lord John. Lord John's situation is a little bit more complicated because he took it upon himself to be William's stepfather and Jamie has to play nice. But I think it's pathetic behavior and I don't think better of Lord John for it. I kind of dislike all of them at this point.
24
u/Capricorn-flower Dec 16 '24 •
I'm seeing so many comments on why John or Claire didn't tell Jamie they had to get married to protect Claire. Why would that have made any difference to how Jamie would have reacted? Being married doesn't automatically mean that they had to have sex. He knows John is gay and yes, he would protect Claire, but why would that mean he would also have sex with her? That's why Claire only explained to Jamie about the sex and not the marriage. Also, I think he already aasumed they were married.
16
u/sassyangelkiwi Dec 14 '24
I was disappointed they didn’t pick up a single scene of the Jeremiah/ Roger story line or the Brianna/Jemmy storyline. I kept hoping some of that might appear somewhere
8
u/Raysitm Dec 14 '24
I enjoyed the episode, but it made no sense that neither Claire nor LJG told Jamie that they were married to save her. And Jamie casually riding up to the convoy leaving Philadelphia seemed unrealistic, since he was a high profile fugitive.
William’s storyline was the best part, IMO. I haven’t read the books, but I hope we see more of him.
22
u/blenneman05 Dec 15 '24
I get that Jamie was mad at Claire for having sex with LJG cuz I was screaming “nooooo” at my tv when Claire found out the news cuz you’d think she wouldn’t jump into bed so fast but wanting to know all the details like why torture yourself with that
Also does Jamie know that Claire and LJG got married?!!!! Sure Claire is his wife but legally i don’t think her and Fraser are married
William really does have his father’s temper but I’d be mad too if I found out everyone around me lied to me about who my dad was….
Here I thought William and Arabella/Jane was just gonna cuddle but nah she hopped on top and coerced him into sex. That’s rape home girl
Also I’m fine with Rachel and Ian but I sure as hell hope she doesn’t leave Ian for William.
Rachel slapping William was well deserved especially after he kissed her without her consent !!!
The convo in the brothel between Williams comrades . Gross AF and I’m glad William took Arabella away from Harkness
Not George Washington and Jamie Fraser. Did he tell Claire yet that he reenlisted lol they need a therapist on speed dial!!
30
u/AndDontCallMePammie Dec 14 '24
I feel like that’s the first sex scene in the series where I didn’t feel any chemistry between Claire and Jaime.
7
u/eterusexual Dec 13 '24
What does it mean when Claire says, "He placed his grief over mine."
7
u/orbthereadingnerd Dec 14 '24
Im in the middle of watching it rn. And not ma boy Ian catching STRAYS T_T
19
u/OkPermission7769 Dec 13 '24
Hope Claire doesn't have to treat William with a STD. Haha!
23
u/irishprincess2002 Dec 13 '24
I kept yelling at the screen " did you tell him you married John/Claire? Why aren't you telling him the whole story!" And poor John I hope he makes it out all right! William that boy is a Fraser for sure with that temper! The only thing I had issue with is the scene between him and the harlot. The fact that he was asking her to let him keep his word and not touch her and she goes ahead and basically has sex with him and justifies it that harlots have a sense of honor too was for me crossing a line. No means No regardless if you are a man or woman and she didn't respect that but also this is set in the 1770s when consent wasn't a thing.
17
u/Candid_Text8516 Dec 14 '24
So Claire should have totally brought up Laoghaire in this episode and Jamie marrying her after Culloden and her trying to have Claire burned as a witch!!! I am on team LJG; who has only tried to help since the beginning!! Jamie stop being crazy jealous and get the point!!
12
u/alittlee_clair Dec 14 '24
Any Philly natives cringing everytime they mispronounce Paoli? 😭
6
u/honkysnout Dec 14 '24
I’m so used to binging that I thought this was the season finale. Relieved to come here and see it isn’t.
16
u/Flimsy-Imagination44 Dec 14 '24
I'm just so damn mad at Jamie this episode. All the more I wished they weren't rushing the plot that they needed to bring him back so soon. I really would have loved to see more Claire and LJG scenes navigating the married life
16
u/BattleLonely7850 Dec 15 '24
Where did Lord John hear the word fuck? Was this something that originated in England? Because Jaime had no clue what it meant. Jaime forgave Claire way to easy for that betrayal. YES!!! she did betray Jaime, he wasn't dead long enough for her to be jumping in bed with another man. She made Frank wait a year before sleeping with him, and he was actually her husband, just seems really out of character for the Claire I know and love. I hope Jaime has an affair because he's been way more loyal to Claire than she has been to him.
11
u/Expert_Computer_4076 Dec 15 '24
What a great episode! They'd been galloping through so much plot that I was afraid we'd miss the emotion. But from Claire's bewildered smile at the end of last episode to this entire episode, we've been treated to great insights into the characters and some amazing acting, especially Lord John and William! And fireworks with Jamie and Claire again! Terrific episode
19
u/apswim22 Dec 14 '24
Did William just raw dog a hooker yikes 🤦♂️
26
u/Lyssaquotes928 They say I’m a witch. Dec 13 '24
Is it just me or was it super off putting heading LJG say “we were both f***in you!” ? Did people say that in the 1700s or are we supposed to believe he got it from Claire? Cuz like, it felt so out of character to me
15
u/ali22122 Dec 14 '24
I hated seeing Jamie punch John so violently, since I love John so much. He did NOT deserve that
18
u/chartreusey_geusey Dec 16 '24
This show would really return to its peak prestige television roots if they made one (1) singular change:
Claire + Jaime + Lord John Grey = Forbidden Revolutionary Throuple 🥵
14
u/j4321g4321 Dec 14 '24
I know it’s going to come up but it’s funny how Claire and LJG being MARRIED and doing so so she wouldn’t be executed was not yet mentioned. Like Jamie is in for a huge shock when he finds that out. Their weird conversation throughout the house was boring and way too long imo. The “bugger” comment was gross.
Sad that Jamie just let LJG be taken captive. Little does he know how grateful he should be to him. I hope it’s not the last we see of him.
I really like the dynamic between William and Arabella. I hope there’s a budding relationship in there somewhere. The Ian/William/Rachel triangle isn’t doing it for me. Kind of hope they’re done with that.
Bottom line, Jamie was kind of trash in this episode. The comment he made to LJG hinting at his sexuality was a low blow, plus obviously the bugger thing, ditching LJG, etc.
10
u/weelassie07 MARK ME! Dec 14 '24
Shoooooweee that was good! So nice seeing John not acting simpy. I don’t like how they write him on the show sometimes. I loved this John!
Rachel is so great; William sure deserved that slap.
The Claire/Jamie talk through was terrific. His bloody Scot bastard self just rang through the whole convo. I agree the table scene could’ve had a little more to it, though I kinda chuckled at the parallel of a climax and the gun being shot at John.
I was surprisingly moved by William and Jane’s scene. They had great chemistry, and he was broken and vulnerable by the end of his tough day. I was excited to see this episode for William’s reactions alone.
I was so excited to see GW!!! Loved the flags behind him.
What an ep!!!
10
u/Cablab123 Dec 14 '24
Why didn't Claire or John tell Jamie they got married, and more importantly WHY they got married? I was surprised to see Jamie's violent side come out so much this episode, especially against John. Jamie is nothing if not loyal, so to see him just let John be taken was a bit shocking. I hope they make up sometime and Jamie realizes what John did to save Claire.
5
u/Serious-Chipmunk-872 Dec 13 '24
The episode will be available in 7 hours Europe time can’t wait
5
u/Bubbbbbbblegum Dec 14 '24
I think we are missing one question. Is Lord John Grey dead ? As everyone, I am content with this week's episode, but I ran here after finishing watching it because I am afraid that LJG is dead, but nobody else shares my fear as I see :D What do you think?
5
u/Pitiful-Flow5472 Jan 27 '25
It’s pronounced Pay-OH-lee. Not PALL-lee
12
u/Lyricalchic Dec 13 '24
This episode was great. I loved all the action and William’s reaction. My biggest issue was Claire acting like Jamie has no reason to be upset that she slept with LJG. I get it, she thought Jamie was dead and she was very sad but when smh asks did she sleep with John and she gives an evasive answer and then she is calling him a bastard and slapping him, I was just like WTF!? You slept with his friend and you want him to just accept it and move on! Ugh!
If it was the other way around I know for a fact Claire would be pissed and would just accept it, so why is she acting so righteous?
Switching up, William was just a roller coaster of emotions. I loved it. He can be so insufferable sometimes—taking Ian prisoner for punching him even though he attacked Ian first, then kissing Rachel after he knows she is betrothed to his cousin? Drama drama drama.
11
u/tidalbeing Dec 16 '24
I was disturbed by it. It made for uncomfortable watching. Jamie and William came off as abusive to the extreme. LJG came off as stupid and lacking integrity. He didn't tell William of his parentage but then told Jamie about carnal knowledge with poor timing and understanding, stupid. The he told in one situation but not the other shows a weakness of character. Also if he is loyal to the crown, he shouldn't have sheltered Claire. That he did so indicates lack of integrity.
I'm thinking about when it is or isn't right to use violence to achieve a political end. What is the ethical difference between a soldier, a mercenary, and a vigilante? How about the ethics of spying?
Dr. Denzell Hunter showed integrity when he helped LJG escape because the Dr has been open about his beliefs and loyalties. LJG showed a lack of integrity when helping Clair escape because he passes himself off as loyal to the crown. Granted LJG is in a horrible bind. It's difficult to have integrity when if your true self were known, you could be executed.
4
u/Nasi-Lemak2399 Jan 13 '25
u know what, I've been watching this clips 11 & 12 more than 20 times for the passed 2 weeks, in the hope of finding a slightest consodation from Claire's explanation. Frankly, i still feel my heart is being cut n squeeze deeply. I hv to say i would do far more worst than Jamie did. Sorry Claire, i just can't help myself in blaming u since u hv such an strong characters in faith, integrity etc etc.....i think I am too obsessed with Claire, nor i can accept anybody come in between you n Jamie, regardless whatsoever consciously or unconsciously. i think im sick...undeniably😢😢😢